Post on 03-Jun-2018
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
1/57
1
Chapter 1
Introduction to frauds
What Are Frauds?
In a broad strokes definition, fraud is a deliberate misrepresentation
which causes another person to suffer damages, usually monetary
losses. Most people consider the act of lying to be fraud, but in a legal
sense lying is only one small element of actual fraud.
A salesman may lie about his name, eye color, place of birth and family,
but as long as he remains truthful about the product he sells, he will not
be found guilty of fraud. There must be a deliberate misrepresentation of
the product's condition and actual monetary damages must occur.
Many fraud cases involve complicated financial transactions conducted
by 'white collar criminals', business professionals with specialized
knowledge and criminal intent. An unscrupulous investment broker may
present clients with an opportunity to purchase shares in precious metal
repositories.
or e!ample, "is status as a professional investor gives him credibility,
which can lead to a #ustified believability among potential clients. Those
who believe the opportunity to be legitimate contribute substantial
amounts of cash and receive authentic$looking bonds in return. If the
investment broker knew that no such repositories e!isted and still
received payments for worthless bonds, then victims may sue him for
fraud.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
2/57
2
raud is not easily proven in a court of law. %aws concerning fraud may
vary from state to state, but in general several different conditions must
be met.
&ne of the most important things to prove is a deliberate
misrepresentation of the facts. id the seller know beforehand that the
product was defective or the investment was worthless( )ome
employees of a large company may sell a product or offer a service
without personal knowledge of a deception.
The account representative who sold a fraudulent insurance policy onbehalf of an unscrupulous employer may not have known the policy was
bogus at the time of the sale. In order to prove fraud, the accuser must
demonstrate that the accused had prior knowledge and voluntarily
misrepresented the facts.
Another important element to prove in a fraud case is #ustifiable or actual
reliance on the e!pertise of the accused. If a stranger approached you
and asked for ten thousand dollars to invest in a vending machine
business, you would most likely walk away. *ut if a well$dressed man
held an investment seminar and mentioned his success in the vending
machine world, you might rely on his e!pertise and perceived success to
decide to invest in his proposal. After a few months have elapsed without
further contact or delivery of the vending machines, you might reasonably
assume fraud has occurred. In court, you would have to testify that your
investment decision was partially based on a reliance on his e!pertise
and e!perience.
The element of fraud which tends to stymie successful prosecution is the
obligation to investigate. It falls on potential investors or customers to
fully investigate a proposal before any money e!changes hands.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
3/57
3
ailure to take appropriate measures at the time of the proposal can
seriously weaken a fraud case in court later. The accused can claim that
the alleged victim had every opportunity to discover the potential for fraud
and failed to investigate the matter thoroughly.
&nce a party enters into a legally binding contract, remorse over the
terms of the deal is not the same as fraud.
The dictionary defines fraud as the intentional perversion of truth to
induce another to part with something of value or to surrender a legal
right. Insurance fraud can be +hard or +soft. "ard fraud occurs whensomeone deliberately fabricates claims or fakes an accident. -riminals
are using increasingly sophisticated electronic schemes to defraud
insurance companies.
)oft insurance fraud, also known as opportunistic fraud, occurs when
normally honest people pad legitimate claims or intentionally understate
the number of miles they drive each year or, in the case of business
owners, list fewer employees or misrepresent the work they do to get a
lower premium.
Those who commit insurance fraud range from organized criminals who
steal large sums through fraudulent business activities and insurance
claim mills to professionals and technicians who inflate the cost ofservices or charge for services not rendered, to ordinary people who
want to cover their deductible or view filing a claim as an opportunity to
make a little money.
)ome lines of insurance are more vulnerable to fraud than others. "ealth
care, workers compensation and auto insurance are believed to be the
sectors most affected.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
4/57
4
Chapter 2
Insurance Fraud and Abuse
A Very Serious Problem
raud and abuse are widespread and very costly to any countrys health$
care system. raud involves intentional deception or misrepresentation
intended to result in an unauthorized benefit. An e!ample would be billing
for services that are not rendered.
Abuse involves charging for services that are not medically necessary, do
not conform to professionally recognized standards, or are unfairly
priced. An e!ample would be performing a laboratory test on large
numbers of patients when only a few should have it. Abuse may be
similar to fraud e!cept that it is not possible to establish that the abusive
acts were done with an intention to deceive the insurer.
Type of Fraud and Abuse
alse claim schemes are the most common type of health insurance
fraud. The goal in these schemes is to obtain undeserved payment for a
claim or series of claims. )uch schemes include any of the following
when done deliberately for financial gain/
*illing for services, procedures, and0or supplies that were not
provided.
Misrepresentation of what was provided1 when it was provided1 the
condition or diagnosis1 the charges involved1 and0or the identity of
the provider recipient.
2roviding unnecessary services or ordering unnecessary tests.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
5/57
5
Many insurance policies cover a percentage of the physician's 3usual3
fee. )ome physicians charge insured patients more than uninsured ones
but represent to the insurance companies that the higher fee is the usual
one. This practice is illegal. It is also illegal to routinely e!cuse patientsfrom co$payments and deductibles. 4A co$payment is a fi!ed amount paid
whenever an insured person receives specified health$care services. A
deductible is the amount that must be paid before the insurance company
starts paying. 5 It is legal to waive a fee for people with a genuine
financial hardship, but it is not legal to provide completely free care or
discounts to all patients or to collect only from those who have insurance.
)tudies have shown that if patients are re6uired to pay for even a small
portion of their care they will be better consumers and select items or
services because they are medically needed rather than because they
are free. 7outine waivers thus raise overall health costs. They are
considered fraudulent because averaging them with the doctor's full fees
would make the 3usual3 fees lower than the amounts actually billed for.
&ther illegal procedures include/
-harging for a service that was not performed.
8nbundling of claims/ *illing separately for procedures thatnormally are covered by a single fee. An e!ample would be a
podiatrist who operates on three toes and submits claims for three
separate operations.
ouble billing/ -harging more than once for the same service.
8p coding/ -harging for a more comple! service than was
performed. This usually involves billing for longer or more comple!
office visits 4for e!ample, charging for a comprehensive visit when
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
6/57
6
t
he patient was seen only briefly5, but it also can involve charging for
a more comple! procedure than was performed or for more
e!pensive e6uipment than was delivered. Medicare documentationguidelines describe what the various levels of service should
involve.
Miscoding/ 8sing a code number that does not apply to the
procedure.
9ickbacks/ 7eceiving payment or other benefit for making a
referral. Indirect kickbacks can involve overpayment for somethingof value.
or e!ample, a supplier whose business depends on physician
referrals may pay e!cessive rent to physicians who own the premises
and refer patients. Another e!ample would be a mobile testing servicethat performs diagnostic tests in a doctor's office. 9ickbacks can
distort medical decision$making, cause over utilization, increase costs,
and result in unfair competition by freezing out competitors who are
unwilling to pay kickbacks.
-riminals sometimes obtain Medicare numbers for fraudulent billing by
conducting a health survey, offering a free 3health screening3 test, paying
beneficiaries for their number, obtaining beneficiary lists from nursing
homes or boarding facilities, or offering 3free3 services, food, or supplies
to beneficiaries.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
7/57
7
!cessi"e or Inappropriate Testin#
Many standard tests can be useful in some situations but not in others.
The key 6uestion in #udging whether a diagnostic test is necessary is
whether the results will influence the management of the patient. *illing
for inappropriate tests:both standard and nonstandard:appears to be
much more common among chiropractors and #oint chiropractic0medical
practices than among other health$care providers. The commonly abused
tests include/
-omputerized inclinometers / Inclinometers is a procedure that
measures #oint fle!ibility. Inclinometer testing may be useful if
precise range$of$motion measurements are needed for a disability
evaluation, but routine or repeated measurements 3to gauge a
patient's progress3 are not appropriate.
;erve conduction studies / These tests can provide valuable
information about the status of nerve function in various
degenerative diseases and in some cases of in#ury. "owever,
3personal in#ury mills3 often use them inappropriately 3to 3follow the
progress3 of their patients.
Thermographs / Thermo$graphic devices portray small temperature
differences between sides of the body as images. -hiropractors
who use thermographs typically claim that it can detect nerve
impingements or 3nerve irritation3 and is useful for monitoring the
http://www.quackwatch.org/02ConsumerProtection/mill.htmlhttp://www.quackwatch.org/02ConsumerProtection/mill.html8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
8/57
8
effect of chiropractic ad#ustments on sublu!ations. These uses are
not appropriate.
