8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
1/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Definition of independence
Conceptual framework
Network firms Public interest entities
Related entities
Those charged with governance
General Provisions
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
2/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Documentation
Engagement period
Mergers and acquisitions
Otherconsiderations
General Provisionscontd
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
3/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Independence of Mind
The state of mind that permits the expression of a conclusion
without being affected by influences that compromise
professional judgment, thereby allowing an individual to act
with integrity and exercise objectivity and professionalskepticism.
Independence in Appearance
The avoidance of facts and circumstances that are so significantthat a reasonable and informed third party would be likely to
conclude, weighing all the specific facts and circumstances, that
a firms, of a member of the audit teams, integrity, objectivity
or professional skepticism has been compromised.
Definition of Independence
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
4/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Conceptual Framework Approach
Threats and Safeguards
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
5/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Self-interest
The threat that a financial or other interest will inappropriate
influence the professional accountants judgment or behavior.
Self-review The threat that a professional accountant will not appropriately
evaluate the results of a previous judgment made or service
performed on which the accountant will rely when forming a
judgment as part of providing the current service.
Advocacy
The threat that a professional accountant will promote a clients
position to the point that the accountants objectivity is
compromised.
Conceptual FrameworkThreats
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
6/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Familiarity
The threat that due to a long or close relationship with a client, a
professional accountant will be too sympathetic to their interests or
too accepting of their work.
Intimidation
The threat that a professional accountant will be deterred from
acting objectively because of actual or perceived pressures,
including attempts to exercise undue influence over the accountant.
Conceptual FrameworkThreats
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
7/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Safeguards fall into two broad categories:
Those created by the profession, legislation or regulation; and
Those in the work environment.
Conceptual FrameworkSafeguards
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
8/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
When safeguards are never adequate
Conceptual FrameworkProhibitions
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
9/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Network firms are required to be independent of auditclients of other firms within the network
Network is defined as a larger structure that is:
Aimed at co-operation; and
Clearly aimed at profit or cost sharing or shares common
ownership, control or management, common quality control
policies and procedures, common business strategy, the use of
a common brand-name, or a significant part of professionalresources.
Network Firms
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
10/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Public interest entities defined as:
Listed entities; and
Entities
defined by regulation or legislation as a public interest entity, or
for which the audit is required by regulation or legislation to be
conducted in compliance with the same independence
requirements that apply to the audit of listed entities.
Public Interest Entities
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
11/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Firms and member bodies are encouraged to determinewhether to treat other entities as public interest entities
because the entities have a large number and wide
range of stakeholders
Factors to be considered include:
The nature of the business, such as the holding of assets in a
fiduciary capacity for a large number of stakeholders;
Size; and
Number of employees.
Public Interest Entities
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
12/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Related entities of the audit client are defined as:
An entity that has direct or indirect control over the client if the client is
material to such entity;
An entity with a direct financial interest in the client if that entity has
significant influence over the client and the interest in the client is materialto such entity;
An entity over which the client has direct or indirect control;
An entity in which the client, or an entity over which the client has direct or
indirect control, has a direct financial interest that gives it significant
influence over such entity and the interest is material to the client and itsrelated entity; and
An entity which is under common control with the client (a sister entity) if
the sister entity and the client are both material to the entity that controls
both the client and the sister entity.
Related Entities
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
13/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Listed entities
References to audit client include its related entities
Independence is required from all related entities.
Non-listed entities
Independence is required from related entities over which the
audit client has direct or indirect control.
When the audit team knows, or has reason to believe, arelationship or circumstance involving a related entity is relevant
to the evaluation of the firms independence, that related entity
shall be included in the evaluation of independence.
Related Entities
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
14/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Regular communication with those charged withgovernance is encouraged.
Communication enables those charged with governance
to: Consider the firms judgments in identifying and evaluating
threats to independence,
Consider the appropriateness of safeguards applied, and
Take appropriate action.
Those Charged with Governance
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
15/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
The professional accountant shall document conclusionsregarding compliance with independence requirements
and the substance of relevant discussions supporting
conclusions:
When safeguards are required, the nature of the threat and
safeguards in place or applied to reduce threat to an acceptable
level shall be documented.
