Critique(the art of passing judgments)
judgmentcritical formalized systematic
evaluation
understanding
What?
How?
what assumption?
what is lacking?
what implications?
Introduction Summary Evaluation Response Conclusion
Introduction Summary Evaluation Response Conclusion
Author & Title
Take away(whole/part)
Evaluation Background information
Introduction Summary Evaluation Response Conclusion
Entire work/Section(s) of it Objective
Presenting the author’s point(s)
(NO OPINION)
Introduction Summary Evaluation Response Conclusion
Accuracy Definition of key terms(or lack of)
Hidden assumption
Clarity of
language fairnessEmotionally
Loadedterms
Common logical fallacies …
SignificanceLogical
argument
Introduction Summary Evaluation Response Conclusion
Agree/disagree
Spotting rights/wrongs
Ultimate merit (what is it good for?)
Recommend/not?
Introduction Summary Evaluation Response Conclusion
Remind of the overall importance
Combine rating & personal response to focus an overall strengths
& weaknesses
Introduction Summary Evaluation Response Conclusion
Introduction Summary Evaluation Response Conclusion
Top Related