8nnecessary !$rays /
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
9/57
9
many unrelated individuals who receive similar treatment from a small
number of providers.
&uac'ery()elated %iscodin#
In processing claims, insurance companies rely mainly on diagnostic and
procedural codes recorded on the claim forms. Their computers are
programmed to detect services that are not covered. Most insurance
policies e!clude nonstandard or e!perimental methods. To help boost
their income, many nonstandard practitioners misrepresent what they do.
They may also misrepresent their diagnosis. or e!ample/
*rief or intermediate$length visits may be coded as lengthy or
comprehensive visits.
2atients receiving chelating therapymay be falsely diagnosed as
suffering from lead poisoning1 and the chelating may be billed as
3infusion therapy3 or simply an office visit.
The administration of 6uack cancer remedies may be billed as
3chemotherapy.3
;onstandard allergy tests may be represented as standard ones.
Viatical Fraud
In viatical settlement transactions, people with terminal illnesses assign
their life insurance policies to viatical settlement companies in e!change
for a percentage of the policy's face value. The company, in turn, maysell the policy to a third$party investor. The company or the investor then
http://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/chelation.htmlhttp://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/chelation.htmlhttp://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/Tests/allergytests.htmlhttp://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/chelation.htmlhttp://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/Tests/allergytests.html8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
10/57
10
becomes the beneficiary to the policy, pays the premiums, and collects
the face value of the policy after the original policyholder dies.
raud occurs when agents recruit terminally ill people to apply for
multiple policies. They misrepresent the truth and answer 3no3 to all of the
medical 6uestions. "ealthy impostors then undergo the medical
evaluation. In many cases, the insurance agent who issues the policy is a
party to the scheme. The agent or one applicant may even submit the
same application to many insurance companies.
?iatical settlement companies then purchase the policies and sell them tounsuspecting third$party investors. The insurance industry is the biggest
victim of this fraud and could incur huge losses within the ne!t few years.
)ome investors receive nothing in return for their 3guaranteed3
investment.
*o#us +ealth Insurance Companies
There have been two reports issued concerning the sale of health
insurance plans that lack legal authorization. These plans place the buyer
at risk for financial disaster if serious illness strikes. &ne report focuses
on consumer vulnerability. The other notes that from >@@@ to >@@>, =
unauthorized entities enrolled at least =B,@@@ employers and more than
>@@,@@@ policyholders who got stuck for over C>@@ million in unpaid
claims.
The investigators found that many of the entitles bore names
similar to those of legitimate companies. In response to the report, the
"ealth Insurance Institute of America is again urging the ;ationalAssociation of Insurance -ommissioners to create an online database of
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
11/57
11
licensed health insurance companies so that anyone can easily check the
legitimacy of companies offering health insurance products. Meanwhile,
the -oalition against Insurance raud offers a few warning signs of a
possible swindle/
The plan readily accepts people with serious illnesses and other
medical conditions that other plans normally re#ect.
The insurance has few or no underwriting guidelines:the agent or
rep appears almost too eager to sign you up.
Dou're approached by an insurance agent, phone or direct mail.
"onest group plans normally are sponsored by your employer:
and aren't sold directly to individuals.
The plan isn't licensed in your state, and the agent 4falsely5 assures
you the federal E7I)A law e!empts the plan from state licensing.
The plan seems like insurance, but the agent or rep avoids calling
3insurance,3 and instead uses evasive terms such as 3benefits.3
The agent or rep doesn't have clear answers to your 6uestions,
seems ill$informed, or avoids sharing information.
Dou've never heard of that health insurance company:and nobody
else has, either.
Dour hospital keeps calling you to complain that your health plan
isn't paying your medical bills. &ften the plan's reps keep making
flimsy e!cuses, or stop returning phone calls altogether.
http://insurancefraud.org/bogus_health.htmhttp://insurancefraud.org/bogus_health.htmhttp://insurancefraud.org/bogus_health.htmhttp://insurancefraud.org/bogus_health.htm8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
12/57
12
Chapter ,
Schemes- scams- scammed
2roperty0casualty insurance fraud cost insurers about CF@ billion in >@@.raud may be committed at different points in the insurance transaction
by different parties/ applicants for insurance, policyholders, third$party
claimants and professionals who provide services to claimants.
-ommon frauds include 3padding,3 or inflating actual claims1
misrepresenting facts on an insurance application1 submitting claims forin#uries or damage that never occurred1 and 3staging3 accidents.
2rompted by the incidence of insurance fraud, about @ states have set
up fraud bureaus. These agencies are reporting a record number of new
investigations, significant increases in referrals : tip about suspected fraud :
and cases brought to prosecution.
)C.T /V0P%.TS
The hurricanes of >@@B, especially "urricane 9atrina, are likely to
result in a surge in insurance fraud. In addition to the usual
schemes, where homeowners or renters make claims for stereos,
televisions or other e!pensive items they never purchased, and
inflate claims for items actually destroyed, home arsons are on therise. )ince many homeowners in the Gulf areas did not have flood
insurance, they may not be covered for some or all of the damage
caused by the hurricanes. ozens of fires have broken out in many
affected communities, some of which may be the result of arson.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
13/57
13
The ;ational Insurance -rime *ureau 4;I-*5 says that by
;ovember >@@B, there were =H@,@@@ vehicles in its flooded motor
vehicle and boat database, which was set up by catastrophes
teams to combat title fraud in the hurricane$affected states. The
;I-* warns that flooded vehicles may be cleaned up, moved and
sold in other areas of the country by unscrupulous operators.
Although the vehicles were totaled by insurance companies and
identified as +salvage on their titles, which means they are not fit
for any use e!cept for scrap or parts, they could end up on the
market in states where it is relatively easy to apply for a regular
title. A database was created in which vehicle identification
numbers 4?I;s5 and boat hull identification numbers 4"I;s5 from
flooded vehicles and boats could be stored and made available to
law enforcers, state fraud bureaus, insurers and state departments
of motor vehicles.
&ne in =@ paid bodily in#ury liability 4*I5 auto claims in -alifornia
had the appearance of fraud or misrepresented the facts of the
claim, according to the Insurance 7esearch -ouncils raud. More
common is the appearance of buildup, or the padding of claims,
which was found in one in five claims. The study, released in
anuary >@@H, e!amined about JF,@@@ claims closed with payment
in >@@>. It found that between CF=K and CF> million in *I
payments were attributable to fraud and buildup.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
14/57
14
Chapter
)eal eyes333)eali4e333)eal lies5
Short +istory of Antifraud fforts
raud in insurance has undoubtedly e!isted since the industry's
beginnings in the seventeenth century, but it received little attention until
the =KL@s because law enforcement agencies had other priorities and
were reluctant to provide the training needed to investigate and
prosecute cases of insurance fraud. And, given the fine line between
investigating suspicious claims and harassing legitimate claimants, some
insurers were afraid that a concerted effort to eradicate fraud might be
perceived as an anti$consumer move. In addition, the need to comply with the time
re6uirements for paying claims imposed by fair claim practice regulations in many states made it
difficult to ade6uately investigate suspicious claims.
*ut by the mid$=KL@s the rising price of insurance, particularly auto and health insurance, together
with the growth in fraud committed by organized criminals, prompted many insurers to ree!amine
the issue. Gradually, insurers began to see the benefit of strengthening antifraud laws and more
stringent enforcement as a means of controlling escalating costs : a pro$consumer move : and
they found ready allies among those who been adversely affected by fraud. These included
consumers, who were paying for fraud through their insurance premiums1 the people used by
organized fraud groups to file false claims, often the poor, who sometimes found themselves on
the wrong side of the law1 and chiropractors and other medical professionals who were concerned
that their reputation as a group was being tarnished by organized fraud ringleaders who had
recruited their members to make fraudulent claims for treatment.
In their fight against fraud, insurers have also been hampered by public
attitudes. &ngoing studies by the Insurance 7esearch -ouncil show that
significant numbers of Americans think it is all right to inflate their
insurance claims to make up for all the insurance premiums they have
paid in previous years when they have had no claims, or to pad a claim to
make up for the deductible they would have to pay.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
15/57
15
Antifraud activity on the part of state fraud bureaus and )I8s 4special
investigative units within insurance companies5 increased in the =KK@s.
