8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
1/39
Free Will and Determinism
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
2/39
Destiny and Fate
Do you believe indestiny?
What are you destinedfor?
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
3/39
Matrix
Morpheus:
Do you believe in fate,Neo?
Neo:
No. ... I dont like theidea that Im not in
control of my life.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
4/39
Minority Report
Do you have a choice?
Are you bound by fate?
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
5/39
Fatalists
The Greek Fatalistsbelieved that life was atragedy and werehelpless victims of
circumstance.
Necessity and fatecontrols our destinies.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
6/39
Moral Responsibility
You are accountablefor your actions.
You can be praised forgood actions andpunished for badactions.
If there is no freedom,there can be no moralaccountability.
See Kant and Boethius
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
7/39
Differing View Points
Hard Determinists
Everything is determined.
Libertarians Nothing is determined; we are free.
Soft Determinists
Some things are determined, but not reason.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
8/39
Hard Determinism
Hard Determinists
Everything isdetermined.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
9/39
Baruch Spinoza (1632-1677)
In the mind there isno absolute or freewill; but the mind isdetermined to wish
this or that by acause, which has alsobeen determined byanother cause, andthis last by anothercause, and so on toinfinity.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
10/39
John Hospers
There are internal forcesand external forceswhich give us theimpression that we areacting with free will.
Action: I read Pride andPrejudice. External Force - I
have an exam on Prideand Prejudice.
Internal Force - I sawPride and Prejudice onTV.
Its all a matter of luck.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
11/39
Clarence Darrow (1857-1938)
Darrows defence oftwo men on trial formurder reduced theirsentence from death
to life.
Punishment aspunishment is not
admissible unless theoffender has the freewill to select hiscourse.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
12/39
Clarrence Darrow (1857-1938)
What has this boy todo with it? He was nothis own father; he wasnot his own mother;he was not his own
grandparents. All ofthis was handed tohim. He did notsurround himself withgovernesses andwealth. He did not
make himself. And yethe is to be compelledto pay.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
13/39
John B. Watson (1978-1958)
Watson suggested thatbehaviour can bepredicted and controlled. Psychological
Behaviourism.
If the universe isdetermined, allactions, ethical andotherwise, arecontrolled by priorcauses which are inprinciple knowable.
Nature and Nurture.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
14/39
Ivan Pavlov (1849-1936)
Conductedexperiments with dogsand bells.
Simple behaviourcan be controlled byconditioning.
Sophisticated
behaviour iscontrolled bysophisticatedconditioning.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
15/39
B. F. Skinner (1904-1990)
Worked on operantconditioning.
This looked at
behaviour in terms ofpsychologicalresponses toexternal stimuli.
The conclusionsshowed that ouractions areconditioned and thatwe do not actuallyhave freedom.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
16/39
Isaac Newton
Determinism is based inthe Newtonianparadigm that theuniverse is governed byimmutable laws of
nature. Like a watch!
If the universe is notmechanical, then theprinciples of cause andeffect areindeterminable. This does not
necessarily implyfreedom.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
17/39
John Locke (1632-1704)
A man wakes up in alocked room. Hedecides to stay wherehe is, not realising
that the door to theroom is locked. Theman thinks that hehas made a freedecision, but in realityhe has no choice.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
18/39
John Locke (1632-1704)
The causes of ouractions are so complexthat it appears thatwe have freedom.
In reality there is nofreedom.
Its like the weather
system; it appearsrandom but it is inreality complex anddeterminable.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
19/39
Paul-Henri Thiry (Baron) dHolbach
You say that I feel free.This is an illusion, whichmay be compared tothat of the fly in thefable, who, upon the
pole of a heavy carriage,applauded himself fordirecting its course. Man,who thinks himself free,is a fly who imagines hehas the power to movethe universe, while ishimself unknowinglycarried along by it.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
20/39
Ted Honderich (1933-)
If everything isdetermined, then theEmpiricist conclusions isaccurate: There is no self which
is the origin of youractions.
The mind is a by-product of brainactivity cause by psych-neural events.
There is no moral
responsibility. There is no Freedom.
There is nosoul/afterlife.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
21/39
Libertarianism
Libertarians
Nothing isdetermined; we arefree.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
22/39
In response to Darrow
Blaming externalforces for our actionsis regret.
