Gujarat Emergency Earthquake Reconstruction Project
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT World Bank
JANUARY – MARCH 2006
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY GOVERNMENT OF GUJARAT
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN - MAR 2004: PART A
Part A
Project Summary
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 2
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 1
CONTENTS
1 INTRODUCTION.................................................................... 2
2 KEY DATES............................................................................... 2
3 COMPONENT COSTS........................................................... 2
4 HIGHLIGHTS OF THE QUARTER.................................... 3
5 GEERP DEVELOPMENT OBJECTIVES............................ 4
6 SAFEGUARDS ......................................................................... 5
7 PROCUREMENT PERFORMANCE................................... 6
8 FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE ............................................ 7
8.1 FUND FLOWS ........................................................................7 8.2 EXPENDITURE .......................................................................7 8.3 CREDIT-WISE CLAIMS ......................................................... 8
9 STATUS OF PROGRESS....................................................... 9
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
1 Introduction
This document presents the Quarterly Progress for the period January – March 2006 for the World Bank assisted Gujarat Emergency Earthquake Rehabilitation Program (GEERP)- Phase II. The phase I program at a cost of US $ 257.90 mn has been fully completed and the Phase II program is currently under progress. Subsequent to the World Bank Mid–Term Review mission in November 2003, a revised Project Implementation Plan (PIP-R) was prepared. The estimated project costs, targets the monitorable indicators are based on the revised PIP of Phase II. This document is divided into three sections; Part A - Project summary; Part B - Sector-wise progress in detail and Part C - Annexures.
2 Key Dates
The GERRP program is currently structured into two phases. Key dates for the same are presented below:
Phase Effectiveness Date
Closing Date Extension Loan Amount
Phase I 31-Mar. 2001 30- Sept. 2002
31-Mar. 2003 (only for Housing component)
US $ 257.9mn
Phase II 15-Jul. 2002 31-Oct. 2007 US $ 442.8mn * * Equivalent to 356 Mn. SDR at the time of signing of agreement.
The monitorable indicators for Phase-II are presented in Annexure – 1.
3 Component Costs
Estimated project costs-Phase II
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 2
6345.57749.37
1765.80377.96343.41
728.262024.543731.802266.90
350.002400.00
21333.61
250.00Project ManagementDMCB
Community ParticipationDam Safety and Irrigation
Roads and BridgesRetrofitting
Other BuildingsPolice Housing
PanchayatState R & B
EducationHousing
Total
Rs. In million
* Inclusive of GoG counter funding.
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
4 Highlights of the Quarter
• GSDMA launched a massive Kite festival Campaign to create awareness amongst the community on safety and precautions to be adopted during the Uttrayan festival. Five radio spots and two television spots were prepared and broadcasted through Doordarshan/AIR (seven stations)/Radio Mirchi to reach the masses in the state of Gujarat.
• A composite ‘Gujarat Hazard Risk and Vulnerability Atlas’ covering five natural and man made disaster was released on 6 february ‘06 by Hon. Chief Minister of Gujarat.
• Government of Gujarat has passed The Gujarat Professional Civil Engineer’s Bill, 2006 in the concluded legislative assembly session. The bill will ensure that only qualified/competent structural engineers are in the profession of designing structures.
• GSDMA has prepared ‘Gujarat Tsunami Management Plan’. The plan will help to prevent and mitigate the effect of Tsunami and to respond effectively in case of disaster. Plan covers various aspects like Tsunami risk and vulnerability assessment, plan for risk reduction and mitigation of Tsunami, Plan for Tsunami preparedness, plan for emergency response in Tsunami and plan for Tsunami relief and recovery.
• GSDMA has prepared and published ‘Gujarat Safety Planning Guidelines for Event Management’. Guidelines takes into account all aspects of planning right from venue selection, approval from authorities, role of police, fire and rescue personnel and also preparation of response plan. Guidelines also include checklist, which will help the organizers to quickly conduct an assessment of safety.
• A book titled “Teachers Experiences of Gujarat Earthquake 2001” was prepared and released by GSDMA.
• A team of Russian Scientists visited Gujarat Earthquake Research Institute (GERI) for installation of a network of seismological equipments from January 29th to February 11th ‘06. The network has been installed and is under testing phase.
• Delegation from Afghanistan and Bhutan visited GSDMA in the month of Feb ’06 to learn from experiences of GEERP by GSDMA.
• Delegation from Jammu and Kashmir visited GSDMA on January 19th ,2006 to learn from implementation experiences of GEERP by GSDMA
• In 69 schools one day training program has been organized in Ahmedabad as a part of Gujarat School Safety Initiatives.
• IEC materials comprising 9,000 task force badges ( 6 types such as first aid, awareness etc) 3,00,000 family and class room hazard checklists and 2,000 project fliers were printed and distributed in schools as part of the Gujarat School Safety Initiative
• Two day training on Agricultural Issues of Natural and Biological Disasters and their management was organised by GIDM for the officials from agricultural department and was attended by 18 officials.
• So far 145 masons were certified through mason’s certification program by Gujarat Council for Vocational Training (GCVT)
• 7 minute documentary film in Gujarati on ‘Disaster Preparedness for Earthquake’ have been prepared for children in association with NGO, Save the children.
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 3
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 4
5 GEERP Development Objectives
The GEERP Development Objectives are to
a) Promote sustainable recovery in the disaster-affected areas; and b) Lay the foundations for sustainable disaster management capacity in Gujarat
The following development outcomes are likely to be achieved in this project:
• Vulnerability reduction through infrastructure built to disaster-resistant standards
• Increased risk awareness and preparedness of communities to natural hazards, through access to more sustainable incomes and enhanced knowledge of hazards and disaster reduction techniques
• Enhanced emergency preparedness and response capacity of responsible entities
GSDMA as the executing agency for the program believes that these objectives will be achieved through various activities and actions initiated by GoG:
a) Promote sustainable recovery in the disaster-affected areas; • Earthquake-affected houses and public buildings are being built, retrofitted,
repaired and strengthened using earthquake-resistant technology. – Over 9.11 lac houses repaired and over 2.01 lac houses have been reconstructed to hazard
resistant construction till date. – Appointment of over 1600 trained engineers to ensure implementation of earthquake
resistant features. – Establishment of a technical audit and quality assurance mechanism in the form of third
party consultant for housing and public infrastructure. 2,78,827 visits have been made to audit most of the reconstructed houses for multi-hazard resistant construction.
– Training of over 29,000 masons & 6,200 engineers for providing technical support in multi-hazard resistant construction.
• Public infrastructure is being restored after incorporating disaster resistant features. – Designing and constructing new infrastructure facilities based on latest technologies – Strengthening existing public infrastructure to incorporate disaster resistant features – Retrofitting of undamaged public buildings are taken up based on hazard resistant
technology.
• Restoration of livelihood. – Restoration of livelihood of over 70000 artisans, 183793 farming units, 18284 industrial
units, 13373 women – Assistance rendered to widows, orphans, and old persons.
b) Lay the foundation for sustainable disaster management capacity in Gujarat • Improving disaster preparedness and emergency response capacity of the
Government – Enactment of Gujarat State Disaster Management Act’ 2003 & formulation of Disaster
Management policy – Preparation of State, District and/Taluka level Disaster Management plans. District level
disaster management plan along with a comprehensive database has been prepared and reviewed for all 25 districts.
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 5
– Building a repository of knowledge on various aspects of disaster management. Profiles of 11,354 villages have been entered in IDRN (Integrated Disaster Resource Network). Profiles of 18,327 villages have been entered in SDRN (State Disaster Resource Network).
– Establishment of emergency response centers in Ahmedabad, Surat, Rajkot, Bhuj and Baroda planned. The study had commenced in October 2003 and final report has been submitted in March 2005.
– Gujarat Institute of Disaster Management and Institute of Seismological Research have been established.
– Provision of emergency preparedness & response equipments for 100 municipalities. Emergency equipments have been handed over to the Municipal Corporations of Ahmedabad, Rajkot and Surat. Search and rescue equipments are to be provided to Vadodara and Jamnagar Municipal Corporation.
• Reduction of vulnerability through long-term mitigation programs – Initiative for compulsory insurance of reconstructed houses. Insurance drive for all
reconstructed houses (G5) i.e. over 2.10 lacs has been initiated. – Streamlining the issues of building permissions and codes. GDCR has been revised, IS
codes has been made mandatory. – Certification of masons and licensing of engineers. Gujarat Professional Civil Engineers
Bill, 2006 has been passed in the concluded legislative assembly session. Competency based certification of masons program has been launched and till date 145 masons have been certified.
