2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

123
Neuromusculoskeletal Pain: Lessons from the Myofascia Jay P. Shah, MD Rehabilitation Medicine Department National Institutes of Health

Transcript of 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Page 1: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Neuromusculoskeletal Pain: Lessons from the Myofascia

Jay P. Shah, MDRehabilitation Medicine Department

National Institutes of Health

Page 2: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Disclosures

Nothing to disclose

Page 3: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

NIH Clinical Research Center “Bench to Bedside -

Bedside to Bench”

LaboratoriesLaboratories

Inpatient Care

Outpatient Care

Page 4: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Pattern-generating mechanism (Neuromatrix)

Brain areas encoding pain experience and behaviorsCultural,

past experience,personality

attention

Autonomic endocrine, immune variables

CNS Plasticity

Sensitization

Pathogenic inputs

Visceral inputs

Somatosensory inputs

Melzack, Trends Neurosci 1990; 13:88-92

Perception

Page 5: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Adapted from Butler, DS The Sensitive Nervous System

Pain Mechanisms

Page 6: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

• Review the diagnostic criteria for myofascial pain and demonstrate the referral patterns of common myofascial trigger points (MTrPs)

• Examine the unique neurobiology of muscle pain

• Discuss the dynamic interplay of muscle nociceptors and endogenous biochemicals in the initiation, amplification and perpetuation of peripheral and central sensitization

• Demonstrate that an active myofascial trigger point (MTrP)

in the upper trapezius has elevated levels of inflammatory mediators, neuropeptides, and cytokines, etc. –

substances

known to be associated with persistent pain states, sensitization and inflammation

Goals of Discussion

Page 7: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Introduce novel applications of ultrasound techniques to visualize MTrPs, measure their stiffness properties and local blood flow

Demonstrate that MTrPs in the upper trapezius are stiffer than surrounding tissue and that active MTrPs can be distinguished from latent MTrPs by their high-resistance blood flow

Goals of Discussion

Page 8: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Myofascial Trigger Points

A Very Common, Complex and Overlooked Cause of Non-articular Musculoskeletal Pain

Hans-Werner Weisskircher www.trigger-point.com

Page 9: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Essential Clinical Criteria for Myofascial Pain

Palpation of a taut band•

Exquisitely tender spot (a myofascial trigger point) in the taut band

Reproduction of the subject’s symptomatic painGerwin et al. Interrater reliability in myofascial trigger point examination. Pain. 1997;69(1-2):65-73

Hans-Werner Weisskircher www.trigger-point.com

Page 10: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Palpation of a taut band•

Exquisitely tender spot (a myofascial trigger point) in the taut band

Reproduction of the subjects symptomatic painGerwin et al. Interrater reliability in myofascial trigger point

examination. Pain. 1997;69(1-2):65-73

Courtesy Marta Imamura

Essential Clinical Criteria for Myofascial Pain

Page 11: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Myofascial Trigger Points

2-5 areas in hard, palpable bands of skeletal muscle:

Active –

cause a clinical pain complaint or other abnormal sensory symptoms

Latent –

show all the other characteristics of active MTrPs, except that they’re pain free

Travell JG, Simons DG. Myofascial pain and dysfunction: the trigger point manual. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins; 1992.

Page 12: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Upper Trapezius

Medial Pterygoid

Lateral PterygoidSCM (sternal division)

Masseter

Orofacial Pain 2º Myofascial Trigger

Points

Hans-Werner Weisskircher

www.trigger-point.com

Page 13: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Release of Inflammatory mediators, Neuropeptides and Cytokines

Release of Inflammatory Release of Inflammatory mediators, Neuropeptides mediators, Neuropeptides and Cytokines and Cytokines

Courtesy Marta Imamura

Muscle Muscle InjuryInjury

Muscle Pain, Inflammation, and Sensitization

Page 14: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Sensitize wide dynamic range neurons and higher centers leading to allodynia, hyperalgesia and…

Sensitize wide dynamic range Sensitize wide dynamic range neurons and higher centers neurons and higher centers leading to allodynia, hyperalgesia leading to allodynia, hyperalgesia andand……

Courtesy Marta Imamura

Muscle Muscle InjuryInjury

Muscle Pain, Inflammation, and Sensitization

Page 15: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Courtesy Marta Imamura

… expansion of the receptive field of pain and referral of pain ……

expansion of the receptive expansion of the receptive

field of pain and referral of pain field of pain and referral of pain

Muscle Pain, Inflammation, and Sensitization

Page 16: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Travell JG, Simons DG. Myofascial pain and dysfunction: the trigger pointmanual. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins; 1992.

