Download - Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

Transcript
Page 1: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic FieldsD Cowell1, S Staples2 , C Vo1, P Jarram3, B Varcoe2, S Freear1

1 School of Electronic and Electrical Engineering,2 School of Physics and Astronomy,

University of Leeds, UK

3 Speir Hunter Ltd,Long Bennington, Newark, UKBooth 429, CORROSION 2013

Information in this presentation is propriety to Speir Hunter Limited.Not to be disclosed without permission.

Page 2: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

2

Overview

• Motivation for remote stress measurement

• Stress Concentration Tomography (SCT)

• Magnetoelastic effects in steel

• Experimental measurement of stress-magnetisation

• Finite element modelling of stress

• Finite element modelling of stress-magnetisation

• Experimental magnetic field characterisation rig

• Prototype SCT instrumentation

• Initial field survey results

STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Page 3: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

3

Motivation

• Ageing global pipeline infrastructure

• Non-invasive, remote, pipeline integrity assessment

• Applicable to non-piggable pipelines

• Non-interruption of pipeline service

• No change to operating parameters

• Detection of stress not geometry

STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Page 4: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

4

Stress ConcentrationTomography (SCT)

• Analyse changes in magnetic field along the pipeline

• Reporting

• Location of abnormal stresses

• Metallurgical and mechanical conditions

• Maximum allowable operating pressure (MAOP)

• Safe operating term

STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Page 5: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

5

Stress ConcentrationTomography (SCT)

• Pipeline experiences stress

• Corrosion Anomaly

• Stress Corrosion and Metallurgical Defects

• Slippage

• Subsidence

STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Page 6: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

6

Stress ConcentrationTomography (SCT)

Defective section

1

Defective section

2

Defective section

3

Length of

anomaly 1

Length of

Anomaly 2

Length of

anomaly 3

Pipeline

Magnetic field

STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Page 7: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

7STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Page 8: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

8

Magnetoelastic effects

Joule MagnetostrictionChange in sample dimension in the direction of the applied field

Villari EffectChange in magnetization due to applied stress

STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Page 9: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

9

Stress-magnetisation in carbon steel

2003 Jiles, Li, IEEE Trans. Mag, 39, 3037

STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Page 10: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

10

Experimental Investigation ofStress-Magnetisation in Carbon Steel

Page 11: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

11STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Physical Composition [%wt] Mechanical Properties

C Si Mn Cr Ni OthersTensile

Strength[N/mm]

YieldPoint

[N/mm]

0.42 -0.50

0.17-0.37

0.50-0.80

<0.25 <0.25 <0.035 570 295

Stress-Magnetisation in Carbon SteelExperimental Setup

• 20 x 210 mm rectangular sample• #45 Carbon Steel• 3 axis fluxgate magnetometer• Cyclic force

• 0-10-0 kN• 0-250-0 MPa

Page 12: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

12

Stress-Magnetisation in Carbon SteelProcessed Experimental Results

STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Page 13: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

13

FE Modelling of Magnetic Scalar Potential in Stressed Steel Bar

Page 14: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

14

FE Modelling of Magnetic Scalar Potential in Stressed Steel Bar

FEM of the Magnetic Scalar Potential of the Steel Bar Stressed to 120 MPa

STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Page 15: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

15

Comparison betweenExperimental and FEM Results

Experiment image of field compared to model calculated image

STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Page 16: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

16

FEM of Cracked Steel Bar

STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Page 17: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

17

Magnetic detection ofStress Concentration Zones (SCZ)

Page 18: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

Characteristic curves of Self Magnetic Flux Leakage(SMFL)

SCZ

Graphic adapted from: Wang, Z.D., et al., Quantitative study of metal magnetic memory signal versus local stress concentration. NDT & E International, 2010. 43(6): p. 513-518.

Magnetic detection of Stress Concentration Zones (SCZ)Methodology - Wang et al

STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Page 19: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

19STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Magnetic detection of Stress Concentration Zones (SCZ)Instrumentation

Page 20: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

ΔZ pk magnitude12.5 μT

ΔZ pk-pk length6 m

Magnetic detection of Stress Concentration Zones (SCZ)Analysis of Field Data

48” diameter Gas Pipe at 40 bar

ΔX pk magnitude3 μT

ΔX pk length6 m

STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Page 21: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

21

Summary

• Motivation for remote stress measurement

• Stress Concentration Tomography (SCT)

• Magnetoelastic effects in steel

• Experimental measurement

• Finite element modelling of stress

• Finite element modelling of stress induced magnetic field

• Experimental magnetic field characterisation rig

• Prototype SCT instrumentation

• Initial field survey results

STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL

Page 22: Detection of Stress due to Corrosion through Passive Measurement and Analysis of Magnetic Fields D Cowell 1, S Staples 2, C Vo 1, P Jarram 3, B Varcoe.

22

Thank you for your attention