– Revision of syllabus of polytechnic and technical colleges to include seismic engineering, 120 faculty members has been trained thus far on the revised syllabus.
– Syllabus of class eight has been revised to include concepts of disaster management – Up gradation of Seismological Network. Procurement of instruments has been initiated
through GERI. Total of 22 observatories and 40 SMAs will be established /upgraded. – Transfer of knowledge on disaster preparedness and mitigation to the public at large to
enable them to respond to disasters at the community level through various IEC campaigns.
– Community based Disaster Risk Management program with UNDP has been launched for awareness, capacity-building activities. Orientation training programs for Government officials in district and talukas, preparation of information materials, organizing participatory activities, training of doctors, paramedics, training in search and rescue operations and early warning and communication systems are being carried out under this program.
– Formation of Disaster Management Committees and Disaster Management Teams in all the villages of the State.
– Mandatory inclusion of DM program as an agenda in all the Gram Sabhas held periodically in all the 18000 villages of the state.
6 Safeguards
The detailed report on social and environmental measures taken up by various implementing agencies will be submitted as a separate report.
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 6
7 Procurement Performance
The summary of the status of contracts of repair and reconstruction under various components has been presented below. Table 3 Details of Procurement of Works
Public Buildings Tech.Edu.
State R & B Panchayat Home Dept. Roads & Bridges Dams
& Irrig. Prim. Edu Description
Major Repairs
Reconstruction
Retroffiting (Damaged)
Retroffiting (Undamaged)
Reconstruction
Retrofitting (Undamaged) Repair Reconst
ruction
Repairs / Reconstruction of Bridges
Strengthening of Roads
Reconstruction
Reconstruction Repair Reconst
ruction
A) Total Packages Total packages 64 58 11 100 46 20 30 15 7 15 95 6 8 3 No. of Buildings / dams /road length 1102 703 232 4042 745 530 2195 562 129 815.83
kms 222 6 64 31
Estimated cost of packages (Rs. In million) 308.34 986.68 31.22 2015.57 358.34 232.63 91.95 248.13 471.61 2851.84 2288.84 7.8 128.50 392.70
B) Packages Signed Contracts signed to date 64 58 11 45 46 14 30 15 7 15 93 6 8 3 No. of Buildings / dams /road length 1102 703 232 1685 745 372 2195 562 129 815.83
kms 220 6 64 31
Value of contracts signed to date (Rs. In million) 273.20 860.33 31.22 848.24 378.03 160.51 78.68 210.16 421.10 2076.74 1749.17 6.2 122.03 254.89
C) Prior review contracts Total No. of prior review contracts 2 12 - 1 8 - - 2 7 15 24 - - 1
Contract Value cost (Rs. In million) 106.90 381.60 - 23.62 193.78 - - 73.72 421.10 2745.77 1165.54 - - 204.60
No. of contracts signed 1 12 - 0 8 - - 2 7 15 22 - - 1 Note: For details refer Part-B
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
8 Financial Performance
8.1 Fund Flows Table 4 Phase II- Financial Details as on 31.03.06 (Rs. In Mn.)
Particulars Current quarter Cumulative Project Expenditure (Gross) 529.27 11,975.60 Claims submitted (eligible amount) 321.39 9,951.53 Amount released by GOI to GOG 491.04 9,839.82 GOG transfer to GSDMA 819.71* 9,835.30 Balance to be received (328.66) 4.53 Note: GoG transferd to GSDMA Rs. 328.66 Mn which was receivable on 31/12/2005
8.2 Expenditure The details of the application of funds sector wise & category wise for Phase II is presented through table 5 to 7.
Table 5 Phase II-Category wise application of Funds as on 31.03.06 (Rs. In Mn)
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 7
Actual Eligible Category % Current Quarter Cumulative To – Date
Works 90 474.22 11,432.06Goods 100 12.05 59.78Consultancy 80 29.50 243.39Training 100 3.72 46.61Incremental Cost -- 9.76 193.75Total Project expenditure 529.27 11,975.60
Table 6 Phase II- Sector wise & category wise application of funds for the quarter &
Cumulative as on 31.03.06 (Rs. In Mn.) Sector Works Goods Consult Training Op. costs Total To date
Housing 32.77 0.02 0.00 0.00 0.65 33.44 5,614.20
Education 82.34 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.01 82.36 381.08
Dam Safety & Irrigation 159.63 0.00 15.22 0.00 0.15 175.00 1,451.08
State R&B 43.03 2.31 0.52 0.00 0.64 46.50 1,043.09
Panchayat R & B 0.34 (0.16) 0.63 0.00 0.39 1.20 343.85
Retrofitting 69.47 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 69.47 205.16
Police Housing 36.47 0.00 1.13 0.00 0.00 37.61 268.36
Other Buildings 2.87 0.00 0.24 0.00 0.00 3.11 73.02
State Highways & Bridges 47.31 0.00 0.45 0.00 0.26 48.02 2,335.09
Community Participation 0.00 0.00 0.00 3.02 0.00 3.02 38.42
DMCB 0.00 9.26 8.73 0.70 0.05 18.74 126.54
Project Management 0.00 0.62 2.58 0.00 7.61 10.80 95.71
Total Project Expenditure 474.22 12.05 29.50 3.72 9.76 529.27 11,975.59
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 8
Table 7 Phase II- Sector wise details of Expenditure (Planned versus Actuals)
For the quarter ending 31.03.06 (Rs. In Mn.) Sector Planned* Actual Variance
Housing 262.80 33.44 (229.36) Education 75.00 82.36 7.36 Dam Safety & Irrigation 114.00 175.00 61.00 State R&B 54.32 46.50 (7.82) Panchayat R & B 0.00 1.20 1.20 Retrofitting 315.00 69.47 (245.53) Police Housing 29.69 37.61 7.92 Other Buildings (AMC, JMC, GIDM, ISR ) 15.56 3.11 (12.45) State Highways & Bridges 280.76 48.02 (232.74) Community Participation Support 11.27 3.02 (8.25) Disaster Management Capacity Building 338.25 18.74 (319.51) Project Management 15.00 10.80 (4.20) Total Project Expenditure 1,511.64 529.27 (982.38)
* Planned figures are as per the revised projections submitted to The World Bank for loan period extension
8.3 Credit-wise Claims The summary of claims for Phase II is presented below. Table 8 Phase II- Category wise Credit Claims (Rs. In Mn.)
Civil Works Goods Consult. Op. Costs Total
Housing 4,792.85 0.00 0.00 56.04 4,848.89 Education 231.44 0.00 0.00 0.03 231.47 Dam safety & Irrigation 1,092.05 0.00 26.20 1.16 1,119.41 Public Buildings 1,529.63 0.00 51.52 0.43 1,581.59 State Highways 1,990.35 0.00 22.04 5.79 2,018.18 Community Participation 0.00 17.60 0.00 3.08 20.68 Project Management 0.00 0.04 27.22 16.35 43.61 DMCB 0.00 57.38 24.72 5.61 87.71 Total 9,636.32 75.02 151.70 88.49 9,951.53
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 9
9 Status of Progress
Table 9 Status of Phase-II work in GEERP as on 31.03.2006 Components/subcompone
nts Physical Achievement Expenditure* (Rs. million)
Housing Component Repair 53,734 houses Reconstruction 1,42,102 houses
5,614.20
Education MDM sheds and TTI’s 6 TTI & 448 MDM sheds reconstructed and all 13 sheds
repaired Municipal Schools All 1567 classrooms repaired and reconstruction of 152
classrooms completed. Technical institutions Major repairs for 57 structures have been completed and
are in progress for 7 structures. In the reconstruction, work is in progress on all 31 structures
381.08
Dam Safety and Irrigation Reconstruction /strengthening of dams
Work awarded for 220 dams. Works completed for 166 nos. dams and is in progress for 54 dams. 1,451.08
Public buildings State Public buildings Major repairs including retrofitting and consultancy
completed for 1099 buildings and is in progress for 1 building. Reconstruction of 691 buildings completed and is in progress for 4 nos. buildings Retrofitting for 232 damaged buildings completed
Panchayat Reconstruction of all 719 buildings is completed Retrofitting (undamaged buildings)
State R&B Total of 4042 buildings are to be taken up for retrofitting (1757 R&B buildings & 2285 Health & Education buildings). Work under progress on 1685 Bldgs. Panchayat R&B 20 packages (530 structures) formulated and bids invited for 20 packages out of which 14 packages have been awarded. Work under progress on 117 bldgs.