"eightened antifraud activity along with growth in funding for fraud$
fighting personnel resulted in increased prosecutions. )uccessfulprosecution not only blocks future fraudulent activities by individuals who
are repeat offenders, but news of prosecutions also acts as a deterrent to
others who may be contemplating committing fraudulent acts.
hile the focus initially was on auto insurance fraud, antifraud efforts
also encompass workers compensation fraud, where investigations are
directed toward employers who, to obtain a lower premium, misrepresent
their payroll or the type of work carried out by their employees. These two
factors impact premiums. 2ayroll is important because workers
compensation insurance provides for lost wages and insurers need to
know the ma!imum they would have to pay if all employees were in#ured
in the same accident1 the type of work carried out by the firm affects the
likelihood of in#uries. orkers that use cutting tools, for e!ample, are
more likely to get in#ured on the #ob than office workers. )ome employers
also apply for coverage under different names to foil attempts to recover
monies owed on previous policies or to avoid detection of their poor claim
record, which would put them in a higher rating category.
raud and abuse take place at many points in the health care system.
octors, hospitals, nursing homes, diagnostic facilities and attorneys
have been cited in scams to defraud the system. &ne huge area of fraud
is the Medicare and Medicaid systems. "ealth care is especially
susceptible to electronic data interchange 4EI5 fraud. EI is direct filing
of claims : computer to computer : and is widely used for Medicare
claims.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
16/57
16
In =KKK, the Government Accounting &ffice released a study of the
Medicare, Medicaid and private health insurance sectors that confirmed
that organized crime is heavily involved in health care fraud. The
investigation found that in seven cases of health care fraud studied,about =H@ health related groups : medical clinics, physician groups,
labs or medical suppliers : had submitted fraudulent claims. The
criminals identified in the report were not health care workers but
criminals already prosecuted for securities fraud, forgery and auto theft.
Apparently, these criminals had moved to health care because fraud was
relatively easy to accomplish.
Anti(Fraud Pro#rams
)everal large insurance companies have #oined forces through the
;ational "ealth -are Anti$raud Association to develop sophisticated
computer systems to detect suspicious billing patterns. The ederal*ureau of Investigation 4*I5 and the &ffice of the Inspector General
4&IG5each have assigned hundreds of special agents to health$fraud
pro#ects. The -oalition Against Insurance raud,a public advocacy and
educational organization founded in =KKF, includes consumers as well as
government agencies and insurers.
The &mnibus -onsolidated Appropriation Act of =KKJ authorized a
"ealth -are Anti$raud, aste, and Abuse -ommunity ?olunteer
emonstration 2rogram to further reduce fraud and abuse in the
Medicare and Medicaid programs. The program enrolled thousands of
retired accountants, health professionals, investigators, teachers, and
other community volunteers to help Medicare beneficiaries and others to
detect and report fraud, waste, and abuse.
http://www.nhcaa.org/http://www.fbi.gov/http://www.fbi.gov/http://www.oig.gov/http://www.oig.gov/http://www.insurancefraud.org/http://www.insurancefraud.org/home.htmlhttp://www.nhcaa.org/http://www.fbi.gov/http://www.fbi.gov/http://www.oig.gov/http://www.oig.gov/http://www.insurancefraud.org/http://www.insurancefraud.org/home.html8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
17/57
17
The Inspector General's office has recovered over a billion dollars
through fines and settlements. Its &peration 7estore Trust, which began
in =KKB, was a #oint federal$state program aimed at fraud, waste, and
abuse in three high$growth areas of Medicare and Medicaid/ home healthagencies, nursing homes, and durable medical e6uipment suppliers. The
6uestionable activities included/
*illing for advanced life support services when basic life support
was provided. ocumentation may be falsified to indicate a patient
needed o!ygen:which is a key indicator in establishing medical
necessity for advanced life support.
*illing for larger amounts of drugs than are dispensed1 or billing for
brand$name drugs when less e!pensive generic versions are
dispensed.
*illing for more miles than traveled for transportation.
alsification of documentation to substantiate the need for a
transport from a hospital back to the patient's home. Medicare will
only cover transport from hospital to home if the patient could not
go by any other means.
Insurers6 Antifraud %easures
Insurance companies are not law enforcement agencies. They can only
identify suspicious claims, withhold payment where fraud is suspectedand to #ustify their actions by collecting the necessary evidence to use in
a court. The success of the battle against insurance fraud therefore
depends on two elements/ the resources devoted by the insurance
industry itself to detecting fraud and the level of priority assigned by
legislators, regulators, law enforcement agencies and society as a whole
to eradicating it.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
18/57
18
Many insurance companies have established special investigation units
4)I8s5 to help identify and investigate suspicious claims1 some insurance
companies outsource their units to other insurers.
These units range from a small team, whose primary role is to train claim
representatives to deal with the more routine kinds of fraud cases, to
teams of trained investigators, including former law enforcement officers,
attorneys, accountants and claim e!perts to thoroughly investigate
fraudulent activities. More comple! cases, involving large scale criminal
operations or individuals that repeatedly stage accidents, may be turnedover to the ;ational Insurance -rime *ureau 4;I-*5. This insurance
industry$sponsored organization has special e!pertise in preparing fraud
cases for trial and serves as a liaison between the insurance industry and
law enforcement agencies. In addition, it publicizes the arrest and
conviction of the perpetrators of insurance fraud to help deter future
criminal activities. Insurance company surveys confirm that )I8s
dramatically impact the bottom line of many insurance companies.
In the mid$=KK@s insurers said that for every dollar they invested in
antifraud efforts, including )I8s, they got up to C>J back, but these
returns have become harder to achieve as the more apparent fraud
schemes have been uncovered and more effort is necessary to ferret out
the sophisticated fraud that remains. A >@@@ study by -onning 7esearch
N -onsulting suggests that results vary widely. 8sing the ratio of +claims
e!posure reduction to the e!pense of running )I8s, the study found
ratios ranging from a low of F to = to a high of >J to =, depending on the
year and line of insurance. Although some insurers are cutting back on
fraud investigation by outsourcing investigations and dissolving their
fraud units, advances in software technology, especially programs that
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
19/57
19
sift though the millions of claims that large health insurers process
annually, are proving effective in fighting fraud. These +data mining
programs can uncover repetitions and anomalies and analyze links to
fraudulent activities or entities.
The consolidation of insurance industry claims databases has put a
valuable new tool in the hands of investigators. The Insurance )ervices
&ffice Inc.'s system, known as -laim)earch, utilizes a data$mining program. -laim
)earch is the worlds largest comprehensive database of claims information. The ;I-* has
developed a program called 2redictive 9nowledge that collects and analyzes information which
can be disseminated to insurers and law enforcement agencies to detect, investigate and prevent
insurance fraud. In addition, the ;I-*, in partnership with iMapata Inc., introduced -AT fraud, to
identify potentially fraudulent catastrophe0weather$related insurance claims.
A national fraud academy : a #oint initiative of the 2roperty -asualty
Association of America, the *I, ;I-* and the International Association
of )pecial Investigating 8nits : was designed to fight insurance claims
fraud by educating and training fraud investigators. It offers online
classes under the leadership of the ;I-*.
An emerging issue for insurers using data sharing services is their impact
on privacy. inancial institutions, including insurers, must respect the
privacy of their customers and protect their personal information, a
practice that may deter efforts to combat fraud.
Insurers may also file civil lawsuits under the federal 7acketeering
Influenced and -orrupt &rganizations Act 47I-&5, which re6uires proving
a preponderance of evidence rather than the stricter rules of evidence
re6uired in criminal actions and allows for triple damages. )ince =KKJ,
some of the largest insurers in the country, especially auto insurers, have
been filing and winning lawsuits against individuals and organized rings
that perpetrate insurance fraud.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
20/57
20
Chapter 7
Itchin# To 8no9 Who Can +elp?
Insurance A#ent Fraud on the )ise
Two years ago, at the age of K@, Thomas 2ickering was doing the
twist.At the behest of his trusted insurance agent, 2ickering was buying
and selling one annuity after another in a deceitful industry practice called
3twisting.3 That's when dishonest agents persuade clients to cash in one
investment for another:against their clients' best interests and for theagents' own financial gain.
