2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

21

Transcript of 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

Page 1: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation
Page 2: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

Examine Case Study – 600 Mwe Nuclear Plant Sources of Capacity Losses Performance Modeling Tool Prediction & Analysis of Capacity

Losses Conclusions & Recommendations

Objectives

Page 3: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

6,216 W 0 W

516,005 W1190.21 H

10,482,117 W 0 W1000.00 P 1190.21 H0.42 %M

7,200 W 1190.21 H8,940 W 7,674,442 W 108,340 W REACTOR CORE POWER = 2535.800 MWT

1274.78 H 1274.78 H RECIRC. PUMP POWER = 7.800 MWT0 W CLEANUP LOSSES = 3.300 MWT

2,124 W FP POWER RADIATION LOSSES = 1.100 MWT11,011,538 W EFF.=76.5 % 7933 KW NSSS THERMAL POWER = 2539.200 MWT

1055.00 P PB = 950.62 TOTAL SHAFT OUTPUT = 878458 KW1190.21 H P1STG = 702.28 1024.94 H GEN. POWER FACTOR = 0.90

0.100% H1STG = 1169.44 3.78 IN.HGA GEN. H2 PRESSURE = 60.0 PSIGDELP = 4.94 % 7,566,102 W MECHANICAL. LOSSES = 3783 KW

9,631 W 9,631 W 186.00 P PB = 177.88 GEN. LOSSES = 10653 KW1086.97 H 1086.97 H 507.76 F HB = 1274.78 GENERATOR OUTPUT = 864022 KW

1274.78 H NET TURBINE HEAT RATE = 10028 BTU/KWHR993.00 P 110.69 P 66.90 P 20.53 P 10.78 P 5.60 P GROSS TURBINE HEAT RATE =9936 BTU/KWHR

369.36 P 578.23 P 578.23 P 1190.21 H TD = 35 F 1232.66 H 1192.57 H 1112.23 H 1073.91 H 1043.24 H1126.33 H 1156.07 H 1156.07 H 1113.96 H 1079.41 H 1063.28 H

358.28 P 560.88 P 560.88 P 192.00 P 985.06 P 107.37 P 64.89 P 19.92 P 5.43 P ELEP = 1004.53 HCORE THERMAL 1086.97 H 46,910 W 542.76 F 187.27 P 498,211 W UEEP = 1009.76 H 3.69 IN.HGA

POWER = 669,994 W 1190.21 H 1235.05 H 12,928 W 136,976 W 5,989,464 W2535.80 MWT 1126.33 H 406,928 W 453,838 W 556.96 P TD = 40 F 197.68 h 135.01 h

206,290 W 412,580 W 1156.07 H 1159.60 H 552.50 P 9,631 W 425,589 W 217,178 W 7,200 W 0 W 108,340 W461.49 h 477.42 F 1086.97 H 1113.96 H 1063.28 H 179.00 h 179.00 h 1024.94 H

16,683 W 234,548 W 469,095 W 461.49 h 188.56 P540.24 h 540.24 h 41,258 W 1197.52 H CF, % = 85.00

0 W 8,780,732 W 8,821,990 W 190.65 P 38,547 W GPM = 352,6001086.97 H 1087.31 H 13.08%M 215,138 W 164.87 h 0 W 16,683 W CWT, F = 77.00 F

MSEFF = 100.00 % 32,071 W 1181.86 H 206.70 H 3.69 IN.HGA HWT, F = 109.27 F1,147,547 W 1079.41 H

30,000 W 0 W 573,774 W 350.26 h0 W 350.26 h 8,140 W 0 W

573,774 W 219,258 W 1181.86 H 0 W577,453 W 0 W 1086.94 H

0 W 1086.97 H HW=122.50 F206,290 W 0 W 8,342 W461.49 h 288,726 W 573,774 W 206.70 h

10,981,538 W 350.26 h426.03 F 234,548 W 107,569 W 16,683 W 11,025,018 W404.24 h 334,997 W 540.24 h 1232.66 H 253,921 W 212,386 W 1086.97 H 5,340 W 218.92 P

348.88 P 3,986 W 183.61 P 99.28 P 60.96 P 1190.56 H 19.60 P 5.40 P 683.63 H 13,480 W 1181.86 H 6,216 W 122.83 FTD = 5.39 F TD = 4.96 F TD = 4.82 F TD = 4.69 F TD = 4.82 F TD = 3.07 F 1190.21 H 91.34 h

5,490,769 W 5,490,769 W 569.10 P 5,486,783 W426.04 F 371.14 F 1141.11 P 369.74 F 322.48 F 289.06 F 222.07 F 162.40 F 141.02 F 652.32 P 123.42 F404.24 h 345.48 h 343.20 h 293.83 h 259.49 h 191.62 h 131.86 h 110.56 h 124.64 F 91.94 h

431.42 F 374.71 F 327.30 F 293.75 F 226.89 F 165.47 F 94.25 hDC = 11.4 F DELTAH =2.47 DC = 10.4 F DC = 9.7 F DC = 9.1 F DC = 9.4 F DC = 7.1 F 6,216 W

178.92 P 5,340 W 130.00 h0 W 124.01 F 179.00 h

92.42 h1,069,031 W 2,231,895 W

775,835 W 332.84 F 298.80 F 171.84 F382.58 F 303.90 h 268.54 h 139.85 h356.52 h 234,548 W 212,386 W

0 W 206,290 W 540.24 h 0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 165.47 F461.49 h 133.43 h

0 W0 W 0 W 0 W 7,971 W

DELTAH =1.83

0 W0 W 0 W 219,258 W 0 W

206,290 W 288,726 W 1086.94 H461.49 h 1086.97 H 178.92 P

234,548 W 573,774 W 107,569 W 253,921 W 8,342 W 124.01 F540.24 h 350.26 h 1232.66 H 1190.56 H 206.70 h 92.42 h

334,997 W 212,386 W348.88 P 3,986 W 183.61 P 99.28 P 60.96 P 19.60 P 5.40 P 683.63 HTD = 5.39 F TD = 4.96 F TD = 4.82 F TD = 4.69 F TD = 4.82 F TD = 3.07 F

5,490,769 W 5,490,769 W 569.10 P 5,486,783 W426.04 F 371.14 F 1141.11 P 369.74 F 322.48 F 289.06 F 222.07 F 162.40 F 652.32 P404.24 h 345.48 h 343.20 h 293.83 h 259.49 h 191.62 h 131.86 h 110.56 h 124.64 F

431.42 F 374.71 F 327.30 F 293.75 F 226.89 F 165.47 F 94.25 hDC = 11.4 F DELTAH =2.47 DC = 10.4 F DC = 9.7 F DC = 9.1 F DC = 9.4 F DC = 7.1 F

775,835 W 1,750,373 W 2,004,295 W 2,231,895 W382.58 F 332.84 F 298.80 F 231.13 F 171.84 F356.52 h 303.90 h 268.54 h 199.56 h 139.85 h 212,386 W

0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 165.47 F133.43 h

0 W

PIV = 183.95

4,900,118 W

99.74 h

4,470 W

1086.97 H

141.02 F

2,231,895 W131.75 F

0 W

1,069,031 W

231.13 F199.56 h

2,004,295 W1,750,373 W

4,470 W

212,386 W

131.75 F99.74 h

2,231,895 W

212,386 W

2,231,895 W

30,000 W

2,231,895 W

1STGRHTR

DRN. TK. A

REBOILER

CONDENSER

TWO DOUBLE-FLOW LP TURBINES

CP

MOIST.SEP.

DOUBLE-FLOW HP TURBINE

D

REACTOR

A

T O SJAE

B

T O CRD

RHTR.1

RHTR.2

T O RFPT

A

RFPTURBINE

TO RECOMBINER

TO REBOILER

VENT FLOW

VENT FLOW

TO CONDENSER

C

T O RBLR

FROMREBOILER

T O HT RSEH-2A,B

BFROM RFPT

FROMRECOMBINER

FROMRADWAST E

FROM MAINSTEAM

T ORADWAST E

MSDRAIN

TANK A

FROMRFP

TO COND. A

FROM MSRDRN.TANKS

MAKEUP

RFP A

GSC SJAE

BP

EH-6A EH-5A EH-4A EH-3A EH-1A DC 1A

T O COND.ST OR.T K.

RFPSEALS

EH-2A

TO RFPSEALS

T O 1ST G & 2ST G RHT R.

DRN. T KS

TO MSDRN.TKS.

T OCOND.A

T O COND. A

EMER. HTR. DRNS.

