Post on 02-Jun-2018
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 1/67
Piping Stress Analysis Training
Introduction and How to Analyze using CAE Software
By: Ferdian Harjono
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 2/67
Timeline (2014/06/17) :
▪ 08:00 – 10:00 -> Basic Piping Introduction & TrainingOverview
▪ 10:00 – 10:30 -> Coffee Break▪ 10:30 – 12:00 -> Introduction to Pipe Stress Analysis
Code Compliance▪ 12:00 – 13:30 -> Lunch Break▪ 13:30 – 15:30 -> Basic Piping Stress Analysis Theory
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 3/67
Timeline (2014/06/18) :
▪ 08:00 – 10:00 -> Piping Stress Analysis Workflow▪ 10:00 – 10:30 -> Coffee Break▪ 10:30 – 12:00 -> Piping Stress Analysis Workflow
(Cont’d) ▪ 12:00 – 13:30 -> Lunch Break▪ 13:30 – 15:30 -> Equipment Analysis
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 4/67
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 5/67
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 6/67
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 7/67
Overview :
▪
Piping Flexibility▪ Piping Support: Purpose▪ Pipe Support Span Calculation▪ Pipe Support Type▪ Piping Stress Engineer Workflow
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 8/67
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 9/67
Scope of Work of Piping SystemSubfield1. Piping Material
- Material Selection, Specification for welding, insulation,painting, fabrication, etc.
2. Piping Design
- Designing Piping System from one equipment to another
equipment / one area to another area based on severaldesign basis
3. Piping Stress Analysis
- Analyzing the stresses in piping system to assure the safetyof the plant (enough flexibility = No overstress occur inthe piping system)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 10/67
Basic Pipe Stress Analysis: WhyHow?Pipe Stress Analysis
Why? Safety
“Piping Stress Analysis adalah suatu metode terpenting untukmeyakinkan dan menetapkan secara numerik bahwa sistem pemipaandan engineering adalah aman ” – Achmad Chamsudi
Actual Loads not exceed Allowable Loads – Codes Standards
How?
Analyze the piping system using piping stress analysis software (CAESAR
/ AutoPIPE)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 11/67
▪
Limit the Stresses in piping▪ Limit the deflection in piping▪ Limit the loads on connected equipment▪ Limit the loads on supports▪ Check leakage at flange joints▪ Avoid unintentional disengagement of pipes from support▪ Avoid excessive displacement
Objectives of Pipe Stress Analysis
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 12/67
Limit the Stress in Piping
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 13/67
Limit the Deflection in Piping
Δ
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 14/67
Limit the Loads on Connected Equipment
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 15/67
Limit the Loads on Support
2000
0
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 16/67
Check Leakage at Flange Joints
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 17/67
Check Leakage at Flange Joints Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 18/67
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 19/67
Avoid Unintentional Disengagement ofPipes from Support
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 20/67
Avoid Excessive Displacement
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 21/67
Codes Standards
▪
Codes : General rules for design, materials, fabrication,installation, and inspection prepared in such manner thatit can be adopted and made into law
▪ Standards : Documents prepared with the basis of properengineering practice and written with mandatoryrequirement
+ Beneficial : + Consistency and safety in design+ Avoiding chances of failure+ Reduction in plant shutdown
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 22/67
Mandatory Requirement from Codes
▪
Piping component Thickness calculation for internal pressure▪ Piping component Thickness calculation for external pressure▪ Reinforcement requirement for branch▪ Minimum flexibility requirement▪ Piping support and their design▪ Allowable stresses for various materials▪ Piping Fabrication and layout requirement▪
Piping inspection and testing method
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 23/67
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 24/67
Terminology of StressTerminology of Stress Strain
Stress ( σ) = Force / Cross Sectional Area
Strain ( ε) = ΔL / L (Longitudinal Strain)
= ΔD / D (Lateral Strain)
Modulus of Elasticity (E) = σ / ε ----- Pipe Span Calculation
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 25/67
Terminology of Stress Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 26/67
▪
Yield Strength : Max Stress a material can withstandwiththout permanent deformation
▪ Ultimate Tensile Strength : Max stress a material canwithstand before uncontrolledyielding and breaking
▪ Allowable Stress : To account for uncertainty in loading anbehavior of materials, a factor of safetywas introduced to find allowable stress
a material
Allowable Stress = Yield Strength (UTS) / Factor of safety
Terminology of Stress Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 27/67
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 28/67
▪
Longitudinal Stress▪ Circumferential / Hoop Stress▪ Radial Stress▪ Axial Stress▪ Bending Stress▪ Shear Stress
Loads Stresses in Piping:Stresses in Piping Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 29/67
▪
Longitudinal Stress– Stress Developed normal to the cross sectional of pipe, caused byinternal pressure▪ Sl = PD/4t
Loads Stresses in Piping:Stresses in Piping
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 30/67
▪
Circumferential / Hoop Stress– Stress developed tangential to the cross section of pipe and is due tointernal pressure loading (parallel to pipe circumference)▪ Sc= PD/4t
Loads Stresses in Piping:Stresses in Piping Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 31/67
▪
Radial Stress– Stress developed in radial direction across the wall thickness of pipe.It’s value is equal to internal pressure at the inside of pipe wall andequal to atmospheric pressure at the pipe’s external surface
– Note – At the outer radius of pipe, radial stress is zero whereas the bendingstress is maximum. Hence this stress component has been traditionallybeen ignored during stress calculation.
