7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
1/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AC^HYKC^HY FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CTSCYV VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~(
yj'946?>>4
BDGCY J+ GiIDOC .ID YOK 406:>:(BGiIdoc@gljl+ilgGL__HYLK * JLC_YVC_AAP6?3 Gdrmcv YvrccvYdk Jrdkihyil! Idahjlrkhd 86403'?6>?Vcacpnlkc2 643+?:>+5000Jdiyhghac2 643+?:>+53??
GHINDCA O+ GHAAC_ .Prl Ndi Zhic(GOGhaacr@gljl+ilgGL__HYLK * JLC_YVC_ AAP4?80 Dzcksc lj vnc DgcrhidyKcu Xlrm! Kcu Xlrm 40406'0030Vcacpnlkc2 ?4?+6:>+>008Jdiyhghac2 ?4?+6:>+5800
Dvvlrkcxy jlr _ccf Cayczhcr Hki+! Ac~hyKc~hy _hym dkfHkjlrgdvhlk Dkdaxvhiy Erlsp Hki+! Ac~hyKc~hy! Hki+!
Ac~hyKc~hy _hym Ylasvhlky! Hki+! Ac~hyKc~hyInlhicPlhkv! Hki+! Ac~hyKc~hy Ychyhkv! Hki+! f,o,dDiisrhkv! dkf Ac~hyKc~hy Erlsp Hki+
SKHVCF YVDVCY FHYV_HIV ILS_V
ICKV_DA FHYV_HIV LJ IDAHJL_KHD
YLSVNC_K FHZHYHLK
AHYD AHOC_H! cv da+!Padhkvhjjy!
z+
L_AX VDHVR! cv da+!
Fcjckfdkvy+
Idyc Kl+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~(AC^HYKC^HY FCJCKFDKVYGCGL_DKFSG LJ PLHKVYDKF DSVNL_HVHCY HKLPPLYHVHLK VL PADHKVHJJY_CTSCYV VL YV_HMC DKFCZHFCKVHD_X LOBCIVHLKY
Fdvc2 Gdx ?4! ?04?Vhgc2 40200 d+g+Bsfec2 Nlk+ Dkfrcu B+ EshajlrfPadic2 Ilsrvrllg 40F
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec 4 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:?0
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
2/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AC^HYKC^HY FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CTSCYV VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~(
yj'946?>>4
VDOAC LJ ILKVCKVY
Pdec
VDOAC LJ DSVNL_HVHCY +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ hh
H+ P_CAHGHKD_X YVDVCGCKV +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 4
HH+ VNC AC^HYKC^HY FCJCKFDKVY JSAAX ILGPAHCF UHVNVNCH_ FHYILZC_X LOAHEDVHLKY++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 3
D+ Padhkvhjjy Jdhacf vl Illpcrdvc uhvn vnc Ac~hyKc~hy FcjckfdkvyVnrlsenlsv vnc Fhyilzcrx Prlicyy! hk Zhladvhlk lj vnc Yphrhv dkfAcvvcr lj _sac ?:+ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 3
O+ Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy Gdfc vnc Kcicyydrx Fhyialysrcy+ ++++++++++ 5
I+ Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy Ucrcdkf _cgdhkUhaahke vlPrlfsic Flisgckvy Yl Alke dy vnc Hkjlrgdvhlk Vncrchk HyPrlvcivcf jrlg Hgprlpcr Fhyialysrc dkf Syc+ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++40
HHH+ P_CIASYHLK LJ CZHFCKIC HY KLV DPP_LP_HDVC OCIDSYCPADHKVHJJY IDKKLV YNLU DKX P_CBSFHIC+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++4?
D+ Vnc Ilsrv Ynlsaf Fckx Padhkvhjjy _ctscyv vl Yvrhmc OcidsycPadhkvhjjy Ndzc Klv Occk Prcbsfhicf+ +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 4?
O+ Prciasyhlk Hy Klv Gdkfdvlrx Uncrc Acyy Yczcrc _cgcfhcyUlsaf Ysjjhic++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 43
HZ+ PADHKVHJJY CZHFCKVHD_X LOBCIVHLKY D_C GC_HVACYY+ +++++++ 4:
D+ Padhkvhjjy Lobcivhlky vl vnc Ydkmcx Fciadrdvhlk drc Gcrhvacyy+ +++++++ 4:
O+ Vnc Lobcivhlky vl vnc Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlk dkf C~nhohvy Drc
Gcrhvacyy+ +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ?04+ Vnc Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlk dkf C~nhohvy Ndzc Occk
Dsvnckvhidvcf+ +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ?0
?+ Vnc Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlk dkf C~nhohvy Drc Klv Ncdrydx+ ++++ ??
9+ Vnc Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlk hy klv hrrcaczdkv+ +++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ?9
I+ Vnc Lobcivhlky vl vnc Plahidyvrl Fciadrdvhlk Drc Gcrhvacyy+ +++++++++++ ?9
ILKIASYHLK ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ?6
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec ? lj 90 Pdec HF)249:?4
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
3/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AC^HYKC^HY FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CTSCYV VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( h
yj'946?>>4
VDOAC LJ DSVNL_HVHCY
Pdec.y(
IDYCY
Oalim z+ Ihvx lj A+D+!?39 J+9f 640 .8vn Ihr+ ?004( ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++?0
Floylk z+ Vuhk Ihvx Jhrc Hky+ Il+!
Kl+ YDIZ 44'048?'FLI!?044 S+Y+ Fhyv+ AC^HY 466986 .I+F+ Ida+ Fci+ 46! ?044(++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++4?
Jrdkm Gsyhi Ilrp+ z+ Gcvrl Elafuxk Gdxcr! Hki+!
55? J+?f 303 .8vn Ihr+ 48>3( ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++5! 44
Jrdycr z+ Ellfdac!96? J+9f 409? .8vn Ihr+ ?009( ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++?0
El Zhfcl z+ Glvhlk Phivsrc Dyyk lj Dg+ .Hk rc Fsda Fcim Zhfcl Idyycvvc_cilrfcr Dkvhvrsyv Ahvhe+(!40 J+9f :89 .8vn Ihr+ 4889( ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++4?
Ellfgdk z+ Yvdpacy vnc Ljjhic Yspcryvlrc! AAI!
:66 J+9f >45 .8vn Ihr+ ?044( ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++4?
Nsency z+ Skhvcf Yvdvcy!839 J+?f 394 .8vn Ihr+ 488?( ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++?4
BLG! Hki+ z+ Dfcaa Padyvhiy! Hki+!489 J+9f 65! 30'34 .4yv Ihr+ 4888( +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++44! 46
Adkdrf Vlxy! Avf+!
953 J+ Dpp~ 503 .8vn Ihr+ ?040( +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++49
Gcvdolahjc Hkva! Hki+ z+ Ulrkhim!?:6 J+9f >9? .8vn Ihr+ ?004( ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++43
Gjlrgdvhlk Vciny+! Hki+ z+ _cycdrin hk Glvhlk Avf+!Kl+ I 0>'06880 BU!?04? S+Y+ Fhyv+ AC^HY 3:5>6 .K+F+ Ida+ Gdr+ ?8! ?04?( +++++++++++++++++++++++++++49! 46
KU Phpc Il+ z+ Fculajj! Olocre * Dyyliy+! Hki+!Kl+ CFIZ 40'0>60!?04? S+Y+ Fhyv+ AC^HY 39>? .I+F+ Ida+ Bdk+ 45! ?04?( +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++43
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec 9 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:??
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
4/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AC^HYKC^HY FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CTSCYV VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( hh
yj'946?>>4
Yvsdrv z+ SKSG Ahjc Hky+ Il+ lj Dg+!?45 J+9f 4463 .8vn Ihr+ ?000( ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++45! ??
Skhvcf Yvdvcy c~ rca+ LIlkkcaa z+ Indpgdk Skhz+!
?63 J+_+F+ :3? .I+F+ Ida+ ?005(++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++46
Skhvcf Yvdvcy z+ Inhafy!3 J+9f 49?> .8vn Ihr+ 4889( ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++?9
Skhvcf Yvdvcy z+ Pdke!9:? J+9f 44>5 .8vn Ihr+ ?006( ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++??
_SACY
Jcf+ _+ Ihz+ P+
_sac ?: +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++pdyyhg_sac ?:.d(.4( +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++3_sac ?:.d(.4(.D(.h( +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++5_sac ?:.i(.4(.E( +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++4?_sac ?:.f(.4(+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++40_sac ?:.c(++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++>_sac ?:.c(.4(.D( +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++>_sac ?:.j( ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++4! 3! :! 40_sac ?:.j(.4(! .?(+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++3
_sac 90.o(.:(+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++5! 49_sac 95 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++pdyyhg_sac 95.i(.4(+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++4?_sac 3: ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++?0_sac 3:.f( +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++9! 49! 43
Jcf+ _+ Czhf+_sac 60? ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++?9_sac 609 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++?6_sac >04.i(++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++45
_sac >09.:( +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++?9_sac 804.o(.4(+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++?4
I+F+ Ida+ Alida _sacy_sac 95 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++?_sac 95'4+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++?_sac 95'?+6++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++?
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec 6 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:?9
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
5/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AC^HYKC^HY FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CTSCYV VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( hz
yj'946?>>4
LVNC_DSVNL_HVHCY
44'3: Gllrcy Jcfcrda Prdivhic Ihzha 3:+84 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++?0
3'804 Uchkyvchky Jcfcrda Czhfckic
804+09+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++?4
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec 3 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:?6
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
6/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( 4
yj'946?>>4
Fcjckfdkvy _ccf Cayczhcr Hki+! Ac~hyKc~hy _hym dkf Hkjlrgdvhlk Dkdaxvhiy
Erlsp Hki+! Ac~hyKc~hy! Hki+! Ac~hyKc~hy _hym Ylasvhlky! Hki+! Ac~hyKc~hy
InlhicPlhkv! Hki+! Ac~hyKc~hy Ychyhkv! Hki+! f,o,d Diisrhkv! dkf Ac~hyKc~hy
Erlsp Hki+ .vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy( rcypcivjsaax ysoghv vnhy lpplyhvhlk vl
Padhkvhjjy _ctscyv vl Yvrhmc dkf Czhfckvhdrx Lobcivhlky Ysoghvvcf hk Yspplrv lj
vnc _ccf Fcjckfdkvy Glvhlk jlr Ysggdrx Bsfegckv .vnc _ctscyv vl Yvrhmc(+
Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy rcypcivjsaax rctscyv vndv vnhy Ilsrv fckx vnc _ctscyv vl
Yvrhmc jlr vnc rcdylky fhyisyycf ocalu+
H+ P_CAHGHKD_X YVDVCGCKV
Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy ndzc ypckv glkvny vrdppcf hk vnc irlyyjhrc lj d
fhypsvc vndv flcy klv hkzlazc vncg! vrxhke vl pdryc vnc daacedvhlky dedhkyv vncg
unhac dvvcgpvhke vl ilgpax hk ellf jdhvn uhvn vnchr loahedvhlky skfcr vnc Jcfcrda
_sacy lj Ihzha Prlicfsrc+ Padhkvhjjy ndzc klv gdfc vnhy dk cdyx vdym+ Jlr c~dgpac!
vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy rcpcdvcfax ylsenv dk hkhvhda ilkjcrckic skfcr _sac
?:.j(! yl vndv vnc pdrvhcy ilsaf c~indkec hkjlrgdvhlk dolsv vnc yilpc dkf kdvsrc lj
vnchr iadhgy= Padhkvhjjy ilskyca rcbcivcf lr heklrcf vncyc rctscyvy+ Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy
Fcjckfdkvy vlaf Padhkvhjjy vndv vncx kccfcf prlvcivhlk vl gdmc ysrc vndv vnchr ellfjdhvn prlfsivhlk lj hkjlrgdvhlk hk vnhy idyc fhf klv ocilgc vnc jdiv pdvvcrk jlr d
kcu idyc ocvucck vnc udrrhke pdrvhcy= Padhkvhjjy kczcr fhypsvcf vnhy acehvhgdvc
lobcivhlk! osv rcjsycf vl yccm ckvrx lj vndv prlplycf prlvcivhzc lrfcr lr lvncruhyc
rcyplkf vl vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy rcpcdvcf dkf ilkvhkshke ljjcry vl rcdin
ylgc davcrkdvhzc rcylasvhlk vndv dffrcyycf olvn pdrvhcy ilkicrky+
Klu! djvcr yhvvhke odim dkf udvinhke vnc ialim rsk lsv lk vnchr fhyilzcrx
vhgcahkc! Padhkvhjjy ilooac vlecvncr yskfrx prlicfsrda dkf czhfckvhdrx lobcivhlky
vndv ucrc klv psryscf lr czck rdhycf prczhlsyax dkf vndv drc dhgcf dv dzlhfhke vnc
gcrhvy lj vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy Glvhlk jlr Ysggdrx Bsfegckv+ Padhkvhjjy
dresc vndv _sac 95 ljvnc Jcfcrda _sacy lj Ihzha Prlicfsrc prlzhfcy vndv .4( vnc
flisgckvy dvvdincf vl vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy Glvhlk jlr Ysggdrx Bsfegckv
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec : lj 90 Pdec HF)249:?3
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
7/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( ?
yj'946?>>4
ynlsaf oc yvrhimck ocidsyc vncx ucrc klv prczhlsyax prlfsicf vl Padhkvhjjy dy pdrv
lj vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy Hkhvhda Fhyialysrcy= .?( vnc fciadrdvhlky lj Ahyd
Plahidyvrl dkf Ahyd Yhgglky ynlsaf oc yvrhimck ocidsyc Plahidyvrl dkf Yhgglky
ucrc klv hfckvhjhcf ox kdgc dy uhvkcyycy hk vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy Hkhvhda
Fhyialysrcy= .9( vnc fciadrdvhlk lj Kcha Ydkmcx ynlsaf oc yvrhimck odycf lk dk
hkvcrprcvdvhlk lj vnc jdivy vndv ilskyca jlr vnc Padhkvhjjy mkluy vl oc jdayc= dkf
.6( vnc flisgckvy dvvdincf vl vnc Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlk ynlsaf oc yvrhimck ocidsyc
vncx ndzc klv occk prlpcrax dsvnckvhidvcf lr drc lvncruhyc hkdfghyyhoac+
Padhkvhjjy glvhlk hy hk zhladvhlk lj vnhy Ilsrvy lrfcr fdvcf Bskc 46! ?044!
.Flimcv Kl+ ??5( rctshrhke acdzc ocjlrc jhahke dkx glvhlk lr lvncr flisgckvy hk
vnhy idyc dkf! czck hj vnc Ilsrv rcdincy vnc gcrhvy! vnchrdresgckvy drc yhgpax
urlke+
Jhryv! hk undv ndy ocilgc vnchrglfsy lpcrdkfh! Padhkvhjjy gdmc vnhy glvhlk
uhvnlsv ilgpaxhke uhvn vnchr loahedvhlk vl gccv dkf ilkjcr uhvn vnc Ac~hyKc~hy
Fcjckfdkvy+ Psrysdkv vl Alida Ihzha _sac 95! prhlr vl jhahke d fhyilzcrx glvhlk! d
pdrvx gsyv jhryv drrdkec jlr d ilkjcrckic uhvn vnc lpplyhke pdrvx+ I+F+ Ida+ A+_+
95'4+ Vnhy rctshrcgckv hkiasfcy glvhlky ahmc vnhy lkc! unhin drc vncgycazcyprcghycf lk _sac 95+ Ndf Padhkvhjjy dvvcgpvcf vl ilkjcr uhvn vnc Ac~hyKc~hy
Fcjckfdkvy prhlr vl jhahke vnc hkyvdkv _ctscyv vl Yvrhmc! vnc pdrvhcy ghenv ndzc occk
doac vl jhkf d udx vl rcylazc Padhkvhjjy daacecf erhczdkicy uhvnlsv osrfckhke vnhy
Ilsrv+ Hkfccf! vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy vrhcf vl rcdin lsv vl Padhkvhjjy ilskyca
czck djvcr vnc jhahke lj Padhkvhjjy glvhlk vl dffrcyy dkx ilkicrky! osv rcichzcf kl
rcyplkyc+ .Fciadrdvhlk lj Ghindca O+ Ghaacr hk Jsrvncr Yspplrv lj vnc Ac~hyKc~hy
Fcjckfdkvy Glvhlk jlr Ysggdrx Bsfegckv .Ghaacr Fcia+( ?9+( Hkyvcdf!
Padhkvhjjy heklrcf vnc rctshrcgckvy lj Alida _sac 95 dkf ilkvhksc vl psrysc vnhy
_ctscyv vl edhk vdivhida dfzdkvdec+ .Hf+( Skfcr vnc padhk vcrgy lj Alida _sac 95'
?+6! vnhy hy jdvda vl vnchr _ctscyv vl Yvrhmc! dkf vnchr glvhlk ynlsaf oc fckhcf lk vnhy
odyhy dalkc+
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec 5 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:?:
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
8/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( 9
yj'946?>>4
Ycilkf! dy d gdvvcr lj ysoyvdkic! vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy fhf klv zhladvc
_sac ?:+ Vnsy! vnc czhfckic vncx yccm vl hkvrlfsic ynlsaf klv oc yvrsim skfcr
_sac 95+ Vl vnc ilkvrdrxdkx fcpdrvsrcy jrlg vnc sysda fhyilzcrx prlicfsrcy
rcysavcf jrlg vnc Padhkvhjjy luk fhyrcedrf lj vnc Jcfcrda _sacy+ Hv hy klvculrvnx hk
vnhy rcedrf vndv Padhkvhjjy fl klv dresc vndv vnc jdivy hkiasfcf hk vnc Yhgglky dkf
Plahidyvrl fciadrdvhlky ucrc uhvnncaf jrlg vncg dkf vncx fl klv gckvhlk dv daa vnc
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy ysoyctsckv fhyilzcrx rcyplkycy lr vnchr skrcylazcf
lobcivhlky vl Padhkvhjjy fhyilzcrx rctscyvy dkf rctscyvy jlr hkhvhda fhyialysrcy
vnchr lkax ilgpadhkv uhvn rcypciv vl vnlyc fciadrdvhlky yvcgy jrlg undv vncx
pcrichzc dy vnc jdhasrc vl c~prcyyax fhyialyc vnc hfckvhvx lj vnc fciadrdkvy hk vnc
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy Hkhvhda Fhyialysrcy+ Hk jdiv! vnc Yhgglky dkf Plahidyvrl
fciadrdvhlky ucrc ljjcrcf hk vnc kdvsrc lj d ilrplrdvc fciadrdvhlk fcyhekcf vl psv
ocjlrc vnc Ilsrv icrvdhk flisgckvdrx czhfckic dkf rcplrvy dy vl ilrplrdvc yxyvcgy+
Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy fhyialycf fsrhke fhyilzcrx olvn vndv ysin vcyvhglkx
ulsaf oc ljjcrcf dkf vnc ysoyvdkic lj vndv vcyvhglkx! hk jsaa ilgpahdkic uhvn _sac
?:+ Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy fhf klv hfckvhjx Gy+ Yhgglky dkf Gy+ Plahidyvrl
dy plvckvhda uhvkcyycy skvha ynlrvax ocjlrc vnc ysoghyyhlk lj vnc fciadrdvhlky.unhin! hk dkx czckv! dayl cjjcivhzcax fhyialycf vnchr hfckvhvhcy hk ydvhyjdivhlk lj
_sac 95(+
Yhghadrax! Padhkvhjjy fl klv gckvhlk vndv vncx kczcr fhypsvcf vnc Ac~hyKc~hy
Fcjckfdkvy acehvhgdvc dkf ucaa'vdmck lobcivhlk vl prlfsihke flisgckvy hk vnc
doyckic lj d prlvcivhzc lrfcr! dkf vndv vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy dyycrvcf vndv
lobcivhlk hk d vhgcax gdkkcr+ Klr fl Padhkvhjjy gckvhlk vndv vnc pdrvhcy ndf derccf
lk d udx lj fcdahke uhvn vnlyc lobcivhlky! osv vndv vnc Padhkvhjjy jdhacf vl jlaalu
vnrlsen lr rcyplkf vl vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy dvvcgpv vl ulrm lsv davcrkdvhzc
gcdky lj dffrcyyhke vncyc hyyscy hk vnc jdic lj Padhkvhjjy hkdivhlk+
Vnhrf! Padhkvhjjy ndzc klv occk prcbsfhicf ncrc+ Vncx fl klv ilkvckf vndv
vncx ucrc prczckvcf jrlg prcyckvhke vnc ocyv dresgckvy dzdhadoac vl vncg .ysin dy
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec > lj 90 Pdec HF)249:?5
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
9/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( 6
yj'946?>>4
vncx drc( hk vnchr Lpplyhvhlk vl vnc Glvhlk jlr Ysggdrx Bsfegckv! acv dalkc
prlzhfc vnc ynluhke rctshrcf skfcr _sac 3:.f( vndv! jlr ypcihjhcf rcdylky! vncx
idkklv prcyckv jdivy cyyckvhda vl bsyvhjx ]vnchrW lpplyhvhlk+ Ycc Jcf+ _+ Ihz+ P+
3:.f(+ Hkfccf! czck djvcr jhahke vnchr glvhlk jlr ysggdrx bsfegckv dkf rcichzhke
Padhkvhjjy lpplyhvhlk! vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy ilkvhkscf vl yccm vl ilkvdiv
Padhkvhjjy ilskyca dkf dffrcyy Padhkvhjjy ilkicrky! acehvhgdvc lr klv+ Padhkvhjjydy
ndy occk vnchr prdivhic vnrlsenlsv vnhy ahvhedvhlkyhgpax rcjsycf vl illpcrdvc lr
lvncruhyc ckedec+ Czck hj Padhkvhjjy glvhlk ucrc erdkvcf! daa vndv ulsaf
diilgpahyn hy jlrihke vnc pdrvhcy vl rc'ahvhedvc vnc glvhlk jlr ysggdrx bsfegckv lk
undv ulsaf hkczhvdoax oc vnc ydgc rcilrf+ Padhkvhjjy idkklv ynlu dkx prcbsfhic! dy
rctshrcf skfcr_sac 95+
Jlsrvn! uhvn rcypciv vl vnc indaackecf flisgckvy vndv ucrc dvvdincf vl vnc
Ydkmcx fciadrdvhlk! hk jdiv vnc flisgckvy dkf hkjlrgdvhlk prlfsicf hk vnc Ydkmcx
Fciadrdvhlk drc prcihycax undv Gr+ Ydkmcx ydxy vncx drc! dkf Padhkvhjjy mklu jsaa
ucaa vndv vnhy hy vnc idyc+ Vnchr dresgckv vl vnc ilkvrdrx hy jrhzlalsy+
Jhkdaax! klkc lj vnc nlfecplfec lj Padhkvhjjy lvncrczhfckvhdrx lobcivhlky hy
ucaa vdmck+ Vnc flisgckvy dvvdincf vl vnc Glvhlk jlr Ysggdrx Bsfegckv drcdfghyyhoac lk d glvhlk jlr ysggdrx bsfegckv skfcr ucaa'diicpvcf czhfckvhdrx
prhkihpacy+
Lj ilsryc! ndf Padhkvhjjy rcyplkfcf vl vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy gdkx
lzcrvsrcy vl ecv d prlpcr fhyilzcrx prlicyy skfcrudx lr rdhycf vnc hyyscy prcyckvcf
lk vnchr isrrckv Glvhlk vl Yvrhmc fhrcivax uhvn vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy! vnc
pdrvhcy ilsaf ndzc rcdincf d gsvsdaax'derccdoac rcylasvhlk vl daa lj vnc fhyilzcrx
hyyscy! dkf vnhy glvhlk ulsaf klv oc kcicyydrx+ Osv vndv hy klv vnc ilsryc Padhkvhjjy
inlyc vl vdmc+
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec 8 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:?>
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
10/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( 3
yj'946?>>4
HH+ VNC AC^HYKC^HY FCJCKFDKVY JSAAX ILGPAHCF UHVNVNCH_ FHYILZC_X LOAHEDVHLKY
Padhkvhjjy glvhlk hy odycf lk d vlpyx'vsrzx diilskv lj czckvy hk unhin vnc
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy zhladvcf vnchr loahedvhlky skfcr _sac ?: ox! diilrfhke vl
Padhkvhjjy! jdhahke vl prlpcrax ysppacgckv vnchr Hkhvhda Fhyialysrcy lr vl prlfsic
flisgckvy dy pdrv lj vnchr Hkhvhda Fhyialysrcy+ Diilrfhke vl Padhkvhjjy zcryhlk lj
czckvy! vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy uhvnncaf hkjlrgdvhlk jrlg vnchr Hkhvhda
Fhyialysrcy dkf frdeecf vnchr jccv dv prlfsihke flisgckvy! daa dy pdrv lj d
ilkicrvcf cjjlrv vl edhk d vdivhida dfzdkvdec lzcr Padhkvhjjy lk d Glvhlk jlr
Ysggdrx Bsfegckv+ ._ctscyv vl Yvrhmc dv 9+( Padhkvhjjy ndzc hv odimudrfy+ Hk jdiv!
vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy ndzc flkc klvnhke osv dvvcgpv hk ellf jdhvn vl gccv
Padhkvhjjy fhyilzcrx fcgdkf! unhac dv vnc ydgc vhgc yccmhke vl ckysrc vndv vnchr
prlprhcvdrx hkjlrgdvhlk rcgdhkcf ilkjhfckvhda dkf udy klv ghysycf ox Padhkvhjjy vl
adskin dklvncr odvvac uhvn vnc Vdhv dkf Ydkmcx Fcjckfdkvy lr ylgclkc cayc+ Vnc
fhjjhisavhcy yvdrvcf rhenv dv vnc ocehkkhke lj vnc fhyilzcrx prlicyy! unck Padhkvhjjy
rcjsycf vl nlaf d _sac ?:.j( ilkjcrckic+ Vl vnc c~vckv fhyilzcrx hk vnhy idyc ndy klv
prliccfcf hk d ilkzckvhlkda udx! vnc jdsav ahcy uhvn Padhkvhjjy+ Dy ysin! vnc prcyckv
ihrisgyvdkicy fl klv udrrdkv dk c~crihyc lj vnc Ilsrvy fhyircvhlk vl yvrhmc vnc
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy czhfckic+
D+ Padhkvhjjy Jdhacf vl Illpcrdvc uhvn vnc Ac~hyKc~hy FcjckfdkvyVnrlsenlsv vnc Fhyilzcrx Prlicyy! hk Zhladvhlk lj vnc Yphrhv dkfAcvvcr lj _sac ?:+
Vncrc hy kl fckxhke vndv vnc fhyilzcrx prlicyy hk vnhy idyc ndy occk glrc
fhjjhisav vndk udy kcicyydrx+ Osv vnc jdsav ahcy uhvn Padhkvhjjy! klv vnc Ac~hyKc~hy
Fcjckfdkvy+ Dy fcyirhocf hk fcvdha hk vnc Ghaacr Fciadrdvhlk! Padhkvhjjy rcjsycf vl
ckedec hk d prlpcr _sac ?:.j( ilkjcrckic prhlr vl vnc yvdrv lj fhyilzcrx! fckxhke vnc
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy vnchr rhenv vl lovdhk glrc hkjlrgdvhlk dolsv vnc iadhgy
dedhkyv vncg dkf vl illrfhkdvc vnc fhyilzcrx prlicyy elhke jlrudrf+ .Ghaacr Fcia+
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec 40 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:?8
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
11/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( :
yj'946?>>4
9'5+( _sac ?:.j( rctshrcy vndv pdrvhcy vl d ahvhedvhlk ilkjcr dy yllk dy hy
prdivhidoac vl fhyisyy vnc kdvsrc lj vnchr iadhgy dkf fcjckycy dkf vl gdmc lr
drrdkec jlr vnc fhyialysrcy rctshrcf ox _sac ?:.d(.4(+ Jcf+ _+ Ihz+ P+ ?:.j(.4(! .?(+
D _sac ?:.j( ilkjcrckic hy zhvda hk czcrx idyc! osv vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy
ocahczcf .dkf vlaf Padhkvhjjy rcpcdvcfax( vndv d _sac ?:.j( ilkjcrckic udy cypcihdaax
hgplrvdkv hk vnhy idyc! uncrc vnc daacedvhlky dedhkyv vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy drc
ilkjsyhke dkf fcdahke uhvn ilskyca hy ljvck fhjjhisav+ .ycc! c+e+! Ghaacr Fcia+ ?':!
4:+( Padhkvhjjy rcjsycf vl pdrvhihpdvc hk d _sac ?:.j( ilkjcrckic! dkf hkyvcdf hkyhyvcf
vndv vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy prlzhfc vnchr Hkhvhda Fhyialysrcy uhvnlsv lkc+ .Hf+!
9! 3! :+(
Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy lobcivcf vl vnhy udx lj prliccfhke dy ilkvrdrx vl
vnc Jcfcrda _sacy dkf skuhyc+ .Ghaacr Fcia+ 9+( Vncx savhgdvcax derccf vl
prlfsic ylgc jlrg lj hkhvhda fhyialysrcy hk dk cjjlrv vl diilgglfdvc Padhkvhjjy
ilskyca dv vnc ocehkkhke lj vnc fhyilzcrx prlicyy dkf hk dk cjjlrv vl ecv vndv prlicyy
yvdrvcf! osv rcpcdvcfax dkf c~prcyyax rcycrzcf vnchr rhenvy+ Vncx gdfc iacdr vndv vnc
Padhkvhjjy jdhasrc vl ilgpax uhvn _sac ?:.j( djjcivcf vnc ysoyvdkic lj vnc Hkhvhda
Fhyialysrcy! dkf vndv vnc Hkhvhda Fhyialysrcy rcgdhkcf ysobciv vl vnchr lobcivhlky+
.Hf+( Vnc Padhkvhjjy fhf klv indaackec vnhy lobcivhlk dv vnc vhgc! osv hkyvcdf ylsenv
icrvdhk ypcihjhi ysppacgckvdvhlk lj vnc Hkhvhda Fhyialysrcy+ .Hf+ 3':+( Hk
savhgdvcax prlzhfhke vndv ysppacgckvdvhlk! vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy dedhk
lobcivcf vl vnc prlicyy! dkf gdfc iacdr vndv! ehzck Padhkvhjjy rcjsyda vl nlaf dk
hkhvhda _sac ?:.j( ilkjcrckic! vncx ulsaf lkax ysppacgckv dy ypcihjhidaax rctscyvcf
dkf fhf klv udhzc vnchr lobcivhlky lr lvncruhyc ysppacgckv vnc rcyplkycy lk dk df
nli odyhy unckczcr vnc Padhkvhjjy ylsenv d gccv'dkf'ilkjcr lk ahghvcf hyyscy+ .Hf
:! 4?! 49+( Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy ljjcrcf vl gccv dkf ilkjcr dolsv vnc
ysppacgckv! osv yseecyvcf vndv vnc pdrvhcy ilsaf glrc prljhvdoax jlisy lk vnchr
ypcihjhi fhyilzcrx rctscyvy dkf rcyplkycy yhkic vnc pdrvhcy ndf glzcf hkvl ypcihjhi
fhyilzcrx rctscyvy+ .Ghaacr Fcia+ :+( Padhkvhjjy fhf klv diicpv vnhy ljjcr! lr
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec 44 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:90
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
12/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( 5
yj'946?>>4
lvncruhyc yccm vl gccv dkf ilkjcr lzcr vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy Ysppacgckvda
Hkhvhda Fhyialysrcy+
Jlr Padhkvhjjy klu vl yccm vl ckjlric loahedvhlky skfcr _sac ?:.j( uhvnlsv
gckvhlkhke vnhy ypcihjhi nhyvlrx! dy hj vncx vncgycazcy ndf ilgpahcf uhvn vnc _sac!
hy jskfdgckvdaax skjdhr+ Lvncr ilsrvy hk yhghadr ihrisgyvdkicy ndzc rcjsycf ysin d
rctscyv! dkf Padhkvhjjy glvhlk ynlsaf oc fckhcf jlr vnhy rcdylk dalkc+ Ycc Jrdkm
Gsyhi Ilrp+ z+ Gcvrl Elafuxk Gdxcr! Hki+! 55? J+?f 303! 343 k+8 .8vn Ihr+ 48>3(
.glvhlk vl c~iasfc prlpcrax fckhcf uncrc glzhke pdrvx fhadvlrx hk psryshke
fhyilzcrx(+
O+ Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy Gdfc vnc Kcicyydrx Fhyialysrcy+
Padhkvhjjy dresc vndv vnc Yhgglky dkf Plahidyvrl fciadrdvhlky ynlsaf oc
yvrhimck hk vnchr ckvhrcvx ocidsyc vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy fhf klv hkiasfc vnc
fciadrdkvy ypcihjhi kdgcy hk vnc Hkhvhda Fhyialysrcy+ Czck dyysghke vndv Padhkvhjjy
idk oc ncdrf vl ydx dkxvnhke dolsv _sac ?:y rctshrcgckvy ehzck vnc dolzc!
Padhkvhjjy dresgckv hy urlke lk olvn vnc jdivy dkf vnc adu+
Jhryv! vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy Hkhvhda Fhyialysrcy gcv vnc rctshrcgckvy lj
_sac ?:+ Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy fhyialycf daa hkfhzhfsday ahmcax vl ndzcfhyilzcrdoac hkjlrgdvhlk rcaczdkv vl vnhy fhypsvc! Jcf+ _+ Ihz+ P+ ?:.d(.4(.D(.h(!
dkf dayl fhyialycf vndv vnc fcjckfdkvy vncgycazcy ulsaf ndzc hkjlrgdvhlk vl
prlzhfc! daochv klv dy pcrihphckv uhvkcyycy osv rdvncr hk vnc gdkkcr lj _sac
90.o(.:( vcyvhglkx+ Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy klvcf hk vnchr Hkhvhda Fhyialysrcy
vndv vncx dy fcjckfdkvy ulsaf ndzc hkjlrgdvhlk! vncrcox hkzhvhke d _sac 90.o(.:(
fcplyhvhlk rctscyv+ Vnc jdiv vndv Padhkvhjjy inlyc klv vl klvhic d _sac 90.o(.:(
fcplyhvhlk hy klv vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy jdsav! ehzck vndv vnc Ac~hyKc~hy
Fcjckfdkvy fhyialycf vndv vnc ilrplrdvc pdrvhcy ulsaf ndzc czhfckic vl ljjcr+
Vnhy hy prcihycax vnc ylrv lj ilrplrdvc rcprcyckvdvhzc vcyvhglkx vndv vnc
indaackecf Plahidyvrl dkf Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlky prlzhfcf dy pdrv lj vnhy ysggdrx
bsfegckv glvhlkvnchr yvdvcgckvy dkf diilgpdkxhke flisgckvy ilkicrk vnc
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec 4? lj 90 Pdec HF)249:94
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
13/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( >
yj'946?>>4
eckcrda kdvsrc lj vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy osyhkcyy dkf vnc ilkvckv lj lk'ahkc
osyhkcyy yxyvcgy vndv drc klv dgckdoac vl divsda prlfsivhlk+ Jlr c~dgpac! hk ncr
fciadrdvhlk Gy+ Plahidyvrl fcyirhocf vnc hkjlrgdvhlk vndv icrvdhk Ac~hyKc~hy
osyhkcyy yxyvcgy flcy dkf flcy klv ilkvdhk! fcyirhocf d tscrx ync rdk lk vnlyc
yxyvcgy! dkf vnck rcilskvcf vnc rcysavy lj vndv tscrx+ Yhghadrax! Gy+ Yhgglky
fciadrdvhlk dvvdincy dfghyyhoac flisgckvy dkf psvy vncg hkvl ilkvc~v ox ycvvhke
jlrvn vnc rcaczdkv ycivhlky+ Vnhy vcyvhglkx ilsaf ndzc occk ljjcrcf ox dkx ksgocr
lj pclpac .dy vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy fhyialycf hk vnchr fhyilzcrx rcyplkycy(!
