20 - Virginia Department of Mines, Minerals & Energy · 2017-02-03 · C nl E 00 0 E 0C e N tn Ce o...
Transcript of 20 - Virginia Department of Mines, Minerals & Energy · 2017-02-03 · C nl E 00 0 E 0C e N tn Ce o...
ClR0m
N0 e0 th—Z 0
m
5 om~C CooCQ
ID
E ECQ UJ Ol
Q.0 00 lhUl e
E 0e NOl 0
QC0 N.IEIL
Cl
IQ 'L0 oOl
0 OD0m
IIL 2IU CQ
w0IL C/J
Ct!
LD
ICI'«IithCt'Z
CCtD
Ctt
CD
IA
ON
0
0'l
N
IACO
TIA
Chtth00!
0tD'o0O
20I-DCICIJ
RI
tl!
Ch
0V0 2C0 2
R. 2V
C«CQ
IU
ZI- I-
Z Z 0
MCI
IOCtQJ0CQ
COUImK02IU
D0CI
Cl
E ce—0 mO Q.Cl
0 ID) Ot
0ID e
Ze O
O P-J m
0V )th ID
m aCQ cX CIJ
2 eO th
CQ PI- ~mN M0 0N 0ZOO OO
O 0th
e 00 CQ0 O!
O m~O) C!L N
Ea~0o 0V Nth Om m(9 mX )Z DOw
CQI-2D2CLQ.
OlL'00IL
O
NCl005
0 eCloC
O.O
m
0 )0—e
CEQ gC!th-
th
0e cl
0 COt
e—CIJ
eth eO th
CD CCO
th
Q. E- mL DJ
IC 0mm
m
Eh)C00CO
eLLD
0eO
Ot
E
0CQ I
C!0 Ctf
olO «
mOttlt
mCC s
20OC
D00Z
IU
«CCI
CQ2ZIU
O
V
C9
XO«0
CQ
«C
mCQZ0
CQ IUIU IUD D2 0
IL
w 0Q. K
CL
020Ot
E
N0
0CQ
IDCI0toCICtCCCtC«C«
00'0
LO
8
CICIC!
"0ID
0t«e
UJ
ID'0OOt
000
ot0
0
E
thC
0CQ'oCtCt0CtCt
0e00e
CtCt
CD
CtfCt
e0Ct!«
Ul
Ot'00m cl!Ce eE 0!
m—Q.
DJ IA
CID
E
NC
0CQ'0thC!0
LA
IOCtf
otCtf
00'oID'000ID
IA
CI
CD
C«1'oID
8t«
LIJ
Ct
e'00 CD
C«0e ctfE ct
JOht
CJ 'Z
0Ql
E
M000(0
Qlal0
Co
II)Cl
0al"000S
CO
ClPJ
OlCl
al
0Qlx
UJCCJCf
S
0»C ClClEoS OVl O
(0
Vl
OK
10O
02.'
Cl
0glC!.
N
JaN
N
al:0tnL00'0
Im0(0S
0(a
SSC ~Qf
aS
S 0
0 00al '0o
ta00 01C
m m
OCQl
ofm Cle (IJ
I
'E L
S 0t- a
00N(1!Ql
00
In 00.'l
tD0 CL
0 '00rn cD m0
IU
tD0 c0 CS-EDN .Ql tp
C(D
tfl '0
c 0S00 0
SDa0<aoi0
VJIQJ'0 m
U
0 !-Of 00 e00 Ja(L IU
tD
'0c etD
E 0«( 0
0tU
Ql
Vl
000'E0CL
N
0tg
0SJPta
JP'hCf
VlS
» CtD
0 0Cl S
CL
0gl
ID CO Ucg a!
(U
0 S
tD Ca'e
0 'ID
tD '0tn
c ae aE<Ql Ql
CC 0(JJ
ClC Nal
Cl CID gldc
PJ 0
'VtIOrff
Ift
IVI
(5tDI Z
E pt(40Cp
~e0 C
IO0
(g
S C'O CQ0C p0
0(U O
0tD
tp
SN(9
C
O 0KIL
m0(0tD
00tD
SVJ0(LtD
0Cl'0tD
I
0tpNIU
0(Q0CL0.
N
Vl 0N
eE
ae cSalof 0ta
a (Jtn QEl»4tg Vl
Ql0Cg
0
IU
0h0m I
Ql0Cl
ttl Ql
o0W D
tp» alC
E vl
0 0ODN Cm m0X ta
O o.a0<ta (D
fJJ0 =N m
N
ID
w Eta
Ql
0105
CL0 N
0a Cl
0 E(f
'lo0(a
mN
0alCl00ta0S0N
JP(nlpID
tnQl
I
0S(LN
o0ta
0SCl
'oxSID0mtn
Ql
JaCl!-Intg
ID
CQl1P
w J=rn
"mw
C(g Itf
CCI!
Itl » 'Om c C
S p . 0 raUD 0 O.
