Download - H16 Mantra User Guide REMOVING NOISE...H16 Mantra User Guide As with Motion Blur, removing noise from images with Depth of Field may have the side effect of removing other types of

H16MantraUserGuide

REMOVINGNOISEAsdescribedintheSamplingsection,under-samplingisalmostalwaysthecauseofnoiseinyourrenders.Simplyincreasingtheoverallamountofsamplingwillreducetheamountofnoise,butitwillalsocausemanypartsofyourimagetobeover-sampledandyourrendertimestoincrease.Targetingthevarioustypesofraystothecorrectpartofyourimageiscriticalforoptimization,sendingmoreofthewrongkindofraywillnotincreasethequalityofyourrender.Thegoal,whensettingyoursamplingparameters,istobalanceSpeedwithQuality.Formoreinformationaboutthespecificparametersdescribedbelow,seeTheSamplingTabandtheExtraImagePlanesTab.

Ingeneral,whenattemptingtoremovethenoiseinyourrender,itisgoodpracticetostartbyaddingthefollowingimageplanes:

DirectLighting(percomponent)

IndirectLighting(percomponent)

DirectSamples

IndirectSamples

Thesewillallowyoutoanalyzedifferentpartsofyoursceneoneatatime.

Thefollowingrenderisanexampleofascenewithmultiplematerialtypesandmotionblur.AllsamplingvaluesontheMantraNodearesettothedefaultsexceptforPixelSamples,whichare1x1.Onthelimitstab,DiffuseLimithasbeensetto2,VolumeLimithasbeensetto2andSSSlimithasbeensetto1.

H16MantraUserGuide

ForeachExamplebelow,wewilladjustonlytheparametersthatarementionedinthedescriptionsaccompanyingeachnoisetype.

MotionBlurWhen“AllowMotionBlur”isenabledontheMantranode,fastmovingobjectscancauseyourimagetobecomenoisy.Thisnoiseisessentiallyatypeofaliasingthatoccurswhenanobjectmustbesampledacrosstimeaswellasspace.SeethechapteronMotionBlur,foramoreindepthexplanationofhowmantrasamplesobjectsinmotionandhowcertainobjectsmaybeoptimizedforheavilymotionblurredscenes.

IncreasingPixelSamples,alsodescribedasPrimaryRays,istheonlywaytoremovethistypeofnoise.

H16MantraUserGuide

IncreasingPixelSampleswillactasamultiplierforallothertypesofrays(seeSamplingTab).Intheexampleabove,youcanseethatincreasingthepixelsampleshasalsoremovedmostoftheothertypesofnoiseinthisscene.Forthisreason,itisagoodideatoremoveMotionBlurasafirststepasitmaysolveothertypesofnoiseinyoursceneatthesametime.

Toidentifythistypeofnoise,itcanbeusefultochecktheAlphaChannelfornoiseattheendsofobjects.Ifoverlappingobjectsmakethisimpossible,turnoff“AllowMotionBlur”andcheckthenoiselevelsversusthenon-motionblurredscene.

DepthofFieldWhen“EnableDepthofField”ischeckedontheMantraNode,objectswhicharedistantfromthecamera’s“FocusDistance”canbecomenoisy.Thisisespeciallyevidentinbrighthighlightsandtheedgesofobjects.

IncreasingPixelSamplesistheonlywaytoremovethistypeofnoise.

H16MantraUserGuide

AswithMotionBlur,removingnoisefromimageswithDepthofFieldmayhavethesideeffectofremovingothertypesofnoiseaswell.Considerremovingthistypeofnoisefirstbeforeattemptingtoremovenoisefromothersources.However,alwayscheckthe“infocus”areasofyourimageforanyoftheothernoisetypesassomeextraattentionmayberequiredintheseareas.

Toidentifythistypeofnoise,itcanbeusefultochecktheAlphaChannelfornoiseattheedgesofobjectsoralongthemotionpath.Ifoverlappingobjectsmakethisimpossible,turnoff“EnableDepthofField”andchecktheamountofnoiseintheimagewithoutDepthofFieldblurring.

