Tsigaridis, Kanakidou, Daskalakis...

Post on 05-Jun-2018

215 views 0 download

Transcript of Tsigaridis, Kanakidou, Daskalakis...

Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Maria!Kanakidou,!Nikos!Daskalakisand!the!AEROCOM!team

Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Maria!Kanakidou,!Nikos!Daskalakisand!the!AEROCOM!team

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 1

20092009

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 2

! CAM"Oslo Alf!Kirkevåg! GISS!MATRIX* Susanne!Bauer! GISS!modelE* Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Dorothy!Koch! GLOMAP** Graham!Mann! SPRINTARS! Toshi!Takemura! TM3! Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Maria!Kanakidou! TM4"ECPL* Nikos!Daskalakis,!Maria!Kanakidou! Measurements Lynn!Russell!and!many!others

*

Preliminary!results

**

Results!not!analyzed!yet

20102010

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 3

! Maria!Kanakidou,!Lazaros!Perakis,!Kostas!Tsigaridis!(TM3)

! Maria!Kanakidou,!Stelios!Myriokefalitakis,!Nikos!Daskalakis!(TM4"ECPL)

! Dorothy!Koch,!Surabi!Menon,!Kostas!Tsigaridis!(GISS!modelE,!GISS!modelE!+!MATRIX)

! AEROCOM!modelers! Alf!Kirkevåg!(CAM"Oslo)! Angela!Benedetti!(ECMWF)! Kirstie!Pringle,!Jos!Lelieveld!(EMAC)! Gabriele!Curci!(GEOS"Chem)! Shantanu!Jathar,!Peter!Adams!(GISS!II’ UBS)

! Graham!Mann!(GLOMAP)! Thomas!Diehl!(GOCART)! Toshi!Takemura!(SPRINTARS)

! Measurements! Lynn!Russell,!Ranjit!Bahadur! Jose"Luis!Jimenez,!Qi!Zhang,!Sally!Ng

! Jean!Sciare! Nikos!Mihalopoulos! Jose!Prospero !Denis!Savoie

20112011

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 4

Total!number!of!models:!27Total!number!of!models:!2727

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 5

2!more!models!are!expected:!IMPACT!(3!versions)!and!INCA

FactsFacts! Year(s)!simulated:!Mostly!2006,!but!not!always!with!2006!emissions!and/or!meteorology.

! Focus!on!surface!concentrations,!at!least!for!now.! Emissions!vary!greatly.!This!is!not!necessarily!bad.! OM/OC is!1.4 for!most!models,!but!not!all.

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 6

What!does!2006!mean?What!does!2006!mean?

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 7

1

23

45

67

891011

12131415

1617

18192021

222324252627

???

Year!other!than!2006Year!other!than!2006,!calculated!onlineYear!2006,!calculated!onlineYear!2006Not!availableUncertain

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14Meteo ??? ??? ???

FF,!BF ??? ???

BB

mPOC

trSOC

Isop

Terp

Arom

Other

15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27Meteo

FF,!BF ??? ???

BB ???

mPO

CtrSOC

Isop ???

Terp ??? ???

Arom

Other

What!does!2006!mean?What!does!2006!mean?

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 8

Primary!Organic!Matter!(POM)Primary!Organic!Matter!(POM)

! All!models!have!fossil!fuel,!biofuel!and!biomass!burning!terrestrial!sources!(tPOM).!GISS"CMU"VBS!assumes!semivolatile!tPOM.!CAM4"Oslo,!GISS"modelE!and!TM4"ECPL!also!include!marine!POM!(mPOM).! Fossil!fuel!and!biofuel:!Bond!et!al.!(2004;!2007);!Diehl!et!al.!(2008);!Lamarque!et!al.!(2010);!Dentener!et!al.!(2006);!Park!et!al.,!2003;!CIRCE.

! Biomass!burning:!GFED!(v1;!v2;!v3);!Diehl!et!al.!(2008);!Dentener!et!al.!(2006);!Lamarque!et!al.!(2010).

! Marine!sources:!CAM4"Oslo,!GISS"modelE,!TM4"ECPL.

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 9

Secondary!Organic!Matter!(SOM)Secondary!Organic!Matter!(SOM)Almost!all!models!have!some!SOM!representation:

! None:!1!model!(BCC).! trSOM:!26!models

! Non"volatile:!13!models;!SOM!is!included!in!tPOM.! A!yield!from!terpenes!emissions!(CAM4"Oslo,!CanAM"PAM,!ECHAM5"SALSA,!ECMWF"GEMS,!EMAC,!GISS"MATRIX,!GMI,!GOCART,!SPRINTARS,!TM5)

! A!yield!from!terpenes!oxidation!(GISS"TOMAS,!2!GLOMAP!versions)! Semi"volatile:!13!models;!“traditional” SOM,!trSOM.

