Challenges of Neighbourhood Democracy - presentation from UKGovCamp 12

Post on 07-May-2015

1.854 views 0 download

description

A presentation by Anthony from UK GovCamp 2012, talking about neighbourhood democracy and neighbourhood councils.

Transcript of Challenges of Neighbourhood Democracy - presentation from UKGovCamp 12

THE DEMOCRATIC SOCIETY

THE CHALLENGE OF NEIGHBOURHOOD DEMOCRACY

Friday, 20 January 12

Government struggles with two concepts of localism

Friday, 20 January 12

We, The People

Friday, 20 January 12

We, The Council

Friday, 20 January 12

These aren’t incompatible ...

Friday, 20 January 12

... if we get participation and representation to work together

Friday, 20 January 12

With neighbourhood budgeting ...

Friday, 20 January 12

... and neighbourhood planning ...

Friday, 20 January 12

... Government has given communities the toughest issues.

Friday, 20 January 12

And in referendums, the worst way to decide on them.

Friday, 20 January 12

We know what we want

1. Community-level participation2. Available to as many people as want to participate3. That informs people of context and data4. Gives them opportunities to discuss things 5. Takes positions but makes decisions only alongside traditional methods6. A meaningful role for councillors

Friday, 20 January 12

And we know some do’s and don’ts

Friday, 20 January 12

Don’t build a portal

Friday, 20 January 12

Don’t create hungry mouths

Friday, 20 January 12

Really don’t build a portal

Friday, 20 January 12

Use networks of networks

Friday, 20 January 12

Go where people are

Friday, 20 January 12

And we know the challenges

Friday, 20 January 12

The Bertolt Brecht Problem

“The Secretary of the Writer's UnionHad leaflets distributed in the StalinalleeStating that the peopleHad forfeited the confidence of the governmentAnd could win it back onlyBy redoubled efforts. Would it not be easierIn that case for the governmentTo dissolve the peopleAnd elect another?”

Brecht, “The Solution”

Friday, 20 January 12

Managing online/offline connexions

Friday, 20 January 12

Paranoia management

Friday, 20 January 12

National/local/hyperlocal

Friday, 20 January 12

Governance

Friday, 20 January 12

Can we turn a fairy story into a blueprint ?

Friday, 20 January 12

by Anthony Zacharzewski for the Democratic Society, 2012

Friday, 20 January 12