In 2ickering's case, he followed his agent's advice, sold investments
before they matured and lost ==,@@@0$ in forfeited interest and penalties.
"e was about to lose another FB,@@@0$ cashing in one annuity to buy
another,netting his agent >@,@@@0$ in commissions. hen the company
holding the annuity intervened. It suspected 2ickering was getting ripped
off and called the authorities.An investigation led lorida's epartment of
inancial )ervices 4)5 to revoke agent 2eter aldon's license for
fraud.
*arry %anier of lorida's ) says he's fielding more complaints about
greedy agents earning whopping commissions upfront by pitchingunsuitable investments like annuities to older people. *ut %anier and
other e!perts say some annuities are not considered to be wise
investments for most olders because they're based on life
e!pectancy.Growing concern over the sale of annuities to older people
prompted the ;ational Association of Insurance -ommissioners 4;AI-5
to adopt regulations that assure that the annuities are suitable to the
buyer's needs.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
21/57
21
Chapter :
/i"ision of Insurance Fraud
The ivision of Insurance raud was originally formed in =KJH to
investigate only fraudulent automobile tort claims. In the early years,
investigators had arrest powers but could not carry firearms. Today, the
division investigates all types of insurance fraud crimes.
Investigators are assigned to work general fraud cases, workers
compensation fraud, medical and health$care fraud, and agent and
company fraud. Areas of assignment may include/
OInsolvency $ raud committed by insurance companies that fail
financially due to internal fraud by owners and corporate officers.
O8nauthorized Entities $ fraud, both criminal and civil, committed
by insurance companies operating illegally in the state.
O"ealth -are raud $ focuses on organized medical and health
care scams.
Oorkers -ompensation $ investigates employers for workers
compensation premium fraud.
O2ublic Employee raud $ investigates state and local government
employees for workers compensation claimant fraud.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
22/57
22
Chapter ;
/ecepti"e 0ife Insurance Sales Practices
Continue
The life insurance industry has been hit with billion dollar verdicts and
multi$million dollar fines for deceptive sales practices.
The two largest companies, Met%ife and 2rudential, have each been hit
with billion$dollar$plus verdict.
Most ma#or companies have also been sued for deceptive sales
practices. The list goes on and on, as successful lawsuits finally caught
up with an industry that has long bilked the public, misrepresented its
product, and ignored the urgent need for basic reforms to stop abuses.
ith billion dollar #udgments 4and that is 3billion3 with a 3b35, you'd think
the industry would learn its lesson. That's what you'd think but you'd be
wrong.
The life insurance industry did establish the Insurance Marketplace
)tandards Association 4IM)A5. &f course, there are now ads announcing
that the life insurance industry is committed to the fair treatment of
policyholders. *ut early returns on the industry's efforts suggest it is #ust a
sham and a shell game designed to prevent real reform by legislation and
regulation.
;ow a study by 2rofessor oseph *elth, publisher of the Insurance
7eform, a respected newsletter on the life insurance industry, finds the
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
23/57
23
reforms are a sham. I'd have to say as usual the life insurance industry
wants to improve its public relations, not its policy relations.
The Insurance orum study correctly notes that much of the lifeinsurance deception comes about because the industry does not make
full disclosure on rates of return and prices necessary to sound decision
making by insurance buyers. *y failing to disclose needed information,
consumers are easily duped by deceptive methods.
The Insurance orum put the industry to a test by asking the chiefe!ecutive officers of @ companies 4F= of which are members of IM)A5
for the kind of information that should be freely and automatically
available to prospective policyholders.
&f the = companies surveyed, >J did not participate. &nly =F companies
4=@ of which are members of IM)A5 participated in the study.
And some of the =F participants provided deceptive information. )ome
provided incomplete information. )ome provided the kind of information
that would not be helpful to the typical consumer.
The Insurance orum study concludes that IM)A will not bring about the
needed changes in the life insurance industry, but will simply delay their
enactment. Most industries prefer 3voluntary3 action, so the fo!es can
continue to guard 4and eat5 the chickens, also known as policyholders.
hat's more, after the great life insurance scandals of the =KL@s and
=KK@s, the industry is determined to perpetuate a system in which life
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
24/57
24
insurance rip$offs by ma#or and minor companies alike will continue to be
standard operating procedures.
The bottom line is that the life insurance industry has practices that areprecisely the opposite of its proclaimed ethical principles.
"ere are some e!amples/
IM)A has an ethical principle that says its company members will
3provide competent and customer$focused sales and services.3 The
Insurance orum survey suggests that most companies will engage inbusiness as usual, giving the consumer no information, inade6uate
information or deceptive information.
IM)A has another ethical principle that says it will 3engage in active and
fair competition.3 *ut by not providing information or by providing
deceptive information, it is clear that ma#or segments of the industry will
continue to engage in competition by confusion.
As *ob "unter of the -onsumer ederation put it, 3The proof of the
pudding is in the eating. It's hard to trust the life insurance industry, given
its recent history. They're going to have to reprove themselves as
trustworthy.3
8nfortunately, the life insurance industry is proving itself untrustworthy.
And as for the proof of its good intention being in the pudding, my advice
is don't eat its pudding. It's the same old stuff plus a phony sermon on
ethical principles.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
25/57
25
Chapter @P is then paid to the insured's estate.
&n the other hand, the business of viatical settlements involves the
selling of a policy death benefit, at less than face value, by a terminally ill
person to a third party. This is accomplished, for a commission, with the
assistance of a broker who offers the policies to settlement provider
companies for bid, with the highest bidder obtaining the policy for resale
to investors. The broker receives a commission based on the sale price.
Si4e of the Industry
raud in the unregulated viatical settlement industry has become
rampant1 as much as @$B@P of the life insurance policies viaticated may
have been procured by fraud.
Clean Sheetin#
8nscrupulous individuals in the viatical industry procure policies by a
practice referred to as 3clean sheeting3 which is the act of applying for life
insurance while intentionally failing to disclose the applicant's status as
being terminally ill. They can get away with it initially because most
insurance companies avoid the added costs and invasiveness of medical
e!ams and blood tests by relying on an honor system below a certain
policy face value.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
26/57
26
Many insurance agents and brokers assist and often encourage aviators
in committing the fraud because it not only provides more policies than
would be available though legitimate means, but it also provides a much
higher rate of return due to the fact they can be bought from aviators so
cheaply.
In a legitimate transaction, the ill person usually receives B@P$J@P of the
face value of the policy. "owever, a 3clean sheeted3 policy viaticated
during the contestable period may offer as little as =@P of the face value
because it carries the high risk of rescission, or cancellation by the
insurance company, due to fraud.
Wet In' Policies
After the policy is issued, the insured person will sell his policy or multiple
policies from different insurance companies, sometimes within weeks, to
a settlement provider using a broker. This is referred to as a 3wet ink
policy3 because the ink on the contract is still 3wet3 when the policy is
sold.
The odds against an individual finding out that he is terminally ill within
weeks of buying a policy are e!ceedingly high. To see that happenrepeatedly within a short period of time with the same broker or provider
is strong evidence that they are both well aware that the policies have
been 3clean sheeted3.
To hide the fact that the policy has been viaticated shortly after issuance,
con artists will obscure viatication by simply changing the beneficiary to
someone at the settlement provider firm. A second way is to employ a
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
27/57
27
3collateral assignment3 which is similar to where the insured seeks a loan
from a third party and secures the loan by pledging the death benefits of
the policy. In fraudulent transactions they pledge the death benefits but
do not receive a loan.
Contestability Period
inally, some settlement providers merely delay reporting that the policy
has been viaticated until the contestability period is over1 falsely believing
that it is not a crime then. An indication of culpability is that virtually all
parties attempt to hide the viatication of fraudulently obtained policies
from the insurance company for as long as possible.
The contestability clause for life insurance lasts for two years after
issuance, during which time it may be rescinded by the insurer for fraud
in the application. After this period ends, the insurer is obligated to paythe death benefit, regardless of any fraud in the application. *ecause
policies viaticated during the contestability period may be rescinded, they
bring, as mentioned, a much lower price in the market.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
28/57
28
Chapter =
A Case Study
As an investor, you are offered the opportunity to purchase an interest in
a life insurance policy in which the insured is terminally ill 4i.e., viatical
settlement5.
