UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
MARK S. ANNIS; et al.,
Plaintiffs - Appellants,
v.
MICHAEL AGUIRRE; et al.,
Defendants -Appellees.
___________________________________
SABIN M. ABRAMS; et al.,
Plaintiffs - Appellants,
v.
MICHAEL AGUIRRE; et al.,
Defendants - Appellees.
__________________________________
)))))))))))))))))))))))))
CASE NO: 08-56653
D.C. No. 3:06-cv-01451-H-PORSouthern District of California,San Diego
STIPULATION OF DISMISSAL OF APPEAL WITHPREJUDICE
(CONSOLIDATED APPEAL NO. 08-56691)
CASE NO. 08-56691
D.C. No. 3:06-cv-01451-H-PORSouthern District of California,San Diego
The following Appellants (“Appellants”):
Adair, Larry
Adams, Lori M.
Adams, Robert Heath
1
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 1 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Agnew, Laurie
Aguirre, Edward R.
Aiken, Michael
Albertsen, Sandra Rapalee
Albrecht, Leslie
Albright, Daniel T.
Ambito, Albert I.
Ammon, Kevin
Anderson, Peggy
Andrews, Thomas J.
Anschick, Robert W.
Armenta, Oscar A.
Ashcraft, Wesley R.
Asher, Michael R.
Atwood, Jennifer (formerly Perea)
Atwood, Robert
Austin, John
Bailey, John B.
Baird, Robert M., Jr.
Barnes, Scott T.
Bassett, Tina
2
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 2 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Bassett, Tod E.
Beamesderfer, Michael A.
Beard, Jana M.
Beathard, David W.
Becker, Edward Lee
Behrendt, Steven M.
Benavides, Joe A.
Bernier, Steve
Bernstein, Meryl
Binkero, Victoria M.
Bisesto, Gregory R.
Bittner, Richard A.
Bixel, Lynn
Black, Carlton E.
Blackford, Jeffrey
Blagg, Brian R.
Boerom, Thomas M. J.
Bolen, James R.
Borrelli, Nick
Bourasa, Steven B.
Bowman, Roger E.
3
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 3 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Boyd, James W.
Bozarth, Phillip Kent
Brady, Cindy Lea
Breitenstein, Glenn A.
Bressler, Robert R.
Brinkerhoff, Paul
Bristol, Russell T.
Brogdon, Michael
Browder, Neal N.
Brown, Ronald O.
Brown, Tim R.
Brown, William M.
Brugman, Joy Marie
Burgess, Randy P.
Burke, David W.
Burkett, Brett
Buxton, Christopher G.
Cairncross, Laurie
Calloway, Jene L.
Caneron, Christen M.
Campbell, Janet M.
4
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 4 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Campbell, William H.
Carignan, Theodore
Carlson, Mark A.
Carlyon, Thomas J.
Carpenter, John D.
Carter, Tony B.
Carter, William
Caruso, Peter J.
Castro, Nydia M.
Cavada, Arthur H.
Cedrun, Misty
Cerar, Daniel
Chaney, John
Chiles, James H.
Chione, Jeffrey W.
Cimmarrusti, Raphael
Clark, James
Clark, Joseph
Clem, James H.
Cloniger, C.J.
Cole, Rex A., Jr.
5
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 5 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Collier, Douglas M.
Collier, Kimberly
Collins, Garry
Colon, Bernie T.
Conley, Paul D.
Council, Carol V.
Coyle, Timothy S.
Cranston, Meghan
Cueva, Celso G.
Culligan, James P.
Cunanain, Rolito
Dare, Robert W.
Darrow, Darby Lee
Daun, Robert
Davies, Lisa L.
Davis, Charles R.
Davis, William T., Jr.
Day, William G.
De Armas, Alexander
Decastro, Conrado V.
Dela Cruz, Charles
6
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 6 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Dela Pena, Susan
Deloach, John
Derning, Patrick R.
Devone, Edward A.
Diaz, Derek
Didelot, John “Jack” R.
Dobbs, Matthew
Dodd, Dorinda K.
Dolezal, Donald J.
Doremus, Dennis P.
Doshibr, Wilbert A.
Dougherty, Marianne L.
Dougherty, Ronald H.
Douglas, David F.
Downs, James E.
Dragi, Julie M.
Drilling, Eric
Dunbar, John G.
Dupree, Anthony L.
Eastep, Donna R.
