2014 · 11.11.2014 · * Accident took place in INS Sindhurath (Feb 2014) Answer (b) - Accidents...
Transcript of 2014 · 11.11.2014 · * Accident took place in INS Sindhurath (Feb 2014) Answer (b) - Accidents...
Page 1
2014 REGIONAL LEVEL
RAIPUR REGION
Page 2
CONTENTS / LIST OF BUSINESS
PROCEEDINGS
1. Oath Taking
2. Obituary Reference
3. Introduction of New Ministers
4. Question Hour
5. Papers to be laid
6. Welcome to the Foreign Parliamentary Delegation
7. Calling Attention Motion
8. Legislative Business,
Bill Introduced
Bill for Consideration
Page 3
YOUTH PARLIAMENT
PROCEEDINGS OF A SITTING
(MADAM SPEAKER IN THE CHAIR)
1. OATH TAKING
MADAM SPEAKER (Miss Trisha Dua): Member to take the oath or affirmation, Secretary General please.
SECRETARY GENERAL (Mr. Aditya Chawra): Miss Shalini Kumari who stands elected from the Koriya Constituency of Chhattisgarh will now take the oath or affirmation. (Call out Miss Shalini Kumari).
(Miss Shalini Kumari proceeds from the place that he is occupying to the right hand of the Secretary's General table and hands over her Certificate of election to the officer at the Table).
SECERETARY GENERAL (Mr. Aditya Chawra): Madam, do you want to take oath or affirmation?
Miss Shalini Kumari: Oath Please
SECRETARY GENERAL (Mr. Aditya Chawra): In which language would you like to take the oath?
Miss Shalini Kumari: In Hindi Please.
(The Secretary General hands over to Miss Shalini Kumari a copy of the form of
oath in the language in which he wants to take the oath).
मै जो युवा संसद के निचले सदि की सदस्य निवााचचत हुई ह ूँ, ईश्वर की शपत लेती ह ूँ की, मै ववचि द्वारा स्थावपत भारत के संवविाि के प्रनत श्रद्धा और निष्ठा रख गंी, देश की एकता एवं प्रभुसत्ता को बिाये रख गंी, तथा जजस पद को मै ग्रहण करिे वाली ह ूँ उसके कताव्यों का श्रद्धाप वाक निवाहि करूँगी!
(The member then places the oath paper on the Table of the Secretary General and shakes hand with the Chair. The member then passes behind the Chair to the other side of the Secretary's General Table, where she signs the Roll of Members. After signing the roll, she takes her seat in the House. The M.Ps. welcome her by thumping on their desks).
Page 4
2. OBITUARY REFERENCE MADAM SPEAKER(Miss Trisha Dua): Hon. Members, as we meet today after two months, it is my duty to inform the house about the sad demise of Mr.Farooq Sheikh, who was an Indian actor, philanthropist and a popular television presenter. In the year 2010, Mr. Farooq Sheikh, won the National Film Award for Best Supporting Actor for the film Lahore. This famous veteran actor died of a heart attack in Dubai on 27 December 2013. I pray the almighty that His soul rest in peace.
PRIME MINISTER AND LEADERS OF THE HOUSE (Miss Sneha
Pramanik): Hon'ble Speaker Madam, I deeply saddened to hear of the sad
demise of the Veteran actor Mr. Farooq Sheikh. An accomplished actor with a unique style and multipurpose talent.
He started his career in Bollywood in 1973 with 'Garm Hava', and two of his last performances in Bollywood were in 'Club 60' and in the commercially hit film 'Yeh Jawaani Hai Deewani'. The Indian film industry and the Indian Cinema have lost one of its most talented artists. I would like to associate myself and my party in sending
our condolences to the bereaved family.
LEADER OF OPPOSITION (Mr Ansuman Tiwari): में आप केद्वारा अवपात की गई श्रद्धांजलल में अपिे को भी सहयोजजत करती ह ूँ।
Page 5
MADAM SPEAKER: The House may now stand in silence for a short while as
a mark of respect to the memory of the departed.
(The Members then stand in silence for a while)
MADAM SPEAKER: Secretary General may convey the message of
condolences to the bereaved family.
SECERETARY GENERAL (Mr. Aditya Chawra): Yes Madam.
3. INTRODUCTION OF NEW MINISTERS
MADAM SPEAKER: Prime Minister to introduce new Ministers.
PRIME MINISTER (Miss Sneha Pramanik): MADAM speaker, I have immense pleasure to introduce to you and through you, to the House, my colleagues, the new Ministers.
Shri Bhavya Dua, Minister of Labour & Employment.
Shri Romil Jain, Minister of Commerce & Industry.
Kumari Satabddi Panda, Minister of Civil Aviation.
(While being introduced each minister in turn stands with folded hands. The Members greet them by thumping on their desks).
Page 6
4. QUESTION HOUR
MADAM SPEAKER :
MADAM SPEAKER : Miss Ishika Bothra
MISS ISHIKA BOTHRA
MADAM SPEAKER :
(Miss Ayushi Sagar)
Page 7
MADAM SPEAKER : Miss Ishika Bothra
MISS ISHIKA BOTHRA:
MADAM SPEAKER :
(Miss Ayushi Sagar)
MADAM SPEAKER : Miss Mansi Tripathi
MISS MANSI TRIPATHI :
Page 8
MADAM SPEAKER :
(Miss Ayushi Sagar)
MADAM SPEAKER : No More Supplimentary Questions Please.