Page 17: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Common Referral Diagnoses for Pain Found to be of Myofascial Origin

Angina Pectoris (atypical)

Appendicitis

Atypical Migraine•

Tension Headache

Occipital Headache

Pectoralis Major

Lower Rectus Abdominis

Sternocleidomastoid, Temporalis, Mastic. Musc, Post. Cervicals,

Travell JG, Simons DG. Myofascial pain and dysfunction: the trigger point manual. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins; 1992.

Page 18: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

“Since no specialty claims skeletal muscle as their organ, it

is often overlooked”David G. Simons, MD

Page 19: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Muscle –

The “Orphan Organ”

NO specialty claims muscle as its organMuscle is ½ of the bodyNo organized emphasis on muscle pain (MTrP) research or student trainingClinicians focus primarily on treating the SYMPTOMS of myogenic pain, not the CAUSE of the pain (MTrPs)

Page 20: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Active MTrPs can only be diagnosed by systematic palpation

Hans-Werner Weisskircher

www.trigger-point.com

Page 21: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Apply Firm Pressure

Hans-Werner Weisskircher www.trigger-point.com

Page 22: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Palpation, Palpation, Palpation•

Careful palpation of the surface of the body reveals distinct differences in the quality and density of the underlying tissue. Many of these areas or points will be tender:

A Shi points in Traditional Chinese Medicine

Kori in Japanese system•

Muskelharten in German system

Page 23: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Nociceptor Function•

Encode Noxious Stimuli•

Possibly leading to pain

Maintain Tissue Health•

Initiate and maintain reaction to injury

Page 24: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Nociceptors are Dynamic “Two-way”

Structures

Page 25: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

A Critical Efferent Nociceptor Function: Neuropeptide (Substance P, CGRP) Production

Courtesy Jan Dommerholt

Page 26: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Muscle pain is NOT skin pain

Unique Neurobiology of Muscle Pain

Page 27: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Muscle Pain is often Overlooked

“I’ll beBack!”

“Ohhh, my

Back!”

Page 28: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Unique Characteristics of Muscle Pain

• Aching, cramping pain, difficult to localize and referred to deep and distant somatic tissues

• Muscle pain activates unique cortical structures Svensson P et al. Cerebral processing of acute skin and muscle pain in humans. J Neurophysiology July 1997; 78: 450-460.

• Inhibited more strongly by descending pain-modulating pathways XianMin Y, Mense S. Response Properties and descending control of rat dorsal horn neurons with deep receptive fields.

Neuroscience 1990; 39:823-831.

• Activation of muscle nociceptors is much more effective at inducing neuroplastic changes in dorsal horn neuronsWall PD, Woolf CJ.

J Physiol 1984 Nov;356:443-458.

Page 29: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Distant Referral Patterns

Hans-Werner Weisskircher www.trigger-

point.com

Page 30: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Powerful Descending Inhibition on Muscle Pain

Fields HL, Basbaum AI: Central nervous system mechanisms of pain modualtion. In Textbook of Pain; 1999:309-329.

Page 31: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Afferent Bombardment of Muscle Nociceptors: 2nd

Messenger Cascades, Induction of Immediate Early

Genes and Protein Synthesis, Excitotoxicity and Cell Death

Activity Dependent PlasticityWall PD, Woolf CJ. Muscle but not cutaneous C-afferent input produces prolonged increases in the excitability of the flexion reflex in the rat. J Physiol. 1984 Nov;356:443-58.

