8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
1/20
Barbara Pocock
Brotherhood of St Lawrence Conference, Tuesday 11th October 2005University of Melbourne
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
2/20
The Howard Industrial Plan:
A 20 year old vision, unfit for a21st Century working family:Anti-family and unfair
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
3/20
The measures: a weaker safety netm inim um pay rate and classifications4 weeks Annual leave10 days Personal/carer s leave
12m onths Parental leave38 ordinary hours, annual average
AWAs override agree m ents and awards
The Case of Billy/Bettina
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
4/20
The measures: Tilts bargainingy Fair pay Co mm issiony weak unfair dis m issal protectionsy More anti-collective than US lawy AIRC neutered
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
5/20
AIRC and work/familyy Maternity leave (1979)y Adoption leave (1984)y Parental leave (1990)y Carers leave (1994/95)y Right to refuse unreasonable overti m e (2001)y Right to request part-ti m e em ploy m ent (2005)
All opposed by coalition and e m ployersHow will any new advances be m ade?
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
6/20
O verall Impacty Low paid workers will be lower paidy $44 lower if govern m ent had had its way since 1996 AWAs
on take it or leave it basis for new e m ployees or onprom otion etc
y
Collective agreem
ents and awards irrelevant overtim ey Union access to workers m ore li m ited and difficult
y (eg 24 hours written notice and reason, only once every 6 m onths forrecruit m ent, no entry if covered by AWAs, individual worker whoseeks help fro m union will be identified to boss, no chance to checknon- m em bers paid correctly, co m plex ballots for industrial action)
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
7/20
Impacty Widening wages dispersiony Sam e workers, different ratesy Tougher for the weaker
y young peopley people returning to worky casualsy working carersy imm igrants
y
Profit not productivity y Even good bosses are forced to co m pete on cutprice wages and conditions
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
8/20
Impact on workers and families?y Shift to AWAs, and stripped back awards will increase:
y hours of worky unsocial working ti m ey wage inequality y the working poor
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
9/20
The evidence: AWAs and payy Pay levels and pay rises are lower for workers on
AWAs (Peetz 2005)y Even though workers on AWAs, work longer
hoursy And have less access to penalty rates for
unsocial hours and overti m ey
AWAs m uch m ore likely to reduce or abolishpay for working overti m e, nights or weekends
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
10/20
AWAs and payy wom en on AWAs paid 11% less than wo m en on
collective agree m ents in May 2004y Casuals on AWAs lower by 15%,y Perm anent part-ti m ers by 25%.y These are all groups with disproportionate
responsibilities for fa m ilies
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
11/20
AWAs: less family friendlyy In 2001 12% of all AWAs had any work/fa m ily m easures
y 2004 DEWR report:y only 8% of AWAs had paid m aternity leave (10%
collective agree m ents)y 5% had paid paternity leave (7%)y 4% unpaid purchased leave
y
Those who need itm
ost, get it least:y 14%m ore m en than wo m en on AWAs had any fa m ily leave in their AWA
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
12/20
Time: A critical work and familyissue
QuickTime and aTIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor
are needed to see this picture.
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
13/20
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
14/20
U nsocial time and familiesy 64% of Australian e m ployees already work either
som etim es or regularly outside standard ti m esy Consistent body of international evidence finds that
unsocial work tim
e affects social and fam
ily tim
e(Strazdins et al, 2004)y Evening and night work is especially stressful for
parents, increasing depression, affecting sleep andreducing parental responsiveness to children
y Positive associations between shift work and m aritaldiscord and divorce
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
15/20
N ight work and familyy N ight work co m bined with parenting is m ost har m ful
for m arital stability (Presser 2000; US study)y N ight working parents have two to six ti m es the risk of divorce co m pared to those working standard dayti m e
hoursy Trans m ission effects to children
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
16/20
U nsocial hours and carey All kinds of unsocial routines (weekend,
afternoon, evening and night) can disrupt fa m ilies
and reduce parent-child tim
ey Such parents spend less ti m e reading, playing andhelping children and are less satisfied with thetim e available with children
y Many parents co m pensate by taking less ti m e forthe m selves
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
17/20
N ew research: effects on childreny Recent analysis of Canadian data by Strazdins et al
(2004) shows that children of parents who work
non-standard hours arem
ore likely to haveem otional or behavioural difficultiesy Independent of socio-econo m ic status and
childcare usey Other kinds of disadvantage can co m pound this
effect
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
18/20
Long hours of worky International research about health & long hours
(Spurgeon, 2003)y
Increases risk of m ental health proble m sy Increases risk of cardiovascular diseasey Adverse effects on fa m ily relationships
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
19/20
Inequalityy Inequality a m ongst wage earners has increasedin recent years
y A growing body of international research
suggesting that inequality is bad for societiesand fa m ilies (Wilkinson 2005)
y More unequal societies: violence, poorercomm unity relations and worse health.
8/9/2019 Industrial Relations Reform
20/20
A family unfriendly,unfair agenda
y With very negative consequences for the lowpaid,young and disadvantaged
y
Will createm
ore pressures inm
any fam
iliesy for children and other dependentsy for relationships
y Long lived social consequences for inequality andunfairness
Top Related