Post on 16-May-2015
1
People of the Link
Estee Solomon Gray @estee
the inaugural :)Asilomar Conference CenterPresident’s Weekend 2012
@PeopleOfTheLink
1Tuesday, February 21, 12
2
2Tuesday, February 21, 12
3
3Tuesday, February 21, 12
“People of the Book” NOT
9th c. Quran Napoleon
“eglise”
NOT
4Tuesday, February 21, 12
Jonathan Rosen, 2000 Charles Kadushin,
5Tuesday, February 21, 12
InterTwined R. Justin Stewart www.rjustin.com
6Tuesday, February 21, 12
7
7Tuesday, February 21, 12
7
At the center of the Limmud experience
is a key but often overlooked attribute
of Jewish learning: everyone can be a
teacher and everyone must be a learner
7Tuesday, February 21, 12
7
At the center of the Limmud experience
is a key but often overlooked attribute
of Jewish learning: everyone can be a
teacher and everyone must be a learner
As much as Limmuds around the
world are connected, they also
reflect their own communities.
Hence Limoud, Limmoed, & Limud.
7Tuesday, February 21, 12
7
At the center of the Limmud experience
is a key but often overlooked attribute
of Jewish learning: everyone can be a
teacher and everyone must be a learner
Every Limmud is literally produced by its participants.
As much as Limmuds around the
world are connected, they also
reflect their own communities.
Hence Limoud, Limmoed, & Limud.
7Tuesday, February 21, 12
From the outset, Judaism has predicated its survival on education. Not education in the narrow, formal sense of acquisition of knowledge, but something altogether more vast.
Indeed, the word ‘education’ is altogether inadequate to describe Judaism’s culture of study and debate, its absorption of texts, commentaries and counter-‐commentaries, its devotion to literacy and lifelong learning.
Descartes said: ‘I think therefore I am.’ A Jew would say, ‘I learn therefore I am.’
Jonathan SacksChief Rabbi of the UK
8
8Tuesday, February 21, 12
9
in CHEVRUTA, please
1. How does one know one is a physicist ?
2. How does one know one is a Jew ?
What does this teach us about learning ?
using your own life & identity(s) as text,
8-10 mins
9Tuesday, February 21, 12
Humans are built to learn.
learning
10
http://wenger-trayner.comEtienne Wenger
social animals›❯
10Tuesday, February 21, 12
11
11Tuesday, February 21, 12
Where Learning Happens
COMMUNITY OF PRACTICE
http://wenger-trayner.comEtienne Wenger
12Tuesday, February 21, 12
CoP Definition #1 (“In Real Life”)
John Seely Brown
13
http://www.johnseelybrown.com/
13Tuesday, February 21, 12
“ .. for the first time, we have the technology
that starts to honor the power and role of
the emergent parts of an organization.”
14
1995
14Tuesday, February 21, 12
CoP Definition #2 (“On One Leg”*)
15
“A social history of learning that has become a social structure.”
*after Hillel
http://wenger-trayner.comEtienne Wenger
15Tuesday, February 21, 12
CoP Definition #2 (“On One Leg”*)
15
“A social history of learning that has become a social structure.”
*after Hillel
http://wenger-trayner.comEtienne Wenger
15Tuesday, February 21, 12
Six Degrees of Canadian Cyclinghttp://www.flickr.com/photos/gordonr/4194608074/
16Tuesday, February 21, 12
17Tuesday, February 21, 12
18Tuesday, February 21, 12
Network of Practice
19*after Hillel
“An extended social history of learning that
has become an extended social structure.”
19Tuesday, February 21, 12
How Learning Actually Happens
participation reification
meaning
identity
practice
practice
knowing in action
innovation learning
20Tuesday, February 21, 12
Arnold Eisen, Chancellor of Jewish Theological Seminary speaking to MPJCDS board, c1997
To see oneself as a Jew is to see oneself as part of a conversation.
A conversation that extends over time, space, media, generations ...
In fact, Judaism IS the conversation.
21Tuesday, February 21, 12
http://pennhillel.org/files/u64/SNL_brochure_pics__4_smaller.jpg
22
Jewish Learning
chevruta
va’ad
beit midrash
... DialogueMakloket Hiddush
Peer Learning Discipleship
22Tuesday, February 21, 12
“Hevruta: From Study to Action” summer/fall 2011
‣ movement between intellectual discussion & personal contemplation
‣ cultivation of compassionate listening
‣ deliberate partnering - paving the way for critical relationships
‣ ideas are multifaceted and complex
‣ responsibility for the other
Maya Bernstein
23Tuesday, February 21, 12
Jewish Practice
Christianity puts a premium on belief. Piety is determined by how committed one is to the belief in God and in Jesus as Savior. Yet, belief, in many Christian views, is not something that the individual achieves by his/her own efforts. Rather, belief (or faith) is a gift or grace of God that helps one find Truth and thus achieve personal salvation.
