Post on 15-Jun-2015
description
NARRATION AND POINT OF VIEW
The Stories of The Cask of Amontillado, A Rose for Emily, and The Thing in the Forest
Emma Stevens
David “Henry” Herman
Alexandra Handle
THE CASK OF AMONTILLADO
By Edgar Allen Poe
THE JOURNEY INTO THE DEPTHS
Montresor lures the aptly named Fortunato into his family crypt with the promise of tasting fine wine.
Little does Fortunato know that Montresor has planned his demise, for insults to the Montresor family.
MONTRESOR & FORTUNATO
MontresorA mentally unstable man,
Montresor narrates this story for us. He begins by telling of the insult and injuries he has borne from
Fortunato. He vows to have vengeance, although never elaborates on what offenses
Fortunato committed.
By bricking Fortunato up in his family vault and leaving him to die of starvation and dehydration, he cements the perception that he is,
in fact, insane.
NarrationSince Montresor is the narrator for
this story and it is immediately apparent that he is not in his right mind, it is easy to say that he is
an unreliable narrator.
The first person point of view narration makes it difficult for the
reader to truly understand and view Fortunato without bias.
FortunatoFortunato, dressed in fool’s garb
for the festival, has a penchant for wine. Upon learning that
Montresor has acquired some Amontillado, he is easily lured to his untimely death. He is foolish not only in his dress, but in his
inability to see Montresor’s madness.
His large ego and state of inebriation serve to be his
ultimate downfall.
A ROSE FOR EMILY
By William Faulkner
While there is still much speculation on who exactly the narrator is, we can discern they are part of the town in which Emily lives.
The narrator also seems to be believable, if not reliable. While parts of the story are told second-hand, they are not outlandish or wild.
Through the limited perspective, and the pronoun use of “we”, “they”, and “she”, the POV is
first person plural.
Emily, and the other townspeople, are deeply colored by their historical surroundings. The social etiquette and small town setting of the American South, shortly after the Civil War allows the plot to move, and a specific characterization to happen.
The small town setting allows for all the townspeople not only to know who Emily is -something that could not be done with a larger cast- but to have respect for her and her family. She garners enough respect that everyone attends her funeral, she is allowed to forego taxes by the local authorities, and they wait until she is in the ground before opening the bedroom door in which hides her secret.
All of the characters act and speak in a way that is unique to the post-Civil War era in the South, because they are affected by the historical context.
THE THING IN THE FOREST
By A.S. Byatt
Faced with a deep, dark forest, Penny and primrose escape into their imaginations….
Where Primrose sees mysteryAnd finds adventure
Penny finds reality, And, in doing so, loses a bit of mystery
TOLD FROM THE THIRD PERSON SUBJECTIVE POINT OF VIEW
Although this story is somewhat of a ‘fairy tale’, Byatt’s narrator presents the account with a touch of realism,
stating how the young girls “saw” a thing in the forest.
Historical context gives us our setting, a ‘world’ set apart from the war; a place that will keep our characters safe and offer them an
opportunity to use their imaginations.
Narration allows us to be with Penny and Primrose at crucial times in their lives, and each of their memories of ‘the thing’ affects
both how they mature and their views of the world.
As they age, the memories of their youth, both horrifyingly real and fantastically imagined, determine who they are,
And instill in each a desire to find the child they left behind.
“War is not about a man’s heroic contest with a Loathly Worm, nor perhaps was it ever so simple a thing, even symbolically”
Byatt uses fantastical descriptions combined with purely Objective narrative to construct her tale, and we are tasked to find her
moral.
• Narrator is believable, if not reliable
• Historical context is vital• POV: First Person Plural• Passive narrator
• Narrator is reliable• Historical context is vital• POV: Third Person
Subjective• Passive narrator
• Narrator is unreliable• Historical context is less
important• POV: First Person
Narrative• Active narrator
A Rose for Emily
The Thing in the ForestThe Cask of Amontillado
Both A Rose for Emily and The Cask of Amontillado feature the first person point of view, however while one narrator is telling their own story, the other is telling the story of someone else. This distinction, coupled with the actions of the narrator make the difference between reliable and unreliable narrators.
Both The Cask of Amontillado and The Thing in the Forest feature characters that are deeply affected by their experiences in their respective stories. The key difference between these stories is the active/passive narrators and characters.
Both The Thing in the Forest and A Rose for Emily feature believable, passive narrators and a historical
context that is vital to the characterization and plot of the
stories. While both stories, upon first look, seem to be told in the third person, when examined closer A
Rose for Emily is in told in the first person.
When comparing all of these stories, we see that regardless of the details that categorize
them, the narrator and point of view are some of the most important elements in creating a
story, and that regardless of details it is possible to create a suspenseful story, full of
round, dynamic characters.
WORKS CITED
Byatt, A.S. “The Thing in the Forest”. Little Black Book of Stories, 2003. Web. Sept. 29, 2014.
CreativeShadows Blog. “A chillingly human tale for Halloween-A.S. Byatt’s The Thing in the Forest”. WordPress.com. Oct 9, 2012. Web. Sept 29, 2014.
Images. “The Thing in the Forest”, A.S.Byatt, Google.com. 2014. Web. Oct. 03, 2014.
SOURCES
Pictures Found
Rose Background
Single Rose
Emily Grierson and Skeleton
Text Citation
Faulkner, William. A Rose for Emily. Ed. Peter Simon. Shorter 10th ed. N.p.: W.W. Norton & Company, 2010. 391-97. Print.
WORKS CITED
THE THING IN THE FOREST BY A.S. BYATTA ROSE FOR EMILY BY WILLIAM FAULKNER
THE CASK OF AMONTILLADO BY EDGAR ALLEN POE