oliE s pi — e Ect N oN Jp ™0 CE 0mme (a(ai= O E—Ola 0-PJIU 0 0 C 'l S
e - Ja ~ 0 0 rn moem< cpu e NoE —O 0s > E m 'Vl Ip gf . J N (pe m w o> N to 0 D al E
i- »MIN yegg'gp'JO ca(0 0
MDN QODvf Npg cg0 00(L~ o eO0 Q 'DMDO -o CCEp alOM MMQC ou clOaD e O)(mao 0tp JE»0 >n e > 0 o < 0 MnQVSJQQSON S(P '' 0ec .e 01 N
'QE0N—c 0 D w tp, - 5.E (L cOJa'E o)D 00 e m
cc CL gl (fl
>, e 0 e J= "-mm=p-Ia Ncu 0
cm o m (L —a tn» Co o c'0 C C. ao 0.cmccemem-MWm'SCCODSSS—"m cam
'
mm Ie 0 af N c Ca 0D 0 ID IU
N(ff e Nm.>Necssoo'DS» 'EDe
0 0 D mppNCJPCQC0 s ta e alOQODO»o=DecS m —.CQl"0
m o c .s E 01'>,0 N 0»0 „ym N —O'LO'X
N~QD„M(Col 38 alow eemeccmtomNcw 0) 9 ae o Nvf 0
al m m 0 (g e cj OOg(L tU Nc e(L CM 0CCL Eem -c D e 0 O e D a(pf 0c 0» .—w > Ql E0 w 0 e OlCWNC(OW JPCODEeD 0»mE) m
N (p (Q 0 Ccf+ tU E tD a<D 0 tD
W N»vi 0) m E c NO 0 0oc No~ 0 80 N S al mf1D eOJD N Sc tD SN tD N S D'OLE —0 m w
'Ztn m —c O e s
x>SE - "EUEw I CD.— m c m'>OD c e»mXD e o 0 s
D ni (L u O (L c 0 u D 0 0 ai
Ql
mal D(g > 00»-I m Vn
C! Ql
E»cvl
S la1P
»m E (a0 (L D Mc —Oc em etg0 )
Ql Q!
»N 02Qf " J (gam—ol.c—)tU CN gle m 0"QO(Q m
m e Ewcee~(L m
0O D)
m J 0CU(o C
rncemta QJX.0 a0) E D0 0 e
>'O
N<orn e
cm soal
S6 „Cna X - D
< < f- (L c0 en(O e
Se xC ID
E (1 (L Ql'-Oc 0(a (0V! 0
C 'OCWgl
'U S ICLp OQal Ja
g< >~9 eeScumm D tp
(E 0 —cNIU
Jpta EomD) JO ta 0 rn'E-»N > Wac ta Jc e 0ttl - C
Df—ap e 0.Sp Nm QJJQ O 0 e
Jl
R0Qn
CnlE 000 E
0C
e N tnCe 0 0oe ul (L-
Q UJ 0
04 04 0>0 0 0Cl Ol
CO I
0 N N0 0 0
0% 0%CDJ0 0
COco I0
gCo fl CONCO CO
LA
tfJ N
g ~0 ~0CO CO CIJ
ON
YJ cn
~0 @0 ~0h toO
ILA0
ox ow ox0 00'O
cd COIA IA NAl N Co
0 CO LA
0e
2 00UJ
"0nltll
N
Q
0Cl"n:
(0O I Ct0 0 00 0 0Q 0 0
IA LO CO W 0- 0- LA LA LA 0 N N COol Co IA I I I I Co no Ol IZJ 0- r LAN LA I Cl W r 0 IA LA 0 Ol LA Ifl0 0 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 a 0 0 0 0 D
0 CO
Eent
Ol
~0 ~0 ~00 0 0O O 00 a oIA LA 10
Qo Qo0 00 00 0Q O
0% OO %00 0 00 0 00 0 Cl0 0 0
«0 ~0 ~00 O 00 Cl O0 0 00 0 CI
~0 Do ~00 0 00 0 00 0 00 0 0
+0 +0 +00 0 O0 0 00 0 00 0 0
of .CLetn CEID N0 e
CC
e
0nl
0
CO Coof CO00 0 00 0 0
IA CO no LA IA 10 O N N CoCD Cl Ltl I I I I CO CO 01 CD 0 IAN IA I CO r L- IA IA 0 Ol 10 IA Io o r o 0- r r o 0 0 0 co co0 0 0 0 Ct 0 0 0 0 0 0 Cl 0 0
0.LD
N0 e0tn
IL 0
0m
C
OLA
D Cl CO
0O N
OlCl
co
CO
IA0 LAN
co co co gN N 0LA ICJ IA
co coLA (0 COO IA
CO N~LA
QUtI-Z(LmILIU
IttIL
0eEeN
JDnl
Q NUJUJ
0 '0
co
0ClCQ00
00000.
tDN0m
0eEN
N
eCD
nl 0ill
Cm
ol0E Itl
tn onl
m01
Q f-
otoI-
eonCDe0ID
nl
0(D
f-
ono
'llO co IO
NI CO Lfl
t-z Q.0 „C0 01
Ct.
IXl 0 O0x
co co
mO Ol
0 mQ I- XO~m
0 0
00 P V
N
tn 0tn0
o c ZCC V V
0m
0LD
'0KCL
0nl
e0
e cntOl COtotD e0LD Y
ID0V
m 2'E
4
CotfJ«0
co
Ztn
m co m
) ) N0 0 ~m'0e 0 0tn 2nf
Ill
ee0e 0
IN N
NmDl
(0 em o eCID 0
CL' CV c
nl no tn
tne oCo a (0
COLACl
)Ctn
c m
m)O,m0 eN nl
toE0 Ole
N ~N NIA
ICtl0
ltl
E =tD jm0V cm0 0
V0 01
ODnlZ CL
IO
C
0C0Q.
Cfl
0 C
Dl
I/I
R9LA CD
m
VID
ttlQ
ID
ID e
OLA
NN
ECDf
ID
V «Cnl m
LN )ttle tnm c
ID
cnLA
'cc
nl tn
0ID
CL
cn co co co co co of co cn
Cl
Q
mIA me
01N CL
mEZ
Etn 0
mnl '0
00mCg L
Ntnc '00 0ID 0
CL 0eeCQ
e'0 tnm
IZlnl'0
CC0
ofto
0 Cl
CD 0C
OL 0'0m 25Q
CD
C0 (00
tn
IA(o
ClQ
O. '0(0 0
em o
cn
EE0V
Etn
~C
n7
I0N'0C
0N
ODN0ICO'0I0Ol
ClOlXOl
tO
O0o.Ol0IOl
40Ol
CO
CSC w
EE ol
~ Zl
p l'V
Ol
OlCO
I0
OD
C 0Ol
Ol
CLo mI
OlCU
l- 0
ID
0'00 ~
00—0 CtOl0 0
Ol0
CI
CD o0ttl OD00I0 04- 00C
N00
NZ0 CC
0 QJ
0Q.