Dou are told/
that your investment will produce a =@@P rate of return because you are
assigned a policy with a face value of twice your investment which you can
claim upon their death1
that you will have the option of reselling your policy once it becomes
incontestable 4two years after the date the policy is issued5 for J@P of the
face value1
and that if the policy is contested or canceled by the insurer, the
promoters will provide a replacement policy through a 3replacement policy
trust3 managed by them.
They say these are better investments than stocks, mutual funds,
annuities, and -'s because viatical investments have the following
attributes/
>Full li@uidity at maturity from roc' solid A rated insurance
companiesB
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
29/57
29
>Ta! ad"anta#ed hassle freeB 1DDE fi!ed rate of return 9hich is
fully secured3
>ero ris' to principal- a totally safe in"estment 9ith no load no
feesB
>Short holdin# periods 9ith early buyout options a"ailable as
9ellB
>.o speculation- no interest rate ris'- no mar'et ris'- no
economic ris'B
In addition they say you will be making a 3humanitarian investment3
because the terminally ill person will be able to use the funds to receive
improved health care1 pay off debts1 take a vacation, reduce family
stress, and enhance their 6uality of life. In e!change for your money you
receive a Membership -ertificate certifying that you are a member of
?iatical unding %%-.
After deducting the fees paid to sales agents, viator agents, and other
intermediaries from your funds, you find that the ill person will actually be
left with very little. In this case only CB,@@, which is only =>P of your
investment of CB,@@@, or HP of the policy's face value of CK@,@@@.
They fail to disclose to you that the insured was terminally ill prior tobeing insured, that they concealed this fact on the application, and thus
sub#ected the policy to cancellation by the insurer.
Instead of being designated as the sole beneficiary you may find you
share it with creditors and family members, and that the option to resell
the ownership interests is not a guaranteed option, but rather an
3assurance3 that they will 3make an effort3 to facilitate a resale.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
30/57
30
In any event, you will not likely receive a promised J@P of the face value
but only the amount another investor would be willing to pay, less
commissions, which could be much less.
They also fail to mention/
the risk of the insured living much longer than the estimated life
e!pectancy, thereby greatly reducing the annual yield1
the risk of their becoming insolvent and unable to replace a contested
or canceled policy1
the risk of the life insurance policy lapsing, or that you will often have to
pay the policy premiums for the duration of the policyholder's life1
the =BP commission the sales agent receives from your investment1
who is responsible for monitoring the health status and location of the
insured, obtaining a death certificate, and making a claim to the insurance
company.
0ife !pectancy of the Insured
To determine their rate of return investors rely on a report which pro#ects
the life e!pectancy of the insured, but there are no minimum
re6uirements as to who may generate these reports or pro#ections. &ne
company used a nurse and a plastic surgeon but could have used the
#anitor.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
31/57
31
?iatical investing is highly speculative and risky. Even when the
policyholder e!ists and is terminally ill, there is a high degree of
uncertainty in predicting when they will die. ;ew AI) drugs and cancer
treatments have compounded the risk for investors because they helppolicyholders live longer.
?iatical settlements are illegal under -anadian insurance legislation so
-anadian investors should not be involved in these schemes at all.
.ot nou#h Sic' People
inancial ederated Title N Trust, and Asset )ecurity -orporation pled
guilty after being charged with conspiring to recruit insurance agents to
defraud more than F,@@@ investors while purchasing viaticated insurance
policy investments over a three year period.
Investors were told that their money would be used to purchase a
beneficial interest in viaticated insurance policies, and that medicaloverviews were being performed on the insured persons whose policies
were being bought.
Although at least C==B million in investor monies was taken in, the
promoters used only CH million of these funds to buy insurance policies
whose total face value was #ust over CJ million. They used the balance of
the money for purposes totally unrelated to the purchase of viaticated
insurance policies.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
32/57
32
Industry Terminolo#y
Cleansheetin#G 7efers to a fraudulent criminal act committed by a
proposed life insurance applicant, and by life insurance agents who
knowingly assist or conspire with the insurance applicants, by failing to
disclose a pre$e!isting medical condition in response to a 6uestion on a
life insurance application which would affect issuance of the policy
ViatorGA person who has a life threatening or terminal illness who sells
or assigns their life insurance policy.
Viatical SettlementGThe life insurance policy of a terminally ill person
sold or offered for sale, generally at less than face value, through a
viatical settlement company.
ContestabilityG2olicies are generally contestable for two years from the
date of issue and are sub#ect to being rescinded by the insurer for cause,
such as application fraud and suicide.
Viatical Settlement Pro"iderGA person who enters into a viatical
settlement contract with a viator. &ften referred to as a settlement
company or funder.
Viatical Settlement *ro'erGA person who, for profit, offers or attempts
to negotiate a settlement contract between a viator and one or more
viatical settlement providers.
Viatical Settlement Sales A#entGA person other than a licensed viatical
settlement provider who arranges for the purchase of a viatical settlement
or an interest in a viatical settlement from a viatical settlement provider.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
33/57
33
%ortality Profile )eportG A report based on a review of a viator's
medical history, which gives a prognosis of a viators life e!pectancy.
8sually done by a health$care professional and generally at the behest of
the viatical settlement provider to calculate the value of a viatical
contract.
Viatical In"estment *ro'erGefines a person or entity other than a
licensed viatical settlement provider who solicits investors to purchase a
viatical settlement interest from a viatical settlement provider.
We Chose to 8eep Hour %oney
Personal Choice pportunities mislead investors when they sold
viatical securities in the form of loan transactions. Investors lent money to
2-& in order for them to purchase the benefits of life insurance policies
from terminally ill individuals on the promise that they would receive a
return on their investment of >=$>BP per annum.
The funds, however, were not used to purchase life insurance policies
but kept instead. &ver ==@@ investors nationwide are believed to haveinvested CL@$=@@ million in these transactions in #ust ten months. ;o
evidence of any valid life insurance policies being purchased has been
discovered.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
34/57
34
)epercussions for the Industry
%ife insurance premiums are based on actuarial tables which are
worthless in fraudulent applications. Insurance companies cannot afford
to pay out large death benefits after collecting small premiums for only a
few years. Even if they don't go bankrupt the added costs are eventually
passed on to other policyholders.
The viatical industry as a whole must take steps to better police itself. If it
does not, it risks ceasing to e!ist as an industry either by being legislated
out of e!istence or by being pushed out of the market after destroying
investor confidence in its product. If this fraud is to be stopped, it will
re6uire the total commitment of the insurance industry. The first step is
for the industry to wake up to the e!istence and scope of the problem.
Penalties
-urrently a person charged with viaticating a fraudulently procured
insurance policy worth C=@@,@@@ face value, who stands to gain tens of
thousands of dollars, faces the same penalty as a shoplifter who takes a
pack of cigarettes. A mere si!ty days in #ail is an encouragement, not adeterrent which may be why the industry watchdog has never received a
single referral from the industry itself reporting such fraud.
0ife Settlements
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
35/57
35
&nce thriving on those dying from a terminal illness, medical advances,
which are helping patients live longer, has caused the business to start
targeting new clients $ usually seniors with high payoffs $ who may be
willing to sell their life insurance policy to investors at a discount.
%ife settlements, or the sale of a life insurance policy to a third party, are
sometimes referred to as 3senior settlements3 because most of the life
insurance policies purchased insure the life of a senior citizen.
The owner of the policy gets cash and the buyer becomes the new owner
and0or beneficiary of the life insurance policy, pays all future premiumsand collects the entire death benefit when the insured dies.
2eople decide to sell their life insurance policies for many reasons. )ome
common ones are the changed needs of dependents, a desire to reduce
or eliminate premiums, and a need for additional cash to meet e!penses.
)tate regulation of insurance generally does not e!tend to lifesettlements. -ertain aspects of these transactions may fall under the
various )ecurities Acts so there can be financial risks involved when
entering into such arrangements.
Dou should consider contacting a professional ta! advisor to find out the
ta! implications as life settlement proceeds are generally not ta! free.
Also know, if you are the seller that you will be re6uired to provide certain
medical and personal information to third parties who will be paid the
proceeds from your policy upon your death. These third parties may sell
your policy and pass along your medical and personal information to
other individuals.