We may not makeourselves but we domake our actions.
Human decisions andchoices cannot beproven to all becaused.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
23/39
Peter Van Inwagen
Life is a journey:
Determinists claim that thereare no branches on the road.There is only one set path foreach person.
Libertarians claim that thereare and we make choices.
It may seem as though wehad not choices, we madedecisions which brought ushere.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
24/39
Werner Heisenberg
The Heisenberguncertainty principle.
We cannot know both thelocation and momentum ofsubatomic particles at thesame time.
We should appeal toprobabilities rather thanformulate general laws ofcertainty.
The universe is in factunpredictable andindeterminable.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
25/39
Honderichs criticism
Heisenbergs principleapplies only tosubatomic particlesand cannot refute
Newtons mechanics.
Quantum Mechanicsqualifies Newtons
view and puts histheories into a broadercontext.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
26/39
The Quantum contradiction
Even if it were thecase that the universewas indeterminable,the opposite of
determinism would berandomness.
If the universe israndom, that does not
prove that we havefree will, only that ouractions cannot bedetermined at all.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
27/39
Jean-Paul Sartre (1905-1980)
Freedom is the goal andmeasure of our lives.
From nothing, man makeshimself what he chooses.
It does not matter what aman does with his freedom,so long as he acts freely freedom is an end in itself.
To do otherwise is toconform to the will of others;this is to be guilty ofmauvaise foi.
To be free is to becondemned to be free.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
28/39
Soft Determinism
Soft Determinists
Some things aredetermined, but notreason.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
29/39
Steven Pinker
Emotions have abiological (andevolutionary) basis.
Man might bepredisposed toviolence, but reasoncontrols thatpredisposition.
A moral sense is innatein us and as real for usas if it were decreed bythe Almighty or writteninto the cosmos.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
30/39
Immanuel Kant
Determinism appliesto everything which isthe object ofknowledge, but not
to acts of the will.
There are two types ofreason:
Pure (theoretical)Reason
Practical Reason
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
31/39
Kants Pure Reason
This is how weperceive the world andhow we explain itscientifically.
Pure reason observesthe determineduniverse and so must
accept determinismto some degree.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
32/39
Kants Practical Reason
Practical reason concernsactions, the will and the waywe see ourselves.
Freedom is a postulate of
practical reason.
Our own self-awareness,without which the worldwould not make sense to us,forces on us the idea that
we are free.
We cannot abolish freedomwithout ceasing to seeourselves as the originatorof our actions.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
33/39
Not a compromise
Compatibilitism is aposition taken due tothe need to havesome accountability
and responsibility forhuman behaviour.
It is, as Kant puts it, a
postulate of PracticalReason. We are self-aware thinking beings,we require freedom.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
34/39
Voltaire, DictionairePhilosophique
Pear trees cannot bearbananas. The instincts of aspaniel cannot be theinstincts of an ostrich.
Everything is planned,connected, limited.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
35/39
Thomas Nagel,What does it all mean?
The sum total of apersons experiences,desires and knowledge,his hereditary constitution,
the social circumstancesand the nature of thechoice facing him,together with other factorsthat we may not knowabout, all combine tomake a particular action inthe circumstancesinevitable.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
36/39
Predestination
The Christian idea thatsalvation anddamnation arepredetermined by God.
This is not scripturaldogma, it is based oninterpretation ofrevelation.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
37/39
Augustine of Hippo
It is not by our ownmerit that we achievesalvation but throughthe grace of Godwhich is freely given.
Note Godsintervention in theministries of Mosesand St Paul.
This was contradictedby Pelagius and hewas branded a heretic.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
38/39
John Calvin (16thCentury)
Mans nature isultimately sinful.
It is only by Gods
intervention predetermined thatwe can gain salvation.
It is God who
permits goodnessand badness; thuswe cannot bepunished or rewarded.
8/13/2019 PP Free Will and Determinism
39/39
John Calvin (16thCentury)
Eternal life is fore-ordained for some,and eternal damnationfor others. Every man,
therefore, beingcreated for one of theother of these ends,we say, he ispredestined to life ordeath.
- Institutes of theChristian Religion Bk3
Ch21 s5
Top Related