Page 32: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Muscle PainPeripheral Mechanisms

Page 33: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

BRADYKININRECEPTOR

BRADYKININRECEPTORBradykinin Receptor

Muscle Nociception

Binding of Substances to Matched Chemoreceptors

(B2→B1)

Page 34: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Muscle PainSpinal Mechanisms

Page 35: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

• REDUCED SPATIAL RESOLUTION–

Due to lower density of muscle sensory afferents compared to the skin

• CONVERGENCE OF SENSORY INPUT–

Input from skin, bone, viscera, periosteum

Characteristics of Muscle Nociceptor Projections to Dorsal Horn

Page 36: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

• Sustained noxious stimulation (of Group IV fibers in muscle) leads to the opening of previously ineffective connections in dorsal horn neurons

• Intramuscular injection of various biochemicals (e.g., bradykinin, prostaglandins, serotonin, acidic saline, etc.) activates muscle nociceptors and causes allodynia and hyperalgesia

Dorsal Horn Changes in Pathologic Conditions –

Central Sensitization

DIVERGENCE OF SENSORY INPUT

Page 37: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Expansion of Receptive Field by a Painful Muscle Stimulus

Hoheisel U, Mense S, Simons DG. Appearance of new receptive fields in rat dorsal horn neurons following noxious stimulation of skeletal muscle: a

model for referral of muscle pain? Neurosci lett 153:9-12, 1993

Selected neuron responds only to deep pressure in biceps femoris muscle

Biceps Femoris

Courtesy Jan Dommerholt

Page 38: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Hoheisel U, Mense S, Simons DG.

Neurosci lett 153:9-12, 1993

5 min after BK injection in TA, the selected neuron can now be excited by additional RF’s located in deep

muscle that normally have high threshold

Expansion of Receptive Field by a Painful Muscle Stimulus

Courtesy Jan Dommerholt

Page 39: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Hoheisel U, Mense S, Simons DG.

Neurosci lett 153:9-12, 1993

Expansion of Receptive Field by a Painful Muscle Stimulus

Page 40: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Hoheisel U, Mense S, Simons DG.

Neurosci lett 153:9-12, 1993

Expansion of Receptive Field by a Painful Muscle Stimulus

Page 41: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Hoheisel U, Mense S, Simons DG.

Neurosci lett 153:9-12, 1993

Expansion of Receptive Field by a Painful Muscle Stimulus

Page 42: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Hoheisel U, Mense S, Simons DG.

Neurosci lett 153:9-12, 1993

Expansion of Receptive Field by a Painful Muscle Stimulus

Page 43: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Hoheisel U, Mense S, Simons DG

Neurosci lett 153:9-12, 1993

15 min after BK injection in the TA the selected

neuron responds to moderate (innocuous) pressure in its original receptive field -

biceps femoris

Expansion of Receptive Field by a Painful Muscle Stimulus

Allodynia (light pressure and muscle

movement)

Hyperalgesia

Page 44: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Glutamate Substance P

Nociceptive Bombardment causes

Central Sensitization and Neuroplastic

Changes in Dorsal Horn Neurons

Page 45: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Pain begins in Calf, Heel and Foot

Page 46: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Then Develops Pain in SI Joint too

Page 47: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Then Develops Pain in SI Joint too

TrP3

Page 48: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Ineffective Synapse

Dorsal horn

Neuron for SI Joint is Initially Inactive

TrP3

Page 49: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Effective synapse

Expansion of the Receptive Field

TrP3

Page 50: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Wide Dynamic Range Neuron

++----

Excitatory tonus via nociceptors

Inhibitory tonus

Page 51: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Dynorphin

Met Leu- enkephalin

SP

Galanin

VIP

NPY

SOMGABA, Glycine, Glutamate, ACh, DA, 5-HT, Nitric Oxide

Immune system

Neurotrophins

Neurosteroids

Cytokines

Glia and Astrocytes

Substances Dynamically Modulating Dorsal Horn Neurons

Page 52: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

MTrPs and the Local Twitch Response

Courtesy Joseph Audette

Page 53: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

FibrositisMyositis

MyofascialPain

MyofascitisMyofibrositis

Muscularrheumatism Myelosis

Radiculitis

Myofascial Pain Historical and Regional Confusion

Page 54: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Historical Context of Trigger Points

Steindler coined the term “trigger points” when he found he was able to relieve

sciatica by injecting Novocain into tender points in muscles in the lumbar and gluteal regions

Travell added the term “myofascial”

after performing a biopsy of the infraspinatus muscle and observed that pinching the fasciae produced the same referral pattern as the muscle

Page 55: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia
Page 56: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Opening of Previously Ineffective Synapses