CO
NE 00
m000"0 00 ~Ol
ODCQ0
N OD
0 OtOl lllOl~
Ol
2 SIO0 CC
ill OlOlc~0
Dt m
ZCD
CBDCDzCDCD
0NCO
I-
COl'0Ol
COl
OI
Ol
Ol
Ol
CDCCO
tD
Ol)0CO
0IDNN
0N
0o.
CDCCD
NE
Ol
TO0Ol
0Ol
ID
CJOl
CD
-OS ttt8 a.
illg C!c CCt- 0
C0Ctl .—0 Ol» 0Cm Eg Em C
Nol m0 0'-'> V0 m
QOfc>00 OlDC
CD Q~CD 0
N 6 OE
T3ICI C DD
CO CD
IOO M ID
0—5 0I 0'O000
OL
S CL
ttl0
0S 0Ol CCD
0 DN CO
N tD0.0tO $oom
0g0 0 tOCOOl CO
0 DLS OlC CL CLKm p»0 Nm+0 ox
CO
gE E4 0
pm DLSOltl OCSOON
m 0m 0 no0
oem0 C yWN 0 0 00
Z.CO N N0 CO
CD OlCLOD +p m
0:OON
DONE AND EXECUTED this 18 day of January, 2017 by a majority of ttlle PiglkaG s'0rIB IIIBoard.
Chairman, Bradley C. Lambert
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF RUSSELL
Acknowledged on this &day ofWirlun rvI, 2~0, personally before me a notary publicin and for the Commonwealth of Virginia, appeared Bradley C. Lambert, being duly sworn diddepose and say that he is the Chairman of the Virginia Gas and Oil Board, that he executedthe same and was authorized to do so. ~KSIj ""+I'.."„'„'„.'.i"":,
*:MY CQMMISSIQN . *-My Commission expires: July 31, 2017
DONE AND PERFORMED this 19 day of January, 2017 by Order of the Virginia Gas ancfO/PALTHBoard. IIIIIII
Rick CooperPrincipal Executive to thestaff, Virginia Gas and Oil Board
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF RUSSELL
Acknowledged on this ~ay ofZcÃEII2m, LO/7 personally before me a notary publicin and for the Commonwealth of Virginia, ay@eared Rick Cooper, being duly sworn diddepose and say that he is the Principal Executive to the staff of the Virginia Gas and OilBoard, that he executed the same and was authorized to do so.
My Commission expires: July 31, 2017
Sarah JesseeIGjlmer, Notary Public262946
IIIIIIIIIIII
R„r.'QTARY ''. c~PUBLIC
REG. 4262246: p--*:MY CQMIMISSIQN
EXPIRES
",,+EALTH QElll lllliiii
Page Number 5.
BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD
PETITIONER: CNX Gas Company LLC DIVISION OF GAS AND OIL
DOCKET NO: VGOB 00-1017-0826-03
RELIEF SOUGHT: (1) DISBURSENIENT FROM ESCROW REGARDING TRACT(S) 2, A portion of 3 (2) AND
AUTHORIZATION FOR DIRECT PAYMENT OF ROYALTIES {3)AND DISMISSAL OF COAL OWNERSPURSUANT TO CODE OF VIRGINIA SECTION 45.1-361.22:2.
HEARING DATE: January 17, 2017
DRILLING UNIT: EE24
BUCHANAN COUNTY VIRGINIA
PETITION FOR ORDER OF DISBURSEMENT OF ESCROW FUNDS
1.Petitioner and its counsel
Petitioner is CNX Gas Company I.LC, PO Box 570, Pounding Mill, VA 24637, {276)596-5075.Petitioner's counsel is Mark A. Swartz, Hillard & Swartz, LLP, 122 Capital Street, Suite 201,Charleston, WV 25301.
2. Relief Sought
1) the disbursement of escrowed funds heretofore deposited with the Board's Escrow Agent(s)attributable to Tract(s) 2 6 portion of 3 as depicted upon the annexed Table; and (2) authorizationto begin paying royalties directly to Rockport Oil 8 Gas LLC, Chisos Ltd, CNX Gas CompanyLLC, Mary L. Clevinger, Steven Randall Boyd, Lloyd Cook, Samantha Levine, Peggy CoreneTiller, Lester Dale Boyd, Pauline Baldwin, Jody Baldwin, Robert Lee Greenwood, Sr., MargaretAnn Shipley, Rodney Boyd, Helen Viola Coleman, Velva Marie Charles.
3. Legal Authority
Va. Code Ann. IJ 45.1-361.1et seq., 4 VAC 25-160-140., and relevant Virginia Gas and Oil
Board Orders ("Board") heretofore promulgated pursuant to law.
4. Type of Well(s)
Coalbed Methane
5. Factual basis for relief requested
Page Number 6.
