A Playbook for the Public Sector - Periscope Holdings · term risks of going with the ERP vs....
Transcript of A Playbook for the Public Sector - Periscope Holdings · term risks of going with the ERP vs....
A Playbook for the Public Sector
8 STEPS TO PROCURING ePROCUREMENT:
Page 2 of 16
TABLE OF CONTENTS
4
11
6
3
8
12
13
14
15
STEP ONE
STEP FOUR
STEP TWO
STEP THREE
STEP FIVE
STEP SIX
STEP SEVEN
STEP EIGHT
Introduction
Embrace Current Challenges and Define Future Goals
Build the Business Case for the Procurement Solution That is Best for Your Agency
Solicit Stakeholder Feedback and Support – and Do It Early
Decide How to Procure an eProcurement Solution
Select the Right Solution – and the Right Partner
Plan Diligently – and Plan for the Unexpected
Execute, Evaluate, and Refine
Don’t Forget to Document, and Share, Your Success
Page 3 of 16
Conservative estimates suggest that reform of government procurement practices, many of which have been in place for decades without change, could save 5 to 10% of total spending. And that’s just the start. eProcurement technology platforms have proven to deliver a host of benefits to federal, state, and local government entities.
However, there still remains confusion as to the purpose and capabilities of an eProcurement system among many in the public sector. Some consider eProcurement to be, in its most basic form, the electronic publishing and receiving of solicitations. Others define eProcurement as the holistic digitalization of the procurement function; the complete transference of purchasing processes, documents and communications to an electronic system. While there are varying levels of eProcurement utilized in the public sector today, the ultimate goal should be to automate the full procure-to-pay process efficiently and intelligently.
eProcurement – or electronic procurement – is gaining widespread attention within the public sector as agencies at all levels begin to evaluate the best technologies to facilitate a full,
and future-proof, digital transformation.
INTRODUCTION
A recent Center for Digital Government survey of 138 government, IT and procurement decision-makers found 31 percent of respondents don’t have a portal or eProcurement system where they can post bids and RFPs online – a fundamental capability necessitated in today’s modern procurement environment.
ROOM FOR IMPROVEMENT
Business Intelligence
eSourcing / Quotes / RFPs /
eCatalogs
Vendor Registration / Management and Bidding
Contract Management
Government-to-Business Punchouts / Requisitions
Invoicing / Accounts Payable
Page 4 of 16
Procurement is how governments get work done — from rebuilding infrastructure to modernizing technology to overhauling school curriculum. However, manual and legacy procurement processes tend to add cost, cause delay and reduce agility, while creating a host of other challenges. This is resulting in a rapid uptick of procurement modernization initiatives, which is great news.
Before you can make any changes to improve your procurement function, though, you must first complete a baseline analysis of its “health.”
It has probably been several years since you last conducted an in-depth audit of your entire purchasing process or, quite honestly, even researched the many modern procurement technologies available in the marketplace. Whether you are eager to make a few small changes to your procurement processes or overhaul your entire procurement function, it is important that you first identify current pain points, the root causes of those issues, and your ideal outcome(s).
Sample Challenges: Where Am I Starting?
We are still using manual processes; we need to digitalize our procurement function
We lack visibility into our spend, which makes it difficult to identify duplicate purchases or make adjustments to vendors/contracts extract more value
We know we need a best-of-breed eProcurement system, and we don’t currently have an ERP solution. However, we don’t have executive support for ePro
We have a new ERP-based procurement system, but it is a bad system and is hurting more than helping; we need to make the case for a standalone ePro system
I just realized that my eProcurement system is not the best out there, and it is no longer supporting my needs
We have an ERP upgrade in the works, but my current system is insufficient and I can’t wait another month, much less another year, to make a change
Embrace Current Challenges and Define Future Goals
STEP ONE
Page 5 of 16
Sample Goals: Where Do I Need to Go, and Why?