EdgeAliasing

WithoutenoughPrimaryRays,theedgesofobjectscanappearjaggedandrough.Thiscanbeespeciallyevidentinhigh-contrastareasorwithinhigh-frequencypatterns.

IncreasingPixelSamplesistheonlywaytoremovethistypeofnoise.

H16MantraUserGuide

Intheaboveexample,noticehowtheedgesofthesphereandplaneappearjaggedintheimageontheleft.

Toidentifythistypeofnoise,itcanbeusefultochecktheAlphaChannelfornoiseattheedgesofobjectsoralongthemotionpath.

Formanyscenes,settingpixelsamplesto3x3willbesufficienttoremovethistypeofnoise.Forimageswithhighfrequencypatternsgeneratedbyashader,itmaybenecessarytoincreasethesevaluestogetafullyanti-aliasedimage.Ifpossible,itmaybemoreefficienttohandlefilteringintheshader,ratherthatusingthebruteforceapproachofincreasingpixelsamples.

H16MantraUserGuide

DIRECTILLUMINATIONDirectReflectionsDirectReflectionsrefertothereflectionoflightsourcesdirectlyfromthesurfaceofanobject.ThesereflectionscanexhibitaspecklednoisepatternespeciallyinmaterialswithsmallamountsofroughnessincombinationwithAreaLightsorEnvironmentLights.

ThebestwaytoremovethistypeofnoiseistoincreasetheSamplingamountontheLightwhichiscausingthenoise.IncreasingPixelSampleswillalsohelpremovethenoise,butwillcauseanincreaseinallothertypesofrays.ItcanoftenbeagoodideatostartwiththedefaultPixelSamplevalueof3x3becauseitwillalsoremoveanydistractingEdgeAliasingfromyourimage.

IncreasinglightsampleswillactlikeamultiplieronthenumberofDirectRaysinyourscenesoitisnotagoodideatosimplyincreasesamplestoextremelyhighvaluesforalllights.IncreasingDirectrays(MinandMaxRaySamples)willhelpremovethistypeofnoise.Thismeansthatyoumustbalancetheneedtocleanupnoisefromaspecificlight,againstcleaningupDirectSourcesofnoisethroughoutyourimage.

Toidentifythistypeofnoise,enablethe“DirectReflect”imagelayer,thiswillallowyoutoexaminethecontributionstoDirectReflectionswithoutinterferencefromothersourcesofnoiseinyourscene.

H16MantraUserGuide

Intheaboveimages,theDirectReflectionnoiseismuchclearersinceitnolongermixedinwithallothersourcesofnoise.

Forcomplexsceneswithmanylights,itcanbeusefultoexportthe“DirectReflect”layerusingthe“PerLight”option.Thiswillallowyoutoisolatethespecificlightsthatarecausingnoiseinyourscene,allowingyoutoincreasesamplingonlyontheoffendinglightsources.

H16MantraUserGuide

DirectRefractionsDirectRefractionsarecausedbytherefractionoflightsourcesthroughasinglesurface(Agridforinstance)TheserefractionscanexhibitaspecklednoisepatternespeciallyinmaterialswithsmallamountsofroughnessincombinationwithAreaLightsorEnvironmentLights.

(RememberthatanyrefractionsthroughmorethanonesurfacewillbeconsideredanIndirectRefraction.)

ThebestwaytoremovethistypeofnoiseistoincreasetheSamplingamountontheLightwhichiscausingthenoise.IncreasingPixelsampleswillalsohelpremovethenoise,butwillcauseanincreaseinallothertypesofrays,causingareasoftheimagewithoutnoisetobecomeover-sampled.

Intheaboveexample,increasingthePixelSamplesto3x3removesalltheDirectRefractionnoiseandsotheSamplingQualityontheEnvironmentLightdidnotneedtobeadjusted.Thisisanothergoodreasontoapproachtheremovalofnoiseinstages.Forthiscase,RemovingEdgeAliasinghaseffectivelyresolvedtheDirectRefractionnoiseaswell.