a. Rockport Oil & Gas LLC, Chisos Ltd and CNX Gas Company LLC, have entered into royaltysplit agreement(s). Said royalty split agreement(s) allow the Applicant and Designated Operatorto pay royalties directly to the persons identified in Exhibit EE.b. Mary L. Clevinger, Steven Randall Boyd, Lloyd Cook, Samantha Levine, Peggy Corene Tiller,Lester Dale Boyd, Pauline Baldwin, Jody Baldwin, Robert Lee Greenwood, Sr., Margaret Ann
Shipley, Rodney Boyd are the gas claimants in Tract(s) 3. As such, Mary L. Clevinger, StevenRandall Boyd, Lloyd Cook, Samantha Levine, Peggy Corene Tiller, Lester Dale Boyd, PaulineBaldwin, Jody Baldwin, Robert Lee Greenwood, Sr., Margaret Ann Shipley, Rodney Boyd, HelenViola Coleman, Velva Marie Charles are entitled to 100% of the CBM royalties attributable to theirgas claims that are now in escrow and as may be hereafter payable. See Va. Code Ann. rJ 45.1-36'l.22:2.A.c. That CNX Gas Company LLC has previously given the notice(s) required by g 45.1-361.22:2.Ato all conflicting coal claimants identified in the above referenced pooling order and any
supplemental orders pertaining thereto.d. That when the Board granted Petitioner's Miscellaneous Petition in VGOB 08-0318-2163-01, it
dismissed the coal claimant Coal Creek Coal Company as a Respondent to these proceedings.Accordingly Coal Creek Coal Company was not provided notice under tJ 45.1-381.22of thehearing set on this Petition.e. That a detailed accounting in accordance with the applicable provisions of tJ 45.1-361.22issubmitted herewith and identified as Exhibit J.f. That an Exhibit identified as Table 1 is annexed hereto, and it specifies how the disbursement(s) is to be calculated and paid by the escrow agent.g. That Va. Code Ann. 1J 45.1-361.22:2.A.further provides that the operator shall pay suchroyalties as may hereafter be payable directly to the gas claimant CNX Gas Company LLC, MaryL. Clevinger, Steven Randall Boyd, Uoyd Cook, Samantha Levine, Peggy Corene Tiller, LesterDale Boyd, Pauline Baldwin, Jody Baldwin, Robert Lee Greenwood, Sr., Margaret Ann Shipley,Rodney Boyd, Helen Viola Coleman, Velva Marie Charles and shall not escrow same. SeeExhibit EE annexed hereto.
6.Attestation
The foregoing Petition to the bast of my knowledge, information, and belief is true and correct.
Page Number 7.
1700000173
11
N 310,837.6'IE 986.499.94
/
/
/
/N 310,766.20E 988,366.79
/f
f
l.f
f
l
\
/
//
//
d f
f
f ~~ / C8M-PGP~E24p4
(/ f /
'~Jf
i80 ACRE UNIT
Il
'fI
fI
I
I 0I
f
fI 'l
I
/// N 308,970.00/
E 986.431.04/
//
/
N 308.898.47E 968,297.95
EXHIBIT A
OAKWOOD F IELD UNIT EE-24FORCE POOLING
VGOB-00-1017-0 ~rCA'
C ny Pocahontos Gas Pcrtnershic Weli Horne ond Nurber IJNIT EE24Coupon/d oca
E I suction Quodren01e. - Keen.aicun'tainTroct No.
Buchcnon Gis'tl ict Hurricane 5caier
d' Elan di did\ y
Page Number g.
1700VfJO>73
POCAHONTAS GAS PARTNERSHIPUNiT EE-24
Tract Identifications
Buckhom Coal Mining - Tr. 2 - FeeConsolidation Coal Company- Below Tiller coal LesseePsrmac, Inc. - Tiller and above coal LesseePocahontas Gas Partnership - Oil & Gas LesseePocahontas Gas Partnership - CBM Lmsee16,39 acres 20.48750%
Hugh MacRae Land Trust- TR 9 - CoalConsolidation Coal Company - Below Tiller coal LesseePerrnac, Inc. - Tiller and above coal LesseePocahontas Gas Partnership - CBM LesseePocahontas Gas Partnership - Oi1 8 Gas LesseeJohn I. Hale Heirs - Oil & GasPerm ac Inc. - Surface0.07 acres
Hugh MacRae Land Trust- TR 9 - CoalConsolidation Coal Company - Below Tiller coal LesseePennac, Inc. - Tiller and above coal i.esseePccahontas Gas Partnership - CBM LesseePocahontas Gas Partnership - Oil 8 Gas LesseeEllen Fletcher - Oil 8 Gas (67.5%)Laura Boyd Heirs, Devisees, Successors or Assigns- Oil & Gas {12.5%)Floyd Jur,ior Blankenship - Surface61.81 acres 77.26250%
Ellen Fletcher - Coal, Oil 8 Gas (87,5%)Laura Boyd Heirs, Devisees;Successors or Assigns —Oil 8 Gas (12.5%)Floyd Junior B!ankenship - Surface0.63 acres 1.03750%
Hugh MacRae Land Trust - TR 9- CoalConsolidation Coal Company- Below Tiller coal LesseePermac, inc. - Tiller and above coal LesseePocahontas Gas Partnership - CBM LesseeCarlos Hale, Heirs - Surface, Oi! & Gas0,90 acres 1.12500%
cage 1 gf13/00
Page Number 9.
Exhibit EUnit EE<4
Docket ¹V GOB 4I 0-10174I8264I 3Ust of Respondents In escrow
Net AcresIn Unit
IntsrestlnUnit
Tract ¹3-61.81acres
COAL OWNERSHIP
(1) Hugh MacRae Land Trust Tr. 9c/o Gum p, Strauss, Akin LLP1 Bryant Park, Flaor41New York, NY 10036-6T15
61.81 acres 77.2625'yo Olsmlsssof wlm
priorfwfleon
By As ignm ant and Bill of Sale (Gas lease royalty/, HML 7devised all ofi is right, title and interest (other than "Excluded Assets I toTorch Energy Advisors inc. effective September 4, 1991and recorded in Buchanan County under DB474/PG384.
Torch Oil & Gas Companyc/o Sue Ann Craddock670 Dona Ana Roadt SWDeming, New Mexico 88030
Effectiv 2/1/11, Torch Orl 8 Gas Company assigned a 2% ORRI to SAC Investments. L.P.
Effective 3/31/14. Tomb Oi I & Gas Company et aL assigned and convoyed 10/o ol its right, tile and interest tc Rockpor! Oif &Gas, L LC. In addition, Torch Oil & Gas Company, ei al. assigned and conveyed thc remaining 90% ofits right, tale andandinteresl to Chinos, Ltd.
