8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
1/94
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
2/94
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
3/94
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1: TRANSNATIONALISM3-4: CONTENTION5-7: ONBORDER8: LEXICON9-13: FORTRESSEUROPE14-15: EXCLAVES16-23: STRAITOFGIBRALTAR:FIELDOFTERRITORIES24-29: EUMIGRATION:SUB-SAHARANMIGRATIONANDTERRITORIALBORDERIMPLICATIONS30-33: CEUTAASSPACEDEFININGTRANSITIONBETWEENCHRISTIANITYANDISLAM34-41: CEUTAASPHYSICALMANIFESTATIONOFFORTRESSEUROPE
42-45: CEUTA46-51: TANGERMED-PORT:EMERGINGWORLDMARKET52-59: FLOWSANDECONOMIES60-63: CEUTAASMOROCCAN?64-67: BORDERASFIELD68-77: SITE78-83: PRECEDENTS84-85: SPECULATION86-92: APPENDIX
1
1
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
4/94
TRANSNATIONAL DISCOURSE INSISTS
ON THE CONTINUING SIGNIFICANCE
OF STATE BORDERS, STATE POLICIES
AND NATIONAL IDENTITIES EVEN AS
THESE ARE OFTEN TRANSGRESSEDBY TRANSNATIONAL COMMUNICATION
CIRCUITS AND SOCIAL PRACTICES.2
2
3
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
5/94
Aboundaryisnotthatatwhichsomethingstops,
but as the Greeks recognized, the boundary isthatfromwhichsomethingbeginsitspresencing.4
MartinHeidegger
3
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
6/94
Theeffectsoftransnationalpoliticalsituations
areradicallychangingthewaywelive.Therealities
of cross-border conicts and political disputes of
autonomy have created strife within cities leading
tocrises ofidentity, place,and hate within culture.
I contend that transnational borders are
places where conict and identity crises have
manifestedinthemostcogentandattainableform.
By investigating transnational border crises, one
can study its effects at a local and transnational
condition, enabling geophysical forces to manifest
in a productive border for the crises at hand.
Atransnationalborderconditionattheedgeof
theEuropeanUnion,intheSpanishexclaveofCeuta,is the site of the project. The exclave, which was
seizedbyPortugalin1415,andSpainin1560,became
anautonomouscityin1995,asapartofSpain.For
over600years,ithasbeenastrongholdofEuropean
presence in North Africa and the Mediterranean.
In 1985, the same year Spain joined the
EU (then the EEC), the Shenghen Agreement
was signed, creating the abolishment of internal
boundaries inside the EU, emphasizing theexternal boundary for movement within. Once
inside, a traveler has unrestricted access to all
countries under the Shenghen Agreement. In
1995, the EU funded a $320 million border fence
in Ceuta under EUs motto, Fortress Europe.
Ceutas border has become a siphon for the
emergent Sub-Saharan migratory phenomenon.5
Ceuta is one of three Sub-Saharan migratory
destinationsinordertocrossintomainlandEurope,
the Canary Islands, Ceutaand Melilla,andMalta. As
theStraitofGibraltaristheoneoftheclosestpoints
between two continentsin the world, ithas become
a deathtrap for migrants, as 1,200 people die each
yeareithercrossingthestraitorattemptingtojump
fences.6 Thus, Ceuta has become the physical
manifestationofthemotto,FortressEurope.
Additionally,theconditionthatexistspresents
acrisisofidentity.Morocco,whichdoesnotrecognize
Ceutaas anautonomous entity, isrooted inMuslimNorthAfricaculturalideologies. ThisforcesMorocco
to play host to Spanish-Christian Ceuta creating
conicting spheres of identities within an existing
sphereof conictinggeopolitics.Thebinarydialectic
emerges at the moment of differencethe border.
Iproposethere-imaginingoftheCeutaborderas
aspaceofproductivedifference.Border,constructed
inthisway, will act asa eld condition bridgingrst
worldwithdevelopingworldspheresofinuence.Theresultant hybrid amalgamation will be programmed,
producing a space that is intimately tied to its
surroundingcontextbutcognizantofthelargerforces
atplay,re-conceptualizingwhatborderconstitutes
inanageofincreasingtransnationalandglobalows.
4
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
7/94
EU
EU as legally constructed EU as resultant border EU Border?
5
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
8/94
ON BORDER
Geographically, we are in a space of transition:
between Africa and Europe, the Mediterranean and the
Atlantic; a space that separates and connects, and hasalways been permeable to the continuous ows of life.
Today this place fullls a strategic function by acting as
a barrier, both physical and mental, separating the legal
from illegal, like a folding line that splits our world in two.
But borders are habitable territories that cant be
reduced to lines on a map. They are environmentsthat
encourage interchange and hybridity, highly dynamic
territories that generate a gradation of shared spaces,
where the character of crossing prevails over that of
barrier. To cross their thresholds means to physicallymove from one place to another, but, even more, it implies
the start of a transformation, to becoming-others.
Spaces for movement and mobile spaces;
capitalist modernity accelerates this quality even as it
expands, bounding over mobile borders. Like the Far
West, destruction and colonization, but also a horizon
for creative exodus. There is a single substance,
that of capitalism and of those who escape from its
chaings to create (and create themselves as) freeterritory; even if people who want to stake it out and
privatize it follow close behind. Our modernity has its
own mobile borders, which, as always , are in search
of the other: the external other that we call nature,
and the internal other-subjectivity, ourselves, in plural.
Against sterile, immutable linear abstraction
stand ideas that spreak like contagious viruses; from
here springs Madiaq territory. Here, at the dense crux
where seas, lands and multitudes convege, over themoat they have made deadly, we are building a multiple
territory, both geographic and infographic, social and
technological, that extens innitely in four directions:
toward the South and toward the North; towards the depths
of carnal bodies and toward the immaterial noosphere
that grows in the ferile land of words without owners.
Maps report existing territories, but
they also construct them; thus territory lives
in the mind and is constructed as knowledge.7
Territory is always shifting in the
mind of the person who crosses it.
6
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
9/94
Thus, the project will produce an architecture that does not
attempt to solve the the conicting conditions that exist at the
Ceuta border: religious conicts, identity crises, and a high
number of migratory deaths.
Rather, the archItecture will be a vehicle to spatialize these
forces, bridging the gap between what is a jarring reality,
and an architectural reality that suspends judgement
in order to juxtapose and highlight conict, producing a
reconceptualization of the current EU border as a space of
productive difference.
7
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
10/94
GLOSSARY
Border: A spatial dierence between outside and inside
simultaneously creating dierence (a new outside o both
meaning and space). A flter or the gathering o dierences.
Territory: a feld or sphere o action, thought, etc.; domain orprovince o a controlling body.
Sovereignty:
Supreme and independent power or authority in government
as possessed or claimed by a state or community. 8
Transnational space:
Space that is simultaneously anchored in nation state, while
transcending one or more nation state, through the people
that inhabit it.
