Post on 23-Sep-2020
www.centerforcsri.org
Administered by Learning Point Associates in partnership with Southwest Educational Laboratory (SEDL), the Education Development Center(EDC), and WestEd, and in collaboration with the Academy for Educational Development (AED), under contract with the Office of Elementaryand Secondary Education of the U.S. Department of Education.
The School ImprovementThe School ImprovementPlanning ProcessPlanning Process
Hugh Burkett, Ph.D.Director, The Center for Comprehensive
School Reform and Improvement
January 2006
www.centerforcsri.org
Adapted from:
A Technical Assistance Document For:Planning and Evaluating Your School Improvement Process
Florida Department of EducationDivision of Public Schools, Bureau of School Improvement
http://www.bsi.fsu.edu/pdf/2005TA.pdf
The WINSS School Improvement Planning Tool:An Overview
Wisconsin Department of Public InstructionNorth Central Regional Education Laboratory
North Central Regional Technology Education Consortiumhttp://goal.ncrel.org/winss/sip/ppt.asp
2
www.centerforcsri.org
The School ImprovementPlanning Process
The Guiding Principle
The Federal Requirements General
Districts and Schools in Improvement
Planning for Success: The Critical Elements Organizing
Planning Implementing Sustaining
3
www.centerforcsri.org
The Guiding Principle
District or school improvement isa “continuous institutional processrather than a sporadic set ofactivities or isolated projects.”
-Craig Jerald
4
www.centerforcsri.org
Why?Improvement planning is arequirement of federal law
ESEA, Title I, Sec. 1111 requires that all State EducationAgencies have a general improvement plan that addresses therequirements of the law such as academic standards,assessments and accountability.
ESEA, Title I, Sec. 1112 requires that all Local EducationAgencies (LEA) have a general improvement plan thataddresses the requirements of the law such as a description ofthe actions the LEA will take to assist its low achieving schoolsidentified as in need of improvement.
Plans must be periodically reviewed and revised as necessary
5
www.centerforcsri.org
Additional Requirements When aDistrict or School Has Been Identified
for Improvement
6
www.centerforcsri.org
“Districts and schools identified forimprovement must develop, or revise, animprovement plan which outlines thedistrict or school’s course of action for thenext two years.”
ESEA, Title I, Sec. 1116(b)(3)
7
www.centerforcsri.org
Planning For Success:The Critical Elements
Organizing
Planning
Implementing
Sustaining
8
www.centerforcsri.org
Organizing for Improvement
The Improvement Planning TeamAssessing Needs
9
www.centerforcsri.org
Organizing:The Improvement Planning Team
Federal law requires that the improvementplanning team include, at a minimum—
ParentsSchool StaffDistrict StaffOutside Experts
ESEA, Title I, Sec. 1116(a)(3)
10
www.centerforcsri.org
Best practice indicates that the work of theimprovement team must be more than fulfilling alegal requirement.
“Involve a wide range of otherstakeholders from the outset, includingparents, representatives of communitygroups, and business leaders…Toooften, participants from outside theschool or district are included simply tomeet a requirement and are not fullparticipants…”
http://www.centerforcsri.org/PDF/The_Center_Policy_Brief_January_2005.pdf
Organizing:The Improvement Planning Team
11
www.centerforcsri.org
A well represented improvement planningteam ensures that all perspectives andexpertise are represented.
A well represented improvement planningteam facilitates effective improvementplan implementation.
Organizing:The Improvement Planning Team
12
www.centerforcsri.org
Organizing:Assessing Needs
The challenging task of “a full, honest andtransparent accounting of the currentstate of affairs.”
-Craig Jerald
13
www.centerforcsri.org
Organizing:Assessing Needs
Step 1 - The Team addresses the following questions:
How will needs be identified?
What data will be collected? Multiple data sources
How will data be collected?
How will data be presented? Disaggregated by school, grade level, subject areas, mandated
subgroups, gender, other categories as identified
What are the unmet objectives from last year’simprovement plan?
14
www.centerforcsri.org
Organizing:Assessing Needs
Step 2 - The team performs the following tasks:
Collects data from multiple sources Disaggregates data in multiple categories Analyzes data to identify problems and needs to be
addressed in improvement plan
15
www.centerforcsri.org
Organizing:Assessing Needs
Step 3 - The team evaluates the needs assessment process:
Were all stakeholders part of the process? Was needs assessment information current? Were needs assessment items directly related to the
desired conditions? Were all populations equitably represented? Has the needs assessment process been documented?