Rackport Oil 8 Gas L.L.C.PO Box 847Houston, TX 77001
olsmtssod wife
pdor poedon
Chisos, LTD670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030
a/aniseed wife
pdor peaaorl
OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP
EE & E Fletcher, Inc. (Ellen Fletcher), et al.
(2) Laura Hale Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns, et al. (1/Bint 1
61.81 acres
7.73 scl'es1/8 of 61.81acres
77.2625%
g.8576%
(a) Marion Rendew Boyd Sr. Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
Lfye Estate Exdngulshed
(a.1) Ardue Guy Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
yyg/A/Edevft not received for tire respondents listed below
(a.1.1.4) James Howard BoydPO Box 236Davenport, VA 24239
0.0585 acres1/1056 af 61.81acres
0.0732yo
(a.1.1.9) Charles Marion Boyd1054 Wood Hollow RdVansant, VA 24656
0.0585 acres1/1056 of 61.81acres
0 0732oA
(a.1.1.11) David Gene BoydPO Box54Vansant, VA 24656
0.0585 aares1/1056 of 61.81acres
0.0732ok
(a.2) Mary Josephine Boyd Cook Heirs, Devisees,Sucaessors or Assigns
(a.2.1) Artie Cook Pre-deceased
Page 1 of 3 10/17/2016
Page Number 10.
Exhibit EUnit EEL%
Docket 8VGOB4IO-1 017-08264I3List of Respondents In escrow
Net Acresin Unit
Interest in
Unit
(a.2.'I.2) Edward Cook Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns(documentation pending 3/29/2016)
(a.2.1.2.1) Nancy Lee Cook1032 Breckenridge StFemdale, Ml 48220
(a.2.1.3) Willard W. & Betty S. Cook
(a.2.1.3.2) Greg Cook6067 Yorkshire StLas Vegas, NV 89156
(a.2.1.4) Ercil Darius Cook, Sr
(a.2.'1.4.1) Mark D. Cook Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(documenlalfon pending 3I29/201 6)
(a.2.1.4.1.1) Ursula M. CruzPO Box 11483Yigo, Guam 96929
0.1756 acies1/352 of 61.81acres
Conveyed by deed of gin 090001089 on 3/20/2009
0.0878 acres1/704 of 61.81acres
Prerifeceaaed
0.0585 acres'I/1056 of 61.81acres
0.0585 acres'I/1056 of 61.81acres
0 2195o%%d
0 1097olo
0.0732v%%d
0.0732r%%d
(aJL1.4.1.2) Ercil D. Cook, Jr410 Tai Gigao RdAgana Heights, Guam 96910
0.0585 acres1/1056 of 81.81acres
0.0732'/o
(a.6) Leah Vemie Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(a.6.2) Opal Mattie Hunt Conveyed to James Curtis Baldwin by deed 7/15/201 5 Instr. 151208
(a.6%&1) James Curtis Baldwin
PO Box 99SVansant, VA 24656
0.0585 acres1/1056 of 61.81acres
0 0732o%
(a.6.4) Leah Mae Mullins Conveyed to James Curds Bs/dw/n by deed 4/I f/2008 Instr. 08-1469
(a.6.4.1) James Curbs Baldwin
PO Box 998Vansant, VA 24656
(a.6.6) Laura Virginia Manier
4022 Leemaster DrVansant, VA 24658
(a.6.10) Bradley Dean Baldwin Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns(documentation pending)
0.0585 acres1/1056 of 61.81acres
O.O585 acres1/1056 of 61.81acres
0,0585 acres1/1056 of 61.81acres
0.0732yv
0.0732r%%d
0 0732o%%d
(a.6.10.1) Bryan D. Baldwin4122 Clifton Glendale RdSpartanburg, SC 29307
(a.6.10.2) Amber Justus634 Willoughby RdBeech Blulf, TN 38313
(a.6.'I1) James Curtis Baldwin
PO Box 998Vansant, VA 24656
0.05fkn acres1/1056 of 61.S1acres
0 0732o%%d
(a.6.'l2) Samuel Marcus Baldwin, II Conveyed fo James Curtis Baldwin by deed 3/3/08 Instr. 08-1009
Page 2 of 3 10/17/2016
Page Number 11.
Exhibit E
UnitEE44Docket ¹VGOBaio-1 017-0626-03List of Respondents In escrow
Net Acresin Unit
1 )00000173
Interest in
Unit
(a.6.12.1)James Curtis BaldwinPO Box 998Vansant, VA 24656
0.0195 acres1/3168 of 61.81acres
0.0244%
(a.8) Ada Nell Stiltner Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(e.8.1) Patricia G. Rice366 Grace StPounding Mill, VA 24637
(a.8.2) Teresa Church917 Russell Fork River Rd.Haysi, VA 24256
(a.8.3) Shelia Miller
2750 Cedar Falls WaySeviervige, TN 37862
0.1171 acres1/528 of 61.81 acres
0.1171 acres1/528 of 61.81acres
0.1171acres1/528 of 61.81acres
0.1463%
0.1463%
0 1463%
(a.8.4) Vickie Viers1637 Dicks Branch RdVansant, VA 24656
(a.8.5) Teny Boyd1115Funnel RdVansant, VA 24656
0.1171acres1/528 of 61.81acres
0.1171 acres1/528 of 61.81acres
0.1463%
0.1463%
(a.8.6) Wayne Stiltner1018 Sanford DrVsnsant, VA 24656
0.1171 acres1/528 of 61.81acres
0.1463%
TOTAL REMA/NING /N ESCROyyrAcres
Percentage1.6291
2.0364v/o
Page 3 of 3 10/17/2016
Page Number 12.