MADAM SPEAKER : Question no. 102. Miss Shalini Sharma Please. MISS SHALINI SHARMA: Question no.102. Hon'ble Speaker Madam Will the Minister of Defence be pleased to state (a) Number of mishaps occured in the recent few months with details ? (b) If so, mention the actions initiated by the Ministry to eradicated such
type of mishaps. give details thereof. MADAM SPEAKER: Hon'ble Minister of Defence, Please.
Page 9
MINISTER OF DEFENCE (Miss Kritansha singh): Madam, Answer (a) - In the recent seven months, unfortunately, there all total elevan numbers of mishaps occured; * The INS Sindhu Rakshak in which 18 sailors died after explosion Fire on submarine at Military Dockyard in Mumbai * Fire reported INS Viraat & INS Konkan * Fishing Traller collided with INS Talwar on * Hole found in pillar conpartment in INS Vipul in * Mishaps occured in INS Sindhughosh * INS Betwa, INS Tarkash Hull, INS Airawat suffers damage * Accident took place in INS Sindhurath (Feb 2014) Answer (b) - Accidents suffers by Navy Vessels over the past few months is really a matter of great concern - The Navy is seariouly looking into all the accident matters and they are in the process of taking corrective actions. It will be seriously observed that such accidents are minimised in the coming days. Each accident among all 10 mishaps is equally serious matter for me and my ministry. There was a need to strictly follow standard operating procedure and draw proper lessons.
MADAM SPEAKER: First Supplementary question, Please. Miss Shalini Sharma. MISS SHALINI SHARMA: Madam (a) Whether the Govt. proposes to modernise Indian Navy for not having such sort of mishaps. (b) If so, the details thereof with the fund provided for this purpose for the current year. (c) Whether the modernisation provision of Indian Navy was hampered due to the lack and insufficiency of fund, if so, the details thereof.
Page 10
MADAM SPEAKER: Hon'ble Minister of Defence, Please. MINISTER OF DEFENCE (Miss Kritansha singh): Madam,
Answer (a & b) Yes Madam, Modernisation of Indian Navy is continuous process keeping in view the prevailing security environment, emerging technology and capability to be achieved. The budget allocation for Indian Navy for the year 2013-14 is 34212.33 crores out of which 22738.70 crorres is earmarked/appropriated for the modernisation purpose. Answer (c) - No madam, sufficient and adequate fund have been
provided by the Govt. to Navy to fulfil the requirement of modernisation process of Indian Navy.
MADAM SPEAKER: Second Supplementary, Mr. Alankrit Pandit, Please. MR. ALANKRIT PANDIT:
Madam, will the Minister of Defence be pleased to state: the number of submarines procured in the country during the last few years with details of procurement.
MADAM SPEAKER: Hon'ble Minister of Defence, Please. MINISTER OF DEFENCE (Miss Kritansha singh): Madam, One Nuclear powered submarine has been procured on lease from Russia and Commissioned in Jan 2012. MADAM SPEAKER: Third Supplementary, Miss Rukaya Khanam, Please. MISS RUKAYA KHANAM: Madam, Will the Minister of Defence be pleased to state : the status of Indian Navy and its capabilities after such mishaps?
Page 11
MADAM SPEAKER: Hon'ble Minister of Defence, Please. MINISTER OF DEFENCE:
Madam, In the last 10 years, the Indian Navy is advanced, most powerful and modern Navy of the world. that is why almost all the countries i.e. All sea faring countries of the world want to have joint exercise and collaboration with us. Every year we are acquiring so many modern
equipments, plateforms, warships - Vikramaditya, T- 81. Every year, in shipyard itself, we are supplying 5 new warships to Indian Navy. The project and planning of Indian Navy has not been hampered or blocked after such mishaps. Till 2013, India has a fleet of 15 submarines including 10 Russian, Kiloclass Vessels, 04 German HDW Vessel and 01 Leased Nuclear INS Chakra.
MADAM SPEAKER : No More Supplimentary Questions Please.
MADAM SPEAKER : Question no. 103. Miss Chitrashree, Please. MISS CHITRASHREE: Question no.103. Honourable Speaker Madam …
Indian railway is the life line to the nation which provides a
great access to our citizen all over the country. It is the cheapest means of
communication and millions of people are dependent on it . But the
condition now a day has gone wilder.The Cheapest Means is no
cheaper.Because of the less frequencies and high population the journey
has become very difficult.
I would like to know the answer of following few questions.
a) In the year 2013-14 how many new trains in different categories have
been introduced? Specially in respect of connecting the northern most
part of India to the main cities of India.
b) How many accidents, collision and the events of derailment had
happened during this year?
c) Is the Government taking any step for the safety, security and to insure
the life of passengers?
