8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
1/23
T & D CONCLAVE
CRITICAL TAX ISSUES
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
2/23
Level Playing field for domestic manufacturersThe cost disadvantage 14%
Sales tax/ VAT, Entry tax/ Octroi, Higher financing cost; Low customs duty NIL (for Mega Projects) and 5% for (Project
Import)
lack of quality infrastructure
dependence on foreign sources for critical raw material and
components.
(CoS) in July 2010 suggested similar duty structure as applicable for non-
mega projects be made applicable to Mega/Ultra Mega Power projects.
Arun Maira Committee recommended 10% BCD, 4% SAD
Suggestion:Customs Duty @ 10%, CVD @ NIL SAD @ 4%
Simultaneously Excise exemption Suitable measures like price preference to domestic manufacturers under the
Mega Power Policy, for cost-plus as well as tariff based power projects.
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
3/23
Interest on differential Excise Duty - Supplementary Invoices
Delay due to delay in publishing applicable indices
In some cases, even prices published by foreign agencies
like LME
Certain Customers insists on prior approval of PV factors
before raising invoices
SC Judgment in SKF case
Suggestion:
Rule 7(4) may be amended to read as THE MONTH IN WHICH
Duty is determined instead ofTHE MONTH FOR WHICH
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
4/23
Exemption to steel & cement used in Mega/Ultra MegaPower Projects
Exemption to goods falling under CHAPTER 98.01
(S. No 400 of Customs Notification No 21/2002)
Hence no exemption to steel and cement.
Suggestion:
Should be amended to read as goods falling under
any chapter. (The language used in notification 06/2006
CE at S.No 91 is any chapter)
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
5/23
Supply to Solar Power Projects
The manufacturer of such goods to furnish an undertaking to Excise
authorities that (Notification 15/2010-CE dated 27.02.2010 -
(a) The said goods shall be used only in the said project or facility and not
for any other use; and
(b) In the event of failure to observe conditions above, the manufacturer
shall pay the duty
no direct control of the manufacturer in execution of projects & uses ofmaterial.
Further, in case of any failure in fulfillment of the above conditions,
supplier liable for penalties.
Manufacturer to pay 5% towards Input credit availed.
Suggestion: Purchaser being the beneficiary of duty exemption, the liability should be on
him to use it in as per the requirement of the statutory condition.
The rule (6) of Cenvat credit rules 2004 should be amended suitably so that no
Cenvat reversal is required for these projects
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
6/23
Inverted Duty Structure on Insulators
Basic duty on all Insulators (chapter 8546 and 8547)is 7.5%
Major imported components like metal parts,
hardwares etc. attract 10% basic duty
The metal parts consist of MCI / SGI casting
component (chapter 7325)
Suggestion:
Customs Duty on inputs under Chapter 7325 used formanufacture of Insulators be reduced to 5%
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
7/23
Service Tax on Power Projects
Infrastructure projects like roads, airports, railways,transport terminals, bridges, tunnels and dams are
exempt from levy of service tax
Suggestion:
Similar exemption be granted to service provided for
construction of power projects
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
8/23
CST/VAT exemption to Mega POWER PROJECTS Imports exempt from CST/VAT
Domestic supplies attract CST @ 2% and VAT from 5% to 14.5%.State Governments advised to exempt supplies to Mega Power Plants from Sales Tax
and other local levies.( OM issued by the MoP - F. No. A-108/98-IPC-I dated
31.05.1999-Clause 2),
Accordingly, the Sales Tax, Local Levies and Octroi on domestically manufactured
capital goods, not to be considered for evaluation of bids, irrespective of the fact
whether the State Governments provide exemptions or not.
However, many customers not accepting this de-loading principle (regarding Sales
Tax, Local Levies & Octroi) and evaluate bids taking these levies, including CST, into
account.
Suggestion:Mega /Ultra Mega Power Projects should be mandatorily exempted from CST/ VAT.