Page 57: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Treatments for Myofascial Pain

Spray/Stretch•

Strain/counterstrain

Muscle energy•

Myofascial release

Medications•

Dry Needling

Trigger point injections•

Botox injections

Orthotics, shoe modification

Counseling•

Behavioral management

Relaxation•

Imagery

Hypnosis•

Coping skills

Acupressure

Page 58: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

“Dry needling MTrPs and eliciting LTRs is as effective as

lidocaine injection in inactivating a MTrP and relieving pain”

Hong CZ. Lidocaine injection versus dry needling to myofascial trigger point. The importance of the local twitch response. Am J Phys Med Rehabil. 1994;73(4):256-63.

Page 59: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Recent studies comparing MTrP injections with a syringe and MTrP needling with an acupuncture needle showed that MTrP needling with an acup

needle does not cause more post-needling soreness

Ga H, Choi JH, Park CH, Yoon HJ. Acupuncture needling versus lidocaine injection of trigger points in myofascial pain syndrome in elderly patients - a randomised trial. Acupunct Med. 2007 Dec;25(4):130-6.

Ga H, Koh HJ, Choi JH, Kim CH. Intramuscular and nerve root stimulation vs lidocaine injection to trigger points in myofascial pain syndrome. J Rehabil Med. 2007 May;39(5):374-8.

Page 60: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Trigger Point Needling: Trigger Point Needling: Proper Technique to Elicit Local Twitch Proper Technique to Elicit Local Twitch

Responses is EssentialResponses is EssentialHong CZ

Arch Phys Med Rehab 1994;73:256

Courtesy Joseph Audette

Page 61: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

How does dry needling work?

Page 62: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

What is the Pathophysiology of Myofascial Pain?

UNKNOWN

Page 63: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia
Page 64: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Simons’ Integrated Hypothesis

Increased Miniature Endplate Potentials

(Endplate Noise)

Increased Fiber Tension (Taut Band)

Release of Sensitizing

Substances? (Pain)

Pathophysiology Histopathology

Histochemistry

Page 65: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

What is the Biochemical Milieu of MTrPs?

Clinical findings

Underlying milieu?

Page 66: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Myofascial Trigger Points: A Unique Perspective at the NIH

In Vivo Microdialysis –

A Technique For Analysis of the Biochemical Milieu of MTrPs

Page 67: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

MicrodialysisLow or no solute

High concentration solute

Semi-permeable membrane

Courtesy Terry Phillips

Page 68: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Microdialysis/Acupuncture Needle

Courtesy Terry Phillips

Page 69: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Microdialysis/Acupuncture Needle –

30 Gauge Hypodermic

Fluid in

Fluid outSolute exchange

surface –

dialyzer membrane set 0.2 mm from the needle tip

Delivery tubes

Courtesy Terry Phillips

Page 70: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Comparison of Needle Tips

25G syringe needle

32G acupuncture needle

Courtesy Terry Phillips

Page 71: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Comparison between a Standard Acupuncture Needle and

our Needle/Probe

Acupuncture needle

Needle/Probe

Courtesy Terry Phillips

Page 72: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Comparison of Needle Tips

Rounded acupuncture needle tip pushes cells aside rather than piercing them

Sharp beveled hypodermic needle tip acts like a miniature scalpel capable of piercing, cutting and tearing cells

Courtesy Terry Phillips

Page 73: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Microdialysis Sampling

Courtesy Sagar Parikh

Page 74: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Microdialysis System

Fraction collector

Soft tissue

Needle

In-flow catheter

Microdialysis pump

Out- flow

catheter

Courtesy Terry Phillips

Page 75: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia
Page 76: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

computer

detector

CE chamber

capillary

Power supply

Page 77: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Co-investigators

Terry Phillips, PhD, DSc

Jerome Danoff, PT, PhD

Lynn Gerber, MD

Page 78: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Hans-Werner Weisskircher www.trigger-

point.com

Page 79: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Design, Setting, and Patients

Three healthy subjects were selected to be in each of three groups (total 9 subjects) based on history and physical examination of upper trapezius:

Group 1)

Normal (no neck pain, no trigger point)•

Group 2)

Latent (no neck pain, trigger point

present)•

Group 3)

Active (neck pain present [<

3months],

trigger point present).

