7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
1/60
Classical Criticism
Presentation -Prepared by-
D. Paragkumar Dave-
M.A. ( Eng.)
Blog:- [email protected]
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
2/60
:Acknowledgements:
I am heartily thankful to all those who have rendered mehand in creation of the present Slides. And of course, I am,always owed to ICT, which has made it feasible to erect ournew perspective in pedagogy.
This is an example of Renovated Self-Study Tech, withwhich I have empirically optimized ICT. I hope this will bevaluable to all literary students, esp. Open Univ. Students(O.U.S.) who are pursuing their Higher-Degree in an OpenUniv.
Hithereto, we have been taught to learn but now, as you allare aware, the principal aim of our higher (University) Studyis to expand the frontiers of ones own thinking,comprehension power.
I thank all those great authors/professors who have createdimmortal works to enrich the English Literary Criticism.
June, 26, 2011 D.Paragkumar Dave
Place:- Surat-city M.A. English
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
3/60
What do we mean by Classical Criticism?What do we mean b
y Classical Criticism?
According to the Longmans Contemporary Dict-Classical as being in accordance with ancientGreek or Roman models in literature or art or withlater systems & standard based on them.
The 8th to 4th B.C.- for its brilliance in literature,
philosophy and the visual arts, is normally knownas the classical age. According to my own opinion Classical is the
inner core, unique and pioneer force with blendingof ideas and inspirations, known-unknown, whichwe have inherited through our ancestors.Thereafter modified and peronalised accordance toour milieu and convenience. In this regard the firstinvented computer can be regarded as a Classical
Piece or antique.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
4/60
Classics are the work of fiction, likeClassics are the work of fiction, like
Shakespeare, Jane Austen, ThomasShakespeare, Jane Austen, Thomas
Hardy- that are relevant to all ages,Hardy- that are relevant to all ages,through all times and for their universalthrough all times and for their universal
appeal, regularity of form and a sense ofappeal, regularity of form and a sense of
beauty and balancebeauty and balance. Nowadays, we consider old movies songs
as the Classical Golden Melodies- .
Songs by Raffic, Lata, Kishor are classicalsongs.
They are sung and enjoyed for ever- that
is classics.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
5/60
What is Classicism? It means those qualities
which are most characteristic of the best
literature of Greece & Rome. It is in partlyidentical with Idealism. It aims to express the
inner truth or central principles of things, without
anxiety for minor details, and it is by nature
largely intellectual in quality, though not by any
means to the exclusion of emotion. In outward
form, therefore, it insists on correct structure,
restraint, careful finish and avoidance of allexcess. Paradise-Lost, Arnolds Sohrab and
Rustam, Addisons essays are modern example
of classicism spirit. (A History of Eng. Lit., Robert Huntington Flethcer)
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
6/60
What is Romanticism? Romanticism, which in general prevails in
modern literature, lays most emphasis on
independence and fullness of expression andon strong emotion, and it may becomparatively careless of form.
The Classical style has well been called
Sculpturesque, the Romantic Picturesque. The dangers of the Classical are coldness
and formality, of the Romantic overluxuriance, formlessness and excess of
emotion.(A History of Eng. Lit., Robert Huntington Flethcer)
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
7/60
Long before the term Literary Criticism
came into practice, literary theory existed
as far back as 4 th Cen. B.C. Plato,Aristotle.
Plato & Aristotle from Greece; and Horace
& Longinus from Rome, formed the coreof classical criticism in ancient time.
Greek civilization is older than its Roman
counterpart. Greeks influenced Romans-
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
8/60
-Classical Works-
Platos Republic
Aristotles Poetics, Rhetoric Horace- Ars Poetica (Art of Poetry)
Longinus- On the Sublime
--Roman dramatist Seneca imitated theGreek Tragedies, and Virgil wasinfluenced by Homer- (from Greece).
Aristotle had influenced in the 16th
& 17th
Cent. Literature. In German, Goethe andSchiller influenced in the 18th Cen.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
9/60
Aristotles Works:- On Rhetoric, On Soul,
On Metaphysics, Analytics, Physics, DeAnima, Nichoman Ethics, Poetics,
--------------------------------------------------------
For the ancient, poets were neither made,nor born, but chosen by the gods. Poetry
was not considered to be entirely within
the control of the poet. The Poet was the
Prophetes of the Muse.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
10/60
Aristotle and Plato were the great masters of the
classical criticism.