Page 12
MADAM SPEAKER: Hon'ble Railway Minister, Please. RAILWAY MINISTER (Miss Sristhi Singh): Hon'ble Speaker Madam, Answer (a) Madam In the year 2013-14 we have introduced 109 trains in all
which is itself a record in the history of Indian railways. Out of 109, 67
are Express trains, 26 passenger trains, 8 MEMU services, 8 DEMU
services. Beside these trains 11 trains are extended to give more access to
the passengers. We have taken a great care of the remote areas of
Northern Eastern India. 5 new trains are started to connect the main
cities of NE India with the capital.
Answer (b) & (c).
Madam… Safety and security of passengers is always our first priority
and Indian railways is deeply concerned about it. But to my grave
sadness and with the heavy heart I am pronouncing that in the year
2013-14 , 12 incidents of accidents ,16 collision,31 events of derailment
and 69 accidents at the railway crossings without gate had happened. In
all 206 passengers died, 308 passengers got major injured, 1028
passenger got minor injuries. Government expresses its deep condolence
to the victims and their families. Government has declared the
compensation of Rs. 15 lac who lost their lives and Rs. 5 lac for the
passengers who got major injuries and Rs. 2 Lac for the passenger with
minor injuries during the mishaps. But compensation can never settle
the as before. Government has tied up with some International security
Agencies and IIT in searching the new techniques of securities including
GPS system, Ultra Sonic sound wave system to check crack and flaws in
the railway tracks.
Page 13
MADAM SPEAKER : First Supplementary Question. Miss Chitrashree, Please.
MISS CHITRASHREE: Madam, Honourable minister has shown a great
concern regarding the safety and security of the passengers in his speech.
But the conditions are terrible.
Madam, I would like to know from the honourable minister
that what steps has been taken by the railway ministry for the safety and
security of woman passengers in the train.
MADAM SPEAKER: Hon'ble Railway Minister, Please.
RAILWAY MINISTER (Miss Sristhi Singh): Hon'ble Speaker Madam,
Indian railway accords, utmost importance to the security of passengers
in Railway premises. The security apparatus in stations / on trains is
being continuously strengthened to ensure passenger security. Special
emphasis is being given on measures to take care of the security needs of
women passengers……..To increase the presence of women personnel in
RPF, 10% of the vacancies in every recruitment are reserved for women.
RPF and GRP staff and officers regularly attend the trains and also
conduct surprise inspections at major stations with focus on security of
women passengers. Surveillance cameras are also installed at key
locations at important stations to watch the movement/activities of
suspicious elements.
MADAM SPEAKER : Second Supplementary Question. Miss Kajal
Patel, Please..
MISS KAJAL PATEL: Hon'ble Madam, will the Minister of Railway be
pleased to state:
a) Even after the very long time why only 31.33% of railway routes are
electrified?
b) Is Government taking any step for speedy development in this regard?
Page 14
MADAM SPEAKER: Hon'ble Railway Minister, Please.
RAILWAY MINISTER: Hon'ble Speaker Madam,
Answer (a) & (b). Electrical traction is an environmental friendly,
pollution-free and energy efficient mode of transport and offer an
excellent alternative to fossil fuels as a source of energy. IR decided to
adopt 25 KV AC traction system and, thus, selected main lines and high-
density routes were taken up for Energisation in a planned manner.
Today, out of the seven major trunk routes connecting Mumbai, Kolkata,
New Delhi and Chennai, six are fully electrified and work is in progress
on the remaining Mumbai-Chennai route. In the XII Five year plan we
set a target of electrification of 2500 RKm(Broad Gauge),750 RKm
(Meter gauge) and to our delight we have achieved 80% of set target by
the end of fourth year of the five year plan.
MADAM SPEAKER : No More Supplimentary Questions Please.
MADAM SPEAKER : Question no. 104. Miss Anuska Agrawal, please.
MISS ANUSKA AGRAWAL :
MADAM SPEAKER :
Page 15
(Miss Veena Shukla)
MADAM SPEAKER : Kumari Anuska Agrawal
KUMARI ANUSKA AGRAWAL:
MADAM SPEAKER :
Page 16
(Miss Veena Shukla)
MADAM SPEAKER : Miss Sudipta Das
MISS SUDIPTA DAS:
MADAM SPEAKER :
(Miss Veena Shukla)
MADAM SPEAKER : No More Supplimentary Questions Please.
Page 17
MADAM SPEAKER : Question no. 105. Ayush Tiwari Ayush Tiwari:
MADAM SPEAKER :
(Md. Amin Khan)
Page 18
MADAM SPEAKER : Ayush Tiwari
Ayush Tiwari
MADAM SPEAKER :
(Md. Amin Khan)
MADAM SPEAKER : Shreya Upadhyay,
SHREYA UPADHYAY :
Page 19
MADAM SPEAKER :
(Md. Amin Khan)
MADAM SPEAKER : Miss Alpana
MISS ALPANA :
MADAM SPEAKER :
(Md. Amin Khan)
MADAM SPEAKER : No More Supplimentary Questions Please.
The Question Hour is over.
Now the Paper to be laid on the table.
