1 Measuring Profitable Safety Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process Safety Session ID #:...

14
1 Measuring Profitable Safety Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process Safety Session ID #: PBTR112 Patrick Fisher, EIT ACM Facility Safety 11/09/11

Transcript of 1 Measuring Profitable Safety Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process Safety Session ID #:...

Page 1: 1 Measuring Profitable Safety Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process Safety Session ID #: PBTR112 Patrick Fisher, EIT ACM Facility Safety 11/09/11.

1

Measuring Profitable Safety

Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process SafetySession ID #: PBTR112

Patrick Fisher, EITACM Facility Safety

11/09/11

Page 2: 1 Measuring Profitable Safety Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process Safety Session ID #: PBTR112 Patrick Fisher, EIT ACM Facility Safety 11/09/11.

2

We are gamblers.

Page 3: 1 Measuring Profitable Safety Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process Safety Session ID #: PBTR112 Patrick Fisher, EIT ACM Facility Safety 11/09/11.

3

X X=

Page 4: 1 Measuring Profitable Safety Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process Safety Session ID #: PBTR112 Patrick Fisher, EIT ACM Facility Safety 11/09/11.

4

Page 5: 1 Measuring Profitable Safety Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process Safety Session ID #: PBTR112 Patrick Fisher, EIT ACM Facility Safety 11/09/11.

5

Page 6: 1 Measuring Profitable Safety Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process Safety Session ID #: PBTR112 Patrick Fisher, EIT ACM Facility Safety 11/09/11.

6

Page 7: 1 Measuring Profitable Safety Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process Safety Session ID #: PBTR112 Patrick Fisher, EIT ACM Facility Safety 11/09/11.

7

Risk Exposure

Risk Exposure Factor

Safeguard Return on Investment

Safeguard Usage Factor

Detect

Decide

Solutions?

Page 8: 1 Measuring Profitable Safety Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process Safety Session ID #: PBTR112 Patrick Fisher, EIT ACM Facility Safety 11/09/11.

8

Data from the HAZOP

Can be used in real time

Page 9: 1 Measuring Profitable Safety Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process Safety Session ID #: PBTR112 Patrick Fisher, EIT ACM Facility Safety 11/09/11.

9

Total Risk ExposureThe “Heartbeat”

Page 10: 1 Measuring Profitable Safety Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process Safety Session ID #: PBTR112 Patrick Fisher, EIT ACM Facility Safety 11/09/11.

10

Risk Exposure FactorThe “Blood Pressure”

Organization Goal

Organization Average

After HAZOPAfter LOPA

Industry Average

After Recommendations

Before Analysis

Page 11: 1 Measuring Profitable Safety Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process Safety Session ID #: PBTR112 Patrick Fisher, EIT ACM Facility Safety 11/09/11.

11

Safety ROIThe “Personal Trainer”

Page 12: 1 Measuring Profitable Safety Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process Safety Session ID #: PBTR112 Patrick Fisher, EIT ACM Facility Safety 11/09/11.

12

$$$Safeguard Usage Factor

The “Nutritionist”

=

Page 13: 1 Measuring Profitable Safety Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process Safety Session ID #: PBTR112 Patrick Fisher, EIT ACM Facility Safety 11/09/11.

13

Profitable Safety Analysis

Minimum Risk Exposure Factor:(all safeguards functioning correctly)

0.48

Current Risk Exposure Factor: 0.52

History

Organization Goal

Organization Average

Current REF

Minimum REF

Industry Average

Return on Investment…

Page 14: 1 Measuring Profitable Safety Session Name: Real-time Risk Exposure in Process Safety Session ID #: PBTR112 Patrick Fisher, EIT ACM Facility Safety 11/09/11.

14

Profitable Safety Analysis

Risk Exposure Factor after HAZOP: 0.57

Risk Exposure Factor after LOPA (before Recommendations):

0.51

Number of Recommended Safeguards: 7

Total Cost of All Recommended Safeguards: $1.10 million

Risk Exposure Factor after Recommendations: 0.43

Predicted Return on Investment (first year): 1450%

Organization Goal:Organization Average:

0.450.55

Industry Average: 0.60

Organization Goal

Organization Average

After HAZOP

After LOPA

Industry Average

After Recommendations