Aristotle regarded Mimesis as a natural healthy
impulse. For him Art initiated Nature. This would
imply that the arts, like Nature work towards
the unfolding of inherent potential. Aristotle didnot consider Mimesis to be mere copying.
Whereas Plato believed poetry to be cut off from
the Universal; it being removed from the truth.
Thucydide a greek Historian said; Poetry is
concerned with universal truths, history traits of
particular facts.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
11/60
Aristotle proposed for the tragedy unity ofaction, place and time. He expanded notion of
Katharsis (Catharsis) in it. What is to be aroused is a pity that arises out offear, and that too fear with pity as opposed toself-centered fear.
Pity-Charged Fear- (Harland-p-13) Plato rejected both the poet & poetry, as he felt
their presence and their capability in arousingsuch powerful emotions would render thecitizens of the Greek city states emotional
basket-cases. Aristotle, on the other hand, believed the
evocation pity and fear to be therapeutic to theaudience, to serve as purgation or cleansing
and therefore healthy.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
12/60
Classical Criticism Vs Romanticism-
(Objective) (Subjective) Classical Criticism is fairly objective, it is
an attempt at expressing infinite ideas
and feelings in a finite form, whereasromanticism is an attempt to express a
kind of universal poetry in the creation of
which the poet made his own laws.
Romanticism is a response to classicism
in Romanticism, the individual or the
subject is more important.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
13/60
Poetry & Philosophy:-
The quarrel between poetry & Philosophywas a continuing one. The philosophers
used language to investigate into the
nature of things, while the poet, the orator
and the rhetorician were aiming at
creating an effect on the audience for
establishing emotional truth. Literary
criticism hovered in between favouring thepoets sometimes and the philosophers at
other.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
14/60
What is Myth- The word Myth is derived from
the Greek Word Mythos- which simply means
Story. Myth is the core of all Greek poetry,drama, narrative, prose and lyric. In all culture
Myths are narratives that have been preserved
in racial memories through ritual enactments on
religious days or representations in sculpture,poetry, temple walls, special seals, shields,
vases, holy objects and all other kinds of
artifacts including toys. In poetry, plays, music
they found the most explicit statements.Example:- We have a number of symbols for
our Village, City, State, Nation- Ashok-Stambh,
why? Because there is a myth behind it. Every
belief has some unknown ground of Myth.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
15/60
Chapter-1. Plato on Imitation & Art
In this chapter, I would shade light to thefollowing points.
Introduction
Platonic View of Mimesis Theory of forms
The Lower Status of Art
Platos definition of truth
Platonic Idea of Social Well-being
Conlusions
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
16/60
Introduction:- The easiest thing is to imaginePlato as an enemy of art because he viewed artproducts of all kinds, whether poetry, theatre or
painting as inferior copies of the ultimate reality. Platos concern were not artistic but rather
philosophical. His views on poetry or Poesis(Making) and mimesis (imitation). Both reflect
the urge to know the truth beyond words. In his Republic , he has given us a picture of
what a perfectly governed state should be andhow that state can be created by educating
young men and women. The rulers of Platonic Utopia are not mere
statesmen, they are also sound philosophershaving a deep understanding of the true natureof things.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
17/60
Cont.- Plato advocated that there was no room for theteaching of poetry and drama as these were neither
healthy for the creation of a strong moral character needin an administrator nor did they provide knowledge ofthe world.
Most poetry of the contemporary Greek was unsuitableas it showed Gods and Heroes with moral infirmities and
something even savagery. Plato advocated for the need of heroism and
courageous spirited poetry.
For Plato, the very purpose of art, was disruptive to theunswerving concentration of a guardian or a citizen ofhis Utopia.
For Plato, art was an unfaithful representation of reality.The artist was not only imitating imperfect objects of thisworld, s/he was also pretending to know things which
s/he actually had no understanding.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
18/60
Platonic view of Mimesis:- Mimesis primarilymeans making. Plato gave a new metaphysical
and epistemological perspective to mimesis,enlarging its meaning from Making by humanhands to making by universal force. Allproduction of arts, in a general way, is mimesis.
In Greek- Mithexis Participation, Homoiosis Likeness, Paraplesia-Likeness-
which all are close to the meaning of mimesis-.