Page 20
5. PAPER TO BE LAID ON THE TABLE
MADAM SPEAKER: Hon'ble Minister of Commerce And Industry. MINISTER OF COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY (Mr. Romil Jain): Madam, I beg to lay on the Table:- (1) Review by the Government of the working of the Chemicals and
Allied Products Export Promotion Council (CAPEXIL), Kolkata, for the
year 2012-2013.
(2) Annual Report of the Shellac and Forest Products Export Promotion
Council (formerly Shellac Export Promotion Council), Kolkata, for the
year 2012-2013.
(3) Review (Hindi and English versions) by the Government of the
working of the Plastics Export Promotion Council, Mumbai, for the year
2012-2013.
MADAM SPEAKER: Hon'ble Minister of Civil Aviation.
MINISTER OF CIVIL AVIATION (Miss Satabddi Panda): Madam, I beg to lay on the Table:- (1) A copy of the Annual Report of the Airports Authority of India, New
Delhi, for the year 2012-2013, along with Audited Accounts.
(2) Statement regarding Review (Hindi and English versions) by the
Government of the working of the Airports Authority of India, New
Delhi, for the year 2012-2013.
Page 21
6. WELCOME TO THE FOREIGN PARLIAMENTARY DELEGATION
MADAM SPEAKER : Hon. Member, I have to make an announcement.
On my own behalf of the hon. Members of the House, I have a great
pleasure in
extending our warm welcome to His Excellency REET DUA, speaker of
the Algeria Parliament and the Hon. Members of the Algeria Parliament
Delegation who are on a visit to India as our honoured guests.
The other Hon. Members of the Delegation are : 1. Miss. ANTARA CHAWDHURY,Deputy Speaker,
2. Miss. PALAK GOYAL , Finance Minister
It is very high powered delegation. They are now seated in the Special Box. We wish them a happy and fruitful stay in our country.
7. CALLING ATTENTION MOTION
MADAM SPEAKER: Now let us take up the Calling Attention Motion."
Ladla Hasan करेंगे
Ladla Hasan :
Page 22
(Mr. Aman Tiwari)
Ladla Hasan
Ladla Hasan :
Atiraj Anand
Page 23
Atiraj Anand
Miss Mansi Singh
Miss Mansi Singh-
Page 24
Miss Shivalika Sharma
Miss Shivalika Sharma-
Miss Shailee Agrawal
Miss Shailee Agrawal
Page 25
(Mr. Aman Tiwari)
Page 26
8. LEGISLATIVE BUSINESS
BILL INTRODUCED
MADAM SPEAKER: Hon’ble Minister of Law and Justice to introduce the
Bill.
Minister of Law and Justice (Miss Paridhi Pansari): Madam, I beg to move
for leave to introduce a Bill “The Judicial Standards and Accountability Bill, 2012”
MADAM SPEAKER: The question is:
“That leave be granted to introduce a Bill “The Judicial Standards and Accountability Bill, 2012”.
“Those who are in favour will please say ‘Aye’.
(The majority of the Members say ‘Aye’)
“Those who are against is please say ‘No’ ”
(A minority of the Members say ‘No’).
I think the ‘Ayes’ have it, the ‘Ayes’ have it, the ‘Ayes’ have it. Leave is
granted.
Minister of Law and Justice (Miss Paridhi Pansari): Sir, I introduce the Bill
MADAM SPEAKER: The Bill will be considered in the next session of
parliament.
BILL FOR CONSIDERATION
MADAM SPEAKER: Now the House will take up consideration of the
National Food Security Bill, 2013. The Minister Of State Of The Ministry Of
Consumer Affairs, Food And Public Distribution, Please.
THE MINISTER OF STATE OF THE MINISTRY OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS,
FOOD AND PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION (Mr. Shantanu Shukla):
Madam I beg to move:
“That the Bill to provide for food and nutritional security in human life cycle approach, by ensuring access to adequate quantity of quality food at affordable prices to people to live a life with dignity and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto" be taken into consideration.
Page 27
Madam India accounts for one third of the world's poor. Almost half of the country’s children aged below 5 years are chronically malnourished. More than a third of Indians aged between 14 and 49 years are categorized as under nourished. Therefore with a view to provide food and nutritional security in human life cycle approach, by ensuring access to adequate quantity of quality food at affordable prices, the Government has brought forward this bill before this august House. This is one of the important steps towards eradication of hunger, malnutrition and resultant poverty.
The Salient features and some of the important provisions of the Bill are as follows.
1. 75% rural and 50% of the urban population are entitled for three
years from enactment to five kg food grains per month at 3 , 2 ,
1 per kg for rice, wheat and coarse grains (millet), respectively;
2. The states are responsible for determining eligibility;
3. Pregnant women and lactating mothers are entitled to a nutritious
"take home ration" of 600 Calories and a maternity benefit of at least
Rs 6,000 for six months;
4. Children 6 months to 14 years of age are to receive free hot meals or
"take home rations";
5. The central government will provide funds to states in case of short
supplies of food grains;
6. The current food grain allocation of the states will be protected by the
central government for at least six months;
7. The eldest woman in the household, 18 years or above, is the head of
the household for the issuance of the ration card;
8. State Food Commissions will be formed for implementation and
monitoring of the provisions of the Act.