Judaism puts primacy on action and not belief. It puts supreme emphasis on imitatio dei. Judaism is a call to turn all actions in the everyday world into moments that transcend the mundane and find higher meaning and significance—acts of holiness. The centerpiece of holiness is not prayer to God or belief in God; rather, it is the performance of mitzvot... the halakhah (literally “the way”), which is the holy practice that leads to salvation (which though in Christianity generally means “saving” in Judaism can be more likened to tikkun olam—or repairing the world).
24
LEARN OR DIE: COVENANTAL COMMUNITIES AS A NEW APPROACH TO HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT,
PhD dissertation, 2008, School of Education, Indiana University
Josh Plaskoff
24Tuesday, February 21, 12
"Renew Our Days as of Old": Innovation as a Metric of Jewishness
God innovates in the act of b’reishit bara ... the rabbis interpret this cosmogenic moment as one of innovation more than creation: God makes new within known frameworks and using preexisting elements. Human creative acts .... must follow the same rules.
The language of innovation is not merely faddish but instead is integral to the processes of Jewishness
.the ability to effectively stand with one’s feet in the past while seeing beyond it to the present and future ..
the hiddush (makes new)
The halaKhic system at it core entails an innovative process of ‘making new’ ancient ideas by applying them to contemporary circumstances.
Yehuda Kertzer
A Tradition of Innovation
Journal of Jewish Communal ServiceWinter/Spring 2011. Volume 86, No. 1/2.
the taqqanah (fix)
25Tuesday, February 21, 12
26
Silicon Valley Learning/Practice
Technology evolves much as a coral reef builds itself from activities of small organisms — it creates itself from itself; and all technologies are descended from earlier technologies
“combinatorial evolution”
With domains, what comes into being is not a new device or method, but a new vocabulary for expression -- a new language for ‘programming’
new functionalities in. And this happens by slow emergence.
a constant re-expressing or re-domaining of old tasks — accounting, or transportation, or medical diagnostics — within new worlds of the possible.”
- ... not a magical, linear process marked by a series of “Eureka!” moments. ..
- more like the way a system of legal codes forms: slow, organic, & cumulative.
at the interstices between disciplines and sectors
26Tuesday, February 21, 12
People of the Link
The link, not the book, is (and always has been)
the core of Judaism.
InterTwined , R. Justin Stewart ( www.rjustin.com )
27Tuesday, February 21, 12
People of the Link
The link, not the book, is (and always has been)
the core of Judaism.
practice
value
meaning
concept▲
InterTwined , R. Justin Stewart ( www.rjustin.com )
27Tuesday, February 21, 12
From
covenant & commandment to
community, commentary & conversation,
the most basic acts of Jewish life are all
forms of linking.
textlearningleadershipprayerpracticepeoplehood
.....
InterTwined , R. Justin Stewart ( www.rjustin.com )
Even the Book is Linked. 28
28Tuesday, February 21, 12
NODENODE
TIE
relationshipconnection
activity
LINK
29Tuesday, February 21, 12
covenant
a thick, bidirectional tie the most profound of relationships
30Tuesday, February 21, 12
covenant
commandedness
31Tuesday, February 21, 12
NODENODE
Link
person self
person person
person community
person G-d
32Tuesday, February 21, 12
commentary, conversation
People of the Link
33Tuesday, February 21, 12
community, authority
People of the Link
34Tuesday, February 21, 12
Ruth
conversion, affiliationPeople of the Link
35Tuesday, February 21, 12
Link
radical thought
36Tuesday, February 21, 12
Link
radical thought
36Tuesday, February 21, 12
Link
(a mutually interactive verb: entailing an interdependency between two subjects, each being the object for the other. )
radical thought
36Tuesday, February 21, 12
The closest we can come to thinking about God is as a process rather than a being.
We can think of it as “be-ing,” as verb, rather than noun ...
We might call It God-ing ...
37Tuesday, February 21, 12
From
covenant & commandment to
community, commentary & conversation,
the most basic acts of Jewish life are all
forms of linking.
textlearningleadershipprayerpracticepeoplehood
.....
InterTwined , R. Justin Stewart ( www.rjustin.com )
Even the Book is Linked. 38
38Tuesday, February 21, 12
why ?
