I
STUDY OF DESIGN CRITERIA OF STORY BOOKS FOR VISUALLY IMPAIRED CHILDREN
by
MEGHA GUPTA
Submitted to NIFT in partial fulfilment
of the requirements for the degree of
Masters of Design
Faculty Guide: DR. NILANJANA BAIRAGI
NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF FASHION TECHNOLOGY
NEW DELHI
2013
© 2013 NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF FASHION TECHNOLOGY (NIFT)
II
STUDY OF DESIGN CRITERIA OF STORY BOOKS FOR VISUALLY IMPAIRED CHILDREN
by
MEGHA GUPTA
M.DESIGN
BATCH: 2011-13
Submitted by Ms Megha Gupta to NIFT in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the
degree of Masters of Design of the National Institute of Fashion Technology at New
Delhi and hereby certify that in the judgment of the following members of jury it is worth
of acceptance:
NAME INSTITUTE/ORGANISATION SIGNATURE
_________________ _______________________ ________________
_________________ _______________________ ________________
_________________ _______________________ ________________
_________________ _______________________ ________________
Remarks regarding fulfilling further requirements:
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Signature of Head PG- DESIGN Date :
III
DECLARATION
The work presented in this dissertation is authentic and original and is the outcome of
the author’s own ideas and labour. No portion of this work has been submitted in support
of an application for another degree pr qualification to this institution or any other
university or any other institute of learning.
Date : (Dr. Nilanjana Bairagi) Place : New Delhi National Institute of Fashion Technology
IV
ACKNOWLEGEMENT
Although I am the sole author of this thesis, I am by no means the sole contributor. Many
people have contributed to my thesis, to my education, and to my life, and it is now my
great pleasure to take this opportunity to thank them. First and foremost, I would like to
thank my academic mentor, Dr. Nilanjana Bairagi who guided me throughout the project
and showed confidence in my project. She had been a pillar of constant support and
always willing to lend a ear to guide and advise and offer suggestions. I am also thankful
to Ms. Shanta, Director of National Association of Blind (NAB) for allowing me to
undertake this project at NAB. I extend my gratitude to Mr Sumit and Ms Shivangi –
teachers at NAB for their consistent cooperation and valuable suggestions. The project
would not have been successful without their support. I am also grateful to all the
children who showed great enthusiasm during the workshops which motivated me to
work hard for them. I would also like to thank Master Roshan- a computer training
student, for volunteering to write Braille by hand. The story books could not have
developed without his help. I thank Ms Ranjana Rana- computer operator at NAB, for
taking out time for me and arranging volunteer for me. My thanks extends to all other
staff members of NAB as well who directly or indirectly assisted in my project. Last but
not the least, I would like to thank my mother Mrs Sunita Gupta, my father Mr.
N.K.Gupta, and other family members who endured this long process with me, always
offering support and love.
May, 2013 (MEGHA GUPTA)
V
ABSTRACT
The study focused on proposing design criteria of story books for visually impaired
children of age group of 6-10 years. Following a pilot study, an ethnographic approach
was adopted at National Association of Blind (NAB), Delhi. It comprised of interactive
workshops and children were observed in their classroom settings for a period of 6 days
to obtain insights on exploration styles, learning styles, knowledge set, tactile perception
and comprehension level of visually impaired children. This study made use of purposive
sampling. Participants were selected because of some defining characteristic that made
them the holders of the data needed for the study. As the pilot study indicated that
stories are read till KG classes having children of age group of 6-10 years, the sample
consisted on 10-15 visually impaired children of the same age group and their teachers.
The collected data was then analyzed and grouped under suitable categories to propose
design criteria for story books. Prior to ideation and conceptualization, a short market
survey and a parallel literature search on various types of picture books and illustration
styles were carried out. Concepts were then brainstormed and prototypes were
developed and tested with the children. Feedback from teachers and children was
recorded and incorporated in the final design.
Some of the major findings of the study revealed that skills and abilities of visually
impaired children differ from that of normal sighted children. While picture books help
normal sighted children to link pictures with words and assist them in reading and
writing, visually impaired children rely on tactile and auditory means and use Braille as
their primary learning medium. It was observed in NAB that apart from Braille books and
audio books, no special printed story books were being used for visually impaired
children. The Braille books too were found to be devoid of any tactile graphics. The
workshops conducted with visually impaired children for 6 days revealed that these
children are more comfortable with the graphics they have been already oriented
towards earlier. They get confused when a set of visuals are represented in different
perspectives. It becomes more convenient for them when the tactile graphics are simple,
big and spacious and not more than two in number per page. They are able to
distinguish between two areas as long as they have different textures. The children with
VI
low vision could use their residual vision to read text in large print and identify colors,
provided the colors are in high contrast to each other.
VII
CONTENTS
Page no.
1 INTRODUCTION 1
1.1. Introduction 1
1.2. Research Question 2
1.3. Aim of the study 2
1.4. Objectives of the study 2
2 REVIEW OF LITERATURE 4
2.1. Introduction 4
2.2. Visual Impairment 4
2.2.1. What is visual impairment? 4
2.2.2. Statistics of visually impaired population 5
2.2.3. Visual impairment in children 6
2.3. Teaching visually impaired children 8
2.3.1. Teaching approaches 8
2.3.2. Teaching pedagogical tools 9
2.4. Tactile illustrations 10
2.4.1 Types of tactile illustrations 10
2.4.2. Challenges to tactile illustrations 11
2.5. Exploration skills of Visually impaired children 13
2.5.1. Theories on tactile perception 13
2.5.2. Work done on tactile skills of visually impaired 13
2.6. Existing books for blind 14
2.6.1. Braille books 14
2.6.2. Story Box Objects 15
2.6.3. Large print books 15
2.6.4. Talking books 16
2.6.5. E-books 17
2.7. Summary 17
3 RESEARCH DESIGN 19
VIII
3.1. Introduction 19
3.2. Methodology 19
3.3. Sample selection 20
3.4. Data collection and analysis 21
3.4.1 Pilot study 21
3.4.2 Ethnographic study 21
3.4.3 Development of story books for visually impaired
children 22
3.4.4 Design and prototype evaluation 22
3.5. Challenges in data collection 22
3.6. Summary 23
4 PILOT STUDY 24
4.1. Introduction 24
4.2. National Association of Blind 24
4.3. Observations 25
4.3.1. Learning equipments 25
4.3.2. Teaching strategies 25
4.3.3. Toys 27
4.3.4. Books 28
4.3.5. Skills 28
4.3.6. Other observations 28
4.4. Summary 29
5 ETHNOGRAPHIC STUDY OF VISUALLY IMPAIRED CHILDREN 30
5.1. Introduction 30
5.2. Observations and inferences 30
5.2.1. Day 1- Random tactile graphics 30
5.2.2. Day 2- Tactile graphics of animal faces 32
5.2.3. Day 3- Clay workshop 33
5.2.4. Day 4 – small tactile flash cards made from single
material 34
5.2.5. Day 5 - Big tactile flashcards 35
IX
5.2.6. Day 5- Story narration 36
5.3. Categorising data under suitable design categories 37
5.3.1. Illustrations 38
5.3.2. Content 39
5.3.3. Layout 40
5.3.4. Typography 40
5.3.5. Color 40
5.3.6 Page size 40
5.3.7. Material 41
5.4. Market study and literature research on Picture books of children
41
5.4.1. Types of children’s books 41
5.4.2. Basic concepts taught in children’s books 42
5.4.3. Illustration styles 42
5.4.4. General preferences of children in picture books 44
5.5. Summary 44
6 DEVELOPMENT OF STORY BOOKS FOR VISUALLY IMPAIRED CHILDREN
45
6.1. Introduction 45
6.2. Key words/phrases from design criteria 45
6.3. Development of prototype 1 46
6.3.1. The concept 46
6.3.2. Layout 46
6.3.3. Explorations 47
6.3.4. Feedback and evaluation of prototype 50
6.4. Challenges in developing prototype 51
6.5. Summary 51
7 CONCLUSION 52
REFERENCES 54
APPENDIX 58
X
LIST OF FIGURES
FIGURE
NO. TITLE PAGE NO.
2.1 (a)- A tube of toothpaste provided as an
illustration in a book about bath time
11
2.1 (b)- A thermoformed image of a shell in clear
plastic, beneath the thermoform is a print drawing
of the shell provided for visual learners
11
2.1 (c )- Fake fur fabric, cut in the shape of a child’s
teddy bear, glued to a paper page
11
2.2 (a)- A raised outline of a hand, filled with a dotted
areal pattern, embossed in paper
11
2.2 (b)- Raised outlines created by felt tip pen on
sponge paper
11
2.3 Braille book 14
2.4 A pig toy, a camera, pretend food pancakes,
shampoo, an envelope, a shoe, some tools and a
glue stick provided along with the story book If
you Give a Pig a Pancake.