Page 80: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Initial Analyte Values in TrapeziusAnalyte Active Latent Normal *P value

pH (pH units) 5.4 6.3 6.5 P<.03

Bradykinin (pm/l) 69 49.6 47.5 P<.01

NE (nmol/l) 3.1 2.0 1.8 P<.01

Serotonin (nmol/l) 6.6 4.7 4.1 P<.01

Substance P (pg/ml) 187 50 34 P<.01

CGRP (pg/ml) 172 37.4 25.5 P<.01

TNF-α

(pg/ml) 173.5 26.5 21.2 P<.001

IL-1β

(pg/ml) 133.7 19.5 17.7 P<.001

*Active >

Latent, Normal (except pH)

Page 81: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

0:00 2:24 4:48 7:12 9:36 12:00 14:24 16:48

Time

pg/m

lConcentration of Substance P over time

I = SEEI

II

Active

Latent

Normal

Page 82: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

• Collect near real-time samples from soft tissue with minimal system perturbation and without harmful effects on subjects

• Proof-of-principle of the system’s ability to distinguish among subjects who have clinically distinct soft tissue findings

• Active MTrP in the upper trapezius has elevated levels of inflammatory mediators

(bradykinin,

protons, etc.), catecholamines

(norepinephrine and serotonin), neuropeptides

(substance P, CGRP)

and pro-inflammatory

cytokines

(TNF-α, IL-1β)

First Phase: What We’ve Demonstrated

Shah J, Phillips T, Danoff J, Gerber L. An in vivo microanalytical technique for measuring the local biochemical milieu of human skeletal muscle. J Appl Physiol. 2005

99(5): 1977-84.

Page 83: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

1) Determine whether these findings are unique to the upper trapezius when compared to a remote uninvolved site in the medial gastrocnemius muscle

2) Measure additional analytes (e.g., IL-6 and IL-8) known to be associated with pain, inflammation and intercellular signaling.

Purpose of Second Phase

Page 84: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

9 subjects, all of whom had no calf pain or calf MTrPs, were divided into 3 groups based on the following findings in the trapezius:

1) Active (painful MTrP present; 3 subjects) 2) Latent (non-painful MTrP present; 3 subjects) 3) Normal (no pain, no MTrP present; 3 subjects)

Design, Setting, and Patients

Page 85: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Hans-Werner

Weisskircher

www.trigger-

point.com

3 Groups of Subjects with following findings in upper trapezius muscle:

1) Active MTrP, 2) Latent MTrP, 3) No MTrP

No MTrP

Page 86: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Exclusion Criteria

Fibromyalgia•

Cervical radiculopathy

Atypical facial neuralgia•

History of previous trigger point injections in the upper trapezius and upper medial gastrocnemius

Knee pain•

History of cervical spine or shoulder surgery

On any medications

Other concurrent pain syndromes

Use of tobacco products•

Any aspirin within 3 days of needling

History of bleeding diatheses•

Being on anticoagulation therapy

An inordinate fear of needles•

Lumbosacral radiculopathy

Page 87: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Procedure and MeasuresProcedure :Samples were obtained continuously from the trapezius site at regular intervals for 14 minutes, and then from the upper medial gastrocnemius site for 10 minutes.

Measures :Levels of protons (H+), bradykinin, SP, CGRP, serotonin, norepinephrine, TNF-α, IL-1β, IL-6 and

IL-8.

Page 88: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Initial Analyte Values in TrapeziusAnalyte Active Latent Normal *P valuepH (pH units) 5.2 6.6 6.7 P<.001Bradykinin (pm/l) 71.3 39.9 41.5 P<.003NE (nmol/l) 3.0 1.9 1.5 P<.0001Serotonin (nmol/l) 6.9 4.2 3.9 P<.0001Substance P (pg/ml) 169.3 46.7 30.8 P<.0001CGRP (pg/ml) 157.3 49.3 25.8 P<.0001TNF-α

(pg/ml) 181.8 30.0 8.9 P<.001IL-1β

(pg/ml) 121.9 20.8 9.9 P<.001IL-6 (pg/ml) 130.2 16.7 10.5 P<.0001IL-8 (pg/ml) 61.7 7.7 6.9 P<.0001