Loads Stresses in Piping:Stresses in Piping Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 32/67
▪
Axial Stress– Stress developed due to external loads in axial direction in pipe▪ Sc= PD/4t
Loads Stresses in Piping:Stresses in Piping Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 33/67
▪
Bending Stress– Stress developed in pipe due to loads acting in a plane normal to theaxis of pipe. These are due to temperature, weight of pipe, weight ofcontents, snow, wind, or earthquake.▪ Sb= M/Z
▪ M = Bending Moment▪ Z = Section Modulus of Pipe
Loads Stresses in Piping:Stresses in Piping Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 34/67
▪ Shear Stress– Sum of 2 components i.e. Torsional Stress and Direct Shear Stress.
Direct shear stress is negligible (max at neutral axis of pipe andzero at max distance from neutral axis. Neglected for calculationbecause very small)
Torsional Stresses are due to twisting moment on pipe▪ St= T/2J
▪ T = torque▪ J = Polar Moment of Inertia
Loads Stresses in Piping:Stresses in Piping Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 35/67
▪ Distribution of Stresses in Piping
Loads Stresses in Piping:Stresses in Piping Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 36/67
▪ A Piping System need to accommodate their own expansionas well as the expansion of connected equipment so as toavoid:– Failure due to overstress– Leakage at Flange Joints– Distortion of connected equipment
Piping Flexibility
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 37/67
Temperature
COLD
HOT
Piping Flexibility Cont’d) ▪ A Piping System need to accommodate their own expansion
as well as the expansion of connected equipment so as toavoid:– Failure due to overstress– Leakage at Flange Joints– Distortion of connected equipment
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 38/67
Methods of Providing PipingFlexibility▪ The method to provide flexibility for 2 different types are as
under:
– Axial Flexibility▪ Can be provided by using certain types of bellows
– Bending Flexibility▪ Can be provided using loops, offsets, bends, bellows, etc.
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 39/67
Methods of Providing PipingFlexibility (Axial Flexibility)▪ Consider member of cross sectional Area A, length L, and
Modulus of Elasticity E subjected to an axial Load P▪ Deflection, δ = PL/AE
▪ Stiffness, k = P/ δ = AE/L
▪ Axial Flexibility = 1/k = L/AE
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 40/67
Methods of Providing PipingFlexibility (Bending Flexibility)Consider the same member is subjected to Bending Load P
– Deflection, δ b = PL3/CEI– C = Constant depending upon Type of Supports, Loading and
Location of applied Bending Load. For example – – Deflection, δ b = PL3/48EI, for Simply Supported Beam– Stiffness k = P/ δ b = 48EI/L3
– Bending Flexibility = 1/k = L3/48EI
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 41/67
Piping Support: Purpose
• Carry weight of Pipe, Fittings, Valves, with / without Insulation,with Operating / Test Fluid
• Provide adequate stiffness against external loads like Wind, Ice,Snow, Seismic Loads etc.
• Avoid overstressing of Piping Material• Avoid sagging which creates draining problem• Control Thermal expansion / contraction in the desired manner• Withstand /dampen vibration produced by connected equipment
or Flow induced vibration, Acoustic induced vibration etc.
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 42/67
Pipe Support Span CalculationCont’d)
• Based on Stress– Total Bending Stress (Sustained Load) shall not exceed hot
allowable Stress,– PD/4t + M/Z ≤ Sh
– For Pipe connection having one end simply supported andother end fixed,
– Bending Moment, M = 5wl 2/48– Hence Span can be calculated by eq.