Exclave:
Territory legally or politically attached to another territory withwhich it is not physically contiguous. 9
Enclave:
Territory whose geographical boundaries lie entirely within the
boundaries o another territory. 10
Transit Spaces:
Space that exists at the point o tension between new
technologies, which open up access and migration control
simultaneously attempting to close it. 11
Peripherality:
Denotes margins that are not problematic to sovereignty andare subordinate to the authority and governance o the state.12
Marginality:
Denotes margins as problematic and necessary to be
eradicated by the sovereign states control. 13
Hybridity:
Denotes the ambiguity o margin as not threatening, but
embraced as a resource. 14
Immigration interface:
Sum o the paths that lead in the direction o long-term legal
residence in Europe. 14
Remote Control:The control over territorial boundaries by extra-territorial locations,
such as embassies and overseas airports. 15
S.I.V.E:
Integrated System o External Vigilance. First developed on
the northern coast o the Strait o Gibraltar in 2002. It is a
technologically advanced structure to detect and intercept
pateras and other small vessels. It measures the approximate
distance and number o people in boats, relating this inormation
to a central agency where urther deployment o helicopters or
boats can be utilized.
Clandestine Migrants:
Migrants who deliberately avoid all orms o border control. They
must be avoid being present in the same space-time as border
control agents i they are to evade detection. 16
Undocumented Migrants:
Migrants who are not able to be traced.
Human migration:
Physical movement by humans rom one area to another,
sometimes over long distances or in large groups. 17
FRONTEX:
European Border Controls Agency established in 2005.18
Territorially Based Control: Establishes proxy control o entire
territories outside o the border itsel, attempting to prevent
migrants rom even reaching the border. 19
Pateras: wooden boats used or small-scale smuggling
8
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
11/94
9
22
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
12/94
10
The problem of immigration is not actually on each
state independently, but rather of the EU in general,
as the adoption of the Schenghen Agreement in
1985 (with the progressive dissolution of interior
or ers rom 1993) allowe or ree movement
between its signatory member states... 20
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
13/94
1957
G e r m a n yF r a n c eI t a l y U n i t e dK i n g d o mLuxembourgNetherlands
TREATY OF ROME
The Treaty o Rome established
a coopertative trade agreement
to allow the ree fow o goods,
services, and peoples, within
the member states borders.21
The countries under this treaty
created an economic border that
can be read as seperate rom the
traditional notion o nation state
territorial boundaries. This border
was an economically devised
transnational border, creating
new fows through politically
connected territories. The rsttreaty within Treaty o Rome
established the EEC |European
Economic Community|, which
would later become the EU. The
border that was created connected
two continents, as Algeria was still
under Frances sovereignty in 1957.
6
11
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
14/94
1985
13
WestGermanyF
ranceItalyUnite
dKingdomSpai
nNetherlandsL
uxdmbourgBel
g i u m G r e e c e
PortugalAustri
a D e n m a r k I
r e l a n d
ACT OF ACCESSION |SPAIN|
SHENGHEN AGREEMENT
Spain and Portugal joined the
EEC in 1985, and with the merger
o these countries, the EECs
boundary established a greater
presence in the Mediterranean
and in Arica. The Single European
Act signed in 1986, gradually
turned the EEC as a Customs
Union into a Common Market
over a seven year period with the
ormation o the EU in 1993.22The Schenghen Agreement
created a territory where the
ree movement o persons isguaranteed. The internal border
o countries were abolished
in avor o on external border.
This agreement maniests
in the EU moto, Fortress
Europe, and simultaneously
created a strong desire or
12
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
15/94
FORTRESS EUROPE
CURRENT STATE OF EU
The EU IS now a unied bodyo 27 countries. The Shenghen
Agreement, critical or the EU to
position itsel advantageously
in the ree world market has put
tremendous strain on the ringes o
the EU as it has become a desirable
place or immigration. Immigration
has led to militarization and
increased surveillance at the
border o the EU, in an attempt
to maintain its internal reedom.
Thus, the moto Fortress
Europe, has maniested
most visibly at the border as
these spaces are otentimes
radically dierent geoeconomic
or geopolitical situations.
2007
13
27
GermanyFranc
eI ta lyUnited
KingdomSpain
PolandRomani
aNetherlandsB
elgiumCzech
RepublicGreec
eHungaryPort
ugalSwedenAu
striaBulgaria
FinlandDenmar
kSlovakiaIrelan
dLithuaniaLatv
iaSloveniaCypr
usEstoniaLuxe
mbourgMalta
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
16/94
EXCLAVES
Territory legally or politically
attached to another territory withwhich it is not physically contiguous.
A true exclave needs to be both anenclave and an exclave, where the
territory needs to be completely
surrounded within another alienterritory. There can be many
variations on exclaves and manydo not ully match the defnition o
a true exclave such as pene, quasi,
virtual, or temporary exclaves.
Pene-exclaves are territories thatcan still be accessed to politicallyattached subordinate such as by
transportation route, or are exclaves
but one side o the territory shares aboundary with water.
Quasi exclaves hold certainexceptions such as a country that
is physically not contiguous but
may hold allegiance to anotherpolitical body simultaneously.
Virtual exclaves can be defned asembassies, or spaces that are not
quite territories.
Temporary exclaves are territoriesthat may have been in a territory
that has since, dissolved theirboundaries, such as West Berlin.
The frst concentration o exclaves
occurred during the Middle Ages
where a series o territories were
decentralized due to eudal rule.
These spaces were sel-sufcient
but still held allegiance to their
eudal lord. The disparate nature
o territories in the Middle Ages
created a eld o territories, that
made a patch-like environment.
The negotiation between these
dierentiated spaces was beore
the Treaty o Westphalia in 1668,
which can be considered the
modern ounding o territorial
states and boundaries. 24
Territorial discontinuity: MiddleAges and the original notion o
exclaves.
STRETCH BOUNDARYEXCLAVE:
HISTORY
EXCLAVE CLASSIFICATION
Nation intact Exclave stretches territorial boundary
True exclave
Pene- exclave
Pene- exclave
Quasi-exclave
1
4
2
3
14
1 2
3 4
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
17/94
CABINDA |ANGOLA|
POLITICAL DISPUTE
FRENCH GUIANA | FRANCE |
TIERRA DEL FUEGO ISLAND | ARGENTINA |
TEMBURONG DISTRICT | BRUNEI |
CYPRUS | TURKEY |
OECUSSI-AMBENO | EAST TIMOR |
ALASKA | USA |
IRELAND | UK |
LLIVIA | SP |
KALININGRAD OBLAST | RUSSIA |
MUSANDAM | OMAN |
GIBRALTAR | UK |
CUETA | SPAIN
MELILLA |SPAIN
PENON DE VLEZ DE LA GOMEZ | SPAIN
PENON DE ALHUCMAS | SPAIN
CHAFARINAS ISLANDS| SPAIN
DISPUTED EXCLAVES
15
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
18/94
STRAIT OF GIBRALTAR: FIELD OF TERRITORIES
16
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
19/94
1717
The Strait of Gibraltar is a unique moment in the boundary between the
Mediterranean Sea and the Atlantic Ocean. Not only is it a geopolitcal
sphere of complex boundaries with 5 areas of disputed territory, but the
straits geographric properties form another kind of spatial boundary.