*Active >

Latent, Normal (except pH)

Page 89: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

0.00

100.00

200.00

300.00

400.00

500.00

600.00

0.00 5.00 10.00 15.00

Time (min)

pg/L

Set 1 Active

Set 1 Latent

Set 1 Normal

Set 2 Active

Set 2 Latent

Set 2 Normal

Combined Data for Substance P Concentration in Trapezius over Time

Page 90: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Concentrations of Analytes in the Active Group at Initial Needle Insertion

Analyte Trap GS *P valuepH 5.5 5.7 NS

Bradykinin 63.7 39.7 P<.001

NE 2.8 2.4 P<.001Serotonin 6.5 6.0 P<.001Substance P 140.9 52.9 P<.001

CGRP 129.9 46.7 P<.001TNF-α 143.9 45.5 P<.001 IL-1β 97.1 44.8 P<.001 IL-6 102.5 39.6 P<.001IL-8 48. 8 21.5 P<.001

*Trapezius >

Gastrocnemius

Page 91: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Analyte GS (Act) GS (Lat) GS (Nor) *P valuepH 5.7 6.7 6.8 P<.01

Bradykinin 39.7 37.4 35.3 P<.01(A>N)

NE 2.4 1.8 1.5 P<.01

Serotonin 6.0 4.4 3.7 P<.01

Substance P 52.9 18 13.8 P<.01

CGRP 46.7 16.1 12.1 P<.01

TNF-α 45.5 17.1 8.6 P<.01

IL-1β 44.8 23.1 8.5 P<.01

IL-6 39.6 14.9 9.5 P<.01

IL-8 21.5 10.5 5.5 P<.01

Concentrations of Analytes at Initial Needle Insertion in Gastrocnemius Muscle

*Active >

Latent, Normal (except pH)

Page 92: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Active

Latent

NormalActive group

I = SEE

(Normal Muscle)

Page 93: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Active

Latent

Normal

I = SEE

(Normal Muscle)

Active group

Page 94: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

I = SEEActive

(Normal Muscle)

Active grou

Page 95: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

ActiveI = SEE

(Normal Muscle)

Active group

Page 96: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

I = SEE

Active

e

(Normal Muscle)

Active group

Page 97: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

e

I = SEE

Active Active group

(Normal Muscle)

Page 98: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

• An active MTrP has a unique biochemical milieu of substances known to be associated with pain states and inflammation

• The biochemical milieu of an active MTrP in the upper trapezius differs quantitatively from a remote, uninvolved site in the gastrocnemius muscle.

Second Phase: What We’ve Learned

Page 99: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

• Subjects with an active MTrP in the upper trapezius have elevated levels of these analytes in a remote, uninvolved muscle compared to latent and normal subjects. This suggests that substances associated with pain are not limited to local areas of MTrPs or a single anatomical locus.

• In the trapezius, the concentration of specific analytes dramatically changes in response to initial needle insertion and also following a local twitch response, particularly in active MTrPs

Second Phase: What We’ve Learned

Shah JP, Danoff JV, Desai MJ, Parikh S, Nakamura LY, Phillips TM, Gerber LH. Biochemicals assoicated with pain and inflammation are elevated in sites near to and

remote from active myofascial trigger points. Archives of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation 2008 Jan;89(1):16-23

Page 100: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia
Page 101: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Biochemical Considerations

Page 102: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

H+

Page 103: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

“Pro-inflammatory cytokines increase the sensitivity of all

peripheral neural structures and their afferent cell bodies, causing

hyperalgesia and the development of neuropathic pain

states”Cytokines and Pain. Watkins

and Maier, eds. 2000

Page 104: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Hypernociceptive role of cytokines and chemokines:

Targets for analgesic drug development?

