ChristmasGiving Insights
2021: Making Christmas even more appealing
Christmas donor trends 2021: Making Christmas more appealing
2enthuse.com
Introduction
Christmas appeals and campaigns are a critical part of the year for most charities.
Judging when to release campaigns and what times of the day are most appealing to
the public is challenging at the best of times. The impact of the pandemic has made this
even harder as the public’s giving habits have been shifting as lockdowns, working from
home and then the easing of restrictions have all changed the ways people behave.
To help charities get the most from their campaigns, we have looked at our own
collated data from the last two years to explore which days could potentially be the
best for online donations and what times of day people are most likely to donate
during the Christmas period.
We looked at our data from the last two years to help uncover behaviour changes and
have particularly focused on the Christmas period from November through to January
to find out when donations start to rise and tail off. From our data it is clear that
charities should be focusing on December as their key month, as both November and
January follow fairly regular giving patterns that we would expect to see most of the
year round.
Christmas donor trends 2021: Making Christmas more appealing
3enthuse.com
If donations were split equally across the month, there would be an average of 3.2%
made each day. Christmas 2019 saw a steady increase during the month peaking on
the 23rd and 24th December, followed by a significant drop off from Christmas Day till
the end of the year. The pattern of giving in 2020 was slightly different, and despite
tiered lockdowns happening in different parts of the country - there was much more
consistent giving throughout the month. And although there were still peaks, the
difference between the first few days of the month and Christmas Eve were much less
marked.
In 2019, Christmas Eve saw 7% of all December donations whereas in 2020, this figure was only
4.6%. This shows how much smoother donations were throughout the month compared to 2019.
This may be because more people were working from home throughout December and there
were still numerous restrictions in place limiting the number of leisure activities people could
take part in. With some having more disposable income to donate, the public may have tended
towards giving earlier. As we return to more normal circumstances around this festive period, it’s
possible that habits may fall back to more like 2019.
December in summary
Christmas donor trends 2021: Making Christmas more appealing
4enthuse.com
December in summary
Figure 1: Donations per day from 2019 and 2020
Donations per day
Christmas donor trends 2021: Making Christmas more appealing
5enthuse.com
Giving Tuesday is a well established part of the US holiday season, linked together with
Thanksgiving and Black Friday. Last year in the US it grew 25% from 2019 and saw a
total of $2.47 billion donated. In the UK, it took place on December 1st and raised £20.2
million - an increase of 43% from 2019. This increase can also be seen in our data which
saw an uplift in donations on Giving Tuesday.
Looking at the first week of December (Tuesday 1st - Sunday 6th), there was an average
of 3.2% of the month’s donations made every day - the same as the average for the whole
of the month. Giving Tuesday stands out in the week with just under 4.2% of donations for
December made on that day. In 2019 this figure was 3.7% so there is a clear jump year on
year as well as in comparison with the rest of the month.
For charities considering getting involved in Giving Tuesday, it is worth noting its growth
and its growing focus in the UK as the start of the traditional giving season. It takes place
on November 30th this year, which could work well as it’s the last day of the month and
pay day for many people. Its impact is very much focused on the day itself, so charities
should anchor activity on the 30th rather than looking to drive donations before or after.
Giving Tuesday
Figure 2: Percentage of daily donations in first week of December
% of donations
Christmas donor trends 2021: Making Christmas more appealing
6enthuse.com
Weekdays are far more popular for donations than weekends. While this pattern
happens all year round, it makes a far more substantial difference in a key donation
month like December. Although most of last December was not a full lockdown, there
were still many more restrictions than are likely to be in place this year. This means the
weekends will see more focus on shopping, catching up with friends and families and
less time for getting involved with charities.
In 2019, without any Covid restrictions, weekends saw an average of 2.5% of monthly
donations, whereas weekdays were 1% higher at 3.5% of monthly donations each day. In
2020, with some Covid restrictions in place, this gap narrowed a little with 2.6% of monthly
donations on the weekend and 3.3% on weekdays. In general terms, as shown in Figure
3, the number of donations rises during the week with Friday seeing the most generous
giving, with Saturday the least.
Figure 3: Percentage of donations made each day of December 2020
% of donations per day
End of the week donating peak
Christmas donor trends 2021: Making Christmas more appealing
7enthuse.com
End of the week donating peak
In 2019, the pattern of giving during December increased each week to a peak on
Christmas Eve, followed by a sharp drop from Christmas Day onwards. For 2020, as can
be seen in Figure 4, there was a different pattern with a much more consistent amount of
donations each week, and the peak period for giving coming in weeks two and three - a
week earlier than 2019. The more consistent giving pattern seen in 2020 may see changes
this year though with a more normal Christmas period expected. This means the peak
week for donating is likely to shift forward again. A sensible approach would see a focus on
week three for driving donations through paid media and campaigns. Week three has seen
high levels of giving in both of the last two years, though it is worth considering that this
is also likely to be the most competitive period. Having looked at the best days and weeks
for donating, we will now explore the best times of the day for fundraising marketing.