Police Housing Major repairs of 2195 buildings completed. Reconstruction of 427 buildings is completed & 135 buildings in progress
1,933.48
Roads and Bridges Repair and Reconstruction of 102 bridges completed. Strengthening of 751.88 Kms of road completed and 63.95 km of road works in progress. 2,335.09
Capacity Building and Community Organization Various activities 38.42
Disaster Management Various activities 126.54
Project Management Various activities 95.71
Grand Total 11,975.59
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
Part B
Detailed Progress Report
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 10
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
CONTENTS
1. Housing.............................................................................................1.1 Introduction....................................................................................1.2 Overall Progress .............................................................................1.2 Phase-II Progress (World Bank Funded Houses) ...........................1.3 Progress in Reconstruction in 4 Towns of Kutch............................1.5 Disbursement Details ...................................................................11.7 Quality Audit ...............................................................................11.8 Public Private Partnership Program.............................................12. Public Infrastructure....................................................................12.1 Primary Education .......................................................................12.2 Technical Education .....................................................................12.3 Urban Schools & Corporation Schools .........................................12.4 Public Buildings - State R & B.......................................................12.6 Public Buildings - Panchayat........................................................12.7 Public Buildings - Home Department ..........................................12.8 Public Buildings – Other buildings ..............................................12.9 ISR and GIDM..............................................................................12.10 Retrofitting (Undamaged buildings in the vulnerable areas).......22.11 Roads and Bridges.......................................................................22.12 Dams & Irrigation.........................................................................23. Community Participation...........................................................23.1 Activities undertaken during this quarter....................................24. Disaster Management Capacity Building..............................24.1 Activities undertaken in this quarter............................................2
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 11
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 12
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
1. Housing
1.1 Introduction
The January 26 earthquake most seriously affected the housing sector. The World Bank funding for the repair and reconstruction component covers only the eligible cases under G2, G3, G4 and G5 categories. The category wise details of houses eligible for financial assistance under the World Bank funding are given below.
Table1: Damaged and Destroyed Houses G1 G2 G3 G4 G5 Total
Total Houses Damaged/destroyed 414638 259289 145694 105724 209915 1135260
Houses planned under WB funding - 181010 140175 100331 167387 588903
Houses planned under Other funding 414638 78279 5519 5393 42528 546357
1.2 Overall Progress The summary of housing progress under the World Bank funding is presented below.
Table 2: overview of housing progress under the World Bank funding Phase I Phase II
Physical Financial Planned Disbursed Cases Category
Actual Actual Planned Actual G2 Total 181010 Urban 29400 Rural 151610
943.39
(G3+G4) Total 183787 56719 53734 Urban 21728 17484 17484 Rural 162059
3074.47 39235 36250
G5 Total 16529 150858 142420 Urban 136 27399 22036 Rural 16393
7425.42 123459 120384
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
Table 3: Overview of the Housing Component including other sources of funding
Housing Beneficiaries Progress Achieved with World Bank funding Other than Bank funding Category
Total Bank funding Others
Completed and fully
paid
Completed but final
payment due
2nd installment received but
not completed
1st installment received but progress not adequate for 2nd
installment
1st installment received but not started
Completed In Progress Not Started
Urban 124690 0 124690 0 0 0 0 0 124690 0 0 Rural 289948 0 289948 0 0 0 0 0 285455 0 0
G1
Total 414638 0 414638 0 0 0 0 0 410145 0 0 Urban 47631 29400 18231 29400 0 0 0 0 17841 390 0 Rural 211658 151610 60048 151610 0 0 0 0 57428 2620 0
G2
Total 259289 181010 78279 181010 0 0 0 0 75269 3010 0 Urban 26728 25679 1049 25679 0 0 0 0 873 176 0 Rural 118966 114496 4470 114172 0 0 324 0 2680 1790 0
G3
Total 145694 140175 5519 139851 0 0 324 0 3553 1966 0 Urban 13947 13533 414 13533 0 0 0 0 306 108 0 Rural 91777 86798 4979 84137 0 0 2661 0 3530 1449 0
G4
Total 105724 100331 5393 97670 0 0 2661 0 3836 1557 0 Urban 27924 27535 389 22172 0 546 384 4433 389 0 0 Rural 181991 139852 42139 136777 0 1614 1461 0 42139 0 0
G5
Total 209915 167387 42528 158949 0 2160 1845 4433 42528 0 0
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 13
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
1.2 Phase-II Progress (World Bank Funded Houses)
The physical progress of the World Bank funded houses in Phase II is presented in table below.
Table 4: physical progresses for Bank Financed Phase II
Progress Achieved with World Bank funding Category Housing
Beneficiaries Bank funding Completed and fully
paid Completed but final
payment due 2nd installment received
but not completed
1st installment received but progress not adequate for 2nd
installment
1st installment receivedbut not started
Urban 9773 9773 0 0 0 0Rural 10354 10030 0 0 0 324
G3
Total 20127 19803 0 0 324Urban 7711 7711 0 0 0 0Rural 28881 26220 0 0 0 2661
G4
Total 36592 33931 0 0 2661Urban 27399 22036 0 546 384 4433Rural 123459 120384 0 1614 1461 0
G5
Total 150858 142420 0 2160 1845 4433
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 14
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 15
1.3 Progress in Reconstruction in 4 Towns of Kutch
Table 5: Progress in reconstruction in 4 towns of Kutch
Housing Beneficiaries Progress Achieved with World Bank funding Other than Bank funding Category
Total Bank funding Others Completed and
fully paid
Completed but final
payment due
2nd installment received but
not completed
1st installment received but progress not adequate for 2nd
installment
1st installment received but not started
Completed In Progress
Not Started
TP 4542 4542 0 3105 0 49 59 1329 0 0 0 NTP 1860 1860 0 1374 0 5 52 429 0 0 0
Bhuj*
Total 6402 6402 0 4479 0 54 111 1758 0 0 0 TP 1221 1221 0 832 35 101 32 221 0 0 0
NTP 4599 4599 0 2914 188 510 172 815 0 0 0 Bhachau
Total 5820 5820 0 3746 223 611 204 1036 0 0 0 TP 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
NTP 1501 1501 0 990 0 193 300 18 0 0 0 Rapar
Total 1501 1501 0 990 0 193 300 18 0 0 0 TP 740 740 0 543 30 28 9 130 0 0 0
NTP 1031 1031 0 711 34 71 6 210 0 0 0 Anjar
Total 1771 1771 0 1254 64 99 14 340 0 0 0 * Earlier 6366 beneficiaries were considered under G5 category in Bhuj. However, of these 12 cases have been shifted to repair category and 48 cases from repair category have been considered under reconstruction category, resulting into increase of beneficiaries to 6402 cases.
