8/4/2019 s&P Us Economic Forecast q3q4 2011
1/5
U.S. Economic Forecast: Still Treading Water
S&P August 2011
On August 5, Standard & Poor's Ratings Services lowered its long-term sovereign credit
rating on the U.S. to 'AA+' from 'AAA' and kept its negative rating outlook, which increased
worries that the economic recovery has faltered. The downgrade and concerns that the
eurozone sovereign debt crisis was spreading north to France caused markets to go into a
tailspin last week. This likely forced the Federal Reserve to take more policy action, which
helped calm markets.
However, while the market panic subsided, recovery concerns that helped launch it are still
very real. After the recession officially ended two years ago, the outlook for growth is
worsening and the U.S. economy is still treading water trying to stay afloat. The "temporary
shocks" sound less convincing, even to the Fed, as an explanation of paltry growth during thelast two quarters. The lack of underlying momentum was highlighted in second-quarter GDP
report, where backward revisions showed not only how much worse the recession was, but
how anemic the recovery really is.
While July data finally showed a slight improvement in the U.S. economy, it's not enough to
support expectations that the second half of the year will see a bounce in growth. We now
expect to see an even slower recovery than the half-speed we earlier expected. We now
expect just 1.9% growth in the third quarter and 1.8% in the fourth, to bring 2011 calendar
year growth closer to 1.7% instead of 2.4% we earlier expected. We also downwardly revised
growth expectations for 2012 and 2013, as a more drawn-out recovery is factored into our
forecast.
It is disturbing that policymakers do not seem to have the weapons or the political resolve to
fight the economic crisis. Those policy problems are a large reason why we believe the
economy is more vulnerable to another recession. Once again the Fed is willing to step in,
just like it did in 2008 when Congress refused to pass legislation (including TARP), as
markets spiraled out of control. But this time, the Fed is confronting the collapse with a sling
shot, not a bazooka, so its measures will have less bite.
We are not surprised that in the aftermath of the worst recession since the Great Depression,
the recovery would be slow and uneven. As history has shown, financial crises are often
followed by prolonged recessions, and after that, a long bout of sub-par growth. Severalstudies measure just how much damage a financial crisis can cause, and how long it can last.
According to these studies, economic growth will be slower than normally expected, which
most people won't recognize as a recovery.
Just Like Old Times
The markets' violent swings in early August resurrected fears of the market meltdown, such
as the one in 2008 when Lehman Brothers went under and Reserve Fund broke the buck.
Currently, the crisis is considered to be much more severe, with U.S. sovereign debt at risk of
default. The low Treasury yields indicated that markets were expecting Congress to come to
its senses and reach a deal. However, the wait and the last-minute deal, which left a lot to be
desired, only increased worries that the government will do more harm than good.
8/4/2019 s&P Us Economic Forecast q3q4 2011
2/5
Confidence in the recovery and in U.S. policymaking has hit new lows. After U.S. sovereign
debt lost its triple-A status and financial markets unwound, consumer confidence hit a 31-
year low and manufacturing sentiment readings contracted. While some hard data, such as the
stronger-than-expected July retail sales and recent jobs report, show that not all news is bleak,
the preponderance of evidence to the contrary explains the sour moods. Though we still
expect weak growth, not a recession, the data indicate a more drawn-out, painful recoverythan the half-speed one we earlier expected.
Continued weak growth after sharply downward GDP revisions has made the "temporary
argument" a less plausible explanation for the slew of bad news for the first half of the year.
At least the GDP revisions make the persistently high unemployment rate make more sense.
But the revised data also indicate a much weaker outlook than we previously expected. As the
boosts from rebuilding inventories and fiscal stimulus unwound, consumer spending and
housing couldn't cover the hole, because the former is still working off excess debts and the
latter excess supply. The recovery comprised a first-half average growth of just 0.8%.
The storms that blanketed the U.S. this winter kept people away from the mall and Japan'snatural disaster supply-chain disruptions can only be partly blamed for lower sales. More
importantly, the consumers have been squeezed by higher commodity prices which wiped out
any benefit of the payroll-tax credit. The high unemployment rate, at 9.1%, kept people
cautious, worried that even if they have a job, they may lose it next week. Amid sluggish job
market and stagnant wages, the wallets are empty after people fill up their gas tanks.
There are some signs that the second half of 2011 won't look as bad as the first; however,
anything slightly better than a 0.8% average growth rate is not impressive. The jobs market
will likely remain weak into 2013, so housing will remain soft. We expected some
improvement in the jobs market to help revive household formation to absorb excess supply.