15
2.5 A large print book 16
2.6 A DAISY audio book reader with the same book
in printed version
16
2.7 A kid reading an E- book in a magnified mode 17
3.1 Overall research design adopted in the study 20
4.1 Ways of teaching different textures to children 26
4.2 Ways of teaching different objects of same shape 26
4.3 Tactile pictures with embossed outlines 26
4.4 Pictures with similar tactile feel cannot be
differentiated
27
4.5 Toys at NAB 27
5.1 Random tactile graphics 30-31
XI
5.2 Tactile graphics of animal faces 32
5.3 Clay models prepared by totally blind children 33
5.4 Clay models by children with low vision 34
5.5 Small tactile flash cards with increasing
complexity level (left to right)
35
5.6 Big tactile flash cards with increasing complexity
level (left to right)
36
5.7 Tactile graphics of 4 legged animal 38
5.8 (a)- Different parts of lion’s face are represented
through different textures
39
5.8 (b)- Different patterns made from a single material
provide distinct feel
39
5.9 Line drawing 42
5.10 Black and white illustration 43
5.11 Colored illustrations 43
5.12 Wash drawing 43
6.1 Layout of the story book pages 47
6.2 Visuals against a white background offering a
high contrast
47
6.3 Visuals against a blue background offering a
relatively lower contrast
48
6.4 Visuals with some highlights added 48
6.5 Different placements of Braille text. 48-49
6.6 Body of honey bee made from foam sheet 50
6.7 Embossed mango fruit and leaves 50
XII
LIST OF TABLES
TABLE NO. TITLE PAGE NO. 5.1 Observations of day 1 workshop 31
5.2 Observations of day 2 workshop 32
5.3 Observations of day 3 workshop 34
5.4 Observations of day 4 workshop 35
5.5 Observations of day 5 workshop 36
5.6 Observations of day 6 workshop 37
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 INTRODUCTION
Children’s literature has an important role to play in children’s learning and lives.
Engagement with picture books at a young age forms the basis of a literate adult and
develops children at a social, personal, intellectual and personal level. Picture books
represent a unique literary form that blends stories with art. Pictures enable children to
explore the world within their own imagination and make connections with characters
and events they see depicted in books. Long before they can read, children respond to
images in an effort to place themselves and the others in their lives into the world around
them. They are constantly exposed to images and texts in their environment; see texts
and symbols on information boards, cereal boxes, shop-windows, road signs, advertising
signs etc. These children therefore quickly learn to recognize different letters and picture
symbols and what they stand for. This recognition of letters and symbols is the first stage
in the development of reading. However, visually impaired children are at risk of missing
out on the special relationship between words and pictures. They are often less familiar
with letters and words when they start school than their sighted peers.
Although it is a proven fact that tactile and auditory cues are most suitable for
training visually impaired kids and many tactile and auditory means have been explored
in other countries, documentation on designing criteria of story books for visually
impaired children is virtually non- existent, especially in India.
Since the reading abilities and mannerisms of visually impaired children differ from
that of normal sighted children, the same picture story books available for normal sighted
children need to be designed differently for visually impaired children suiting to their
needs and requirements.
This project is an initiative to propose design criteria for developing picture story
books for visually impaired children. The study provides information on their skills,
1
environment, knowledge and interests gathered through both secondary and primary
research. The insights obtained have been incorporated in the final prototype.
1.2 RESEARCH QUESTION
The fact that picture story books play an important role in children’s lives and visually
impaired children can not enjoy the relationship between picture and words contributed
to the formulation of the research question of this study – how should the picture story
books be designed for visually impaired children?
The following sub-questions arose from it-
• What kinds of stories are read to visually impaired children and how are they
read?
• At what age are these stories read to them?
• How are visually impaired children different from normal sighted children?
• How are their exploration and cognitive skills? How are they different in
completely blind and low vision children?
• How do they recognize a particular thing?
• How does a visually impaired child perceive things around?
1.3 AIM OF THE STUDY
To study the designing criteria of story books for visually impaired children and
incorporate them into a prototype.
1.4 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
1. To study the interaction system of visually impaired children with the current training
aids and their surroundings
2. To study the design factors which facilitate and hinders reading visually impaired
children.
2
3
3. To develop concepts for interactive and informative story books for visually impaired
children.
4
CHAPTER 2 REVIEW OF LITERATURE
2.1 INTRODUCTION
Children acquire skills that assist them in the task of learning to read and write long before
they enter school. They listen to stories and become aware that print has meaning and learn
to link pictures with the words that are being read to them. According to Pinnell, Lyons,
DeFord, Bryk, and Seltzer (1994) these concepts seem to “emerge” from experience.
“Literacy begins at birth. It does not wait until a child reads his first work or even until he
opens his first book. Literacy is a basic process, set in motion long before actual reading
and writing take place, and it involves all of the child’s development.” (Stratton & Wright,
1991)
A book’s pictures play an important role for a child with typical vision. Pictures add
meaning and interest to the storybooks, enable in stretching the short attention spans of
many children and model coping strategies for children who are just learning to deal with
powerful emotions. However, visually impaired children do not learn to read print in the
traditional way. They rely on tactile and auditory means and use Braille as their primary
learning medium and have very different needs and requirements for teaching approaches.
The following review of the literature focuses on various factors and mediums that hinders
and facilitates the interaction of visually impaired children with books.
2.2 VISUAL IMPAIRMENT
2.2.1 What is visual impairment?
"Visually impaired" means a medically verified visual impairment accompanied by limitations
in sight that interfere with acquiring information or interaction with the environment to the
extent that special education instruction and related services may be needed. 40 The term
5
includes both partial sight and blindness. This impairment refers to abnormality of the eyes,
the optic nerve or the visual center for the brain resulting in decreased visual acuity.
In India, the broad definition of visual impairment as adopted in the Persons with
Disabilities (Equal Opportunities, Protection of Rights and full Participation) Act, 1995 as
well as under the National Programme for Control of Blindness (NPCB) is:-
“Blindness refers to a condition where a person suffers from total absence of sight or
visual acuity not exceeding 6/60 or 20/200 in the better eye even with correction lenses or
limitation of the field of vision subtending an angle of 20 degree or worse”.41 The WHO
working definition of Low Vision (WHO, 1992) is as follows:
“A person with low vision is one who has impairment of visual functioning even after
treatment, and/ or standard refractive correction, and has a visual acuity of less than 6/18 to
light perception or a visual field of less than 10 degrees from the point of fixation, but who
uses, or is potentially able to use, vision for the planning and/or execution of a task”.41
Visual impairment in a person is decided on the basis of visual acuity scores. These
scores are based on the sight perception of people with ‘perfect vision’, and are expressed
as fractions. So a person with a score of 6/18 can see at six metres from an object whereas
a person with perfect sight would see at 18 metres.
People with visual acuity scores ranging from:
" 6/6 to 6/18 are described as having ‘normal vision’
" less than 6/18 to greater than 3/60 are described as having ‘low vision’, and
“less than 3/60 are described as blind.
Although visual acuity is the most common measure, other factors such as field of view
can also be important in determining where an individual sits on the spectrum of sight loss
2.2.2 Statistics of visually impaired population
According to World Health Organization fact sheet 2012, 285 million people are visually
impaired worldwide: 39 million are blind and 246 have low vision. Approximately 90% of
6
visually impaired people live in developing countries. About 65 % of all people who are
visually impaired are aged 50 and older, while this age group comprises about 20 % of the
world's population. With an increasing elderly population in many countries, more people are
at risk of age-related visual impairment. An estimated 19 million children are visually
impaired. Of these, 12 million children are visually impaired due to refractive errors, a
condition that could be easily diagnosed and corrected. 1.4 million are irreversibly blind for
the rest of their lives. 43
About 90% of the world's visually impaired live in developing countries. With 7.8 million
blind people in India, the country accounts for 20 per cent of the 39 million blind populations
across the globe. 16
According to a study conducted by National Sample Survey organization in 2009, among
the major states of India, the prevalence of blindness is found to be highest in Orissa (226
per lakh population) followed by Uttar Pradesh (204 per lakh population) and Andhra
Pradesh (190 per lakh population) where as it is least in Assam (88 per lakh population)
followed by Jharkhand and Gujarat (98 and 99 per lakh population respectively). 43
The prevalence of visual disability found to be higher among female population (0.12
percent) compared to male population (0.10 percent). The prevalence of both blindness and
low vision is highest in rural areas compared to urban areas. It is almost twice in illiterate
persons compared to those who are literate. As the age of person increases, the prevalence
of blindness and low vision increases very sharply. 43
2.2.3 Visual impairment in children
Visual impairment in children means an impairment in vision which may range from having
limited vision (e.g., some light perception only) to having some functional vision under
certain conditions or within a very circumscribed visual field.44 Being able to see gives us
tremendous access to learning about the world around us—people’s faces and the
subtleties of expression, what different things look like and how big they are, and the
physical environments where we live and move, including approaching hazards.
Visually impaired children are delayed in developing a wide range of skills. While they can
do virtually all the activities and tasks that sighted children take for granted, children who are
7
visually impaired often need to learn to do them in a different way or using different tools or
materials.3 Central to their learning is touching, listening, smelling, tasting, moving, and
using whatever vision they have.4
The concepts of reading and writing are known long before in young sighted children
before they learn to read (Wormsley, 1997b). They have exposure to incidental learning in
their preschool years (Koenig, 1996b). As their parents read to them, the children become
aware of the print in books. Their vision of objects around them unifies and structures the
information received via their senses and gives it meaning. Vision helps them in
understanding the relationship of size and shape, details of the form, color and spatial
relationship of objects (Lowenfeld, 1973). Thus, when they start going to school, teachers
use children’s early experiences as a basis for formal literacy instruction (Koenig &
Farrenkopf, 1997).