When a threat required significant analysis to determine
whether safeguards were necessary and the accountant
concluded safeguards were not necessary because the threat
was already at an acceptable level, the nature of the threat and
rationale for the conclusion shall be documented.
Documentation
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
16/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Independence is required during the engagement periodand the period covered by the financial statements.
The engagement period starts when the audit team
begins to perform audit services and ends when theaudit report is issued.
If the engagement is recurring, the period ends at the
later of the notification by either party that the
professional relationship has terminated or the issuanceof the final report.
Engagement Period
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
17/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
When, as a result of merger or acquisition, an entitybecomes a related entity of the audit client, the firm
shall:
Identify and evaluate previous and current relationships that
could affect independence, and
Take steps necessary by the effective date of the merger or
acquisition to terminate any current interests or relationships
that are not permitted.
Mergers and Acquisitions
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
18/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
If the firm cannot reasonably terminate an interest orrelationship by the effective date, the firm shall:
Evaluate the significance of the threat, and
Discuss the matter with those charged with governance and ifthose charged with governance request the firm to continue as
auditor, the firm shall do so only if:
The interest or relationship will be terminated as soon as reasonably
possible and in all cases within six months of the effective date;
Any individual with such an interest or relationship is not a member of
the engagement team or the individual responsible for the engagement
quality control review; and
Appropriate transitional measures are applied and discussed with
those charged with governance.
Mergers and Acquisitions
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
19/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
When the firm has completed a significant amount of audit workbefore the effective date of the merger or acquisition and can
complete the audit in a short period of time, and those charged with
governance request the firm to complete the audit while continuing
with an interest or relationship that would otherwise be prohibited,
the firm shall do so only if :
The firm has evaluated the significance of the threats and discussed such
evaluation with those charged with governance;
The individual with such an interest or relationship is not a member of the
engagement team or the individual responsible for the engagement qualitycontrol review;
Appropriate transitional measures are applied; and
The firm ceases to be the auditor no later than the issuance of the audit
report.
Mergers and Acquisitions
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
20/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
In all cases, the firm shall determine whether, even if all therequirements can be met, the interests or relationships create
threats that would remain so significant that objectivity would be
compromised .
The firm shall document any prohibited interests or relationshipsthat will not be terminated by the effective date of the merger or
acquisition, including the:
Reasons why the interest or relationship was not terminated;
Transitional measures applied; Results of the discussion with those charged with governance; and
Rationale as to why the threats that remain are not so significant that
objectivity would be compromised.
Mergers and Acquisitions
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
21/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
An inadvertent violation of an independencerequirement generally will be deemed not to
compromise independence provided:
The firm has appropriate quality control policies and
procedures (equivalent to ISCQ 1) in place to maintain
independence; and
Once discovered, the violation is corrected promptly and any
necessary safeguards are applied to eliminate any threat or
reduce it to an acceptable level.
The firm shall determine whether to discuss the matter
with those charged with governance.
Other Considerations
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
22/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
General Provision
Financial interests
Loans and guarantees
Business relationship
Family and personal relationships
Employments with an audit client
Key Independence Provisions
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
23/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Temporary staff assignments
Recent service with an audit client
Serving as a director or officer
Long association (including partner rotation)
Provision of non-assurance services
Fees
Key Independence Provisions
P bli I E i i
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
24/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Compensation and evaluation policies
Gifts and hospitality
Actual of threatened litigation
Reports that include a restriction on use or
distribution
Key Independence Provisions
P bli I t t E ti ti
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
25/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
The slides that follow cover particular circumstances orrelationships addressed in Section 290 of the Code.
However, Section 290 does not describe all of the
circumstances or relationships that create or may createthreats to independence.
The firm and members of the audit team shall evaluate
the implications of similar, but different, circumstances
and relationships and determine whether safeguards canbe applied when necessary to eliminate the threats or
reduce them to an acceptable level.