IncreasinglightsampleswillactlikeamultiplieronthenumberofDirectRaysinyourscenesoitisnotagoodideatosimplyincreasesamplestoextremelyhighvaluesforalllights.Also,increasingDirectrays(MinandMaxRaySamples)willalsohelpcleanupthistypeofnoise.Thismeansthatyoumustbalancetheneedtocleanupnoisefromaspecificlight,againstcleaningupDirectSourcesofnoisethroughoutyourimage.

Toidentifythistypeofnoise,enablethe“DirectRefract”imagelayer,thiswillallowyoutoexaminethecontributionstoDirectRefractionswithoutinterferencefromothersourcesofnoiseinyourscene.

H16MantraUserGuide

Forcomplexsceneswithmanylights,itcanbeusefultoexportthe“DirectRefract”layerusingthe“PerLight”option.Thiswillallowyoutoisolatethespecificlightsthatarecausingnoiseinyourscene,allowingyoutoincreasesamplingonlyontheoffendinglightsources

DirectShadowsDirectShadows,whichoccurwhenapointinyourscenedoesnothaveadirectpathtoalightsource,canexhibitaspeckledorroughnoisepattern.Thisisespeciallyevidentinsoftshadowscastfromlargearealights.

ThebestwaytoremovethistypeofnoiseistoincreasetheSamplingamountonthelightwhichiscausingthenoise.IncreasingPixelsampleswillalsohelpremovethenoise,butwillcauseanincreaseinallothertypesofrays,causingareasoftheimagewithoutnoisetobecomeover-sampled.

H16MantraUserGuide

Increasinglightsampleswillactlikeamultiplieronthenumberofdirectraysinyourscenesoitisnotagoodideatosimplyincreasesamplestoextremelyhighvaluesforalllights.Also,increasingDirectrays(MinandMaxRaySamples)willalsohelpcleanupthistypeofnoise.Thismeansthatyoumustbalancetheneedtocleanupnoisefromaspecificlight,againstcleaningupDirectSourcesofnoisethroughoutyourimage.

Toidentifythistypeofnoise,enablethe“DirectDiffuse”imagelayer,thiswillallowyoutoexaminetheshadowscausedbydirectlightingwithoutinterferencefromindirectsourcesofshadow.

Intheaboveexample,identifyingwhichlightisresponsibleforthenoiseisdifficult,especiallysinceenvironmentlightshavetheeffectof“fillingin”shadows.Itcanbeusefulinthesecasestoexportthe“DirectDiffuse”layerusingthe“PerLight”option.Thiswillallowyouisolatethespecificlightsthatarecausingnoiseinyourscene,allowingyoutoincreasesamplingonlyontheoffendinglightsources.

H16MantraUserGuide

Intheexamplesabove,itismuchmoreobviouswhichlightiscausingthevarioustypesofnoise.Thisisespeciallyevidentontheedgesoftheshadowscastbythearealight.Inthiscase,youcanseethattheArealightrequiredfewersamplestoremovethenoisethantheEnvironmentlight.Incomplexscenes,thiskindofcloseexaminationofper-lightnoisecanhelppreventsignificantlyover-samplingyourscene.

H16MantraUserGuide

INDIRECTILLUMINATIONIndirectDiffuse

IndirectDiffuse,whichisthelightcontributionfromotherobjectsinascene,canbeasignificantsourceofnoise.Thiscanbeespeciallyevidentinsceneswithphysicallyaccuratelightsourceswhicharealsoverynearotherobjects(Lightsconcesorinsetlights,forinstance.)andonlycontributeasmallamounttodirectlighting.

Thebestwaytoremovethistypeofnoiseistoincreasethenumberofindirectsamplesthatarebeingsent.YoucanachievethisbyadjustingtheDiffuseQualityparameterontheMantranode.IncreasingPixelsampleswillalsohelpremovethenoise,butwillcauseanincreaseinallothertypesofrays,causingareasoftheimagewithoutnoisetobecomeover-sampled.

