8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
1/38
In Search of a Demos:
Transformations of Citizenship andBelonging in the Republic of
Macedonia
Ljubica Spaskovska
Working Paper 2010/11
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
2/38
The University of Edinburgh is a charitable body, registered in Scotland, with registration number SC005336.
!"#
$ %%
!"#
" &% ' ()*)+**
,"- ()./0.)1/
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
3/38
2 ()*) $ %% 3 4
5 6 4
76 844% 3
4
' ,
9 :
;< (= ,
4444%++%
5 " 5 >
7 * 5 ())1 !7(?)(?1#
'$ $ @++444%+
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
4/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 1
$ %% *
3 7 A % @ !# B B B 4 " + @B 0B !# 4 30 3 A 4
!
B B 0B B AB 4
C
D 4 :
D :4
" 7 9% 6
: E *
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
5/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 2
4 !>% ())IB ())I# :% A & & :% & 9
42
: 0 % 0 E C EC !,% ())*@ (((# A 3 D 4 D *1I. D 4
AC 3
*11* A !#A 4 ())* 9 % 5 0 A 0 ! D 0# 4 3 $ A34 3 5 0 !$ *11*#4 A *1.. D 4
% A % 4 % @
0 3 A EC !:% J ()))@ (I# B
0 C B0 B0 B 0 A 4
( % % , C 7 A *1(
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
6/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 3
% 3 6@
*# (# ?# .#
% % E !# C A
4 3 0 A 0 A4 3 0 0 " 4 5 ())< AC $
3 4 A % 3 0 4
" # $
:%
4 : 0 :% 0 E0 0 C !>% ())?# 4 " 3 0 0 4 *11) *11(
0 EC !K% ()*)# 3
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
7/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 4
E C !G J ())*@ /#4 5 A 3 *11)4
0 0 *1I.4 5:% 7 6 3 0 0 E C !:% J ()))@ (/#4 ; 3 7 ; % 3
E C ! *1
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
8/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 5
0@ A 5 5 4 &
IF *1?1 ?F4I *1F? *)41 *1
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
9/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 6
0 6 6 A5 % ! ())*@ *F(#4
5 4 (.1 *1I. E
7 C 4 *1II 7 A *1/F4654 * E 7 A 7 AC4 " A 0
E A G :C !%A J ; *11.@ *11* $ 3 : A' 5$ "U , G 0 E' C47A 0 4 ' % A ! A # ! # - ! # 48 " 3
A ! 4 5 3
/EVWXYZ [W \]^W_`WZab_YbY ZW cYde`WfeabegXW hijklfeXW mWXi\YZe`WC+ 7 A cfk^liZ _iaZeX ZW cYde`WfeabegXW hijklfeXW mWXi\YZe`W *1+II+ !" #$*1+II4IE' C%&'()*+,- ./ 0*1(23-'/ 4/'*5&+-6/ 7789!: !" #$ 778!%$@ " " ())
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
10/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 7
E 4 5 STC !% A J ;
*11.@
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
11/38
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
12/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 9
4 : E:C A E : C !, ())*#4
AC 3
A 410 *11) G% 4 " *11( 0 % E" A% %C PA G%Q E A LC !, ())*@ (?.#4 AC 3 0 04
& % 3 *11) 4 " ! ())*#4 9 A A *11( 0 - ' !-'7997# >*11?4 5 ! ())*# - 4 7 *11F -'7p' ! - ' p # 3 44 *11I 5 *11< , ! - *11