While the strait is a meeting point between the Atlantic Ocean and theMediterranean Sea, it is also a meeting point of a top layer of warm fresh
water owing eastward into the Mediterranean and a bottom layer of colder
and salty layer ow westward into the Atlantic. Through this process,
solitons are formed, which are underwater waves maintaining shape while
traveling at a constant speed. A density boundary separates the layers at
a 330 foot depth. The Camarine Sill, at the very westward end of the Strait,
is the shallowest seaoor pass between the Iberian Peninsula and Africa, at
-918 feet, causing the waters from the Atlantic to rise to the Sill, then force
its way into the Strait. The Straits current, depending on the winds ows
between 2 - 4 knots (2.3 - 4.6 mi/hr), making the strait dangerous to cross.25
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
20/94
FIELD OF INVISIBLE BOUNDARIES
-200
-200-400
-400
-400
200
00
-600-200
-200
-600
-600
-600
-600
-600
-200
-200
-800
ALGECIRAS
UK
SPAIN
GIBRALTAR
TARIFA
CEUTA
TANGIER
14KM
10 km
3600
3545
3
615
18
Sea oor topography |in Meters|
Territorial waters boundary
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
21/94
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
22/94
DISPUTED TERRITORIES IN STRAIT
Penon de Velez de la GomeraPenon de Alhucemas
Melilla
Gibraltar
Ceuta
Chafarinas Islands
0 40km
20
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
23/94
Ceuta
POPULATION
77,289
71,448
29,431
60
190
>50
3 km
Melilla
Gibraltar
PenondeAlhucmas
ChafarinasIslands
PenonDeVe
lezdelaGomera
RELATIVE SIZES OF DISPUTED TERRITORIES
CededbyPortugal
Occupied
in
reference
to
TreatyofTordesillas
CededbytheSultan
Peacefullyoccupied
Cededbyforce
CededbySpain
21
Both Spain and Morocco claim over
sovereignty over ve territories in
the Strait of Gibraltar: Ceuta, Me-
lilla, Penon de Alhucmas, Penon
Velez de la Gomera, and the Cha-
farinas Islands in North Africa. The
most important of these is Ceuta.
Spain claims these territories based
mainly on historical terms: right ofconquest, terra nullis principles and
longevity of occupation. 26Spain also
argues that the territories are im-
portant for military security. All but
two territories, Ceuta and Melilla, are
under 1 sq miles in area and are only
military garrisons. As a composite of
Spanish hegemony near the Strait of
Gibraltar, these exclaves stretch the
boundary of Spain, creating a eld of
hegemony over the Strait of Gibral-
tar, pulling Moroccan land into theStrait, and consequently into the EU.
Moroccos argument maintains that
Spain claims the right to Gibraltar
from the UK, therefore nullifying their
own actions against the disputes
over the 5 exclaves with Morocco.
VS.
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
24/94
Strait territorySpain | Morocco | Strait of Gibraltar
Madrid
Spains exclaves
stretch boundary
Spains sovereignty creates
eld over Strait of Gibraltar
OVERLAP
STRAIT OF GIBRALTAR AND RESULTANT SPATIAL FIELDS
22
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
25/94
23
Because of its geostrategic importance, Ceuta
remains at the epicentre of the dispute [between
Morocco and Spain]; the future of the other four
plazas is directly contingent of that of Ceuta.27
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
26/94
25
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
27/94
Since 1993, There have been 13,621
documented refugee deaths in Fortress
Europe. These deaths constantly re-structure
the relationship between inside and outsideof the EU, increasingly evolving the nature
of the EUs transnational border-sphere.
25
30026
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
28/94
Drowning |shipwreck, river or lake|
Suicide
Lack of care |racist act|
Other|hypothermia, exhaustion, minefield
Policing
0
100
300
550
850
300
4002000 600 800 1000km
26
EU MIGRANT DEATHS
27
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
29/94
27
MIGRANT DEATHS AS FIELD INTENSITIES
28
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
30/94
28
INTERNAL|SUICIDE| VS. EXTERNAL |WATER CROSSING |DEATHS
29
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
31/94
INTERCONNECTED FIELD INTENSITIES | DEATHS AS EU BORDER RE-CONSTRUCTION
30
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
32/94
CEUTA AS SPACE DEFINING TRANSITION
BETWEEN ISLAM AND CHRISTIANITY
31
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
33/94
RELIGION IN AFRICA
Areas of Islam
%
-
Areas of Christianity
% 0 2 5 10 4 0 6 0 7 5 85 9 0 9 5 100 -90-100
32
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
34/94
SUB-SAHARAN MIGRANT ROUTES IN RELATION TO RELIGIOUS SPHERES OF INFLUENCE
2
1
3
1. The coast of Western Africa where pateras can access the Canary Islands.2. Travel through Libya to reach the coast of Malta and Italy.3. Travel through Saharan dessert, Morocco, and into Ceuta or Melilla.
The extreme dialectic between Christianity and Muslim territories is
physically manifested at the borders of Ceuta and Melilla, where literally the
Muslim territory of Morocco plays host to the Christian exclaves.
Sub-Saharan migrant routes Concentration of routes in relation to Christian-Spain
33
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
35/94
The distances migrants travel, as indicated by the furtherst points Kampala and
Mogadishu are nearly 2,570 km from the Strait of Gibraltar.
Michael Collyer describes the
fragmented journey that
migrants undergo as a result of
the mismatch between policy
response to transit migration and
the social organization engaged in
these fragmented journeys.28
2,570 kmKampala
Mogadishu
Ceuta
This mismatch is a result of thespatial morphology in response toterritorially based border controlimplementation as well as thegeographic difculties of the NorthAfrican region. The paradoxicalnature of this type of bordercontrol methodology fragmentsthe journeys of migrants moreincreasingly. Surprisingly, this hasnot mitigated migration arrivals.
Thus, border control may start as faraway from the actual border itself.The border in Ceuta, for instance,has become as symbolic as it isphysical even though it still a siphonfor the emergent Sub-Saharanmigration.