Just Don’t Forget to Document and Analyze “As Is” Business Processes
What else do you want to achieve?
Place the steps into a flowcharting software program in a swim lane format, i.e. process map. This will help you clearly identify process re-engineering requirements as you overhaul your
technology system and modernize the entire procurement function.
Increase supplier diversity and/or participation from Certified Business Entities (i.e. small, local, women-, minority-, or veteran-owned businesses)
Increase visibility, create transparency and enhance accountability
Increase competition to improve quality and value
Identify what’s needed to perform the process and where it comes from (e.g. paper, web, fax, etc.)
Improve resource utilization
Identify who completes each activity
Introduce more effective spending controls
Create system that facilitates easy local agency purchasing off statewide contracts
Centralize procurement function
Identify the start and end points of the process.
Reduce processing times for purchase requests
Identify what’s produced by the process
Automate procure-to-pay workflows
Establish a framework that can support new green purchasing standards
Embrace Current Challenges and Define Future GoalsSTEP ONE
C O N T I N U E D
Page 6 of 16
Build the Business Case for the Procurement Solution That is Best for Your Agency
STEP TWO
Begin to Develop Your Business Case…
And Your Budget...
List the pros/cons of each
Identify missing functionality
Determine the degree of interfacing integration across the systems
Baseline ERP module or homegrown system
Best-of-breed eProcurement advantages
Hybrid options
Consider quantifiable costs and benefits
Consider the immediate and long-term risks of going with the ERP vs. eProcurement or compromising on functionality/capabilities by not selecting best-of-breed
Perform Financial Analysis
Prepare a Funding Plan
• Quantifiable benefits and costs• Non-quantifiable benefits and costs
• Determine funding options for consideration• Develop proposed funding model that is fair
and equitable• Draft budget issue for consideration by
project sponsors and governing authority
Page 7 of 16
Build the Business Case for the Procurement Solution That is Best for Your Agency
STEP TWO
C O N T I N U E D
Then Prepare Your Business Case Analysis Report
A Word of Caution
Once you complete this exercise, it will be easier to identify potential remedies to current challenges and decide which type of
procurement technology platform is best for your agency.
Not all procurement problems can be solved using software alone. Although technology can and should be utilized to facilitate change, it is only possible to make meaningful improvements and sustain a long-term return on investment if you simultaneously overhaul your business
processes or address statutory obligations and restrictions.
Executive Summary
Alternative solutions for moving forward
Scope and approach
Detailed discussion of financial analysis and results
Analysis of existing ERP systems environment
Recommendations & high-level implementation plan
Page 8 of 16
Solicit Stakeholder Feedback and Support – and Do It Early
STEP THREE
No purchase decision is going to be made in a procurement silo. Given the tight integration of eProcurement systems with other agency functions, and the direct impact that procurement has on the success of government initiatives, it is critical to involve all stakeholders in your decision making process in some capacity. Present your business case
and seek input not only from your procurement team, but from finance, IT and even upper management. These key personnel will serve as either influencers or decision makers – or both. Without their unified support, or at least understanding, it may be challenging to secure approval for any eProcurement technology purchase.
Recruit a “Champion” for Your Cause from Upper Management…
Then Build Your Winning Team for Project Execution.
CIO
Finance/accounting department
Governor, mayor or other
civil leader
Procurement leaders and
users
CTO
IT department
CFO
Legal department/
auditors
Page 9 of 16
Solicit Stakeholder Feedback and Support – and Do It Early
Prepare for The Ultimate Showdown: Deciding Which Procurement Technology Solution is Best
C O N T I N U E D
STEP THREE
Athough many public sector CIOs may advocate for procurement to be conducted via the ERP, and many public sector procurement professionals will push for a
best-of-breed eProcurement system, the ideal technology solution to facilitate fast procurement modernization may indeed be an eProcurement system that lives
outside of – but remains tightly integrated with – the core ERP.