Visual impairment at an early age affects the incidental learning through casual
observation (Koenig & Farrenkopf, 1997). A blind child receives information in fragments
through touch and hearing and must form a concept of wholeness from information of parts.
This is particularly true of large objects where higher, symbolic thinking skills are needed to
relate a model of an object to the real thing (e.g., model of a car/real car). Extracting the
essential factors of objects which are necessary for recognition, discrimination, classification
and abstraction (e.g., size, shape, texture and function) will create difficulties for a blind
child. Absence of vision in child interferes with the observation of environment and child is
unable to reach out to people or objects that initiates interaction with the environment
(Lowenfeld, 1973).
Corn and Koenig (1996) specifically define low vision. They propose that a person with
low vision has difficulty accomplishing visual tasks even with prescribed corrective lenses.
Pagliano (1994) defines three important aspects of vision. These are “visual perception”,
“visual functioning” and “visual efficiency”. “Visual perception”, he states is “the ability to
understand and interpret all visually received information”. Because “visual perception” is
related to learning capabilities rather than the eye condition, Pagliano argues that children
can still learn with low vision. “Visual functioning” or how children use their residual vision is
related to a child’s experiences, motivation, needs and expectations. “Visual efficiency”
refers to the degree to which a child is able to perform visual tasks easily and comfortably.
8
Pagliano (1998) suggests that the child’s learning environment is a critical factor in his/her
development of effective, efficient visual functioning. The term vision impairment, therefore,
indicates a significant loss of vision that may be the result of one, or a combination of eye
conditions and the resulting vision problems cannot be corrected by glasses.
When visual impairment is caused by a disease or brain hemorrhage, other factors may
also cause difficulties in learning (e.g., brain damage which affects cognitive ability,
orthopedic defects which affect mobility). When visual impairment is one of the several
disabilities, the problems become more severe and complex.
According to the National Federation of the Blind, there are a few learning problems that
visually impaired children may experience in any learning setting, and particularly in a
traditional classroom. If educators use a board to draw out graphs, charts, or other
examples, visually impaired children can't always see it or benefit from it. The same concept
applies to physical exercises and group activities, which are very visual. Educators can help
teach visually impaired children by including specific verbal explanations and tangible
objects that children can touch and feel.
2.3 TEACHING VISUALLY IMPAIRED CHILDREN
2.3.1 Teaching approaches
Since absence of vision obstructs incidental learning in children through casual observation,
visually impaired children need deliberate exposure to concepts. Lowenfeld (1973) identified
3 basic principles necessary for teaching visually impaired children. Those are providing
opportunities by learning, providing concrete experiences and providing unifying
experiences. He emphasized that by participating in hands on activities and completing it
from beginning to end would help such children to integrate information from all of his/her
senses and make meaning from the experience.
Koeing (1992) outlined 3 types of literacy which are essential for students and teachers
play a critical role in developing them- emergent, academic, functional literacy. Emergent
literacy refers to a young child’s developing ability to bring meaning to reading and writing,
academic literacy refers to the type of reading and writing mastery skills that children learn
9
during their school years and functional literacy refers to literacy activities that relate to the
day-to-day completion of practical tasks.
2.3.2 Teaching pedagogical tools
Various Specialized Materials, Equipment and Technology have been used for visually
impaired children ( Carney, Engbretson, Scammell, Sheppard, 2003). They include Braille
(an arrangement of 6 embossed dots read tactually), large print, low vision aids such as
magnifying glasses, telescopic lenses on glasses, monoculars and audio cassettes. For
children with low vision , extra illumination can be provided through various desk lamps
preferably with rheostat control.
Screen readers/speech synthesizers provide auditory feedback when using the keyboard
as well as auditory access to information displayed on the monitor. Students with limited or
no reading vision find these devices useful, especially when connected to Braille and regular
printers for output (JAWS, Intellitalk, IBM Screen Reader/DOS). Similarly, Voice access
systems which allow the user to interact with the computer screen by using voice commands
instead of the keyboard can be connected to Braille and regular printers for output
(DragonDictate, Naturally Speaking).
Optical Character Recognition Software recognizes scanned text and when used in
conjunction with a computer system equipped with a speech synthesizer and Braille printer,
can convert standard print materials to speech or Braille (Arkenstone, OpenBook Ruby
Edition, Kurzweil).
Electronic Braille writers having six standard six-key Braille keyboards and facility to
connect to personal computers and Braille printers allow the user to write, read, edit and sort
approximately 200 pages of Braille.
There are many other facilitators available commercially such as Print-to-Braille software,
Braille printer, calculators with voice output, cassette recorders, Description Video Service
(DVS) describing the visual elements of a movie, Language Master or the speaking
reference guide containing dictionary ,definitions and words and low tech adaptations
maximizing keyboard access through the use of tactile indicators.
10
Some equipments can specifically help children with low vision. These include screen
enlarger software and close circuit TV. - Screen enlarger software programs display
information on a computer screen in a variety of magnification levels. The entire screen, a
portion of the screen or just one line may be enlarged. Students with low vision may benefit
from these programs (ZoomText, MAGic, VisAbility).Closed circuit television systems
electronically enlarge printed, handwritten and graphic materials onto a monitor screen. The
student can control the size, focus, brightness and contrast and polarity of the display (black
on white to white on black).
2.4 TACTILE ILLUSTRATIONS
Many children with visual impairments demonstrate interest and enthusiasm for tactile
illustrations (Miller, 1985; Stratton & Wright, 1991; Wright, 1991; Swenson, 1999; Norman,
2003).Tactile illustrations giving tactile information about story’s book or topic have the
potential to add meaning and interest to books in a child who cannot view the book’s
pictures (Wright, 2008). These tactile illustrations can vary in use. Some books designed for
visual learners contain a few tactile features. However, such tactile features may be of
limited use for a visually impaired child. Braille labels to tactile books produced for visual
learners prove to be more useful for a visually impaired child as it gives the advantage of
offering important Braille exposure and something to touch, even if the tactile illustration falls
short of having true meaning for a young child with significant vision loss. Books with both
print and Braille are appropriate for a range of audiences: children with significant visual
impairments, typically sighted children, children with low vision, and adult readers who are
Braille or print readers.
2.4.1 Types of tactile illustrations
Tactile illustrations may be composed of objects or parts of objects glued, tied, velcroed or
otherwise attached to the page or enclosed in a bag, envelope, or pouch fixed to the page (
figure 2.1a), or forms of objects molded in a thin plastic sheet (clear or opaque) by heating
the plastic in a special machine by a process, called thermoforming (figure 2.1 b), or flat
shapes cut from textured fabric, paper, foam paper usually depicting the outer shape of an
object, and the texture resembling the texture of the real object (figure 2.1 c) or raised lines
and shapes embossed on a paper page providing only an outline of the object where the
outline is often “filled” with a pattern (called an areal pattern) (figure 2.2 a).
(a) (b) (c)
Figure 2.1 (a) A tube of toothpaste provided as an illustration in a book about bath time;
(b) A thermoformed image of a shell in clear plastic
(c) Fake fur fabric, cut in the shape of a child’s teddy bear, glued to a paper page.
Source: American Foundation of Blind
(a) (b)
Figure 2.2 (a) A raised outline of a hand, filled with a dotted areal pattern, embossed in paper ;
(b) Raised outlines created by felt tip pen on sponge paper
Source: American Foundation of Blind
2.4.2 Challenges to tactile illustration
Although tactile illustrations have its own advantages, a tactile illustration cannot replace a
visual picture. A tactile illustration can never be understood as instantly and completely as a
11
12
visual picture. They cannot be seen at a glance and the “viewing area” is limited to what is
beneath a fingertip (Loomis, Klatzky, & Lederman, 1991). Larger areas can be felt with the
whole hand, but detail will be missed. To understand the tactile illustration in wholesome,
the child must scan each part of it and then associate them together logically to make
meaning out of it.
The real experience of an object can never be duplicated in a flat representation, making
it difficult for the child to make a connection between the tactile illustration and the object it is
intended to show. Further, while representing an object through tactile, context becomes
critical because the same shape can be interpreted in many different ways. For example, a
raised outline of a circle can be interpreted as a ball, cookie, saucer, orange, a wheel, moon
etc. Tactile illustrations must be given a context—either provided in the book’s written text,
through verbal explanations, or both. Like shape, texture of a tactile illustration can also be
confused with many other things that have a similar texture (Wright, 2008).
For people who are blind, one of the most difficult problems is to solve its proportion.
Differences in size between an object and its tactile illustration can be especially confusing.
(Jhulka, 2010; Wright, 2008).Spatial relationships are difficult to show and to interpret in a
tactile illustration. The relative arrangement of objects on an illustrated page is quite
different from the child’s everyday experienced positions like above, under, behind in his
tactile explorations of objects.
There are certain conventions used in both visual and tactile displays; being familiar with
these is critical to interpreting tactile illustrations. For example the use of different
perspectives (side view, overhead, cross-section), use of arrows to indicate movement,
hiding a part of object to indicate that it’s behind an another object. A young tactual learner
will not be acquainted with these. In addition, there are many underlying concepts a child
with a visual impairment may be lacking (Aldrich & Sheppard, 2000).
Tactile illustrations of imaginary and non- existent things like castles and dragons prove to
be a significant challenge for visually impaired children to make out a meaning from them.