General Provision
P bli I t t E ti ti
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
26/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
A firm, a member of the audit team, or an immediatefamily member shall not have a direct financial interest
or material indirect financial interest in the audit client.
Financial Interests
P bli I t t E ti ti
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
27/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Partners, and their immediate family members, shallnot have a direct financial interest or material indirect
financial interest in any audit client served by
engagement partners located in the same office.
Partners and managerial employees who provide non-
audit services to an audit client, except those whose
involvement is minimal, or their immediate family
members, shall not have a direct financial interest or
material indirect financial interest in such audit client.
Financial Interests
P bli I t t E ti ti
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
28/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Financial interests held by immediate family members of:
Partners in the office of the engagement partner, or
Partners or managerial employees who provide non-audit services to
the audit client
will not compromise independence if the interest is received
as a result of the family members employment rights and
safeguards are applied when necessary.
When the immediate family member has the right to disposeof the interest or, in the case of stock options, exercise the
option, the interest shall be disposed of or forfeited as soon
as practicable.
Financial Interestscontd
P bli I t t E ti ti
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
29/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Those prohibited from having a direct or materialindirect financial interest in an audit client shall not
hold such interest as trustee unless:
The trustee, or immediate family member, or the firm are not
beneficiaries of the trust;
The interest in the audit client is not material to the trust;
The trust cannot exercise significant influence over the audit
client; and
The trustee, or immediate family member, or the firm cannot
significantly influence any investment decision involving a
financial interest in the audit client.
Financial Interests
P bli I t t E ti ti
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
30/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
A firm, a member of the audit team, or an immediatefamily member shall not have a financial interest in an
entity that the audit client also has an interest in if the
interest is material to any party and the audit client can
exercise significant influence over the entity.
Financial Interests
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
31/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
If the firm, a partner or employee of the firm, or immediatefamily member, receives a financial interest that would not
be permitted, for example by way of an inheritance, gift or
as a result of a merger:
If received by the firm, a member of the audit team, or immediatefamily member, the interest shall be disposed of immediately, or if
the interest is indirect, a sufficient amount shall be disposed of such
that the remaining interest is immaterial
If received by an individual who is not a member of the audit team,
or immediate family member, the interest shall be disposed of as
soon as possible, or if the interest is indirect, a sufficient amount
shall be disposed of such that the remaining interest is immaterial
Financial Interests
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
32/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Threats may be created:
If a member of audit team knows a close family member, or
other individuals ,such as professionals in the firm or close
personal friends, holds a direct financial interest or material
indirect financial interest in the audit client
A firms retirement benefit plan holds a direct financial
interest or material indirect financial interest in an audit client
A firm, a member of the audit team, or immediate family
member, has a financial interest in an entity and a director,
officer or controlling owner of the audit client is also known to
have a financial interest in that entity
Financial Interests
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
33/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Audit clients that are banks or similar institutions
A firm, a member of the audit team, or immediate family member,
may not have a loan or guarantee of a loan provided it is made under
normal lending procedures, terms and conditions.
If a loan to a firm is permitted under the above and is material to theaudit client or the firm, it may be possible to apply safeguards to
reduce the threat to an acceptable level.
Audit clients that are not banks or similar institutions
A firm, a member of the audit team, or immediate family member,may have a loan or guarantee of a loan unless it is immaterial to the
firm or member of the audit team and the immediate family member,
and the client.
Loans and Guarantees
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
34/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
A firm, a member of the audit team, or an immediatefamily member, shall not make or guarantee a loan to
an audit client unless the loan or guarantee is
immaterial to both the firm or member of the audit team
and the immediate family member, and the client.
Loans and Guarantees
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
35/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
A firm shall not have a business relationship with an audit clientor its management unless any financial interest is immaterial and
the business relationship is insignificant to the firm and the client
or its management.
If any financial interest from a business relationship between amember of the audit team and the audit client or its management
is material or the relationship is significant to that member, the
individual should be removed from the audit team.
If the business relationship is between an immediate family
member of a member of the audit team and the audit client or its
managements, any threat shall be evaluated and safeguards
applied when necessary.
