8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
1/24
WhitesWhites TThreehree DDisciplines andisciplines and
RRelativeelative VValuationaluation OOrderrder
Countering the social ignorance ofautomated data collection and analysis
Steven McDermott (Author)
Institute of CommunicationsStudies, University of Leeds
International Conference on
Advances in Social Networks
Analysis and Mining, 9-11
August 2010.
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
2/24
Overview
This paper sits within the wider debate regarding the
emancipatory nature of the Internet in authoritarian regimes
(Habermas, 2006), with Singapore as a case study.
A concern is to ensure that the social and cultural aspects of
domains are represented in social network analysis.
The discourse of Network Analysis is gaining hegemonic
ground and to remain truly descriptive rather than
prescriptive needs to allow for other forms of organisation.
Is there room for a critical social network analysis allowing
for self-reflexivity as well as emancipatory applications of the
methods?
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
3/24
IntroductionChoice of Case Study
The Singapore blogosphere was described by Lin,Sundaram, Chi, Tatemura, and Tseng, (2007) and Hurst(2006), as an isolated and distinct network with no
theme or focus. We rarely find a community that is absolutely isolated.
What are the methods of control and what is thenature of the Singapore identity online?
Where does power reside within the blogosphere? Will an analysis of the discourse present us with the
identity of the blogosphere?
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
4/24
SOCIAL NETWORK THEORY
Social structure and culture are part of the
complexities of discursive practices of those
who populate the institutions and
organisations.
The accessing and assessing that passes
between the identities are the entangled
chaotic mix of culture and social structure
from which meanings emerge.
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
5/24
Netdoms are first order elements from whichnetworks and domains derive.
Networks are the formations of stories andstories are the formation of networks.
Disciplines emerge out of network forms as thestruggle for control comes to rest on a valuationorder.
Whites three genres of disciplines; interface,
council and arena each with a distinct processand valuation order.
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
6/24
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
7/24
SOCIAL NETWORK ANALYSIS
The rhizomatic model of knowledge results in anetwork model that is chaotic.
The logic of the connection in the rhizomatic
network is movement. There is no hierarchy; no node takes precedence
over another. The order is in constant flux withtotal inclusiveness.
Knox et al., (2006) argue that Social NetworkAnalysis focus on structuralism has in recentyears shifted to attempts at developing a culturalapproach.
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
8/24
NETWORK ETHNOGRAPHY
My major concern with research conducted
on the Singapore blogosphere by Lin,
Sundaram, Chi, Tatemura, and Tseng, (2006)
and Hurst (2006) was that it led to
technological and/or organizational
determinism.
Applying an online ethnography should
overcome this.
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
9/24
January 2009
EXTRACTING THE SOCIAL NETWORKUSING HYPERLINK NETWORK ANALYSIS
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
10/24
February 2009
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
11/24
March 2009
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
12/24
April 2009
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
13/24
Close-up of Singapore blogosphere in
Jan 2009
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
14/24
CORPUS DATA COLLECTION AND
ANALYSIS Internet mirroring created files of 24 megabytes for the two monthsin the paper. Now though the approach generates 70-80mbs.
Manually analysing so much data would increase human error andallow the bias of the researcher to skew interpretations.
As computer software is socially ignorant, the ethnographiccomponent [participant observer in the network for 5 years]to thisapproach enables a socio-cultural reading of the results to ensurethat themes highlighted by the software make sense.
The emergent themes enable a quick reading of the large corpus.
Emergent themes are visible to the user, and are expandable using
the map visualisation that links directly to the areas of the corpus inwhich the concept occurs.
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
15/24
First Attempt...
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
16/24
January 2009 Themes and Concepts
1,432 sites
(70.9 MBs)
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
17/24
February 2009 Themes and Concepts
1,216 sites
(62.2 MBs)
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
18/24
March 2009 Themes and Concepts
1,201 sites
(71.7 MBs)
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
19/24
April 2009 Themes and Concepts
1,232 sites
(72.3 MBs)
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
20/24
Reading the Corpus
The top ranking concepts that appear alongside the concept of government (the most
dominant theme for Jan 2009) are opinion, views, indicating that voice was an important
factor within the Singapore online contextualisation of government in January 2009. Below
are example quotes from a government query. The example quotations are said to be
characteristic of the use of the query term.
1./jan2009/www.cherian.blogspot.com/index~1.html/1/1_249
The fact of the matter is that it is untenable for the PAP government to preside over a Singapore that includes
any urban slum. Whoever the MP is, the government will have to intervene before any HDB estate becomes
decrepit.
8. /jan2009/topmleehsienloong.blogspot.com/index~1.html/1/1_52
Jobs for Singaporeans. The Government will spend $5.1 billion to help Singaporeans stay employed so they
can continue to support their families by introducing a, Enhancing SPUR, (Skills Programme for Upgradingand Resilience) providing a WIS Special Payment and expanding recruitment across the public sector.
Stimulating Bank Lending The Government will extend $5.8 billion of government capital to stimulate
bank lending through enhancing existing schemes and a new Special Risk-Sharing Initiative (SRI).
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
21/24
THEMES AND DISCIPLINES
The use ofLeximancerhighlights the themes and conceptsthat aid in enlarging the scope of awareness that I have as aparticipant observer within the network.
It increases my scope of awareness as an observer, well
beyond my own ego-network of daily interaction. The skill of reading the maps requires an awareness of the
social context in which the data was gathered.
It highlights story sets that I was aware of as well asnumerous story sets that I was not.
A query of the concept Singapore brought to my attentionbloggers that I was unaware and concepts that wereassociated with Singapore for that month, such as NationCheated.
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
22/24
Themes and Topics
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
23/24
CONCLUDING REMARKS
The ethnographic approach is integral to unpacking the social andcultural forces that are at work within and withoutthe network.
Singapore blogosphere has embedded via dependence as it hasbecome locked together with the external disciplines of theSingapore government and government affiliated mainstream
press. There is little interest in reaching out to control or gain action and
so the flows of information remain within its own boundaries.
Bloggers are primarily concerned with the quality of the blog postsand the quality of sources. Making qualitythe dominant valuationorder of the Singapore blogosphere.
This leads to the conclusion that it is an interface discipline.
8/8/2019 Whites Three Disciplines and Relative Valuation Orders, countering the social ignorance of automated analysis and mining techniques
24/24
The Singapore blogosphere is not an isolated and distinct
network without theme or focus.
It is split along ethnic factions.
Has themes that arise, dissipate and re-occur over time.
This assigned normality of flux - contrasts with the fixed and
rigid nature of the Lin, Sundaram, Chi, Tatemura, and Tsengs,
(2006) reading of the Singapore blogosphere.
It may have been isolated in 2006 but by 2009 shows clearlinks to the wider global blogosphere.
There is little talk of action offline.Steven McDermott (Author)
Institute of Communications Studies
University of Leeds
Leeds, United Kingdom
Top Related