11
LAWYERS
Economic Sanctions against Russia
Tim Hesselink, Partner/Attorney-at-Law
22
2007 Outlook
Source: ABN AMRO, Economics Department/Sector Research, September 2007
“International business and foreign investors are striving to increase their market share, strengthen their financial position, broaden their product range, ensure stability and find the best talent. Russia provides a solid basis for this. It may not happen overnight, but surely in the somewhat longer term.”
33
2019 Outlook
Source: ABN AMRO, Group Economics, Emerging Markets Research, 13 February 2019
“However, we do expect new rounds of businesses and individuals being targeted under the US sanction regime. This ‘known unknown’ of new sanction rounds is continuing to have an impact on markets as foreign investors and businesses are extremely cautious about doing business with their Russian counterparts.”
44
1. EU restrictive measuresagainst Russia
2. U.S. Sanctions Regimes
3. Business cases
4. Key Takeaways
Agenda
55
EU RESTRICTIVE MEASURES
66
Council Regulation (EU) No. 883/2014 concerning restrictive
measures in view of Russia’s actions destabilizing the situation in
Ukraine. The restrictive measures currently in place focus on:
Arms export and import;
Dual-use goods export if military end-users or military end-use;
Financial measures;
Prohibition to satisfy claims;
Export of certain goods, technology and services related to oil
exploration and production.
EU restrictive measures
against Russia
77
• License obligation for certain goods (Annex II) suited to the
following categories :
① Oil exploration and production in waters deeper than 150 metres;
② Oil exploration and production in the offshore area north of theArctic Circle; or
③ Projects that have the potential to produce oil from resourceslocated in shale formations by way of hydraulic fracturing; it does notapply to exploration and production through shale formations tolocate or extract oil from non-shale reservoirs.
• Prohibition to provide associated services (drilling, well testing,
logging and completion services and supply of specialized
floating vessels) related to the above mentioned categories.
• License obligation for technical assistance and brokering
services related to the above mentioned technologies.
Restrictive measures
related to the oil-industry
88
As part of the EU’s non-recognition policy of the illegal annexation of
Crimea and Sevastopol, the EU has imposed substantial restrictions
on economic exchanges with the territory. The restrictions are
included in Council Regulation (EU) No 692/2014:
• Prohibition to import goods originating in Crimea or Sevastopol.
• Prohibition to invest in Crimea.
• Prohibition on the export to Crimean companies or for use in
Crimea of goods and technology for the transport,
telecommunications and energy sectors or the exploration of
oil, gas and mineral resources.
• Prohibition to provide technical assistance, brokering,
construction or engineering services related to infrastructure.
• Prohibition to provide services directly related to tourism
activities in Crimea or Sevastopol.
Sanctions for Crimea and
Sevastopol
99
U.S. SANCTIONS REGIMES
1010
• March 2014OFAC began the Ukraine/Russia-related sanctions program.
• April 2018OFAC placed seven prominent Russian businessmen, 12 companies, 17 senior Russian government officials, and a state-owned Russian weapons trading company and its subsidiary Russian bank on the SDN List (CAATSA 2017).
• August 2018
US State Department issued targeted sanctions against Russia in relation to the Chemical and Biological Weapons Control and Warfare Elimination Act of 1991 (CBW Act).
• September 2018
New Executive Order imposing sanctions in the event of foreigninterference in a US election.
• August 2019
Another round of sanctions against Russia in relation to the CBW Act.
U.S. Sanctions Regime
Developments in 2018/19 on sanctions against Russia
1111
• Directive 4 under executive order 13662 prohibits:– the provision, exportation, or re-exportation, directly or indirectly, of
goods, services (except for financial services), or technology;
– in support of exploration or production for deepwater, Arctic offshore, or shale projects;
– that have the potential to produce oil in the Russian Federation, or in maritime area claimed by the Russian Federation and extending from its territory;
– that involve any person identified on the SSI List under Directive 4, including that person’s property, or its interests in property.
• Similar to the EU, but more Russian companies are targeted.
• Due to amendments in 2017, Directive 4 can also apply in projects beyond Russia.
• Extraterritorial reach of the US Sanctions and Export Controls regime.
U.S. Sanctions Regime
Ukraine/Russia-related sanctions program – E.O. 13662
1212
In 2017, the US adopted the “Countering America’s Adversaries
Through Sanctions Act” (CAATSA) which imposes (amongst
others) sanctions on Russia:
• Countering Russian Influence in Europe and Eurasia Act of
2017.
Little additional impact for the energy sector:
• Directive 4 was amended in such a way that now also projects
beyond the borders of Russia can be prohibited.
• Tightening of restrictions on the financing of, or transactions in,
debt issued by particular entities in the Russian financial
services and energy sectors.
U.S. Sanctions Regime - CAATSA
Countering America’s Adversaries Through Sanctions Act (CAATSA)
1313
BUSINESS CASES
1414
WHAT-WHO-WHERE-WHY
Item Characteristics
End Use/ End User
Destination
1515
• Dutch company specialised in technical
knowledge for oil and gas well design and
construction
• Tender Russian oil company for oil and gas well
design & construction services for USD 2m
• EU sanctions legislation against Russia -
prohibitions or restrictions?
• Prohibition investment services
• Export authorisation for technical assistance for
Annex II goods
• Specific end-use declaration criteria by Dutch
Ministry of Foreign Affairs (no deep water oil or
Arctic oil exploration and production, or shale oil
projects)
• Russian oil company withdraws tender
Business case I – Well
Design & Construction
1616
• EU supplier of offshore supply services
• Providing a seismic supply vessel to ensure
geophysical surveys for oil exploration
conducted by a Russian entity in the Barents
Sea
• EU sanctions legislation against Russia -
prohibitions or restrictions?
• No sanctions parties involved
• Prohibited associated services for oil exploration and
production in waters deeper than 150 meters
• Seismic supply vessels are allowed
• Contracts have been signed
Business case II –
Offshore support vessels
1717
• EU supplier of conformity assessment
services
• Considers to perform conformity assessment
services related to dual-use goods of
Category 0
• EU sanctions legislation against Russia -
prohibitions or restrictions?
• No sanctioned parties involved
• Conformity assessment services can be considered
technical assistance
• Technical assistance related to dual-use items is
prohibited if provided to sanctioned entities or if
intended for military end-use or a military end-user
• Not prohibited under EU sanctions regime
Business case III – Conformity
assessment services
1818
• EU supplier of heavy lifting equipment
• Considers to sell equipment to a Russian
shipbuilding yard
• EU sanctions legislation against Russia -
prohibitions or restrictions?
• No sanctioned parties involved
• Due to sanctions risks, company wishes to apply for
a request for classification
• Company wishes to conclude the contract only on
the condition of approval of the request for
classification
• Company includes a suspensive condition of
approval in the contract
Business case IV – Contracts
1919
KEY TAKEAWAYS
2020
Key Takeaways
• Determine which laws and regulations apply to the company
• Look out for red flags
• Use a risk-based assessment to determine possibleirregularities
• Carry out due diligence togain control over business risks
• If possible use sanctionsclauses for contracting
• Use export control assistance fromgovernmental authorities
2121
Questions?
2222
LAWYERS
THANK YOU
2323
Kneppelhout & Korthals Lawyers
Postbus 546
3000 AM Rotterdam
Gebouw Willemswerf
Boompjes 40
3011 XB Rotterdam
Telefoon 010 - 400 5100
Top Related