The musician imitates divine harmony, the good
man imitates the virtues, the wise legislatorimitates the Form of God, God imitates theForm in the making of this World.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
19/60
Theory Of Forms:- For every kind of
activity there must be an ideal to be
followed, and every ideal or Form must
have its Super-Form. Plato postulated
that there was a primary form, which was
the essential nature of every object oreven thought. Worldly objects are idols or
imitative images (eidola) of the ideal
Forms, and artist, picture or poeticdescriptions are images (eidola) of the
objects of this World. Thus, all art
according to Plato, remains a turning
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
20/60
The Lower Status of Art:- Phantasma is afalse representation, and poets and painters;
according to Plato, are adepted at doing this.Hence, Plato gave them a lower status.
Socrates says, The sixth (class) shall befittingly given to a poet, or any other imitative
artist. They are all seducers from the truth. To conclude, Plato sees little good in art, and it
is doubtful if he would have liked to praiseCatharsis. He would have no trust on who
listened to music and were purified of theirdiseases, with the emotional relief that audiencefeel after going through an artistic experience.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
21/60
Platos definition of Truth:- Plato postulated
that there was no possibility of a category such
as artistic-truth as apart from the Truth.
There could be only one reality, that was
available to the philosopher who saw things
beyond the illusion. Plato had rejected the ideathat poetry could communicate the truth and
also rejected the traditional idea of poetry or art
being a gift (phya) from the Muse. It is all
mimetic task and artist can never break themimetic chain. The poet is making a copy of a
copy art. But for Plato, as inspiration and phya
were suspect, art was more of a deception or at
best an emotionally manipulative make belief
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
22/60
As dialogue on Art runs in Book X of theRepublic:-
So the artist has neither knowledge nor
correct opinion about the goodness orbadness of the things he represents.Apparently not. So the poet too as artist willbe pretty ignorant about the subjects of hispoetry. Completely ignorant. But he will goon writing poetry, inspite of his ignorance ofall he writes about and will representanything that pleases ignorant multitude.What else can he do? Well, I conclude, we
seem to be pretty well agreed that the artistknows little or nothing about the subjects herepresents and that his art is something thathas no serious value; and that this applies toall tragic poetry, epic or dramatic. Yes,
entirely agreed,. Republic-602 (Lee).
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
23/60
The form alone is real as it is unchanging.
All changing things can be a basis for
opinions but not knowledge. Virtue is
hence equivalent to knowledge. Lack of
virtue is ignorance, knowledge is
happiness. Artistic creation andenjoyment cause ignorance according to
Plato.
--------------------------------------------------------
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
24/60
Platonic Idea of Social Well-being :- There is no
place for any artist in the Utopian State that
Plato envisaged in the Republic or later in hisfinal work- the Law. Just as appetite must be
controlled and kept under constant check
through resolve, reason and virtue to prepare
the soul for knowledge, so should the guardians
endowed with superior training and selective
breeding control the general population to keep
a society productive and law abiding. Plato feltthat for young students most epic poetry of
Homer and Hesiod was weak in morals as it
showed Gods and Heroes in a poor light. Plato
shows the way to most purists and moralists. In
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
25/60
Unknowingly, Plato made ground for hisChristian successors like Augustive and
Justine who forbade theater, masks andacting. Plato accepted the traditionalGreek view that experiencing emotional
employment in art formed the character ofaudience and artist. Plato postulated thatpoetry has the same effect on us when itrepresents sex and anger, and the other
desires and feelings of pleasure and pain.The poet with all his fellow artist hardlydeserves to be a citizen of the perfectstate. Low degree of truth appeals to a
low element
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
26/60
Conlusions :- It has been speculated that
Plato was well aware of the military
weaknesses of the Athenian State in
comparison with the disciplined army of
Spartans. He, therefore, wanted no stone
unturned in prescribing the strongestideals for Athens. Bad art and poor taste
among the art lovers were perhaps too
noticeable. Therefore, Plato was so anxious to save
society from the ravages of a decadent
politics, found in all art.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
27/60
AristotleAristotle :-( 384-322 B.C.) Aristotle was the son of a well:-( 384-322 B.C.) Aristotle was the son of a wellknown medical practitioner, Nicomachus who came fromknown medical practitioner, Nicomachus who came from
the Asklepian trading located in Macedonia. At the age ofthe Asklepian trading located in Macedonia. At the age of
seventeen, Aristotle became a student of Plato. Later inseventeen, Aristotle became a student of Plato. Later in
Athens, he established his school and research, funded byAthens, he established his school and research, funded by
Alexander, on music, botany, Zoology, medicine,Alexander, on music, botany, Zoology, medicine,
Mathematics and Logic. His cosmology, physics,Mathematics and Logic. His cosmology, physics,
astronomy and theology were complied at his academy.astronomy and theology were complied at his academy.The dialogues now lost were modeled on Platos and wereThe dialogues now lost were modeled on Platos and were
called On Rhetoric, On Soul, On Philosophy, Oncalled On Rhetoric, On Soul, On Philosophy, On
Metaphysics etc. His prominent works are Analytics,Metaphysics etc. His prominent works are Analytics,
Physics, De Aniima, Methaphysics, Nichomian Ethics,Physics, De Aniima, Methaphysics, Nichomian Ethics,
Politics, Ryheotoric and Poetics (fragment). He was reallyPolitics, Ryheotoric and Poetics (fragment). He was really
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
28/60
Here, I would like to lay down the
following relevant points over Aristotle
for discussion.