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
Table 6 : Status of Reconstruction in TP and non-TP areas
Area Total Houses
Nos. of houses to be relocated
Nos. of houses to be constructed insitu
Rejected Cases
Non-starter Cases
TOWN PLANNING AREA Anjar 1143 403 740 0 0 Bhachau 1221 328 893 0 0 Rapar 0 0 0 0 0 Bhuj 4505 1708 1342 581 748 NON TOWN PLANNING AREA Anjar 628 0 628 0 0 Bhachau 4599 170 4479 0 0 Rapar 2411 300 2111 0 0 Bhuj 1861 1195 167 22 407
Table 7 : Status of Plot Allocation Plot Allocation applications (units) Town
Received Rejected Sanctioned Handed over
TOWN PLANNING AREA Anjar 1932 3 1929 1929 Bhachau 1496 0 1496 1397 Rapar 0 0 0 0 Bhuj 0 0 0 0 TOTAL 3428 3 3425 3326 NON-TOWN PLANNING AREA Anjar 801 1 800 800 Bhachau 0 0 0 0 Rapar 0 0 0 0 Bhuj 0 0 0 0 TOTAL 801 1 800 800 RELOCATION SITES Anjar 169 53 115 115 Bhachau 372 0 1868 1769 Rapar 61 0 61 87 Bhuj
Rawalwadi 4118 2400 1718 1718 Mundra Road 1410 200 1210 1210
R.T.O 1191 214 977 977 Bhuj Subtotal 6719 2814 3905 3905 GRAND TOTAL 7321 2867 5949 5876
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 16
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
Table :8 Status of Building Permissions
Building Permissions applications (units)
Received Rejected Sanctioned Under Scrutiny Town Appl Unit Appl Units Appl. Units Appl. Units
TOWN PLANNING AREA Anjar 556 558 2 2 552 554 2 2 Bhachau 591 591 16 16 574 574 1 1 Rapar 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Bhuj 2213 2233 75 75 2046 2068 92 92 TOTAL 3360 3382 93 93 3172 3196 95 95 NON-TOWN PLANNING AREA Anjar 1001 1007 4 5 994 997 3 5 Bhachau 4508 5212 71 71 4448 4638 1 1 Rapar 865 954 87 87 741 867 48 48 Bhuj 2994 4590 133 133 2686 4282 175 175 TOTAL 9368 11763 295 296 8869 10784 227 229 RELOCATION SITES Anjar 2 115 0 0 2 115 0 0 Bhachau 8 377 0 0 8 377 0 0 Rapar 11 57 0 0 11 57 0 0 Bhuj
Rawalwadi 803 1479 3 3 790 1466 10 10 Mundra Road 699 990 7 7 688 979 4 4
R.T.O 626 667 1 1 624 665 1 1 Bhuj Subtotal 2128 3136 11 11 2102 3110 15 15 TOTAL GRAND TOTAL 2149 3685 11 11 2123 3659 15 15
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 17
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 18
Table :9 Physical Progress Of Houses
Permitted (units) Without permission (units) Town Completed In Progress Not started Completed In Progress
TOWN PLANNING AREA Anjar 398 331 201 10 0 Bhachau 867 133 221 0 0 Rapar 0 0 0 0 0 Bhuj 831 913 322 39 0 TOTAL 2096 1377 744 49 0 NON-TOWN PLANNING AREA Anjar 1115 1206 582 364 0 Bhachau 3182 602 815 0 0 Rapar 921 118 0 269 18 Bhuj 1753 1440 1089 41 0 TOTAL 6971 3366 2486 674 18 RELOCATION SITES Anjar 95 0 20 0 0 Bhachau 0 0 0 0 0 Rapar 40 1 0 0 0 Bhuj
Rawalwadi 1087 365 14 0 0 Mundra Road 645 332 2 0 0
R.T.O 506 157 2 0 0 Bhuj Subtotal 2238 854 18 0 0 GRAND TOTAL 2373 855 38 0 0
Table: 10 Category wise disbursement details of Bhuj Number of House holds benefitted Categor
y Eligible houses 1st installment 2nd installment 3rd installment
G1 1869 1869 0 0 G2 2073 2073 2067 0 G3 2838 2838 2802 0 G4 2022 2022 2022 0 G5 6402 5799 4533 4479
Total 15204 14601 11424 4479
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 19
Table : 11 Category wise disbursement details of Rapar
Number of House holds benefitted Category Eligible houses
1st installment 2nd installment 3rd installment
G1 99 99 0 0 G2 320 320 320 0 G3 540 540 540 0 G4 990 990 990 0 G5 1501 1501 1183 990
Total 3450 3450 3033 990
Table: 12 Category wise disbursement details of Bhachau
Number of House holds benefitted Category Eligible houses
1st installment 2nd installment 3rd installment
G1 0 0 0 0 G2 0 0 0 0 G3 80 80 80 0 G4 86 86 86 0 G5 5820 5820 4182 3571*
Total 5986 5986 4348 3571
Table: 13 Category wise disbursement details of Anjar
Number of House holds benefitted Category Eligible houses
1st installment 2nd installment 3rd installment G1 4451 4451 0 0 G2 1665 1665 1665 0 G3 1645 1645 1645 0 G4 699 699 699 0 G5 1771 1771 1387 1254
Total 10231 10231 5396 1254
1.5 Disbursement Details
The category wise disbursement details in the overall housing sector are presented below.
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 20
Table 14: Category-wise Disbursement Details Number of House holds benefited
Category Eligible Houses 1st installment 2nd installment 3rd installment
G1 414638 410145 0 0 G2 259289 258259 256279 0 G3 145694 144604 143404 0 G4 105724 104518 101506 0 G5 209915 209723 203124 201477
Total 1135260 1127249 704313 201477 In G5 Category, the physically completed houses where third installment is paid are 2,01,477. The delay in disbursing the second installment is due to the following reasons:
- Non starting of houses
- The house has not reached plinth/lintel level District-wise details of progress on the same are attached as Annexure 2. Some difference in figures reported by the districts and what was reported by the districts earlier has been noticed. GSDMA has started a reconciliation and verification program to cross check with the Districts and Talukas. The reconciliation work is in process in housing sector. The next quarterly report will provide the reconciled figures in each category and exact progress in each category.
1.7 Quality Audit
NCCBM has been appointed as a technical audit and quality assurance consultant for ensuring that the houses constructed meet the multi-hazard resistant reconstruction and repairs standards. Nearly 2,78,827 visits have been carried out for auditing of reconstructed houses till the month of February 2006. During the month of February, technical audit of 302 houses was carried out including repeat visits. Out of 83 new houses inspected, 100% houses come under conforming category.
1.8 Public Private Partnership Program
In addition to the World Bank funding, housing repair and reconstruction is being funded by several other agencies such as ADB, GOI, and NGOs apart from GOG. One such component is the public-private-partnership-program (PPPP) funded by ADB. This program covers reconstruction at relocated houses as well as in-situ reconstruction. Several NGOs, Private Business Houses and other state governments have adopted villages under Package 1 (Relocation) and Package 2 (In-Situ Reconstruction). The details of various packages are given below.
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 21
Table 15: Reconstruction under Public-Private Partnership
Package No. of Villages
Houses to be constructed
Houses completed
Houses under construction
Complete relocation at new site 24 5720 5720 0 Partial relocation at new site 37 10014 10014 0 Insitu rehabilitation 77 14396 14396 0 Insitu rehabilitation with no Govt. share
148 11772 11772 0
Total 286 41902 41902 0
2. Public Infrastructure
2.1 Primary Education
The World Bank funded component of Primary Education includes repairs of 13 Mid Day Meals (MDM) sheds, reconstruction of 448 Mid Day Meals (MDM) sheds and 6 Teacher Training Institutes (TTIs) in the affected districts of Ahmedabad, Patan, Surendranagar, Rajkot, Jamnagar, Bhavnagar, Junagadh and Porbander. State project office of the District primary education project (DPEP) is the implementing agency for this component.
Work of all the structures has been completed in December 2003. All the works for the MDM kitchen sheds were undertaken through the Village civil works committee (VCWC).
2.2 Technical Education
Phase II of this component includes Major repairs of 64 structures and reconstruction of 31 structures. While the Technical education department is the nodal agency, the state R&B department is the implementing agency for carrying out the repair and reconstruction work under this component.
Physical Progress The details of physical progress are presented below.
Physical Progress in Phase II
Component Target Completed WIP Yet to commence % comp.
Major Repairs ( 8 Packages ) 64 57 7 -- 89 Reconstruction ( 3 packages ) 31 -- 31 -- 0
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 22
Procurement Progress Status of contracts
(Rs. In million) Total contracts Contracts signed Sub-components
Packages Structures Est. Value Packages Structures Value Major Repairs 8 64 128.50 8 64 122.03 Reconstruction 3 31 392.70 3 31 254.89
2.3 Urban Schools & Corporation Schools
The primary schools damaged or destroyed in the municipal areas of Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation(AMC), Bhavnagar Municipal Corporation (BMC), municipalities of Surendranagar and Radhanpur and other urban towns in the districts of Amreli, Banaskantha, Patan, Rajkot, Surendranagar, Junagadh, and Porbander form part of this component. The main implementing agency for municipal schools in the urban towns is the office of the State Project Director, District Primary Education Programme (DPEP). The respective municipal corporations are implementing the repair and reconstruction of schools in Bhavnagar and Ahmedabad whereas in Radhanpur and Surendranagar respective municipalities are taking up repair and reconstruction in partnership with private agencies. Physical Progress The details of the physical progress in the Urban schools is presented below:
Physical Progress in Phase II (Classrooms)
Component Target Completed WIP Yet to commence
% comp. Remarks
Municipal Schools (DPEP) Classrooms/ Schools- Repairs
1155 /109
1155 /109
0 0 100
Reconstruction 28 28 0 0 100
All works were completed by Dec’03
AMC Schools Classrooms/ Schools- Repairs
104/54 104/54 0 0 100 All works were completed by Dec’03
BMC Schools Classrooms/ Schools- Repairs
308/42 308/42 0 0 100
Classrooms/ Schools- Reconst.