In tactile books, the meaning of a tactile illustration depends upon the words of the story
(Stratton & Wright, 1991).
13
Tactile illustrations have to be as minimalistic as possible. Blind people get lost and
confused when presented with too much information and are unable to determine just
exactly what it is you want them to “see”. An order or a sequence is always required while
making such illustrations so that the visually impaired child progresses in one particular
direction to get a complete picture of what the book is intended to deliver
2.5 EXPLORATION SKILLS OF VISUALLY IMPAIRED CHILDREN
Unlike normal sighted children who can use vision to solve a task, visually impaired children
have to use touch to obtain information. Moreover, ordinary tasks that are easily performed
by using vision may be complex when they are performed by using touch (Jansson, 2008).
2.5.1 Theories on tactile exploration
The perception of an object is determined by the exploratory actions. An example is the
distinction between active and passive touch. According to Heller and Meyers (1983), active
touch is essential for performing tasks where the perception of forms is involved or during
manipulation of objects in order to obtain information about them. Passive touch can be
important for the perception of known forms of limited size.
Haptic exploration was studied in depth by Jones and Lederman (2006), Klatzky,
Lederman, and Metzger (1985), and Lederman and Klatzky (1987, 1996). Two phases in
exploratory strategies were observed by them: non specific exploratory procedures and
specific exploratory procedures. The non specific exploratory procedures (like enclosure),
give global information about objects, whereas the specific procedures (such as following
contours) give more or less exact information about objects.
2.5.2 Work done on tactile skills of visually impaired
Millar (1997, 2006) studied Braille reading and analyzed the tactile skills necessary for fluent
Braille reading. She concluded that familiarity, practice, and experience are important and
evident in tactile discrimination.
The perception of pictures by people who are blind was studied by Heller (2006) and
Kennedy (2000). The blind people when presented with raised-line pictures were often able
to recognize sketches and outline drawings, even those that were drawn in perspective.
Thereafter, these researchers studied different modes and aspects of picture
representations: tactile space, outline drawings, perspective, and metaphors. It was showed
by Kennedy (2006) that touch allows people to understand outline drawings and in visually
impaired people, the development of drawing is similar as that of normal sighted people.
Kennedy also showed that the geometry of perspective used for making outline pictures is
largely the same for both touch and vision. However the concept of perspective is more well
defined in vision than in touch.
2.6 EXISTING BOOKS FOR BLIND
2.6.1 Braille books
Braille or a reading system using series of raised dots that can be read with the fingers are
the most common and traditional books used for visually impaired people. However,
exploring Braille may not hold the attention of a young child for long periods, and lengthy
descriptions of pictures can take away from rather than add to a child’s interest (Wright,
2008).
Figure 2.3 Braille book
Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braille
14
2.6.2 Story Box Objects
Story box objects are real objects, related to the book, given to the child for handling and
exploration as the story is read to them. They serve as a good first step for sharing books
with young children who cannot view pictures. However, as story box objects are not part of
the book, they may not engage the child in exploring the book to the same extent as visual
pictures and may divert the child’s attention away from the content of the book (Lewis &
Tolla, 2003).
Figure 2.4 A pig toy, a camera, pretend food pancakes, shampoo, an envelope, a shoe, some tools
and a glue stick provided along with the story book If you Give a Pig a Pancake.
Source: http://www.pathstoliteracy.org
2.6.3 Large print books
Standard print is usually in a 10-12 point size. While large print was often thought of as 18-
24 point, today computers and printers can produce text in any size the user desires and in
a variety of fonts. Most users of large print prefer a sans serif font such as Arial or Verdana
which do not have embellishments on letters that can cause visual clutter and confusion like
those found on Times New Roman and other serif fonts (American Foundation for Blind).
15
Figure 2.5 A large print book
Source: www.nationalbookstore.com
2.6.4 Talking books
Talking Books are recorded materials—most often books or magazines—in audio formats.
Talking Book cassettes have to be played on special playback equipment. These books are
easily available worldwide and cover a wide range of subjects (American Foundation for
Blind)
Figure 2.6 A DAISY audio book reader with the same book in printed version
Source: http://www.who.int
16
E-books 2.6.5
An el
can e
who h
and c
to sp
differ
users
new b
lectronic boo
either be rea
have difficul
change the f
poken books
rent factors,
s and differe
business mo
ok or e-book
ad on a pers
ty reading c
font. Text-to
s. Developin
such as th
ent compute
odels (Leopr
k is the digita
sonal compu
conventional
o-speech sof
ng a useful
he reading p
r platforms,
rini, 2004).
al media equ
uter or on de
books can
ftware can b
educational
patterns of u
copyright a
uivalent of a
edicated har
benefit from
be used to a
e-book req
users, acce
and legal iss
conventiona
rdware or so
the ability t
utomatically
quires consid
ssibility to d
ues and the
al printed bo
oftware. Rea
o adjust text
y convert e-b
deration of m
different type
e developme
ook. It
aders
t size
books
many
es of
ent of
Figure 2..7 A kid reading an E- book in a magniffied mode
Source: httpp://www.visionaaustralia.org/
2.7 SUMMARYY
Base
writin
vision
the in
and a
resid
visua
impa
ed on literatu
ng differ grea
n. While visi
nformation in
auditory me
ual vision to
al aids. Vario
ired children
ure review,
atly from no
ion of objec
n books to g
diums for re
o read large
ous types o
n have been
it is eviden
ormal sighted
cts in norma
ive it a mean
eceiving info
e print and a
f pedagogic
n discussed
nt that the n
d children to
l sighted ch
ning, blind c
ormation. Ch
achieve nea
cal tools and
in this pape
needs and r
o completely
ildren helps
children have
hildren with
ar normal re
d books des
er. Tactile ill
requirements
y blind and t
s them to un
e to complet
low vision c
eading rates
signed espe
ustrations fo
s of reading
those having
nify and stru
tely rely on t
can still use
with the he
cially for vis
orm an impo
g and
g low
ucture
actile
their
elp of
sually
ortant
17
18
part while designing books for such children as these children have shown enthusiasm and
interest for tactile illustrations in the past. However, tactile illustrations have their own
disadvantages due to which they can never be understood as instantly and completely as a
visual picture. The understanding of these illustrations is always subjected to the child’s prior
experiences, skills and description either through Braille or through an external reader. Just
the relevant features, a particular order, context and suitable description are some of the
important considerations highlighted by researchers for designing a book for visually
impaired children.
19
CHAPTER 3 RESEARCH DESIGN
3.1 INTRODUCTION
This chapter discusses research design chosen for the study after a background
research and literature review. Following an initial pilot study, an ethnographic research
approach was adopted. An ethnographic approach relies on observations of interactions
and interviews with participants in naturally occurring situation. Interactive workshops
were conducted with visually impaired children (age group 6-10 years) of National
Association of Blind (NAB), Delhi over a period of 6 days. While the researcher broadly
knew the issues to be answered, it was only as the conversations and interviews
progressed that the next question emerged. In this way, the collection of data
progressed through observations and chains of conversations with students and
teachers. Feedback for the research output, the story book prototype in this case, was
finally taken from the participants of the study (students and teachers of NAB) and
incorporated in the final product.
3.2 METHODOLOGY
The methodology started with a pilot study on a group of visually impaired children in
National Association of Blind, Delhi to study the existing system and prevailing problems.
After a preliminary analysis of the system, an ethnographic approach was adopted to
have an in-depth understanding of the exploration styles, learning styles, knowledge set,
tactile perception and comprehension level in visually impaired children of age group 6-
10 years. This study extended over a period of 6 days and included interactive
workshops and non-participant observations. The collected data was then analyzed and
grouped under suitable categories to propose design criteria for story books. Prior to
incorporation of the proposed design criteria into prototypes, a market survey on
existing interactive and story books was carried out to have a general idea about the
communication techniques in these books. A parallel literature search was done on
illustration types and styles in children’s books and general preferences of children in
those books. Concepts were then brainstormed on different subjects taught to visually
impaired children within age group of 6-10 years. An initial prototype on one of the
concept was developed and tested with the children. Feedback from teachers and
children was recorded and incorporated in the final product.
Figure 3.1 Overall research design adopted in the study
3.3 SAMPLE SELECTION
This study made use of purposive sampling. Participants were selected because of
some defining characteristic that made them the holders of the data needed for the
study. For the purpose of this study, the sample was chosen on the basis of pilot study
conducted at NAB. It was observed that stories are read to children of up to KG classes
only and the focus of upper classes is mainly on academics as the students are being
prepared for regular schools. Further, the age group of children found up to lower KG
class varied from 6- 10 years. Thus, 10-15 visually impaired children within the age
20
21
group of 6-10 years and their teachers have been used as sample for this study. Data
was validated through interviews with teachers, Braille typists and librarians
3.4 DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS
3.4.1 Pilot study
The pilot study was done at NAB over a period of 3 days. The objective of the study was
to understand how the education system of visually impaired children is different from
that of normal sighted children. After obtaining permission from school authorities,
informal interactions were made with teachers, students and other staff members of
auditory and Braille printing room. The children and teachers of both junior and senior
classes were interacted with to draw out a comparison in skills and teaching strategies of
both the classes. The observations were focused on areas such as types of learning
equipments, the kind of subjects taught and ways of teaching in different classes, types
of books being used, cognitive and exploratory skills of students and other activities
being done at the school.