1. Aristotles theory of Imitation
2. His theory of Tragedy-13. His theory of Tragedy-2
4. Criticism as Dialogue
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
29/60
1. Aristotles theory of Imitation:- The poetics
opens with the statement that mimesis is a
valuable method for artistic representation. Hethen goes on to define that Rhythm, Language
and Harmony are the basic channels through
which artistic imitation is made possible.
Language, Rhythm and Harmony are
manifested as the six elements of tragedy,
namely 1. Myth or Plot, 2. Ethos or character 3.
Dianoia or Argument 4. Lexis or diction 5.Melopoii or Music and finally 6. Opsis or the
visual Spectacle These 6 elements are found
in all other form such as the comedy & Satyr.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
30/60
According to Aristotle all art and other imitation(Sculpture, Paining, poetry etc.) leads to
knowledge. The pleasure that mimesis providesis on account of this knowledge. Mimesis is defined as a pleasurable likeness.
Human beings is the most living creature and helearns his earliest all lessons through imitating
Ah, that is he. Imitation is one instinct of ournature. Artist is not liar but he leads us to Truth.
For Plato, all creation was an imitation of Forms,and for Aristotle, though the form (eidos) of
every object existed but it is nature which itselftends to attain. Art helps Nature in attaining theperfection of Form. Ars imitates Nature and theartist may imitate things as they ought to be. Ithas been argued that the inner principle of
Nature is what art imitates.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
31/60
Aristotle was clear that the purpose of
imitation in dram, was to provide proper
pleasure (hedona) by imitating action.Mimesis of men in action was mimesis of
all human life.
Dance, imitates character, emotions andaction.
The Media of Mimesis:-
A. Rhythm B. Language and C. Harmony
The imitation is produced by rhythm,
language and harmony, either singly or
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
32/60
Theatre is a unifier of the Arts- Rendering
of Lexis through Rhythm and Tone-
Aristotle stated that in drama, Rhythm,language and harmony were all used
together.
According to Aristotle mimesis is basedupon a study of life as we see it and that it
is pleasant and educative. It was credited
a moral function.
Thus Aristotle imparted a metaphysical, moral
and aesthetic worth to mimesis and thus to art
which Plato had denied on all these three
counts.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
33/60
Aristotles theory of Tragedy- Here,Aristotle discusses how mimesis works in
Tragedy-(1). Introduction:-
(2). The six elements of Tragedy
1.Myth (Plot),2. Ethos (Character)
3. Dianoia thought-saying
4. Lexis (Lang.)5. Melopoiia or Music
6. Opsis or Visual Content
(3). Catharsis:-
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
34/60
1.Introduction:- During the ancient time,
plays/dramas were performed in the
religious place on special religious
occasions to communicate with ancestors
and gods. The strong emotions generated
while worshipping the gods, theancestors; and this also provided an
aesthetic of emotional arousal which we
find at its core. This aesthetic value wasformulated as Catharsis (katharsis).