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
13/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 10
A A 6 3 A 5 % H 7 7 AC4 A
5 0 4 5 5 A E0 C A4 5 ; E: 6 C !;*11?@ (F#4 7 9
A G 5 *11I4 !# 4
5 (*4I $ 5 !" ()*)#4 5 A 5 0 0 () A $4 A 5 A $ 4 5 !,% ())*#4 ; ,% E % % C !,% ())*@ F)#4
% % 34 5
3 A , E C !, ())(@ *)1#4 " 6 12 3 6 0 3 !; *11I#4 *11?
*(5 *1
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
14/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 11
6 A 4 G *11.0*11F A 413p G
E % GC A C !, ())*@ (./#4 9 7 A ! ())*@ (1?#4 5 3 *12*+ ?*@+-' +/ 0*1(23-'/ 4/'*5&+-6/P9 G 7 AQ /I+1(4
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
15/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 12
6 % 0 4 ; *11( % @ ' p '
!'p'# 5 A16
A 4 5 17 % A A A 6 6 4 p 4
E 'C 7 A A 0 6 4 ' 0 6 5 7 A % !'s% *11 *11?C ! ! !" #$M@++44%++&:p4N4*
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
16/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 13
!# 4 *11( *11
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
17/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 14
. ) &
" E"
A 9 5C !'J , ()).@ *.*#4 5 5 ())* 9 %5 % A4 " % $ D % 4 ; ())* % 0 0())* 4 5 5 !55#
A 1 5 ())* A 5 C 4& A 9 !" ()*)# 5 E C E 0 AC C4
.%" / +!$
9 5 % E C !: ()).@ (..#4 5 5 0 0! 5 # 4 0% 4 % 19 6
+ 0$ ! 0 : $# D6 $ $ 5
*1 ' A @ E 7 A A 5 % H 7 :% % A
3 A 6 C4
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
18/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 15
0$ A' 4 " % E0 3
C !: ()).@ (?1# A4 3 + 9 5 4
0G > ())( 9 0G 5 ()). *(?
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
19/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 16
5 6 9 % 5 A % 4
.%*
- ())? 4 5 6 5 ()).421 ' 6 0 *11(
4
22
5 C - ())?423 6 A A
A 6 C 424 6 3 3 E 74 A 74 A D 3 %0 % C4 & %04 5% 5 % 4 "
% A *1F) *1/) !" ())/ 7" ()*)#4
()). 4 6
E 3 C
(* !>0 ()).# $ A:B ;:@ 50 4 " AC ' % 4((9 H$% Ex]^W_`WZab_Y aY Yakw yY\eZe j]iabY` _Y [iw`W_WC P 0Q DP Q (? > ()).4(?;:"< !" #$
M@++44%+4R""pq5)5)?:::I1*5.:/5./1)p115N(.9 H$% Ex]^W_`WZab_Y aY Yakw yY\eZe j]iabY` _Y [iw`W_WC P 0Q DP Q (? > ()).4
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
20/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 17
0 A 4 % A " 3 ()).
3 4A
7 4 " E 6 7 A 7 A 7C425
7 5 A *11( + 0 64 " p ()). % A G -;7 4 3 7 5 3 4
())
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
21/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 18
())1 I?I1 $ */
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
22/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 19
"0' :# A ! ; 7 ()*)#4
5 0 G% A G
G% & *1./0*1.1 $ 4 *1 G% - 0G% ! ; 7 ())1#4 A 5 07 5 A % 6 G% 430 5 4 A 3
A 4 E; " AC 3 *1F* 3 5 431 0 HA790p'A- 432 A + % A A !7 ())
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
23/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 20
.%0 &
0A
A % @ 0 ! p 5 A 0 pA# C 0 HA790p'A-350 " A7 94 5 *11* 5 @ p ' 5 !p'5+'p# p "!p"+:p"# ())* 436 5 ; E 3C !; *11?@ ??#4
; 4 3 ())1 37 5 ' -p ' " A E A 9C4 3 4 0 A % $ % D E 0 C !% *11/@ ?
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
24/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 21
E0 C !, J :$0p ())/@ (?.#4 5 0 %
!' J ,()).#4 A E C !: ()).@ (.(#4 A 3 E0 C !" ()*)@ ?.F# ' ' 439 0 0 + 440-
+ % E C !7"()*)@
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
25/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 22
3 C G4 0
AC 4 " 3 C E C ! *11.@ (F# 4
.%1 ) )
5 " H$ E 0 + % %
& L C !H$ *11F@ ?
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
26/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 23
5 A 7 ! 7 A# 7 0 4 7 p 7 "
())F0()*F 4 7 I?