3.4.2 Ethnographic study
The data of ethnographic study was collected through interactive workshops. The
workshops were conducted in classroom setting during school timings of junior classes,
from 10.30 am to 1.30 pm. The tasks of each day workshop were decided on the basis
of results obtained from the previous workshop. The children were first given orientation
by the researcher, either through hands-on-experience or through oral instructions
depending upon the objective of workshop. The children were then asked to perform the
task and the observations were made in the areas of tactile perception, exploration and
learning style, comprehension level and knowledge set. The researcher also participated
in their routine conversations and classroom activities to maintain the naturalness of
ongoing interactions. Informal interviews in which questions were tailored to the unique
concerns of data analysis were conducted with teachers at regular intervals. The
discussions provided insights on general skills, habits, behavior of visually impaired
children and dos and don’ts that need to be considered while designing a story book for
22
them. The collected data was finally segregated under suitable design categories of
story book.
3.4.3 Development of story books for visually impaired children
(a) Market survey
Prior to ideation and conceptualization, a short market survey and a parallel literature
search on various types of picture books for different age groups, content, illustration
styles and general preferences of children in picture books was done. The objective was
to design a story book which could be read and liked by normal sighted children too. The
market survey was done through visits to the children’s sections of Delhi bookstores and
online book retailers (amazon.com).
(b) Development of prototype
The market survey revealed that 5 types of concepts are usually taught to children
through picture story books- spatial, temporal, quantity, quality and socio-emotional.
These concepts were taken as central themes and stories were built around them for
visually impaired children considering the design criteria obtained from previous studies.
Reference pictures were collected; sketches were made and were digitalized for the final
development of prototype. The designs were explored in terms of color scheme,
placement of Braille text and materials. Tactile elements were added by hand to areas
easy to read by visually impaired children
3.4.4 Design and prototype evaluation
The developed prototypes were tried out with children at NAB to check the preferences
of children. Feedback was also taken from teachers and the suggestions were
incorporated in the final design.
3.5 CHALLENGES IN DATA COLLECTION
To observe the exploration style of each student of the group, the flash cards were given
to them one by one. However, other students kept interfering and touching the cards out
23
of curiosity. This disturbed the process of data collection. Further, as children with low
vision could use their residual vision to identify the tactile graphics, the actual data on
tactile perception in absence of vision could not be obtained.
3.6 SUMMARY
In this chapter the research design and methodology of the study were discussed in
detail followed by an explanation of data collection methods, analysis and challenges.
24
CHAPTER 4 PILOT STUDY
4.1 INTRODUCTION
This chapter discusses the pilot study conducted at National Association of Blind, New
Delhi to have a general idea about the existing system there and prevailing problems.
The children were observed for a period of 3 days and informal interactions were made
with the teachers. The observations focused on learning equipments, teaching
strategies, types of books and toys and exploratory and cognitive skills of children within
different age groups.
4.2 NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF BLIND
National Association of Blind (NAB), established in 1979, is a non- government
organization working for the cause of blind. It is about 50% funded by the Central and
the Delhi Governments and rest it generates from donations.
NAB, Delhi runs a preparatory school for blind children in the age group of 5-9 years.
The students are trained in languages (oral, reading and writing), daily living skills,
environmental information and object perception, orientation and mobility, physical
fitness and recreation. Around 270 blind students of NAB study along with sighted
students in about 35 regular schools such as DPS, St. Mary’s, Sarvodaya Vidyalaya and
Navyug schools. NAB also runs a Centre that caters to the special needs of 66 Blind
children with additional disabilities. It focuses on the developmental, social education
and rehabilitation needs of such children.NAB also runs a hostel for blind students both
boys and girls within the campus. Currently around 200 students are residing there.
NAB Computer Centre has Speech Synthesizers attached with computers through
which students undergo training in Windows, Word Processing, Internet, Spread Sheets
etc. It also has a Talking Book Library, where printed textbooks are recorded in audio-
CD and cassettes.
25
4.3 OBSERVATIONS
4.3.1 Learning equipments
The teachers at NAB mainly made use of 3 equipments while teaching students – Braille
slate and stylus, Taylor’s mathematical frame and audio books.
Braille slate and stylus – A Braille slate and stylus is a writing device through which
children are taught to write Braille. It consists of two pieces of plastic fastened together
with a hinge on one side. The front portion contains rows of rectangular openings which
guide the stylus. The back portion has rows of indentations arranged in cells allowing the
stylus to emboss dots on paper. Stylus consists of a small handle made of wood or
plastic with a sharp metal point.
Taylor’s mathematical frame – It is an instrument used for learning mathematics. It
consists of an aluminium frame and a set of metal pegs or type with patterns. The frame
has rows of opening each set out as an eight pointed star. The pegs could therefore be
placed in the frame in one of eight orientations which could be used to represent
numbers, letters or signs.
Audio books – Printed textbooks are often recorded in audio cassettes or CDs to
facilitate students in their learning.
4.3.2 Teaching strategies
Teaching different textures – difference in textures is taught in nursery class by
introducing things from daily life such as different kind of fabrics or different food items.
Through the items of daily use, the children get hands on knowledge about rough,
smooth, soft and hard textures.
Figure 4.1 Ways of teaching different textures to children
Teaching different objects of same shape – objects of same shape are taught by
either introducing the actual object, if smaller in size, or through cutouts of different
materials. Some objects are even hand drawn and colored on white paper to facilitate
learning of children with low vision.
Figure 4.2 Ways of teaching different objects of same shape
Embossed outlines for identification through touch – The shapes of some things are
introduced to them through embossed representations where only the outlines are
embossed. Visually impaired children scan the outlines of these representations through
their finger tips to form an image in their minds. Such representations are also used as a
classroom activity for children for filling colors within the borders.
Figure 4.3 Tactile pictures with embossed outlines 26
The Stories are narrated orally by relating to their personal experiences. Scale and
size problems are solved by comparing them with things children have experienced. For
example, elephant can be described as big as a door.
Confusing shapes such as banana and moon (crescent shape) can be avoided by
describing them in different contexts and not using in the same book or story.
Figure 4.4 Pictures with similar tactile feel cannot be differentiated
4.3.3 Toys
There were no special toys being used for visually impaired children. The common toys
that are made for normal sighted children were being used for visually impaired children.
However, sound toys are specially used for teaching animal sounds to children.
Figure 4.5 Toys at NAB
27
28
4.3.4 Books
There were no special story books visually impaired children. The same story books
available for sighted children were used for visually impaired children too. The tactile
graphics remain absent from the Braille books as the organization doesn’t have special
embossing machines and thus it becomes difficult to produce tactile graphics for a mass
population. Apart from Braille books, e-books (stored on computer) and daisy books
(stored in CD or pen drives) are provided to students. Large print books are also
available for children with low vision. The stories were narrated to children of primary
classes only and senior students were only taught academic subjects.
4.3.5 Skills
Cognitive skills - Children with low vision can identify colors with high contrast. For
example they can differentiate between green, yellow and black but blue is taken as
black, orange is perceived as red. The children were aware of different sounds
associated with animals.
Exploratory skills – Visually impaired children usually use left hand while reading
Braille and right hand for writing it.
4.3.6 Other observations
In the playground, a child could not identify which side to climb on a ladder swing until he
reached the top and realized he had climbed the wrong side. This shows the
requirement of some differentiating element which can help visually impaired children
distinguish between 2 different sides of a particular object.
Each teacher at NAB handles a group of 10-12 students, thus giving individual attention
to each student. There is no difference in teaching methods for low vision and
completely blind as the chances of losing sight on growing up is high for children with
low vision.
29
4.4 SUMMARY
The key findings of the pilot study conducted at NAB suggest that apart from Braille
books and audio books there are no special printed story books being used for visually
impaired children. Teachers read stories to children from regular books available in
market. Story narration is restricted up to upper KG standard. The focus of higher
classes is academics as the students are being prepared for regular schools.
In the light of above findings and importance of picture books for children, an
ethnographic study was conducted with visually impaired children of NAB within 6-10
years of age to encompass some practical insights in the further design development of
books for them.
CHAPTER 5 ETHNOGRAPHIC STUDY OF VISUALLY IMPAIRED
CHILDREN
5.1. INTRODUCTION
This chapter discusses the ethnographic study conducted with visually impaired children
of age group 6- 10 years at NAB, Delhi. The study was done over a period of 6 days and
comprised of interactive workshops and non- participant observations. The interactive
workshops were conducted in classroom settings between 10.30 am to 1.30 pm. The
study was done to know how is the tactile perception in such children, what are their
learning and exploration styles and their knowledge set.
5.2. OBSERVATIONS AND INFERENCES OF INTERACTIVE WORKSHOPS
5.2.1 Day 1- Random tactile graphics
On the first day, the children were shown embossed outline representations of random
things. The objective of the workshop was to see if they could identify things by just their
embossed outer shapes.
30
Figure 5.1 Random tactile graphics
Observations Inferences
1. The children could identify the shape of cloud
through touch as they have been oriented towards it in
nursery class
Unless children in nursery are
oriented with a particular
representation, they are not able
to identify the tactual graphics
2. The trunk in the representation of elephant’s face
was mistaken to be a leg as the representations of
elephant and turtle’s body had a similar shape of leg.