39Tuesday, February 21, 12
Three Eras of Jewish HistoryThree Stages of Covenant Rabbi Yitz Greenberg
40Tuesday, February 21, 12
Three Eras of Jewish HistoryThree Stages of Covenant Rabbi Yitz Greenberg
40Tuesday, February 21, 12
Three Eras of Jewish HistoryThree Stages of Covenant Rabbi Yitz Greenberg
[LAY? ]
40Tuesday, February 21, 12
Three Eras of Jewish HistoryThree Stages of Covenant Rabbi Yitz Greenberg
Link !
40Tuesday, February 21, 12
omg-d moments (Aspen 1996)
41
‣‘The Jews’ actually skipped the whole pyramid hierarchy thing.
‣ We’ve been living & evolving radically linked architectures for millennia.
‣ (But evidently lost our language for it along the way. )
41Tuesday, February 21, 12
“Judaism has always been a religion of grassroots organizing and the rabbinic model of the 20th century synagogue is perhaps the most foreign to the traditional Jewish heritage.
The real question is not how are independent minyanim new, but how are suburban synagogues -‐ a product of early to mid-‐twentieth century -‐ a departure from a Jewish organizing heritage shared by ... dozens of Jewish communal structures of years past.
There is no new “big idea”; there is just investment in the old, but in a serious, meaningful, and thoughtful way.”’
42Tuesday, February 21, 12
43
New/old language: The Networking of Knowledge
“ We thought that knowledge was scarce, when in fact it was just that our shelves were too small. Our new knowledge is not even a set of works. It is an infrastructure of connection.”
“ Traditional knowledge is what you get when paper is its medium... an accident of paper.”
“Networked knowledge is less certain but more human. Less settled but more transparent. Less reliable but more inclusive. Less consistent but far richer. It feels more natural because the old ideals of knowledge were never realistic...”
43Tuesday, February 21, 12
44
New/old language: The Networking of Knowledge
“ The smartest person in the room is the room itself: the network that joins the people and ideas in the room and connects to those outside of it. It’s not that the network is becoming a conscious super-brain. Rather, knowledge is becoming inextricable from - literally unthinkable without - the network that enables it.”
44Tuesday, February 21, 12
45
“To think that knowledge itself is shaped like books is to marvel that a rock fits so well in its hole in the ground.”
David Weinberger , Too Big To Know
45Tuesday, February 21, 12
45
“To think that knowledge itself is shaped like books is to marvel that a rock fits so well in its hole in the ground.”
“To think that Judaism itself is made of its institutions is to ...
David Weinberger , Too Big To Know
45Tuesday, February 21, 12
learningleadershipfundingprayerpracticepeoplehood .....
InterTwined , R. Justin Stewart ( www.rjustin.com )46
(invitation to reconsider )
People of the Link
46Tuesday, February 21, 12
Link= (LIMMUD = learning)
47
47Tuesday, February 21, 12
Link= (LIMMUD = learning)
47
As Jews, Link is one of our native national languages. But, as with Hebrew, we need to relearn how to speak it.
47Tuesday, February 21, 12
Link= (LIMMUD = learning)
47
As Jews, Link is one of our native national languages. But, as with Hebrew, we need to relearn how to speak it.
To educate a Jew is to bring him/her into the Jewish community of practice and to link him/her to the larger network that is the Jewish people.
- Josh Plaskoff, Estee Solomon Gray, NATE conference, Feb 2011
47Tuesday, February 21, 12
48
Go Forth and
Link !
48Tuesday, February 21, 12
49
Appendices
49Tuesday, February 21, 12
50
Judaism as CoP/NoP
content relationship praxis
reification participation
MEANING IDENTITYLEARNING
50Tuesday, February 21, 12
JUDAISM COMMUNITY OF PRACTICE
■ Learning is the root process ...■ “I learn therefore I am.”
■ ... out of which emerges community, meaning, identity, practice. ■ and not only individual communities, but whole landscapes, whole peoples
■ The socialness of it all! ■ Both the engine & the output of learning are social. ■ Jews are always negotiating of meaning !
■ The primacy of practice over belief ■ Removing the hyphen in Judaeo-Christian ■ The primacy and extensibility of active link / covenant / commandment / community
■ Distributed authority and multiple global/local forms of power ■ Since the destruction of the Temple, if not before ■ The primacy and extensibility of active link / covenant / commandment ■ People of the Link
51
51Tuesday, February 21, 12
CONGRUITY
Estee’s professional/community life 1970-2010
52Tuesday, February 21, 12
20001995 2005 2010 53
53Tuesday, February 21, 12