PD/4t + 5wl 2/48Z ≤ Sh
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 43/67
Pipe Support Span CalculationCont’d)
M
w
l
l l
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 44/67
Pipe Support Span CalculationCont’d)
Based on Deflection- For Pipe connection having one end simply supported and
other end fixed,
– Maximum Deflection
δ = wl4/128E I
–Where,–δ = Maximum Deflection–E = Modulus of Elasticity–l = Pipe Span–I = Moment of Inertia,–w = Unit weight of Pipe
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 45/67
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 46/67
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 47/67
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 48/67
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 49/67
Pipe Support Type Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 50/67
▪ Shoes– Used for Carrying weight of insulated Pipe– Used where less space is available (w.r.t hanger)– Used where frictional resistance is not a criteria (else slide plates
are used)– Local stress check required where CA>1/8” or wall thickness <
STD (for single web shoe)
Pipe Support Type Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 51/67
– Trunnion / Dummy Support▪ Used generally for vertical pipes▪ Used where clearance between BOD and grade is higher (w.r.t
Shoe)▪ Used where elbow required to be supported▪ Local stress check is essential for dummy support
Pipe Support Type Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 52/67
• Flexible Hanger – Variable Spring:• Used for piping with vertical movement but less than 35-40 m• Used to distribute load when pipe is thermally moving up or d• Used where load variation is less than 25% (from different loa
conditions)
• % Variability = (Hot Load – Cold Load) / Hot Load x 100 = Ky / Ho
Pipe Support Type Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 53/67
Pipe Support Type Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 54/67
Flexible Hanger – Variable Spring (Selection):
1) Calculate Piping Load for Spring (Hot Load)2) Calculate thermal Movement (y) and its direction at that location3) Locate hot load in load table (preferred at center of table) and
spring suitable for that thermal movement4) Calculate Installed Load = Hot Load ± (Thermal Movement [y]
Spring Rate [k] )5) Calculate Variability if Hot and Cold or Installed Load in same
column6) If Variability is within Project Specification (or < 25%) then OK7) Else move to adjacent column where Hot and Cold load can be
located in working Range8) Repeat step 3 to 69) From Dimension table find length of Spring Assembly10)Compare with Available clearance
11) If not OK repeat step 3 to 10
Pipe Support Type Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 55/67
i. Anchor:• It is a mechanical connection (Welded or Bolted) between
Pipe and Structure• They do not allow movement and rotation of Pipe and
completely fix the line in place• Equipment Nozzles are also anchors but experience thermal
movement
ii. Directional Anchor (Line Stop):• Stops movement of Pipe in axial direction but allow
sideways movement
Pipe Restraint
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 56/67
iii.Guides:• Stops movement of Pipe in sideways direction but allow
axial movement
iv. U - Clamps:• They act as guide or anchor depending on construction and
installation•
Used for small bore (less than 2”) pipes
Pipe Restraint Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 57/67
v. Sway Struts:• It retains movement in one direction while allowing for
movement in another direction• Used where normal Guide or DA is not feasible due to non
availability of Steel Structure• Used where resistance due to friction is not acceptable• Effective under Tensile or Compressive Force• Allows angular motion or misalignment of ± 5°
Pipe Restraint Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 58/67
Pipe Restraint Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 59/67
vi. Vibration Absorbers – Snubbers (Hydraulic):• Used where Pipe experiences vibration due to earthquake,
wind, sudden valve opening/closing, rotating equipmentetc.
• It allows slow Thermal growth but resists sudden vibration• It goes to restraint mode based on particular velocity or
acceleration of motion depending on its design called
Activation Level• It consists of Double acting Cylinder and Piston assembly
(A), Flow control Device (B), and Reservoir (C)
Pipe Restraint Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 60/67
Pipe Restraint Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 61/67
vii.Vibration Absorbers – Snubbers (Mechanical):• It utilizes an inertia Mass which generates different
magnitude of resistance force against input Load inproportion to its acceleration level (M.a = F)
• Low input acceleration generates negligible level ofresistance force allowing free movement of Pipe
• High input acceleration generates sufficient resistance force
to completely restrain the vibration of Pipe• Mechanical Snubbers are preferred as no Oil Leakage or
change of Oil required
Pipe Restraint Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 62/67
Pipe Restraint Cont’d)
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 63/67
Pipe Restraint Cont’d)
viii.Sway Brace:
• It has a pre – loaded spring which can be extended orcompressed in order to give increasing resistance in bothdirection
• The increase in resistance allows it to dampen vibrations onpipe from equipment, opposes pipe sway and absorbsShock Forces
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 64/67
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 65/67
Stress Symbol
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 66/67
8/11/2019 [PSE] - PSA Training
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/pse-psa-training 67/67