Exhibit EEUnit EE-24
Docket gYGOB-00-1017-08264I3List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements/Court Drders/HB2058
17000(JO<'73
Net AcresIn Unit
Interest In
UnitPercent
of Escrow
3)Stpt ¹2- 0 07 santa
COAL OWNERSHIP
(1) Hugh MacRae Land Trust Tr 17c/o Dump, Strauss, Akin LLP1 Bryant Park, Floor 41New York, NY 100364)715
0.07 acres 0.0875% nfa
By Assignment and Bill of Safe (Gas lease roysay), HMLT devised ell of hs right. title end interest (other than "Excluded Assets")Torch Energy Advisors inc. effective September 4. 1991snd recorded in Buchanan County under DBn 74 /PG384
Torch Oil & Gas Companyc/o Sue Ann Cradd ock670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030
Effecfive 2/1/11, Torch Oil 8 Gas Company assigned s 2% ORRI to SAC Investments, L.P.
Effeclive 3/3'I/14, Torch Oil & Gas Company et el assigned snd conveyed 10% of Ils right, title end interest to Rockpon C
Ges, L.L.C. In additron, Torch Oil & Gss Company. et al. assigned end conveyed the remaining 90% ofits right, title andendinterest to Crises, Ltd.
Rockport Oil & Gas L.L.C.PO Box 847Houston, TX 77001
0.0070 acres1/10 of 0.07 acres
0 0088% 0.0238% - 50%(Royalty Split}
Chisos, LTD670 Dona Ana Road SW
Darning, New Mexico 88030
OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP
CNX Gas Company LLC
(1) CNX Gss Company LLCPO Box 643830Pittsburgh, PA 15264G830(Previously John i. Hale Heirs)
(2) CNX Gas Company LLC
PO Box 643830Pittsburgh, PA 15264-3830(Previously Pocahontas Gas Partnership)
0.0630 acres9/1 0 ot 0.07 acres
0.07 acres
0.0162 acres76/329 of 0.07 acres
0.05 acres253/329 of 0.07 acres
0.0788% 0,2139 /e 50%(Royalty Split)
0.0875%
0.0202% 0.2377% - 50%(Royalty Split)
0.0673% n/a
Ac I'es
Percent0.0700
0.0875%
Tyact¹3=61.81 acres
COAL OWNERSHIP
(1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.gc/o Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP1 Bryant Park, Floor 41New York, NY 100364I715
61.81 acres 77.2625% n/a
By Assignmenr and Bill of sale (Gss lease royally), HMLT devised all of Its right, title and interest /other than "Excluded A sects 7Torch Energy Advisors Inc. effective September 4, 1991 snd recorded in Buchanan County under DB474 / pG384.
Page 1 of 7 10I17/2016
Page Number 13.
Exhibit EEUnit EE-24
Docket N/GO BJI0-1017-88284I3List of Respondents with Royalty Split AgreementslCaurt Orders/H 82058
17000(J0178
Net Acresin Unit
Interest In
UnitPercent
of Escrow
Torch Oil & Gas Companyc/o Sue Ann Ciaddock670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030
Effective 2/7/71. Torch Oil & Gas Company assigned a 2% ORRI to SAC lnvestmsnts, L.P.
Effective 3/31/74, Torch Cil & Gas Company, et sl. assigned and conveyed 70% ofits right, title and interest tc Rockport 0Gas, L.L.C. ln addlhon, Torch OV & Gas Company, st sl. assigned and conveyed the remaining 90% cf its right, title andand lntsresf to Ch/sos, Ltd.
Rockport Oil & Gas L.L.C.PO Box 847Houston, TX 77001
Chisos, LTD670 DonaAna Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030
OIL & GAS OWNERSHip
EE & E Fletcher, Inc., et al.
(1) EE & E Fletcher, Inc.Na Eddie Flstaher3652 Garden Creek RoadRows, VA 24646/previously Ellen Fletcher)
(2) Laura Hale Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns, et al. (1/Bint)
61.81 acres
54.08 acres7/8 af 61.81acres
7.73 acres1/8 of 61.81acres
77.2625%
67.6047% nls
9,6578% nla
(a) Marian Rendew Boyd Sr. Heirs, Devisees,Sucaessors or Assigns
(a.'I) Ardue Guy Boyd Heirs, Devisees.Successors ai'sslgtls
(a.1.1) Jane Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(a.1.1.1) Marshall Boyd3421 Highgate Rd
Raleigh, NC 27603
(a.1.1.2) Thslma Jane Laster1012 Destiny RdBig Rack, VA 24603
(a.1.1.3) Farrell Boyd3117 Leemester DrVansant, VA 24656
(a.1.1.5) Ella Mae Boyd
(a.1.1.6) Anna Lou Colley3631 Murphy RdVansant, VA 24656
Liye Estate Exdngulshed
0.0585 acres1/1056 of 61.81acres
0.0585 acres1/1056 af 61.81acres
0.0585 acres1/1056 of 61.81acres
Pre-Deceased - no issue
0.0585 acres1l1056 of 61.81acres
0.0732% n/a
0.0732% nla
0.0732% n/a
0.0732r/o n/e
(a.1.1.7) Irene Boyd Clevinger Prs-Deceased - no issue
(a.'l.1.7.1) Robert Franklin Clevinger Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
Page 2 of 7 10/1 7/2016
Page Number 14.