hkiasfhke vnc pcrihphckv uhvkcyycy hfckvhjhcf ox kdgc rcpcdvcfax ox vnc Ac~hyKc~hy
Fcjckfdkvy+
Ycilkf! ox jlisyhke ylacax lk vnc Hkhvhda Fhyialysrcy dkf heklrhke advcr
fhyilzcrx dkf vnc pdrvhcy zdrhlsy gccv'dkf'ilkjcr ilkjcrckic idaay! Padhkvhjjy
ghyyvdvc vnc adu2 _sac ?:.c( c~prcyyax prlzhfcy vndv d pdrvx idk ysppacgckv hvy
hkhvhda fhyialysrcy vnrlsen gcdky lvncr vndk vnc hkhvhda fhyialysrcy vncgycazcy!
hkiasfhke ox gdmhke hkjlrgdvhlk mkluk vl vnc lvncr pdrvx! vnrlsen lvncr urhvvck
fhyilzcrx rcyplkycy lr lvncruhyc+ Ycc Jcf+ _+ Ihz+ P+ ?:.c(.4(.D( .pcrghvvhke
ysppacgckvdvhlk hk urhvhke lr lvncruhyc fsrhke vnc fhyilzcrx prlicyy(+ Vndv hyundv ndy ndppckcf ncrc+
Vnc zcrx jdivy fcyirhocf ox Gy+ Plahidyvrl dkf dayl Gy+ Yhgglky ucrc
fhyialycf vl Padhkvhjjy hk vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy fhyilzcrx rcyplkycy dkf hk
zdrhlsy gccv'dkf'ilkjcr ilkjcrckicy .hkiasfhke vnc gccv'dkf'ilkjcr uhvn rcypciv vl
vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy dkvhihpdvcf glvhlk jlr ysggdrx bsfegckv! uncrc vnc
ysoyvdkic lj vnc fciadrdvhlky udy fhyialycf(+ .Ghaacr Fcia+ 6+( Dedhk! hv hy vcaahke
vndv Padhkvhjjy zcrx ypcihjhidaax indaackec dk daacecf jdhasrc vl ysppacgckv vnc Hkhvhda
Fhyialysrcy lkax! klv d jdhasrc vl fhyialyc glrc eckcrdaax+ Vnhy hy ocidsyc vncx
idkklv jhkf jdsav hk vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy fhyialysrcy+ Jlr c~dgpac! hk vnc
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy _cyplkycy dkf Lobcivhlky vl Padhkvhjjy Hkvcrrledvlrhcy! vnc
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy klvcf vndv Padhkvhjjy Jhryv Dgckfcf Ilgpadhkv ocdry kl
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec 49 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:9?
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
14/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( 8
yj'946?>>4
rcadvhlk vl Fcjckfdkvy divsda osyhkcyy! dkf vnsy dkx hkfhzhfsda uhvn mkluacfec lj
Fcjckfdkvy osyhkcyy .dkf vncyc drc vll ksgcrlsy vl gckvhlk( ulsaf ilkichzdoax
ndzc hkjlrgdvhlk rcadvhke vl Fcjckfdkvy fcjckycy + + + ._cyplkyc Kl+ ? hk
Ac~hyKc~hy _hym Fdvd Gdkdecgckv Hki+y _cyplkycy vl Padhkvhjjy Jhryv Ycv lj
Hkvcrrledvlrhcy Dffrcyycf vl Fcjckfdkv Ychykv! Hki+! f,o,d Diisrhkv+( Vnc
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy lobcivcf vl hfckvhjxhke vnc kdgc lj vnc ilrplrdvc uhvkcyy vl
oc fcyhekdvcf dy pdrv lj vnc fhyilzcrx lrvlochke jlricf vl hfckvhjx daa lj vnc
hkfhzhfsday uhvn ysin mkluacfec+4 Padhkvhjjy kczcr indaackecf vndv lobcivhlk hk dkx
lj vnc pdrvhcy gccv'dkf'ilkjcr ilggskhidvhlky lr lvncruhyc+
Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy jsrvncr klvcf hk fhyilzcrx vndv! vnc kdvsrc lj
Fcjckfdkvy osyhkcyy dkf vnc hkdpplyhvc kdvsrc lj vnc Dgckfcf Ilgpadhkvy
daacedvhlky hy uhfcax mkluk uhvnhk Fcjckfdkvy lredkhdvhlk hk pdrvhisadr dkf vnc
hkfsyvrx dy d unlac+ .Ycc Ghaacr Fcia+ C~+ D ._cyplkyc Kl+ ? hk Ac~hyKc~hy _hym
Fdvd Gdkdecgckv Hki+y _cyplkycy vl Padhkvhjjy Jhryv Ycv lj Hkvcrrledvlrhcy
Dffrcyycf vl Fcjckfdkv Ychykv! Hki+! f,o,d Diisrhkv (+( Glrclzcr! vnc Ac~hyKc~hy
Fcjckfdkvy c~pdkfcf lk vncyc ysoyvdkvhzc hyyscy hk vnchr fhyilzcrx rcyplkycy! dkf
prlzhfcf d ucdavn lj hkjlrgdvhlk hkiasfhke vnc hkjlrgdvhlk hkiasfcf hk vncYhgglky dkf Plahidyvrl fciadrdvhlky+ .Ycc! c+e+! hf+ _cyplkyc Kly+ 9! 6! 8! 40! 44!
49! ?4! ?6! dkf ?3+(
Vl oc ysrc! vncrc drc dayl hkfhzhfsday uhvnhk vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkv
ilrplrdvhlky unl fl ndzc pdrvhisadr mkluacfec lj vnc jdivy dkf ihrisgyvdkicy lj
vnhy fhypsvc dy pcrihphckv uhvkcyycyh+c+! hkfhzhfsday unl ndf fhrciv ilkvdiv uhvn
Padhkvhjjy dkf unl ndzc pcrihphckv mkluacfec lj vnc jdivy lj Padhkvhjjy hkvcrdivhlky
uhvn vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy+ Vnlyc hkfhzhfsday kdgcyBckkhjcr Bske! Ahkfd
Iadrm! dkf Mczhk Jlacxucrc fhyialycf vl vnc Padhkvhjjy ox pnlkc! hk vnc
4 Hk jdiv! Gy+ Yhgglky dkf Gy+ Plahidyvrl ndf klv xcv occk hfckvhjhcf ox vncAc~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy dy vnc ilrplrdvc rcprcyckvdvhzcy+ Vncx ucrc hfckvhjhcfynlrvax ocjlrc vnchr fciadrdvhlky ucrc ycrzcf lk Padhkvhjjy+ .Ghaacr Fcia+ 45+(
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec 46 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:99
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
15/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( 40
yj'946?>>4
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy Ysppacgckvda Hkhvhda Fhyialysrcy lk Gdrin ?! ?04?! dkf hk
vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy fhyilzcrx rcyplkycy+ .Ghaacr Fcia+ C~+ D ._cyplkyc
Kl+ 4+( Vnsy! vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy ilgpahcf uhvn vnchr loahedvhlky skfcr
_sac ?:! dkf ynlsaf klv oc ysobciv vl dkx ydkivhlk skfcr_sac 95+
I+ Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy Ucrcdkf _cgdhkUhaahke vlPrlfsic Flisgckvy Yl Alke dy vnc Hkjlrgdvhlk Vncrchk HyPrlvcivcf jrlg Hgprlpcr Fhyialysrc dkf Syc+
Padhkvhjjy dayl indaackec vnc hkiasyhlk lj icrvdhk flisgckvy dy c~nhohvy vl vnc
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy ysggdrx bsfegckv glvhlk ocidsyc vncx ydx vnlyc
flisgckvy ndzc klv occk prlfsicf vl vnc Padhkvhjjy+ Dedhk! Padhkvhjjy drc vcaahke
lkax ndaj vnc yvlrx+
Czck ocjlrc vncx rcichzcf dkx flisgckv rctscyvy jrlg Padhkvhjjy! vnc
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy gdfc iacdr vndv vncx ulsaf lkax prlfsic flisgckvy hj vnc
pdrvhcy ckvcrcf hkvl dk dpprlprhdvc prlvcivhzc lrfcr+ .Ghaacr Fcia+ >! 8! 48! ?0+(
Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy gdfc vnhy lobcivhlk cdrax vl ehzc Padhkvhjjy d indkic vl
dffrcyy hv .vnhy hy vnc ylrv lj hyysc vndv hy sysdaax dffrcyycf hk d _sac ?:.j(
ilkjcrckic(+ Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy fhf klv yhgpax gdmc vnhy fcgdkf dkf
vnck yhv odim dkf udhv jlr d prlvcivhzc lrfcr vl oc ckvcrcf= rdvncr! hk d prlicyyderccf vl ox vnc pdrvhcy! ilskyca jlr vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy frdjvcf d prlplycf
lrfcr! dkf yckv Padhkvhjjy d ilpx lj vndv lrfcr lk Jcorsdrx 8! ?04?+ .Ghaacr Fcia+
>! 8+( Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy fhf vnhy cdrax hk vnc pdrvhcy fhyilzcrx prlicyy hk
lrfcr vl ckysrc vndv vnc pdrvhcy ndf packvx lj vhgc vl dffrcyy Ac~hyKc~hyy
ilkjhfckvhdahvx ilkicrky+?
Padhkvhjjy ydhf vndv vncx derccf uhvn vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy ilkicrky dkf
ucrc uhaahke vl dffrcyy vncg+ Ocjlrc vnchr fhyilzcrx rcyplkycy ucrc fsc! vnc
? Vnc lkax zdahf fhyilzcrx rctscyvy hyyscf hk vnhy divhlk ox vnc Padhkvhjjy vlvnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy ucrc ycrzcf lk Jcorsdrx ?! ?04?+ Vnc Ac~hyKc~hyFcjckfdkvy rcyplkycy ucrc fsc vl oc ycrzcf ox gdha lk Gdrin 3! ?04?! vnc fdx ljvnc fhyilzcrx isv'ljj+ Vnc pdrvhcy advcr c~vckfcf vndv fcdfahkc vl Gdrin > yl alkedy vnc rcyplkycy ucrc ycrzcf ox cgdha+ .Ghaacr Fcia+ 5+(
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec 43 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:96
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
16/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( 44
yj'946?>>4
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy frdjvcf dkf yckv vl Padhkvhjjy d prlplycf jlrg lj prlvcivhzc
lrfcr+ .Hf+( Padhkvhjjy kczcr vlaf vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy vndv vncx ucrc klv
elhke vl prliccf dy ndfocck derccf dkf ndzc kczcr ljjcrcf ilggckvy lk vnc
prlvcivhzc lrfcr+ Vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy rc'dyycrvcf vnchr lobcivhlky vl
prlfsivhlk hk vnc doyckic lj ilkjhfckvhdahvx dkf syc prlvcivhlky hk vnchr jlrgda
fhyilzcrx rcyplkycy+ .Ycc! c+e+! Ghaacr Fcia+ C~+ I ._cyplkyc Kly+ 4! 9! 3! :! 8! 44!