26
RELATIVE DISTANCES BETWEEN DEPARTURE CITIES
34
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
36/94
CEUTA AS PHYSICAL EMBODIMENT OF FORTRESS EUROPE
31
35
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
37/94
Ceuta Ceuta Ceuta Ceuta
Ceuta Ceuta Ceuta Ceuta
Migrants reach Ceuta
Migrants held in Ceuta for avg. 2-4 yrs. New border established at Strait of Gibraltar Migrant passes away in Strait | or reaches EU | Boundary extends, cycle repeats
Migrants wait outside border for 1-2 yrs. Migrants breach boundary, filters through Boundary accepts difference
BORDER CROSSING SCNEARIO
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
38/94
37
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
39/94
There is a paradox inherent within
the pattern of spatial morphology
associated with migration in North
Africa. While greater systems of
territoriality based control have
increased due to ineffectual linear
border control measures, they
have succeeded in increasing the
travel time of migrants. Due to this,
a greater impetus to nish ones
journey because of social and
monetary pressure is the norm. In
territorially based migration control,
the more the journey becomes
fragmented within various social
networks. Most paradoxically,
perhaps, is the fact that while more
control is established, the migrant
arrivals have are not hindered.29
PARADOXICAL MORPHOLOGY OF MIGRANTS
TERRITORIALLY
BASED MIGRATION
CONTROL
FRAGMENTED
JOURNEY
TIME OF
MIGRATION
CHANCE OFRETURN
SOCIAL
NETWORKS
MIGRATION
ARRIVALS
= + Time
= - Time
29
Data distributed according to place of arrival (Nr. of boats)
2003 2004 until 31/8/2005
Cdiz 130 75 -42% 36 -28%
Mlaga 25 32 28% 21 -5%
Almera 101 89 -12% 28 -59%
Granada 99 103 4% 40 -46%
Melilla 1 2 100% 16 1500%
Murcia 1 1 - - -
Gran Canaria 32 36 13% 44 132%
Lanzarote 145 17 -88% 9 -18%
Fuerteventura 390 239 -39% 38 -74%
Tenerife 13 2 -85% 5 150%
Ibiza 0 1 100% 0 -100%
http://extranjeros.mtas.es/es/general/NoticiasActualidad7aeb0b3823d6ac9f28d12e30dd2d19b4.html http://
extranjeros.mtas.es/es/general/PATERAS_2003_Y_2004.pdf
: Ministerio deTrabajo y Asuntos Sociales.GabinetedeComunicacinSource
5 143 2760% 42 180%Ceuta
Irregular immigration through small boats
38
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
40/94
TIMELINE OF BORDER CONTROL METHODS IN CEUTA
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
41/94
1999
2000 2001 2003 2004
2005
2006 2007 2008 2009
20102002 2004
First, the patterns of migrations to Europe are constantly changing; thus we can identify even newer geographies of
European migration. 30
In 1999, double
fences were
constucted in
Ceuta and Melilla.
The high tensionsteel fence had a
barbed wire top. 31
Caused migrantsto
move southward,such as the Canary
islands to try
and enter the EU
there. Emphasis is
spread from wall to
territorial elds.
Caused migration
shift back to Straitof Gibraltar. There
is an Increase in
migrants to Ceuta
and Melilla to cross
Strait.
The migrant camp
Bel Younes, outsideCeuta becomes
b o m b a r d e d
with migrants.
Estimates of 3,000
migrants in the
summer of 2004. 32
The Moroccan gov-
ernment agrees
to place controlson the Mediterra-
nean coast . SIVE
|Integrated Sys-
tem of External
Vigilance| is intro-
duced.
Entire North coast
of Africa named
zone rouge.
This zone had
zero tolerance of
u n d o c u m e n t e d
migrants. Territorial
based migration
control is in full
operation.
Territorially based
migration control
places emphasis
on the hinterlands
of Ceuta. The line,
as in the case of
the wall, acts more
symbolically, than it
did a decade ago.
Frontex established
as ofcial border
control agency of
the EU.
?
*
*
40
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
42/94
In Spain, persons who are arrested on
the basis of illegal entry or residence can
be detained for a maximum of 3 days.
*?If their national origin can be deter-mined, an expulsion process is initi-ated and can be detained at an in-
ternment center for up to 40 days.
BORDER PROCESS
A recent survey
in Morocco has
revealed thattheir average duration of
stay in the country is 2.5
years, with 25 percent
of them having arrived
between 4 and 12
years ago, 65 percent
between 1 and 3 years,
and only 10 percent
less than a year ago.33
Pending Expulsion
Grant of asylum or other permit
BORDER BORDER
Overstay
Border rejection
Return Unathorized entry Authorized Entry
Border rejection
RegularizationNon-Return
Illegal Residence Legal Residence
41
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
43/94
MIGRANTS SPEND ON
AVERAGE: 2-4 YEARS IN CEUTA
The migrants are subsequently
issued an expulsion order, but
by Spanish law cannot enforce
the actual removal of people.
42
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
44/94
CEUTA
43
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
45/94
The contour o the Ceuta morocco border
region is not static; Although it is fxed and
well defned at the Spanish side, it is elastic on
the Moroccan side. The border region contour
varies depending on how Ceutas hinterland is
conceptualised and spatially demarcated. 34
44
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
46/94
What You See
45
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
47/94
What Others see
46
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
48/94
What others See
TANGER-MEDPORT:EMERGINGWORLDMARKET
47
TANGIER MED-PORT AND PROXIMITY TO EU
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
49/94
+150,000 JOBS
Morocco'strade with the EU is booming: exports
rose from $7.11 in 2001 to $11.3 billion in 2006,
while imports jumped from $11 billion to $22.4
billion. Trade between Africa and Europe is also
increasing: Arican exports to the EU doubled
between 1999 and 2006 to $113 billion.34
TANGIER MED-PORT AND PROXIMITY TO EU
The Tanger-Med port is on course to reach
8 million containers, 7 million passengers,
700,000 trucks, 2 million vehicles, and 10
million MT of oil products by 2015. This willmake the Tanger-Med region a economic
force in the Mediterranean and in the world.
240 Vessels a day
150 vessels a day
>1,000 gross tonnage
73,000 vessels a year
Free Zone of
Oued Negro
T a n g i e r
Tanger-Med Port
1 in 5 container ships in the worldpass through the Strait o Gibraltar
2015 2015+2010
Ceuta
As a result o the increase o goods
between Morocco and the EU, Ceuta
is bombarded with material ows.In Ceuta, the goods predominantly
maniest in smuggled goods, and a
large black market is present. The
border, in an economic sense, is
constantly accepting these ows,
while acting as a blocker or others.
13 km
H i g h w a yRa i l roa d
Free Trade zones
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
50/94
To Ceuta
49
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
51/94
To Ceuta
Tanger Med-1
Tanger Med-
N
50
CEUTA PORT AND BORDER TRADE
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
52/94
Border Crossings
Ceuta was a free port from 1863-
>1863 1863-1956 >1956
51
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
53/94
Morocco does not allow legal cross-border trade.
However, Moroccan authorities allow it to happen
anyway. As documented by the Shenghen Agreement
of 14 June, 1985, Moroccans registered in the province
of Tetouan are allowed access into Ceuta without a visa
requirement for up to 24 hours. 37 This law is the loophole
to not only bring citizens in, but to smuggle goods across
the border.
The nearby city o Fnideq, 4 km south, hassurged rom this agreement with Ceuta.Ceutans ock to Fnideq to purchase lowerpriced goods and Moroccans ock to Ceutato sell goods on the street. The border allowsthis cross-border exchange.
1986 until joined the EU. Now,
it has a low-tax system within
the European Monetary System.
Items within Ceuta sell duty-free
and therefore increases tourism.
Additionally the exclave has a 50%
VAT reduction, which has prompted
industries to station themselvesnear the border, in an industrial
complex called Polygonal Tarajal. 35
We are a port city, but we really liveoff the military barracks and the
stuff we smuggle into Morocco.36
52
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
54/94
38N-352 highway to Fnideq
FLOWS AND ECONOMIES
53
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
55/94
Ofcial border crossing into Ceuta 39
54
onNO. OF PEOPLE CROSSING BORDER DAILY
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
56/94
*If Ceuta is a part of Spain, then
it is intrinsically conjoined toMorocco, both through current
social and cultural practices and
through a history of interrelation.