EH-6B EH-5B EH-4B EH-3B EH-1B DC 1B

RFPSEALS

EH-2B

T OCOND. B

T O COND. B

T OCOND. A

C

FROMRFP

T OCOND. A

FROMRFP

2STGRHTR

DRN. TK. A

2STGRHTR

DRN. TK. B

1STGRHTR

DRN. TK. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

MSDRAIN

TANK B

T OCOND. A

FROM BOOST ERPUMPS

A

BP

BP

D

RFP B

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

FROMRFP

FROM BOOST ERPUMPS

FROMREBOILER

Baseline Heat Balance for Case Study

Page 4: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

Reactor Thermal Power Fixed at Licensed Value of 2536 Mwt Circulating water Inlet Temp.

Fixed at 77.0 F (Design) Feedwater Heater TTD's & DCA’s

Predicted Using Data Sheets Steady-State Conditions, No

Cycle Isolation Losses

Performance Modeling

Page 5: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

1. Main Steam Bypass 2. Moisture Separator Drains to

Condenser 3. 1Stg Reheater Drains to Condenser 4. 2Stg Reheater Drains to Condenser 5. Heater Drains to Condenser 6. Thermal Power

Sources of Capacity Loss

Page 6: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

LEGEND

MAIN STEAM BYPASS

MOISTURE SEPARATOR DRAIN TO CONDENSER

1STG. REHEATER DRAIN TO CONDENSER

2STG. REHEATER DRAIN TO CONDENSER

HEATER DRAINS TO CONDENSER

REACTOR THERMAL POWER

1STGRHTR

DRN. TK. A

REBOILER

CONDENSER

TWO DOUBLE-FLOW LP TURBINES

CP

MOIST.SEP.

DOUBLE-FLOW HP TURBINE

REACTOR

1

T O CRD

RHTR.1

RHTR.2

RFPTURBINE

TO CONDENSER

FROMREBOILER

T O HT RSEH-2A,B

FROMRECOMBINER

FROMRADWAST E

T ORADWAST E

MSDRAIN

TANK A

MAKEUP

RFP A

GSC SJAE

BP

EH-6A EH-5A EH-4A EH-3A EH-1A DC 1A

T O COND.ST OR.T K.

EH-2A

EH-6B EH-5B EH-4B EH-3B EH-1B DC 1BEH-2B

2STGRHTR

DRN. TK. A

2STGRHTR

DRN. TK. B

1STGRHTR

DRN. TK. B

MSDRAIN

TANK B

BP

BP

RFP B

FROMREBOILER

T O RBLR

3

4

34

2

2

5

5 5

5

5 5 5

5

5

555

6

TO RECOMBINER

1

2

3

4

5

6

T O RHT R.DRN. T KS.

FROMRFP

FROMRFP

FROMRFP

FROMRFP

FROM BOOST ER PUMPS

T O MSDRN. T KS.

FROM BOOST ER PUMPS

Sources of Capacity Loss

Page 7: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

6,216 W 0 W

517,307 W1190.21 H

10,358,969 W 0 W1000.00 P 1190.21 H0.42 %M

7,200 W 1190.21 H104,822 W 8,967 W 7,577,271 W 108,317 W REACTOR CORE POWER = 2535.800 MWT

1275.02 H 1275.02 H RECIRC. PUMP POWER = 7.800 MWT0 W CLEANUP LOSSES = 3.300 MWT

2,098 W FP POWER RADIATION LOSSES = 1.100 MWT10,994,514 W EFF.=76.5 % 7903 KW NSSS THERMAL POWER = 2539.200 MWT

1055.00 P PB = 949.11 TOTAL SHAFT OUTPUT = 867112 KW1190.21 H P1STG = 694.03 1026.05 H GEN. POWER FACTOR = 0.90

0.100% H1STG = 1168.88 3.81 IN.HGA GEN. H2 PRESSURE = 60.0 PSIGDELP = 5.09 % 7,468,953 W MECHANICAL. LOSSES = 3783 KW

9,514 W 9,514 W 183.67 P PB = 175.65 GEN. LOSSES = 10455 KW1086.45 H 1086.45 H 507.76 F HB = 1275.02 GENERATOR OUTPUT = 852874 KW

1275.02 H NET TURBINE HEAT RATE = 10159 BTU/KWHR993.00 P 109.24 P 65.96 P 20.22 P 10.62 P 5.51 P GROSS TURBINE HEAT RATE =10065 BTU/KWHR

364.91 P 571.54 P 571.54 P 1190.21 H TD = 35 F 1232.83 H 1192.64 H 1112.25 H 1073.96 H 1043.40 H1125.80 H 1155.54 H 1155.54 H 1113.99 H 1079.54 H 1063.36 H

353.96 P 554.40 P 554.40 P 189.59 P 985.06 P 105.97 P 63.98 P 19.61 P 5.35 P ELEP = 1005.69 HCORE THERMAL 1086.45 H 47,028 W 542.76 F 184.92 P 497,166 W UEEP = 1010.83 H 3.72 IN.HGA

POWER = 666,168 W 1190.21 H 1234.68 H 12,833 W 134,262 W 5,903,548 W2535.80 MWT 1125.80 H 398,118 W 445,146 W 550.51 P TD = 40 F 196.86 h 134.38 h

202,339 W 404,678 W 1155.54 H 1159.20 H 546.11 P 9,514 W 424,004 W 211,416 W 7,200 W 0 W 108,317 W460.08 h 476.19 F 1086.45 H 1113.99 H 1063.36 H 179.00 h 179.00 h 1026.05 H

16,688 W 235,139 W 470,279 W 460.08 h 186.19 P540.24 h 540.24 h 40,468 W 1197.34 H CF, % = 85.00

0 W 8,672,389 W 8,712,857 W 188.26 P 38,540 W GPM = 352,6001086.45 H 1086.79 H 13.10%M 215,588 W 164.14 h 0 W 16,688 W CWT, F = 77.00 F

MSEFF = 100.00 % 31,597 W 1181.86 H 206.70 H 3.72 IN.HGA HWT, F = 109.49 F1,135,587 W 1079.54 H 104,822 W

30,000 W 0 W 567,793 W 349.15 h0 W 349.15 h 8,140 W 0 W

567,793 W 218,419 W 1181.86 H 0 W575,512 W 0 W 1087.05 H

0 W 1086.45 H HW=122.81 F202,339 W 0 W 8,344 W460.08 h 287,756 W 567,793 W 206.70 h

10,964,514 W 349.15 h424.91 F 235,139 W 107,794 W 16,688 W 11,007,994 W403.02 h 333,084 W 540.24 h 1232.83 H 253,340 W 207,907 W 1086.45 H 5,340 W 219.01 P

344.68 P 3,986 W 181.31 P 97.98 P 60.10 P 1190.65 H 19.31 P 5.32 P 681.29 H 13,480 W 1181.86 H 6,216 W 123.14 FTD = 5.36 F TD = 4.94 F TD = 4.81 F TD = 4.69 F TD = 4.82 F TD = 3.00 F 1190.21 H 91.65 h

5,482,257 W 5,482,257 W 569.84 P 5,478,271 W424.92 F 370.11 F 1140.76 P 368.73 F 321.54 F 288.14 F 221.27 F 161.84 F 140.94 F 652.80 P 123.74 F403.02 h 344.41 h 342.13 h 292.86 h 258.55 h 190.82 h 131.30 h 110.49 h 124.95 F 92.25 h

430.28 F 373.67 F 326.35 F 292.82 F 226.08 F 164.84 F 94.56 hDC = 11.3 F DELTAH =2.46 DC = 10.3 F DC = 9.7 F DC = 8.9 F DC = 9.3 F DC = 6.9 F 6,216 W

179.01 P 5,340 W 130.00 h0 W 124.33 F 179.00 h

92.74 h1,062,802 W 2,218,492 W

770,563 W 331.81 F 297.80 F 171.15 F381.42 F 302.82 h 267.51 h 139.16 h355.28 h 235,139 W 207,907 W

0 W 202,339 W 540.24 h 0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 164.84 F460.08 h 132.80 h

0 W0 W 0 W 0 W 7,971 W

DELTAH =1.83

0 W0 W 0 W 218,419 W 0 W

202,339 W 287,756 W 1087.05 H460.08 h 1086.45 H 179.01 P

235,139 W 567,793 W 107,794 W 253,340 W 8,344 W 124.33 F540.24 h 349.15 h 1232.83 H 1190.65 H 206.70 h 92.74 h