Verri WA, Cunha TM, Parada CA et alPharmacology and Therapeutics 2006

TNF-α, IL-1β,

IL-6 and IL-8 were among the first cytokines described as participating in the development of

inflammatory and neuropathic pain

Page 105: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Cg, LPS or Ag

Nociceptor Sensitization

IL-1β

↔IL-6

Cytokine Cascade and Pain

TNF-α

Prostaglandins

IL-8 ↔CINC-1

Sympathetic amines

Ag

IL-18 ↔ IL-12

ET-1

Verri WA et. alPharmacology and Therapeutics 2006

Cox enzyme β-Blocker

Page 106: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

50-μm laser-drilled hole for embedding hydrogel

Second Generation Needle with Hydrogel

First Generation Microdialysis Needle

Moving Ahead: Microanalytic Systems for in-vivo Measurement of the Biochemical Milieu of Muscle

Shah et al. J. Appl. Physiol. 2005 99:1977-94

30-gauge needle~0.5 μL sample

Page 107: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

The Next Phase: A Natural History Study

• Does the biochemical milieu at and around the MTrP change with respect to the natural history of myofascial pain in the upper trapezius?

• Does the biochemical milieu of the upper trapezius correlate with changes in the severity of pain, presence or absence of physical findings or degree of local tenderness over time?

• What are the levels of anti-inflammatory substances (e.g., IL-4, IL-10), neurotrophins (e.g., NGF, NT-3), analgesic substances (e.g., β-endorphin) and substances associated with muscle metabolism and physiology (e.g., creatine kinase, aldolase, ACh esterase, etc.)?

Page 108: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Treatment TrialsAssess the local biochemical milieu of MTrPs as an outcome measure

of efficacy in clinical treatment trials utilizing

pharmacologic and physical medicine approaches

Page 109: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

A New Direction

To Address an Old Controversy

Page 110: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Obstacles

There are currently no imaging criteria for the diagnosis of trigger points or for assessing clinical outcome of treatments.

It remains a clinical diagnosis based exclusively on history and physical examination.

Page 111: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Our Research Question

In the long term, we want to understand the pathophysiology of myofascial pain and develop

clinical outcome measures.

Can ultrasound imaging be used to develop objective descriptions of the tissue and blood flow characteristics of

myofascial trigger points (MTrPs) and the immediately adjacent structures?

Page 112: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Hypoechoiec trigger point

3 cm

Fascia

Uppertrapezius

Upper Trapezius Muscle with MTrP

Page 113: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Vibration Sonoelastography

30 kPa

63 kPa 44 kPa

Page 114: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Vibration Applicator

Page 115: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Hypoechoeic trigger 

point 

Focal decrease of color 

variance indicates a 

localized stiffer region 

upper trapezius

Vibration Sonoelastography of Muscle with MTrP

Page 116: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Uniform echogenecity in 

uninvolved muscle 

Uniform color  variance 

indicates homogeneous  

stiffness

upper trapezius

Vibration Sonoelastography of Uninvolved Muscle

Page 117: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Vibration Sonoelastography of Uninvolved Muscle

Page 118: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Sonoelastography Imaging

Objective diagnostic test

Outcome measure to evaluate tissue changes in response to treatment

Describe natural history

Sikdar et al. Arch. Phys. Me Rehabil., 2009 (in press)

Page 119: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Imaging blood flow near MTrPs in the Upper Trapezius

B BFS=1

A BFS=0

BFS=2D

BFS=2C

Page 120: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

• Ultrasound is feasible for imaging MTrPs

• MTrPs exhibit different echogenecity compared to surrounding muscle.

• Vibration sonoelastography shows differences in relative stiffness between trigger points and normal (uninvolved) muscle. Sikdar et al. Assessment of Myofascial Trigger Points (MTrPs): A

New Application of Ultrasound Imaging and Vibration Sonoelastography. Conf Proc. IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc. 2008

Observations

Page 121: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Observations•

Blood flow waveform characteristics can be used to differentiate Active and Latent MTrPs

Retrograde flow in diastole indicating a very high resistance vascular bed and possible blood vessel compression is associated with Active MTrPs Sikdar S, Shah JP, Gebreab T, Yen R, Gilliams E, Danoff J, Gerber L. Novel Applications of Ultrasound Technology to Visualize and Characterize Myofascial Trigger Point and Surrounding Soft Tissue. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation. In press. 2009

Page 122: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

XXInflamatory

Mediators, BK,NE, SP,

Serotonin, Cytokines

Integrated

Neuromuscular

Theory

Courtesy Bryan O’Neill

Page 123: 2012 aaom shah neuromusculoskeletal pain lessons from the myofascia

Injection Therapies

What?Where? Why?