The Real Win-Win: A Hybrid ePro-ERP ApproachThis type of compromise does not require procurement to wait until an ERP upgrade
is complete a year, or three years, from now to start introducing new efficiencies. A best-of-breed solution can be integrated with existing systems and on-boarded
immediately and then later integrated with new or upgraded finance, human resources or ERP systems. As a result, buyers gain access to fully-functioning
eProcurement system within weeks or months, and other agency stakeholders maintain full access to cross-functional business systems – and critical procurement
data – as incremental technology upgrades occur.
Page 10 of 16
Solicit Stakeholder Feedback and Support – and Do It Early
C O N T I N U E D
STEP THREE
Still Facing Challengers?
Examples of Proof Points to Compile
Your credibility or relationship with C-level leaders may not be enough to secure their support for your cause. Before you can plea your case to decision makers, arm yourself with proof that your preferred eProcurement system is best for the entire agency. And you must be prepared to present that proof in a language each stakeholder will understand.
Whether you are advocating for your agency’s move to a standalone eProcurement platform
Case studies provide more than “proof of concept”. They are filled with stats, process descriptions, and testimonials that clearly demonstrate the value and feasibility of your preferred procurement technology solution in an environment that mirrors your own.
(because you don’t have an ERP) or the utilization of an integrated ERP/eProcurement system, you have to communicate the risks associated with not investing in an eProcurement solution, waiting for an ERP upgrade or – worse – not making any changes at all. Of course, be sure to tout the benefits of your recommended solution too.
See below for stats that will persuade.
Easy Integration
TIP: Use case studies to ‘prove’ your business case to other decision makers.
Better Resource Utilization
Cost Savings
Governor / Mayor
CIO / IT
CFO
49% of respondents said they desired a procurement solution that is easier to integrate into processes.*
40% of respondents said more efficient use of their staff time was among the top 3 benefits that attracts them to a best-of-breed eProcurement module.*
Money Talks. Best-of-breed eProcurement software cost less to implement and maintain than traditional ERP procurement modules. That’s the #1 reason why government agencies prefer ePro over ERP.
ePro offers tools that increase supplier diversity, deliver more value for every taxpayer dollar spent, which protects rainy day funds and allows you to deliver on promised infrastructure, programs, etc.. ePro also increases small, women, minority and veteran-owned business participation in solicitations, which builds goodwill among caucauses that appreciate the administration’s support of such business enterprises, especially those that return revenues to the local economy
ePro is easy to integrate with ERP; minimal burden on IT resources; eliminates redundant inputs; cloud-based systems are neat; the ePro vendor will lead integration so that you don’t have to worry about interfaces; ePro also provides visibility into project spend and quality - this transparency improves governance for high profile digital transformation project
ePro will directly interface with your finance system, so you will always have a single source of truth about spend, direct access to clean and complete data sets; increased visibility into spend will aid with budget planning and reporting
Whatever you do, be sure to speak your stakeholders’ language.
Use findings from third-party research, such as the data from this recent Center for Digital Government survey of 138 Government, IT and procurement decision-makers.
Turn to your peers for help building your case.
Page 11 of 16
Decide How to Procure an eProcurement Solution
STEP FOUR
Just like any other public sector technology purchase, there are many vehicles that can be used to solicit for an eProcurement system. To
determine which is best for your agency, consider the following:
Resources
Priorities
Solicitation Types
• How much time and effort can my staff dedicate to this project?
• Do I need to outsource most of the process analysis/re-engineering and system integration?
• What capabilities do I need immediately?
• What does my budget allow me to procure now vs. later?
• What parts of the project are most important to me and other stakeholders?
• What are the pros and cons of using a formal RFP vs. co-op or other type of solitication?
• Do I need to issue an RFI/RFQ first to ensure my project is even achievable within current budget/system /timeline parameters
Page 12 of 16
Select the Right Solution – and the Right Partner
STEP FIVE
Modern procurement technologies should be designed to simplify the purchasing process, protect taxpayer dollars and ensure fair competition.