4?! 48! ??(+( Padhkvhjjy fhf klv indaackec vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy yvdvcf
lobcivhlky hk rcyplkyc vl fhyilzcrx+ .Ghaacr Fcia+ ?0+(
Jdicf uhvn Padhkvhjjy hkdivhlk lk vnc lkc ndkf dkf vnchr rcpcdvcf fcgdkfy
jlr d prlfsivhlk lk vnc lvncr! vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy prlplycf vndv vnc pdrvhcy
fhyisyy dk davcrkdvhzc rcylasvhlk yl dy vl mccp vnc idyc glzhke uhvn ylgc
ycgoadkic lj lrfcr2 ilskyca vl vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy vlaf Padhkvhjjy ilskyca
rcpcdvcfax! dkf dy rcickvax dy Dprha 90! ?04?! vndv vncx ulsaf oc uhaahke vl prlfsic
flisgckvy uhvnlsv d prlvcivhzc lrfcr hk padic! yl alke dy vnc pdrvhcy rcdincf dk
derccgckv dhgcf dv gdhkvdhkhke vnc flisgckvy ilkjhfckvhdahvx+ .Ghaacr Fcia+
48! ?9+( Dedhk! Padhkvhjjy fhf klv lobciv vl vnc prlplyda! klr dresc vndv vnc
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy ilkjhfckvhdahvx ilkicrky ucrc skudrrdkvcf lr haacehvhgdvc+Hkyvcdf! vncx yhgpax heklrcf vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy prlplyday dkf cjjlrvy vl
ilggskhidvc! dkf orlsenv vnhy glvhlk hkyvcdf+ .Ghaacr Fcia+ ?9+(
Vnc glvhlk hy unlaax hkdpprlprhdvc+ Dy vnc ilsrv c~padhkcf hkBLG! Hki+ z+
Dfcaa Padyvhiy! Hki+! d pdrvx idkklv adx hk udhv! uhvnlsv gdmhke dkx dvvcgpv vl
lovdhk flisgckvy hv mkluy vl c~hyv! dkf vnck yvrdvcehidaax yccm c~iasyhlk lj vnlyc
flisgckvy dv vnc adyv glgckv+ 489 J+9f 65! 30'34 .4yv Ihr+ 4888( .fckxhke rctscyv
vl c~iasfc flisgckvy uncrc pdrvx yccmhke c~iasyhlk ndf klv ylsenv zlaskvdrx
prlfsivhlk lr jhacf d glvhlk vl ilgpca! osv hkyvcdf ohfcf hvy vhgc hk lrfcr vl
c~palhv hvy dfzcrydrxy daacecf fhyilzcrx zhladvhlk= kl prciasyhlk ocidsyc
lobcivhlk ynlsaf ndzc occk rdhycf fsrhke fhyilzcrx dkf orlsenv vl vnc ilsrvy
dvvckvhlk vnck(= ij+Jrdkm Gsyhi! 55? J+?f dv 343 .klvhke vndv d pdrvx ydvhyjhcy hvy
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec 4: lj 90 Pdec HF)249:93
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
17/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( 4?
yj'946?>>4
loahedvhlky unck vnc skfcraxhke flisgckvy drc gdfc dzdhadoac jlr hkypcivhlk + + +
dkf vnhy hy yl czck hj lpplyhke ilskyca jdhay vl dzdha nhgycaj lj vnc lpplrvskhvx vl
rczhcu vnc flisgckvy(+
Vnsy! vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy ndzc klv gdfc d jlrgda prlfsivhlk lj
flisgckvy vl fdvc ocidsyc! fcyphvc vnc Padhkvhjjy yvdvcf derccgckv vl rcylazc vnhy
hyysc illpcrdvhzcax! Padhkvhjjy ndzc klv idrrhcf vnrlsen hk vndv derccgckv+ Vnc
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy ndf czcrx rhenv vl fcgdkf ysin prlvcivhlk dkf Padhkvhjjy
illpcrdvhlk! cypcihdaax hk d idyc hkzlazhke daacedvhlky vndv vnc pdrvhcy ghysycf
ilkjhfckvhda hkjlrgdvhlk+ Ycc Jcf+ _+ Ihz+ P+ ?:.i(.4(.E( .ilsrv gdx hyysc dk lrfcr
rcedrfhke vnc fhyialysrc lj d vrdfc ycircv lr lvncr ilkjhfckvhda rcycdrin!
fczcalpgckv! lr ilggcrihda hkjlrgdvhlk(=ycc! c+e+! El Zhfcl z+ Glvhlk Phivsrc
Dyyk lj Dg+ .Hk rc Fsda Fcim Zhfcl Idyycvvc _cilrfcr Dkvhvrsyv Ahvhe+(! 40 J+9f
:89! :83 .8vn Ihr+ 4889( .rcilekhhke vndv prlvcivhzc lrfcry drc ljvck yvhpsadvcf vl
hk fhypsvcy hkzlazhke osyhkcyy ckvhvhcy(=Floylk z+ Vuhk Ihvx Jhrc Hky+ Il+! Kl+
YDIZ 44'048?'FLI .GAE~(! ?044 S+Y+ Fhyv+ AC^HY 466986! dv "40'44 .I+F+
Ida+ Fci+ 46! ?044( .hkysrdkic ilgpdkxy rcycrzc hkjlrgdvhlk tsdahjhcy dy d vrdfc
ycircv lr lvncr ilkjhfckvhda rcycdrin! fczcalpgckv! lr ilggcrihda hkjlrgdvhlkskfcr _sac ?:(+ Dy ysin! vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy ilkfsiv hy ysoyvdkvhdaax
bsyvhjhcf! prciasfhke vnc dppahidvhlk lj_sac 95+ Jcf+ _+ Ihz+ P+ 95.i(.4(=
Ellfgdk z+ Yvdpacy vnc Ljjhic Yspcryvlrc! AAI! :66 J+9f >45! >?: .8vn Ihr+ ?044(
.d ilsrv uhaa klv prciasfc d pdrvx jrlg syhke prczhlsyax skfhyialycf hkjlrgdvhlk lr
uhvkcyycy hj vnc jdhasrc vl fhyialyc udy ysoyvdkvhdaax bsyvhjhcf lr hy ndrgacyy(
.hkvcrkda ihvdvhlky lghvvcf(+
HHH+ P_CIASYHLK LJ CZHFCKIC HY KLV DPP_LP_HDVCOCIDSYC PADHKVHJJY IDKKLV YNLU DKX P_CBSFHIC+
D+ Vnc Ilsrv Ynlsaf Fckx Padhkvhjjy _ctscyv vl Yvrhmc OcidsycPadhkvhjjy Ndzc Klv Occk Prcbsfhicf+
Padhkvhjjy daacec vndv vncx ndzc occk fckhcf vnc lpplrvskhvx vl dkdaxc vncyc
flisgckvy= ]dkf ndzcW occk fckhcf vnc dohahvx vl fcplyc dkf c~dghkc Fcjckfdkvy
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec 45 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:9:
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
18/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( 49
yj'946?>>4
Cgpalxccy ]yhiW! Ahyd Yhgglky dkf Ahyd Plahidyvrl= dkf rcycaacry lj vnc _ccf
Fcjckfdkvy+ + + ._ctscyv vl Yvrhmc dv :+( Padhkvhjjy daacedvhlky vnsy rctshrc vnc
Ilsrv vl diicpv vnc dyysgpvhlk vndv! ndf vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy prlzhfcf d
glrc ilgpacvc fhyialysrc! Padhkvhjjy ulsaf ndzc klvhicf Plahidyvrly dkf
Yhgglkyy fcplyhvhlky! lr vdmck jsrvncr yvcpy vl ckvcr vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy
prlplycf prlvcivhzc lrfcr+ Osv Padhkvhjjy ilkfsiv hk vnhy idyc yspplrvy bsyv vnc
lpplyhvc ilkiasyhlk+ Padhkvhjjy ilsaf ndzc vdmck d _sac 90.o(.:( fcplyhvhlk lj vnc
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy= hkyvcdf! vncx fhf klv klvhic d yhkeac fcplyhvhlk lr czck
rdhyc vnc plyyhohahvx lj flhke yl+ .Ghaacr Fcia+ ??+( Vncx ilsaf ndzc vdmck yvcpy
vl ckvcr vnc prlplycf prlvcivhzc lrfcr= hkyvcdf! vncx fhf klvnhke unhac ilkvhkshke vl
fcgdkf vndv vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy prlfsic ilkjhfckvhda hkjlrgdvhlk+ .Ghaacr
Fcia+ 48! ?9+( Glrclzcr! Padhkvhjjy ycrzcf vnchr fhyilzcrx rctscyvy yl vndv vnc
rcyplkycy ucrc fsc lk vnc adyv fdx lj vnc fhyilzcrx pcrhlf+ Hk ysg! Padhkvhjjy adim
lj fhaheckic vnrlsenlsv vnc fhyilzcrx pcrhlf skfcrghkcy vnchr dyycrvhlk lj
prcbsfhic+ Ycc Adkdrf Vlxy! Avf+! 953 J+ Dpp~ 503! 549 .8vn Ihr+ ?040( .fhyvrhiv
ilsrv fhf klv dosyc hvy fhyircvhlk ox acvvhke c~pcrv vcyvhjx dv vrhda uncrc dppcaadkvy
ilsaf ndzc fcplycf vnc c~pcrv osv inlyc klv vl(=ycc dayl Gjlrgdvhlk Vciny+! Hki+ z+
_cycdrin hk Glvhlk Avf+! Kl+ I 0>'06880 BU! ?04? S+Y+ Fhyv+ AC^HY 3:5>6! dv
"96 .K+F+ Ida+ Gdr+ ?8! ?04?( .jhkfhke kl ndrg uncrc fcjckfdkvy ndf dgpac
lpplrvskhvx vl c~dghkc vnc hkjlrgdvhlk dv hyysc! osv udhvcf d xcdr vl fl yl(+
Jsrvncrglrc! hk vnhy ilkvc~v vnc lkax prcbsfhic vndv czck ilkichzdoax ilsaf
oc ynluk ox vnc Padhkvhjjy ulsaf oc hj vnc daacecf jdhasrc vl fhyialyc djjcivcf vnc
Padhkvhjjy dohahvx vl lpplyc vnc pckfhke glvhlk jlr ysggdrx bsfegckv+ Osv
Padhkvhjjy kczcr daacec vndv vncx ndzc occk fcprhzcf lj dkx jdivy cyyckvhda vl bsyvhjx
]vnchrW lpplyhvhlk vl vnc Glvhlk jlr Ysggdrx Bsfegckv! acv dalkc vl gdmc vnc
rctshrcf ynluhke skfcr _sac 3:.f(+ Jcf+ _+ Ihz+ P+ 3:.f(+ Hkfccf! Padhkvhjjy
orhcjhke lk vnc prcyckv glvhlk yspplrvy bsyv vnc lpplyhvc ilkiasyhlk2 Padhkvhjjy
ysoghvvcf d ?3'pdec orhcj hk Lpplyhvhlk vl vnc Glvhlk jlr Ysggdrx Bsfegckv!
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec 4> lj 90 Pdec HF)249:95
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
19/30
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
20/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( 43
yj'946?>>4
O+ Prciasyhlk Hy Klv Gdkfdvlrx Uncrc Acyy Yczcrc _cgcfhcy UlsafYsjjhic+
Czck hj lkc dyysgcy vndv ylgcvnhke udy klv fhyialycf dkf vndv vnc daacecf
klkfhyialysrc udy klv ysoyvdkvhdaax bsyvhjhcf lr ndrgacyy! yvrhmhke vnc Ac~hyKc~hy
Fcjckfdkvy Fciadrdvhlky dkf C~nhohvy yvhaa ulsaf klv oc dpprlprhdvc+ _sac 95
c~prcyyax prlzhfcy vndv prciasyhlk lj czhfckic klv prlfsicf hk fhyilzcrx hy klv
gdkfdvlrx+ Ilsrvy hk vnhy Fhyvrhiv ndzc! jlr c~dgpac! rclpckcf fhyilzcrx jlr
ahghvcf psrplycy dkf lrfcrcf vnc klk'fhyialyhke pdrvx vl ysppacgckv hvy fhyilzcrx
rcyplkycy rdvncr vndk c~iasfc skfhyialycf czhfckic hk rcyplkyc vl d _sac 95
glvhlk+ KU Phpc Il+ z+ Fculajj! Olocre * Dyyliy+! Hki+!Kl+ CFIZ 40'0>60!