Toidentifythistypeofnoise,enablethe“IndirectDiffuse”imagelayer,thiswillallowyoutoexaminethelightcontributionstothislayerwithoutinterferencefromothertypesofnoise.

H16MantraUserGuide

Keepinmindthatyoudonothavetocompletelyremovenoisefromthiscomponenttohaveacleanimage,indirectnoiseisoftenimperceptiblewhenithasbeencombinedwithdirectlightinginformation.AlwaysrefertotheCombinedColorimageplanetoseehowyoursamplingisaffectingthefidelityofthefinalimage.

IndirectReflections

IndirectReflections,whicharethereflectionsofotherobjects,canberesponsibleformuchofthenoiseinyourscene.Thiscanbeparticularlyevidentinsceneswithverybrightglossyreflectionsincombinationwithotherobjectswithroughreflections.

Thebestwaytoremovethistypeofnoiseistoincreasethenumberofindirectsamplesthatarebeingsent.YoucanachievethisbyadjustingtheReflectionQualityparameterontheMantranode.IncreasingPixelsampleswillalsohelpremovethenoise,butwillcauseanincreaseinallothertypesofrays,causingareasoftheimagewithoutnoisetobecomeover-sampled.

Toidentifythistypeofnoise,enablethe“IndirectReflect”imagelayer,thiswillallowyoutoexaminetheamountofnoisecausedbyindirectreflectionswithoutinterferencefromothertypesofnoise.

H16MantraUserGuide

Keepinmindthatyoudonothavetocompletelyremovenoisefromthiscomponenttohaveacleanimage,indirectnoiseisoftenimperceptiblewhenithasbeencombinedwithdirectlightinginformation.However,unlikeindirectdiffusenoise,indirectreflectionscanberesponsibleformostofthecolorofafinalpixel.(Anobjectwithamirror-likefinish,forexample)AlwaysrefertotheCombinedColorimageplanetoseehowyoursamplingisaffectingthefidelityofthefinalimage.

IndirectRefractions

IndirectRefractions,whicharetherefractionsofotherobjectsandsurfacesinyourscene,canbesignificantsourcesofnoiseinyourscene.Thisisespeciallytruewhenrenderingrefractiveobjectswithahighroughnessvalue.

Thebestwaytoremovethistypeofnoiseistoincreasethenumberofindirectsamplesthatarebeingsent.YoucanachievethisbyadjustingtheRefractionQualityparameterontheMantranode.IncreasingPixelsampleswillalsohelpremovethenoise,butwillcauseanincreaseinallothertypesofrays,causingareasoftheimagewithoutnoisetobecomeover-sampled.

Toidentifythistypeofnoise,enablethe“IndirectRefract”imagelayer,thiswillallowyoutoexaminetheamountofnoisecausedbyindirectrefractionswithoutinterferencefromothertypesofnoise.

H16MantraUserGuide

Keepinmindthatyoudonothavetocompletelyremovenoisefromthiscomponenttohaveacleanimage,indirectnoiseisoftenimperceptiblewhenithasbeencombinedwithdirectlightinginformation.However,unlikeindirectdiffusenoise,indirectrefractionscanberesponsibleformostofthecolorofafinalpixel.(Aglassofwater,forinstance.)AlwaysrefertotheCombinedColorimageplanetoseehowyoursamplingisaffectingthefidelityofthefinalimage.

SubsurfaceScattering

SubsurfaceScatteringreferstoatypeofindirectlightcausedbylightscatteringinsidethesurfaceofanobjectbeforeexiting.Typically,thiseffectisseeninmaterialslikecandlewaxorhumanskin.ObjectswithSubSurfaceScatteringenabledcancontributeasignificantamountofnoiseinyourscene.