CST exemption should be provided in the CST Act itself.Alternately, CST/VAT component, should be excluded for the purpose of bid
evaluation.
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
9/23
EXEMPTION FROM C FORMS
Previously States had powers to exempt specified sales/class ofsales/class of dealers from submitting C Form before amendment
to CST Act in May 2002.
States using these powers exempted certain class of dealers from
specified sales from C forms submission
Suggestion:
The facility of exempting submission of C forms may be restored
back to the respective state governments as before amendment in
2002
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
10/23
Supply of goods to SEZs - BOIs
As per existing provisions:Exemption for SEZs from CST for manufactured goods
against Form I
However no provision, not even machinery provision,
for exemption from CST for supplies effected fromvendors directly to SEZs.
However exemption provision exist for vendor supplies
against physical exports
Customers insisting on modalities not prescribed under
CST Law.
CST Act needs amendment
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
11/23
Provisions of CST ActSection 8. Rates of tax on sales in the course of inter-State trade
or commerce.
(6) Notwithstanding anything contained in this section, no tax
under this Act shall be payable by any dealer in respect of sale of
any goods made by such dealer, in the course of inter-State trade
or commerce, to a registered dealer for the purpose of
manufacture, production, processing, assembling, repairing,
reconditioning, reengineering, packaging or for use as trading or
packing material or packing accessories in an unit located in any
special economic zone, if such registered dealer has beenauthorized to establish such unit by the authority specified by the
Central Government in this behalf.
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
12/23
Provision of CST Act
Section 8.
(8) The provisions of sub-section (6) and (7) shall not apply to any
sale of goods made in the course of inter-State trade or commerce
unless the dealer selling such goods furnishes to the authority
referred to in sub-section (6) a declaration in the prescribed manner
on the prescribed form obtained from the authority referred to in sub-
section (5), duly filled in and signed by the registered dealer to
whom such goods are sold.
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
13/23
Summary of main/Charging section
What is exempt under sub-section (6) is the sale by a dealer
to a registered dealer for setting up a unit located in any
Special Economic Zone or for development, operation and
maintenance of Special Economic Zone by the developer of
Special Economic Zone.
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
14/23
Requirements to avail exemption under CST Act
Exemption can be claimed only by the dealer selling the goods whohas to furnish to his tax authority Form-I obtained from the
specified authority which should be duly filled in and signed by
the registered dealer (SEZ unit) to whom such goods are sold.
In those cases where there are two sales, as in the case of vendor
supplies, it cannot be said that the vendors of bought out items
had sold the goods to a registered dealer in the Special Economic
Zone.
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
15/23
SEZ provisions
Section 26 (1). Exemptions, drawbacks and concessions toevery Developer and entrepreneur.
(g) exemption from the levy of taxes on the sale or purchase
of goods other than newspapers under the Central Sales TaxAct, 1956 if such goods are meant to carry on the authorised
operations by the Developer or entrepreneur.
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
16/23
SEZ provisions
Rule 10. Permission for procurement of items.
Provided further that exemptions, drawbacks and
concessions on the goods and services allowed to a Developer or
Co-developer, as the case may be, shall also be available to thecontractors including sub-contractors appointed by such
Developer or Co-developer, and all the documents in such cases
shall bear the name of the Developer or Co-developer along with the
contractor or sub-contractor and these shall be filed jointly in the
name of the Developer or Co-developer and the contractor or sub-contractor, as the case may be.
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
17/23
Can Rules override the provisions of Act?
Settled position of law is that a rule cannot override the substantive
provisions of an enactment.
Since, SEZ Act does not provide for exemption to sub-
contractor, can Rules expand the scope of exemption?
The CST Act dealing with inter-State sales, does not provide forsuch exemption for supplies made by the sub-contractors/sub vendors
similar to physical imports [Sec 5(3)].
The authorities administering the CST Act would be bound by
the provisions of the CST Act and would not go beyond what is
provided in the said Act to grant exemption to sub-contractors.