333,084 W 207,907 W344.68 P 3,986 W 181.31 P 97.98 P 60.10 P 19.31 P 5.32 P 681.29 HTD = 5.36 F TD = 4.94 F TD = 4.81 F TD = 4.69 F TD = 4.82 F TD = 3.00 F

5,482,257 W 5,482,257 W 569.84 P 5,478,271 W424.92 F 370.11 F 1140.76 P 368.73 F 321.54 F 288.14 F 221.27 F 161.84 F 652.80 P403.02 h 344.41 h 342.13 h 292.86 h 258.55 h 190.82 h 131.30 h 110.49 h 124.95 F

430.28 F 373.67 F 326.35 F 292.82 F 226.08 F 164.84 F 94.56 hDC = 11.3 F DELTAH =2.46 DC = 10.3 F DC = 9.7 F DC = 8.9 F DC = 9.3 F DC = 6.9 F

770,563 W 1,738,390 W 1,991,730 W 2,218,492 W381.42 F 331.81 F 297.80 F 230.22 F 171.15 F355.28 h 302.82 h 267.51 h 198.63 h 139.16 h 207,907 W

0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 164.84 F132.80 h

0 W

PIV = 181.65

4,864,355 W

99.84 h

4,483 W

1086.45 H

140.94 F

2,218,492 W131.84 F

0 W

1,062,802 W

230.22 F198.63 h

1,991,730 W1,738,390 W

4,483 W

207,907 W

131.84 F99.84 h

2,218,492 W

207,907 W

2,218,492 W

30,000 W

2,218,492 W

1STGRHTR

DRN. TK. A

REBOILER

CONDENSER

TWO DOUBLE-FLOW LP TURBINES

CP

MOIST.SEP.

DOUBLE-FLOW HP TURBINE

D

REACTOR

A

T O SJAE

B

T O CRD

RHTR.1

RHTR.2

T O RFPT

A

RFPTURBINE

TO RECOMBINER

TO REBOILER

VENT FLOW

VENT FLOW

TO CONDENSER

C

T O RBLR

FROMREBOILER

T O HT RSEH-2A,B

BFROM RFPT

FROMRECOMBINER

FROMRADWAST E

FROM MAINSTEAM

T ORADWAST E

MSDRAIN

TANK A

FROMRFP

TO COND. A

FROM MSRDRN.TANKS

MAKEUP

RFP A

GSC SJAE

BP

EH-6A EH-5A EH-4A EH-3A EH-1A DC 1A

T O COND.ST OR.T K.

RFPSEALS

EH-2A

TO RFPSEALS

T O 1ST G & 2ST G RHT R.

DRN. T KS

TO MSDRN.TKS.

T OCOND.A

T O COND. A

EMER. HTR. DRNS.

EH-6B EH-5B EH-4B EH-3B EH-1B DC 1B

RFPSEALS

EH-2B

T OCOND. B

T O COND. B

T OCOND. A

C

FROMRFP

T OCOND. A

FROMRFP

2STGRHTR

DRN. TK. A

2STGRHTR

DRN. TK. B

1STGRHTR

DRN. TK. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

MSDRAIN

TANK B

T OCOND. A

FROM BOOST ERPUMPS

A

BP

BP

D

RFP B

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

FROMRFP

FROM BOOST ERPUMPS

FROMREBOILER

1

MAIN STEAM BYPASS

Predicted Performance - 1% Main Steam Bypass

Page 8: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

Stage Shell Pressures Decrease By Approximately Same Proportion

Final feedwater Temperature Decreases By About 1.0 F

FW Flow, TTD’s, DCA’s Decrease Slightly

Generator Output Decreases by About 11.1 Mwe (1.3%)

Impact of 1% Main Steam Bypass

Page 9: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

Predicted Performance - 20% Moist. Sep. Drain Tank “A” Drains Dump to Condenser

6,216 W 0 W

515,865 W1190.21 H

10,482,174 W 0 W1000.00 P 1190.21 H0.42 %M

7,200 W 1190.21 H8,941 W 7,672,753 W 108,357 W REACTOR CORE POWER = 2535.800 MWT

1274.78 H 1274.78 H RECIRC. PUMP POWER = 7.800 MWT0 W CLEANUP LOSSES = 3.300 MWT

2,124 W FP POWER RADIATION LOSSES = 1.100 MWT11,011,455 W EFF.=76.5 % 7933 KW NSSS THERMAL POWER = 2539.200 MWT

1055.00 P PB = 950.62 TOTAL SHAFT OUTPUT = 877077 KW1190.21 H P1STG = 702.28 1024.99 H GEN. POWER FACTOR = 0.90

0.100% H1STG = 1169.44 3.78 IN.HGA GEN. H2 PRESSURE = 60.0 PSIGDELP = 4.94 % 7,564,396 W MECHANICAL. LOSSES = 3783 KW

9,629 W 9,629 W 185.96 P PB = 177.85 GEN. LOSSES = 10628 KW1086.96 H 1086.96 H 507.76 F HB = 1274.78 GENERATOR OUTPUT = 862665 KW

1274.78 H NET TURBINE HEAT RATE = 10043 BTU/KWHR993.00 P 110.51 P 66.71 P 20.45 P 10.74 P 5.57 P GROSS TURBINE HEAT RATE =9952 BTU/KWHR

369.35 P 578.23 P 578.23 P 1190.21 H TD = 35 F 1232.54 H 1192.37 H 1112.00 H 1073.71 H 1043.07 H1126.33 H 1156.07 H 1156.07 H 1113.74 H 1079.25 H 1063.13 H

358.27 P 560.89 P 560.89 P 191.96 P 985.06 P 107.20 P 64.71 P 19.84 P 5.40 P ELEP = 1004.65 HCORE THERMAL 1086.96 H 46,897 W 542.76 F 187.23 P 504,970 W UEEP = 1009.85 H 3.70 IN.HGA

POWER = 670,343 W 1190.21 H 1235.05 H 12,986 W 136,607 W 5,964,296 W2535.80 MWT 1126.33 H 406,955 W 453,852 W 556.96 P TD = 40 F 197.47 h 134.82 h

206,296 W 412,593 W 1156.07 H 1159.60 H 552.50 P 9,629 W 431,427 W 219,436 W 7,200 W 0 W 108,357 W461.49 h 477.42 F 1086.96 H 1113.74 H 1063.13 H 179.00 h 179.00 h 1024.99 H

16,683 W 234,484 W 468,968 W 461.49 h 188.51 P540.24 h 540.24 h 41,259 W 1197.52 H CF, % = 85.00

0 W 8,778,881 W 8,820,140 W 190.61 P 38,663 W GPM = 352,6001086.96 H 1087.30 H 13.08%M 224,056 W 164.69 h 0 W 16,683 W CWT, F = 77.00 F

MSEFF = 100.00 % 31,955 W 1181.86 H 206.70 H 3.70 IN.HGA HWT, F = 109.30 F1,147,388 W 1079.25 H

30,000 W 0 W 573,694 W 350.24 h0 W 350.24 h 8,140 W 114,741 W

573,694 W 225,309 W 1181.86 H 0 W578,988 W 0 W 1087.33 H

0 W 1086.96 H HW=122.54 F206,296 W 114,741 W 8,341 W461.49 h 289,686 W 458,953 W 206.70 h

10,981,455 W 350.24 h426.02 F 234,484 W 116,316 W 16,683 W 11,024,935 W404.24 h 335,172 W 540.24 h 1232.54 H 260,712 W 215,228 W 1086.96 H 5,340 W 218.92 P

348.87 P 3,986 W 183.57 P 99.12 P 60.79 P 1190.42 H 19.53 P 5.37 P 689.03 H 13,480 W 1181.86 H 6,216 W 122.86 FTD = 5.39 F TD = 4.98 F TD = 4.90 F TD = 4.78 F TD = 4.91 F TD = 3.15 F 1190.21 H 91.38 h

5,490,727 W 5,490,727 W 569.11 P 5,486,742 W426.03 F 371.11 F 1141.11 P 369.71 F 322.29 F 288.78 F 221.78 F 162.13 F 140.25 F 652.32 P 123.46 F404.24 h 345.45 h 343.16 h 293.63 h 259.21 h 191.33 h 131.60 h 109.79 h 124.68 F 91.98 h

431.42 F 374.69 F 327.19 F 293.56 F 226.69 F 165.28 F 94.29 hDC = 11.4 F DELTAH =2.47 DC = 10.4 F DC = 9.1 F DC = 8.2 F DC = 8.7 F DC = 6.5 F 6,216 W