12/3 12/3 0 0 100
All works completed
Other Municipality Schools Classrooms/ Schools- Reconst. (Surendranagar)
62/5 62/5 0 0 100 All works completed
Classrooms/ Schools- Reconst. (Radhanpur )
50/3 50/3 0 0 100 All works completed
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 23
2.4 Public Buildings - State R & B
Under Phase-I, work of debris removal, setting up of 344 temporary office shelters, minor repairs for 1796 buildings and reconstruction of one building were taken up at a overall cost of Rs. 228.99 million. In Phase-II, major repairs of 1187 buildings and reconstruction of 814 buildings are being taken up. Out of the original target of 1187 structures in major repairs, and of 814 structures for reconstruction, 87 structures and 119 structures have been taken out of the World Bank funding respectively. The State R&B Department is the implementing agency for all the above works. Physical Progress The quarterly trends both in major repairs and reconstruction are presented in Exhibit 2.
Exhibit 2 Status of Repair and Reconstruction of State R & B Buildings
1100
1099
1099
1100
0
695
570
596 69
1
4
0
450
900
1350
Target Completed by Sept05
Completed by Dec05
Completed by Mar06
In Progress Mar 06
Major Repairs Reconstruction
The details of physical progress are presented below.
Physical Progress in Phase II
Component Target Completed WIP Yet to commence % comp
Major Repairs 327 327 0 0 100 Major Repair with Retrofitting 521 521 0 0 100 Major Repair with consultancy 34** 34 0 0 100 Major Repairs with Retrofitting and consultancy 218** 218 0 0 100
Total Repairs 1100** 1100 0 0 100
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 24
Reconstruction 695* 691 4 0 99 Retrofitting of damaged buildings 232 232 0 0 100
* Out of the original target of 814 structures , 111 structures of Package KCH/REC/12 & 18, 2 structures of KCH/REC/G-7, 2 structures of KCH/REC/G-22 (contract awarded but dropped due to legal problems) and 4 structures from GUIDE staff quarter in Kutch have been taken out of the World Bank funding. ** RJD/MRC/G-5 (Mani Mandir) , 2 structures in RJD/MRC/G-3 and NAV/MRC/R/G-1 (84 units of Vastrapur Colony) has been dropped from the World Bank funding.
Procurement Progress The status of contracts awarded under this component is presented in Table below. All contracts have been awarded.
Out of 64 contracts in major repairs, comprising of 1100 structures all 64 packages comprising of 1100 structures has been completed up to Mar ’06. Out of 58 contracts in reconstruction, comprising of 695 structures, 54 contracts comprising of 637 structures has been completed up to Mar ’06.
Status of contracts (Rs. In million)
Total contracts Contracts signed Sub-components Packages Structures Est. Value Packages Structures Value
Repairs 64 1100* 308.34 64 1100 273.20 Reconstructions 58 695** 986.68 58 695 860.33 Consultancy 13 4306 55.11 13 4306 55.11 Retrofitting of damaged buildings
11 232 31.22 11 232 31.22
* RJD/MRC/G-5 (Mani Mandir) , 2 structures in RJD/MRC/G-3 and NAV/MRC/R/G-1 (84 units of Vastrapur Colony) has been dropped from the World Bank funding ** Out of the original target of 814 structures , 111 structures of Package KCH/REC/12 & 18, 2 structures of KCH/REC/G-7, 2 structures of KCH/REC/G-22 (contract awarded but dropped due to legal problems) and 4 structures from GUIDE staff quarter in Kutch have been taken out of the World Bank funding
Progress against plans The status of progress of repair and reconstruction works against those planned till the end of this quarter is presented below.
Status of Progress (Rs. in million)
Planned as on Mar ‘06 Actual as on Mar ‘06 Completion (%) Activity Works Est. Value Works Value Works Value
Repairs 1100 1100 100 Reconstruction 695
1329.97 691
1042.10 99
78
* Original target of 1187 has been reduced by 87 structures to 1100 structures ** Original target of 814 has been reduced by 119 structures to 695 structures Note: Planned figures taken as per revised projections submitted to Bank for project extension
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 25
Quality Assurance M/s SMEC India Pvt Ltd. (Package I) has carried out 173 site visits auditing 2039 structures (392 packages) to date. Over 3772 non-conformances have been observed for which remedial measures were proposed. The department/ contractor have taken actions for over 3614 cases and for the remaining are under progress. M/s Dorsch Consult India Pvt. (Package II) has carried out 1185 site visits auditing 2250structures (450 packages) to date. Nearly 38 structures in 29 packages have been audited during this quarter ending Mar ‘06. Over 510 non-conformances have been observed for which remedial measures were proposed. The department/ contractor has taken actions for over 419 cases and for the rest is under consideration.
2.6 Public Buildings - Panchayat
This component provides for repairs and reconstruction of residential and non-residential Panchayat buildings (Panchayat Ghar, Taluka Panchayat, Jilla Panchayat Bhavan, staff quarters and Gram sevak Quarters etc ). Under the Phase I program, 963 buildings were taken up for minor repairs and were completed at a cost of Rs 25.65 million. Reconstruction of 26 buildings of the overall 838 buildings was also completed at an estimated cost of 34.95 million. Out of the remaining 812 buildings to be reconstructed, 52 buildings are being reconstructed by other sources and 41 buildings are dropped due to land problem. The Phase II program includes the reconstruction of the balance 719 buildings at an estimated cost of Rs. 371.62 million. The R&B Department (Panchayat) is the implementing agency for undertaking the above works. Physical Progress The quarterly trends in reconstuction are presented in Exhibit 3.
Exhibit 3 Reconstruction of Panchayat buildings in Phase II719 719 719 719
00
200
400
600
800
Target Completed by Sept 05 Completed by Dec 05 Completed by Mar 06 In progress
The details of progress have been presented below
Physical Progress in Phase II
Component Target Completed WIP Yet to commence % comp.
Reconstruction 719 719 -- -- 100
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 26
Procurement Progress The details of contracts in the major repairs and reconstruction is presented below
Status of contracts (Rs. In million)
Total contracts Contracts signed Sub-components Packages Structures Est. Value Packages Structures Value
Reconstructions 46 745* 358.34 46 745* 378.03 Consultancy 1 -- 6.67 1 -- 6.34 * Includes 26 structures completed in Phase I. All 46 contracts comprising of 719 buildings have been fully completed by September 2005.
Progress against plans The status of progress of reconstruction works against those planned till the end of this quarter is presented below
Status of Progress (Rs. in million)
Planned upto Mar 06 Actual upto Mar 06 Completion (%) Activity
Works Est. Value Works Value Works Value Reconstruction 719 378.03 719 366.86 100 99 Note: Planned figures taken as per revised projections submitted to Bank for project extension
Quality Assurance NCCBM was appointed as quality consultant for technical audit and quality assurance of reconstruction. All 719 structures to be taken up for reconstrcution in Phase II under Panchyat departments were instpected by the consultant, remedial actions suggested have been implemented for related structures.
2.7 Public Buildings - Home Department
In the Earthquake of 26th January 2001, Police buildings, both residential & non-residential, Police stations, police chowkeys, outposts and offices belonging to the police department were severely affected. Kachchh, Jamnagar, Rajkot, Surendranagar, Patan, Bhavnagar, Junagadh, Porbandar and Amreli were the worst affected districts. Major repair of 2195 buildings comprising of 2076 residential and 119 non-residential buildings and Reconstruction of 562 buildings comprising of 552 residential and 10 non-residential buildings, has been envisaged to be taken up under Phase-II at an estimated cost of Rs. 343.419 million. The implementing agency is the Gujarat State Police Housing Corporation Limited.
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 27
Physical Progress Repair works on 2195 structures have been completed. Reconstruction works has commenced and is in progress. Details of progress are presented below
Physical Progress in Phase II Component Target Completed WIP Yet to Commence % comp.
Repairs 2195 2195 0 0 100 Reconstruction 562 427 135 0 76
Procurement Progress
Status of contracts (Rs. in million)
Total contracts Contracts signed Sub-components Packages Structures Est. Value Packages Structures Value
Repairs 30 2195 91.95 30 2195 78.68 Reconstruction 15 562 248.13 15 562 214.64 Consultancy 3 - 8.10 3 - 13.55 Quality Assurance Repair works were carried out under the direct supervision and monitoring of the qualified civil engineers of the Corporation. M/s. Sheladia Associates & consultants (I) Pvt. Ltd have been appointed as third party quality consultant for technical audit and quality assurance of reconstruction works. All supervising staff, QATA consultants and contractors have been fully mobilised at site. Laboratory has been established at the site and the sampling and testing procedures have been streamlined.