Typically, life settlements are offered to buyers, for resale to investors, ata discount from the death benefit. The discount is for the entire life of the
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
36/57
36
policy, not an annual rate of return. An annual rate of return cannot be
guaranteed. Dour rate of return depends on when the insured dies, and
no one can predict a person's life e!pectancy. 9eep in mind that a life
settlement is not a li6uid investment because the return on such aninvestment does not occur until the insured dies.
Spreadin# the )is'
The Alabama )ecurities -ommission issued a -ease and esist &rder
against Viatical lderly Settlement Pro"iders- 00C VSP)SJ
ashington, .-., to stop conducting business in a few states after they
received information that they were engaged in the illegal offer and sale
of investment contracts involving fractionalized viatical settlement
contracts there.
?E)2E7), though not licensed to sell this type of security in the state,have solicited independent insurance agents to sell interests in viaticals
issued by them with promises of low risk and high returns of >L$J@
percent on two to five year investments for a =@P commission.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
37/57
37
Chapter 1D
*e A9are- /on6t *e a Victim
The -oalition Against Insurance raud 4-AI5 is a national advocacy
organization of consumer groups, public interest organizations,
government agencies and insurers. Its website notes +insurance fraud is
hard to measure because so much goes undetected, and complete
research has yet to be done. )till, we have enough evidence to know that
fraud is widespread : and e!pensive.=
;ational studies conducted by the Insurance 7esearch -ouncil 4I7-5
show that auto insurance, workers compensation and health insurance
are the lines that are most vulnerable to fraud. The I7- estimates that
one$third of all bodily in#ury claims from auto accidents contain some
amount of fraud, usually in terms of padding or e!aggerating a claim, but
only FP are totally fraudulent such as staged accidents. Another form of
fraud, lying on applications in order to reduce premium, costs auto
insurers C=F.J billion annually 4Insurance Information Institute, or III5.
As to workers compensation fraud, one of the most common forms of
workers compensation fraud in Maine is a faked or e!aggerated in#ury,
an area within the #urisdiction of the Maine orkers -ompensation*oards raud and Abuse 8nit to investigate. There are, however, other
forms of workers compensation fraud are employers who misrepresent
payroll or the type of business in order to reduce their insurance
premiums and real or bogus entities that purport to provide real or bogus
workers compensation coverage or +alternatives to coverage to
employers.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
38/57
38
In late =KKK the Governmental Accounting &ffice found that organized
crime is heavily involved in health insurance fraud and that the criminals
identified were not health care workers, per say, but individuals already
prosecuted for securities fraud, forgery and auto theft. ith theenactment of "I2AA 4"ealth Insurance 2ortability and Accountability Act
of =KKH5 detection and prosecution of health insurance fraud received a
boost. The epartment of ustice calls health care fraud and abuse its
number two law enforcement priority, after violent crimes. In =KKH,
according to the *I, -ongress provided an added CB million over
seven years for health care fraud enforcement.
2roperty insurance, based upon the *ureaus >@@ data, had the third
highest fraud and abuse count by line of business at =HB reported cases.
According to the ;ational ire 2rotection Association, arson or suspected
arson account for nearly B@@,@@@ fires each year, or one in four fires in
the 8nited )tates. Arson and suspected arson are the largest causes of
property damage in the 8.).
espite what may appear to be a bleak picture, a number of tools e!ist
for combating fraud. In addition to those Maine Insurance and -riminal
-ode provisions, previously discussed, several federal laws are used to
address fraud. These include/ The ederal Mail raud )tatute, the
7acketeer Influenced and -orrupt &rganizations 47I-&5 and the "ealth
Insurance 2ortability and Accountability Act 4"I2AA5. Also, the ?iolent
-rime -ontrol and %aw Enforcement Act of =KK makes insurance fraud
a federal crime when it affects interstate commerce.
-ertain state agencies work with insurers to address fraud, as well. The
orkers -ompensation *oards raud and Abuse 8nit tackles issues
such as fakes or e!aggerated in#uries, the ire Marshals &ffice
investigates possible arson, and the epartment of "uman )ervices
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
39/57
39
takes on Medicare and Medicaid fraud. 7ecently, one ") employee
received the &ffice of the Inspector General Integrity Award for her
investigative and logistical support in a Medicare and Medicaid fraud
case in *angor ederal -ourt.
raud has also gotten the attention of the ;ational Association of
Insurance -ommissioners 4;AI-5, which encourages the insurance
industry to take a proactive role in controlling fraud. The ;AI- offers
states support through their Antifraud Task orce.
The mission of the Antifraud Task orce is to serve the public interest by
assisting state insurance supervisory officials, individually and
collectively, in the following fundamental antifraud activities/
2romotion of the public interest through the detection, monitoring
and appropriate referral for investigation of insurance crime, both
by and against consumers.
2rovision of assistance to the insurance regulatory communitythrough the maintenance and improvement of electronic databases
regarding fraudulent insurance activities.
isseminate the results of research and analysis of insurance fraud
trends as well as case$specific analysis to the insurance regulatory
community and state and federal law enforcement agencies.
2rovision of the liaison function between insurance regulators, law
enforcement and other specific antifraud organizations.
"ighlights of the >@@ charges of the Antifraud Task orce include/
compile and maintain detailed information on antifraud databases
maintained by antifraud organizations, financial regulators, and law
enforcement1 consider developing further guidelines for use by the
industry in determining when suspicious claims should be reported1
review industry compliance with antifraud initiatives1 develop methods to
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
40/57
40
enhance the investigation and prosecution of financial services fraud1 and
establish guidelines on the investigation and prosecution of insider
insurance industry fraud.=H
Additionally, in >@@B the ;AI- created a +raud eb line, an online
insurance fraud reporting system located on the eb site of the ;ational
Association of Insurance -ommissioners 4;AI-5. The system allows
consumers to provide information anonymously.
The new fraud reporting system was developed as part of the response
by insurance regulators to the national allegations about misconductinvolving compensation agreements between some insurance companies
and brokers. The allegations of improper activity spurred regulators to
improve their abilities to collect information from consumers, producers
and insurance company employees. Many places participates in the
online fraud reporting system, in con#unction with the ;AI-.
The online fraud reporting system lets consumers anonymously supply
detailed information regarding suspected fraudulent activities to the ;AI-
where the information is then forwarded to the appropriate state.
Although consumers may identify themselves, no personal identifying
information is re6uired to report an allegation of suspected fraud.
-onsumers are re6uired to designate the state where the suspected
fraud occurred and the name and address of the business or individual. A
te!t bo! is included for the consumer to provide the details of the
suspected fraud. &ther optional fields on the form include phone number,
date of birth, date of suspected fraud, and amount of loss.
espite the anti$fraud activities of state and federal agencies discussed
above, the *ureau notes that an enforcement and prosecutorial gap
e!ists in current Maine government operations insofar as no entity e!ists
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
41/57
41
that is focused on investigation and prosecution of fraudulent insurance
acts and the crimes of insurance deception and deceptive insurance acts.
The American Insurance Association and the 2roperty -asualty Insurers
Association and several of the individual fraud investigators whocommented as interested persons all noted the frustration when hard
work has been e!pended to develop a case and local prosecutors have
refused to prosecute or believe that it is not a serious crime meriting their
attention. The interested persons believe that a strong and effective
insurance fraud unit would be effective not only in punishing those
convicted of insurance fraud, but in deterring others.
orty other states currently have insurance fraud units. The irector of
the raud ivision of the ;ew "ampshire Insurance epartment shared
his concern with the oint )tanding -ommittee on Insurance and
inancial )ervices during his testimony on %.. =BH= that organized
insurance fraud rings are gravitating toward those #urisdictions with the
least regulation, for the conduct of affairs. That concern has been echoed
by other interested persons as well.
K) %ISSI.G
The mission of the ;AI- is to assist state insurance regulators,
individually and collectively, in serving the public interest and achieving
the following fundamental insurance regulatory goals in a responsive,
efficient and cost effective manner, consistent with the wishes of its
members/
Protect the public interest;
Promote competitive markets;
Facilitate the fair and equitable treatment of insurance
consumers;
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
42/57
42
Promote the reliability, solvency and financial solidity of
insurance institutions;
andSupport and improve state regulation of insurance.
Chapter 11
International association of insurance fraud
a#enciesIAIFAJ
+W do they operate?