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
35/60
The Dramatic Theory in Poetics of Aristotle canbe said to consist of four principles of the
ancient classification system. (1). The concept of Mimesis
(2).The treatment of the various genres of
poetry, namely epic, tragedy and comedy.
(3).The division of tragedy into 6 elementsnamely- 1. Plot (Muthos/myth)2.Character(ethos) 3.Language (Lexis)4. Thought (dianoia)
5. Music (Melopoiia) 6. Spectacle (Opsis)
(4) The concept of Catharsis- (Katharsis)
Thus above 1 to 4 principles are discussed in
Poetics of Aristotle.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
36/60
Now lets discuss the 6 elements of tragedy in
detail.
1. Myth (Muthos) or Plot:- For the ancientMuthos or myth simply meant the story,
commonly translated into English as Plot.
(Plot implies intricate turn of events, full of
surprise and suspense.) The stories, of only
some famous houses which came from the
collective memory of the culture are recreated
and nurtured here. Aristotle has called myth the soul of tragedy.
It was dramatic action (praxis) and was
imitation (mimesis) of an action made up of
series of dramatic events or series.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
37/60
Myth or Plot as an organic whole:- Aristotle
postulated that myth or plot must be in an
organic whole, almost like the body of structureof a living animal. It must have a definite shape
or magnitude. Aristotle defined tragedy as:-
Tragedy is an imitation of an action that iscomplete, and whole, and of certain magnitude.
A whole is that which has a beginning, a middle
and an end. It must be in a certain magnitude
for beauty depends on magnitude and order. Asin the case of animate bodies and organism a
certain magnitude is necessary. So it must be in
a certain length as to embrace easily by
memory.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
38/60
Here, Aristotle wanted to convey us that a plot(myth,muthos) of a tragedy must be in a whole withcertain magnitude (length) as to comprehend easily bythe readers/spectators.
For example, our human being bodies are in certainmagnitude as well our bodily parts i.e. nose, ears, legs,hands, head, etc. So as a whole we can have a perfect
human figure as to figure it out that this is a man orwoman or (baby) boy or girl. Hence a spectator caneasily comprehense us visually. So magnitude meansthe outer structure which is supported by the unity ofaction. Aristotle allows the poet to make changed in the
events- as poet can modify history. The wholeness andmagnitude provide a unity of action to the plot.
For Aristotle, there is only one kind of Unity, that ofAction. He does not prescribe unities of time and place.These were attirubuted to him by the Renaissance
critics.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
39/60
Two kinds of Myths- Simple and Complex:- Aristotle defines two kinds of plots, the simple
(aploi) and the complex (peplegmenoi). The simple plot or myth is without reversal of
fortune (peripetia) and recognition of a past actor identity of person (anagnorsis) .
The complex plot or myth has both- reversal offortune (peripetia) and recognition of a past actor identity of person (anagnorsis).
Anagnorisis- thats recognition of a past act oridentity of person is defined as a change from
ignorance to knowledge, producing love or hatebetween the persons destined by the poet toface good or bad fortune. In both tragic-comicperipetia and anagnorsis clearly work together.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
40/60
Pathos or Suffering:- The third part of a
Myth, that is the scene of suffering is
called pathos. Destructive and painful action, such as
death on the stage, bodily agony,
wounding etc. The best tragedies werethose in which the final destructive was
averted. It fulfills the tragic purpose of
arousing horror and pity.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
41/60
2. Ethos or Character:- Broadly
speaking, character in a tragedy had to be
a good man, and those in comedy andsatire, were, mean persons (bad man).
So all characters fall into the category of
either admirable people or ludicrous folks.
The Aristotle prescribed several qualities
of the protagonist of a tragedy. He must
have goodness, moral purpose, propriety
(reflect goodness) ,true to life andconsitency.
Aristotle has given us pattern of what the tragic
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
42/60
Aristotle has given us pattern of what the tragic
hero should be like. He should be a good man
as ourselves. As he was always supposed to be
a royal house-hold. He should have moralchoices- The protagonist does not take too long
to decide- it may be Hippolytus, Antigone,
Drestes or Hecabe. He should give the reasons
for making the choice, deliberately revealing thethought process behind the choice. The
protagonist was obliged to explain his conduct to
his family, friends and the gods. The greatness
of ethos or character was judged by the couragewith which moral choices were made. A
confused procrastinator like Hamlet unable to
make a timely choice, would have been an anti-
hero to the ancient Greek.
