Comparing regional strategies and policy
options for addressing the lack of human capital
Marifé Zudaire Echávarri and Marian García Martínez ,NASUVINSA
Arnoud Lagendijk and Frans de Man, Nijmegen School of Management
Frans Coenen, University of TwenteRSA, Delft, 16-05-2012
Setting
• Material is taken from sub-project BUTTON – Pushing the right Button, Towards tailored policy measures to attract and retain highly educated workers, a part of the INTERREG IV C Mini-Programme ‘Brain Flow’, funded by the ERDF.
• Button aims at delivering bespoke regional policy options based on an understanding and analysis of attraction, retention and outmigration of highly educated people.
Five Regions
Ostwestfalen-Lippe (OWL)NRW, GermanyHedmark, NorwayNavarra, SpainTwente, NetherlandsGreater Basel, Switzerland
All in ‘non-core’ positions between peripheral and core metropolitan areas, located at a certain distance from the core.
The regional ‘talent’ issue
• talent is relatively immobile and remains sticky relative to finance or knowledge
• highly educated workers are often prepared to travel longer distances, facilitated by for instance high-speed rail and cheaper flights, but they are generally susceptible to ‘intervening opportunities’ innovative business and talent always tends to cluster together.
• the result is an economic geography of slow but ongoing concentration.
Three pervasive major spatial trends
• core regions prone to grow, particularly if they welcome new talent (cf. London), benefitting from ‘smart growth’
• peripheral areas bound to undergo population decline and hence socio-economic change, requiring bespoke strategies of ‘peripheral specialisation and ‘managed decline’
• intermediary regions too small for ‘smart growth’ and too big for ‘peripheral specialisation’, requiring focused ‘smart specialisation’ based on the attraction/retention of ‘talent’ and knowledge valorisation, amongst others
The meaning of ‘talent’
• not just mean the embodiment of ‘knowledge’ or ‘knowledge creation’.
• also reflexivity, i.e. sensitivity to local and global opportunities and challenges, and for local capacities and opportunities for capacity building and collective learning
• important social dimension: expression of interests, preferences, passion
• orchestrators of local socio-economic development• ‘talent’ presents a complex, context-specific
regional asset (or vector).
So, what is the role of ‘brains’, or ‘talent’ - under the conditions of
• increasing need for talent for wealth creation (knowledge intensity, sensitivity to local and global opportunities and challenges, reflexivity)
• ongoing trends towards urban agglomeration and concentration, in polycentric forms – deepening the divide between core, peripheral or intermediary spaces (‘non-core’)
• specific local challenges of economic restructuring, population decline and other pressing social problems
• mounting socio-economic problemsprompted by economic crisis?
Assessing policy response• insights into the drives, reasons and motives behind in
and out migration of highly educated workers, in view of regional development challenges
• awareness amongst politicians, employers and society of the multiple aspects of the problem and remedies
• understanding the role for place-marketing• engagement of private partners and non-governmental
organizations in policydesign
Policy aspects1. Strategic development: selection of key issues, domains,
clusters, forms of governance2. Image building and branding, as basis for retention & attraction3. Quality of life: housing, transport, provisions and amenities4. Labour market: brokerage, targeting particular social groups5. Education policies and measures (e.g. life-long learning)6. Business support: training and improvement of local living
conditions by large firms; talent attraction and use by SMEs7. Research and innovation; role of talent in research centres,
universities, consultancies, R&D departments, innovation projects and circles etc.
Regional assessmentsAspect Twente OWL Navarra
Strategy Attraction/ retention/ clustering
Nurturing talent/ ‘future oriented sectors’
Comprehensive plans; nurturing talent
Branding cluster-based Outreach strategy
Quality of Life Family orientation
Labour Market Human capital route
focusing on women and ethnic groups
Competencies & skills improvement
Education ‘Linx’ learning chain preventing dropouts
Internationalisation strategy
Business support TOP-programme SME focus clustering & exports
Innovation ‘Triple Helix’ Triple Helix +union R&D promotion
Regional assessmentsAspect Gr. Basel Hedmark
Strategy Accommodating talent, no attraction
Creative class, attraction talent
Branding cluster based Regional branding
Quality of Life housing, family focus, clean streets
nature and sports, HST
Labour Market
Education HE investment
Business support cluster based cluster based
Innovation Labs & innovation circles
‘Triple Helix’
Conclusion• Tendency in policy discourse to use ‘talent’ in an
instrumental way• Policy perspectives in the regions often manifest a richer,
more varied socio-economic use of ‘talent’ • But also the tendency to copycat• Search for the right balance between local pathways and
learning from other regions, between ‘bespoke’ and ‘boilerplate’ solutions
• Need for a more inclusive policy discourse (in development)
Top Related