16
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 4 -
The team revises the needs assessment based on theinformation gathered in Step 3.
Organizing:Assessing Needs
17
www.centerforcsri.org
Planning for Improvement
Collaborative, Strategic Problem SolvingEstablishing Vision & MissionGoal SettingIdentifying ObjectivesIdentifying Implementation Strategies
18
www.centerforcsri.org
Planning:Collaborative, Strategic Problem Solving
“High performing schools engage inmore collaborative decision making,work harder to connect professionaldevelopment to student achievementdata, and make more efficient use oftime and resource. None of theseactivities is possible, or at leastpossible to do well, without seriousand thoughtful planning.”
http://www.centerforcsri.org/PDF/April.policy.final.pdf
19
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 1 - The team establishes a results-based orientationfocused on tangible student outcomes.
Staff members firmly believe that they are at least andprimarily responsible for making sure that studentslearn.
Staff members take direct responsibility for studentachievement.
Planning:Collaborative, Strategic Problem Solving
20
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 2 - The team:
Relentlessly analyzes data and other empirical evidenceat all levels of disaggregation to identify problems.
Gathers additional evidence to identify internalweaknesses that are causing or abetting low outcomesand obstructing improvement.
Planning:Collaborative, Strategic Problem Solving
21
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 3 - The team (continued):
Identifies possible solutions to problems andopportunities for making changes that will lead togreater success.
Uses common sense, creativity, and extensiveinvestigation of research- and evidence-based practicesto decide among possible solutions.
Planning:Collaborative, Strategic Problem Solving
22
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 4 -
The team revises the collaborative, strategic problemsolving strategies based on the information gathered inStep 3.
Planning:Collaborative, Strategic Problem Solving
23
www.centerforcsri.org
“A clear vision and a common mission thatidentifies the learning to be achieved canhelp keep a school and the efforts of itsstaff and students on target. A sharedvision is critical to an organization’s futurebecause it provides the underlyingfoundation upon which all decisions aremade.”
-A Technical Assistance Document For:Planning and Evaluating Your School Improvement
Process
Planning:Establishing Vision & Mission
24
www.centerforcsri.org
A vision statement—
Provides a compelling picture of what thedistrict or school can become in thefuture.
Answers the question What are weworking to become?
A Technical Assistance Document For: Planning and Evaluating Your School Improvement Process
Planning:Establishing Vision & Mission
25
www.centerforcsri.org
A mission statement—
More specific than a vision statement.Often defines what the district or school is
trying to accomplish and for whom.Answers the question Why do we exist?
A Technical Assistance Document For: Planning and Evaluating Your School Improvement Process
Planning:Establishing Vision & Mission
26
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 1 - The team:
Identifies a process for building consensus about visionand mission.
Reviews literature related to district and schoolimprovement to inform the development of the visionand mission.
Drafts vision and mission statements.
Planning:Establishing Vision & Mission
27
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 2 - The team:
Has adequate time and resources to meet anddeliberate.
Engages in a transparent process where drafts areproduced and distributed for comment.
Uses consensus to determine the final vision and missionstatements.
Planning:Establishing Vision & Mission
28
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 3 - The team evaluates the vision and missionstatement development process:
Do the statements incorporate a concern for the academic successof all students and reflect the belief that all students can learn?
Do the statements reflect the belief that all teachers are responsibleimplementing instructional strategies that meet the needs of allstudents?
Are the statements attainable?
Do the statements address increasing subgroup performance?
Are the statements aligned to “other” plans? Title I plan
District plan
Planning:Establishing Vision & Mission
29
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 4 –
The team revises the vision and mission statements basedon the information gathered in Step 3.
Planning:Establishing Vision & Mission
30
www.centerforcsri.org
Planning:Goal Setting
Knowing what you want to accomplish andmaking a plan to get there.
31
www.centerforcsri.org
A goal is -
A general statement about an area to be improved overa period of time.
Focused and clearly stated.
Directly based on data that demonstrates a problem.
Leads to sustainable, systemic change.
Can be achieved.
Planning:Goal Setting
32
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 1 - The team:
Uses data, needs assessment results, and the vision andmission statements to identify areas for improvement.
Planning:Goal Setting
33
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 2 - The team:
Drafts goal statements that are – Clear and Motivating Based on data Challenging Attainable
Planning:Goal Setting
34
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 3 - The team evaluates the goal setting process:
Do the goals reflect the vision and the mission of thedistrict or school?
Are the goals aligned with federal, state, and districtrequirements and priorities?
Do the goals address the critical needs determined bythe needs assessment?