! ())1#4 A 7 " 0 7 0 7 !7" ()*)#4 A 7
4
41
5 -G9
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
27/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 24
- $ C A
4
0 ' ! 2
*1I. : @ E5 % 0
% C C ! *11(@ 1?#4 3 % $4 A!A#42 A *11* : !# % $ + *1I)443 5 3 % 4
*111 5 A 3 4 5 A 5 5 !55# 5 ())*4 " A ()). p ())F 4 & % !()).# %
% A !9 ())1#45 A 05 4 3 G
.( *1.< ; & 4
.?" A4 $ 5 % 0 A ' *1I) C "6 !5 ())1#4 A4 5 C
4 C 4
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
28/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 25
C 4 5 H G E 4 9 4 9
0% C !G ()).@1/#4
0%"
: E C ! ()*)@ ()# 0 *11* E C E C
!, J ())I#4 5 A !" ()*)# A C E3C % & :% 4 ())F 5 & :% p 3 7 p ! ()*)B ()*)#4 9 A 5 !5# ' ! 7 0 0 7 # " '05 5 !"'5#4 E & :% ())1 % % @ 0 B B -G9 % C ! ()*)@ *#4
: ())I
% 44 $ %4 ()))0())/ 6 : A 6 ?(I)( ())) **? ! J > ()*)@*F#4 " *)
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
29/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 26
: p A ' :444 : A : A 4 $
: ! J > ()*)# : "p 3 4 5 A0: 45 +
4
0%* & 34 3
' A $ $ 4 E C !> ())1# E C! ())F# 6 0 4 ; ()*) $ 0 ())I446
& :4 : -59 AC 4 5 E 3
..E: : C / 9 ())14EbZegiaXebi lfyW]e [W_]efe _eai Yl]W[Y_WZei k ZWa i jYfkgW_Wb jY0l][Y y]W^\WZab_YC !())1#P : : 6 : Q 9CPQ F 9 ())14M@++4%4++())1+*)+)F+I1.1*1r%rrrrr+N4.F5 A ; A : A 3 A ' : 4 A0: : ' % : 4 A A 'A $ G% 6 :4
./E AC ! ::H :M@++44++0+rrrrr+0+3r4N ! * > ()*)#4
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
30/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 27
C !G ()).@ 1I#4 0 047 % 0
0 '4 4 E%0 ! #L %0 C!G ()).@ 1.#4
5 3
3 A4 &:% 0 3 4 ; AC 4
A 0 0 C 04 3 0 !# 0 4 0
A % 9 % 5 ())* 4 7 0 0 4 & ())< 4 9 ())14 "
.I E C :I 5 ())14
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
31/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 28
44 !# 47 3 0
0 3 45 E C !' J , ()).@ (I.#4 " & C ! ())*# 3 4
45 E 6 C !9 *11I@ (.?#4 E C !>% J % *111@ *F# % 0 0 4 ; E C!,% ())*@ ?*.# 4 E C D E C !G *111@ IF# 44 00 4 A 3 6 + % 4" E % C !, ())*@ F1#4 " 3 0 % 6
6 4
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
32/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 29
5 :4 !())*# E& @ RC - 7 1@ ?*0.(4
: 4 !()).# E' @ : A ,C 54 A4 ' "4 , !4#- @ 4 : +- %@ ' 4 (?*0(.14
:% 74 J 4 !()))# E: S"TC (1 P*Q@*0.I4
: 4 4 !*1
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
33/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 30
xYXkwiZbe [W hijklfeXW mWXi\YZe`W *11)0())F+p 7 A *11)0())F4 %$@ " "4 ())
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
34/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 31
" 4 !4# !())/# @ 7 5@ 34 G@ 5 p "4
" G !"G# !()))# EAC 5@ C 7 -4 1 4 !())1# E5 @ C S" 9CT > 75 " *F@
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
35/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 32
- @ 4 :+- %@ ' 4 *)*0*.I4
, 4 !())*# EG% ' 79A "
7C >4 ' !4# A 64 @ '' 4 ((/0(/?4
, A4 4 !())*# E 5 7 A@ C - 'I!.#@ ?I0/F4
, p4 J H4 :$0p !())/# E :%@% 0 0 C F@ ((?0
(.*4,% &4 !())*# ' @ 4 - %@ 93 '4
,% &4 !())*# E& C &4 ,% J A4 9% !4# 3R& 4 - %@ 93 ' 4 *?0*)I4
E > *1 *
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
36/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 33
9 4 ,4 !*11I# 4 @ ' '4
's% 4 !*11 11@ *F?.0*FF4 !())I# @ 4 @ '4
>4 !()*)# E @ C "&% ' ()*)+)I4
% 4 !*11/# '0 4
&@ "' '4
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
37/38
CITSEE WORKING PAPER SERIES 2010/11 34
p4 J 4 > !()*)# E 7@ :C p9 94
K% "4 !()*)# E5 @
C " &% ' ()*)+)(4
4 !*11.# A4 '@ ' '4
A4 !*11(# 5 @ 4 @ H:%4
4 !())*# E"A79 *)) q 79AR AC >4 ' !4# A 64 @ '
' 4 /)0I14E-;7 7 A 5 ())1C!())1# -;7 7 7 A 4
- !*11I# E7 G - ' p +*11I+?/FC4
- !*11
8/10/2019 In Search of a Demos
38/38
Top Related