Page 28
9. The cost of the implementation is estimated to be $22 billion(1.25 lac
crore), approximately 1.5 % of GDP.
10. The poorest who are covered under the Antodaya yojna will remain
entitled to the 35 kg of grains allotted to them under the mentioned
scheme.
Madam Speaker, I am confident that the all Hon’ble Members of this House irrespective of party affiliation will welcome the Bill whole heartedly. I now move that ‘National Food Security Bill, 2013’, be taken into consideration. MADAM SPEAKER: Motion moved. MADAM SPEAKER: Miss Shilpi Agrawal MISS SHILPI AGRAWAL: Food Security Bill, 2013 is brought before
the Parliament at a time, when India suffer with poverty, malnutrition,
hunger and under nourished. Keeping all features points in mind, I
would like to support the food security bill as it proposes to give
subsidized food grains to 75 per cent of Indian 833 million rural
population and 50 per cent of an estimated 377 million urban people.
The provisions of the Bill says that the beneficiaries would get a
total of 5 kilogram of rice, wheat and coarse grains every month at the
price ranging from one rupee to three per kilogram it is much cheaper
than the market price. My next point is about Nutrition Support to
pregnant women and lactating mothers. The provision in the Bill says
that free meal would be given to pregnant women during pregnancy and
six months thereafter. And maturity benefit of not less than Rs.6,000
also provided to them. Expressing my great satisfaction about the way in
which this Bill is moved in this House to remove poverty and hunger
making Right to Food a reality.
Page 29
MADAM SPEAKER: Miss Chitralekha , Please.
MISS CHITRALEKHA : Thank you very much Madam for giving
me this opportunity to speak my point of view about the Bill. I
think Govt should create job opportunities and work for
every person to make a poverty free country and I think this
bill will add more poverty to our country. The very first point
is this the expenditure behind this step. From where such a
huge amount will come to feed a huge population of our
country at a negligible cost. And even at such a stage when
rupee is struggling to keep its reputation. Such a huge cost
will definitely cut down costs from many important
development or growth sectors. Second thing is about
corruption in our country. Now with this bill a huge amount
of money and food grains will travel through a long chain
before it landed into poor people's plate. And all of us know
that by the time 1KG rice will be converted into 10 gm rice or
may be less. That's what is happening in our country and will
be happening coming days because there is no such solid
system implement to stop corruption. So with this bill many
such Netas or officials will be very happy as they might get a
chance to earn some extra money. Another point is about the
amount of food Govt has to collect from market to keep this
plan success. From here Govt has indirectly allowed to grow
the black market and may be some more scams for future.
This might create an emergency situation in market and food
grain prices may go up unnecessarily.I, therefore, strongly
oppose & against the bill.
Page 30
MADAM SPEAKER: SRI GAURABH BISWAS MR. GAURABH BISWAS: Madam, It is very famous citation and
actual truth ‘Agar Pet na Payian Rotian Sabe Galan Khotian” (if person is
hungry he will not listen to even truth, Food is basic need for a living). I
want to cuote that in our Holy Granth “Sri Guru Granth Sahib”, Bhukhe
Bhagat Na keeje, Je apni Mala Leeje’ mean if a persons or saint is hungry
it is not possible for him to concentrate on his spiritual life. Due to
this historic bill giving food for all, food security to 75% of the rural area
and 50% of the urban population with focus on nutritional need of
children, women especially for poor pregnant women and lactating
women. The National Food Security Bill will be a revolution in Food
Distribution System. It is a historic reform that the delivery of the food
grain will be end to end to all the beneficiaries. I stand with support to
this historic bill giving food for all.
Page 31
MADAM SPEAKER: Mr. Ansuman Tiwari, Please.
MR. ANSUMAN TIWARI: आजादी के बाद भारत में सरकारों िे 50 से अचिक
योजिाएं गरीबी हटािे और भ ख का अतं करिे के ललए चलाई, लेककि इसके बावज द भ ख िे
भारत में पांव जमाए हुए है। अब जब आम चुिाव करीब आ रहा है तब केन्द्र सरकार िे भ ख का
अतं करिे के ललए दनुिया की सबसे बडी खाद्य सुरक्षा योजिा की शुरूआत कर दी है।
लोगों को खाद्यान्द्ि देिे की योजिा को केवल अिाजों तक ही सीलमत क्यों रखा गया है
और इसमें दालों और खाद्य तेलों आदद को शालमल क्यों िहीं ककया गया? इि खाद्यान्द्िों में
प्रोटीि की कमी की कोई जांच िहीं होती, खरीद के समय इस पर कोई ध्याि िहीं ददया जाता
है। बड ेदखु की बात है कक जजस देश में लाखों टि अिाज गोदामों में सड जाता है, च हों और
जािवरों की भेंट चढ़ जाता है, वहां इंसाि भ खों मरते हैं। सरकारी गोदामों में 50 लाख टि से
अचिक खाद्यान्द्ि का स्टॉक रहिे के बावज द देश में भुखमरी है। आज खाद्य सुरक्षा
स चकांक में भारत का स्थाि 70वा ंहै, जबकक वर्ा 2012 में 66वा ंथा। खाद्यान्द्ि पेट का
सवाल है या वोट का?