Hamartia or the Tragic Falling: Instead of our right
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
43/60
Hamartia or the Tragic Falling:- Instead of our rightchoice, we fail some time in our life. To explain the logicof failure, Aristotle has used the term hamartia- whichmeans hitting off the mark. It is an error or flaw (but
Aristotle had not made it clear whether itsintellectual flaw or moral flaw) of judgement madeinadvertently. The value of Hamartia was highly raised inChristian as well as in Modern moralists. Tragedy wherethe downfall of the hero is caused by a cardinal (basic)
sin or a serious lapse. Even by making the right choicethe hero could not avert (prevent) a calamity or suffering,because his suffering was not always caused by hisweakness. According to this theory it was not ambition ofa Macbeth, the jealousy of an Othello, or the arrogance
of a Lear not was it the inner sin that destroyed man, butinstead it was the dilemma imposed upon him by forcesfar beyond his control that caused destruction. Heresuffering comes not from within but from without.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
44/60
Aristotle postulated the terms:-
Moira and hubris. Moira literally meaning
portion or the family share, metaphoricallyindicate the misfortune allotted by the
gods.
Hubris means daring A hero madesustain efforts to avert and escape form
the tragic miss-furtune.
Moira and Hubris were concepts used byGreeks to define human behaviour.
3 Dianoia Thought/thinking/dialogue/saying/
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
45/60
3. Dianoia-Thought/thinking/dialogue/saying/
argument ( Dia- round):-
Third in order is the faculty of saying what is possible
and pertinent in given circumstance.Dianoia and The Protagonist:- The inner questioning
that goes on in the mind of a character and makes him
choose one way or another is called Dianoia. The ability
to choose, the moral fibre or the courage to choose, iscalled ethos, but the ferment of thoughts that leads to
the point of choice is known as Dianoia. Aristotle insists
that dianoia be regarded as an essential element of
tragedy. The power to take a decision of a character is
also called Dianoia. A debate which has a moral or
philosophical perspective in relation to the action of the
protagonist is Dianoia.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
46/60
4.Lexis or Diction or Language:- Lexis and Melopoiia
(music) have been given very little notice in Poetics.
Lexis or Lang. in theatre can be divided into two parts:-
A. The spoken word and B. The sung words. The spokenwords in the form of a natural conversational speech was
not much used in ancient theatre. Sound was considered
to generate meaning in two ways i.e., by language and
by Music. Next, as regards Diction, one branch of theinquiry treats modes of utterance. It includes what is a
command, a prayer, a statement, a threat, a question ,an
answer, and so forth.
Kinds of Styles:- Play wrights linguistic style Aristotle
seems to recommend a balance between the clarity
produced by the usage of current words and loftiness
achieved by extraordinary usage. Loftiness was much
admired by Aristotle.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
47/60
5.Melopoiia or the Musical Element:-
Application of music in theatre- The great
playwright improved drama by not only providing
fresh scripts of high literary value, they were
composed of music and dance as well. As the
famous saying goes Phrnikos invented as
many dance steps as the waves of the sea. In Indian music we believe in the association of
certain tone colours with seasons or specific
emotional state. The Greek dramatists must
have used the same thing. The value of music was pivotal (crucial)in
tragedy.
(6) Opsis or the Visual Content:
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
48/60
(6).Opsis- or the Visual Content:- The totality of Opsis:- Opsis has the last but the least place inOpsis has the last but the least place in
Aristotelian scheme. Although Opsis should beAristotelian scheme. Although Opsis should betaken to mean everything visual in theatre suchtaken to mean everything visual in theatre suchas formation of dancers in the chorus theas formation of dancers in the chorus thecostumes, movements, gestures and hand signscostumes, movements, gestures and hand signsof the actors. The totality of opsis was immenseof the actors. The totality of opsis was immense
in Greek Theatre.in Greek Theatre. Visual Parts of Tragedy:- All plays began with aVisual Parts of Tragedy:- All plays began with a
prologue, spoken by a single actor or at times byprologue, spoken by a single actor or at times bytwo. The chorus then entered often from thetwo. The chorus then entered often from the
right side singing and dancing. Then followed aright side singing and dancing. Then followed adramatic episode or an act in which the actordramatic episode or an act in which the actorspoke or sang to each other to which the chorusspoke or sang to each other to which the chorusalso reacted mostly in song.also reacted mostly in song.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
49/60
Greek Gesture & Dance:- Gestures forGreek Gesture & Dance:- Gestures for
orators was prescribed by the Greekorators was prescribed by the Greek
rhetoricians for arousing emotions andrhetoricians for arousing emotions andeffective communications Quintilian haseffective communications Quintilian has
given an account of how the head, face,given an account of how the head, face,
arms, body and feet can be made toarms, body and feet can be made toexpress joy, sorrow, humility, abhorrence,express joy, sorrow, humility, abhorrence,
wonder and many other emotions.wonder and many other emotions.