Business Relationships
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
36/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
The purchase of goods and services from an audit clientby the firm, or a member of the audit team or an
immediate family member, does not generally create
threats to independence if the transaction is in the
normal course of business and at arms length.
If the nature or magnitude of the transactions is such
that a self-interest threat is created, safeguards shall be
applied when necessary.
Business Relationships
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
37/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
An individual who has an immediate family member inone of the following positions at an audit client, or who
was in the position during any period covered by the
engagement or financial statements, shall not be a
member of the audit team:
A director or officer; or
An employee in a position to exert significant influence over
the preparation of the accounting records or the financial
statements.
Family and Personal Relationships
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
38/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Threats to independence are created when a member ofthe audit team has an immediate family member who is
an employee in a position to exert significant influence
over the clients financial position, financial
performance or cash flows.
The significance of the threats shall be evaluated and
safeguards applied when necessary.
Family and Personal Relationships
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
39/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Threats to independence are created when a member ofthe audit team has a close family member in one of the
following positions at an audit client:
A director or officer; or
An employee in a position to exert significant influence over
the preparation of the accounting records of the financial
statements.
The significance of the threats shall be evaluated andsafeguards applied when necessary.
Family and Personal Relationshipscontd
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
40/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Threats to independence are created if a member of the auditteam has a close relationship with other persons in one of the
following positions at an audit client:
A director or officer; or
An employee in a position to exert significant influence over the
preparation of the accounting records of the financial statements.
A member of the audit team who has such a relationship shall
consult in accordance with firm policies and procedures.
The significance of the threats shall be evaluated and
safeguards applied when necessary.
Family and Personal Relationships
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
41/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
A former member of audit team or partner of the firmshall not join an audit client as director or officer or an
employee in a position to exert significant influence
over the accounting records or financial statements
unless:
The individual is not entitled to any benefits or payments from
the firm, unless made in accordance with fixed pre-determined
arrangements and any amount owed to the individual is not
material to the firm; and
The individual does not continue to participate, or appear to
participate, in the firms business or professional activities.
Employment with an Audit Client
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
42/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
If no significant connection remains between the firmand the former member of the audit team or partner, the
significance of the threats shall be evaluated and
safeguards applied when necessary.
Firm policies and procedures shall require members of
the audit team to notify the firm when entering
employment negotiations with an audit client.
Safeguards shall be applied when necessary.
Employment with an Audit Clientcontd
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
43/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Independence is compromised if a key audit partneror thefirms Senior or Managing Partner joins the audit client as a
director or officer or an employee in a position to exert
significant influence over the accounting records or
financial statements unless aspecified period has passed.
An exception exists if a former key audit partner or the
firms Senior or Managing Partner is in such a position as a
result of a business combination, provided certain criteria
are satisfied.
Employment with an Audit Clientcontd
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
44/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Key audit partners include the:
Engagement partner;
Individual responsible for the engagement quality control review; and
Other audit partners on the engagement team who make key decisions
or judgments on significant matters with respect to the audit.
Specified period
In the case of key audit partners, the client has issued audited
financial statements covering a period of not less than twelve monthsand the partner was not a member of the audit team with respect to the
audit of those financial statements.
In the case of the former Senior or Managing Partner, twelve
months have passed since the individual held that role.
Employment with an Audit Clientcontd
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
45/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Such assistance may be given only for a short period oftime.
Firm personnel shall not:
Provide a non-assurance service that would not be permitted under
section 290; or
Assume a management responsibility.
In all cases the audit client shall be responsible for directing
and supervising the activities of the loaned staff.
The significance of any threats shall be evaluated and
safeguards applied when necessary.
Temporary Staff Assignments
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
46/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
A partner or employee of the firm shall not serve as adirector or officer of an audit client.
A partner or employee may serve as Company
Secretary if:
The practice is specifically permitted under local laws and
professional rules of practice;
Management makes all relevant decision;
The duties are routine and administrative; and
The significance of the threats are evaluated and safeguards
applied when necessary.