Exhibit EEUnit EE-24
Docket ¹VGOB-00-1017.0826¹ISList of Responderrts with Royalty Split Agreements/Court Orders/HB2058
$ 8/00900lV8
(a.1.'I.7.1.'I) Mary L Clevinger7691 Lovers Gep Rd
Vansant, VA 24656
Net Acresin Unit
0.0293 acres1/2112 of 61.81acres
Interest In
Unit
0.0366%
Percentof Escrow
Q.s604%HB2058
(a.t.t.72) Donald Clevinger1365 Dicks Branch RdVansant, VA 24656
(e.1.1.8) Estel Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
0.0293 acres1/2112 of 61.81acres
0.0366%
(s.1.1.8.1) Cstherine Boyd116Ville Ln
Taylorsville, NC 28681
O.Q585 acres 0.0732% nla1/1D56 of 61.81acres
(a.1.'l.10) William Preston Boyd1192Willie RdVansant. VA 24656
O.O585 acres1/1056 of St Jtt acres
0.0732% nla
(a.1.1.'l2) Steven Rsndall Boyd6211 Leemaster DrVsnssnt,VA 24656
O.DS85 acres1/1056 of 61.81acres
0.0732% 1.7209'leH 82058
(a.1.1.13) Robert Guy Boyd1082 Ardue 8 Jane Rd
Vanssnt, VA 24656
O.OSSS sores1/1056 af 61.81acres
0 0732%
(a.2) Mary Josephine Boyd Cook Heirs, Deviseas,Successors or Assigns
(a.2.1) Artie Caok
(a.2.1.1) Llayd Cook1Q31 Bakersfield Dr
Grundy, VA 24614
Pre<scanned
0.1756 acres1/352 of 61.81acres
0 2195% 5.1626%HB2058
(a.2AI.3) Willard W. 8 Betty S.Cook Conveyed by deed ofgia 090001089 an 3/20/2009
(a.2.1.3.1) Samantha Levine6228 E.Owens Ave
Las Vegas, NV 89110
(a.3) Charles Milton Boyd Heirs, Deviance,Successors or Assigns
(a.3.1) Annie Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
0.0878 acresI/704 of 7.73acres
OAI097'ys 2.5813%HB2058
(a.3.1.1) Helen vials coleman4522 Lovers Gap RdVansant, VA 24656
(a.3.1.2) Betty Geneva Perkins5632 Leemaster Rd
Vansant, VA 24655
0.117'I acres1/528 of 61.81acres
0.117'I nares1/528 of 61.8'I acres
0.1463%
0 1463%
3A418%HB20 58
(a.3.'l.3) Peggy Corene Tiller
3742 Leemaster Rd
Vansant. VA 24656
(a.3.1.4) Joan B.Boyd4055 Leemaster RdVansant, VA 24656
0.1171 acres1/528 af 61.81acres
0.1171acres1/528 of 61.81acres
Page 3 of 7
0.1463% 3A418%HB2058
0.1463% n/a
10/17/2016
Page Number 15.
Exhibit EEUnit EE-24
Docket 6VG 0B-00-1017-08264I3List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements/Court Orders/HB2058
1200000i'7'd
Net AcresIn Unit
Interestin PercentUnit of Escrow
(a.3.1.5) Barbara Gail Evans1685 Peach Grove AveHamsonburg, VA 22801
(a.3.1.6) Laster Dale Boyd559 Forest Kills Dr
Pounding Mill, VA 24637
0.1171acres1/528 of 61.81acres
0.1171acres1/528 of 61.81acres
0.1463% n/a
D 1463o/o 3A418%HB2058
(a.4} Myrtle Boyd Baldwin (aka Laura}
(a.4.'I) James D. RasnakePO Box 1914Honaker, VA 24260
Conveyed lc James D. Rasnake by deed 2/f/2001 DB519/446
0.7024 acres 0.8780% n/e'I/88 of 61.81acres
(m5) Walter Francis Boyd
(a.5.1) James D. RasnakePO Box 'I914Honaker, VA 24260
Conveyed/o James D. Roanoke bydeed 1/22/2001 DB519/157
0.7024 acres 0.8780% n/a
1/88 of 6'l.81 acres
(a.6) Leah Vernie Boyd Heim, Devisees.Successors or Assigns
(a.6.1) Valve Marie Charles2066 Watkins St
Grundy, VA 24614
(a.6.3}Pauline Baldwin
5931 Berkshire Ct.Alexandria, VA 22303
O.OS8S acresI/1056 of 61.8t acres
0.0585 acres1/1056 of 61.81acres
0.0732'Yo
0.0732%o
1.7209%HB2058
1.7209%HB2058
(a.8.5) Beulah Diane Boyd1124 Beulah Land RdVansant, VA 24656
(a.6,7) Henry Nathan Baldwin, Jr.403 Surface DrVansant, VA 24656
0.0585 acres1/1056 of 61.81acres
0.058S acres1/'f056 of 61.81acres
0.0732%
0.0732% n/a
(a.8.8) Judy Elixabeth HagyPO Box 104Vansant, VA 24656
0.0585 acres1/1058 of 6'I.81 acres
0.0732%
(a.6.9) Gary Raymond Baldwin HeirsDevisees, Successors or Assigns
(a.6.9.1) Mary Margaret Baldwin (2nd wife) Conveyed lo Jody Brenl Baldwin by deed 3/8/08 Instr. 08-878
(a.6.9.1.1)Jody Baldwin
341 Pennsylvania Ave
Salem, VA 24153
0.0195 acres1/3168 of 61.81acres
0.0244% 0.5736'YH8 2058
(a.6.9.2) Jody Baldwin
341 Pennsylvania Ave
Salem, VA 24153
0.0390 acres1/1584 of 61.81acres
0.0488'Yo 1.1473%HB2058
(a.6.13) Brandon Scott Baldwin
(a.6.13.1)CNX Gas Company LLCAttn: Property Tax
4000 Brownsviile RdSouth Park, PA 15129.9545
Conveyed fo CNX Gas Company LLC Oy deed 9/4'07 Instr. 07-3762
0.019Sacres 0.0244% n/a1/3168 of 61.81acres
Page 4 of 7 10/17/2016
Page Number 16.