Are goals written to increase student performance forsubgroups that did not achieve Adequate YearlyProgress?
Planning:Goal Setting
35
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 4 –
The team revises the vision and mission statements basedon the information gathered in Step 3.
Planning:Goal Setting
36
www.centerforcsri.org
The steps needed to accomplish the goal.
Planning:Identifying Objectives
37
www.centerforcsri.org
An objective is—
Measurable.Developed to address specific problems related
to the goal.Specific Measurable Attainable
RealisticTimebound
Planning:Identifying Objectives
38
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 1 - The team:
Develops a process for identifying objectives for eachgoal.
Develops objectives based on available data.
Planning:Identifying Objectives
39
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 2 - The team:
Identifies at least one measurable objective for eachgoal.
Ensures that all objectives have SMART qualities. States objectives in terms of student achievement to be
attained. Ensures that objectives lead to increased student
achievement and put the district or school on the pathtowards achieving Adequate Yearly Progress.
Chooses objectives that promote systemic, positivechange.
Planning:Identifying Objectives
40
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 3 - The team evaluates the identifying objectivesprocess:
Are the objectives challenging and attainable in thetimeframe given?
Do objectives include measurable expectations for allstudent populations, particularly mandated subgroups?
Is each objective aligned with its corresponding goal?
Planning:Identifying Objectives
41
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 4 -
The team revises the objectives based on the informationgathered in Step 3.
Planning:Identifying Objectives
42
www.centerforcsri.org
The HOW of Implementation
Planning:Identifying Strategies
43
www.centerforcsri.org
A strategy—
Specifies the actions to be taken to achieve theobjectives.
Addresses research-based instructional approaches to beimplemented.
Addresses research-based instructional materials to beused.
Determines professional development necessary toimplement instructional approaches.
Is continuously monitored.
Planning:Identifying Strategies
44
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 1 - The team:
Extensively investigates strategies whose effectivenesshave been validated by scientific research.
Ensures that strategies support stated goals andobjectives.
Determines who will be responsible for implementingstrategies.
Determines a timeline for strategy implementation.
Determines all resources necessary for implementing thestrategies.
Planning:Identifying Strategies
45
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 2 - The team:
Identifies effective research-based strategies that willaddress needs. Instructional Programs and Curricula
Professional Development
Instructional Materials
Identifies strategies to monitor the implementation ofthe Improvement Plan
Planning:Identifying Strategies
46
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 3 - The team evaluates the identifying strategiesprocess:
Are the strategies clearly aligned with needs?
Will the strategies address the needs of all subgroups?
Have the necessary resources been allocated?
Is there a process for evaluation that includes proceduresand a timeline?
Planning:Identifying Strategies
47
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 4 -
The team acts to correct any strategies that are notproducing the intended results.
Planning:Identifying Strategies
48
www.centerforcsri.org
Implementing Improvement
Overcoming Barriers to Improvement
49
www.centerforcsri.org
Implementing:Overcoming Barriers to Improvement
“The implementation stage is themost difficult of all…Implementing animprovement plan…really comesdown to changing a complexorganization in fundamental ways.”
http://www.centerforcsri.org/files/August_Policy_Brief.pdf
50
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 1 - The team:
Confronts the internal barriers to change. Technical challenges—the lack of “know how”
Cultural challenges—traditional beliefs, expectations, norms,habits, and ingrained patterns of behavior that run counter tonew ideas
Political challenges—passive or overt resistance to newstrategies and/or conflicts among competing interests
Implementing:Overcoming Barriers to Improvement
51
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 1 – The team (continued):
Confronts the external barriers to change. Insufficient support at the district level for specific school
improvement efforts
Insufficient control over budgets at the school level
Insufficient control over personnel
Implementing:Overcoming Barriers to Improvement
52
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 2 - The team:
Becomes knowledgeable about the research on organizationalchange.
Restructures district offices to provide schools with the support theyneed to implement ambitious improvement plans.
Provides principals with the time to focus on implementingimprovement plans.
Distributes the responsibility for implementing the plan among theschool staff.
Allocates resources to support school improvement. Enacts policies to give schools real control over their own budgets. Enacts policies to give schools real control over personnel.
Implementing:Overcoming Barriers to Improvement
53
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 3 - The team:
Begins to think outside the box and engages in creativestrategies to help schools overcome internal and externalbarriers to serious organizational change andimprovement.
Implementing:Overcoming Barriers to Improvement
54
www.centerforcsri.org
Step 4 -
The team evaluates their progress in overcoming thebarriers to improvement and makes changes as necessary.