As such, Ceuta is also a bridge
between First World and Third.40
= 500 people
Spain
Morocco
13, 000 3 0, 000 77, 589
Ceutapopulatio
Ceutans
Moroccans
55
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
57/94
Polygonal Tarajal | industrial complex |
Principle Alfonso |All Muslim slum| pop. 12,000
* GDP
GDP
56
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
58/94
SPAIN
MOROCCO$145.6billion
$1.362
trillion
POPULATION VS. GDP
57
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
59/94
SPAIN
MOROCCO
$1.362
trillionPop:
31.6million
Pop:
46.5
Million
$145.6billion
58
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
60/94
But the winds of change seem to be blowingacross the border landscape. The pattern of cross-
border trade [in Ceuta] is rapidly evolving dueto a number of factors. Mainly: gradual
commercial debordering between EU and
Morocco; free-trade agreements signed byMorocco with the US and China; substantial
investment and infrastructural transformations
taking place in the north of Morocco. 41
59
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
61/94
42
60
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
62/94
CEUTA AS MOROCCAN?
CEUTA TIMELINE
DED
OMOUS
61
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
63/94
CARTHAGINIANS
CHRISTIAN
ISLAM
CHRISTIAN
ROMANS
VANDALS
BYZANTINES
OMEYYADS
ALMORAVIDS
INDEPENDENT
MARINIDS
HAFSIDS
MOROCCO
PORTUGUESE
CEUTAFOUND
CEUTAISAUTONO
TRE
ATYOFLISON
YEARS OF RULE
42 AD600 BC
1031 AD
1415
1668
1995
SPAIN
279
389
105
175
352
149
3
23
6
7
88
12
165
430
948
550
595
INDEPENDENT
INDEPENDENT
CARTHEGINIANS
ROMANS
ANDALS
BYZANTINES
OMEYYADS
LMORAVIDS
INDEPENDENT
MARINIDSHAFSIDS
MOROCCO
PORTUGUESE
SPAIN
279
389
94
175
352
149
3
23
57
88
12
INDEPENDENT
INDEPENDENT
POPULATIONS OF MUSLIMS IN CEUTA PER DISTRICT
62
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
64/94
>50
51-200
51-200
51-200
51-200
12,000 (2010)
1986 2010
Fuente: Instituto Nacional de Estadistica. 1986.
There are presently approximately
27,000 Muslims living in Ceuta, which
is 40% o Ceutas population. 12,000
live in the slum, Principe Alonso,
which is half of the total population of
Ceutas Muslim population.43It is the
rst residential area one sees when
crossing from Morocco into Spain.
MUSLIM POPULATION AS ENCLAVES
Neutral Zone Border Border ?
MOROCCAN PROJECTIONS
63
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
65/94
The marker of this holiday
signals a slow but improving
acceptance of the Muslim
citizens in Ceuta. The
signicance of this event is a
critical step in Ceuta garnering
a supportive partnership
between the two countries,
and as a rapidly developing
economic sphere, Ceuta may
be poised to allow the exchange
of culture in a denitive way.
Dec 2_2010 2050
By 2050, Moroccospopulation will be 60%larger than Spains.
1950
28 million
Spanish | Morocco population projections
Source: World population Prospects: 2000 Revision (United Nations Population Division, 2001.)
39.9 million 31.2 million8.9 million 29.8million 50.3 million
20002050
64
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
66/94
BOUNDARY AS FIELD
44
65
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
67/94
How can architecture utilize the
emergent territorial dynamics
between Ceuta and Morocco as a
catalyst to propose a space of ltering
that dematerializes the border but
simultaneously allows for its presence?
Paradoxically, together with
the selective militarization of
Ceutas perimeter, the evolution
of territorial dynamics in the
border region suggests the
gradual socio-economicamalgamation between
the two sides o the border.
...The new confguration o
power relations between Ceuta
and Morocco (understood as the
new distribution of geopolitical
and geoeconomic inuence
capacity between the two sides
of the border) might requirethe reconcezptualization
o cross-border political
interaction in the region.
...In this mileu, dialogue and
co-operation between the two
main local political institutions
(ciudad Autonoma de Ceuta and
Municipalite de Fnideq) could
be depicted as a potentially
constructive management tool of
current border territorial dynamics.
...co-operation potentialities
cannot be detached from the
extraordinary urban development
in the border region. Urban
continuity across the border
gains salience and it suggests
the prospective forging of a
cross-border metropolitan
amalgamation between Ceutaand its hinterland. In this context,
the room, as well as the need
for cross-border management
initiatives is presumably growing.4 5
Ceuta is at the crossroads o not
only Third world and First, but
exists as a place o limbo or the
temporary inhabitants o the
city. The surrounding territory
is poised to have a larger say in
international economics, as the
Tanger-Med Port will become amajor international player in port
handling. This catalyst , along with
the gradual acceptance o Muslim
tradition in Ceutamakes the borderreconceptualization critical in the
our current transnational world.
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
68/94
67
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
69/94
CONNECT TO FNIDEQ WITH A FIELD
UTILIZE THE CONDITIONS THAT EXIST
Physical borderSITE
68
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
70/94
100 M 275M 370 M 505 M
Beginningofbordercrossingsequence
Bordercrossing
Geopoliticalborder
E
ndofMoroccanbordersequence
TerritoriallimitbetweenCeuta|Fnideq
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
71/94
70
OPERATIONS
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
72/94
Existing situation Ceuta | Fnideq proximity
Fnideq
Ceuta
2 km
71
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
73/94
Extend eld | dissolve boundary Cross-program
72
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
74/94
Build eld Allow for islands to settle
73
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
75/94
Dissolve maritime border Re-connect built program with local conditions
74
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
76/94
HYBRID ZONE CREATED WHERE BOUNDARY IS DISSOLVED. FLOWS COME FROM ANY DIRECTION
75
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
77/94
FIELD CONDITIONS TREATS CONSTRAINTS AS OPPORTUNITY AND
MOVES AWAY FROM A MODERNIST ETHIC- AND AESTHETICS-
OF TRANSGRESSION. WORKING WITH AND NOT AGAINST SITE,
SOMETHING NEW IS PRODUCED BY REGISTERING THE COMPLEXITY
OF THE GIVEN....FIELD CONDITIONS ARE BOTTOM-UP PHENOMENA:
DEFINED NOT BY OVERARCHING GEOMETRICAL SCHEMAS BUT BYTHE INTRICATE LOCAL CONNECTIONS. FORM MATTERS, BUT NOT SO
MUCH THE FORMS OF THINGS AS THE FORMS BETWEEN THINGS. 46
Physical borderSITE
76
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
78/94
100 M 275M 370 M 505 M
Beginningofbordercrossingsequence
Bordercrossing
Geopoliticalborder
EndofMoroccanbordersequence
TerritoriallimitbetweenCeuta|Fnideq
TOURISM
FISHING
INDUSTRIALSERVICES
INDUSTRIALSERVICES
BLACKMARKET
BLACKMARKET
SPANISHGOODS
MOROCCANGOODS
TOURISM
FISHING
77
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
79/94
1.5 KM
TerritorialedgeofFnideq
SPANISHGOODS
MOROCCANGOODS
78
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
80/94
PRECEDENTS
In Cordoba, for example, independent elements are combined additively to form an indeterminate whole...the local syntax
isxed butthereisnooverarchinggeometricscaffolding Partsarenotfragmentsofwholesbutsimplyparts thestructure
PRECEDENT: MOSQUE OF CORDOBA
79
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
81/94
Mosque designed to
typological standard
Hall lengthened by
eight bays, new
entrance addedHall lengthened by
12 bays, qibla and
mihrab addedSize doubled with addition of
12 bays. Mihrab decorated and
separated from rest of mosque,
producing a maqsura, a decorated
screen in front of the mihrab.Hall widened along one side by
eight naves
Abd-ar-Rahman Abd-ar-Rahman I Abd-ar-Rahman II Al Hakam II784-786
833-852784-786 961 987
is xed, but there is no overarching geometric scaffolding.Parts are not fragments of wholes but simply parts...the structure
can be added to without substantial morphological transformation. Field congurations are inherently expandable...45
Boundary is dissolved
within the interior. Each
new addition createsan outer boundary, but
the feld dissolves the
previous boundaries.