The consultant have been visiting all the sites and providing with list of non-conformities relating to material and workmanship to the supervising staff of the department for remedial action. They consultant makes day to day site visits and have till date audited 473 structures in 13 packages. 241 non conformance observed and remedial actions suggested, 224 non-conformity notes have been complied with and for rest is under progress. Compliance to environmental and social management are also provided as part of periodic reports submitted by the third party consultant.
2.8 Public Buildings – Other buildings
This component includes repair and reconstruction of other buildings and urban local bodies.
Physical Progress Physical Progress in Phase II
Component Target Completed WIP Yet to Commence
% comp.
Repairs to AMC buildings 125 125 0 0 100 Reconstruction of JMC building 1 1 0 0 100
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 28
Procurement Progress Status of contracts
(Rs. in million) Total contracts Contracts signed Sub-components
Packages Structures Est. Value Packages Structures Value Repairs to AMC buildings 6 125 40.00 6 125 51.80
Reconstruction of JMC building
1 1 41.38 1 1 41.38
Consultancy of JMC building
1 -- 1.49 1 -- 1.49
Quality Assurance Zonal staff of AMC was supervising and monitoring the quality of works and procurement of material. Consultants / T.P.I agencies were appointed as per requirement.
2.9 ISR and GIDM
Institute of Seismological Research (ISR)
This subcomponent provides for establishment of the ISR. The Department of Science and Technology (DST), Government of Gujarat are being assisted by the Earth Institute of Columbia University in conceptualizing the Institute, its role, scope and other activities which are envisaged to be taken up by the Institute. Columbia University has submitted report on establishment of ISR to DST.
Simultaneously, DST has initiated the process for appointment of an architectural firm, and is under final stage of award of work. Also advertisement for position of Scientist at different levels (9 positions) was given in the leading newspapers by ISR. Applications have been received and interview will be conducted shortly.
Gujarat Institute of Disaster Management (GIDM)
This subcomponent provides for the establishment of GIDM including providing state of art facilities for training and education. The subcomponent other than consultancy and works also includes procurement of furniture and equipments for the institute. The implementing agency is GSDMA. A study was initiated for conceptualizing the institute and to provide details on organization structure, courses/curriculum to be introduced, training activities to be conducted etc. The consultant M/s ICET, Netherlands has submitted the final report of the study.
Land for establishment of GIDM has been allotted. Architectural and structural consultants have started working on initial plan and estimates.
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 29
GIDM is already functional in premises of SPIPA, Ahmedabad and till date nearly 64 training programs have been conducted covering 1,922 participants from all over the state.
2.10 Retrofitting (Undamaged buildings in the vulnerable areas)
The public buildings belonging to State R&B, Panchayat and other buildings belonging to health sector which were not covered in Phase I are being taken up for Retrofitting under phase II. Nearly 4572 buildings at an estimated cost of Rs. 2248.20 Mn are to be retrofitted in zone 4; zone 5, 50 kms beyond zone 4 boundary and 25 kms stretch on either side of the fault lines. Consultants have been appointed for suggesting retrofitting measures for these buildings depending on which zone they reside. The State R&B department and the Panchayat R&B department have been identified as the implementing agencies for the retrofitting works.
Physical Progress in Phase II
Component Target Completed WIP Yet to Commence
% comp.
State Public Buildings 1757 114 1571 72 7 Panchayat Buildings 530 31 117 382 6 Health & Education Buildings 2285 0 0 2285 0
Total 4572 145 1688 2739 3 Procurement Progress The retrofitting consultants have been appointed by both State and Panchayat R&B to prepare inventory of all the undamaged buildings of critical importance in the vulnerable areas and provide for retrofitting solutions. State Public Buildings: The State R&B department has appointed M/s. Consulting Engineering Services for package I and M/s Structwell Designers and Consultants Pvt Ltd. for package II. The status of the works is given below: Package I: Nearly 688 R&B State buildings (22 packages) and 1451 Health & Education buildings (30 packages) are to be retrofitted under this package at the cost of approximately Rs. 394.27 Million and Rs. 700.00 Million respectively. State R&B Buildings: 19 packages comprising of 685 buildings have been awarded and work is under progress. Tenders have been reinvited for 3 packages comprising of 3 buildings. Health & Education Buildings: 30 packages comprising of 1451 Health and Education buildings have been formulated. Tenders have been invited for 5 packages comprising of 150 buildings and for the rest survey and estimation is under progress. Package II: Nearly 1069 R&B State buildings (28 packages) and 834 Health & Education buildings (20 packages) are to be retrofitted under this package at the cost of approximately Rs. 521.30 Million and Rs. 400.00 Million respectively.
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 30
State R&B Buildings: 26 packages comprising of 1000 buildings have been awardedand work is under progress. 2 packages comprising of 69 buildings are under variousstages of approval. Health & Education Buildings: 20 packages comprising of 834 Health and Educationbuildings have been formulated. Survey and estimation for these packages is underprogress. Panchayat R & B: M/s. SPAN consultants have been appointed for retrofitting ofundamaged panchayat buildings. 20 packages comprising of 530 structures have beenformulated. Bids have been invited for all 20 packages at an estimated value of Rs.232.63 Mn of which 14 packages comprising of 372 structures valuing Rs. 147.36Million have been signed till Mar ‘06. Rest 6 packages are at various stages of approval.
2.11 Roads and Bridges
Phase I consisted of repair and reconstruction of 185 Km of State Highway Roads and129 other structures (bridges and culverts). While the strengthening work on 184.4 kmroads had been fully completed by the end of phase I, repair and reconstruction of only26 out of the 129 structures planned were completed by the end of phase I. Of the balance 103 structures ( 85 for repairs and 18 for recosntruction ), 102 are takenup in Phase II ( One structure dropped) along with the strengthening of 815.83 kms ofState roads in the earthquake affected districts viz. Kachchh, Rajkot, Junagadh,Jamnagar, Ahmedabad, Surendranagar, Mehsana, Patan and Banaskantha.
Physical Progress
The quarterly trends in repairs and reconstruction of bridges and other structures arepresented in Exhibit 4.
Exhibit 4 Repair & Reconstruction of Bridges84 84 84
0
18 18 18 18
0
84
0
25
50
75
100
Target Completed - Sept 05 Completed - Dec 05 Completed - Mar 06 In Progress
Major Repairs Reconstruction
The details of the cumulative progress of works in the repair & reconstruction of bridgesand other structures and the strengthening of roads are presented below.
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 31
Physical Progress in Phase II
Component Overall Target Completed WIP Yet to commence % comp.
Repair and Reconstruction of Bridges and other structures
102* 102 0 0 100
Strengthening of State Roads 815.83** 751.88 63.95 0 92 * Repair works on one structure (EERP Bridge 5) has been dropped from the original target of 103 structures of World Bank funding ** Package EERP-21 and EERP-22 (140.37 Kms) have been dropped from the World Bank funding and are taken under GoG funding
Procurement Progress The procurement progress is presented below.
Status of contracts (Rs. In million)
Total contracts Contracts signed Packages Unit Est. Value Packages Unit Value
Restoration of Bridges and other structures 7 129*
bridges 471.61 7 129 Bridges 421.10
Strengthening of State Roads 15 815.83 Km 2851.84 15 815.83Km 2076.74
Consultancy for design and QATA 3 - 100.00 3 - 30.60
* Includes 26 bridges completed in Phase – I Progress against plans The status of progress of repair and reconstruction works against those planned till the end of this quarter is presented below:
Status of Progress
(Rs. in million) Planned as on Mar ‘06 Actual as on Mar ‘06 Completion (%)
Activity Works Est. Value Works Value Works Value
Bridge works 102 421.10 102 416.20 100 99.50 Road works 815.83 3101.31 751.88 1958.89 92 63 Note: Planned figures taken as per revised projections submitted to Bank for project extension
Quality Compliance
Inspection and testing plan for Technical audit has been prepared for EERP-Bridges and submitted to engineer for implementation of quality aspects. The manual prepared under this plan has been circulated to all the contractors and engineer representatives for the quality implementation. This has been followed during the execution of the works and test records are maintained at sites. Consultants, bridge inspectors and quality engineers have been visiting structures where work is in progress and guiding
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 32
contractors and supervisors on quality aspects. M/s Frischmann Prabhu (India) Pvt. Ltd. is conducting the quality auditing for strengthening of road works.
2.12 Dams & Irrigation
Emergency repairs of all the 245 dams were undertaken before monsoon of 2001 to ensure that the earthquake is not followed by a disaster like dam breaking.
