Download - Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Transcript
Page 1: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Ecological Tax Reform

Theory and Reality

Page 2: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Education

Labeling

Liability Regimes

Regulation

Voluntary AgreementsPermitTrading

Taxation

Page 3: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

environmental taxation

Page 4: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Tax base x Tax rate Tax revenue=

Page 5: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Tax base x Tax rate Tax revenue=

a case study in theory

Page 6: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Tax base x Tax rate Tax revenue=

a case study in tax policy

Page 7: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Tax base x Tax rate Tax revenue=

a case study in politics

Page 8: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Theories

• Pigouvian theory

Page 9: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Pigouvian Theory

tax base x tax rate = tax revenue↓

external cost

Page 10: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Theories

• Pigouvian theory

• Polluter pays principle

Page 11: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Polluter Pays Principle

tax base x tax rate = tax revenue↓

for what?

Page 12: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Polluter Pays Principle

tax base x tax rate = tax revenue↓

external costsrestoration costs

cost required to abate pollution

Page 13: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Theories

• Pigouvian theory

• Polluter pays principle

• Least cost abatement

Page 14: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Least Cost Abatement

tax base x tax rate = tax revenue↓

cost required to abate pollution

Page 15: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Theories

• Pigouvian theory

• Polluter pays principle

• Least cost abatement

• Double dividend

Page 16: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.
Page 17: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Double Dividend

tax base x tax rate = tax revenue↓

tax rate under another theory that provides sufficient revenue for

tax reduction

Page 18: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

The Choice

tax base x tax rate = tax revenue↓

external costsrestoration costs

cost required to abate pollutioncost required for tax reduction

Page 19: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Tax base x Tax rate Tax revenue=

a case study in tax policy

Page 20: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Tax policies affecting the tax base

• Environmental effectiveness

• Administrative feasibility

• Economic effect

Page 21: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.
Page 22: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Tax policies affecting the tax base

• Environmental effectiveness

• Administrative feasibility

• Economic effect

Page 23: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Tax policies affecting the tax base

• Environmental effectiveness

• Administrative feasibility

• Economic effect

• Equity

Page 24: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Tax policies affecting the tax base

• Environmental effectiveness

• Administrative feasibility

• Economic effect

• Equity

• Still environmentally effective?

Page 25: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Tax base x Tax rate Tax revenue=

a case study in politics

Page 26: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

tax base x tax rate = tax revenue ↓

- $$$

+ $$$

Page 27: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Proposed energy incentives

• Wind and biomass -- $1 billion

• Solar -- $71 million

• Alternative fuel vehicles -- $2.4 billion

• Politically easy; fiscally difficult

Page 28: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Environmental tax increase

Dedicated revenues=

How to spend the money?

Deficit reduction

Other tax relief

Page 29: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Where is the political will?

Page 30: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Effective fabric or the emperor’s new clothes?

Page 31: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

The evidence to date

Page 32: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Tolerance Principles

• Iterative approach

• Best available alternative

• Cost allocation ethic

• Educational function

Page 33: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Effective fabric or the emperor’s new clothes?

Page 34: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Ecological Tax Reform

Theory and Reality

Page 35: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Education

Labeling

Liability Regimes

Regulation

Voluntary AgreementsPermitTrading

Taxation

Page 36: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

U.S. Taxes in 2000

• $2 trillion federal tax revenues

• $540 billion state tax revenues

• $332 billion local tax revenues

• Total -- $2.9 trillion

Page 37: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.

Taxation -- and Environment

Taxation Environment

Environmental Taxes

Page 38: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.
Page 39: Ecological Tax Reform Theory and Reality. Education Labeling Liability Regimes Regulation Voluntary Agreements Permit Trading Taxation.