178.92 P 5,340 W 130.00 h0 W 124.05 F 179.00 h

92.46 h1,070,108 W 2,139,740 W

775,952 W 332.70 F 297.88 F 170.88 F382.55 F 303.75 h 267.60 h 138.89 h356.50 h 234,484 W 215,228 W

0 W 206,296 W 540.24 h 0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 165.28 F461.49 h 133.25 h

0 W0 W 0 W 0 W 7,971 W

DELTAH =1.83

0 W0 W 0 W 219,104 W 0 W

206,296 W 289,302 W 1086.58 H461.49 h 1086.96 H 178.92 P

234,484 W 573,694 W 107,740 W 253,887 W 8,341 W 124.05 F540.24 h 350.24 h 1232.54 H 1190.37 H 206.70 h 92.46 h

335,172 W 211,433 W348.87 P 3,986 W 183.57 P 99.12 P 60.79 P 19.53 P 5.37 P 682.31 HTD = 5.39 F TD = 4.97 F TD = 4.83 F TD = 4.69 F TD = 4.82 F TD = 3.05 F

5,490,727 W 5,490,727 W 569.11 P 5,486,742 W426.03 F 371.11 F 1141.11 P 369.72 F 322.36 F 288.87 F 221.86 F 162.23 F 652.32 P404.24 h 345.45 h 343.17 h 293.70 h 259.30 h 191.42 h 131.69 h 110.53 h 124.68 F

431.42 F 374.69 F 327.19 F 293.56 F 226.69 F 165.28 F 94.29 hDC = 11.4 F DELTAH =2.47 DC = 10.4 F DC = 9.8 F DC = 9.1 F DC = 9.4 F DC = 7.1 F

775,952 W 1,751,158 W 2,005,045 W 2,232,491 W382.55 F 332.75 F 298.64 F 230.93 F 171.67 F356.50 h 303.80 h 268.37 h 199.36 h 139.67 h 211,433 W

0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 165.28 F133.25 h

0 W

PIV = 183.91

4,810,447 W

99.13 h

4,470 W

1086.96 H

140.99 F

2,139,740 W131.13 F

0 W

1,069,725 W

230.01 F198.43 h

1,906,089 W1,645,377 W

4,470 W

211,433 W

131.76 F99.75 h

2,139,740 W

215,228 W

2,232,491 W

30,000 W

2,232,491 W

1STGRHTR

DRN. TK. A

REBOILER

CONDENSER

TWO DOUBLE-FLOW LP TURBINES

CP

MOIST.SEP.

DOUBLE-FLOW HP TURBINE

D

REACTOR

A

T O SJAE

B

T O CRD

RHTR.1

RHTR.2

T O RFPT

A

RFPTURBINE

TO RECOMBINER

TO REBOILER

VENT FLOW

VENT FLOW

TO CONDENSER

C

T O RBLR

FROMREBOILER

T O HT RSEH-2A,B

BFROM RFPT

FROMRECOMBINER

FROMRADWAST E

FROM MAINSTEAM

T ORADWAST E

MSDRAIN

TANK A

FROMRFP

TO COND. A

FROM MSRDRN.TANKS

MAKEUP

RFP A

GSC SJAE

BP

EH-6A EH-5A EH-4A EH-3A EH-1A DC 1A

T O COND.ST OR.T K.

RFPSEALS

EH-2A

TO RFPSEALS

T O 1ST G & 2ST G RHT R.

DRN. T KS

TO MSDRN.TKS.

T OCOND.A

T O COND. A

EMER. HTR. DRNS.

EH-6B EH-5B EH-4B EH-3B EH-1B DC 1B

RFPSEALS

EH-2B

T OCOND. B

T O COND. B

T OCOND. A

C

FROMRFP

T OCOND. A

FROMRFP

2STGRHTR

DRN. TK. A

2STGRHTR

DRN. TK. B

1STGRHTR

DRN. TK. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

MSDRAIN

TANK B

T OCOND. A

FROM BOOST ERPUMPS

A

BP

BP

D

RFP B

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

FROMRFP

FROM BOOST ERPUMPS

FROMREBOILER

Page 10: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

Less Drains Enter Heater 4A Extrn. Steam Flows, TTD’s for

Heaters Upstream in “A” String Increase Slightly

DCA’s for These Heaters Decrease Generator Output Decreases by

About 1.4 Mwe (0.16%)

Impact of 20% Moist. Sep. Drn. Tank “A” Drains Dump to Condenser

Page 11: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

Predicted Performance - 20% 1Stg Rhtr. Drain Tank “A” Drains Dump to Condenser

6,216 W 0 W

515,441 W1190.21 H

10,481,579 W 0 W1000.00 P 1190.21 H0.42 %M

7,200 W 1190.21 H8,942 W 7,666,922 W 108,343 W REACTOR CORE POWER = 2535.800 MWT

1274.80 H 1274.80 H RECIRC. PUMP POWER = 7.800 MWT0 W CLEANUP LOSSES = 3.300 MWT

2,122 W FP POWER RADIATION LOSSES = 1.100 MWT11,010,435 W EFF.=76.5 % 7931 KW NSSS THERMAL POWER = 2539.200 MWT

1055.00 P PB = 950.61 TOTAL SHAFT OUTPUT = 877538 KW1190.21 H P1STG = 702.24 1025.02 H GEN. POWER FACTOR = 0.90

0.100% H1STG = 1169.43 3.78 IN.HGA GEN. H2 PRESSURE = 60.0 PSIGDELP = 4.94 % 7,558,579 W MECHANICAL. LOSSES = 3783 KW

9,622 W 9,622 W 185.82 P PB = 177.71 GEN. LOSSES = 10637 KW1086.91 H 1086.91 H 507.76 F HB = 1274.80 GENERATOR OUTPUT = 863119 KW

1274.80 H NET TURBINE HEAT RATE = 10038 BTU/KWHR993.00 P 110.55 P 66.79 P 20.49 P 10.76 P 5.58 P GROSS TURBINE HEAT RATE =9947 BTU/KWHR

369.13 P 578.20 P 578.20 P 1190.21 H TD = 35 F 1232.65 H 1192.52 H 1112.17 H 1073.86 H 1043.20 H1126.29 H 1156.06 H 1156.06 H 1113.90 H 1079.37 H 1063.25 H

358.06 P 560.85 P 560.85 P 191.81 P 985.06 P 107.24 P 64.78 P 19.87 P 5.42 P ELEP = 1004.63 HCORE THERMAL 1086.91 H 46,858 W 542.76 F 187.09 P 500,210 W UEEP = 1009.85 H 3.70 IN.HGA

POWER = 675,038 W 1190.21 H 1235.07 H 12,937 W 136,690 W 5,976,703 W2535.80 MWT 1126.29 H 406,979 W 453,837 W 556.92 P TD = 40 F 197.57 h 134.91 h

206,290 W 412,579 W 1156.06 H 1159.59 H 552.47 P 9,622 W 427,288 W 217,564 W 7,200 W 0 W 108,343 W461.49 h 477.41 F 1086.91 H 1113.90 H 1063.25 H 179.00 h 179.00 h 1025.02 H

16,684 W 234,291 W 468,583 W 461.49 h 188.37 P540.24 h 540.24 h 41,258 W 1197.50 H CF, % = 85.00

0 W 8,772,481 W 8,813,739 W 190.47 P 38,576 W GPM = 352,6001086.91 H 1087.25 H 13.08%M 216,603 W 164.77 h 0 W 16,684 W CWT, F = 77.00 F

MSEFF = 100.00 % 32,008 W 1181.86 H 206.70 H 3.70 IN.HGA HWT, F = 109.29 F1,146,818 W 1079.37 H

30,000 W 41,258 W 573,409 W 350.18 h0 W 350.18 h 8,140 W 41,258 W

573,409 W 221,073 W 1181.86 H 0 W580,087 W 0 W 1087.09 H

0 W 1086.91 H HW=122.53 F165,032 W 0 W 8,342 W461.49 h 291,337 W 573,409 W 206.70 h

10,980,435 W 350.18 h425.95 F 234,291 W 108,962 W 16,684 W 11,023,915 W404.16 h 339,879 W 540.24 h 1232.65 H 255,964 W 213,005 W 1086.91 H 5,340 W 218.93 P

348.67 P 3,986 W 183.43 P 99.16 P 60.86 P 1190.54 H 19.56 P 5.38 P 685.23 H 13,480 W 1181.86 H 6,216 W 122.85 FTD = 5.41 F TD = 4.98 F TD = 4.84 F TD = 4.72 F TD = 4.85 F TD = 3.09 F 1190.21 H 91.37 h