Exhlbft EEUnit EE-24
Docket gVGOBJIO-1017-08264I3List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements/Court Orders/H B2058
17001)l00l'73
Met AcresIn Unit
InterestlnUnit
Percentof Escr'ow
(a.6XI4) Samantha Lash Baldwm Conveyed /o Cr/X Ges Company LLC by deed 9/4/07 /ns/r. 07-3761
(a.6.14.1)CNX Gas Company LLCAttn: Property Tax4000 Brownsville RdSouth Park, PA 15129.9545
(a.y) Lizzie Trula Greenwood Heirs, Dsvisees,Successors or Assigns
(a.7.1) Robert Lee Greenwood1216Woodland CtHamstead, MD 21074
(a.7.2) Margaret Ann Shipley4605 Brookview Dr
Hamstead, MD 21074
0.0195acres1/3168 of 61.81acres
0.3512 acres'I/1T6 of61.81 acres
0.3512 acresI/1T6 of 61.81acres
0.0244% n/s
0.4390% 10.3253%HB20 58
0.4390% 10.3253%HB2058
(a.g) Madon Rendue Boyd, Jr. Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(s.9.1) Likie Martha Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(a.9.1.1)Sandra Boyd Street19117 Bethel RdAbingdon, VA 24211
0.1756 acres 0,2195% n/a1/352 of 61.81acres
(a.9.1.2) Larry ireson BoydPO Box 265
Vansant, VA 24656
0.1756 acres1/352 of 61.81acres
0.2195% n/e
(a.9.1.3)Sherry Boyd StacyP.O. Box 980
Vansant, VA 24656
(a.9.1.4) Rodney Boyd1042 Sugar Bend Rd
Grundy, VA 24614
(a.10) Ireson Boyd Heirs. Devisees,Successors or Assigns
0.1756 acres1/352 of 61.81acres
0.1756 acres1/352 of 61.81acres
02195% n/a
0.2195% 5.1626%HB2058
(a.10.1) Hassie C. Boyd
(a.'I0.'l.1) James D. RasnakePO Box 19'l4Honaker, VA 24260
Conveyed fo James D. Resnske by deed 3/6/01 in DB 520/576
0.7024 acres 0.8780% n/a1/88 of61.81acres
(a.10.2) Marcus 8 Joyce Boyd Conveyed Io James D. Rssnske by deed 3/6/01 in DB 520/575
(a.10JL1) James D. RasnakePO Box 1914Honaker. VA 24260
O.T024 acresI/88 of 61.81acres
0.8780% n/a
Acres 60.1809Percent 75.2261'Ys
Page 5 of 7 10/17/2016
Page Number 17.
Exhibit EEUnit EE-24
Docket gu GO BJI0-I0174I8264I3List of Respondents with Royalty Splrt Agreements/Court Orders/H B2058
1'700000173
Net Acresin Unit
Interest in
UnitPercent
of Escrow
Tract 85 = 0.90acres
COAL OWNERSHIP
(1) Hugh MacRae Land Trust Tr. 9r/o Dump, Strauss, Akin LLP1 Bryant Park, Floor 41New York, NY 100364I715
0.90 acres I Al 25%
By Assignment end Bill of Sale (Gss lease myslty), HMLT devised ell ofih right„ title and interest /other than "Excluded Assets")Torch Energy Advisors Inc, effective September 4, 1991 end recorded in Buchanan County under DS474/PG384.
Torch Oil 3 Gas Companydo Sue Ann Craddock670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030
Effective 2/1/11, Torch Oil 8 Gas Company assigned 4 2% ORRI to SAC Investments. L.P.
Et/ective 3/31/14, Torch Orl 8 Gas Company et sl assigned and conveyed 10% ofiis right, title and interest to Rockport C
Gas, L L 0, in addition, Torch Oil 5 Gas Company et el assigned and conveyed the remaining 90/ ofits right, title and
and interest to Chisos, Ltd.
Rockport Oil & Gas L.L.C.PO Box 847Houston, TX 7700'I
Chisos, LTD670 Dona Ans Road SW
Darning, New Mexico 88030
DIL 8 GAS OWNERSHIP
A/Edev/t from Torch Oil 8 Gas Co., dated August 5, 2015 stating they make no claim to ihe CBM due to the current stateTire owners listed below are ptandffs in case noi 1:10ev59
(1) Jeffery C. Hale, et al
(ska Canoe Henry Hale Heirs)
0.90 acres 1.1250%
(a) Lorene Hale Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns (1/3)
Psr will, her interestis to be divided equally among her 3 children. (OOD 10/.
(a.1) Pamela Jo Keene3707 Garden Creek RoadRows, VA 24646
0.10 acres1/9 of 0.90 acres
0.1250% n/a -100%
(a.2) Jamie Hen/7 Hale1901 Lum Hollow RoadHaysi, VA 24256
0.10 acres1/9 of 0.90 acres
0 1250% ir/s -100%
(s.3) Jelfery Carlos Hale1926Zacks Fork RoadLenoir, NC 28645
0.10 acres1/9 of 0.90 acres
0.'l250%
(h) Pamela Jo Keene3707 Garden Creek RoadRows, VA 24646
(c) Jamie Henry Hale1901 Lum Hallow RoadHaysi, VA 242S6
0.20 acres2/9 of 0.90 acres
0.20 acres2/9 of 0.90acres
0.2500v/o n/a
0,2500% n/a -100%
Page 6 of 7 10/17/2016
Page Number 18.
Exhibit EEUnit EE-24
Docket SVGOB-00-1017-0826-03List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements/Court Orders/HB2058
1V00000>'73
Net Acresin Unit
Interest In
UnitPercent
of Escrow
(d) Jeffsry Cados Hale1926 Zacks Fork RoadLenoir, NC 28645
0.20 acres 02500%2l9 of 080 acres
Acres 0.9000Percent 1.'l250%
TOTAL CONFL/CTS RESOLVEDAcres 61.1509
Percentage 784386%
Dt"I/g'kc '\II NJ/ I ED, Dl I„f/v
Page 7of7 10/17/2016
Page Number 19.