सरकार खाद्य सुरक्षा देिे जा रही है - अभी तक वह ककसािों को उिके द्वारा उत्पाददत
अिाज की समुचचत सुरक्षा व भंडारण की गारंटी भी िहीं दे सकी है। सरकारी गोदामों में उिकी
क्षमता से कम भंडारण होिे पर भी अिाज सडता है क्योंकक उसे जाि-ब झकर सडाया जाता है
ताकक उसे शराब के उत्पादि में इस्तेमाल ककया जा सके। इस फ ड लसक्योररटी बबल में ि
जािे ककतिी खालमयां हैं - पांच ककलो अिाज से ककसी व्यजक्त के महीिे भर का पोर्ण ककस
तरह सुनिजश्चत होगा? सरकार की इस योजिा से एक व्यजक्त को प्रनतददि केवल 167 ग्राम
अिाज ही लमलेगा।
Page 32
MADAM SPEAKER: Miss Priyanshi Gautam, Please.
MISS PRIYANSHI GAUTAM: Madam, It is a good thing that the
Central Government is thinking of providing food security to the millions
of poor people of India. But I want to ask the Government that still the
number of people who are truly poor is not properly identified and many
people who should be real beneficiaries are still not having any BPL card
either. In many States rich and middleclass people have BPL cards just
be beneficiaries of Government land and subsidies provided by the
Central Government. So, in my view a proper survey of true poor people
should be done. So, I think first the Government should think of a proper
distribution of PDS because in many places and States the PDS system is
not in proper order and many times the beneficiaries don’t get the proper
benefit. Even after having mid-day meals and Aaganwadi the small
children of India die of poor conditions of food and hygiene. So, before
implementing I suggest that a proper format of the bill with proper
suggested amendments should be carried out as we have time to
implement it properly.
MADAM SPEAKER: Hon'ble Prime Minister, Please.
HON'BLE PRIME MINISTER: इस महत्वप णा बबल से देश ग्रामीण के्षत्रों में बसि े
वाले 75 प्रनतशत तथा शहरों की 50 प्रनतशत आबादी को सस्ता अन्द्ि लमलेगा। नियम के लाग होिे की नतचथ से तीि वर्ा की अवचि के ललए सभी पात्र लाभाचथायों के ललए चावल 3 रपए, गेंह 2
रपए व मोटा अिाज 1 रपए प्रनत ककग्रा की दर से ववतररत ककया जाएगा। राष्रीय खाद्य
सुरक्षा बबल में 612.3 लाख टि के अिुमानित वावर्ाक खाद्यान्द्ि हेतु 1,00,953 करोड तथा इसके कियान्द्वयि हेतु 23,794 करोड अथाात ्कुल 1,24,747 करोड रपए की अिुमानित खाद्य
राजसहायता दी जािी है। इस नियम के माध्यम से प्रत्येक व्यजक्त को 5 ककलो खाद्यान्द्ि,
अन्द्तोदय अन्द्ि योजिा के अतंगात प्रत्येक पररवार को 35 कक.ग्रा. अिाज उपलब्ि होगा। गभाावस्था के दौराि और उसके पश्चात ्छः माह तक िःशुल्क भोजि तथा 6000/- रपए का माततृ्व लाभ देिे का निणाय ललया गया है। इसके अनतररक्त 6 माह से 14 वर्ा के बच्चों के ललए
Page 33
उिकी आयु के अिुक ल उच्च पोर्ाहार वाला भोजि देिे का भी प्राविाि इस अचिनियम में ककया गया है।
हालांकक, गरीबी के अिेकों-अिेक आंकडे हैं, कफर भी मािा जाए तो 21.9 प्रनतशत यािी
26 करोड लोग गरीब की शे्रणी में आते हैं, लेककि मैं यह बतािा चाह ंगा कक इस योजिा के
माध्यम से 82 करोड लोगों के लाभाजन्द्वत होिे का लक्ष्य रखा गया है। यह बबल गरीबों की पीडा
को ध्याि में रखते हुए बिाया गया है, अिुस चचत जानत के व्यजक्तयों को अचिकतम लाभ ददया
गया है और यदद य पीए सरकार के द्वारा चलाई गई महत्वप णा प्रमुख योजिा मिरेगा को इसके
साथ जोडकर देखा जाए तो गरीब मिरेगा से मजद री लेगा और खाद्य सुरक्षा योजिा के
अतंगात पेट भरि ेहेतु सस्ता अन्द्ि।
खाद्य भंडारण के बारे में प्रश्ि उठाए गए। यह सही है कक खाद्यान्द्ि के ललए
भंडारण क्षमता अभी भी हमारे सामिे एक चुिौती है। मैं, माििीय मंत्री जी को िन्द्यवाद देता ह ं, जजिके प्रयासों से आज देश की भंडारण क्षमता 822.38 लाख टि है जो कक योजिा हेतु आवश्यक अिुमानित क्षमता 614.3 लाख टि से कहीं ज्यादा है।
इस महत्वप णा योजिा को अकेले केन्द्र द्वारा लाग िहीं ककया जा सकता, राज्य
सरकारों को इस महत्वप णा योजिा में अपिा योगदाि देिा है। अतः मैं इस बबल का समथाि करता ह ं।
Page 34
MADAM SPEAKER: The Minister of State of the Ministry Of Consumer Affairs, Food And Public Distribution, Please
THE MINISTER OF STATE OF THE MINISTRY OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS,
FOOD AND PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION:
Madam, today this House has discussed this important Bill & hon. Members have participated in this discussion. The entire House has taken a very active part in the discussion. Madam, I am grateful to all the Members who have supported the Bill I am also grateful to those members who have given their constructive criticism on it. Madam, we have made wider consultations and the Standing Committee has done a good job.