The IAIA and its members are continually working to improve the 6uality
of data available to members and break down the #urisdictional barriers
by working with regulators, companies and other law enforcement
agencies.Those who break the law are adept at using these #urisdictional
boundaries as a protective shield. IAIA is trying to cut red tape involved
in the various 4often necessary5 #urisdictions' 3privacy3 laws in an attempt
to track down crime and encourage other enforcement agencies to share
information to the mutual benefit of all who are involved in assuring a
high level of integrity throughout the insurance industry.
W+AT are their Loals?
IAIA's goal is 3to co$ordinate the efforts, training and education of law
enforcement agencies, government bodies, and the insurance industry to
move more efficiently prevent and combat insurance fraud worldwide.3
IAIA has kept its focus on insurance fraud, which its members view as a
crime against all segments of society $ not a victimless felony, as some
would define it.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
43/57
43
W+. do they meet?
IAIA meets annually. The annual conferencehosts eminent speakers
whose presentations update the members on critical developments. It
also enhances personal contacts and e!change of information between
members throughout the year.
IAIA cooperates in regional seminars which focuses on such topics as
how to effectively use the laws to prosecute and recover assets gained
by fraudulent means. Added to this, these meetings have widened the
network of contacts for members from Europe, Asia, Australia, the
-aribbean, Africa, and ;orth America.
*etween meetings, our ne9sletter keeps members informed of the
various pro#ects undertaken by the Association and its members, as well
as presenting new trends in the field of insurance fraud, both from a
criminal and law enforcement perspective.
W+) are they found?
International is the first word in IAIA's name. That means what it says.
hile IAIA began in ;orth America, the founders were not so insular to
believe that they had a uni6ue place in insurance fraud. More than ever,
sharing intelligence and finding ways to successfully prevent and combat
crimes is essential for the members to do their #ob effectively.
http://www.iaifa.org/meeting.htmhttp://www.iaifa.org/meeting.htm8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
44/57
44
This is why the IAIA wants even more countries to #oin in this worldwide
effort. It is a classic case of the sum of the whole being greater than the
sum of its parts. The interchange of information is invaluable, and should
be available to everyone in their fight against sophisticated global fraud
W+ are the members?
It could be you and your organization. IAIA's members include
government insurance departments and fraud bureaus, law enforcement
agencies, respected insurance companies, and related firms with a
strong interest in combating insurance frauds.
Dou may obtain the application by logging on the site or by contacting us
for a mailing of the application. 8pon receipt, your application will be
considered by IAIA's e!ecutive committee. If you are accepted, you andyour organization will have made a ma#or step forward in beating
insurance crime. This will be true not only for you in your own #urisdiction,
but for your colleagues elsewhere, who will welcome hearing how you
cope with escalating problems of insurance fraud.
W+H 9ere they formed?
Insurance fraud is recognized internationally as a multi$billion dollar
problem. IAIA was created after a group consisting of the irectors of
Insurance raud Agencies from the 8.).A. and -anada met to confront
this burgeoning problem which is not restricted by #urisdictional
boundaries.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
45/57
45
It soon became apparent that if the agencies could share information
they would increase their degree of effectiveness. 7apid communication
is of the essence in catching fraud artists who know how to move money
literally at the speed of light. rom those early beginnings in =KLH, withonly a handful of members in ;orth America, IAIA now encompasses
the Globe.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
46/57
46
Chapter 12
/ealin# 9ith fraud on the .et
As time goes on, the number of attacks will only increase and network
forensics will become a part of our lives, who could put you on the track
by helping record and analyse previous security threats.
In a perfect world, network security wouldnt be re6uired. 8nfortunately
this isnt a perfect world, and even if there are many who will throw up a
firewall and other such security measures as solutions, this doesnt stop
the problem. ;o firewall is impenetrable and theres no such thing as a
perfect security measure. Theres always a way to get around them, and
the number of people trying to do that keeps increasing.
According to the 8) General Accounting &ffice, appro!imately >B@,@@@
break$ins were attempted into ederal computer systems alone in =KKBand this number gets bigger every year. &nly one to four per cent of
these attacks ever get detected.
;etwork forensics is the capture, recording, and analysis of network
events in order to discover the source of security attacks or other
problem incidents. It attempts to prevent hackers from attacking asystem, and searches for evidence after an attack has occurred.
There are three parts to network forensics/ intrusion detection1 logging
4the best way to track down a hacker is to keep vast records of activity on
a network with the help of an intrusion detection system51 correlating
intrusion detection and logging.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
47/57
47
The ultimate goal of network forensics is to provide sufficient evidence to
allow the criminal perpetrator to be successfully prosecuted. The practical
applications could be in areas such as hacking, fraud, insurancecompanies, data theft:industrial espionage, defamation, narcotics
trafficking, credit card cloning, software piracy, electoral law, obscene
publication, per#ury, murder, se!ual harassment, and discrimination.
Technical Challen#es
IT managers, network consultants, auditors, software developers, and
analysts would all like to understand the data that is sent over their
corporate networks. ;etwork monitoring is an essential tool for network
optimization and security. "ow much data was sent( hen( hat was
sent( -urrent tools only answer the first two 6uestions, and have trouble
with the third. The tools base their analysis primarily on I2 and T-2
headers, which can be misleading or intentionally falsified.
This leaves security consultants and network managers to manually sift
through raw network packet dumps, piece together data streams and
undo transfer encoding, and seek to understand the significance of a
single connection. This is tremendously time$consuming and since
networks deal with one packet at a time, this isnt very useful or complete
to someone trying to get a big picture view of an employees suspected
network abuse, or a deep$level view of an intrusion attempt.
And yet the internet is critical, and we havent a choice but to connect
internal networks to the rest of the world : to link with customers,
suppliers, partners, and their own employees. Even if that connection
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
48/57
48
brings in threats of malicious hackers, criminals, and industrial spies.
These network predators regularly steal corporate assets and intellectual
property, cause service breaks and system failures, sully corporate
brands, and frighten customers. 8nless companies can successfullynavigate around them, they will not be able to unlock the full business
potential of the internet.
Even enterprises with e!ceptional security have their front doors open to
employees sending and receiving data. Is there a user abusing the
system for personal reasons, or accidentally or maliciously releasingconfidential information( 8nfortunately, the variety of data formats and
sheer volume of traffic make detailed network monitoring a ma#or
technical challenge. Traffic monitors focus on bandwidth. Although some
go so far as to keep basic statistics such as web page hits and average
visit length, theyre mostly useful for capacity planning and simple web
marketing. 2ort scans allow network security specialists to find some
vulnerability.
Intrusion detection systems scan traffic for known attack signatures.
"owever, because these tools base their analysis primarily on the I2 and
T-2 headers, which can be intentionally falsified or misleading, they are
sub#ect to incorrect analysis and spoofing. -urrent tools cant provide the
information that IT managers, network consultants, auditors, software
developers, and analysts need to know/
+ho is running an unauthorized web server on a non$standard port(
+"ow long is it taking our e$commerce system to process a customer
order from start to finish(
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
49/57
49
+hat generated that huge spike of traffic between B/FBam and B/@am
this morning(
+E!actly what happened during Q and before Q last nights attemptedbreak$in(
The fleeting nature of any kind of electronic data is such that its
preservation, is re6uired especially for legal proceedings : the
methodology can be broken down into two key elements/ ac6uiring
evidence and analyzing evidence.
This information is re6uired for dealing with a law enforcement
investigation. It involves capturing and storing every packet passing
through wires and then regenerating the se6uence flow for analysis. If we
are able to regenerate the attack it can now be treated as evidence.
ull$content network monitoring is no longer the province of spooks and
spies : its increasingly a practice that is an integral part of a
multilayered defense system that serves a variety of goals for both
computer security and overall network policy.
The solution is to follow a multi$layered security approach and a system
that can perform the following tasks/ integrated network I)0 anomaly
detection 0forensic analysis1 capture data at high speeds1 run invisibly
and capture packets from the monitored network1 assemble the collected
packets into connection streams1 read the actual data in packets and
categorizes it by type, rather than make assumptions based on packet
headers and port numbers1 automatically determine key connection
attributes1 operates at the level of complete, assembled data streams,
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
50/57
50
rather than arbitrarily mi!ed$together packets1 search capability through
network traffic by keyword1 protocol recognition capability and correlation
functionality.