! A!yield!from!terpenes!emissions!(CAM5"MAM3)! Fixed!3D!monthly!climatology!(HadGEM2,!climatology!from!STOCHEM)! 2"product!model!(GEOS"Chem,!GEOS"Chem"APM,!2!GISS"modelE!versions,!

IMAGES,!MPIHAM"v2,!OsloCTM2,!3!TM4"ECPL!versions)! Volatility"basis!set!(GISS"CMU"VBS)

! ntrSOM!(Glyoxal,!from!cloud!and!aerosol!water!chemistry):!4!models(IMAGES,!3!TM4"ECPL!versions)

! MSA!(from!DMS!oxidation):!9!models!(CAM4"Oslo,!GEOS"Chem"APM,!2!GISS"modelE!versions,!3!TM4"ECPL!versions,!TM5)

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 10

Mean!model!surface!distributionMean!model!surface!distribution

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 11

Median!vs.!individual!models!(1x1!grid)Median!vs.!individual!models!(1x1!grid)

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 12

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 13

Primary!Organic!Matter!(POM)Primary!Organic!Matter!(POM)

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 14

Textor!et!al.!(2006)!mean:96.6Tg!a"1

±26%(includes!19.1Tg!a"1

non"volatile!SOM)

Secondary!Organic!Matter!(SOM)Secondary!Organic!Matter!(SOM)

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 15

Possible!precursors!Isoprene,!monoterpenes!Higher!terpenes!Aromatics!Higher!alkanes,!alkenes

Dry!depositionDry!deposition

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 16

Textor!et!al.!(2006)!mean:18.6Tg!a"1

±49%

Wet!depositionWet!deposition

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 17

Textor!et!al.!(2006)!mean:86.9Tg!a"1

±32%

BurdenBurden

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 18

Textor!et!al.!(2006)!mean:1.70Tg!±27%

Aerosol!Optical!Depth!(AOD)!550nmAerosol!Optical!Depth!(AOD)!550nm

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 19

OA!life!cycleOA!life!cycle

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 20

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 21

Organic!Carbon!(OC)!– PM 2.5

Organic!Carbon!(OC)!– PM2.5

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 22

Bahadur!et!al.,!2009

Organic!Carbon!(OC)Organic!Carbon!(OC)

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 23

Pindado!et!al.,!2009Ward!et!al.,!2004Koulouri!et!al.,!2008Li!et!al.,!2009He!et!al.,!2004Salma!et!al.,!2004Graham!et!al.,!2003Sciare!et!al.,!2009Fuzzi!et!al.,!2007Gatari!and!Boman,!2002Smith!et!al.,!1996Zappoli!et!al.,!1999Chow!et!al.,!1994Hueglin!et!al.,!2005Kim!et!al.,!2005Ho!et!al.,!2004Fan!et!al.,!2004Eatough!et!al.,!2001;!2003Long!et!al.,!2003Sawant!et!al.,!2004Kim!et!al.,!2000Jeong!et!al.,!2004Artaxo!et!al.,!2002Balasubramanian!et!al.,!2003Xu!et!al.,!2004Krivacsy!et!al.,!2001Shakya!et!al.,!2010

Comparison!with!OC!measurementsComparison!with!OC!measurements

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 24

Comparison!with!OC!measurementsComparison!with!OC!measurements

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 25

Organic!Matter!(OM)!– PM 1

Organic!Matter!(OM)!– PM1

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 26

Zhang!et!al.,!2007

Comparison!with!OM!measurementsComparison!with!OM!measurements

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 27

Comparison!with!OM!measurementsComparison!with!OM!measurements

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 28

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 29

SeasonalitySeasonality

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 30

Almost!identical!correlationsAlmost!identical!correlations

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 31

Almost!identical!correlationsAlmost!identical!correlations

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 32

FinokaliaFinokalia

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 33

Huge!peaksHuge!peaks

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 34

Nice!performanceNice!performance

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 35

Nice!performanceNice!performance

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 36

HawaiiHawaii

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 37

Amsterdam!IslandAmsterdam!Island

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 38

Alta!Floresta,!BrazilAlta!Floresta,!Brazil

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 39

Alta!Floresta,!BrazilAlta!Floresta,!Brazil

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 40

Concluding!remarksConcluding!remarks! Large!model!diversity.! In!general!models!underestimate measurements,!especially!during!winter.

! Remote!stations!are!better!captured!compared!to!urban!and!marine!ones.

! A!condensed!(and!updated?)!version!of!this!presentation!is!scheduled!for!IAMA!(Davis)!and!AGU!(SF)!this!December.

! A!paper!is!under!preparation.!At!least!two!others!are!planned.

10/30/2011 Kostas!Tsigaridis,!Columbia!University/NASA!GISS 41