However, not all procurement technologies are created equal. The only way to ensure that the best-of-breed eProcurement platform you plan to use is really the best for your agency is to develop a thorough requirements
checklist for reference during the evaluation process.
Be Sure to Ask the Right Questions
Sample Features and Capabilities Checklist
Customizable vendor management (registration, bidding, purchase orders/POs, etc.)
Self-service vendor model (vendor manages profile maintenance, electronic quoting, PO/change order pickup)
De-centralized informal quote support
Pre-encumbrance, encumbrance, and expense control
Out-of-the-box account NIGP or other classification code support
Configurable approval paths
Built-in audit trails that are tied to workflows and document processing
Multi-layered, enterprise-grade security ecosystem, including firewalls, intrusion detection, network partitioning, physical security, managed and hosting security services, threat management, disaster recovery, data encryption
eCatalogs that provide consumer shopping-like experience and automate/enforce contract spending
24/7 web-enabled application for easy access by all users and stakeholders
Full integration with third-party systems
Full-service process re-engineering, platform integration, on-boarding, training and post-launch support services by vendor team
Business Intelligence Reporting and Dashboards with advanced filtering capabilities like top/bottom filtering, chart formatting, dashboard exports, and tree maps
Page 13 of 16
Plan Diligently – and Plan for the Unexpected
STEP SIX
Every successful digital transformation requires a well-defined strategy. Once you have convened all parties involved in your procurement
modernization effort, it is time to map out a plan of attack.
Warning
Internal delays are possible and, quite frankly, to be expected. Have a contingency plan prepared. Factor delays into your timeline. Most
importantly, be flexible.
Validate Business Goals and Objectives
Communicate with All Parties
Outline Your Vision
Begin with the End in Sight
Establish Project Management Structure and
Standards
Be Willing to Compromise
Develop, Maintain, and Refine (as needed) a Detailed Project Plan
with a Timeline
Keep Pursuing
Page 14 of 16
Execute, Evaluate, and Refine
STEP SEVEN
The project does not end once you “go live.” In fact, it is almost more important to conduct an in-depth analysis of eProcurement system performance in the months immediately following launch
than during beta testing.
Develop a set of both quantifiable and intangible key performance indicators (KPIs).
Consistently solicit feedback from both end-users and the integration team.
Identify gaps in capabilities once real-world applications are tested on a mass scale. Incrementally on-board new system features as needed.
Maintain a support team that can address technical issues in real-time.
Analyze both the technology and associated processes simultaneously to ensure they are in sync. Be prepared to adjust workflow rules or define new processes if needed to facilitate more efficient procurements in the modern technology system.
Don’t forget to train end-users thoroughly on the new system; this will minimize productivity disruptions during the transition
Page 15 of 16
Don’t Forget to Document, and Share, Your Success
STEP EIGHT
It is so important to showcase your project’s success both internally and externally. Not only does this build credibility for you and your team, but it shines a spotlight on your superiors.
Give credit where credit is due – to IT, vendors, and certainly your government’s leadership.
Develop case studies, leverage social media, and be willing to talk to media to tout the impact of your procurement modernization efforts on both your agency, larger government, and the local economy – to include the businesses and taxpayers benefiting from streamlined procurement processes.
Develop internal newsletters, or host public events, to showcase the benefits of your new procurement system. This will help to recruit vendors (which will increase competition) and internal agency users/local agency users (which aids with procurement standardization and centralization efforts).
No matter the communications channel, remember to talk about change agents during the implementation. This will help you demonstrate the
extensive effort that was put into making this project a success while aiding with the documentation of “lessons learned” and best practices for future
implementations by both your agency and others in government.
We eradicate waste and maximize the value of every dollar you spend. This is our purpose. It guides everything our company
does – from product development to customer interaction.
To learn more, visit
www.periscopeholdings.com