Al-Mansur Ibn Abi Aamir
1286King Ferdinand III of Castile takes Cordoba
80
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
82/94
The Mosque of Cordoba is a space that contains two
different ideologies of form and content. The use of the
eld and the object simultaneously produce a hybrid
architectural space that are both within each other as
an objects, but experientially separate from one another.
While standing at the intersection of the phenomenological
boundary of the two, one understands both conditions
simultaneously. At this moment, the object and eld
both construct this boundary, and dissolve others.
MOSQUEOF
CORDO
BA
HYBRIDITY AND |RE| ORIENTATION
81
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
83/94
14th-18th centuries
Mosque turned into Catedral de Crdoba_King Charles V
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
84/94
PRECEDENT: MEDINA | BOOK OF WALLS | MOROCCON COURTYARD TYPOLOGY
83
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
85/94
The Book of Walls records from a legal perspective
building-related conicts-contestations and|or
transgressions- plus their solutions that occured in, and
referred to, the medinas environments semi-private
and public spaces....The Book of Walls established
and embodied a legal aesthetic of urban architectural
space: a way of thinking about, or judging this space, and
hence organizing it. this aesthetic was exible, as it was
informed by local custom and commonly negotiated via an
application mechanism responsive to local conditions...50
If two men contest a party wall;
On the wall between the neighbors
and neither one has roong, and one
of them permits the other to place a
roof over the wall. Then he appears
to him and says: Remove your roof!;
If a man buys a wall and no mention is
made of its land, the sale occurs on the
wall without the land. Then it is said to
be the purchaser: Remove your wall!
If a man buys half a wall;
If a man establishes a wall [next] to
another, and does no more than that
the wall belongs to the place by its land;
If the bottom of a wall belongs toone man and the top of it to another;
On the collapsed wall: if one of two owners
wants to rebuild it but the other refuses,
can the latter be forced to rebuilt it? 51
Case titles from Kitb al-Htn
Buildings built within a Moroccan
medina have a central, open-air atrium
space that acts as lobby, circulation,
dinning room, and common room.Together, the voids within the medina
create a eld of local conditions
innitely tied to one another,
separated only by ones party walls.
Medina as feld
SPECULATION
CONNECT TO FNIDEQ.
84
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
86/94
Q
UTILIZE FISHING INDUSTRY.
DISSOLVE MARITIME BORDER.
EMBRACE MOROCCAN SOUK TRADITIONS.
CONNECT MUSLIM NEIGHBORHOOD PRINCIPE ALFONSO ACROSS BORDER.
ALLOW ARCHITECTURAL MANIFESTATION OF MATERIAL FLOWS ACROSS BORDER.
CREATE SPACE OF HYBRIDITY, BOTH PROGRAMMATICALLY, AND SPATIALLY.
ARCHITECTURE WILL DERIVE FROM RELATIONSHIPS WITHIN FIELD.
RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN PROGRAM AND ELEMENTS IS CRITICAL.
ALLOW EXISTING CONDITIONS TO DETERMINE PROGRAMMATIC HYBRID AMALGAMATIONS.
SPECULATE ON THE NATURE OF THE TANGER-MED FREE TRADE ZONE AREA.
CEUTA AS A LINK IS CRITICAL.
ARCHITECTURE IS RESULTANT FROM FORCES THAT, IN 2010, ARE PHYSICALLY SALIENT.
ARCHITECTURE DERIVES FROM REAL DATA AND REAL SITUATIONS HAPPENING RIGHT NOW.
ARCHITECTURE AS CLANDESTINE BENEFACTOR.
PRODUCTIVE BORDERS.
85
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
87/94
1. Holmes, Brian, Charles Heller, and Ursula Biemann. Maghreb Connection. Barcelona: Actar, 2006.
2 Smith Michael P Transnational Urbanism: Locating Globalization Malden MA: Blackwell Publishers 2001
APPENDIX
86
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
88/94
2. Smith, Michael P. Transnational Urbanism: Locating Globalization. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishers, 2001.3. Balilty, Oded. Power of One. Digital image. Accessed October 28, 2010. http://static.wix.com/media/85265415b72feebd854137
a40a1ff616.wix_mp.
4. Bhabha, Homi K. The Location of Culture. London: Routledge, 1994.
5. Souare, Issaka K. The Perilous Journey of Sub-Saharan African Emigrants to Europe: Why Take the Risk? Report. Institute forSecurity Studies.
6. Souare. Perilous Journey. 3.7. Holmes, Brian, Charles Heller, and Ursula Biemann. Maghreb Connection. Barcelona: Actar, 2006.8. Sovereignty - Denition and More from the Free Merriam-Webster Dictionary. Merriam-Webster Online. Accessed November 03,
2010. http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/sovereignty9. Exclave - Denition and More from the Free Merriam-Webster Dictionary. Merriam-Webster Online. Accessed November 02,
2010. http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/exclave. Enclave - Denition and More from the Free Merriam-Webster Dictio nary.Merriam-Webster Online. Accessed November 02, 2010. http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/enclave.
10. Collyer. In-Between Places. 670.11. Parker, Noel. The Geopolitics of Europes Identity: Centers, Boundaries and Margins. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2008.12.
Parker. Geopolitics of Europes Identity. 143.13. Parker. Geopolitics of Europes Identity. 144.14. Migration Control and Migrant Fatalities at the Spanish-African Borders. International Migration Review 41, no. 2
(2007): 316-43. doi:10.1111/j.1747-7379.2007.00070.x.15. Collyer, Michael.In-Between Places: Trans-Saharan Transit Migrants in Morocco and the Fragmented Journey to Europe.
Antipode 34, no. 4 (2007): 668-90.16. Collyer. In-Between Places. 670.17. Human Migration. Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia. Accessed November 03, 2010. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_
migration.18. Collyer. In-Between Places. 672.19. Carling. Migration Control. 325.20. Cimadomo, Guido, and Pilar Martinez Ponce. Ceuta and Melilla: A Defensive System? Rep. Sarai Reader. Web. 10 Oct. 2010. .21. Treaty Establishing the European Economic Community, EEC Treaty - Original Text (non-consolidated Version). EUROPA The Ofcial
Website of the European Union. July 10, 2007. Accessed November 03, 2010. http://europa.eu/legislation_ummaries/institutional_affairs/treaties/treaties_eec_en.htm.The Schengen Area and Cooperation. EUROPAl33020_en.htm.