Government of Gujarat has decided to strengthen the dams as per latest Indian Standard Codes so that the dams can withstand an earthquake of similar magnitude. Total 222 dams (37 dams of Saurashtra + 185 dams of Kutch) are being strengthened. The Dam Safety Review Panel (DSRP) was formulated for expert opinion/suggestion in strengthening works of dams. The implementing agency for this component is the NWR&WSD. Physical Progress Out of 222 dams to be strengthened, contracts for 220 dams have been awarded and works for the same have commenced. DSRP has reviewed the design for all 222 dams. The detailed status of the 222 dams is presented below.
Physical Progress in Phase II
Component Overall Target Completed WIP Yet to commence % comp.
Strengthening of Dams Kutch 185 165 20 0 89 Saurashtra 37 1 34 2 3
Total 222 166 54 2* 75 * Includes packages which are yet to be awarded Note: Macchu dam has been dropped due to technical reasons. Procurement Progress The details of the procurement progress is presented below
Status of contracts (Rs. In million)
Total contracts Contracts signed Sub-components Packages Structures Est. Value Packages Structures Value
Dams (minor + medium schemes) Kutch 72 185 1700.73 72 185 1352.40 Saurashtra 23 37 588.11 21 35 396.77 Status of pending contracts: 1 package in Saurashtra region (Bhadar Dam) is yet to be invited and 1 package in Kutch region (Machchu Dam) has been dropped due to technical reasons.
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 33
Progress against plans The status of progress strengthening works against those planned till the end of this quarter is presented below:
Status of Progress
(Rs. in million) Planned as on Mar ‘06 Actual as on Mar ‘06 Completion (%) Activity Works Est. Value Works Value Works Value
Dam Works 158 1571.66 166 986.27 105 63 Note: Planned figures taken as per revised projections submitted to Bank for project extension
Quality Assurance Consulting Engineering Services has been appointed as quality consultant for technical audit and quality Assurance works. They have visited all the sites at Kutch where work is in progress and have been submitting fortnightly progress reports to the department. These reports include meetings with officers, field visits undertaken, physical progress against target and number of tests carried out by department and observations and shortcomings at various sites. The consultants have carried out 205 dam site visits during the quarter, including repeat visits. They have undertaken 6200 dam site visits to date auditing 215 structures under 93 packages. The Department has also appointed 13 nodal officers of the rank of Executive Engineers to look after the quality aspect of works.
The department also has an in-house Quality Control organization having experienced engineers for inspection of works. Separate control divisions and sub divisions have been established by the department and the necessary measures are being taken up at field as well as laboratories as per norms laid down by the department, for regular assurance of quality.
3. Community Participation Community Participation and Capacity Building is a crucial component in the Owner-driven housing rehabilitation program. Various Information, Education and Communication (IEC) activities have been initiated by GSDMA through participatory approach. In association with UNDP, a Community Based Disaster Management Program has been launched in over 4000 Villages in 68 Talukas of 14 Districts selected on the basis of vulnerability. The objectives of this program include awareness generation activities at the individual community district and state levels, developing preparedness and response plans at all administrative levels and capacity building of various disaster management teams and PRI member at all administrative levels with special focus on women. The detail of the entire activities undertaken in DRM component till the end of March 2006 is presented in Annexure 5.
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 34
3.1 Activities undertaken during this quarter
• Kite flying safety campaign was launched on the first day of January 2006. Thetarget group of this activity included general public and the public of the sevenmunicipal corporations. The objective of the campaign was to look into the causesof accidents occurring while Kite-Flying during Uttarayan and to minimize themby educating people. This activity was undertaken by GSDMA. The processinvolved preparation of two television spots and 5 radio spots and broadcastedthem through All India Radio (7 stations), DD Gujarat and Radio Mirchi for 15days. The 250 CDs containing the spots were sent to various channels to impartthe knowledge to create awareness. The Kite-Flying Safety Campaign waslaunched all over the schools in State through department of education. DPEOand DEO were asked to instruct all schools to initiate campaign so as todisseminate messages on safety tips to be followed for safe kite flying.Precautionary messages were prepared to educated students one month beforethe festival. Government of Gujarat issued a Government order making itmandatory for all teachers (primary and secondary schools) to teach preparednessmeasures to be undertaken during kite festival.
• Public Awareness Campaign for disaster preparedness and risk reduction wasundertaken by door to door distribution of IEC materials in selected doctor’sclinics in the state for reading of the same by patients who wait in the clinics fordoctor’s appointment. The target group included all types of patients who arevisiting the doctor’s clinics. The objective of the program was to utilize fruitfullythe time otherwise wasted by patients in the doctor’s clinics while waiting fordoctor’s appointment. This activity has been undertaken all over the state. Thisactivity was undertaken during the month of February 2006 by GSDMA. Toachieve this, 1400 copies of home owner’s guide for fire safety have beendistributed to selected doctor’s clinics across the state.
• Gujarat Safety Planning Guideline for event management has been prepared forall government and private agencies that organises events in small and large scale.The objective of carrying out this activity was to prevent accidents due to faultyplanning of events causing casualty to participants attending the event. Theactivity targeted the entire state. It was undertaken in the month of February 2006by GSDMA. The initiative included compilation of various safety norms and allaspects of event planning, right from venue selection, approval from authorities,role of police, fire officials, security and rescue personnel and it also included thepreparation of response plan. The guideline is expected to provide safety norms tothe event organisers. To create systematic approach to event planning byfollowing the comprehensive checklist.
• Preparation of IEC materials for the blind students has been undertaken in themonth of January 2006 by GSDMA. The target group included the blind children.The primary objective of the program was to disseminate information on disasterpreparedness and create awareness. This activity has been solely undertaken inAhmedabad. The process included the “Braille” reading material on disasterpreparedness among the blind children.
Printing and preparation of IEC materials for Gujarat School Safety Initiative. The target group for this activity included selected schools in Ahmedabad, Jamnagar and Vadodara. The objective was to involve school children in mock drills and
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 35
• preparation of disaster management plans. The scale of the activity was big as itwas carried in around 150 schools in Ahmedabad, about 100 schools in 35 schoolsin Vadodara and 15 schools in Jamnagar. This was carried out by GSDMA in themonth of January 2006. In this program three lakh IEC materials of class roomsafety hazard checklist and family safety hazard checklist were prepared inGujarat and English were distributed in the schools. Nine thousand three taskforce badges on fire safety, evacuation, first aid treatment, warning, search &rescue and disaster awareness have been prepared and were distributed inschools. One thousand project fliers have been printed to promote awarenessabout the projective objectives to be carried out during the program. The expectedout come is to link orientation and sensitisation workshops carried out at schoollevel to actually practice of mock drills and preparation of school based disastermanagement plan. It would also initiate the formation of student task forces thatshall be trained, which would become local emergency responders in the schoolsduring any disasters.
• Project for Gender Sensitisation was undertaken in the month of January 2006 byGADMA for government officials, police personnel, NGOs, teachers, adolescentgirls and women. The objective was to create sensitivity on gender. This wascarried out in all Talukas and Districts of the State.
• Training of teachers (GSSI – II) program on disaster risk reduction was carriedout. These 100 teachers so trained would train 625 teachers, 25 teachers in eachdistrict, who in turn train 1000 teacher and these together would training 7500teacher in the state. The aim of the program is to increase school abilities toimplement comprehensive school safety and school based disaster managementplan.
• Under mason’s certification program 125 masons have been certified tillSeptember 2005. This program was organised by GSDMA and held in Rajkot,Patan and Porbandar district. The objective of the program was to assess the skillsof the masons on multi-hazard resistant construction and train them so as toenhance their skills in MHR construction. To certify such trained masons asskilled masons for the MHR construction.
• Gujarat Tsunami Management Plan has been prepared by GSDMA in the monthof January 2006. The target group includes all vulnerable citizens of Gujarat. Theaim of Gujarat Tsunami Management Plan is to plan for risk reduction andmitigate tsunami disaster. The plan comprises tsunami risk and vulnerabilityassessment, plan for emergency response, preparedness, relief and recovery andbudget for the plan, its testing, activation and review. Based on the plan everydepartment should prepare a detailed plan pertaining to the actions to beundertaken for Tsunami management in Gujarat. Thus to strengthen the disasterpreparedness in the state and frame better emergency response.