When a set of visuals of a
particular category is to be
shown, for example wild animals,
there should be uniformity in the
number and type of parts being
shown.
3. While exploring the graphics, children got confused
on where to start from and what route to follow.
An order should be evident in the
representations to aid their
exploration by children
4. Bubbles formed while making the representation of
elephant body were perceived as eyes by some
children. The same elephant was perceived to have 3
eyes by one child.
The touch of these kids is very
sensitive and thus the tactile
graphics need to be neat and
accurate to avoid wrong
perception
31
Table 5.1 Observations of day 1 workshop
5.2.2 Day 2- Tactile graphics of animal faces
On day 2, the children were shown tactile representations of animal faces. . The parts of
faces were made from different materials. A tactile graphic of human face was shown as
a reference in the beginning. A unique feature of each animal face was described to
them in the orientation round to help them identify the animals on their own.
The objective was to evaluate if they could identify the parts of a face through different
textures of different material.
Figure 5.2 Tactile graphics of animal faces
Observations Inferences
1. The children started exploring the graphic from
the middle of the page and then went randomly.
They scanned the empty space on side, rotated the
page due to which the concepts such as ‘nose
below the eyes’, ‘mouth below the nose’ etc
became confusing for them.
There should be an order or a
direction to guide them during
touching and to make a sense out of
the picture.
32
2. Most of the children could identify just the parts
(whether it’s a nose or ear etc) due to the difference
in texture of the materials.
Different textures can be used to
differentiate between two areas.
3. The children could not identify the animal until
they were reminded of its unique feature.
Description, either verbal or textual,
is important for effective
comprehension of a concept.
4. Some children asked questions about the
animals’ legs and hands as they have been
introduced with the toy models of the same animals
in nursery class. They were also aware of the
sounds made by these animals.
The prior experience of the children
is an important consideration while
deciding the content of the book.
Table 5.2 Observations of Day 2 workshop
5.2.3 Day 3- Clay workshop
On day 3 children were asked to play with clay and make whatever they like. The
objective was to see what their interest levels are and how they perceive things around
them.
Figure 5.3 Clay models prepared by totally blind children
33
Figure 5.4 Clay models by children with low vision
Observations Inferences
1. The items made were models of local and
everyday things experienced by children. They
represented the culture of the place they are living
in. For example- laddu, sevaiyan, dhoop batti,
diya, chapati, local taps.
The representations and content of a
book should represent the culture of
the target audience and not include
foreign names or visuals which
children can’t relate to.
2. Children with low vision could make relatively
more complex and detailed objects in comparison
to completely blind children.
The representations could be more
detailed when made only for children
with low vision.
Table 5.3 Observations of Day 3 workshop
5.2.4 Day 4 – small tactile flash cards made from single material
In the previous workshop, children could distinguish between different materials. The
objective of the 4th day workshop was to see if they could distinguish between different
patterns prepared by using same material. Small sized flashcards with patterns of
different complexity level were prepared to see the extent of their fine exploration skills.
The material used for making these patterns was a mixture of plaster of paris and fevicol
which was then filled in a cone and used for making patterns
34
Figure 5.5 Small tactile flash cards with increasing complexity level (left to right)
Observations Inferences
1. Flashcards with pointed and sharp textures were
rejected by the teacher as they could harm the
sensitive finger tips of children
No tactile representations with sharp
or pointed textures capable of
harming children’s finger tips should
be included in the book
2. Flash cards of small surface area were deemed
unsuitable by the teacher for use by children. It was
stated that with small cards children will end up
playing with edges only. Half A4 sheet was
suggested to be the minimum size for any tactile
representation.
The pages of the book should not be
smaller than half A4 sheet.
3. Any shape/ pattern drawn should be accurate as
it becomes difficult for children to change a concept
once it is formed in their minds.
There should be a consistency in the
shapes/patterns of all the visuals of a
particular thing in a book
Table 5.4 Observations of Day 4 workshop
5.2.5 Day 5 - Big tactile flashcards
Based upon the feedback received from teacher on Day 4, big tactile flashcards were
prepared using the same material and patterns. All the flashcards were prepared in
pairs. These flashcards with patterns of different complexity level were then introduced
to children one by one and the children were asked to identify the matching counterpart
of each card.
35
Figure 5.6 Big tactile flash cards with increasing complexity level (left to right)
Observations Inferences
1.The cards of level 1 consisting of simple
geometrical shape such as square, triangle and
circle were readily matched by all the children. They
could even tell what shape it is and its
characteristics.
Simple shapes, preferably
geometrical should be used for
representations for easy and quick
recognition by children
2.The cards of level 2 with distinct patterns were
also readily matched by children.
Different textures (either made from
different material or from same
material) should be used to
distinguish between 2 different
areas.
3.The 3rd level of cards which had all the patterns
involving lines was confusing with children and
relatively more time was taken to match them> One
student even stated all the cards to be similar.
2 different areas should not have a
similar tactile feel to avoid confusion.
Table 5.5 Observations of Day 5 workshop
5.2.6 Day 6- Story narration
Stories from 2 different genres were narrated to children. The genres chosen were
fables and fairy tales. From fairy tales, the stories of Cinderella and sleeping beauty and
from fables, animal stories of the thirsty crow and the tortoise and hare were chosen for
narration. While narration, children were asked questions at intervals to record their
responses.
36
37
Observations Inferences
1.The children did not know what a hare or a
tortoise looks like when asked about it during hare
and tortoise story.
Prior experience or knowledge can
affect the comprehension of a story
or a concept. For example in this
case the children might not be able
to create any pictures in their mind
until described about tortoise and
hare to them.
2.The children were aware of the hungry crow story.
One child was permitted to narrate the story to the
group. Throughout the story, other children kept
correcting him and adding their inputs.
The interest level increases when
children encounter a familiar
concept.
3.The children were unable to describe a palace or
a princess when asked about them during
Cinderella story.
A suitable description of things not
experienced by children should be
provided in book for children to
understand a concept.
4.The children kept silent during narration of fairy
tales until they were asked some question. They
were not as enthusiastic as in the case of animal
stories.
The children could not relate to the
characters and things described in
the story as they had not
experienced them or had been
taught about them.
Table 5.6 Observations of Day 6 workshop
5.3. CATEGORISING DATA UNDER SUITABLE DESIGN CATEGORIES OF BOOK
The observations obtained through the study have been organized under suitable design
categories required for developing a book for these children.
5.3.1 Illustrations
(a) Planning considerations
As visually impaired children identify graphics through touch, it is essential not to use
two different categories of visuals with similar feel in the same book. Further, when a set
of visuals of a particular category such as wild animals is shown, there should be a
consistency in the perspective being shown. For example, if one visual represents the
side view of the body of a four legged animal, the subsequent animals of the same
category should also represent the side view (Figure 5.7).
Correct Wrong
(a) 1st tactile graphic (b) 2nd tactile graphic
Figure 5.7 Tactile graphics of 4 legged animal
The previous encounters of a particular tactile graphic by children facilitate its
interpretation in the book. They are more comfortable with the graphics they have been
already oriented to and associate with them faster. Thus it is advisable to have a prior
knowledge of such tactile graphics and try to incorporate them in the book. For any new
tactile graphic, an initial hands-on-experience needs to be given to the children.
38
(b) Technical considerations
The touch of these kids is very sensitive and thus the tactile graphics need to be neat
and accurate in terms of overall feel to avoid wrong perception. Two different areas
should be represented through different textures, shapes or lines having a distinct feel
(Figure 5.8).
(a) (b)
Figure 5.8 (a) Different parts of lion’s face are represented through different textures
(b) Different patterns made from a single material provide distinct feel
Any texture or a pattern having a sharp or a pointed feel capable of damaging their
sensitive finger tips is prohibited for use. The illustration should be sufficiently spacious
and the two lines should be at least 1/4 inch apart to be considered as separate.
5.3.2 Content
Without providing a context to the illustration, the children are unable to make sense out
of the graphic. Description, either verbal or textual, is important for effective
comprehension of a concept. A suitable textual description for a simple tactile illustration
can convey an idea to the child’s mind. However, the narrating skills of the external
reader still play an important role and support the understanding of a concept. 39
40
The content of the book should be based on the interest levels and background
knowledge of the children to hold their attention. It should represent the culture of the
place they are living in and not include any foreign names or visuals they can’t relate to.
5.3.3 Layout
Visually impaired children scan tactile graphics haphazardly and may overlap their
starting and ending points which leads to confusion. An order should be evident in the
representations to aid exploration process by children.
There should be sufficient empty space around illustration for their fingers to scan. In
absence of sufficient empty space the children would not know what they are being
made to focus on. There should be not more than two illustrations on one page.
5.3.4 Typography
As there is a standard size of Braille, there is no option of choosing another font or size.
However, in addition to Braille, large print with at least 18 font size can be used for
children with low vision. The type should be simple. Arial, Times New Roman, Verdana,
Calibri are some of the examples. The font should be bold and clear. Text should be
positioned in the same place on each page would provide a direction to children and
help them in reading.
5.3.5 Color
Use of color in books is only useful for children with low vision. These children can
identify high contrast and bright colors.
5.3.6 Page size
The page size should not be smaller than their palm size, approx half A4 sheet. A small
page will only misguide them in their interpretation of what is supposed to be explored
and they might end up with just playing with the edges of the paper.