Eichmann, Randal W.
7
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 7 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
El-Assis, Antoine
Elkins, Roland
Ellithorpe, Shari L.
Ellsworth, Philip
Elmore, Stanley A.
English, James D.
Epperson, Julie
Epperson, Steve
Ericson, Cassie
Escalante, Manuel, III
Escuaero, Christopher C.
Fabregas, Robert C.
Farrar, Debra Lance
Farrar, James W.
Farrell, Mary V.
Faubel, Tim
Fay, Paul J.
Fellows, Andrew L.
Filley, James D.
Filley, Robert
Finch, Robert
8
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 8 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Fischer, Rodney W.
Flanagan, Michael F.
Flores, Riter
Ford Yankovich, Anna M.
Fowler, Robert M.
Fragoso, Alan R.
Freitas, John W.
Fune, John Patrick
Furst, Andrea S.
Garcia, David A.
Garcia, David D.
Garcia, Ivan
Garlow, Justin
Gasteiger, Mark
Gault, Ryan P.
Gerke, Frederick R.
Gilmore, Cory E.
Glazewski, Dewayne F.
Gobbi, Marcos
Goldberg, Brian
Gollehon, Gary L.
9
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 9 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Gomez, Edward R.
Gonzalez, Tristan
Gonzalez-Reed, Hilda
Goodman, Gregg
Goodner, Derrel
Gore, Larry K.
Graham, William M.
Graves, James E., III
Greenwood, Scott
Gressel, Mary K.
Groff, Michael D.
Gross, Jeffrey George
Grubbs, Daniel L.
Grubbs, Jennifer
Haley, Michael A.
Hall, David A.
Hall, Patrick
Hansen, Richard A.
Harbin, Levi
Harris, Paul A.
Hart, Shannon W.
10
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 10 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Hartman, M.A.
Hastings, Michael R.
Hastings, Ramona R.
Hattler, Daniel C.
Havin, Jess R.
Hays, Eric
Head, George A.
Headley, David M.
Heims, Robert
Henderson, Scott
Henry, Shaun P.
Hentigan, Michael
Heppell, James K.
Herrera, Victor M.
Hershman, Carlton R.
Hesselgesser, Larry R.
Hibshman, Byron
Hicks, Matthew P.
Higdon, Daniel
Highsmith, David F.
Hill, Gary W.
11
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 11 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Hodges, Diana
Hodges, Kenneth Paul, Sr.
Hodges, Mark
Hoerman, Frank J.
Hoff, Lloyd
Hoffman, Andrew T.
Holden, Mike D.
Hollister, Dan
Holmes, William B.
Holmstrom, Richard E.
Holt, Chris
Hone, Natalie M.
Hoolihan, John P.
Horvath, John
Hoyte, Hector E.
Hubbs, Kenneth
Hubbs, Phillip D.
Hudson, Edward
Hurley, Michael P.
Hustad, David J.
Isbell, Craig E.
12
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 12 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Jackson, Brian A.
Jacobsen, Jane E.
Jarvis, Lynda E.
Jarvis, Philip T.
Jennings, David E.
Joaquin, Jerome O.
Johnson, Anthony K.
Johnson, Buddy L.
Johnson, Jeffrey M.
Johnson, Jeffrey M.
Johnson, Sarah
Johnson, Tim Daniel
Johnston, Scott W.
Jones, David H.
Jones, Edward V.
Jones, Randal L.
Karsh, Daniel
Kay, Charles Q.
Keating, Timothy J.
Keene, Jonny F.
Keelsing, David
13
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 13 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Kelbaugh, Nicolas I.
Kennedy, James L.
Kenney, Francis L.
Kern, Jacob
Kilby, Christopher W.
Kitts, Dale
Knish, Jack
Kolender, William B.
Kook, Lloyd E.
Korenkov, Andrew
Kral, Franklin, Jr.
Kremer, Denny K.
Kriebel, Jerry, II
Krosch, Calvin L.
Krouss, Joseph
Kulinski, Nancy
Labo, John G.
LaChapelle, Sandra
Landman, David L.
Lange, Terry A.
Lara, Charles
14
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 14 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Larmour, Ronald P.
Lasher, Daniel P.
Lawson, Brooke Pamela
Leds, Alberto H.
Lemaster, Ronald W.
Lemahan, B.
Leribeus, Brian J.
Levan, John Brian
Lewak, Kazimierz P.