Quaintilian and Plutarch etc. indicate thatQuaintilian and Plutarch etc. indicate that
a definite choreology for the purpose ofa definite choreology for the purpose of
teaching and practicing dance exist inteaching and practicing dance exist in
GreeceGreece.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
50/60
Conclusion:-Conclusion:- Aristotle provides a frameAristotle provides a frame
work for us to see the art of tragedy in itswork for us to see the art of tragedy in its
totality and as a theatrical experience.totality and as a theatrical experience.Platos primary concern was to see thePlatos primary concern was to see the
function of tragedy in the Utopian State,function of tragedy in the Utopian State,
Aristotles aim was to analysis tragedy asAristotles aim was to analysis tragedy asit was to be found in Greek Culture.it was to be found in Greek Culture.
Aristotle described the genre of tragedy inAristotle described the genre of tragedy in
six parts as well recorded how thesesix parts as well recorded how these
diverse parts made a whole.diverse parts made a whole.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
51/60
Aristotles theory of Tragedy-2Aristotles theory of Tragedy-2
Hedone Proper Pleasure- Catharsis, EmotionalHedone Proper Pleasure- Catharsis, EmotionalArousalArousal
Aristotle has talked about the proper pleasure of tragedyAristotle has talked about the proper pleasure of tragedy(hedone) . Catharsis has been regarded as the sole aim of(hedone) . Catharsis has been regarded as the sole aim oftragedy. Pleasure which is proper only to tragedy and which istragedy. Pleasure which is proper only to tragedy and which isnot be found in comedy or any other form. Aristotle states thatnot be found in comedy or any other form. Aristotle states thattragedy cannot afford every kind of pleasure but only thattragedy cannot afford every kind of pleasure but only thatwhich is proper to it, and this comes about from pity and fearwhich is proper to it, and this comes about from pity and fear
through imitation. Pleasure is said to be derived fromthrough imitation. Pleasure is said to be derived fromcompleteness and wholeness of action in a plot. Pleasure iscompleteness and wholeness of action in a plot. Pleasure issaid to be a result of music and spectacular effects.said to be a result of music and spectacular effects.
Tragedy defined:- Tragedy, then, is an imitation of an actionTragedy defined:- Tragedy, then, is an imitation of an actionthat is serious, complete, and of a certain magnitude, inthat is serious, complete, and of a certain magnitude, in
(pleasurable) language embellished with (accessories) each(pleasurable) language embellished with (accessories) eachkind of artistic ornament, the several kinds being found inkind of artistic ornament, the several kinds being found inseparate parts of the play in the form of action (dramatic), notseparate parts of the play in the form of action (dramatic), notof narrative, through pity and fear effecting the purgation orof narrative, through pity and fear effecting the purgation orKatharsis of these emotions- (Butcher-23)Katharsis of these emotions- (Butcher-23)
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
52/60
Catharsis- (Katharsis) Purgation:-
Catharsis is not only a fact of psychology or ofpathology, but a principle of art.
Clinical definition:- According to the Hippocratictheory, an imbalance among the elements of air,bile-black bile, yellow bile, melancholy, andphlegm causes each and every disease.
Musical Catharsis:- In the ancient time , there wasa practice of curing madness. The Patients weremade to listen to certain melodies which madethem fall back into their normal state, as if theyhad undergone a medical or purgative (cathartic)treatment. Catharsis yield in net result of a nobleemotional satisfaction which is an essentialfeature of it. It fulfills the aesthetic function.
Inner restoration but not the enjoyment of a
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
53/60
- Inner restoration, but not the enjoyment of anew aesthetic element, can at best be thepurpose of Catharsis. The factors of enjoymentthats hedone (proper pleasure) which isdifferent.