Serving as a Director or Officer
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
47/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Using the same senior personnel on an auditengagement over a long period of time creates threats
to independence, which should be evaluated and
safeguards applied when necessary.
Key audit partners shall rotate after seven years and
shall not be a member of the engagement team or a key
audit partner for the client for two years.
Long Associationof Senior Personnel
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
48/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
Where continuity is especially important to audit quality,key audit partners may, in rare cases due to unforeseen
circumstances outside of the firms control, be permitted
one additional year as long as threats to independence can
be eliminated or reduced to an acceptable level by applying
safeguards.
The time served as a key audit partner is taken into account
when the audit client becomes a public interest entity.
An additional year is permitted only when the individual has servedas a key audit partner for six or more years when the audit client
becomes a public interest entity.
Long Association of Senior Personnel
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
49/81
Public I nterest Enti ties
During the two year time out period, the individualshall not:
Participate in the audit of the entity;
Provide quality control for the engagement; Consult with the engagement team or the client regarding
technical or industry-specific issues, transactions or events; or
Otherwise directly influence the outcome of the engagement.
Long Association of Senior Personnelcontd
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
50/81
ub c te est t t es
Rotation is not required if:
The firm has only a few people with the necessary knowledge
and experience to serve as a key audit partner;
An independent regulator has provided an exemption from
rotation in such circumstances;
The independent regulator has specified alternative safeguards;
and
The alternative safeguards are applied.
Long Association of Senior Personnel
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
51/81
Before the firm accepts an engagement to provide anon-assurance service to an audit client, a
determination shall be made whether providing the
service creates a threat to independence.
The firm shall not provide the service if the threats
cannot be reduced to an acceptable level by the
application of safeguards.
Provision of Non-assurance Services
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
52/81
A firm may provide a non-assurance service that wouldotherwise be restricted to the following related entities,
provided the results of the services will not be subject to
audit procedures:
An entity that has direct or indirect control over the audit client;
An entity with a direct financial interest in the audit client if that
entity has significant influence over the client and the interest in
the client is material to the entity; or
An entity under common control with the audit client.
The significance of any threats shall be evaluated and
safeguards applied when necessary.
Provision of Non-assurance Services
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
53/81
A non-assurance service provided to the audit clientbefore the client becomes a public interest entity does
not compromise the firms independence if:
The service was permissible for audit clients that are not
public interest entities;
The service that is not permitted for public interest entities is
terminated before or as soon as practicable after the client
becomes a public interest entity; and
Safeguards are applied when necessary.
Provision of Non-assurance Servicescontd
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
54/81
A firm shall not assume a management responsibility foran audit client.
To avoid the risk of assuming a management
responsibility, the firm shall be satisfied that a member
of management is responsible for:
Making the significant judgments and decisions that are the
proper responsibility of management;
Evaluating the results of the service; and
Accepting responsibility for the actions to be taken from results
of the service.
Management Responsibilities
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
55/81
Except in emergency situations, a firm shall not provide
accounting and bookkeeping services, including payroll services ,
to an audit client or prepare financial statements on which the
firm will express an opinion or financial information which forms
the basis of financial statements. A firm may provide services of a routine and mechanical nature
for divisions or related entities if the personnel providing the
service are not on the audit team and:
The divisions or related entities are collectively immaterial; or
The services relate to matters which are collectively immaterial to the
financial statements of the division or related entity.
Preparing Accounting Records andFinancial Statements
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
56/81
Emergency Situations
In emergency or other unusual situations when it is
impractical for the audit client to make other
arrangements, accounting and bookkeeping services thatwould otherwise be prohibited may be provided if:
Those who provide the services are not on the audit team;
The services provided only for a short period of time and are
not expected to recur; and
The situation is discussed with those charged with governance.
Preparing Accounting Records andFinancial Statements
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
57/81
Valuation services may create a self-review threat,which shall be evaluated and safeguards applied
when necessary.
A firm shall not provide valuation services if thevaluations would have a material effect, separately
or in the aggregate, on the financial statements.