Toremovethistypeofnoise,increasetheSSSQualityparameterontheMantranode.IncreasingPixelsampleswillalsohelpremovethenoise,butwillcauseanincreaseinallothertypesofrays,causingareasoftheimagewithoutnoisetobecomeover-sampled.

Toidentifythistypeofnoise,enablethe“IndirectSSS”imagelayer,thiswillallowyoutoexaminetheamountofnoisecausedbyindirectreflectionswithoutinterferencefromothertypesofnoise

H16MantraUserGuide

Keepinmindthatyoudonothavetocompletelyremovenoisefromthiscomponenttohaveacleanimage,SSSnoiseisoftenimperceptiblewhencombinedwithotherlightingcomponents.However,insomematerialstheSSScomponentmayberesponsibleformuchofthefinalpixelcolor,inthosecasesasignificantincreaseinthenumberofrayssentmaybenecessary.Additionally,becauseSubsurfaceScatteringishighlydependingontheviewingangle,itmaybeagoodideatotestyoursamplingsettingsacrossmultipleframesifyourcameraorobjectisanimated.AlwaysrefertotheCombinedColorimageplanetoseehowyoursamplingisaffectingthefidelityofthefinalimage.

VOLUMES

Volumesrequireadifferentsamplingstrategythansurfaces,rays“march”througheachobjectandaccumulatevaluesacrossmultipledepthsamples.Thisaddedcomplexitycanmakerenderingvolumescostly.Likesurfaces,itisbesttoapproachtheremovalofnoiseinaseriesofstagesbasedonthetypeofnoisepresent.DirectVolumesDirectVolumetriclighting,referstovolumesthathavereceivetheirlightingonlydirectlyfromlightsources.

Whenrenderingvolumes,therecanbemorethanonetypeofnoisepresentpercomponent-noisefromunder-samplingthetransparentpartsofanobjectandnoisefromunder-samplingthelights.

Tobegin,increasingStochasticSampleswilldramaticallyreducenoisewithoutcausingalargeincreaseinrendertimes.Thiswillbemostnotableinsemi-transparentareas,usuallyinthesoftedgesofthevolumetricobject.Atsomepoint,increasingStochasticSampleswillnolongerhaveasignificanteffectonnoise.Ifthisoccurs,andnoiseremainsinthiscomponent,beginincreasingMaxRaySamplesslowlyuntiltheremainingnoiseisremoved.

H16MantraUserGuide

Toidentifythesetypesofnoise,enablethe“DirectVolume”imagelayer,thiswillallowyoutoexaminetheamountofnoiseinthiscomponentwithoutinterferencefromtypesofnoise.

Aswithallnoisetypes,increasingPixelsampleswillhelpreducethistypeofnoise.Thiscanbeparticularlyexpensivewhenrenderingvolumes,soitisbesttoavoidthisifpossible.However,thedefaultsettingof3x3pixelsamplesisoftenagoodstartingplace.

Ifyouplantocompositeyourvolumetricimageswithaseparatebackgroundimage,besuretooccasionallycheckthenoiselevelsaftercompositing.Noisethatisevidentagainstablackbackgroundmaybeinvisibleonyourfinalplate.Theoppositecanalsobetrue,wherenoiseisinvisibleagainstablackbackground,butbecomesobviouswhenthealphachanneloftheimageistakenintoaccount.Asmuchaspossible,refertotheCombinedColorchannel(orthecompositedfinalframe)toverifyhowyoursamplingisaffectingthefidelityofyourimage.

IndirectVolumetricLightingIndirectVolumetricLighting,whichinvolvesvolumeswhichreceivelightfromindirectsourcessuchasotherobjectsorthroughthescatteringoflightwithinthevolumeitself,cancreatesignificantamountsofnoiseinyourrenders.Indirectvolumetricnoiseismostoftennoticeableintheshadowedareasofvolumetricobjects.

H16MantraUserGuide

AswithDirectVolumenoise,beginbyremovingthenoisecausedbyunder-samplingtheopacityofyourvolumebyincreasingStochasticSamples.However,ifyou’vealreadyremovedthistypeofnoisefromyourdirectvolumecomponent,youmayfindthatincreasingthevalueofthisparameterhaslittleeffectsincetransparentsamplesaresharedbetweenthesecomponents.