So without that jobs-related boost, housing won't contribute to the recovery. However, maybe
it was retail therapy after all the sour news, but the July retail sales data showed that
consumers began to spend more. Total sales jumped an upbeat 0.5% over June numbers, and
it's not because of a hefty price tag at the pump. Excluding autos, gas, and building materials,
sales were up 0.3% in July after a 0.4% increase in June (sharply revised up from a 0.1%
gain). This comes while the government payrolls report posted a better-than-expected
117,000 job gain and the unemployment rate slipped to 9.1% from 9.2% in June. The results
by no means suggest that we are in the clear. But at least the economy is inching away from a
double-dip recession.
Ready To Take Another Dip?
Does the Great Recession have company? Many think that another crisis will follow the
Great Recession. The global stock-market plunge reflected fears that a double-dip recession
is coming. The bad news during the last few months suggests that these fears may not be
unfounded. The supply shock due to the earthquake in Japan, climbing energy prices, and
massive storms have certainly contributed to the slowing U.S. economy. But even the Fed
admitted that those events alone may not explain the extent of the decline. As I said in my
last monthly forecast report, if a couple of one-offs can do so much damage, it shows just
how fragile this recovery is.
As the economic data continue to disappoint, we have become more worried about the
strength of the recovery. We have been expecting a half-speed recovery for some time.However, the onslaught of dismal news puts even that forecast at risk. We now expect below-
8/4/2019 s&P Us Economic Forecast q3q4 2011
3/5
potential growth through the end of next year. And while the numbers are still positive, the
smaller they get, the greater the risk of dipping into another recession. On August 5, we
increased the chance of a recession in the next year to 35% from 30% in June, and well above
the 25% odds we expected in March.
Given a lag in the release of economic data, which is often revised, it's hard to identify arecession in real time. It takes the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) many
months to announce the start of a recession, and in case of the 2001 recession, it ended just
when NBER declared that it began. But markets still keep trying to predict. There are a lot of
rules of thumb that the investment community uses to signal a recession. One, backed up by a
Fed study, says that when real GDP growth drops below 2% year-over-year, a recession
follows within a year roughly 70% of the time. Second-quarter GDP growth was 1.6% over
last year, so we have a little more time. The three-month unemployment average rate is
another important indicator. Since the Second World War, if unemployment rate climbs by
more than 0.3%, a recession has always followed. We would need the three-month average
rate to reach 9.3%, in order to top the 8.9% trough in March, to say with more certainty that
recession has started. Given the July figure edged down 0.1% to 9.1%, we still haven't arrivedat that point. While a market sell-off is also watched, a plunge in stocks during the past three
weeks doesn't necessarily mean a new recession (the economy avoided a recession after the
stock market crash of 1987). However, amid the fragile economy, the shock of another stock
market drop and resulting loss of wealth could be the tipping point.
Trying to use various rules of thumb to determine a coming recession can be dangerous. And
in this case, where we have a very sluggish recovery, the normal rules may not apply. We
may still be in a sustained, though weak, recovery with intermittent declines bringing the
growth rate so close to zero, which would imply that the economy is falling into recession.
But the signals are disturbing, and at a minimum they show an economy with very feeble
growth prospects.
With the odds of a double dip at 35% and climbing every time stock market sells off, credit
spreads widening, and consumer confidence dropping, when does a double dip becomes the
most likely outcome for the U.S.? As the recovery is on a precipice, there are a few things to
watch. Another shock to the economy, even a mild one, could push the recovery back into
recession. We'd watch whether the deterioration in financial conditions persists or if leading
economic data worsen. Another plunge in the stock market, a deeper contraction in already
weak consumer confidence levels, one more spike in initial claims that holds, or sub-50 ISM
readings for several months would push the recession gauge to the brink.
It's Only Just Begun
Why are we surprised that in the aftermath of the worst recession since the Great Depression
the recovery would also be slow and uneven? As history has shown, financial crises are often
followed by prolonged recessions, which is followed by a long bout of sub-par growth.
Several studies measure just how much damage a financial crisis can cause and how long it
can last. According to these studies, recoveries from financial crises are typically a hard
climb. The economic growth will be slower than normally expected and won't be felt as a
recovery by most.
