Download - Response From DIA regarding report by Denver auditor

Transcript
  • 1

    Date:April23,2015ThewhitepaperissuedtodaybytheDenverAuditorsOfficecontainsmisleadingconclusionsregardingthecostoftheHotelandTransitCenter(HTC)atDenverInternationalAirport(DIA).Firstandforemost,itismisleadingtosuggesttheHTCprojecthasexperienceda40percentincreaseduetocostoverruns.SomeadditionalworkunrelatedtotheHTCwasaddedtotheprogramatalaterdatethatwasneverincludedintheoriginalbudgetestimates,makingtheAuditorsgroupingofcostsdistorted.Wewouldhaveclarifiedthiswiththeauditorpriortothereleaseofthisdocumentifwehadbeenaffordedtheopportunity.TheauditorsaccountingandcostprojectionsfortheHTCcombinedcostsrelatedtobaggagesystem,terminal/concoursetrainsystemimprovements,roadsandbridges,andotherworkconstructedforthebenefitoftheairport,beyondtheHTC.Thisinterpretationresultsinacalculationthatisnotanaccuraterepresentationofhowtheprojectitselfhasprogressed.MostofthisworkwasaddedlatersoDIAcouldminimizedisruptionstopassengersandtakeadvantageoftheefficienciesofhavingthesamecontractordothiswork.Itshouldbenotedthattheauditor,inthe2014PerformanceAuditofHotelandTransitCenter,recognizedthenecessityoftheseprojectsregardlessoftheHTC.Secondly,thetiming,toneandcontentofthewhitepaperaresuspect:

    Noneoftheinformationintheauditorsdocumentisnew.Allprojectcostsandaccountinghavebeensharedwiththepublic,pressandCityCouncilthroughouttheyearslongproject.Infact,estimatedcostshavenotchangedsinceApril2014.

    Theauditorintentionallychosetoissueanunofficial,politicalwhitepaperinsteadofconductingthemoretraditional,formalandprofessionalperformanceauditlessthantwoweeksbeforetheMay5municipalelection.

    InApril2014,thecityandDIAcompletedariskassessmentthatconcludedthatthefinalcostofalloftheworkunderwaycouldbe510percentoverthe2013contractedbudget.DIAhasbeenverytransparentaboutthisandpubliclyshareditwiththecommunity,theauditorandDenverCityCouncil.DIAhasworkedhardtocontrolcostshowever,duetotheregionsstrongeconomicrecoveryhashadhighermaterialandlaborcosts.Additionally,someunforeseenitemsandthefasttracknatureoftheprojecttomeetRTDsscheduledidcontributetothisprojectedincrease.ItshouldalsobenotedthattheprojectisnotbeingfundedbytaxpayerdollarsandDIAsoverallfinancialpositionisstrong.NothinghaschangedsinceDIAlastannouncedtheprojectedincreasein2014.Today,theprojectremainswithinthebudgetdisclosedlastyear.ThefollowinginformationclearlyshowstheprogressionofcostsassociatedwiththeHotelandTransitCenterandincludesaseparateaccountingoftheothercapitalprojects.TheprojectisnearingcompletionandisonscheduleforthehoteltoopenandbegingeneratingrevenuethisNovemberwiththestationreadytoacceptpassengerswhentheEastRailLinebeginsservicein2016.

  • 2

    2010

    PreliminaryEstimate

    2013ContractSignedwithContractortoBuildHotelandTransitCenter

    2014Announcedriskassessmentprojecting510%increase

    2015CurrentProjectionforProjectCompletion

    HotelandTransitCenter

    $500M $544M $571 $598M $580$586MOtherCapitalImprovements*

    $0M $75M $78 $82M $78$81M

    RTDraillinecosts** $26M $53M $56$59M $56$58M*Othercapitalimprovementsincludesimultaneouslyextendingtheterminaltrainstorageareatoincreasecapacity,rebuildinglevels4and6roadwaybridgesandotherworkthattakesadvantageofcostanddisruptionefficiencies.Noneofthisadditionalworkisrequiredforthehotelortransitcenter,butinsteadsupportsthefutureneedsoftheairportandsoisaccountedforseparately.**LitigationunderwaytodetermineRTD/DIAcostshare,butDIAplannedforthefullamountasaprudentmeasure.