The important thing is that in the present BPL system, a consumer is getting 35 kgs and, the BPL and AY together is only 6.52 crores, that we are covering only 32 crore of the people. In the new Bill we are covering 67 per cent of the population of the country, that is, 82 crore people.
some Members suggested whether we have enough storage capacity. Madam, five years back, our storage capacity was to the tune of 55 million tonnes which at present has grown to 75 million tonnes. By 2014-15, we will have 85 million tonnes of storage capacity. I know this is not enough because we should have intermediate godowns in the States. We have suggested to the States that they should build intermediate godowns for four months of their PDS requirement which needs about four lakh metric tonnes.
Madam, I thing we have clarified most of the points and some doubts here. So, my request is that this Bill be passed unanimously.
MADAM SPEAKER: Now the question is that “The National Food Security
Bill,2013" for matters connected therewith, be taken into consideration”
Those who are in favour will say ‘Aye’.
(The majority of Members say ‘Aye’)
Those who are against it will say ‘No’
(A minority of the Members say ‘No’)
I think the ‘Ayes’ have it, ‘Ayes’ have it, ‘Ayes’ have it.
The motion is adopted.
Now, Clause by clause consideration.
Page 35
MADAM SPEAKER: Now the question is that clause 2-10 stands part of the
Bill.
There is one amendment in clause 5 by Miss Priyanshi Gautam.Are you moving
it?
Miss Priyanshi Gautam: No, Madam, in view of the reply given by the
Minister I am not pressing my amendment.
MADAM SPEAKER: Now the question is that clause 2-10 stand part of the
Bill.
Those who are in favour will say ‘Aye’
(The majority of Members say ‘Aye)
Those against will say ‘No)
(A minority of Members say ‘No’)
I think the ‘Ayes’ have it, the ‘Ayes’ have it, the ‘Ayes’ have it,
The motion is adopted
Clause 2-10 stand part of the Bill.
MADAM SPEAKER: Now the question is:
“That clause I, the enacting Preamble and the Title stand part of the Bill”
Those who are in favour will please say ‘Aye’.
(The majority of Members say ‘Aye’)
Those who are against it will please say ‘No’.
(A minority of Members say ‘No’.)
I think the ‘Ayes’ have it, the ‘Ayes’ have it, the Ayes’ have it.
The motion is adopted.
MADAM SPEAKER: The Minister Of State Of The Ministry Of Consumer
Affairs, Food And Public Distribution, Please.
THE MINISTER OF STATE OF THE MINISTRY OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS,
FOOD AND PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION:
Sir, I move the Bill be passed.
Page 36
MADAM SPEAKER: Motion moved:
“That the Bill is passed”.
Those who are in favour will please say ‘Aye’.
(The majority of Members say ‘Aye’)
Those against it may please say ‘No’.
(A minority of Members say ‘No’.)
I think the ‘Ayes’ have it, the ‘Ayes’ have it, the Ayes’ have it.
The motion is adopted.
MADAM SPEAKER: The House is adjourned till tomorrow.
