Post on 28-Feb-2018
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
1/41
DRAFT*
Political Law Review Dean Eduardo Sanson
First Semester, 2015201! "ud#e Edilwasi$ %addiri
Re&uired Te't(oo)
Bernas S.J., Fr. Joaquin (2011) The 1987 Philippine Constitution ! Co"prehensi#e
$e#ie%er, &anila $e' Boo Store, n*.
Bernas S.J., Fr. Joaquin (200+) The 1987 Constitution o the $epu-li* o the Philippines !
Co""entar, &anila $e' Boo Store, n*.
/a*hura, !ntonio (200) utline $e#ie%er in Politi*al a%, 3ue4on Cit 5J 6raphil !rts,
n*.
lassroom Policies
Stuents are e'pe*te to ha#e rea the assine "aterials or the *lass sessions an %ill -e
*alle or re*itation.
ni#ersit rules o#ernin a-sen*es are o-ser#e.
Cell phones an other ele*troni* e#i*es "ust -e ept in silent "oe. Stuents "ust rerain
ro" usin these e#i*es urin *lassroo" sessions.
Plaiaris" an *heatin are ra#e oenses o intelle*tual ishonest an are punisha-le -
uni#ersit rules.
Consultation an is*ussion is a#aila-le upon request o the stuent. :"ail "e
e-airi;"ail.*o"
A+ -ST.T/T.-AL LA 1
Pream(le
Article . Te -ational Territor3
$.!. 92
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
2/41
Se*tion 1. Philippines as a >e"o*rati* an $epu-li*an State
n re etter o !sso*iate Justi*e Puno, 210 SC$! @, 6$ 17+0+=, *to-er 9, 2007
Se*tion +. Ci#ilian Supre"a* an !FP $ole
BP #. Aa"ora, ++8 SC$! 81 (2000)
Se*tion =. >ut o 6o#ern"ent to the People
Se*tion
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
3/41
Se*tion 1=. $ole o Do"en an :qualit o &en an Do"en
Se*tion 1! #. C!, 2+1 SC$! 292 (199=) an 2e*e"-er 18, 2008
Se*tion 17. :u*ation, S*ien*e an Te*hnolo, !rts, Culture an Sports
Se*tion 18. a-or Prote*tion
Se*tion 19. Sel$eliant an nepenent /ational :*ono"
6ar*ia #. B, 191 SC$! 288 (1990)
Tanaa #. !nara, 272 SC$! 18 (1997)
Se*tion 20. $ole o Pri#ate Se*tor
Se*tion 21. Pro"otion o Co"prehensi#e $ural an !rarian Poli*
Se*tion 22. Pro"otion o $ihts o nienous Cultural Co""unities
Se*tion 2+. Co""unitBase Pri#ate rani4ations
Se*tion 2=. 5ital $ole o Co""uni*ations
Se*tion 2is*losure
Article . Te Le#islative De4artment
Se*tion 1. eislati#e Po%erE /on>eleation
!raneta #. 6at"aitan, 101 P@ +28 (19
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
4/41
Soli*itor 6eneral #. &&!, 20= SC$! 8+7 (1991)
!-aaa 6uro Part ist #. Purisi"a,
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
5/41
Se*tion 8.$eular :le*tions
Coilla #. >e 5ene*ia 6$ /o. 1is*iplineE JournalG$e*ors
(par. 1) >eensorSantiao #. 6uinona, 6$ 1+=
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
6/41
!a-ao #. C&::C, 6$ /o. 1+7e*e"-er 27, 2007
!rnault #. /a4areno, 87 P@ 2< (1990)
Sa-io #. 6oron, PD@ #. 3uirino, 6$ /o. 18+===, *to-er 12, 2011
(par.