Valuation Services
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
58/81
Tax Return Preparation
Providing tax return preparation services does not
generally create a threat to independence if
management takes responsibility for the returns and any
significant judgments made.
Taxation Services
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
59/81
Tax Calculations
Preparing calculations of current and deferred tax
liabilities (or assets) for purpose of preparing
accounting entries that will be subsequently audited by
the firm creates a self-review threat.
The significance shall be evaluated and safeguards
applied when necessary.
Taxation Servicescontd
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
60/81
Tax Planning and Other Tax Advisory Services
A self-review threat may be created when advice will affect
matters to be reflected in the financial statements. The threat
shall be evaluated and safeguards applied when necessary.
A firm shall not provide tax advice if the effectiveness of
the advice depends on a particular accounting treatment or
financial statement presentation and:
The audit team has reasonable doubt as to the appropriateness of therelated accounting treatment or presentation; and
The outcome or consequence of the corporate finance advice would
have a material effect on the financial statements.
Taxation Services
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
61/81
Assistance in the Resolution of Tax Disputes
An advocacy or self-review threat may be created when the
firm assists the audit client with the resolution of a tax dispute
once the tax authorities have notified the client that they have
rejected the clients arguments and the matter is beingreferred for determination in a formal proceeding. The threats
shall be evaluated and safeguards applied when necessary.
A firm shall not act as an advocate for the audit client before a
public tribunal or court in the resolution of a tax matter if theamounts involved are material to the financial statements.
Taxation Services
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
62/81
When providing internal audit services to an audit client, firmpersonnel shall not assume a management responsibility, and the
firm shall be satisfied that:
The client designates an appropriate and competent resource to be in
charge and acknowledge responsibility for internal controls;
Management or those charged with governance review, assess and
approve the scope, risk and frequency of the services;
Management evaluates the adequacy and results;
Management decides which recommendations to implement; and
Management reports to those charge with governance the significant
findings and recommendations.
Internal Audit Services
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
63/81
If the firm provides internal audit services and the results of thoseservices will be used in conducting the external audit, a self-
review threat is created, which shall be evaluated and safeguards
applied when necessary.
A firm shall not provide internal audit services that relate to:
A significant part of the internal controls over financial
reporting;
Financial accounting systems that generate information that is,
separately or in the aggregate, significant to the clientsaccounting records or financial statements; or
Amounts or disclosures that are, separately or in the aggregate,
material to the clients financial statements.
Internal Audit Services
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
64/81
The firm may provide the following services provided firmpersonnel do not assume a management responsibility:
Designing or implementing IT systems that are unrelated to internal
control over financial reporting;
Designing or implementing IT systems that do not generateinformation forming a significant part of the accounting records or
financial statements;
Implementation of off-the-shelf accounting or financial
information reporting software not developed by the firm if no
significant customization is required to meet the clients needs; and
Evaluating and making recommendations on a system designed,
implemented or operated by another or the client.
IT Systems Services
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
65/81
A firm shall not provide services involving the designor implementation of IT systems that:
Form a significant part of the internal control over financial
reporting; or
Generate information that is significant to the accounting
records or financial statements.
IT Systems Services
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
66/81
If the firm provides litigation support servicesinvolving estimating damages or other amounts that
affect the financial statements, the requirements
regarding valuation services shall be followed.
For other litigation support services, the significance of
any threat created shall be evaluated and safeguards
applied when necessary.
Litigation Support Services
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
67/81
A firm shall not act in an advocacy role for an auditclient in resolving a dispute or litigation when the
amounts involved are material to the financial
statements.
A partner or employee shall not act as General Counsel
for legal affairs of an audit client.
For other legal services, the significance of any threat
created shall be evaluated and safeguards applied whennecessary.
Legal Services
Public Interest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
68/81
Providing recruiting services may create threats toindependence, which shall be evaluated and safeguards
applied when necessary.
A firm may generally provide services such as:
Reviewing the professional qualifications of candidates and
providing advice on their suitability for a position; and
Interviewing candidates and advising on their competence for
financial accounting, administrative or control positions.