Page 37
LIST OF THE STUDENTS & THEIR'S ROLE
SL NO
NAME OF THE STUDENT CLASS
GENDER
ROLE OF THE STUDENT
1. TRISHA DUA XIB F SPEAKER 2. AKASH RAJAK VIIIA M MARSHAL 3. ADITYA CHAWRA VIIIA M SECRETARY GENERAL 4. GEETANJALI SINGH VIIIA F SECRETARY 1 5. ADITI SINGH VIIIA F SECRETARY 2 6. SHUBHANKAR DAS VIIIA M SECRETARY 3 7. RISHABH BHATTACHARYA VIIIA M MEDIA PERSON (PRESS) 8. AMAN TIWARI VIIIA M MEDIA PERSON (PRESS) 9. REET DUA VIIA F FOREIGN DELEGATE 10. ANTARA CHAWDHURY VIIA F FOREIGN DELEGATE 11. PALAK GOYAL VIIIA F FOREIGN DELEGATE 12. SNEHA PRAMANIK XA F PRIME MINISTER 13. SHANTANU SHUKLA XB M FOOD & SECURITY 14. AMAN TIWARI XB M HOME MINISTER 15. KRITANSHA SINGH XIA F DEFENCE MINISTER 16. SHRISHTI SINGH IXB F RAILWAY MINISTER 17. VEENA SHUKLA VIIIA F HRD MINISTER 18. AYUSHI SAGAR XA F EXTERNAL AFFAIRS 19. MD. AMIN KHAN XA M TELECOMMUNICATION 20. PARIDHI PANSARI VIIIB F LAW & JUSTICE 21. SATABDDI PANDA IXA F CIVIL AVIATION 22. BHAVYA DUA VIIA M LABOUR & EMPLOYMENT 23. ROMIL JAIN VIIIA M COMMERCE & INDUSTRY 24. ALPANA SINGH VIIIA F MEMBER OF RULING PARTY
(MP) 25. SUDIPTA DAS XA F MEMBER OF RULING PARTY
(MP) 26. PRIYANSHI GAUTAM XB F MEMBER OF RULING PARTY
(MP) 27. SHILPI AGRAWAL VIIIB F MEMBER OF RULING PARTY
(MP) 28. MANSI TRIPATHI VIIIA F MEMBER OF RULING PARTY
(MP) 29. GAURAV BISWAS XIC M MEMBER OF RULING PARTY
(MP) 30. SHALINI KUMARI IXB F MEMBER OF RULING PARTY
(MP) 31. RUKAYA KHANAM XA F MEMBER OF RULING PARTY
(MP) 32. SHREYA UPADHYAY XA F MEMBER OF RULING PARTY
(MP) 33. SWAMY MISHRA XB M DEPUTY SPEAKER 34. ANSHUMAN TIWARI IXB M LEADER OF OPPOSITION 35. SHAILY AGRAWAL IXA F MEMBER OF OPPOSITION
(MP) 36. ISHIKA BOTHRA VIIIB F MEMBER OF OPPOSITION
(MP) 37. SHALINI SHARMA IX B F MEMBER OF OPPOSITION
(MP)
Page 38
38. ANUSHKA AGRAWAL IX B F MEMBER OF OPPOSITION (MP)
39. CHITRALEKA YADAV XI A F MEMBER OF OPPOSITION (MP)
40. CHITRASHREE CHAKRABORTY IX A F MEMBER OF OPPOSITION (MP)
41. LADLE HASAN X B M MEMBER OF OPPOSITION (MP)
42. ALANKRIT PANDIT X B M MEMBER OF OPPOSITION (MP)
43. SHIVALIKA SHARMA X B F MEMBER OF OPPOSITION (MP)
44. KAJAL PATEL X B F MEMBER OF OPPOSITION (MP)
45. MANSI SINGH X A F MEMBER OF OPPOSITION (MP)
46. ATIRAJ ANAND VIII B M MEMBER OF OPPOSITION (MP)
47. AYUSH TIWARI X A M MEMBER OF OPPOSITION (MP)
STUDENTS' DETAILS SL NO
NAME OF THE STUDENT CLASS
GENDER
छात्रों के िाम
1. TRISHA DUA XIB F
2. AKASH RAJAK VIIIA M
3. ADITYA CHAWRA VIIIA M
4. GEETANJALI SINGH VIIIA F
5. ADITI SINGH VIIIA F
6. SHUBHANKAR DAS VIIIA M
7. RISHABH BHATTACHARYA VIIIA M
8. AMAN TIWARI VIIIA M
9. REET DUA VIIA F
10. ANTARA CHAWDHURY VIIA F
11. PALAK GOYAL VIIIA F
12. SNEHA PRAMANIK XA F
13. SHANTANU SHUKLA XB M
14. AMAN TIWARI XB M
15. KRITANSHA SINGH XIA F
16. SHRISHTI SINGH IXB F
17. VEENA SHUKLA VIIIA F
Page 39
18. AYUSHI SAGAR XA F
19. MD. AMIN KHAN XA M
20. PARIDHI PANSARI VIIIB F
21. SATABDDI PANDA IXA F
22. BHAVYA DUA VIIA M
23. ROMIL JAIN VIIIA M
24. ALPANA SINGH VIIIA F
25. SUDIPTA DAS XA F
26. PRIYANSHI GAUTAM XB F
27. SHILPI AGRAWAL VIIIB F
28. MANSI TRIPATHI VIIIA F
29. GAURAV BISWAS XIC M
30. SHALINI KUMARI IXB F
31. RUKAYA KHANAM XA F
32. SHREYA UPADHYAY XA F
33. SWAMI MISHRA XB M
34. ANSHUMAN TIWARI IXB M
35. SHAILY AGRAWAL IXA F
36. ISHIKA BOTHRA VIIIB F
37. SHALINI SHARMA IX B F
38. ANUSHKA AGRAWAL IX B F
39. CHITRALEKA YADAV XI A F
40. CHITRASHREE CHAKRABORTY IX A F
41. LADLE HASAN X B M
42. ALANKRIT PANDIT X B M
43. SHIVALIKA SHARMA X B F
44. KAJAL PATEL X B F
45. MANSI SINGH X A F
46. ATIRAJ ANAND VIII B M
47. AYUSH TIWARI X A M
Page 40
NAME OF THE ESCORT: 1. AUROBIND BEHERA, LIB 2. MRS. INDIRA SINGH, TGT SST 3. MR. AKHILESHWAR RAM, TGT SST 4. MRS. P.TOPPO, PGT BIO