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
7/41
(par. 1) Phil*onsa #. 6i"ene4, 1< SC$! =79 (19
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
8/41
Balao #. &a*apaal!rroo, 6$ /o. 18=e*e"-er 1+, 2011
$oriue4 #. &a*apaal!rroo, 6$ /o. 19180esierto, +
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
9/41
Pu-li* nterest 6roup #. :l"a, 6$ /o. 1+89e Castro #. Jui*ial an Bar Coun*il, 6$ /o. 191002, !pril 20, 2010 an &a 1, 2010
Se*tion 1. Po%er to !ppointE Co""ission on !ppoint"ents
6o#ern"ent #. Spriner :/$ :"ploees, 6$ /o. 1=972=, !u. 19, 200+
5illalu4 #. Aali#ar, 1< SC$! 710
Tono &ei*al Center :"ploees #. C!, 6$ /o. 17+2=, Jul 17, 2007
&alaria :"ploees #. :'e*uti#e Se*retar, 6$ /o. 1009+, Jul +1, 2007
rosa #. $oa, 6$ /o. 1=0=7, Jul 1=, 200Phillips Seaoo #. B, 6$ /o. 17
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
10/41
6uani #. Sena, 6$ /o. 1701e*e"-er 2, 1989
People #. Salle, Jr 6$ /o. 10+e*e"-er =, 199a#i #. !rroo, =89 SC$! 12
People #. &ateo, =++ SC$!
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
12/41
P/B #. !sun*ion, 0 SC$! +21
Santero #. CF Ca#ite, 1a"as*o #. aui, 1 SC$! 21=
People #. a*son, =00 SC$! 22
St. &artin Funeral @o"es #. /$C, 29< SC$! =9=
People #. 6utierre4, + SC$! 172 (1970)n $e Cunanan, 9= P@ e 5era (200+)
Bauio &arets 5enor #. Jue, 6$ /o. 16, 6$ /o. 102
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
13/41
Se*tion 1=. Contents o >e*isionE Petition or $e#ie%E &otion or $e*onsieration
People #. :s*o-er, 1elas in Cases Beore the Sanian-aan I !& /o. 0080e*e"-er , 2010
Ses-reno #. C!, 6$ /o. 11+90, !pril 1, 2008
Se*tion 1. Su-"ission o !nnual $eport
Article .6 onstitutional ommissions
!. Co""on Pro#isions
Se*tion 1. nepenent Co""issions
&a*alintal #. C&::C, 6$ 1B&, =82 SC$! 2++
Se*tion . Pro"ulation o $ules
&a*alintal #. C&::C, 6$ /o. 1e*isions o the Co""issions
Filipinas :nineerin an &a*hine Shop #. Ferrer, 1+< SC$! 2eensorSantiao, +
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
21/41
"-us"an #. $oriue4, 6$ /o. 172700, Jul 2+, 2010
6ar*ia #. &iro, 6$ /o. 1=89==, Fe- e*laration o !ssets an ia-ilities
Se*tion 18. !lleian*e o Pu-li* i*ers
Caasi #. C!, 191 SC$! 229 (1990)
Article 6..+ -ational Econom3 and Patrimon3
Se*tion 1. Threeol 6oal o the /ational :*ono"
Se*tion 2. $ealian >o*trine
ee @on ?o #. >a#i, =8 SC$! +72
Carino #. nsurer 6o#ern"ent, =1 P@ 9+:/$, +=7 SC$! 128 (2000)
Sta. $osa &inin #. eio, 1:/$, 6$127872, Jan 27, 200=, &$ 6$ 127882, >e*. 1,
200=
Philippine 6eother"al #. /apo*or, 6$ /o. 1==+02, &a 27, 200=
J6 Su""it #. C!, 6$ /o. 12=29+, Januar +1, 200o"ain>ire*tor o ans #. !quino, 192 SC$! 29 (1990)
$epu-li* #. C!, 10 SC$! 228 (1988)
!pe' &inin #. Southeast &inanao 6ol, n*, 6$ /o. 1ir. o ans #. !C, 1= SC$!