41
5.3.7 Material
Paper needs to be of good quality to hold the tactile elements. As children explore the
whole page haphazardly, the chances of it getting torn are high if the paper is not of
good quality. The tactile elements can be added using different types of materials or
making different patterns with the same material.
5.4. MARKET STUDY AND LITERATURE RESEARCH ON PICTURE BOOKS OF CHILDREN
Prior to ideation and development of prototypes of story books, a survey on various
types of picture books available in market for small children was done to know about the
concepts and communication techniques in them. The objective was to design a story
book that could be liked and read by normal sighted children too. Thus, a parallel
literature search was also done to learn about the general preferences of children of in
picture books. The market survey was done through visits to the children’s sections of
Delhi bookstores and online book retailers (amazon.com). The books were observed for
their illustration styles, color scheme and subject matter.
5.4.1 Types of Children’s books
Baby books - For infants, these books are generally lullabies, nursery rhymes, finger
plays, or wordless books. The length and format varies with the content.
Toddler books - Very simple stories for ages 1-3 (fewer than 300 words) familiar to a
child's everyday life, or concept books (teaching colors, numbers, shapes, etc.) Books
are short (12 pages is average) and the format can be board books (sturdy paper-over
board construction), pop-ups, lift-the flaps or novelty books (books that make sounds,
have different textures, etc.)
Early picture books - Picture books for children up to 8 years of age. The stories are
simple and contain fewer than 1000 words. Some of them are easy-to-read books for
children who have just started to read on their own. The stories are told mainly through
action and dialogue, in grammatically simple sentences
5.4.2 Basic concepts taught in children’s books
Spatial (location) – right/left, up/down, top/bottom, front/back, forward/backward, above/below etc
Temporal (time) – 7 days of a week, 12 months, always/never, yesterday/today/tomorrow etc
Quantity (number)- counting , addition, subtraction etc
Quality (description) – describing a particular thing, full/empty, tall/short, thick/thin, hard/soft, smooth/rough etc
Socio- emotional (feelings) – Moral stories, manners, expressions (happy, sad etc)
5.4.3 Illustrations styles
The various illustration styles in children’s books include line drawings, wash drawings
(where washes of colors are used), black and white illustrations, full color reproductions
in 3 primary colors and illustrations with a predominant color.
Figure 5.9 Line drawing
Source: http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2009/jun/20/bruce-ingham
42
Figure 5.10 Black and white illustration
Source: http://nancycote.blogspot.in/
Figure 5.11 Colored illustrations
Source: http://www.penguin.co.nz/products/9781409305156/baby-touch-flip-flap-book
Figure 5.12 Wash drawing
Source: http://illustrationforkids.blogspot.in/2007/06/childhood-books-and-favorite-childrens.html
43
44
5.4.4 General preferences of children in picture books
Children prefer books with more than 25% of the space occupied by pictures. Large and
colorful pictures are most popular among them. Young children prefer crude or primary
colors. Soft tints, fine shading and details make pictures confusing for them and are
generally not favored by them. As children grow, their preferences for detailed and softer
tones increase. Children select pictures on the basis of color, prettiness, scenery and
interests in the subject portrayed. Photographs in books are not liked much by small
children.
5.5. SUMMARY
The observations of interactive workshop visually impaired children were segregated
under suitable design criteria of the story book such as illustrations, content, page
layout, color, typography and material. The knowledge set of target audience, big and
spacious tactile displays, distinct tactile feel for distinct areas, colors of high contrast,
definite order in tactile displays and text, consistency in the perspective large font and
plain type, good quality paper are some of the important considerations while designing
a story book for visually impaired children. A short market study on picture books and a
parallel literature on children’s preferences in these books were done to know about the
various illustration styles and visual communication techniques in them.
45
CHAPTER 6 DEVELOPMENT OF STORY BOOKS FOR VISUALLY
IMPAIRED CHILDREN
6.1 INTRODUCTION
After obtaining design criteria and a market study of types of story books and illustration
styles, few concepts were analyzed, designed and developed as prototypes. The
different types of subjects taught to children up to upper KG class were taken as
themes and from each of them concepts were brainstormed and developed as
prototypes. A short study on illustration styles and types of books helped in the
realization of concepts. The prototypes were tried with the visually impaired children to
test their feasibility. The results and feedback from teachers was then incorporated in
the final product.
6.2 KEY WORDS/PHRASES FROM DESIGN CRITERIA
• Content to be planned in accordance to background knowledge
• Page size not smaller than their palm size
• Not more than 2 tactile graphics per page
• No sharp or pointed textures capable of harming their fingertips
• Uniformity and consistency in the shapes of tactile graphics being shown
• Sufficient space (not less than 1/4 inch) between 2 distinct lines
• Enough empty space around a tactile graphic
• Typography- Arial/Times New Roman
• Large print- not smaller than 18 point
• Use of local terminology in content
• Different textures for different areas
• A definite order in placement of visuals and text to guide its reading in a specific
direction
• High contrast colors
46
• Simplest illustrations
• Only 2-3 lines per page
6.3 DEVELOPMENT OF PROTOTYPE 1
6.3.1 The concept
The visually impaired children in nursery class are taught about different fruits as part of
their syllabus. They are given hands on experience through real fruits and through
class activities involving embossed drawings of fruits. Similar embossed drawings have
been incorporated in the first concept. Knowledge about mango has been conveyed in
the form of a story.
In this story, a honey bee and mangoes have been represented as characters. One
day the honey bee encounters two mangoes, one green and one yellow and asks them
certain questions. The answers given by the mangoes form the knowledge part of the
story that is conveyed to the reader. As it is represented through a story, it would have
a stronger impact on children’s minds and would improve their retention power.
Simple illustrations, contrasting colors, 1 line per page, just 1-2 tactile graphics per
page are the other considerations taken in account. For the tactility part, different
materials can be explored and tested with the children to find out the best option. Braille
overlays could be stuck over printed text enabling both normal sighted and visually
impaired to read book.
6.3.2 Layout
The following layout was used for making the pages of the book:
Figure 6.1 Layout of the story book pages
6.3.3 Explorations
Illustrations
The illustrations were prepared in 3 sets with each subsequent set having decreased
contrast and increased use of colors. The objective was to evaluate the degree to
which number of colors can be used and which set was the most liked and felt
comfortable with by the children with low vision.
Figure 6.2 Visuals against a white background offering a high contrast 47
Figure 6.3 Visuals against a blue background offering a relatively lower contrast
Figure 6.4 Visuals with some highlights added
Placement of Braille text
Braille can either be printed directly on sheets of book or transparent Braille overlays
can be stuck on the sheets
(a) (b) 48
(c ) (d)
Figure 6.5 Different placements of Braille text.
Material explorations
Paper – Printouts were taken on paper of 100 gsm, 175 gsm and 300 gsm to evaluate
which would be the most suitable for making pages of story books.
Tactile elements - Different areas need to have different textures for children to
distinguish between them. In this story, 4 different areas needed to be embossed-
mango fruit, its leaves, seed and honey bee. As the visually impaired children are not
aware of the different perspectives, oval body of the honey bee as a whole has been
textured using a foam sheet so that the children encounter same shape on every page
and do not get confused. No tactility has been added to other parts such as wings,
antennae, eyes and mouth. In mango, just the contours of the fruit have been
embossed and for leaves, the complete shape has been embossed. This would enable
children to differentiate between the mango fruit and its leaf. For the purpose of the
prototype, embossing has been done manually.
49
Figure 6.6 Body of honey bee made from foam sheet
Figure 6.7 Embossed mango fruit and leaves
6.3.4 Feedback and evaluation of prototype
The 3 sets of illustrations were introduced to children with low vision. They were asked
to state the most liked one and the one which they feel most comfortable with. The
tactile pages were then tried with a group of 5 children, 3 totally blind and 2 with low
vision, to check the responses of the children towards the book. Feedback was also
taken from 2 teachers. The following were the results obtained:
• The children with low vision preferred the 3rd set of illustrations as it was more
colorful.
• The wings of the honey bee need to be of darker shade as the backdrop and the
current color of wings tend to be similar which may not be distinguished by visually
impaired children 50
51
• Braille text was suggested to be placed below the English text because when the
Braille is place at top, children tend to tear the page in the process of sliding their
hand up against the page
• The book was suggested to be printed in Hindi language also as many parents of
children do not understand English.
• The children could identify different tactile parts on each page due to the difference
in textures.
• The children tend to scratch the foam sheet to feel it’s both sides. Thus, use of a
strong glue or direct embossing of the page is advisable.
6.4 CHALLENGES IN DEVELOPING THE PROTOTYPE
• Braille had to be hand written as the required Braille printing machine was not
available anywhere in Delhi. This was time and labor consuming.
• As the Braille slate is of A4 size, the Braille text could not be written beyond the
width of the slate. As the pages of the book were in landscape mode, a lot of
horizontal space assigned for Braille text got wasted.
• The pages of the book need to be thick as children handle them in a rough
manner. But as writing Braille is difficult on a thick sheet and requires more
pressure, it needs to be written on a separate material (plastic sticker sheet in this
case). This adds to the cost of the book
6.5 SUMMARY
The design criteria obtained from workshops and market study was incorporated into a
story book on mango. Various explorations were done in terms of illustrations,
placement of Braille, page thickness and material. The developed prototypes were then
tested with visually impaired children and evaluation and feedback of prototypes from
children and teachers at NAB was sincerely recorded. The challenges while developing
the prototype has also been discussed in this chapter.