5,490,218 W 5,490,218 W 569.15 P 5,486,232 W425.96 F 371.04 F 1141.09 P 369.64 F 322.37 F 288.92 F 221.93 F 162.29 F 140.78 F 652.35 P 123.45 F404.15 h 345.39 h 343.09 h 293.71 h 259.35 h 191.49 h 131.75 h 110.32 h 124.66 F 91.96 h

431.37 F 374.63 F 327.21 F 293.64 F 226.78 F 165.37 F 94.28 hDC = 10.7 F DELTAH =2.47 DC = 10.0 F DC = 9.5 F DC = 8.8 F DC = 9.2 F DC = 6.9 F 6,216 W

178.93 P 5,340 W 130.00 h0 W 124.04 F 179.00 h

92.45 h1,035,010 W 2,202,759 W

739,202 W 332.34 F 298.47 F 171.50 F381.78 F 303.38 h 268.20 h 139.51 h355.67 h 234,291 W 213,005 W

0 W 206,290 W 540.24 h 0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 165.37 F461.49 h 133.34 h

0 W0 W 0 W 0 W 7,971 W

DELTAH =1.83

0 W0 W 0 W 219,152 W 0 W

206,290 W 288,750 W 1086.86 H461.49 h 1086.91 H 178.93 P

234,291 W 573,409 W 107,641 W 253,868 W 8,342 W 124.04 F540.24 h 350.18 h 1232.65 H 1190.52 H 206.70 h 92.45 h

335,160 W 211,833 W348.67 P 3,986 W 183.43 P 99.16 P 60.86 P 19.56 P 5.38 P 683.14 HTD = 5.39 F TD = 4.96 F TD = 4.82 F TD = 4.69 F TD = 4.82 F TD = 3.06 F

5,490,218 W 5,490,218 W 569.15 P 5,486,232 W425.98 F 371.04 F 1141.09 P 369.66 F 322.39 F 288.95 F 221.96 F 162.32 F 652.35 P404.18 h 345.39 h 343.11 h 293.73 h 259.38 h 191.51 h 131.78 h 110.55 h 124.66 F

431.37 F 374.63 F 327.21 F 293.64 F 226.78 F 165.37 F 94.28 hDC = 11.4 F DELTAH =2.47 DC = 10.4 F DC = 9.7 F DC = 9.1 F DC = 9.4 F DC = 7.1 F

775,740 W 1,750,012 W 2,003,880 W 2,231,374 W382.49 F 332.75 F 298.70 F 231.02 F 171.74 F356.43 h 303.81 h 268.43 h 199.44 h 139.75 h 211,833 W

0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 165.37 F133.34 h

0 W

PIV = 183.78

4,870,527 W

99.55 h

4,471 W

1086.91 H

141.00 F

2,202,759 W131.56 F

0 W

1,068,962 W

230.73 F199.16 h

1,973,344 W1,717,380 W

4,471 W

211,833 W

131.75 F99.75 h

2,202,759 W

213,005 W

2,231,374 W

30,000 W

2,231,374 W

1STGRHTR

DRN. TK. A

REBOILER

CONDENSER

TWO DOUBLE-FLOW LP TURBINES

CP

MOIST.SEP.

DOUBLE-FLOW HP TURBINE

D

REACTOR

A

T O SJAE

B

T O CRD

RHTR.1

RHTR.2

T O RFPT

A

RFPTURBINE

TO RECOMBINER

TO REBOILER

VENT FLOW

VENT FLOW

TO CONDENSER

C

T O RBLR

FROMREBOILER

T O HT RSEH-2A,B

BFROM RFPT

FROMRECOMBINER

FROMRADWAST E

FROM MAINSTEAM

T ORADWAST E

MSDRAIN

TANK A

FROMRFP

TO COND. A

FROM MSRDRN.TANKS

MAKEUP

RFP A

GSC SJAE

BP

EH-6A EH-5A EH-4A EH-3A EH-1A DC 1A

T O COND.ST OR.T K.

RFPSEALS

EH-2A

TO RFPSEALS

T O 1ST G & 2ST G RHT R.

DRN. T KS

TO MSDRN.TKS.

T OCOND.A

T O COND. A

EMER. HTR. DRNS.

EH-6B EH-5B EH-4B EH-3B EH-1B DC 1B

RFPSEALS

EH-2B

T OCOND. B

T O COND. B

T OCOND. A

C

FROMRFP

T OCOND. A

FROMRFP

2STGRHTR

DRN. TK. A

2STGRHTR

DRN. TK. B

1STGRHTR

DRN. TK. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

MSDRAIN

TANK B

T OCOND. A

FROM BOOST ERPUMPS

A

BP

BP

D

RFP B

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

FROMRFP

FROM BOOST ERPUMPS

FROMREBOILER

Page 12: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

Less Drains Enter Heater 6A Extrn. Steam Flows, TTD’s for

Heaters Upstream in “A” String Increase Slightly

DCA’s for These Heaters Decrease Generator Output Decreases by

About 1.0 Mwe (0.1%)

Impact of 20% 1Stg. Rhtr. Drn. Tank “A” Drains Dump to Condenser

Page 13: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

Predicted Performance - 20% 2Stg Rhtr. Drain Tank “A” Drains Dump to Condenser

6,216 W 0 W

515,056 W1190.21 H

10,481,041 W 0 W1000.00 P 1190.21 H0.42 %M

7,200 W 1190.21 H8,944 W 7,661,627 W 108,340 W REACTOR CORE POWER = 2535.800 MWT

1274.81 H 1274.81 H RECIRC. PUMP POWER = 7.800 MWT0 W CLEANUP LOSSES = 3.300 MWT

2,121 W FP POWER RADIATION LOSSES = 1.100 MWT11,009,512 W EFF.=76.5 % 7929 KW NSSS THERMAL POWER = 2539.200 MWT

1055.00 P PB = 950.60 TOTAL SHAFT OUTPUT = 877075 KW1190.21 H P1STG = 702.20 1025.08 H GEN. POWER FACTOR = 0.90

0.100% H1STG = 1169.43 3.78 IN.HGA GEN. H2 PRESSURE = 60.0 PSIGDELP = 4.94 % 7,553,287 W MECHANICAL. LOSSES = 3783 KW

9,616 W 9,616 W 185.69 P PB = 177.59 GEN. LOSSES = 10628 KW1086.87 H 1086.87 H 507.76 F HB = 1274.81 GENERATOR OUTPUT = 862663 KW

1274.81 H NET TURBINE HEAT RATE = 10043 BTU/KWHR993.00 P 110.48 P 66.74 P 20.47 P 10.75 P 5.58 P GROSS TURBINE HEAT RATE =9952 BTU/KWHR

368.89 P 578.16 P 578.16 P 1190.21 H TD = 35 F 1232.66 H 1192.53 H 1112.17 H 1073.87 H 1043.21 H1126.25 H 1156.06 H 1156.06 H 1113.90 H 1079.38 H 1063.25 H

357.82 P 560.82 P 560.82 P 191.68 P 985.06 P 107.16 P 64.73 P 19.86 P 5.41 P ELEP = 1004.69 HCORE THERMAL 1086.87 H 46,823 W 542.76 F 186.96 P 500,145 W UEEP = 1009.90 H 3.70 IN.HGA

POWER = 680,401 W 1190.21 H 1235.09 H 12,931 W 136,543 W 5,972,022 W2535.80 MWT 1126.25 H 407,001 W 453,824 W 556.89 P TD = 40 F 197.53 h 134.88 h

206,284 W 412,568 W 1156.06 H 1159.59 H 552.44 P 9,616 W 427,198 W 217,274 W 7,200 W 0 W 108,340 W461.48 h 477.41 F 1086.87 H 1113.90 H 1063.25 H 179.00 h 179.00 h 1025.08 H

16,684 W 234,116 W 468,232 W 461.48 h 188.24 P540.24 h 540.24 h 41,257 W 1197.49 H CF, % = 85.00

0 W 8,766,670 W 8,807,927 W 190.34 P 38,575 W GPM = 352,6001086.87 H 1087.21 H 13.09%M 216,617 W 164.73 h 0 W 16,684 W CWT, F = 77.00 F