22. Treaty Establishing the European Economic Community, EEC Treaty - Original Text (non-consolidated Version). EUROPA The Ofcial
Website of the European Union. July 10, 2007. Accessed November 03, 2010. http://europa.eu/legislation_ummaries/institutional affairs/treaties/treaties eec en.htm.The Schengen Area and Cooperation. EUROPA
87
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
89/94
ummaries/institutional_affairs/treaties/treaties_eec_en.htm.The Schengen Area and Cooperation. EUROPAl33020_en.htm.
23. Houtum, Henk Van, and Roos Pijpers. Eurozine - Towards a Gated Community - Henk Van Houtum, Roos Pijpers. Eurozine -Headlines. October 27, 2010. Accessed October 28, 2010. http://www.eurozine.com/articles/2005-01-12-houtumpijpers-
en.html24. Catudal, Honore M. Exclaves. Rep. Www.eurodit.com. Web. 1 Dec. 2010. .s25. U-Boats, Density Currents, and the Strait of Gibraltar. Web. 23 Nov. 2010. .26. OReilly, Gerry. Gibraltar: Sovereignty Disputes and Territorial Waters. Rep. Durham University/International Boundaries Research Unit.
Web. 2 Oct. 2010. .27. OReilly. Gibraltar: Sovereignty Disputes. 2428. Collyer. In-Between Places. 687.29. Collyer. In-Between Places. 684.30. Collyer, Michael, Franck Duvell, and Hein De Haas. Critical Approaches to Transit Migration. Rep. Wiley Online Libary, 2010. Wiley Online
Library. Web. 13 Nov. 2010. .31. Collyer. In-Between Places. 684.32. Collyer. In-Between Places. 684.33. Fargues, Phillipe. Work, Refuge, Transit: An Emerging Pattern of Irregular Immigration South and East of the Mediterranean.
International Migration Review 43.3 (2009): 544-77. Wiley Online Library. Web. 20 Nov. 2010.
34. Special Report: North Africa - Tangiers Global Bid. TangerMed Port. Web. 09 Dec. 2010. .
35. Harbers, Arjan, and Kristin Jensen. Reciprocal Developments. Rep. Topotronic. Web. 5 Dec. 2010. .
36. Losa, Alvaro Largas. Ceutas Scream. The Independent Institute, December 9, 2009. http://http://www.independent.org/newsroom/article.asp?id=2676.
37. Ferrer-Gallardo, Xavier. Territorial Discontinuity. 7.38. Loose, Ronaldinho. To Fnideq. Digital image. Panoramio. February 17, 2007. Accessed November 3, 2010. http://
commondatastorage.googleapis.com/static.panoramio.com/photos/original/19100380.jpg.39. Loose, Ronaldinho. Border. Digital image. Panoramio. February 17, 2009. Accessed November 3, 2010. http://
commondatastorage.googleapis.com/static.panoramio.com/photos/original/19100218.jpg.40. Sampedro, Benita, and Simon R. Doubleday. Border Interrogations: Questioning Spanish Frontiers. New York: Berghahn, 2008. Print.41. Ferrer-Gallardo, Xavier. Territorial Discontinuity. 7.42. Siebert, Moritz. Grenzzaun Berge. Digital image. Flickr.com. Yahoo! Inc., 26 Mar. 2006. Web. 28 Oct. 2010. .43. Jordan, Javier, and Humberto Trujillo. Favourable Situations for the Jihadist Recruitment: The Neighborhood of Principe Alfonso (Ceuta,
88
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
90/94
, , j g p ( ,Spain). Jihad Monitor (2006): 1-7. JihadMonitor.org, 27 Nov. 2006. Web. 25 Oct. 2010.
44. Gerster, Georg, and Ch Trmpler. The past from Above: Aerial Photographs of Archaeological Sites. Los Angeles, CA: J. Paul GettyMuseum, 2005.
45. Ferrer-Gallardo, Xavier. Territorial Discontinuity. 12.46. Allen, Stan. From Object to Field. Architectural Design67 N. 5-6 May-June 1997: 24-31. Print.47. Allen. Object to Field. 25.48. Wilson, Mark. Mark Wilson, e10910, 2010 Archival Ink Jet Print. Digital image. Mark Wilson. Web. 14 Dec. 2010. 49. Wilson, Mark. Mark Wilson, Untitled, 1973 Drawing. Digital image. Mark Wilson. Web. 4 Dec. 2010.
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
91/94
2. Aguileria, Antonio. Portaderas. Digital image. Panoramio. January 14, 2009. Accessed November 3, 2010. http://commondatastorage.googleapis.com/static.panoramio.com/photos/original/17840109.jpg.
3. Allen, Stan. From Object to Field. Architectural Design67 N. 5-6, May/June 1997.4. Andres, Carlos De. Arket of Clothes in Ceuta Clothes Market Stands in a Square of Ceuta. Digital image. Getty Images. April 26, 2006.
Accessed December 4, 2010. http://www.gettyimages.com/detail/89660298/Hulton-Archive.5. Balilty, Oded. Power of One. Digital image. Accessed October 28, 2010. http://static.wix.com/media/85265415b72feebd854137a40a1
ff616.wix_mp.6. Bhabha, Homi K. The Location of Culture. London: Routledge, 1994.7. Bittner, Regina, Wilfried Hackenbroich, and Kai Vckler. Transnationale Rume = Transnational Spaces. Berlin: Jovis, 2007.8. Border Trouble Europes New Wall. Digital image. June 04, 2006. Accessed October 18, 2010. http://www.spiegel.de/international/0,1518,
grossbild-524370-410178,00.html.9. Borjaventura. Valla Fronteriza En Benz, Ceuta. Digital image. Flickr.com. November 23, 2007. Accessed December 4, 2010. http://www.
ickr.com/photos/24154220@N05/2326741117/.10. Carling, Jrgen. Migration Control and Migrant Fatalities at the Spanish-African Borders. International Migration Review 41, no. 2 (2007):
316-43. doi:10.1111/j.1747-7379.2007.00070.x.11.
Catudal, Honore M. Exclaves. Report. Accessed December 1, 2010. http://www.erudit.org/revue/cgq/1974/v18/n43/021178ar.pdf.12. Cimadomo, Guido, and Pilar Martinez Ponce. Ceuta and Melilla: A Defensive System? Report. Accessed October 10, 2010. http://www.sarai.net/publications/readers/06-turbulence/10_guido.pdf.
13. Collyer, Michael, Franck Duvell, and Hein De Haas. Critical Approaches to Transit Migration. Report. Wiley Online Libary, 2010. AccessedNovember 13, 2010. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/psp.630/pdf.
14. Collyer, Michael. In-Between Places: Trans-Saharan Transit Migrants in Morocco and the Fragmented Journey to Europe. Antipode 34, no.4 (2007): 668-90.
15. Death at the Border | Abolish Foreignness. Abolish Foreignness | All Human Beings Are Born Free and Equal in Dignity and Rights. UDHRArt. 1. Accessed November 01, 2010. http://www.abolishforeignness.org/blog/death-at-the-border.
16. Digital image. THE GOOD CLUB OF TOURISM. Accessed November 19, 2010. http://translate.google.com/translate?js=n&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&layout=2&eotf=1&sl=es&tl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.tvradioturismo.com%2Findex.php%3Fdisplay%3Dcontent%26opc%3D1040&act=url.