Lewis, Robert L.
Little, Darrell K.
Livesey, James R.
Lobel, Henry J.
Lofftus, Mel
Long, James W.
Long, Timoth M.
Loucks, Gene C.
Lozano, Alfred
Lucchesi, Brian
Lucchesi, Mark
Luce, Chris M.
15
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 15 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Luth, Christopher
Luth, Daniel D.
Lyall, Charles David
Maggi, Louis John, Jr.
Maglaras, George
Maley, David
Marcos, Mark
Margetts, Stephen G.
Martinez, Chrissy
Martinez, Rudy
Martz, Philip, Jr.
Maschmeier, Michael W.
Mauzy, Kathleen M.
Mauzy, Ralph C.
McCarvel, Roger W.
McClain, Terry L.
McElfresh, Noel
McElroy, Guy
McGhee, James
McGowan Minto, Laura
McGuire, Ed
16
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 16 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
McLellan, Scott D.
McLoed, Michael D.
McMillen, Steve L.
McMurrin, Joel
McNair, Sharon K.
McNamara, Kevin Dean
McQuien, Robert M.
Meisner, Robert N.
Melhorn, Skip
Mendez, Michael J.
Mensior, Kerry A.
Metz, Richard D., Jr.
Michalek, David R.
Michalek, Debra S.
Miles, Carmi D.
Miller, Douglas D.
Miller, Jeffrey L.
Miller, Thomas P., III
Mills, Peter R.
Minton, Robert D.
Mitrovich, Gary E.
17
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 17 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Molinoski, Joseph W.
Mondesir, Gary F.
Montierth, Charles
Moore, James G.
Mora, Robert
Morales, Miguel P.
Morales, Ray A.
Morris, David L.
Morrison, Cynthia
Morrison, James D.
Morrison, Scott A.
Moser, Jay
Mosteller, Jacob
Munoz, Cynthia L.
Muren, George Timothy
Myers, Gregory J.
Navarn-Moran, Angelica
Needham, James
Nelson, Kenneth E.
Nezgodinsky, Alexander
Newquist, Robert L.
18
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 18 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Nikkola, Gordon
Nisleit, David
Nobbs, Robert H.
Norton, Lee
Norton, Regina
Nalton, John R.
O’Hanlon, Richard M.
Oliver, Gene F.
Olson, Barney C., III
Olson, Shelly K.
O’Neill, James
O’Neill, Michael
Oplinger, Sandra
Orden, Thomas A.
Packer, Thomas R.
Page, Denise D.
Papenhausen, Billy J.
Parpart, Richard C.
Parrella, Richard
Patrick, Kevin
Perez, Marco
19
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 19 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Perkins, Curtis E.
Perez, Jose Paul
Petersen, Jeffrey P.
Petrick, Edward K.
Pettitt, Duane E.
Phelps, Bradley L.
Pickett, Douglas L.
Pinarelli, Greg A.
Pino-Jarvis, Marisela
Pitucci, Marc A.
Plein, Dan R.
Powers, Jason
Prutzman, Bob
Prutzman, Michael J.
Pudgil, Duane
Pursel, Dalana Sue
Queen, Corinne
Queen, John
Rabell, Michael J.
Ramsay, Michael
Randolph, Matt
20
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 20 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Rausis, Kevin C.
Redding, Robert M., Jr.
Reece, Dwight P.
Reif, John J.
Reno, Wendy S.
Rey, Robert L.
Rhodes, Thomas M.
Ricardez, Rolanda M.
Richmond, Brenda T.
Ries, Darin
Righthouse, Bret A.
Righthouse, Susan M.
Robertson, Todd J.
Robinson, Steve
Rodriguez, Elias
Rojorquez, Eugene H.
Rollins, Bobby D.
Roman, Daniel G.
Ronquillo, Carlos
Root, David L.
Rorrison, Paul R.
21
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 21 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Rosales, Jorge
Rosario, Angel D.
Rosenbloom, Steven
Rude, Robert
Ruvido, Joseph
Rydalch, Lynn D.
Salas, Paul H.
Salinas, Jeffrey
Salvatierra, Alfonso
Sanchez, Juan
Santos, Alejandrino Cruz, III
Sarot, Christopher M.
Schaeffer, Jack D.
Seiter, Eric
Sells, Gaylon W.
Shanley, Patrick J.
Sharki, Adam T.
Shaw, Marvin L.