As time goes on, the number of attacks will only increase and network
forensics will become a part of our lives. It has an ability to strengthen our
securities, check compliance against policies, and punish those that
attempt to disrupt our IT infrastructure. The future of information security
lies in an organisation ability
to not only prevent malicious activity, but also investigate and prosecute
the perpetrators whether internal or e!ternal.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
51/57
51
Chapter 1,
Precaution is better than cure
Insurance fraud is not typically a violent crime, #ust a lucrative one. As
consumers, there are several common$sense steps you can take to help
reduce fraud and minimize its impact.
*e an Informed Consumer3
Insurance premiums are a significant e!pense for most of us. The
premiums you pay are based on your individual claims history and the
degree of risk involved. Generally speaking, the greater the risk, the
higher the premium. or e!ample, the theft premium for a "onda Accord
will be far higher than that of a Dugo 6uite simply because more "onda
Accords are stolen. )imilarly, a tightrope walker will pay more for lifeinsurance than a librarian, all else being e6ual.
Comparison Shop3
2remiums can vary significantly frominsurer to insurer so it pays to shop
around. To make comparison shopping a little easier, the Insurance
epartment publishes consumer guides for auto, homeowners, long$term
care and "M&0health insurance that provide sample premiums for
insurers that offer these coverage. In addition, the Insurance
epartment's eb site is also the home of an Interactive Guide to "M&s,
which allows consumers to find information about "M&s operating within
their home county.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
52/57
52
8no9 Hour A#ent or *ro'er3
-onsumers can often be victimized by unscrupulous agents or brokers
and discover only after they file a claim that they are without coverage for
their home or their car. If an uninsured home is damaged by fire, the
owner is solely responsible for restoring it and paying back any mortgage
holders. If a driver is involved in an accident while driving an uninsured
vehicle, any personal assets are sub#ect to forfeiture if that driver is sued
for damages. eal only with licensed agents and brokers. Agents and
brokers must carry proof of licensure.
Wheres the Proof?
;ever pay for a premium in cash. 2ay by check or a money order made
out to the insurance company directly or to the agency:not to the
individual agent or broker. In addition, always re6uest a receipt.
Wheres the Policy?
Dou should receive a copy of any type of insurance policy complete with
endorsements and declarations specifically outlining your coverage and
its limitations within a reasonable period after your purchase. If you do
not receive it, 6uestion your agent or broker. If there is no satisfactory
e!planation for the delay, contact the ;ew Dork Insurance epartment
immediately. Dou may not have the insurance coverage you paid for.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
53/57
53
Are Hou *ein# *illed for Ser"ices Hou +a"e .ot )ecei"ed?
If you have received medical or dental treatment that is covered by an
"M& or an insurance company, you will receive an 3E!planation of
*enefits3 statement listing the services for which benefits have been paid.
7eview it carefully to ensure that your health care provider has not
3bumped up3 your claim 4i.e., overstated services provided in order to
receive a higher payment5, or charged for services you did not receive.
-ontact your insurer immediately if you feel there are discrepancies.
raudulent claims payments translate into higher insurance premiums for
all of us.
What If Hou6re In"ol"ed in an Automobile Accident?
-all the police to the scene and make sure that the details of the
accident are documented and the identities of the occupants of the other
vehicle are verified. *e suspicious if the driver of the other vehicle insists
there is no need to call the police. That drivers insurance card may be
fraudulent and his car uninsured.
Auto Insurance Fraudis a multi$billion$dollar problem nationwide. atch
out for these common scams/
The sta#ed accident MA vehicle filled with people will stop suddenly in
front of you, setting you up as the cause of a rear$end collision. The
3victims3 will then file costly multiple medical and damage claims using
doctors and lawyers who are part of the scam.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
54/57
54
SteerersQ These individuals will solicit the in#ured or allegedly in#ured
parties and direct them, for a 3referral fee,3 to lawyers, doctors and0or
medical facilities that are part of the scheme. *e on the lookout for
steerers at accident scenes and dont become their victim.
Inflated claimsQ If you are in an automobile accident, be sure you know
the e!tent of the damages to your own car and the other vehicle and
carefully review claims. ?ehicle owners and body shops fre6uently inflate
estimates for damages and then either perform other repairs not related
to the accident or simply keep the e!tra money.
* A0)T B IT6S HK) %.H3
Think twice before replacing an e!isting life insurance policy with a new
one. The new policy may have e!clusions or waiting periods for pre$
e!isting conditions that are covered by your current policy. And premiums
are likely to be higher because you are older. The Insurance epartmentprotects consumers by re6uiring agents to provide prospective
purchasers with pertinent facts when that purchase will cause the buyer
to surrender, lapse, or in any way change the status of an e!isting life
insurance policy. epartment 7egulation H@ re6uires this full disclosure
so that prospective life insurance purchasers can make decisions in their
own best interest.
ont allow high$pressure salesmanship to persuade you to sign up for a
type of policy or certain coverage that you are not sure you need. Take
time to decide whats right for you.
7ead your policy carefully before you sign. If you have 6uestions, ask
your agent or broker, or your insurer. An additional source of information
and help is the Insurance epartments -onsumer )ervices *ureau.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
55/57
55
Summary
Insurance, a very well known concept today and many people could
relate to in more than one ways. This is the influence of the changing
times that have changed the concept of insurance in the minds of the
young and the old. 2eople have changed their attitude towards insurance
and accepted its new look from being an entry of lu!ury to an investment
and a necessity. The number of people taking insurance has increased
considerably in the past few decades due to the entry of private players
in the market.
&ne knows that every coin has two sides. )imilarly, insurance also has
two faces. &ne of which is investments and getting regular returns from
financial institutions for oneself and for loved ones. The other, awfully, is
of which people deceive insurance companies for their undue advantageand cause intimidation to many others.
Though, there have been many laws and agencies all over the world to
impede such criminal activity, it is not a full proof solution to all insurance
frauds.
In a world today where every person seeks their right to information anddemands the same, it is very difficult to scam them. &ne must know all
the loop$holes of their business to scheme some one. This could be the
act of some one who is carrying on criminal bustle on the vigor of his
acute knowledge about their business. %ack of knowledge and not
knowing ones basic rights on behalf of the prey could land them in
scrambled scam bis6ue.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
56/57
56
There have been many institutions and agencies formed all over the
world to detect fraud and penalize the one conscientious for such
mishaps. There is ivision of Insurance raud, International Association
&f Insurance raud Agencies 4Iaifa5, etc. through the enduring andconscious endeavor of these institutions insurance fraud tempo has
declined by an enormous amount. )everal have studied preceding and
enduring market conditions to identify with the diverse frauds that take
place and the reasons behind committing these frauds.
&ne cannot diminish frauds, schemes, swindles, scams but can positively
be alert of them so as not to be a victim of it themselves. Tumbling
fraudulent situations is a unremitting and collective effort of countless.
&ne must be sensitive and offer their helping as much as they can.
&ne can either grumble about how things are all going wide of the mark
and swallow the conse6uences. &r put their foot down and make an
attempt to change the immoral to the right. The wrong will change andeveryone will see the bright light of truth and right with the revolution of
knowledge, awareness, an attitude for change amongst the humanity.
8/12/2019 Dinesh Project
57/57
57
*iblio#raphy
*lue-ross N *lue)hield 8nited of isconsin/ hat
is health care fraud(
*arrett )./ -helation therapy and insurance fraud
2rivate health insurance/ Employers and individuals
are vulnerable to unauthorized or bogus entities
selling coverage
)cam alert./ -oalition Against Insurance raud eb site.
Weblio#raphy
www.naic.org
www.irda.gov.in
www.yahoo.com
www.google.com
www.wikipedia.org
www.investopedia.com
www .Moneycontrol.com
www .insurancefraud bureau.org
http://www.healthnetconnect.net/fraud/whatf.htmlhttp://www.healthnetconnect.net/fraud/whatf.htmlhttp://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/chelationfraud.htmlhttp://www.gao.gov/new.items/d04312.pdfhttp://www.gao.gov/new.items/d04312.pdfhttp://www.gao.gov/new.items/d04312.pdfhttp://www.insurancefraud.org/bogus_health.htmhttp://www.naic.org/http://www.irda.gov.in/http://www.yahoo.com/http://www.goog