Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

91
start anywhere what Faceted Navigation is not good for peter boersma henning fischer
  • date post

    20-Sep-2014
  • Category

    Design

  • view

    6
  • download

    0

description

Presentation for Euro IA 2010 by Peter Boersma (with support by Henning Fischer) of Adaptive Path. This presentation reflects the things we tell clients when they suggest to use Faceted Navigation. It goes into what Faceted Navigation is and is not good for and what tips & tricks we've learned in researching, designing and evaluating faceted-based solutions.

Transcript of Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Page 1: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

start anywhere what Faceted Navigation is not good for

peter boersma

henning fischer

Page 2: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 3: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 4: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

three locations

Page 5: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

events

4,000 p a r t i c i p a n t s

20 c o u n t r i e s

50 c o n s u l t a n c i e s

consulting

e x p e r i e n c e

researche x p e r i e n c e

designe x p e r i e n c e

strategy

hundredso f a r t i c l e s

r+d

8b o o k s

thousandso f r e a d e r s

Adaptive Path helps teams and organizations create products and services that deliver great experiences to improve people’s lives.

Page 6: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 7: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

our clients ask for it

Page 8: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

“wouldn’t it be cool if...”“we want to...”

“we already have...”“can you make it like...”

Page 9: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 10: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 11: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Faceted Navigation 101

Page 12: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

facets=

attributes of content items

Page 13: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

navigation=

finding your wayin (an information) space

Page 14: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

faceted navigation=

selectingattributes of content items

in order tofind your way

in an information space

Page 15: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

typical design

facet1 value1.1(#) value1.2(#)

facet2 subfacet2.1(#) subfacet2.2(#)

item item item

item

item item item

item itemall content items(or none)

Page 16: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

typical design

facet2 subfacet2.1(#) subfacet2.2(#)

value a.b (x)

item item item

item

item item

item itemall content items

whose attributes matchvalue a.b

Page 17: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

typical design

facet2 subfacet2.1 value2.1.1(#) value2.1.2(#)

value a.b(x) subfacet c.d(x)

item item item

item itemall content items

whose attributes match value a.b and subfacet c.d

Page 18: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

When to useFaceted Navigation

Page 19: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Good when:all your content items have

all the metadata

Page 20: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 21: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

online magazines

books

training & events

software & tools

news

about Kluwer

scientific articles

Page 22: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Good when:your facets and values

actually distinguishcontent items

Page 23: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 24: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 25: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Good when:your users understandthe facets and values

Page 26: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 27: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 28: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 29: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

When NOT to useFaceted Navigation

Page 30: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Not good when:your users may have problems with the UI

e.g. select/deselect facets,orthogonal hierarchies,controlled vocabulary

Page 31: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 32: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Not good when:your users prefer search

over browse

Page 33: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 34: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Not good when:your content items have

optional features

Page 35: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

facets

Page 36: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

facets

optionalfeatures

optionalfeatures

Page 37: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Not good when:you only have

a small collection

Page 38: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 39: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Not good when:your users are

in non-selection phases of the purchase process

Page 40: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 41: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Not good when:you want to

encourage serendipity

Page 42: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 43: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

related

top 5

recent

soon

Page 44: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 45: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Known alternatives

Page 46: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

search

Page 47: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 48: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

directory listing

Page 49: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 50: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

product tables,comparison charts

Page 51: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 52: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

product configurators, wizards, advisors

Page 53: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 54: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

top 5/10/50 lists

Page 55: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 56: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

fewer products

Page 57: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 58: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Adaptive Path’sTips & Tricks

Page 59: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

#1make sure thatselected facetsremove other,

non-relevant facets

Page 60: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 61: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 62: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 63: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

#2at some point,

comparison charts may be a better solution

Page 64: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 65: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 66: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 67: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 68: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

#3for products that appear in

many categories,add a “for general use”

facet/value

Page 69: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 70: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 71: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 72: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 73: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

#4the order of facets

determines how they will be used

Page 74: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 75: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 76: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

#5use faceted navigation

in combination withother navigation types

Page 77: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 78: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

related

top 5

recent

soon

search & filter

Page 79: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

#6“view all designs”

is not a filter

Page 80: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 81: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 82: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

#7ask yourself:

should weuse faceted navigationfor all content types?

Page 83: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 84: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 85: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)
Page 86: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Summary

Page 87: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Goodwhen:

Not Good when:

- metadata in place- facets distinguish content items- users understand facets

- problems with UI- users prefer search- optional features- small collection- non-selection phases- serendipity

Page 88: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Alternatives- search- directory listings- product tables- comparison charts- configurators/wizards/advisors- top 5/10/50 lists- fewer products

Page 89: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Tips & Tricks

#1 selected facets remove non-relevant facets#2 comparison charts may be better#3 consider a “for general use” facet

#4 think about order of facets in interface

#5 combine facets with other navigation#6 “view all” is not a filter#7 use facets only for content where it makes sense

Page 90: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

Questions?

Page 91: Start Anywhere - Faceted Navigation (euroIA 2010)

start anywhere what Faceted Navigation is not good for

peter boersma

henning fischer