MSEFF = 100.00 % 31,982 W 1181.86 H 206.70 H 3.70 IN.HGA HWT, F = 109.30 F1,146,300 W 1079.38 H

30,000 W 0 W 573,150 W 350.12 h0 W 350.12 h 8,140 W 46,823 W

573,150 W 221,025 W 1181.86 H 0 W579,987 W 0 W 1087.10 H

46,823 W 1086.87 H HW=122.54 F206,284 W 0 W 8,342 W461.48 h 291,287 W 573,150 W 206.70 h

10,979,512 W 350.12 h425.89 F 187,293 W 108,969 W 16,684 W 11,022,992 W404.10 h 345,337 W 540.24 h 1232.66 H 255,929 W 212,772 W 1086.87 H 5,340 W 218.93 P

348.44 P 3,986 W 183.31 P 99.09 P 60.81 P 1190.54 H 19.54 P 5.38 P 685.13 H 13,480 W 1181.86 H 6,216 W 122.86 FTD = 5.41 F TD = 4.98 F TD = 4.84 F TD = 4.72 F TD = 4.85 F TD = 3.09 F 1190.21 H 91.38 h

5,489,756 W 5,489,756 W 569.19 P 5,485,771 W425.89 F 370.99 F 1141.07 P 369.59 F 322.32 F 288.87 F 221.89 F 162.25 F 140.77 F 652.37 P 123.46 F404.08 h 345.33 h 343.03 h 293.66 h 259.30 h 191.44 h 131.72 h 110.31 h 124.68 F 91.98 h

431.30 F 374.57 F 327.16 F 293.59 F 226.74 F 165.34 F 94.29 hDC = 10.7 F DELTAH =2.47 DC = 10.0 F DC = 9.5 F DC = 8.8 F DC = 9.2 F DC = 6.9 F 6,216 W

178.93 P 5,340 W 130.00 h0 W 124.05 F 179.00 h

92.46 h1,034,673 W 2,202,088 W

738,914 W 332.28 F 298.41 F 171.46 F381.71 F 303.32 h 268.14 h 139.47 h355.60 h 234,116 W 212,772 W

0 W 206,284 W 540.24 h 0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 165.34 F461.48 h 133.31 h

0 W0 W 0 W 0 W 7,971 W

DELTAH =1.83

0 W0 W 0 W 219,104 W 0 W

206,284 W 288,700 W 1086.86 H461.48 h 1086.87 H 178.93 P

234,116 W 573,150 W 107,648 W 253,832 W 8,342 W 124.05 F540.24 h 350.12 h 1232.66 H 1190.53 H 206.70 h 92.46 h

335,065 W 211,601 W348.44 P 3,986 W 183.31 P 99.09 P 60.81 P 19.54 P 5.38 P 683.04 HTD = 5.38 F TD = 4.96 F TD = 4.82 F TD = 4.69 F TD = 4.82 F TD = 3.06 F

5,489,756 W 5,489,756 W 569.19 P 5,485,771 W425.92 F 370.99 F 1141.07 P 369.61 F 322.34 F 288.90 F 221.92 F 162.28 F 652.37 P404.11 h 345.33 h 343.06 h 293.68 h 259.33 h 191.47 h 131.75 h 110.54 h 124.68 F

431.30 F 374.57 F 327.16 F 293.59 F 226.74 F 165.34 F 94.29 hDC = 11.4 F DELTAH =2.47 DC = 10.4 F DC = 9.7 F DC = 9.1 F DC = 9.4 F DC = 7.1 F

775,465 W 1,749,435 W 2,003,267 W 2,230,713 W382.42 F 332.70 F 298.64 F 230.97 F 171.71 F356.36 h 303.75 h 268.38 h 199.39 h 139.72 h 211,601 W

0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 165.34 F133.31 h

0 W

PIV = 183.65

4,868,730 W

99.56 h

4,472 W

1086.87 H

141.00 F

2,202,088 W131.56 F

0 W

1,068,636 W

230.68 F199.11 h

1,972,720 W1,716,791 W

4,472 W

211,601 W

131.75 F99.75 h

2,202,088 W

212,772 W

2,230,713 W

30,000 W

2,230,713 W

1STGRHTR

DRN. TK. A

REBOILER

CONDENSER

TWO DOUBLE-FLOW LP TURBINES

CP

MOIST.SEP.

DOUBLE-FLOW HP TURBINE

D

REACTOR

A

T O SJAE

B

T O CRD

RHTR.1

RHTR.2

T O RFPT

A

RFPTURBINE

TO RECOMBINER

TO REBOILER

VENT FLOW

VENT FLOW

TO CONDENSER

C

T O RBLR

FROMREBOILER

T O HT RSEH-2A,B

BFROM RFPT

FROMRECOMBINER

FROMRADWAST E

FROM MAINSTEAM

T ORADWAST E

MSDRAIN

TANK A

FROMRFP

TO COND. A

FROM MSRDRN.TANKS

MAKEUP

RFP A

GSC SJAE

BP

EH-6A EH-5A EH-4A EH-3A EH-1A DC 1A

T O COND.ST OR.T K.

RFPSEALS

EH-2A

TO RFPSEALS

T O 1ST G & 2ST G RHT R.

DRN. T KS

TO MSDRN.TKS.

T OCOND.A

T O COND. A

EMER. HTR. DRNS.

EH-6B EH-5B EH-4B EH-3B EH-1B DC 1B

RFPSEALS

EH-2B

T OCOND. B

T O COND. B

T OCOND. A

C

FROMRFP

T OCOND. A

FROMRFP

2STGRHTR

DRN. TK. A

2STGRHTR

DRN. TK. B

1STGRHTR

DRN. TK. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

MSDRAIN

TANK B

T OCOND. A

FROM BOOST ERPUMPS

A

BP

BP

D

RFP B

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

FROMRFP

FROM BOOST ERPUMPS

FROMREBOILER

Page 14: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

Less Drains Enter Heater 6A Extrn. Steam Flows, TTD’s for

Heaters Upstream in “A” String Increase Slightly

DCA’s for These Heaters Decrease Generator Output Decreases by

About 1.4 Mwe (0.16%)

Impact of 20% 2Stg. Rhtr. Drn. Tank “A” Drains Dump to Condenser

Page 15: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

Predicted Performance - 10% Leak in Heater 6A Emergency Drain Valve to Condenser

6,216 W 0 W

515,616 W1190.21 H

10,482,293 W 0 W1000.00 P 1190.21 H0.42 %M

7,200 W 1190.21 H8,942 W 7,669,763 W 108,356 W REACTOR CORE POWER = 2535.800 MWT

1274.79 H 1274.79 H RECIRC. PUMP POWER = 7.800 MWT0 W CLEANUP LOSSES = 3.300 MWT

2,123 W FP POWER RADIATION LOSSES = 1.100 MWT11,011,325 W EFF.=76.5 % 7932 KW NSSS THERMAL POWER = 2539.200 MWT

1055.00 P PB = 950.62 TOTAL SHAFT OUTPUT = 877466 KW1190.21 H P1STG = 702.29 1025.00 H GEN. POWER FACTOR = 0.90

0.100% H1STG = 1169.44 3.78 IN.HGA GEN. H2 PRESSURE = 60.0 PSIGDELP = 4.94 % 7,561,407 W MECHANICAL. LOSSES = 3783 KW

9,626 W 9,626 W 185.89 P PB = 177.78 GEN. LOSSES = 10635 KW1086.93 H 1086.93 H 507.76 F HB = 1274.79 GENERATOR OUTPUT = 863048 KW

1274.79 H NET TURBINE HEAT RATE = 10039 BTU/KWHR993.00 P 110.57 P 66.77 P 20.48 P 10.76 P 5.58 P GROSS TURBINE HEAT RATE =9948 BTU/KWHR

369.33 P 578.24 P 578.24 P 1190.21 H TD = 35 F 1232.62 H 1192.47 H 1112.10 H 1073.80 H 1043.15 H1126.32 H 1156.07 H 1156.07 H 1113.84 H 1079.32 H 1063.20 H

358.25 P 560.89 P 560.89 P 191.88 P 985.06 P 107.25 P 64.76 P 19.86 P 5.41 P ELEP = 1004.63 HCORE THERMAL 1086.93 H 46,874 W 542.76 F 187.16 P 502,723 W UEEP = 1009.84 H 3.70 IN.HGA

POWER = 670,893 W 1190.21 H 1235.07 H 12,958 W 136,678 W 5,972,023 W2535.80 MWT 1126.32 H 407,003 W 453,877 W 556.96 P TD = 40 F 197.54 h 134.88 h

206,308 W 412,615 W 1156.07 H 1159.59 H 552.51 P 9,626 W 429,483 W 218,655 W 7,200 W 0 W 108,356 W461.49 h 477.42 F 1086.93 H 1113.84 H 1063.20 H 179.00 h 179.00 h 1025.00 H