• Work for the revision for syllabus for Architectural institutes has been carried outby GSDMA in the month of January 2006. The target is obviously the architecturalstudents who are responsible for bringing up the building in the future. The aimfor this was to introduce disaster management as a science in the coursecurriculum (both in bachelor and master courses). The work is carried at the statelevel. For the work and expert team has been constituted and courses have beentaken up for revision. Thus it would help to introduce in architectural practice theconcepts of disaster management in design layouts, building material selection instructural mechanics.
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 36
• Documentary animation film on disaster preparedness has been preparedtargeting the children. The film has been prepared by joint venture of GSDMAand Save the Children, in the month of January 2006. The film tries to target thechildren of the whole state. The aim of such an animation movie is to disseminateinformation on disaster risk reduction – with focus on earthquakes in audiovisualformats to children. The movie includes dos and don’ts on earthquake. Theinformation has been scripted in child friendly manner and presented in a sevenminute duration film. This would help to effectively propagate the message ondisaster risk reduction and disaster preparedness among children. The film beingmade in Gujarati shall be widely comprehended by children living in the remoteareas of Gujarat.
• As part of School Safety Initiative orientation of school teachers and students in all5055 students 81 teachers in 9 schools have undergone orientation. 3230 studentsand 63 teachers have attended the mock drill of earthquakes. 9 schools havejoined and become a part of school safety clubs. Plays and films on disastermitigation has been shown in 7 schools. All these programs have been organisedwith the joint venture of GSDMA and SEEDS in the month of February 2006. Thevarious included the promotion of culture of disaster safety in schools, reduce riskthrough structural and non-structural corrections, preparation of school disastermanagement plans, establishment of emergency management plan, prepareappropriate tools for training school teachers and students in disaster reduction.The expected out come in general is that this would develop the culture ofdisaster preparedness among the students, which will ultimately transform intothe future emergency responders.
The details of the entire activities till the end of March 2006 in the prescribed formatare presented in Annexure 3.
4. Disaster Management Capacity Building This component deals with the main facets of disaster management, including bothpre-disaster and post-disaster activities: • Emergency management, including pre-disaster preparedness and post-disaster
response; • Hazard mitigation, comprising both structural (e.g., retrofitting of hazardous
buildings) and non-structural measures (such as building the relevant regulatorystructure; development of studies necessary to support decision making, forexample hazard assessment and vulnerability studies) and risk transfer; and
• Disaster management capacity building through education, information sharing,hazard-related research and training.
The principal objective of the disaster management component is to reduce the risk offuture natural hazards and also increase the preparedness of the state of Gujarat for futurenatural and other disasters, so as to reduce the vulnerability of its population and economy,as well as to minimize life and property loss.
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 37
4.1 Activities undertaken in this quarter
• Three day training on Agricultural issues of natural and biological disaster andtheir management was organised. The participants included the deputy directorsof the Agriculture departments. In all 18 deputy directors of various agriculturaldepartments attended the training. The training was undertaken at SPIPA. Theobjective was to give training on Agricultural issues of natural and biologicaldisaster and their management. It was organised in the month of January 2006 andthe mode of imparting knowledge included various lecture and presentation andcase studies. The expected outcome of the training would be that it would help theparticipants (Deputy Directors of Agricultural Department) in the preparation andthe management at the time of disasters.
• One day workshop on Disaster Risk Management Plan was organised on the 13thDay of January 2006. The participants included District Disaster ManagementOfficers and Project Support Officers. There were in all 35 participants. The eventwas organised at SPIPA. The objective of the workshop was to make acquaintedthese personnel with the components of Disaster Risk Management Plan. And theactivities to be undertaken on priority basis if at all a disaster strikes. So mainly theaim was to streamline their response strategically in the event of disaster.
• Three day training was organised on Environmental Planning and Disaster RiskReduction for the Range Forest Officers of the Forest Department from 6th to 8thJanuary 2006. The training was attended by 20 Range Forest Officials in all. Thetraining was organised at SPIPA. The objective of the training was to make theRFOs as to how the natural resources must be handled in the event of disasters andhow the Environmental Planning could be used to mitigate the impact of disasters.
• Training of three days was organised on Disaster Management Planning from 22ndto 24th of February. The training was attended by 27 Range Forest Officers of theforest department. The objective of the training was to make the RFOs aware of thecomponents of the Disaster Management and learn as to how to do the DisasterManagement Planning.
• Training of three days was organised on Disaster Management Planning from 28thFebruary to 1st of March. The training was attended by 27 Range Forest Officers ofthe forest department. The objective of the training was to make the RFOs aware ofthe components of the Disaster Management Plan and learn as to how to do theDisaster Management Planning.
• One day training was organised on 4th of March 2006 on “Disasters andPsychological Trauma Management” (Post Trauma Management after Disasters).The training was organised for Medical officers of the Health Department. Total of49 medical officers participated in this training. It was organised at SPIPA byGSDMA and IHA Vadodara. The medium of communicating information wasthrough lectures, presentations, discussions and video screening. The expectedoutcome is that it will help doctors to cope up with the psychological trauma theyface during disasters.
Search & Rescue training was organised using specialised equipments. This training has been oraganised upto 1st April 2006. The training was meant for the fire & emergency staff of municipal corporations in the State. The aim of the training was to improve and refresh SAR operations by Fire & Engineering staff. Till date 151 fire fighters and engineers have been trained. It was organised by
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 38
• GSDMA and training was imparted using practical training. It is expected that itwill help departments in effective response during disasters.
• Search and Rescue training was organised for multi-disciplinary staff. The traininghas been taken up to March 2006. It targeted multi-disciplinary staff of all districtsin the state. The aim of the training was to augment first responders’ capabilities ofgovernment employees in all districts. Under this training till date 336 personnelhave been trained. To cover all the districts the training has been organised atvarious places like Rajkot, Surat and Vadodara. It is expected that this would makethe response much more effective in the case of disasters.
Studies/Consultancy Assignments: The current status is as follows: • Final report for “Feasibility Study for Seismic Microzonation” was submitted by
consultants in June 2004. Inputs from this feasibility reports have been studied andactual Seismic Microzonation in Gandhidham has been undertaken.
• Procurement process for Seismic Microzonation at Gandhidham has been initiated.Both technical and financial bids have been opened and evaluated. The evaluationreport has been submitted to The World Bank for approval.
• The draft final report for the study on “Hazard Risk & Vulnerability Assessmentand Preparation of Vulnerability Atlas” was submitted in March 05 and final reportsubmitted in July 2005. Hazard Risk & Vulnerability Atlas has been printed andsubmitted to GSDMA. GSDMA has initiated process for distribution of theseatlases to relevant departments. Also GSDMA has envisaged undertaking trainingto relevant departments for use of atlas.
• Final report for the study on “Establishment of Hazard Early Warning andCommunication System” has been submitted by consultants in March 05.
• Final report for the study on “Review of Building Codes” has been submitted inJuly 2005. GSDMA has awarded additional scope within this assignment whichwill look into the codes on “Manual for protection of buildings against terroristattacks” and on “Guidelines for seismic design of buried pipelines”. The work onthis assignment is scheduled for submission in May, 2006. The draft report for“Guidelines for seismic design of buried pipelines” has been submitted by theconsultants in September 2005.
• Consultants have submitted the final report on “Damage & Loss AssessmentMethodology” in March, 2006.
• Final report for the study on “Establishment of Emergency Response Centres inGujarat” has been submitted by the consultants in June 2005.
• Consultancy on “Architectural Services for construction of GIDM” has beenawarded and work on the same has been initiated.
• The study on “Gender Sensitisation” (Advantage India Pvt. Ltd) has commenced inMarch 2005 and the inception report on this study has been received. GSDMA havesuggested changes to be made in the inception report. The revised inception reporthas been submitted.
• Final report for the study on “Establishment of GIDM” has been submitted byICET, Netherlands in June 2005.
• Appointment of consultants for procurement of equipments for “Hazard earlywarning and communication system” and “Emergency response centers” is underway.
QUARTERLY PROGRESS REPORT – JAN – MAR 06: PART A
• A study on review of GSDMA “Its Institutional set up, Arrangements and Future”has been undertaken. Study is conducted by IIM-Ahmedabad and is underprogress.
• GSDMA has initiated a study on “Flood vulnerability of four cities in Gujarat”.EOIs for this assignment have been received and are under evaluation.
• Award of consultancy for third party quality audit of undamaged public buildingsundertaken for retrofitting has been initiated. The consultancy assignment is likelyto be awarded by May, 2006.
The detail of the entire activities undertaken in the DMCB component till the end ofMarch 2006 in the prescribed format is presented in Annexure 4.
GUJARAT STATE DISASTER MANAGEMENT AUTHORITY 39
Top Related