Figure 4: Average number of donations made each week of December (2020 and 2019)
Average % of donations each week
Christmas donor trends 2021: Making Christmas more appealing
8enthuse.com
Restrictions, such as working from home, changed the dynamics of the times of day
people donated. There were marked differences between peaks in the times of the day
people donated from December 2019 to September 2020. There was a general shift
to giving earlier and some clear spikes in popular hours to donate. This year looking
at December 2020 and September 2021 there is much more consistency between the
hours that people donate, as shown in Figure 5.
Looking at the figures for December 2020, while no single hour stood out, there was a
clearly favoured period for donating between 10.00-13.00. Across the month, these 3 hours
accounted for 21.4% of donations being made during a 24 hour period. The same time
period was also the peak for Christmas Eve 2020 with 22.3% of that day’s donations made
then. Giving Tuesday 2020 had a slightly later peak with 11.00-14.00 being the strongest
period with 21.2% of the day’s donations made then.
Last December’s figures are important to consider when thinking about the hours to push
campaigns and paid media. However, it is also worth looking at more recent months to
understand how changes in Covid restrictions and the return to offices is impacting on
donation patterns. Looking at August-September this year, there are two peak three hour
periods for donations. Firstly 8.00-11.00, which accounts for 20.7% of daily donations, and
secondly 18.00-21.00, which accounts for 20.6% of daily donations. The shift in hours from
December seems likely to be down to people returning to the office and commuting once
again, with people more likely to donate at the start and end of their working day.
Is there a golden hour for donations?
Christmas donor trends 2021: Making Christmas more appealing
9enthuse.com
Is there a golden hour for donations?
Figure 5: Peak donation hours for December, Giving Tuesday, Christmas Eve and August-September
Peak donation hours
Christmas donor trends 2021: Making Christmas more appealing
10enthuse.com
Platforms
When thinking about Christmas appeals it’s important to consider how you can best
help your supporters by providing them with templates for the platforms they use to
promote their fundraising. Our quarterly donor research, Donor Pulse, has shown that
Facebook is the clear leader amongst all age groups, with 52% saying they would share
on the platform to try and raise funds (Figure 6). For all age groups this is more than
twice as much as its nearest competition - Instagram and WhatsApp, both at 25%.
However, this gap is closed significantly for younger age groups. While 67% of Gen Z
would use Facebook, 57% would use Instagram and 39% would use TikTok. For millennials,
again Facebook leads with 65%, with Instagram on 43% and WhatsApp in third place on
40%.
Unsurprisingly social platforms are most popular with younger age groups and once past
age 55, nearly half (47%) would not share their fundraising on social media. Surprisingly,
amongst all age groups, neither Twitter or email performed well - with just 14% saying they
would use either of these to share their fundraising efforts.
So when charities are considering their fundraising packs for Christmas campaigns,
they need to be thinking more about how to help their supporters spread the word on
Instagram and TikTok rather than Twitter and email.
Figure 6: Social networks used to share fundraising
Christmas donor trends 2021: Making Christmas more appealing
11enthuse.com
Conclusion
The last 18 months have been anything but normal so there is a lot to consider when
looking at this data. There have been numerous different restrictions in place at
different times which have impacted the peak periods for donations. But this appears
to be settling now as people go back to their offices, and to an extent a return to more
normal timings for donations can be seen appearing.
The first thing to consider is that Giving Tuesday is growing and starting to establish
itself as the start of the Christmas giving period as it has done in the US. If your charity is
involved in this, the focus is purely on the day - November 30th this year - and the peak
time last year was slightly later than other days in December. This may be down to early
activity in the US on the day making it trend on social media from around 11am, so an
approach that takes this into account is the best route.
When thinking about wider Christmas campaign planning - think about the different weeks
to focus on first. The first two weeks of December should be used to build awareness
of your activities and appeals through a variety of content and media. While Facebook
is popular for spreading awareness of fundraising, there is plenty of activity on other
platforms with Instagram and TikTok very popular with younger age groups, so think about
experimenting with different platforms.
Week three of December has been a peak donation period for the last two years, so
consider using this as a focus week, before the public gets too busy with the festive
season. This is particularly important this year when people are likely to spend more time
with friends and family after the tight restrictions of 2020.
Focusing on the elements of the campaign looking for donations mid-December will create
the best opportunities to fundraise. It’s also worth planning for a final push in the last few
days before Christmas when pay day has taken place, as the 20-24th December are always
traditionally big donation days, whereas from the 25th onwards, donations drop rapidly.
Though do bear in mind if you are using paid media that the 20-24th December will be
highly competitive, so consider this when planning.
When looking at the days of the week to focus efforts around - the optimal times to push
your Christmas appeal messages are towards the end of the week, and avoid weekends.
There may be less competition for donors earlier in the week, but the generosity of donors
is far higher on Thursday and Friday than the rest of the week.
Christmas donor trends 2021: Making Christmas more appealing
12enthuse.com
Conclusion
The hours of the day to consider for targeted ads, organic posts and email marketing are
not as clear cut. While December traditionally has been late morning, there has been a
shift earlier as more normal work patterns return, so it is worth thinking about whether
your supporters and donors are likely to be back in the office before planning your
spend. Testing and learning during the month to find the optimal donation time for your
organisation will provide the most successful route.
Good luck, and if you would like to discuss your Christmas campaign planning, please drop
us an email at [email protected].
Top Related