?04? S+Y+ Fhyv+ AC^HY 39>?! dv "4? .I+F+ Ida+ Bdk+ 45! ?04?( .fckxhke rctscyv vl
c~iasfc czhfckic dkf klvhke vndv vnc jdiv vndv vnhy ydkivhlk idk oc hgplycf flcy
klv kcicyydrhax gcdk vndv hv ynlsaf(+ Lr! hj vnhy Ilsrv fcyhrcy! vnc Ac~hyKc~hy
Fcjckfdkvy ilsaf rc'jhac vnchr glvhlk syhke vnc vcyvhglkx lj lkc lj vnc prczhlsyax
hfckvhjhcf uhvkcyycy! lr djvcr ysppacgckvhke vnchr prczhlsy fhyilzcrx+
Ncrc! vrhda hy glkvny! hj klv xcdry! dudx! dkf kl vrhda fdvc hy yincfsacf+ Hj
undv Padhkvhjjy ylsenv udy dffhvhlkda fhyilzcrx lk ypcihjhi hyyscy! vncx ynlsaf ndzc
glzcf skfcr _sac 3:.f( jlr glrc vhgc vl lovdhk fhyilzcrx dkf,lr vdmc fcplyhvhlky+
Ycc Jcf+ _+ Ihz+ P+ 3:.f( .Hj d klkglzdkv ynluy ox djjhfdzhv lr fciadrdvhlk vndv!
jlr ypcihjhcf rcdylky! hv idkklv prcyckv jdivy cyyckvhda vl bsyvhjx hvy lpplyhvhlk! vnc
ilsrv gdx2 .4( fcjcr ilkyhfcrhke vnc glvhlk lr fckx hv= .?( daalu vhgc vl lovdhk
djjhfdzhvy lr fciadrdvhlky lr vl vdmc fhyilzcrx+ + +(=ycc dayl Gcvdolahjc Hkva! Hki+ z+
Ulrkhim! ?:6 J+9f >9?! >6: .8vn Ihr+ ?004( ._sac 3:.f( rctshrcy fhyilzcrx uncrc
vnc klkglzhke pdrvx ndy klv ndf vnc lpplrvskhvx vl fhyilzcr hkjlrgdvhlk vndv hy
cyyckvhda vl hvy lpplyhvhlk+( .tslvhkeDkfcrylk z+ Ahocrvx Aloox! Hki+! 655 S+Y+
?6?! ?30 k+3 .48>:((+ Davcrkdvhzcax! vncx ynlsaf ndzc ylsenv vl gccv'dkf'ilkjcr lk
vncyc hyyscy dkf! hj vncx vnlsenv hv kcicyydrx! glzcf vl ilgpca rcyplkycy+
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec ?0 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:98
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
21/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( 4:
yj'946?>>4
Padhkvhjjy ndzc klv ihvcf d yhkeac _sac 95 idyc hk unhin _sac 95 ndy occk ckjlricf
uncrc d pdrvx ndf lobcivhlky lsvyvdkfhke lk vnc rcaczdkv fhyilzcrx hyyscy+
Hkyvcdf! vncx dym vnc Ilsrv vl pskhyn vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy hk d ohf vl
jsrvncr fcadx vnc c~hv jrlg vnhy idyc lj pdrvhcy uhvn kl rcaczdkv ilkvdivy vl vnc
skfcraxhke fhypsvc+ Ysin gdkcszcry fl klv udrrdkv vnc Ilsrvy c~crihyc lj
fhyircvhlk! dkf vnc glvhlk vl c~iasfc ynlsaf vncrcjlrc oc fckhcf+
HZ+ PADHKVHJJY CZHFCKVHD_X LOBCIVHLKY D_CGC_HVACYY+
Hk vnchr _ctscyv vl Yvrhmc! Padhkvhjjy dayl hkvcrplyc icrvdhk czhfckvhdrx
lobcivhlky vl vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy fciadrdvhlky dkf c~nhohvy+ Inhcjax! vncx
dresc vndv vnc fciadrdvhlky dkf c~nhohvy drc hkdfghyyhoac ocidsyc vncx drc ncdrydx
dkf ndzc klv occk dsvnckvhidvcf+ Vncx dayl dresc vndv vnc Ydkmcx Fciadrdvhlk
ynlsaf oc yvrhimck odycf lk dk dresgckv vndv Padhkvhjjy ilskyca mkluy hy jdayc+
Vncyc lobcivhlky drc gcrhvacyy+
D+ Padhkvhjjy Lobcivhlky vl vnc Ydkmcx Fciadrdvhlk drc Gcrhvacyy+
Hk vnchr glzhke pdpcry! vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy klvcf hk d orhcj jllvklvc
vndv Kcha Ydkmcx fhf klv lovdhk jrlg vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy vnc yl'idaacfpcrylkda hfckvhjxhke hkjlrgdvhlk hfckvhjhcf ox vnc Padhkvhjjy hk vnchr Jhryv
Dgckfcf Ilgpadhkv+ .Lpckhke Or+ dv >'8 k+9+( Hk yspplrv lj vnhy jdiv! vnc
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy ysoghvvcf d fciadrdvhlk jrlg Kcha Ydkmcx hk unhin nc
fcyirhocf c~divax nlu nc lovdhkcf vndv pcrylkda hfckvhjxhke hkjlrgdvhlk+
Gr+ Ydkmcx vcyvhjhcf vl vnc jlaaluhke hk nhy Fciadrdvhlk2
H lovdhkcf vnc yl'idaacf pcrylkda hfckvhjxhke hkjlrgdvhlkrcedrfhke Ahocrh hkiasfhke ncr jsaa Ylihda Ycisrhvx ksgocrdkf fdvc lj ohrvn jrlg ilsrv jhahkey gdfc ox Gy+ Ahocrhdy fcvdhacf ocalu+ H lovdhkcf vnc ilsrv jhahkey fhrcivaxjrlg vnc ilsrvy hk tscyvhlk! ocjlrc vnc c'gdhahkercjcrrcf vl ox vnc Padhkvhjjy+ Klkc lj vnc Ac~hyKc~hyFcjckfdkvy udy hkzlazcf hk dkx udx hk gx rcvrhczda ljvncyc psoahiax dzdhadoac flisgckvy+
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec ?4 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:60
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
22/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( 45
yj'946?>>4
.Ydkmcx Fcia+ 9+( Gr+ Ydkmcx uckv lk vl fcyirhoc hk fcvdha vnc vul flisgckvy
jrlg unhin nc lovdhkcf vnc yl'idaacf pcrylkda hfckvhjxhke hkjlrgdvhlk+ Vnc
jhryv flisgckv! dvvdincf dy C~nhohv D vl nhy fciadrdvhlk! udy d ilpx lj vnc
Fciadrdvhlk lj Ahyd Ahocrh vndv udy jhacf ox Gy+ Ahocrh lk Ycpvcgocr ?4! ?00:! hk
d irhghkda divhlk orlsenv dedhkyv Gy+ Ahocrh hk Ydk Ocrkdrfhkl! Idahjlrkhd .Idyc
JUZ 0?>000(+ Gr+ Ydkmcx klvcf vndv! ]hWk vndv fciadrdvhlk! Gy+ Ahocrh ycvy jlrvn
ncr jsaa skrcfdivcf ylihda ycisrhvx ksgocr! ncr fdvc lj ohrvn! ncr gdrrhdec nhyvlrx
.dalke uhvn gdhfck kdgcy dkf ncr nsyodkfy kdgc( dkf ylgc plrvhlk lj ncr
irhghkda nhyvlrx+ .Ydkmcx Fcia+ 6+( Gr+ Ydkmcx c~prcyyax hfckvhjhcy vnc
flisgckv dvvdincf dy C~nhohv D dy d vrsc dkf ilrrciv ilpx lj vnc jhahke gdfc ox
Gy+ Ahocrh vndv nc lovdhkcf jrlg vnc ilsrv rcilrfy+ .Hf+( Nc flcy klv hfckvhjx vnc
flisgckv dy lkc vndv nc isrrckvax gdhkvdhky hk nhy jhacy+
Vnc ycilkf flisgckv fcyirhocf ox Gr+ Ydkmcx! dvvdincf dy C~nhohv O vl nhy
fciadrdvhlk! udy d ilpx lj icrvdhk flisgckvy jhacf ox Gy+ Ahocrh hk ilkkcivhlk uhvn
d odkmrspvix divhlk jhacf lk ocndaj lj Ahyd Ahocrh hk vnc S+Y+ Odkmrspvix Ilsrv hk
vnc Ickvrda Fhyvrhiv lj Idahjlrkhd .Odkmrspvix Pcvhvhlk Kl+ :20?'om'??>63'PI(+
Gr+ Ydkmcx klvcy vndv vnhy flisgckv hkiasfcf jsaa skrcfdivcf ylihda ycisrhvxksgocry rcadvcf vl Gy+ Ahocrh .davnlsen C~nhohv O hvycaj hkiasfcy lkax rcfdivcf
ksgocry(+ .Ydkmcx Fcia+ 3+( Dedhk! nc fhf klv hfckvhjx vnc flisgckv dy lkc vndv
nc isrrckvax gdhkvdhky hk nhy jhacy+
Vncyc flisgckvy ucrc klv prlzhfcf jlr vnc vrsvn lj vnc gdvvcry dyycrvcf
vncrchk! dkf vnsy drc klv ncdrydx+ Jcf+ _+ Czhf+ >04.i(= Yvsdrvz+ SKSG Ahjc Hky+
Il+ lj Dg+! ?45 J+9f 4463! 4436 .8vn Ihr+ ?000( .yvdvcgckvy klv ljjcrcf jlr vnc
vrsvn lj vnc gdvvcry dyycrvcf ucrc klv ncdrydx(+ _dvncr! vnchrgcrc c~hyvckic
yspplrvy Gr+ Ydkmcxy vcyvhglkx vndv prlzcy uncrc vnc yl'idaacf pcrylkda
hfckvhjxhke hkjlrgdvhlk rcedrfhke Ahocrh idgc jrlg! hj klv jrlg vnc Ac~hyKc~hy
Fcjckfdkvy+
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec ?? lj 90 Pdec HF)249:64
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
23/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( 4>
yj'946?>>4
Padhkvhjjy fl klv prcyckv dkx czhfckic vndv yseecyvy vndv vncyc flisgckvy drc
klv c~divax undv Gr+ Ydkmcx ydxy vncx drc+ Hj dkx ysin czhfckic c~hyvcf! lkc
ulsaf ndzc c~pcivcf Gy+ Ahocrh vl hkiasfc hv hk ncr fciadrdvhlk+ Hk jdiv! nluczcr!
Gy+ Ahocrhy fciadrdvhlk hy yhackv lk vnc ysobciv! dkf flcy klv vrx vl yseecyv vndv ync
fhf klv dsvnlr vncyc flisgckvy hk vnc irhghkda dkf odkmrspvix divhlky! lr vrx vl
indaackec vnc dsvnckvhihvx lj ncr yhekdvsrc lk cdin flisgckv+
Padhkvhjjy ilskyca vdmcy d fhjjcrckv dpprldin+ Nc ychcy lk vnc jllvklvc hk
vnc lpckhke ysggdrx bsfegckv orhcj dkf drescy vndv vnc ncdfcr lk vlp lj cdin lj
C~nhohv D dkf C~nhohv O rcjacivy vndv Gr+ Ydkmcx fhf klv lovdhk vnc ilphcy dvvdincf
vl nhy fciadrdvhlk fhrcivax jrlg vnc ilsrv jhac! dy nc yvdvcy! osv hkyvcdf vndv
Gr+ Ydkmcx lovdhkcf ilphcy lj vncyc flisgckvy jlr vnc jhryv vhgc jrlg ilskyca jlr
Gy+ Vdhv djvcr vncx ucrc jhacf uhvn vnhy Ilsrv lk Bsax 44! ?044+ Padhkvhjjy ilskyca
drescy vndv ilskyca jlrGy+ Vdhv lovdhkcf vncyc flisgckvy jlr vnc jhryv vhgc lk
Bskc ?0! ?044+ Nc ilgcy vl vndv ilkiasyhlk ox ysoghvvhke d pdec jrlg Gy+ Ahocrhy
irhghkda ilsrv rcilrf ynluhke vndv ylgclkc pdhf d Jhkc hk vndv irhghkda divhlk
dedhkyv Gy+ Ahocrh lk Bskc ?0! ?044 jlr &44:+00 .Ocre Fcia+! C~+ 4?+( Padhkvhjjy
ilskyca vnck yvdvcy .uhvnlsv dkx dppdrckv odyhy( vndv vnhy Jhkc udy divsdaax drcprlfsivhlk indrec jrlg vnc Ydk Ocrkdrfhkl ilsrvy iacrmy ljjhic jlr vnc chenv'
pdec Ahocrh fciadrdvhlk klvcf dolzc+
Padhkvhjjy ilskyca mkluy lr ynlsaf mklu vndv vnhy dresgckv hy jdayc+ Vnc
lkax alehida dyysgpvhlk hy vndv nc hy hkvckvhlkdaax vrxhke vl ghyacdf vnc Ilsrv+
Jhryv! Padhkvhjjy ilskyca mkluy vndv ilskyca jlrGy+ Vdhv fhf klv lovdhk vnhy
flisgckv lk Bskc ?0! ?044+ Nc mkluy vnhy ocidsyc vnc Ahocrh fciadrdvhlk udy jhryv
jhacf lk Bskc 46! ?040! ox vnc Vdhv Fcjckfdkvy hk vnc prcfcicyylr divhlk vl vnhy lkc
vndv Padhkvhjjy dkf vnc Vdhv dkf Ydkmcx Fcjckfdkvy ndf occk ahvhedvhke hk vnc
Cdyvcrk Fhyvrhiv lj Pckkyxazdkhd+ .Ycc Ghaacr Fcia+! C~+ J dv 43'4:! 4>'?9+(
Yhghadrax! hv dppcdry vndv lvncr flisgckvy jrlg vnc ydgc Ahocrh odkmrspvix jhahke
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec ?9 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:6?