16,683 W 234,371 W 468,742 W 461.49 h 188.44 P540.24 h 540.24 h 41,262 W 1197.51 H CF, % = 85.00

0 W 8,775,607 W 8,816,868 W 190.54 P 38,611 W GPM = 352,6001086.93 H 1087.27 H 13.08%M 218,286 W 164.74 h 0 W 16,683 W CWT, F = 77.00 F

MSEFF = 100.00 % 31,990 W 1181.86 H 206.70 H 3.70 IN.HGA HWT, F = 109.29 F1,147,105 W 1079.32 H

30,000 W 0 W 573,552 W 350.21 h0 W 350.21 h 8,140 W 0 W

573,552 W 223,300 W 1181.86 H 0 W581,792 W 0 W 1087.25 H

0 W 1086.93 H HW=122.53 F206,308 W 0 W 8,342 W461.49 h 292,888 W 573,552 W 206.70 h

10,981,325 W 350.21 h426.01 F 234,371 W 110,567 W 16,683 W 11,024,805 W404.23 h 335,446 W 540.24 h 1232.62 H 258,453 W 214,237 W 1086.93 H 5,340 W 218.92 P

348.85 P 3,986 W 183.50 P 99.17 P 60.84 P 1190.50 H 19.55 P 5.38 P 687.32 H 13,480 W 1181.86 H 6,216 W 122.85 FTD = 5.39 F TD = 5.02 F TD = 4.87 F TD = 4.75 F TD = 4.88 F TD = 3.12 F 1190.21 H 91.37 h

5,490,663 W 5,490,663 W 569.11 P 5,486,677 W426.03 F 371.06 F 1141.10 P 369.64 F 322.35 F 288.87 F 221.87 F 162.22 F 140.50 F 652.32 P 123.45 F404.23 h 345.40 h 343.09 h 293.69 h 259.30 h 191.42 h 131.68 h 110.05 h 124.67 F 91.97 h

431.42 F 374.66 F 327.22 F 293.62 F 226.75 F 165.34 F 94.28 hDC = 11.5 F DELTAH =2.47 DC = 9.5 F DC = 9.3 F DC = 8.5 F DC = 9.0 F DC = 6.7 F 6,216 W

178.92 P 5,340 W 130.00 h0 W 124.04 F 179.00 h

92.45 h995,871 W 2,170,086 W

698,512 W 331.87 F 298.19 F 171.19 F382.52 F 302.89 h 267.91 h 139.20 h356.46 h 234,371 W 214,237 W

77,612 W 206,308 W 540.24 h 0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 165.34 F382.52 F 461.49 h 133.30 h356.46 h

0 W0 W 0 W 0 W 7,971 W

DELTAH =1.83

0 W0 W 0 W 219,141 W 0 W

206,308 W 288,904 W 1086.75 H461.49 h 1086.93 H 178.92 P

234,371 W 573,552 W 107,719 W 253,896 W 8,342 W 124.04 F540.24 h 350.21 h 1232.62 H 1190.47 H 206.70 h 92.45 h

335,446 W 211,696 W348.85 P 3,986 W 183.50 P 99.17 P 60.84 P 19.55 P 5.38 P 682.81 HTD = 5.39 F TD = 4.96 F TD = 4.83 F TD = 4.69 F TD = 4.82 F TD = 3.06 F

5,490,663 W 5,490,663 W 569.11 P 5,486,677 W426.03 F 371.06 F 1141.10 P 369.69 F 322.40 F 288.93 F 221.93 F 162.28 F 652.32 P404.23 h 345.40 h 343.14 h 293.74 h 259.36 h 191.48 h 131.74 h 110.54 h 124.67 F

431.42 F 374.66 F 327.22 F 293.62 F 226.75 F 165.34 F 94.28 hDC = 11.5 F DELTAH =2.47 DC = 10.4 F DC = 9.8 F DC = 9.1 F DC = 9.4 F DC = 7.1 F

776,125 W 1,750,772 W 2,004,667 W 2,232,150 W382.52 F 332.77 F 298.69 F 230.99 F 171.72 F356.46 h 303.82 h 268.42 h 199.42 h 139.73 h 211,696 W

0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 165.34 F133.30 h

0 W

PIV = 183.84

4,839,725 W

99.33 h

4,471 W

1086.93 H

141.00 F

2,170,086 W131.33 F

77,612 W

1,069,500 W

230.38 F198.80 h

1,938,443 W1,679,990 W

4,471 W

211,696 W

131.75 F99.75 h

2,170,086 W

214,237 W

2,232,150 W

30,000 W

2,232,150 W

1STGRHTR

DRN. TK. A

REBOILER

CONDENSER

TWO DOUBLE-FLOW LP TURBINES

CP

MOIST.SEP.

DOUBLE-FLOW HP TURBINE

D

REACTOR

A

T O SJAE

B

T O CRD

RHTR.1

RHTR.2

T O RFPT

A

RFPTURBINE

TO RECOMBINER

TO REBOILER

VENT FLOW

VENT FLOW

TO CONDENSER

C

T O RBLR

FROMREBOILER

T O HT RSEH-2A,B

BFROM RFPT

FROMRECOMBINER

FROMRADWAST E

FROM MAINSTEAM

T ORADWAST E

MSDRAIN

TANK A

FROMRFP

TO COND. A

FROM MSRDRN.TANKS

MAKEUP

RFP A

GSC SJAE

BP

EH-6A EH-5A EH-4A EH-3A EH-1A DC 1A

T O COND.ST OR.T K.

RFPSEALS

EH-2A

TO RFPSEALS

T O 1ST G & 2ST G RHT R.

DRN. T KS

TO MSDRN.TKS.

T OCOND.A

T O COND. A

EMER. HTR. DRNS.

EH-6B EH-5B EH-4B EH-3B EH-1B DC 1B

RFPSEALS

EH-2B

T OCOND. B

T O COND. B

T OCOND. A

C

FROMRFP

T OCOND. A

FROMRFP

2STGRHTR

DRN. TK. A

2STGRHTR

DRN. TK. B

1STGRHTR

DRN. TK. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

MSDRAIN

TANK B

T OCOND. A

FROM BOOST ERPUMPS

A

BP

BP

D

RFP B

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

FROMRFP

FROM BOOST ERPUMPS

FROMREBOILER

Page 16: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

Extrn. Steam Flows, TTD’s for Heaters Upstream in “A” String Increase

DCA’s for These Heaters Decrease Capacity Loss is About 1 Mwe

(0.11%)

Impact of 10% Leak in Htr. 6A Emergency Drain Valve to Condenser

Page 17: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

Capacity Loss - 10% Leak in Emergency Heater Drain Valves to Condenser

Description Generator Output, Kw

Capacity Loss, Kw

Capacity Loss, %

Base Case 864,022 Base Base

Htr. 6A 863,048 974 0.11

Htr. 5A 863,104 918 0.11

Htr. 4A 862,923 1,099 0.13

Htr. 3A 863,524 498 0.06

Htr. 2A 863,914 108 0.01

Page 18: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

Extrn. Steam Flows, TTD’s for Heaters Upstream in “A” String Increase

DCA’s for These Heaters Decrease Capacity Losses Greatest for Leaks

in Heaters 4A, 6A (About 1 Mwe)

Impact of 10% Leak in Emergency Heater Drain Valves to Condenser

Page 19: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

Predicted Performance - 1% Reduction in FW Flow 6,216 W 0 W

518,212 W1190.21 H

10,370,095 W 0 W1000.00 P 1190.21 H0.42 %M

7,200 W 1190.21 H8,961 W 7,598,299 W 106,174 W REACTOR CORE POWER = 2513.413 MWT

1274.96 H 1274.96 H RECIRC. PUMP POWER = 7.800 MWT0 W CLEANUP LOSSES = 3.300 MWT

2,104 W FP POWER RADIATION LOSSES = 1.100 MWT10,901,723 W EFF.=76.2 % 7744 KW NSSS THERMAL POWER = 2516.813 MWT

1055.00 P PB = 949.24 TOTAL SHAFT OUTPUT = 871135 KW1190.21 H P1STG = 694.77 1026.10 H GEN. POWER FACTOR = 0.90

0.100% H1STG = 1168.93 3.74 IN.HGA GEN. H2 PRESSURE = 60.0 PSIGDELP = 5.08 % 7,492,125 W MECHANICAL. LOSSES = 3783 KW

9,542 W 9,542 W 184.22 P PB = 176.18 GEN. LOSSES = 10525 KW1086.61 H 1086.61 H 507.76 F HB = 1274.96 GENERATOR OUTPUT = 856827 KW