The restorative function of catharsis may bringrelief such as a sick person feels upon recovery.
The dual concept of purity and impurity which
pervaded the physical, moral, religious andspiritual life of the Greeks was the most deepseated factor governing their dailys activities.
The duality of Pollution (Miasma) and Purgation
(Catharsis) was part of the Indo-European beliefsystem. We have in India rituals were prescribed for
purging of pollution. Thus Tragedy was adepiction of the cycle of Miasma and Catharsis.
Entertainment and ritual were intertwined
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
54/60
Entertainment and ritual were intertwined
in ancient theatre. Religion, customs and
faiths were revived through the device of
re-telling the myths in the form of dramatic
enactment on festival and special
occasions. In this manner tragedy was a
reliving of the pollution and purity cycle byboth the actors and the spectators. All
underwent into catharsis. Thus catharsis is
the process of proving purity.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
55/60
As Else puts it, An unconscious intention to killa person who is a close kind i.e. without beingaware of the kinship as Oedipus did not knowthat he killed his father would therefore be pure,catharos. But purity must be proved to oursatisfaction. Catharsis would then be theprocess of proving that the act was pure in that
sense. It is by the remorse of the doers whichshows that if he had known the facts he wouldnot have done the deed. In Oedipus, the thingwhich establish this to ours satisfaction is
Oedipus self blinding. It, then, effects apurification of the tragic deed and so makesOedipus eligible to our pity-(Else-98).
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
56/60
In this regard of Elses view it seems
Catharsis is purification of the tragic deed
and not of the emotions of the spectators.This goes against all other instances of
Catharsis as mentioned by Plato and
Aristotle. Aristotle is more concerned with
showing how we can feel pity for the
protagonist and not purifying the sin and
the sinner.
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
57/60
Arousal Of Emotion:-
Aristotle does not state that the purpose of thedramatists art is to create emotional excitement. He
said; The pleasure proper to tragedy comes from pityand fear through imitation- (Poetics-xiv:3), In the firsteleven chapters of the second book of Rhetoric, it isshown that a orator can arouse anger, affection,friendliness, enmity, hatred, fear, shame, pity,
indignation and many other emotions. The supremeemotion on which tragedy depends most is pity-(eleos).Here Pity means Compassionate grief, sympathy forsorrow thats witnessed. Situation like the loss of a child,a father murder, the abduction of a wife, horror at unjust
sexual compulsions etc. can become tragic or providepleasure proper to tragedy.
The Other Major Tragic emotion is fear
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
58/60
The Other Major Tragic emotion is fear Phobos- which seems to imply an instinct to runaway. Terror is better translation to it. The
symptoms of fear as described by rhetoriciansand dramatists are of shivering, shuddling,shrieking, hair standing on etc. prostration
Anger and hatred are the desire for revenge
when harms has been done to a dear one. Conclusion:- Aristotelian scheme of artistic
creation the sequence was as follow:- Mimesiswas the prime method that result in a powerful
emotional arousal which provided for theaudience not only a specific sort of pleasure(hedone) but also a relief or Catharsis.
-Bibliography-
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
59/60
-Bibliography- Primary Texts:- Works of Aristotle, Tran. W.D. Ross. London Oxford UP, 1928 The Republic, Trans. H.D.P. Lee, Penguin-1955,
Works of Aristotle Tran. W.D. Ross. London Oxford UP, 1928 Butcher S.H. Aristotles theory of poetry and Fine Arts. Trans. And
with notes Joun Gasnner , 4 th Ed. USA: Dover Pub. Inc. 1951 Secondary Texts:- Cole, David, Theatrical Event Mythos, A Voca. Middle Town :
Weleyan U,1975.
Beardsley, Monroe C. Aesthetics from Classical Greece to thePresent: A short Histopry. Alabama U of Alabama P -1932
--- Also taken from my random search over Internet search
IGNOUs Study Materials- Prepared by Dr. Bharat Gupt, College ofVocational Studies, Delhi Univ. Delhi
7/27/2019 Classical Criticism in English Literature
60/60
Audio-Visual Out-Put
I am soon going to publish my Audio and
Video lecture over the present Slide
shows. And I hereby invite all of you, if any
body is interested to help me with thistask.
Top Related