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
24/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( 48
yj'946?>>4
ucrc pdrv lj vnhy ydgc jhahke hk ?040! dkf vnlyc flisgckvy dayl hkiasfcf
Gy+ Ahocrhy skrcfdivcf ylihda ycisrhvx ksgocr+ .Hf+ dv 49'46+(
Padhkvhjjy ilskyca glzcf vl yvrhmc vnc Bskc 4:! ?040! jhahke dkf vl ydkivhlk
ilskyca jlr vnc Vdhv Fcjckfdkvy+ .Ycc Ghaacr Fcia+! C~+ C+( Nluczcr! hk nhy jhahke!
Padhkvhjjy ilskyca fhrcivcf vnc rcdfcr vl uncrc vnc flisgckvy ilsaf oc lovdhkcf
jrlg dk hkvcrkcv yhvc+ .Hf+ dv 4+(
Vncrc hy lvncr rcilrf czhfckic vndv ilkjhrgy Gr+ Ydkmcxy diilskv hk nhy
fciadrdvhlk dkf vndv psvy vnc ahc vl Padhkvhjjy ilskycay fhynlkcyv dresgckv+ Jlr
c~dgpac! lk Gdrin 43! ?008 .alke ocjlrc vnc Bsax 44! ?044! fdvc rcahcf lk ox Gr+
Ocre(! Gr+ Ydkmcx urlvc dk cgdha vl Gy+ Lyvcaad hk unhin nc vlaf Gy+ Lyvcaad! Hj
xls ulsaf pdyy vnhy lk vl Fr+ L! H uhaa el lsv vl Ydk Ofl vnhy uccm dkf ndzc d allm
dv vnc ?00? jhac! flkvind vnhkm! ?008! Gr+ Ydkmcx prlzhfcf dk diilskv lj uncrc nc
lovdhkcf vnc rcaczdkv hkjlrgdvhlk vndv ilkjhrgy vnc yulrk diilskv prlzhfcf hk nhy
fciadrdvhlk2
]Gy+ VdhvW dymcf gc vl jhkf lsv uncvncr! ync ndf ncdrfjrlg dklvncr ylsric! vndv Ahyd Ahocrh ndf d irhghkdarcilrf dkf vndv ncr rcda kdgc udy lvncr vndk Ahyd Ahocrh+Dkf ync dymcf gc vl allm hkvl hv+ Dkf lj ilsryc! dy yllkdy xls allm dv vnc rcilrfy hk Ydk Ocrkdrfhkl dkf Hulsaf dff vndv vncyc drc psoahi rcilrfy! vncx drc lpck!Hkvcrkcv! dkxolfx idk! dkx lkc lj xls idk el hk vncrc dkfallm dv vncyc rcilrfy pdec ox pdec+ Hv hy daa vlvdaax
psoahi! dy hy vnc odkmrspvix ilsrv dkf xls idk ycc daa ljvnhy yvsjj vncrc+ Vncrc hv hy+ Vncrc hy dk hkfc~ lkahkc! dvvnc ilsrvnlsyc! lr vnrlsen vnc ilsrvnlsyc+ Uncrc xlsidk hkfc~ ncr ox kdgc! ox idyc ksgocr unhinczcr udx
xls udkv vl fl hv+ Dkf hv uhaa vcaa xls czcrxvnhke Hzcehzck lsv+ Czcrxvnhke hy lsv vncrc
.Ycc Ghaacr Fcia+! C~+ N .cgpndyhy ysppahcf(+(
Padhkvhjjy ilskycay dresgckv uhvn rcypciv vl vnlyc c~nhohvy jrlg vnc Ydkmcx
Fciadrdvhlk hy jrhzlalsy dv ocyv dkf ghyacdfhke dv ulryv+ Padhkvhjjy ilskyca nhgycaj
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec ?6 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:69
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
25/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( ?0
yj'946?>>4
czck ackfy dffhvhlkda yspplrv vl Gr+ Ydkmcxy fcyirhpvhlk lj nlu nc lovdhkcf vncyc
gdvcrhday hk ?008 unck nc fcyirhocy hk ercdv fcvdha vndv vncyc flisgckvy drc klv
isrrckvax dzdhadoac lzcr vnc hkvcrkcv+ .Ycc Ocre Fcia+ 60'64+( Lkax Gr+
Ydkmcxy fcyirhpvhlk lj nlu nc lovdhkcf vncyc gdvcrhday! dkf unck nc lovdhkcf
vncyc gdvcrhday! gdmcy dkx yckyc+
Padhkvhjjy glvhlk vl c~iasfc vncyc flisgckvy lr Gr+ Ydkmcxy fcyirhpvhlk lj
vncg hk nhy fciadrdvhlk ynlsaf oc rcbcivcf+
O+ Vnc Lobcivhlky vl vnc Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlk dkf C~nhohvy DrcGcrhvacyy+
Padhkvhjjy aczca cyyckvhdaax vnrcc lobcivhlky vl vnc Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlk dkf
vnc C~nhohvy vncrcvl+ Vncx dresc vndv vnc C~nhohvy dkf plrvhlky lj vnc Fciadrdvhlk
dkf ndzc klv occk dsvnckvhidvcf! drc ncdrydx! dkf drc hrrcaczdkv+ Cdin lj vncyc
lobcivhlky hy gcrhvacyy+
4+ Vnc Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlk dkf C~nhohvy Ndzc OcckDsvnckvhidvcf+
Padhkvhjjy dresc vndv vnc Ilsrv ynlsaf klv ilkyhfcr vnc fciadrdvhlky dkf
flisgckvy ocidsyc vncx ndzc klv occk dsvnckvhidvcf dkf vncrcjlrc drc klv
dfghyyhoac+ Vnhy hy klkyckyc+
Dv vnc ysggdrx bsfegckv yvdec! czhfckic kccf klv oc prcyckvcf hk
dfghyyhoac jlrg+ Hkyvcdf! vnc rctshrcgckv hy lkax vndv vnc pdrvx ysoghvvhke vnc
czhfckic ynlu vndv hv uhaa oc plyyhoac vl psv vnc hkjlrgdvhlk! vnc ysoyvdkic lr
ilkvckv lj vnc czhfckic! hkvl dk dfghyyhoac jlrg+ 44'3: Gllrcy Jcfcrda Prdivhic
Ihzha 3:+84=Jrdycrz+ Ellfdac! 96? J+9f 409?! 409: .8vn Ihr+ ?009( .]dWv vnc
ysggdrx bsfegckv yvdec! uc fl klv jlisy lk vnc dfghyyhohahvx lj vnc czhfckicy
jlrg+ Uc hkyvcdf jlisy lk vnc dfghyyhohahvx lj hvy ilkvckvy+(=Oalim z+ Ihvx lj A+D+!
?39 J+9f 640! 64>'48 .8vn Ihr+ ?004( .]vWl ysrzhzc ysggdrx bsfegckv! d pdrvx
flcy klv kcicyydrhax ndzc vl prlfsic czhfckic hk d jlrg vndv ulsaf oc dfghyyhoac dv
vrhda! dy alke dy vnc pdrvx ydvhyjhcy vnc rctshrcgckvy lj Jcfcrda _sacy lj Ihzha
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec ?3 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:66
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
26/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( ?4
yj'946?>>4
Prlicfsrc 3:+(=Nsency z+ Skhvcf Yvdvcy! 839 J+?f 394! 369 .8vn Ihr+ 488?(
.ahvhedvhlk dfzhycry djjhfdzhv gdx oc ilkyhfcrcf lk ysggdrx bsfegckv fcyphvc
ncdrydx dkf ocyv czhfckic rsac lobcivhlky= vnc jdivy skfcraxhke vnc djjhfdzhv drc lj
vnc vxpc vndv ulsaf oc dfghyyhoac dy czhfckic czck vnlsen vnc djjhfdzhv hvycaj ghenv
klv oc dfghyyhoac(+
Ncrc! vncrc idk oc kl flsov vndv hv ulsaf oc plyyhoac vl ljjcr vnc Yhgglky
Fciadrdvhlk dkf C~nhohvy hk dk dfghyyhoac jlrg+ Dy ynluk ocalu! vnc Yhgglky
Fciadrdvhlk darcdfx prlzhfcy hkjlrgdvhlk ysjjhihckv vl dsvnckvhidvc hvy luk ilkvckvy
dkf hvy C~nhohvy+ Czck hj hv fhf klv! nluczcr! olvn Yhgglky dkf Plahidyvrl ndzc
gdfc iacdr vndv vncx ilsaf dkf ulsaf vcyvhjx ilgpcvckvax vl vncyc jdivy hj idaacf
dy d uhvkcyy dv vrhda+ .Yhgglky Fcia+ 4= Plahidyvrl Fcia+ 4+( Diilrfhkeax! vnc
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy ilsaf ilrrciv dkx daacecf fcjhihckihcy ox idaahke Yhgglky
lr dklvncr pcrylk dy d uhvkcyy dv vrhda vl ljjcr dffhvhlkda vcyvhglkhda czhfckic vl
dsvnckvhidvc vnc Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlk dkf C~nhohvy+
Jlr c~dgpac! vnc Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlk hy darcdfx ysjjhihckv vl dsvnckvhidvc
hvy luk ilkvckvy dkf vnc dvvdincf C~nhohvy+ Czhfckic gdx oc dsvnckvhidvcf ox
vcyvhglkx lj d uhvkcyy uhvn pcrylkda mkluacfec+ Jcfcrda _sac lj Czhfckic804.o(.4(= 3'804 Uchkyvchky Jcfcrda Czhfckic 804+09+ Dy dk cgpalxcc unl hy
hkvhgdvcax jdghahdr uhvn vnc Ac~hyKc~hy osyhkcyy prdivhicy dkf rcilrfy!