1274.96 H NET TURBINE HEAT RATE = 10023 BTU/KWHR993.00 P 109.65 P 66.28 P 20.34 P 10.68 P 5.54 P GROSS TURBINE HEAT RATE =9933 BTU/KWHR

365.63 P 572.16 P 572.16 P 1190.21 H TD = 35 F 1232.85 H 1192.76 H 1112.40 H 1074.08 H 1043.45 H1125.90 H 1155.59 H 1155.59 H 1114.14 H 1079.62 H 1063.41 H

354.66 P 555.00 P 555.00 P 190.16 P 985.06 P 106.36 P 64.29 P 19.73 P 5.38 P ELEP = 1004.58 HCORE THERMAL 1086.61 H 47,110 W 542.76 F 185.48 P 492,138 W UEEP = 1009.82 H 3.65 IN.HGA

POWER = 658,989 W 1190.21 H 1234.66 H 12,813 W 135,091 W 5,933,466 W2513.41 MWT 1125.90 H 398,621 W 445,731 W 551.11 P TD = 40 F 197.17 h 134.60 h

202,605 W 405,210 W 1155.59 H 1159.25 H 546.70 P 9,542 W 420,789 W 215,314 W 7,200 W 0 W 106,174 W460.21 h 476.31 F 1086.61 H 1114.14 H 1063.41 H 179.00 h 179.00 h 1026.10 H

16,696 W 235,551 W 471,101 W 460.21 h 186.75 P540.24 h 540.24 h 40,521 W 1197.38 H CF, % = 85.00

0 W 8,695,509 W 8,736,030 W 188.83 P 38,461 W GPM = 352,6001086.61 H 1086.95 H 13.09%M 212,283 W 164.41 h 0 W 16,696 W CWT, F = 77.00 F

MSEFF = 100.00 % 31,771 W 1181.86 H 206.70 H 3.65 IN.HGA HWT, F = 108.98 F1,137,731 W 1079.62 H

30,000 W 0 W 568,865 W 349.41 h0 W 349.41 h 8,140 W 0 W

568,865 W 216,801 W 1181.86 H 0 W570,132 W 0 W 1087.04 H

0 W 1086.61 H HW=122.09 F202,605 W 0 W 8,348 W460.21 h 285,066 W 568,865 W 206.70 h

10,871,723 W 349.41 h425.19 F 235,551 W 106,141 W 16,696 W 10,915,203 W403.33 h 329,494 W 540.24 h 1232.85 H 250,840 W 210,318 W 1086.61 H 5,340 W 219.48 P

345.36 P 3,986 W 181.86 P 98.34 P 60.39 P 1190.74 H 19.42 P 5.34 P 684.14 H 13,480 W 1181.86 H 6,216 W 122.42 FTD = 5.26 F TD = 4.86 F TD = 4.73 F TD = 4.60 F TD = 4.74 F TD = 3.03 F 1190.21 H 90.93 h

5,435,862 W 5,435,862 W 573.83 P 5,431,876 W425.21 F 370.43 F 1138.83 P 369.06 F 321.89 F 288.54 F 221.64 F 162.03 F 140.61 F 655.39 P 123.02 F403.33 h 344.73 h 342.48 h 293.22 h 258.97 h 191.20 h 131.50 h 110.17 h 124.24 F 91.54 h

430.46 F 373.92 F 326.62 F 293.14 F 226.39 F 165.06 F 93.86 hDC = 11.2 F DELTAH =2.43 DC = 10.2 F DC = 9.6 F DC = 8.9 F DC = 9.3 F DC = 7.0 F 6,216 W

179.48 P 5,340 W 130.00 h0 W 123.61 F 179.00 h

92.03 h1,057,197 W 2,208,193 W

767,650 W 332.09 F 298.16 F 171.35 F381.67 F 303.12 h 267.88 h 139.36 h355.55 h 235,551 W 210,318 W

0 W 202,605 W 540.24 h 0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 165.06 F460.21 h 133.03 h

0 W0 W 0 W 0 W 7,971 W

DELTAH =1.84

0 W0 W 0 W 216,801 W 0 W

202,605 W 285,066 W 1087.04 H460.21 h 1086.61 H 179.48 P

235,551 W 568,865 W 106,141 W 250,840 W 8,348 W 123.61 F540.24 h 349.41 h 1232.85 H 1190.74 H 206.70 h 92.03 h

329,494 W 210,318 W345.36 P 3,986 W 181.86 P 98.34 P 60.39 P 19.42 P 5.34 P 684.14 HTD = 5.26 F TD = 4.86 F TD = 4.73 F TD = 4.60 F TD = 4.74 F TD = 3.03 F

5,435,862 W 5,435,862 W 573.83 P 5,431,876 W425.21 F 370.43 F 1138.83 P 369.06 F 321.89 F 288.54 F 221.64 F 162.03 F 655.39 P403.33 h 344.73 h 342.48 h 293.22 h 258.97 h 191.20 h 131.50 h 110.17 h 124.24 F

430.46 F 373.92 F 326.62 F 293.14 F 226.39 F 165.06 F 93.86 hDC = 11.2 F DELTAH =2.43 DC = 10.2 F DC = 9.6 F DC = 8.9 F DC = 9.3 F DC = 7.0 F

767,650 W 1,732,203 W 1,983,043 W 2,208,193 W381.67 F 332.09 F 298.16 F 230.57 F 171.35 F355.55 h 303.12 h 267.88 h 198.99 h 139.36 h 210,318 W

0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 0 W 165.06 F133.03 h

0 W

PIV = 182.20

4,848,577 W

99.26 h

4,480 W

1086.61 H

140.61 F

2,208,193 W131.26 F

0 W

1,057,197 W

230.57 F198.99 h

1,983,043 W1,732,203 W

4,480 W

210,318 W

131.26 F99.26 h

2,208,193 W

210,318 W

2,208,193 W

30,000 W

2,208,193 W

1STGRHTR

DRN. TK. A

REBOILER

CONDENSER

TWO DOUBLE-FLOW LP TURBINES

CP

MOIST.SEP.

DOUBLE-FLOW HP TURBINE

D

REACTOR

A

T O SJAE

B

T O CRD

RHTR.1

RHTR.2

T O RFPT

A

RFPTURBINE

TO RECOMBINER

TO REBOILER

VENT FLOW

VENT FLOW

TO CONDENSER

C

T O RBLR

FROMREBOILER

T O HT RSEH-2A,B

BFROM RFPT

FROMRECOMBINER

FROMRADWAST E

FROM MAINSTEAM

T ORADWAST E

MSDRAIN

TANK A

FROMRFP

TO COND. A

FROM MSRDRN.TANKS

MAKEUP

RFP A

GSC SJAE

BP

EH-6A EH-5A EH-4A EH-3A EH-1A DC 1A

T O COND.ST OR.T K.

RFPSEALS

EH-2A

TO RFPSEALS

T O 1ST G & 2ST G RHT R.

DRN. T KS

TO MSDRN.TKS.

T OCOND.A

T O COND. A

EMER. HTR. DRNS.

EH-6B EH-5B EH-4B EH-3B EH-1B DC 1B

RFPSEALS

EH-2B

T OCOND. B

T O COND. B

T OCOND. A

C

FROMRFP

T OCOND. A

FROMRFP

2STGRHTR

DRN. TK. A

2STGRHTR

DRN. TK. B

1STGRHTR

DRN. TK. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. B

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

MSDRAIN

TANK B

T OCOND. A

FROM BOOST ERPUMPS

A

BP

BP

D

RFP B

T OCOND. A

T OCOND. A

FROMRFP

FROM BOOST ERPUMPS

FROMREBOILER

Page 20: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

Final FW Temp. Decreases by About 0.8 F

HP, LP Turbine Bowl, Stage & Extrn. Steam Pressures Decrease By About 1%

TTD’s, DCA’s in Both Strings Decrease By About Same Amount (0.1 to 0.2 F)

Capacity Loss is About 7 Mwe (0.8%)

Impact of 1% Reduction in FW Flow

Page 21: 2004 ASME Power Conference Capacity Losses in Nuclear Plants - A Case Study Sunder Raj Presentation

Detailed Model Permits Predicting Changes in Capacity & Impact Upon Various Parameters Facilitates Conducting Diagnostics

& Confirming As Well As Validating Predicted Changes

Conclusions & Recommendations