Theremainingnoiseislikelyduetounder-samplingtheindirectsourcesoflightinyourscene.Toremovethisnoisetype,slowlyincreasetheMaxRaySamplesparameteruntilthenoiseisresolved.LikeStochasticsampling,thisparameterissharedwiththedirectvolumecomponent.However,becauseindirectsamplingofvolumescanbeespeciallynoisy,itislikelyyouwillneedtoincreasethemaxraysamplesfurthertoremovenoisefromthiscomponent.

Toidentifythistypeofnoise,enablethe“IndirectVolume”imagelayer,thiswillallowyoutoexaminetheamountofnoisecausedbyindirectvolumetriclightingwithoutinterferencefromtypesofnoise.

Keepinmindthatyoudonothavetocompletelyremovenoisefromthiscomponenttohaveacleanimage,oftenindirectnoiseisinvisiblewhenithasbeencombinedwithdirectlightinginformation.AlwaysrefertotheCombinedColorimageplanetoseehowyoursamplingisaffectingthefidelityofthefinalimage.

VolumeQualityUnliketheother“Quality”parametersontheSamplingTaboftheMantraNode,VolumeQualitydoesnotrefertotheamountofindirectsampling.Instead,itexplicitlyreferstothenumberofvoxelswhichareconsideredforsampling.(See“TheSamplingtab”formoreinformationonthisparameter)

Ingeneral,itwillbeunnecessarytochangethisparametersolongasStochasticTransparencyinenabled.However,itispossiblethatsmalldetailswillbemissedwhenthisVolumeQualityissettoolow.

H16MantraUserGuide

Ifyoufeelthatthereismoreinformationinthevolumethanappearsintherender,considerincreasingthisvalue.

WhenStochasticTransparencyisdisabled,thisparameterdirectlycontrolstheamountofsamplinginthevolumeandwillhaveadramaticeffectonrendertimes.

FINALIMAGEHereisaversionofthecompletescenewiththerenderingsettingsrequiredtogenerateacleanimage.

SPECIALCASESInsomecases,theremaybespecificobjectsinyourscenethatareespeciallynoisyincomparisontootherobjects.Youmayfindthattogetenoughsamplesontotheseobjectsyouwillendupover-samplingtherestofyourscene.Thiscanoccurinmanydifferentcircumstances,butacommoncausewouldbearefractiveorreflectiveshaderwithhighroughnessvalues.

H16MantraUserGuide

Toavoidthisover-samplingproblem,youcanaddthesamplingpropertiesontotheobjectitself.Thiswillmeanthatonlytheproblem-casewillreceivemoresamples.Toachievethis,gotoanobjectandselectthe“EditRenderingParameters”optioninthegearicon.

Under“RenderProperties”,navigatetotheMantra/Samplingfolder(OrusetheFilterFieldtonarrowyoursearch).Addthefollowingpropertiestoyourobject:–

DiffuseQuality

ReflectionQuality

RefractionQuality

SSSQuality

MaxRaySamples

MinRaySamples

NoiseLevel

ThesepropertieswillgiveyouthesamecontroloversamplingthatyouhaveontheMantranode,butisolatedtothisspecificobject.NotethatPixelSamplescannotbealteredperobject,itisaglobalsetting.

H16MantraUserGuide

ThesphereontherighthashadtheSamplingparametersaddedandthevaluesadjustedtoremoveanynoise.TherestoftheobjectsinthesceneusethesamplingvaluessetontheMantranode.(Forthepurposesofthisexample,NoiseLevel:0.01,MinRays1,MaxRays2).

Youcanseethatmantrasamplestheobjectsinthescenesatdifferentrates,allowingyoutooptimizetherenderingofspecificobjectsinyourscenewithoutnegativelyaffectingtheoverallsamplingofyourimage.