2. The relationship between the American Catholic Church to the
sciences has frequently been misunderstood.
3. There is a common misconception that there must be a divide
between religion and sciencethat scientists cannot be religious and
the religious cannot be scientists.
4. While it may appear that science and religion have little in
common, there has historically been much activity between
them.
- Catholicism and science are absolutely incompatible
John William Draper
1898
5. In fact, the Catholic Church has made substantial contributions
to science.J.L. Heilbron, for instance, maintains in his book, The
Sun in the Church (1999) that the Roman Catholic Church gave more
financial and social support to the study of astronomy for over six
centuries, from the recovery of ancient learning during the late
Middle Ages into the Enlightenment, then any other, and, probably,
all other institutions. (Binzley 697)
6. However, by the 20th century, it was no longer enough to sing
the historical praises of the Church
7. to point out the help which the Popes gave to science in the
13th century by funding the most important universities
8. or the fact that some of the most important scientists of the 19
century were Catholics, including Pasteur, one of the most
prominent chemists and biologists of his time, and an obedient son
of the Church. (Binzley 704)
Louis Pasteur
Chemist, Biologist, Catholic
1822 - 1895
9. During the early part of the 20th century, American education
was undergoing powerful changes and student enrollment in the study
of the sciences soared.
Founded in 1789, Georgetown University in Washington DC is the
oldest Catholic University in America.
10. Catholic institutions of higher learning, however, were still
teaching a curriculum based on a European model that focused on a
primarily classical-humanist education.
11. These modern changes forced Catholic education to acknowledge
the need to conform their schools to the emerging standard of
American collegiate education, while maintaining their
traditionally accepted Catholic foundation.
12. Most leaders of Catholic education had come to regard
neo-scholastic philosophy, otherwise known as Thomism, as the key
instrument for infusing modern educational institutions with an
explicit Catholic rationale. (Binzley 700)
13. Named for St. Thomas Aquinas, Thomism was the notion that there
exists an objective and intelligible reality to which all persons
have access through the use of reason and intuition. (Binzley
701)
14. In 1928 the Catholic Round Table of Science was founded.
15. However, by the end of World War II, the Round Table ultimately
disbanded with an overall lack of success.
16. Catholic scientists wished to re-establish a national
organization focused on the advancement of science.
17. The Rev. Patrick Henry Yancey, S.J., chairman of the biology
department at Spring Hill College, a small Jesuit college in
Mobile, Alabama, and a recent appointee of President Trumans to the
newly founded National Science Board led the establishment of a new
organization, the Albertus Magnus Guild.
18. The Guilds purpose was to improve Catholics scientific
performance and to refute the widely held notion among non-Catholic
Americans that Catholicism was inherently hostile to science.
(Binzley 695)
19. By affirming both the human minds capacity to acquire objective
truth and the rational basis of Christian faith, the Guild
attempted to promote research collaboration, increased interaction
and scientific activity amongst Catholic scientists, and assistance
in uniting the perceived rift between science and religion.
(Binzley 701)
20. The Great Debate encompassed a period of severe intellectual
turmoil within the Catholic Church of America.
21. Philosophy of Nature
Ontological context of
scientific findings
Modern science based
on empirical data
Many Thomists couldnt accept or grasp the rapidly growing
distinction of scientific ideas that were emerging.
22. Controversial areas of scientific research demanded Catholic
action in the form of research programs and public policies
consistent with Catholic morals and values.
23. The majority of the Guilds membership, however, consisted
primarily of members of Catholic higher education, lacking in
modern research knowledge.It thus began to lose its appeal to
Catholics living and working in secular society.
The AMG leadership at the 1962 annual meeting. Pictured from left
to right are Hugh Taylor (guild president from 1953 to 1960);
Patrick Yancey; John Wright, Bishop of Pittsburgh (guild honorary
president from 1959 to 1969); Frederick Rossini, Dean of the
College of Science at Notre Dame University (guild president from
1960 to 1965); and Lawrence Baldinger, Associate Dean of the
College of Science at Notre Dame University (Editor of the Bulletin
from 1961 to 1965).
24. Walter J. OngKnowledge does not consist of a static system that
can simply be passed on from one generation to the next. (Binzley
720)
25. Ong argued that American Catholics have a duty to be more
receptive to modern thought to learn about, facilitate, and
consider the significance (of the sciences) for Catholic theology
and philosophy. (Binzley 720)
26. This ultimately led to an American Catholic educational
institution very similar to non-Catholic systems.
27. In 1969 the Rev. Patrick Henry Yancey and the Albertus Magnus
Guild died together, yet not without leaving a lasting impression
on Catholicism, science, and American education.
28. Science departments in Catholic universities were improving
~
~ Catholic participation in the sciences had noticeably
increased.
29. The Rev. Patrick Henry Yancey and the Albertus Magnus Guild
maintained the belief that religion should have no bearing on the
practice of science in the laboratory that in this sense there was
no Catholic science rather Catholic philosophy that should provide
a guide for placing moral limits on the work of Catholic
scientists. ( Binzley 723)
30. The development of Catholic science education and the
relationship between the American Catholic Church and the sciences
can be viewed through these efforts of Yancey and the Albertus
Magnus Guild. (Binzley 722)
31. Sources"A Biblical Portrayal of Healing." ShutterStock.com.
Web. 27 Mar 2010. "Albertus Magnus." GAIA Community. Web. 27 Mar
2010."Array of French Popes." Travelpod. Web. 27 Mar 2010. Binzley,
Ronald A. "American Catholocism's Science Crisis and the Albertus
Magnus Guild, 1953-1969." Isis. 98. (2007): 695-723. Print. "Dolly
the Sheep." The Age. Web. 28 Mar 2010. "Fordham University." Guests
of a Guest. Web. 28 Mar 2010. "John William Draper."
Chemistry.About. Web. 27 Mar 2010. Kurtz, Paul, ed. Science and
Religion Are They Compatible?. 1st ed. Amherst, NY: Prometheus
Books, 2003. Print. "Louis Pasteur." Garden of Praise. Web. 27 Mar
2010. "Rev Patrick Yancey." TimotheosPrologizes. Web. 28 Mar 2010.
"Oldest Catholic Univesity." DowntownDCHotel. Web. 28 Mar 2010.
"Pope Benedict XVI." Top News. Web. 27 Mar 2010."Science and
Society." Physics Today. Web. 28 Mar 2010. "Science Class." Bishop
Challoner.org. Web. 28 Mar 2010. "Stem Cells." MyPortfolio.usc.edu.
Web. 28 Mar 2010. "St. Thomas." HolbytiaWorldpress. Web. 28 Mar
2010. Stop Abortion..." StoptheACLU.com. Web. 28 Mar 2010.
"Thinker." MSPMentor. Web. 28 Mar 2010.
Top Related