Shiraishi, Michael S.
Shockley, Dale T., Sr.
Shumaker, Benjamin
22
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 22 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Sidhu, Amalia
Simms, John W.
Simonds, Thomas G.
Sinclair, Lori A.
Smith, James
Smith, James F.
Smith, Larry H.
Smith, Robert W.
Smith, Timothy M.
Snarponis, Joseph G.
Snow, Ronald
Spear, Andrew
Speck, David
Spetter, Howard W.
Stacy, Michael L.
Stadler, John
Staley, Leroy
Stephens, Norman O.
Stewart, Gary G.
Stewart, Kenneth P.
Stewart, Leslie W.
23
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 23 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Stiasny, Elliot S.
Stratton, Jerry G.
Stricklin, John Jay
Stutz, William F.
Sullivan, Mark C.
Sullivan, Thomas A.
Surwilo, David
Swadener, Arturo
Swanson, Michael Joseph
Szakara, John
Szymczak, Charles M.
Tamagni, Louis A.
Tate, John H.
Taylor, Dana D.
Terhaar, Philip J.
Thach, Alvin
Thompson, Scott A.
Toneck, Daniel D.
Tos, David
Truderung, Robert
Trumper, Ernie
24
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 24 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Underwood, Timothy L.
Updike, Bernard P., Jr.
Valencia, Janis E.
Valentin, Ramon
Valentin, Wendy J.
Van Abel, Mark A.
Vandiver, Rodney L.
VanHorn, Dale L.
Vanlaningham, Edward F.
Van Proyen, Joel
Varonfakis, James G.
Vega, Danny
Verdone, Kenneth J.
Vile, Daniel R.
Vittek, Robert
Vollmar, Timothy
Voss, Duane A.
Voss, Gary R.
Wallawer, Gerard M.
Wade, Sylvester, Jr.
Wadhams, Kevin L.
25
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 25 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Wagner, Elyse S.
Wagner, Thomas
Wahl, Michael D.
Walb, Kristopher
Wallace, Mitchell B.
Ward, Dick L.
Warrick, Deanna M.
Watkins, Donald E.
Watkins, Victoria D.
Way, Dean
Weathersby, Sedonia
Weaver, Michael W.
Weeden, Larry W.
Wegson, Adrian
Wendell, Diane
Wetter, Raymond
Whitfield, David L.
Wilkins, Larry
Wilkinson, Scott
Williams, Brent
Williams, Donna L.
26
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 26 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Williams, Tina M.
Wilson, Lawrence
Witt, Steven
Wolfe, Dawn
Woods, William H.
Worden, David M.
Worthington, Phillip
Wright, Stephen W.
Wuemler, Jeffrey J.
Yu, Dave C.
Zaitz, Mathew
Zeljeznjak, Anthony
Zepeda, Monica
Zetterlund, Timothy P.
Ziegler, Jeffrey P.
and Appellees, City of San Diego, Scott Peters, Jim Madaffer, Ralph Inzunza, Toni
Atkins, Tony Young, Brian Maienschein, Donna Frye, Michael Zucchet, Cathy Lexin,
Mary Vattimo, Terri Webster, Ed Ryan, P. Lamont Ewell, Michael Uberuaga, and Bruce
Herring (collectively “Stipulating Appellees”), by counsel, pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P.
41(a)(1)(ii) stipulate to the dismissal with prejudice of Appellants’ appeal against
27
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 27 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Stipulating Appellees, each party to bear its own costs and attorney’s fees.
Respectfully submitted,
DATED: April 26, 2010 LAW OFFICE OF MICHAEL A. CONGER
/s/ Michael A. Conger Specially appearing for dismissing appellants tofacilitate dismissal pursuant to written authorityfrom dismissing appellantsE-Mail: [email protected]
DATED: April 26, 2010 LATHAM & WATKINS, LLP
/s/ Colleen C. Smith Attorneys for Appellees City of San Diego, Scott Peters, Jim Madaffer,Ralph Inzunza, Toni Atkins, Tony Young, BrianMaienschein, Donna Frye, Michael Zucchet,Cathy Lexin, Mary Vattimo, Terri Webster, EdRyan, P. Lamont Ewell, Michael Uberuaga, andBruce Herring E-Mail: [email protected]
28
Case: 08-56653 04/26/2010 Page: 28 of 28 ID: 7315363 DktEntry: 80-1
Top Related