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
18/23
Can Rules override the provisions of Act? Some of the judgments
The basis of the statutory power conferred by the Statute cannot be
transgressed by the rule making authority. The rule making authority has noplenary power. It has to act within the limits of the power granted to it
(Bimal Chandra Banerjee v. State of Madhya Pradesh AIR 1971 SC 517)
The Rules, therefore, cannot be so framed which do not carry out the purpose
of the chapter and cannot be in conflict with the same (Laghu Udyog Bharti v.
UOI 2006 (2) STR 276 SC)
Delegated legislation must be read in the context of the primary/legislative
Act and not the vice-versa - In case of a conflict between a substantive
provision of an Act and delegated legislation, the former shall prevail
( ITW Signode India Ltd. v. Collector of central excise 2003 (158) E.L.T. 403
(S.C.)
Other similar judgments: Chief Commissioner v. Kishan Goyal (1982) 50 STC 1 (Del) (F.B.);State of Tamil Nadu v. E.I.D. Parry (India) (1998) 109 STC 146 at 165 (Mad.); Rallis India Ltd. v.
State of A.P. (1980) 45 STC 456 (S.C.); The S.T.O. v. H. Farid Ahmed & Sons (1975) 36 STC 567
(S.C.); Sales Tax Officer v. Abraham (1967) 20 STC 367 (S.C.)
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
19/23
SEZ provisions
Section 51. Act to have overriding effect.
The provisions of this Act shall have effect
notwithstanding anything inconsistent therewith
contained in any other law for the time being in forceor in any instrument having effect by virtue of any law
other than this Act.
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
20/23
Can exemption be assumed under CST Act?
When a language is plain and unambiguous and admits of only onemeaning no question of construction of a statute arises, for the Act
speaks for itself. When the words of a statute are clear, plain or
unambiguous, i.e., they are reasonably susceptible to only one
meaning, courts are bound to give effect to that meaning irrespective
of consequences. If the words used are capable of more than one
construction, only then it would be open to the courts to adopt any other
hypothetical construction on the ground that such construction is more
consistent with the alleged object and policy of the Act. The spirit of the
law may well be an elusive and unsafe guide and the supposed spirit
can certainly be not given effect to in opposition to the plain language
of the sections of the Act- Orient Paper & Industries Ltd. Vs. State of
M.P. and others (and a transfer petition) [2006] 148 STC 0649
[SUPREME COURT OF INDIA]
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
21/23
Can exemption be assumed under CST Act?
"The Act in question is a taxing statute and, therefore, must beinterpreted as it reads, with no additions and no subtractions, on the
ground of legislative intendmentor otherwise." -Vikrant Tyres Ltd. Vs.
First Income-tax Officer, Mysore [2002] 127 STC 0005 [SUPREME
COURT]
"In interpreting a taxing statute, equitable considerations are entirely
out of place. Nor can taxing statutes be interpreted on any
presumptions or assumptions. The Court must look squarely at the
words of the statute and interpret them. It must interpret a taxing
statute in the light of what is clearly expressed: it cannot imply
anything which is not expressed; it cannot import provisions in the
statutes so as to supply any assumed deficiency" - Commissioner of
Sales Tax, U.P. Vs Modi Sugar Mills Ltd.[1961] 012 STC 0182
[SUPREME COURT OF INDIA]
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
22/23
What about Transit Sale ?
Section 6 (2)- No such subsequent sale exempt unless selling
dealer furnishes to his tax authorities
- Certificate in E1/EII [Rule 12 (4)]
- Declaration in Form C [Rule 12 (1)]
Can SEZ unit issue Form C Yes as per Clarification by Maharashtra commissioner to L&T
dated 9th June 2008.
- Further such SEZ is registered under CST/VAT Acts of
respective States
8/3/2019 Critical Tax Issues
23/23
THANK YOU
Suraj Prakash AGM (Fin Ind. Taxation)BHEL, New DelhiMember IEEMA Economic & Taxation Committee
Top Related