Implementing:Overcoming Barriers to Improvement
55
www.centerforcsri.org
Sustaining Improvement
Communicating
Maintaining
Extending
Evaluating
Adapting
56
www.centerforcsri.org
Sustaining:Communicating, Maintaining, Extending, Adapting, Evaluating
“Sustaining an improvement effortrequires more than simplemaintenance. Prolonged,continuous improvement requirescontinually asking and acting on theanswers to several key questions:How can we do even bettertomorrow? What’s working andwhat’s not? What do we need tochange?”
http://www.centerforcsri.org/files/Center_PB_Sept_fnl.pdf
57
www.centerforcsri.org
Communicating
Create a strategy for communicating the district orschool vision, core values, and reform efforts toall staff, both new and old, and other keystakeholders so they understand not just howthings are done, but why things are done theway they are.
Sustaining:Communicating, Maintaining, Extending, Evaluating, Adapting
58
www.centerforcsri.org
Maintaining
Maintaining an improvement effort beyond a fewmonths or the first year of implementationrequires keeping a sharp eye on how the changeprocess is affecting staff members and students;keeping a constant lookout for warning signs ofobstacles that might threaten the effort; andkeeping a very open mind to how challenges canarise from even the most unlikely places.
Sustaining:Communicating, Maintaining, Extending, Evaluating, Adapting
59
www.centerforcsri.org
Sustaining:Communicating, Maintaining, Extending, Evaluating, Adapting
Extending
Sustaining success over the long term requires afierce, very intentional kind of “opportunism.” Theorganizations that are most successful atsustaining improvement over long periods of timelearn to enact new, “next generation”improvements even as they work to maintainpractices that are already working.
60
www.centerforcsri.org
Evaluating
Evaluation gives direction to future improvementefforts by changing and improving district andschool improvement plan. It’s informative, notpunitive. It is the process that: identifies thesuccesses of the current plan; identifies the needsfor the next year’s plan; and evaluates and adjuststhe plan’s progress throughout the year.
A Technical Assistance Document For: Planning and Evaluating Your School Improvement Process
Sustaining:Communicating, Maintaining, Extending, Evaluating, Adapting
61
www.centerforcsri.org
Adapting
Organizations that sustain growth over longperiods of time cling fiercely to the core visionswhile considering everything else—practices,structures, job definitions, schedules—up forgrabs.
Sustaining:Communicating, Maintaining, Extending, Evaluating, Adapting
62
www.centerforcsri.org
Organizing for, planning for, implementingan, and sustaining a reform effort is acomplicated process that requiresintellectual honesty, creativity, andunflinching courage. There is plentifulevidence that sustaining improvement ispossible, even over very long periods, andthat the benefits for students are greatindeed.
63
www.centerforcsri.org
ResourcesA Technical Assistance Document For: Planning and Evaluating Your School Improvement ProcessFlorida Department of Education Division of Public Schools, Bureau of School Improvementhttp://www.bsi.fsu.edu/pdf/2005TA.pdf
The WINSS School Improvement Planning Tool: An OverviewWisconsin Department of Public Instruction, North Central Regional Education Laboratory, North Central Regional Technology EducationConsortiumhttp://goal.ncrel.org/winss/sip/ppt.asp
Establishing a Strong Foundation for School ImprovementCraig JeraldThe Center for Comprehensive School Reform and Improvementhttp://www.centerforcsri.org/PDF/The_Center_Policy_Brief_January_2005.pdf
Planning That Matters: Helping Schools Engage in Collaborative, Strategic Problem SolvingCraig JeraldThe Center for Comprehensive School Reform and Improvementhttp://www.centerforcsri.org/PDF/April.policy.final.pdf
The Implementation Trap: Helping Schools Overcome Barriers to ChangeCraig JeraldThe Center for Comprehensive School Reform and Improvementhttp://www.centerforcsri.org/files/August_Policy_Brief.pdf
More Than Maintenance: Sustaining Improvement Efforts Over the Long RunCraig JeraldThe Center for Comprehensive School Reform and Improvementhttp://www.centerforcsri.org/files/Center_PB_Sept_fnl.pdf
Elementary and Secondary Education Act, Part A, Subpart 1http://www.ed.gov/policy/elsec/leg/esea02/pg2.html
64
www.centerforcsri.org
Hugh Burkett, Ph.D.202-884-8540hugh.burkett@learningpt.org
65
www.centerforcsri.org
877-277-2744
www.centerforcsri.org
1825 Connecticut Avenue NWWashington, DC 20009
66