52
CHAPTER 7
CONCLUSION
The aim of the study was to study the design criteria of story books for visually impaired children
and incorporate it into a prototype. A pilot study was conducted at National association of Blind,
Delhi, to understand the existing system and prevailing problems there. The results showed that
are no special printed story books being used for visually impaired children and teachers read
stories to children from regular books available in market. In the light of above findings and
importance of picture books for children, an ethnographic study was conducted with visually
impaired children of NAB within 6-10 years of age to encompass some practical insights in the
further design development of books for them. The study was done over a period of 6 days and
comprised of interactive workshops conducted in classroom settings between 10.30 am to 1.30
pm. The study was done to know how is the tactile perception in such children, what are their
learning and exploration styles and their knowledge set. The observations were segregated
under suitable design criteria of the story book along with a parallel market study and literature
research on picture books of children. The prototypes were developed and tried out with
children to analyze the preferences of children and assess the effectiveness of the prototypes.
They were also evaluated by teachers and the feedback was duly recorded to be incorporated
in the final product.
From the study, it has been observed that,
• The needs and requirements of reading and writing differ greatly from normal sighted
children to completely blind to those having low vision. While children with low vision can
make use of their residual vision to understand a particular concept, totally blind children
have to completely rely on auditory and tactile means.
• The teaching strategies remain same for both totally blind and low vision children as the
chances of losing the vision are high among the low vision children.
• Visually impaired children need to be given a prior orientation and hands on experience
towards various tactile graphics for effective comprehension of the story in the book.
53
• The tactile visuals in the book should be big and spacious and not more than two in
number per page
• The graphics should be simple and any different tactile areas should have distinct textures
to enable visually impaired children to distinguish between them.
• The tactile graphics should be consistent in shape and perspective if the same visual is
being repeated. They should be placed in a definite order
• The text should be plain and simple, bold and large and placed in a definite order.
• Visually impaired children prefer colourful illustrations like normal sighted children.
However, the colours need to be in high contrast to each other.
• Visually impaired children take more interest in subjects in story books which they have
been taught about or introduced earlier. Thus the knowledge set of a visually impaired child
plays an important role in deciding the content of the book
• Visually impaired children tend to take off and scratch any tactile element in the book that
has been stuck to it. Thus a strong glue or direct embossing of the page is advisable.
SCOPE OF FURTHER RESEARCH
There is no specific organisation researching and developing story books for visually impaired
children in India. Further research needs to be conducted in this area with children of different
age groups.
54
REFERENCES
1. American Foundation for the Blind. (2011). Accommodations and modifications at a
glance. Retrieved on 10th February, 2013 from
http://www.familyconnect.org/parentsite.asp?SectionID=72&TopicID=347&DocumentID
=3820
2. American Foundation for the Blind. (2011). What’s different about the way visually
impaired children learn? Retrieved on 10th February, 2013 from
http://www.familyconnect.org/parentsite.asp?SectionID=75&TopicID=351&DocumentID
=3880
3. Bishop. V.E.(2004). Teaching Visually Impaired Children. Charles C Thomas
4. Bright .K. , Cook G. , Harris.J. (1997). Colour, Contrast & Perception ,Design Guidance
for Internal Built Environments. The Research Group for Inclusive Environments, The
University of Reading, UK.
5. Carney.S, Engbretson.C, Scammell.K, Sheppard.V.(2003). Teaching Students with
Visual Impairments. Saskatchewan Learning.
6. Children’s book insider. Retrieved on April 1, 2013 from
http://write4kids.com/colum44.html
7. D.M.Frances, F.Carol.(2000). Looking to Learn: Promoting Literacy for Students with
Low Vision. American Foundation for the Blind
8. Edman.P.K (1992).Tactile Graphics., New York : American Foundation of Blind
9. Eriksson.Y. (1999). How to make tactile pictures understandable to the blind reader. The
Swedish Library of Talking Books and Braille
10. Elster.C., Simons.H.D. (1985). How important are illustrations in children's readers? The
Reading Teacher
11. Foulke.E ., Schiff .W. (1982). Tactual Perception. Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge
55
12. Garnett Francis, Saskatchewan Learning, Gail Clark, Saskatchewan LearningTeaching
Students with Visual Impairments retrieved on 15th feb, 2013 from
http://www.education.gov.sk.ca/vision
13. Guthrie.J , Alao.S.(1997). Designing contexts to increase motivations for reading.
Educational Psychologist. Vol 32, Issue 2
14. Griffin, H. & Gerber, P. (1981). Tactual development and its implications for the
education of blind children. Education of the Visually Handicapped
15. Heller, M. A. (1989). Texture perception in sighted and blind observers. Perception and
Psychophysics
16. India accounts for 20 per cent of global blind population(April,2012). Retrieved 19th
February, 2013 from http://www.deccanherald.com/content/240119/india-accounts-20-
per-cent.html
17. Jalongo.M.R.(2004). Young Children and Picture books. National Association for the
Education of Young Children, Washington, DC.
18. Jhulka.A. (2010). Cognitive Architecture In Visually Impaired. Discovery Publishing
House
19. John Warren Sting. Children’s preference in pictue book illustration. Retrieved April 1 ,
2013 from http://www.ascd.org/ASCD/pdf/journals/ed_lead/el_197212_stewig.pdf
20. Kaneko, K., & Sugai, H. (1999). Study on Production and Effective Utilization of Picture
Books for Blind Children – Examination through Trial in 2 Study Cases. Bulletin of the
National Institute of Special Education
21. Kershman, S. (1976). A hierarchy of tasks in the development of tactual discrimination:
Part one. Education of the Visually Handicapped
22. Kennedy, J. M. (2000). Recognizing outline pictures via touch: Alignment theory. In M. A.
Heller (Ed.), Touch, representation and blindness (pp. 67–99). Oxford, England: Oxford
University Press
56
23. Klatzky, R. L., Lederman, S. J., Metzger,V. A. (1985). Identifying objects by touch: An
“expert system.” Perception & Psychophysics
24. Klein.M.D., Cook.R.E., Gibbs.A. (2001). Strategies for Including Children With Special
Needs in Early Childhood Settings. Cengage Learning
25. Koeing.A.J.,Farrenkopf.C. (1997). Essential experience to undergrid the early
development of literacy. Journal of visual impairment and blindness
26. Lederman.S.J.(1982). The Perception of texture by touch. New York : Cambridge
University Press
27. Leporini.B. (2007). An accessible and usable E-book as an educational tool. Conference
& Workshop on Assistive Technologies for People with Vision & Hearing Impairments
Assistive Technology for All Ages
28. Lewis, S., Tolla, J. (2003). Creating and using tactile experience books for young
children with visual impairments. Teaching Exceptional Children
29. Millar, S. (1997). Reading by touch. London: Routledge.
30. Norman, J. (2003). Tactile picture books: Their importance for young blind children.
British Journal of Visual Impairment
31. Norton, D.E. (1987). Through the eyes of a child: An introduction to children's literature. Columbus OH: Merrill.
32. Otto, F. (1997). Guidelines for design of tactile graphics. American Printing House for the
Blind.
33. Poppe, K. (2004). Guidebook: Setting the stage for tactile understanding: Making tactile
pictures make sense. American Printing House for the Blind.
34. Research and Development Institute (2006). Tactile displays and graphics: Guidelines
for designing tactile displays.
35. Sheppard, L., Aldrich, F. (2000). Tactile graphics: A beginner’s guide to graphics for
visually impaired children. Primary Science Review
57
36. Stratton.J.M., Wright.S. (1991). On the way to literacy: Early experiences for visually
impaired children. American Printing House for the Blind
37. Swift S.H., Davidson. R.C , Weems L.W. (2008). Cortical Visual Impairment in Children:
Presentation Intervention, and Prognosis in Educational Settings. Teaching Exceptional
Children Plus, Volume 4, Issue 5
38. Teacher Resources for Teaching Blind and Visually Impaired Students. Retrieved on
15th feb, 2013 from http://www.ace-
education.org/educ_resource/pt_4/res_impairstud.pdf
39. Telling stories through touch . Retrieved on 31st January, 2013 from
http://www.tactilebooks.org/making/telling-touch.pdf
40. Visually Impaired (2007) . Retrieved on 31st January, 2013 from
http://www.asec.net/tses/Disability%20Criteria/vispaired.htm
41. Visual impairment . Retrieved on 31st January, 2013 from
http://www.bpaindia.org/VIB%20Chapter-I.pdf
42. Visual impairment and blindness (June 2012). Retrieved on 19th February, 2013 from
http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs282/en/
43. Visual Disability in India: Evidence from National Sample Survey (2009). Retrieved on
19th February from http://paa2009.princeton.edu/papers/91928
44. Visual impairment including blindness (2012). Retrieved on 10th February, 2013 from
http://nichcy.org/disability/specific/visualimpairment
45. Withagen.A., Vervloed.M.P.J., Janssen.H.K., Verhoeven.L. (2010). Tactile Functioning in
Children Who Are Blind: A Clinical Perspective. Journal of Visual Impairment &
Blindness, American Foundation of Blind
APPENDIX
STORY BOOK PAGES- HONEY BEE MEETS MANGOES
58
59
60
61
Top Related