Recruiting Services
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
69/81
A firm shall not provide the following services withrespect to a director or officer of the audit client or
senior management in a position to exert significant
influence over the clients accounting records or
financial statements: Searching for or seeking out candidates for such positions; and
Undertaking reference checks of prospective candidates for
such positions.
Recruiting Services
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
70/81
Providing corporate finance services may create threatsto independence, which shall be evaluated and
safeguards applied when necessary.
A firm shall not provide corporate finance advice if the
effectiveness of the advice depends on a particular
accounting treatment or financial statement
presentation and:
The audit team has reasonable doubt as to the appropriatenessof the accounting treatment or presentation; and
The outcome or consequence of the tax advice would have a
material effect on the financial statements.
Corporate Finance Services
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
71/81
Threats are created when fees from an audit clientrepresent a large proportion of the total fees of the firm
or a large proportion of the total revenue of an
individual partner or an individual office of the firm.
The threats shall be evaluated and safeguards applied
when necessary.
FeesRelative Size
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
72/81
If the total fees from the client are more than 15% of the firmstotal fees for two years, the firm shall discuss which of the
following safeguards to apply with those charged with
governance:
A pre-issuance engagement quality control review performed by a
professional accountant who is not a member of the firm; or
A post-issuance review equivalent to an engagement quality control
performed by a professional accountant who is not a member of the firm.
If the total fees significantly exceed 15% of the firms total fees ,
the firm shall determine whether the significance of the threat issuch that a pre-issuance review is necessary.
FeesRelative Sizecontd
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
73/81
A threat may be created when fees from an audit clientremain unpaid for a long time.
Generally, the firm is excepted to require payment of
any significant unpaid fees before the issue of the audit
report for the following year.
If fees remain unpaid after the report has been issued,
any threat shall be evaluated and safeguards applied
when necessary.
FeesOverdue
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
74/81
A contingent fee shall not be charged in respect of an auditengagement.
A contingent fee shall not be charged for a non-assurance
service provided to an audit client if:
The fee is charged by the firm and the fee is material or expected to
be material to the firm;
The fee is charged by a network firm that participates in a significant
part of the audit and the fee is material or expect to be material to the
network firm; or
The outcome of the non-assurance service, and therefore the amount
of the fee, is dependent on a future or contemporary judgment related
to the audit of a material amount in the financial statements.
Contingent Fees
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
75/81
For other contingent fee arrangements, threats toindependence shall be evaluated and safeguards applied
when necessary.
Contingent Fees
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
76/81
Key audit partners shall not be evaluated on orcompensated for the partners success in selling non-
assurance services to their audit clients.
A threat may be created if other members of the audit
team are evaluated on or compensated for their success
in selling non-assurance services to their audit clients.
The threat shall be evaluated and safeguards applied
when necessary.
Compensation and Evaluation Policies
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
77/81
A firm or member of the audit team shall not acceptgifts or hospitality from an audit client unless the value
is trivial and inconsequential.
Gifts and Hospitality
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
78/81
Litigation between the firm or a member of the auditteam and an audit client creates a threat to
independence.
The significance of the threat shall be evaluated and
safeguards applied when necessary.
If safeguards do not reduce the threats to an acceptable
level, the firm shall withdraw from the audit
engagement.
Actual or Threatened Litigation
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
79/81
The Code provides for some modifications to theindependence requirements for audit engagements where
the report includes a restriction on use and distribution,
unless the audit is required by law or regulation.
The modifications are permitted if the intended users of
the report:
Are knowledgeable as to the purpose and limitations of the
report; and
Explicitly agree to the application of the modified independence
requirements.
Reports that Include a Restriction on Use orDistribution
Public I nterest Enti ties
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
80/81
The revised Code is effective on January 1, 2011.
Certain transitional provisions apply to the following:
Public interest entities;
Partner rotation;
Non-assurance services;
Feesrelative size; and
Compensation and evaluation policies.
Effective Date
8/12/2019 Independence Public Interest Entities
81/81
International Federation of Accountants
www.ifac.org
Top Related