Gy+ Yhgglky hy tsdahjhcf vl dvvcyv vl vnc c~hyvckic lj vncyc osyhkcyy rcilrfy+ Ncrc!
dy fhyisyycf dolzc! vnc Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlk yvdvcy vndv Yhgglky ndy pcrylkda
mkluacfec lj vnc jdivy yvdvcf ocalu+ .Yhgglky Fcia+ 4+( Yhgglky jsrvncr
c~padhky vnc odyhy jlr pcrylkda mkluacfec ox dzcrrhke vndv ync ndy occk cgpalxcf
ox Ac~hyKc~hy Fdvd Gdkdecgckv Hki+! d ilgpdkx jlrgcrax mkluk dy Ychyhkv Hki+
.AK_FGH( jlr vnhrvcck xcdry! jhryv dy Diisrhkv Prlfsiv Gdkdecr dkf vnck dy
Zhic Prcyhfckv lj Prlfsiv Fczcalpgckv+ .Hf+( Ync ehzcy odimerlskf hkjlrgdvhlk
lk AK_FGH! vnc Diisrhkv prlfsiv ahkc! dkf AK_FGHy derccgckvy uhvn icrvdhk
vnhrf'pdrvx hkjlrgdvhlk prlzhfcry .rcycaacry( skfcr unhin rcycaacry ilsaf rsk
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec ?: lj 90 Pdec HF)249:63
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
27/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( ??
yj'946?>>4
ycdrincy hk Diisrhkv fdvdodycy+ .Hf+( Vnhy hkjlrgdvhlk hy ysjjhihckv vl adx d
jlskfdvhlk! ox gcdky lj pcrylkda mkluacfec! dy vl vnc ilkvcyvcf plrvhlky lj ncr
fciadrdvhlk+ Jsrvncr! vnhy hkjlrgdvhlk hy ysjjhihckv vl dsvnckvhidvc cdin lj vnc vnrcc
C~nhohvy dvvdincf vl vnc Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlk+ Dy dk cgpalxcc lj AK_FGH unl
hy hkvhgdvcax jdghahdr uhvn hvy prdivhicy dkf rcilrfy dkf uhvn vnc Diisrhkv prlfsiv
ahkc ypcihjhidaax! Yhgglky hy tsdahjhcf vl dsvnckvhidvc ilkvrdivy AK_FGH ckvcrcf
hkvl uhvn rcycaacry dkf lvncry! dy ucaa dy rcycaacr ilkvrdivy vndv rcadvc fhrcivax vl vnc
Diisrhkv prlfsiv ahkc+
?+ Vnc Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlk dkf C~nhohvy Drc Klv Ncdrydx+
Ycilkf! Padhkvhjjy dyycrv vndv vnc C~nhohvy vl vnc Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlk dkf
plrvhlky lj vnc Fciadrdvhlk hvycaj ynlsaf klv oc ilkyhfcrcf ocidsyc vncx drc ncdrydx
Vnhy lobcivhlk hy dayl gcrhvacyy+
Dy fhyisyycf dolzc! lk d glvhlk jlr ysggdrx bsfegckv! d pdrvx kccf lkax
ynlu vndv hv uhaa oc plyyhoac vl psv vnc hkjlrgdvhlk! vnc ysoyvdkic lr ilkvckv lj vnc
czhfckic! hkvl dk dfghyyhoac jlrg+ Ncrc! vnc indaackecf ilkvckvy lj vnc Yhgglky
Fciadrdvhlk ilsaf cdyhax oc ljjcrcf hk dfghyyhoac jlrg ocidsyc Yhgglky hy
dzdhadoac vl vcyvhjx dv vrhda+ .Yhgglky Fcia+ 4+(Klr fl ncdrydx ilkicrky prciasfc vnhy Ilsrv jrlg ilkyhfcrhke vnc C~nhohvy vl
vnc Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlk+ Dy vnc Khkvn Ihrishv ndy gdfc iacdr! lsv'lj'ilsrv
yvdvcgckvy vndv drc ljjcrcf dy czhfckic lj acedaax lpcrdvhzc zcroda ilkfsiv drc klv
ncdrydx+ Vncx drc ilkyhfcrcf zcroda divy+ Skhvcf Yvdvcy z+ Pdke! 9:? J+9f 44>5!
448? .8vn Ihr+ ?006(+ Ncrc! daa vnrcc c~nhohvy drc ilkvrdivy ljjcrcf klv jlr vnc vrsvn
lj vnc gdvvcry dyycrvcf vncrchk! osv rdvncr dy czhfckic lj zcroda divy! ynluhke vndv
vnc pdrvhcy vl vnlyc ilkvrdivy ckvcrcf hkvl acedaax lpcrdvhzc derccgckvy uhvn vcrgy
rcaczdkv vl Padhkvhjjy iadhgy ncrc+ Yvsdrvz+ SKSG Ahjc Hky+ Il+ lj Dg+! ?45 J+9f
4463! 4436 .8vn Ihr+ ?000( .jhkfhke vndv d urhvvck ilkvrdiv ilkyvhvsvcy d zcroda div
vndv hy c~iasfcf jrlg vnc fcjhkhvhlk ljncdrydx dkf hy dfghyyhoac czhfckic ocidsyc
hv hy d acedaax lpcrdvhzc flisgckv vndv fcjhkcy vnc rhenvy dkf ahdohahvhcy lj vnc
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec ?5 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:6:
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
28/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( ?9
yj'946?>>4
pdrvhcy(+9 Jsrvncr! czck hj vnc vnrcc C~nhohvy ucrc klv zcroda divy! vncx ulsaf
oc dfghyyhoac dy c~icpvhlky vl vnc rsac dedhkyv ncdrydx ocidsyc vncx drc osyhkcyy
rcilrfy skfcr Jcfcrda _sac lj Czhfckic >09.:(+ Ycc Skhvcf Yvdvcy z+ Inhafy! 3 J+9f
49?>! 499?'99 .8vn Ihr+ 4889( .djjhrghke dfghyyhlk lj dk dppahidvhlk jlr d ahickyc
padvc gdhkvdhkcf ox FGZ! dkf nlafhke vndv c~nhohvy idk oc dfghvvcf dy osyhkcyy
rcilrfy lj dk ckvhvx! czck unck vndv ckvhvx udy klv vnc gdmcr lj vnlyc rcilrfy! yl
alke dy vnc lvncr rctshrcgckvy lj _sac >09.:( drc gcv dkf vnc ihrisgyvdkicy
hkfhidvc vnc rcilrfy drc vrsyvulrvnx(+
9+ Vnc Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlk hy klv hrrcaczdkv+
Jhkdaax! Padhkvhjjy dresc vndv plrvhlky lj vnc Yhgglky Fciadrdvhlk drc
hrrcaczdkv vl vnc Padhkvhjjy iadhgy dkf vncrcjlrc hkdfghyyhoac skfcrJcfcrda _sac
lj Czhfckic 60?+ Vnc plrvhlky lj vnc Fciadrdvhlk hk tscyvhlk fcyirhoc AK_FGHy
prdivhic vl gdmc iacdr vndv Diisrhkv rcplrvy ucrc klv ilkysgcr rcplrvy uhvnhk vnc
gcdkhke lj vnc Jdhr Ircfhv _cplrvhke Div .JI_D(+ .Yhgglky Fcia+ 44! 4?!
49+( Ysin hkjlrgdvhlk hy rcaczdkv dy hv prlzhfcy odimerlskf lk vnc yvrsivsrc lj vnc
Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy! unhin hy kcicyydrx vl ilkvrdfhiv Padhkvhjjy daacedvhlky vndv
vnc Diisrhkv ycdrincy lr rcplrvy drc ilkysgcr rcplrvy uhvnhk vnc gcdkhke lj vncJI_D ocidsyc lvncr Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy ycaa rcplrvy vndv divsdaax drc
ilkysgcr rcplrvy+ Padhkvhjjy fl klv ilkvrdfhiv vnhy dyycrvhlk! klr idk vncx+
I+ Vnc Lobcivhlky vl vnc Plahidyvrl Fciadrdvhlk Drc Gcrhvacyy+
Padhkvhjjy lobciv vl pdrderdpn 9 lj vnc Plahidyvrl Fciadrdvhlk! hk unhin
Plahidyvrl c~padhky vndv AK_FGHy rcilrfy ilkvdhk hkjlrgdvhlk daaluhke ncr vl
fcvcrghkc unhin ycdrincy dkf rcplrvy ucrc psrindycf ox Vnc Ydkmcx Jhrg!
hkiasfhke ycdrincy vndv ucrc hkhvhdvcf vnrlsen rcycaacry+ Padhkvhjjy dyycrv vndv vnhy
9 Vnc jdiv vndv C~nhohv O hy dk skyhekcf ilkvrdiv hy hrrcaczdkv+ Hv yvhaailkyvhvsvcy d zcroda div! ljjcrcf klv jlr vnc vrsvn lj vnc gdvvcry dyycrvcf vncrchk!osv rdvncr vl ynlu AK_FGHy acedaax lpcrdvhzc ilkfsiv hk prlplyhke vnc ilkvrdivvcrgy+
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec ?> lj 90 Pdec HF)249:65
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
29/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
AK FCJY+ LPPK VL PAY+ _CT+ VL YV_HMCIDYCKL+ IZ44'006>3 DE .DBU~( ?6
yj'946?>>4
pdrderdpn hy ghyacdfhke dkf ilkjsyhke dkf vncrcjlrc idsycy skjdhr prcbsfhic+
Padhkvhjjy jdha vl c~padhk c~divax nlu vnhy pdrderdpn hy ghyacdfhke lr ilkjsyhke!
davnlsen vncx yccg vl yseecyv vndv hv ilkjahivy uhvn pdrderdpn 3 lj vnc Plahidyvrl
Fciadrdvhlk! hk unhin Plahidyvrl c~padhky vndv AK_FGH fhf klv rcvdhk rcilrfy lj
unhin hvcgy lj fdvd ucrc rcvsrkcf hk rcyplkyc vl d ycdrin irhvcrhd! lkax vnc irhvcrhd
sycf jlr vnc ycdrin lr rcplrv+ Pdrderdpny 9 dkf 3! nluczcr! drc klv hk ilkjahiv dkf
fl klv ircdvc ilkjsyhlk lr skjdhr prcbsfhic+ Pdrderdpn 9 lj vnc Plahidyvrl
Fciadrdvhlk yhgpax gdmcy iacdr vndv AK_FGHy rcilrfy ilkvdhk hkjlrgdvhlk lk vnc
ycdrincy rsk ox Ydkmcx dkf lvncr isyvlgcry lj rcycaacry! dkf hkfhidvc unhin vxpc lr
vxpcy lj rcplrvy ucrc psrindycf! osv fl klv ilkvdhk vnc ilkvckvy lj dkx psrindycf
rcplrvy+ Jlr c~dgpac! vl psv hv hk vcrgy glrc jdghahdr vl aduxcry! hj d pdrvhisadr
aduxcr rdk d Ac~hyKc~hy ycdrin jlr vnc vcrg ysggdrx bsfegckv! vnc rcilrfy
ulsaf rcjaciv vndv jdiv! osv ulsaf klv hkiasfc d fspahidvc ilpx lj daa lj vnc idycy
rcvsrkcf dy vnc ycdrin rcysav+ Hk lvncr ulrfy! AK_FGHy rcilrfy ilkvdhk vnc
tscyvhlky dymcf ox Ydkmcx dkf lvncry! osv klv vnc dkyucry vl vnlyc tscyvhlky+
Vncrc hy klvnhke ilkjsyhke lr ghyacdfhke dolsv vnhy fcyirhpvhlk dkf kl rcdylk vl
c~iasfc hv dy prcbsfhihda skfcr Jcfcrda _sac lj Czhfckic 609+ILKIASYHLK
Jlr cdin lj vnc rcdylky ycv jlrvn dolzc! vnc Ac~hyKc~hy Fcjckfdkvy
rcypcivjsaax rctscyv vndv vnc Ilsrv fckx Padhkvhjjy _ctscyv vl Yvrhmc+
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec ?8 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:6>
7/31/2019 Reeds Opp to Plaintiffs Motion to Strike Doc 518
30/30
4
?
9
6
3
:
5
>
8
40
44
4?
49
46
43
4:
454>
48
?0
?4
??
?9
?6
?3
?:
?5
?>
Fdvcf2 Gdx 5! ?04?BDGCY J+ GiIDOCGL__HYLK * JLC_YVC_AAP
Ox2 ,y Bdgcy J+ GiIdoc
Bdgcy J+ GiIdoc
Dvvlrkcxy jlr _ccf Cayczhcr Hki+!Ac~hyKc~hy _hym dkf HkjlrgdvhlkDkdaxvhiy Erlsp Hki+! Ac~hyKc~hy!Hki+! Ac~hyKc~hy _hym Ylasvhlky! Hki+!Ac~hyKc~hy InlhicPlhkv! Hki+!Ac~hyKc~hy Ychyhkv! Hki+! f,o,dDiisrhkv! dkf Ac~hyKc~hy Erlsp Hki+
Idyc >244'iz'006>3'DE'DBU Flisgckv 34> Jhacf 03,05,4? Pdec 90 lj 90 Pdec HF)249:68
Top Related