17. Dirdal, Kjartend, and Sylva Van De Wetering. Reception Of Asylum Seekers in Spain. Report. 2005.18. Enclave - Denition and More from the Free Merriam-Webster Dictionary. Merriam-Webster Online. Accessed November 02, 2010. http://
www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/enclave.19. European Borders Controls, Detention and Deportations. Report. Accessed December 6, 2010. http://www.statewatch.org/news/2010/
nov/migreurop-annual-report-nov-10.pdf.20. European Union. Signature of the Acts of Accession of Spain and Portugal in the EC. Digital image. European Commision Audiovisual
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
92/94
original/19100380.jpg.39. Loose, Ronaldinho. To Fnideq. Digital image. Panoramio. February 17, 2007. Accessed November 3, 2010. http://commondatastorage.
googleapis.com/static.panoramio.com/photos/original/19100380.jpg.
91
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
93/94
g g p / p /p / g / jpg40. Mara Ortuo, Jos. Migration, Asylum and Security: The Case of Ceuta and Melilla. In MIGRATION, ASYLUM AND SECURITY Border
Challenges in an Enlarged EU, 1-14. Proceedings of The Changing Landscape of European Liberty and Security, The Victoria Hotel,George Borg Olivier Street (Malta), Silema.
41. Melilla. Digital image. Fortress Europe, Festung Europa in Ceuta. May 05, 2005. Accessed October 21, 2010. http://www.all4all.org/2005/10/2126.shtml.
42. Migrant Deaths along the Mexico United States Border. Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia. Accessed October 30, 2010. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Migrant_deaths_along_the_Mexico__United_States_border.
43. Moroccans demonstrating against the visit of Spains King Juan Carlos. Digital image. November 05, 2007. Accessed December 4, 2010.http://www.daylife.com/photo/08QpbARbpp30h.
44. Mur De Ceuta. Digital image. Accessed November 2, 2010. http://avenirdeleurope.eurogoo.com/villes-d-europe-f20/basse-terre-ceuta-funchal-hamilton-mamoudzou-st-p-port-t1008.htm.
45. News Ceuta - 19/11/1910. Google Translate. November 19, 2010. Accessed December 02, 2010. http://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&tl=en&u=http://www.rtve.es/mediateca/videos/20101119/noticias-ceuta---19-11-10/935516.shtml.
46. OReilly, Gerry. Ceuta and the Spanish Sovereign Territories: Spanish and Moroccan Claims. Report. No. 2 ed. Vol. 1.47. OReilly, Gerry. Gibraltar: Sovereignty Disputes and Territorial Waters. Report. Accessed October 2, 2010. http://www.dur.ac.uk/resources/
ibru/publications/full/bsb7-1_oreilly.pdf.48. Parker, Noel. The Geopolitics of Europes Identity: Centers, Boundaries and Margins. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2008.49. Pinto, Jose Manuel. Border Morocco-Ceuta. Digital image. Panoramio. December 31, 2008. Accessed November 3, 2010. http://
commondatastorage.googleapis.com/static.panoramio.com/photos/original/17337223.jpg.50. Saddiki, Said. Ceuta and Melilla Fences: a EU Multidimensional Border? Report. Accessed November 1, 2010. http://www.cpsa-acsp.ca/
papers-2010/Saddiki.pdf.51. Sampedro, Benita, and Simon R. Doubleday. Border Interrogations: Questioning Spanish Frontiers. New York: Berghahn Books, 2008.52. Sanchez, Rafael Myro, and Carmen Diaz Mora. The Integration of Spain into the European Union: Main Industrial Effects. Report. Accessed
October 31, 2010. http://www.ucm.es/info/ecap2/myro_r/Spanish%20Integration%20(1).pdf.53. The Schengen Area and Cooperation. EUROPA The Ofcial Website of the European Union. Accessed November 01, 2010. http://
europa.eu/legislation_summaries/justice_freedom_security/free_movement_of_persons_asylum_immigration/l33020_en.htm.
54. Siebert, Moritz. Grenzzaun Am Haus. Digital image. Flickr.com. March 26, 2006. Accessed October 28, 2010. http://www.ickr.com/photos/su_mo/145614781/in/set-72057594134561901/.
55. Siebert, Moritz. Grenzzaun Berge. Digital image. Flickr.com. March 26, 2006. Accessed October 28, 2010. http://www.ickr.com/photos/su_mo/145614915/in/set-72057594134561901/.
56. Siebert, Moritz. Grenzzaun Meer. Digital image. Flickr.com. March 25, 2006. Accessed October 28, 2010. http://www.ickr.com/photos/su_mo/145615008/in/set-72057594134561901/.
57. Smith, Michael P. Transnational Urbanism: Locating Globalization. Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishers, 2001.58. Souare, Issaka K. The Perilous Journey of Sub-Saharan African Emigrants to Europe: Why Take the Risk? Report. Institute for Security
Studies.
92
8/8/2019 Final Book_jan 6_2010 Opt
94/94
59. Sovereignty - Denition and More from the Free Merriam-Webster Dictionary. Merriam-Webster Online. Accessed November 03, 2010.http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/sovereignty.
60. SPAIN: ISLAMIC FEAST OF SACRIFICE OFFICIAL IN CEUTA, MELILLA - Spain - ANSAMED.info. ANSAmed. November 17, 2010. Accessed
December 02, 2010. http://www.ansamed.info/en/spagna/news/ME.XEF86958.html.61. Special Report: North Africa - Tangiers Global Bid. TangerMed Port. Accessed December 09, 2010. http://tangermed.blogspot.
com/2008/10/special-report-north-africa-tangiers.html.62. TATE ETC. - Europes Largest Art Magazine. Tate: British and International Modern and Contemporary Art. Accessed October 30, 2010.
http://www.tate.org.uk/tateetc/issue19/rightsofpassage.htm.63. Territory | Dene Territory at Dictionary.com. Dictionary.com | Find the Meanings and Denitions of Words at Dictionary.com. Accessed
November 03, 2010. http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/territory.64. Treaty Establishing the European Economic Community, EEC Treaty - Original Text (non-consolidated Version). EUROPA The Ofcial
Website of the European Union. July 10, 2007. Accessed November 03, 2010. http://europa.eu/legislation_summaries/institutional_affairs/treaties/treaties_eec_en.htm.
65. U-Boats, Density Currents, and the Strait of Gibraltar. Accessed November 23, 2010. http://formontana.net/uboats.html.66. Vargas Llosa, Alvaro. Ceutas Scream: Newsroom. The Independent Institute. December 09, 2009. Accessed December 04, 2010. http://
www.independent.org/newsroom/article.asp?id=2676.67. OMeara, Simon. Space and Muslim Urban Life: at the Limits of the Labyrinth of Fez. London: Routledge, 2007. Print.68. Wilson, Mark. Mark Wilson, e10910, 2010 Archival Ink Jet Print. Digital image. Mark Wilson. Web. 14 Dec. 2010. .69. Mark. Mark Wilson, Untitled, 1973 Drawing. Digital image. Mark Wilson. Web. 4 Dec. 2010.
Top Related