The McKinsey report (Debt and deleveraging: The global credit bubble and its economicconsequences, 2010) found 45 episodes of deleveraging since the Great Depression, of which
8/4/2019 s&P Us Economic Forecast q3q4 2011
4/5
32 foll
"belt ti
econo
type of
what th
The M
experie
As the
unempl
unfortu
A pape
to the
real pe
crisis G
that in
higherfive ad
crisis e
that fol
the U.
estimat
What'
In a sh
last we
usual c
wed a fin
htening,"
ic expansi
deleveragi
e U.S. is n
Kinsey re
nce six-sev
debt is pai
oyment c
nately
r by Carme
ews. Acco
capita G
DP growth
the 10 year
than in thevanced eco
isodes, un
lowed now
. unempl
d 5.5% na
Left In T
rp departu
k assigned
aveats, wh
ancial crisi
assive de
n, a war,
ng after a
w experien
ort said t
en years o
down, G
nsistently
ounds
n M. Rein
rding to th
P growth
declining
s followin
decade prnomies of
mployme
through en
yment rat
ural rate f
e Tool Bo
re from th
a time fra
ich gives t
s. The typ
faults, high
r a "peace
ajor finan
cing.
at if today
deleveragi
P growth
high, and
all too
art and Vi
ir study, d
ates were
bout 1% i
a severe f
ceding theabout 5%
t has never
d-2009." T
will rem
r another 1
?
usual prot
e to its "e
he Fed a
s of delev
inflation,
dividend").
cial crisis i
's economi
ng where t
could be sl
inflation
simila
cent R. Re
uring the d
"significant
the five a
inancial cri
crisis, withigher. Th
fallen bac
hese depre
ain above
0 years.
ocol, the F
xtended pe
ay out, it
eraging th
r "growin
The repor
s the "belt
es were to
he debt-to-
ower than
low (or
to
inhart (Aft
ecade follo
ly lower"
vanced ec
sis, unemp
h the mediy wrote th
to its pre-
sing result
8.5% thro
ederal Ope
riod" phras
indicated t
report do
out of de
found tha
tightening"
follow tha
DP ratio
it would h
deflation
our c
r the Fall,
wing a sev
ith the m
nomies. T
oyment rat
n unemplat "In ten
crisis level
support o
gh 2013
Market C
. While th
hat econo
cumented i
bt" (throug
the most
scenario,
t path, the
alls by ab
ve been ot
for some),
rrent s
2010) put
ere financi
dian post-
he study al
es are sign
yment ratof the fifte
s, not in th
r expectati
and not r
ommittee
e statement
ic conditi
ncluded
h strong
ommon
hich is
would
ut 25%.
herwise,
which
ituation.
umbers
l crisis,
inancial
o found
ificantly
for then post-
decade
ons that
ach the
FOMC)
had the
ns "are
8/4/2019 s&P Us Economic Forecast q3q4 2011
5/5
likely t
2013."
which
2011. I
more y
to stren
The sta
over c
weakne
that do
hike fr
attempt
Both m
econo
Given
tighten
o warrant
Neverthele
ould lead t
n addition
ars, the F
gthen the r
tement not
ming quart
ss in econ
nside risk
m the Fed
another pr
easures sh
ic growth.
hat the Fe
policy, the
xceptional
ss, it's imp
o an intere
to the Fed'
MC went
covery, an
d that the
ers" than i
mic growt
s have incr
before 201
gram of q
uld boost
They will
d has few
Fed will li
ly low lev
ortant to n
ting strugg
s pledge t
n to say th
"is prepar
Committee
t did befor
h was tran
eased, sug
4. Since th
antitative
inancial co
however,
r effective
ely project
ls for the
te that th
le between
essentiall
at it "discu
ed to empl
"now exp
. The FO
itory. And
esting that
e Fed has
asing simi
nditions, th
prevent th
ways to s
the outloo
federal fu
re were th
the doves
offer free
sed the ran
y these to
cts a some
C also fi
to no one'
more easi
lready pla
lar to the la
ough they
risk of sl
op deflati
to remain
ds rate at
ee dissent
nd hawks f
money to
e of polic
ls as appro
what slow
ally indica
surprise, t
g is likely.
ed its best
st one, pos
ill only m
ipping into
n but has
weak and f
least throu
rs to that
or the rem
markets f
tools avai
priate."
r pace of
ted that no
he Commi
We expec
hand, it w
ibly later t
odestly su
outright d
numerous
ight deflati
gh mid-
opinion,
inder of
r a few
lable"
ecovery
t all the
tee said
no rate
ll likely
is year.
port the
eflation.
ways to
n.