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
22/41
Cru4 #. Se*. o >:/$, +=7 SC$! 128 (2000)
Se*tion . Co""on 6oo
Tele*o" #. C&::C, 289 SC$! ++7 (1998)
Se*tion 7. Pri#ate ans$epu-li* #. C!, 2+< SC$! e $a"ire4, 111 SC$! 70= (1982)
@alili #. C!, 287 SC$! =< (1998)
ee #. $epu-li*, + SC$! (2001)
Fren4el #. Catito, 6$ /o. 1=+9C #. P5B, 192 SC$! 2
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
23/41
!an #. P!TC, =20 SC$! a#i #. &a*apaal!rroo, 6$ /o. 171+9, &a 200
Se*tion 18. /ationali4ation
$epu-li* #. P>T, 2 SC$! 20 (198)
P>T #. /TC, 190 SC$! 717 (1990)
Se*tion 19. &onopolies an Co"-inations
:ner $eulator Boar #. C!, 6$ /o. 11+079, !pril 20, 2001
6ar*ia #. :'e*uti#e Se*retar, 6$ /o. 1+2=e*e"-er 17, 1999
Tata #. Se*retar o :ner, 281 SC$! ++0
:astern !ssuran*e #. TF$B, 6$ /o. 1=9717, *t. 7, 200+
!#on #. una, 6$ /o. 1e*e"-er 20, 200
Se*tion 21. Forein oans
Se*tion 22. !*ts ni"i*al to the /ational nterest
Artcile 6.+ 7eneral Provisions
Se*tion 1. Fla o the Philippines
Se*tion 2. /a"e, /ational !nthe" or a /ational Seal
Se*tion +. ""unit Fro" Suit
$epu-li* #. Feli*iano, 1=8 SC$! =2= (1987)
&etran #. Parees, 79 Phil 819 (19=719=8)
/!C #. Teooro, 91 Phil 20+ (19! #. /$C, 227 SC$! 9+ (199+)
:P6 Constru*tion #. 5iilar, 6$ /o. 1+1
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
24/41
Carpio #. :'e*uti#e Se*retar I 20 SC$! 290 (1992)
>epart"ent o Buet #. &anilaHs Finest, 6$ /o. 19=, &a 9, 2007
&eno4a #. P/P, 6$ /o. 1+9e#elop"ent o Filipino Capa-ilit an Co""uni*ation Stru*tures
Se*tion 11. %nership an &anae"ent &ass &eia an !#ertisin
Se*tion 12. Consultati#e Bo or nienous Cultural Co""unities
Article 6..+ Amendments or Revisions
Se*tion 1. !"en"ent or $e#ision
"-on #. C&::C, +< SC$! 28 (1970)
a"-ino #. C&::C, eensorSantiao #. C&::C, 270 SC$! 10 (1997)E &$ (1997)
a"-ino #. C&::C,
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
25/41
1. Purpose o the Bill o $ihts
2. Three 6reat Po%ers o 6o#ern"ent
+. Poli*e Po%er
=. The Seat o Poli*e Po%er
&&>! #. Bel!ir 5illae !sso*iation, et* 6$ /o. 1+
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
26/41
:state o Fran*is*o #. C! I 199 SC$! is"issal Boar #. Tori*ta I ++0 SC$! 1
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
27/41
5illeas #. @iu Chion Tsai Pao @o I 8 SC$! 270
>u"lao #. C&::C I 9 SC$! +92
6oesart #. Clear ++< S ==
r"o* Suar Central #. r"o* Cit I Fe-. 7, 198
Sison, Jr. #. P!6C$ I &a 1=, 1991
$epu-li* #. Sanian-aan I 2+0 SC$! 711@i"aan #. People I 2+7 SC$! iono I June 19, 197
Ba*he O Co. # $ui4 I +7 SC$! 82+
Pla*er #. 5illanue#a I 12 SC$! =+
Buros, Sr. #. Chie o Sta, !FP I 1++ SC$! 800
Corro #. isin I 1+7 SC$! ) #. >e la $osa I 197 SC$! 8
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
28/41
ouse !l6houl #. C! I 6$ 128
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
29/41
"il #. $a"os I 187 SC$! +11 (&ain)E &$ I *t. +, 1991
People #. Su*ro I 19< SC$! +88
6o #. C! I 20 SC$! 1+8
People #. Briones I 202 SC$! 708
People #. &enote I 210 SC$! 17=
People #. Si"on I 2+= SC$!
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
30/41
!er Pro. PT. T>. 5. Jue Capulon I 10 SC$! 8i#ison Superintenent I 219 SC$! 2
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
32/41
Cha#e4 #. P:! I 6$ 1++2e Castel#i I
7/25/2019 List of Const Law 1 Cases
33/41
an Ban #. C! I 2=9 SC$! 1=9E (&$) 2e#elop"ent #. i*e o the Presient I 2+1 SC$! 7=
&iners !sso*iation #. Fa*toran I 2=0 SC$! 100
Juare4 #. C! I 21= SC$! =7