Download - CantonPublicWorks Presentation

8/13/2019 CantonPublicWorks Presentation

1/41

Town of Canton

Relocation of the Canton Municpal Highway Garage

Site and Needs Assessment

Draft

January 7, 2014


2/41

Mission Statement

Design a new highway garage facility for the

Department of Public Works

The new facility to support the current and

future needs of the department

Evaluate three identified sites and develop a

qualitative and quantitative analysis of eachsite. Selecting a recommend site for future

development.


3/41

Due Diligence

Re-evaluate the current space and

programmatic needs

Compare the proposed program to surrounding

towns and industry standards

Re-evaluate proposed floor plan layouts

Review site conditions and land use restrictions


4/41

Proposed Program Comparsions


5/41

Plan A

Net SF: 21,641


6/41

Plan B

Net SF: 19,485


7/41

Plan C

Net SF: 19,079


8/41

Plan D

Net SF: 19,903


9/41

Proposed SitesKey Map

55 Lawton Rd

325 Commerce DR

51 River Road


10/41

Site 3 55 Lawton RoadProperty Line


11/41

Site 3 55 Lawton RoadBuilding Setback Line


12/41

Site 3 55 Lawton RoadTree Buffer


13/41

Site 3 55 Lawton RoadWetland Buffer


14/41

Site 3 55 Lawton RoadNoise Buffer


15/41

Site 3 55 Lawton RoadImpervious Area


16/41

Site 3 55 Lawton RoadBuildable Area


17/41

Site 3 55 Lawton RoadProposed Layout


18/41



19/41



20/41

!"#$%#&'() +,'&-,'# .'&- / 0 11 2#3&() 4(#5+,'&-,'# 678(,)9- :,#5- .9(,- +(77-)&;


21/41

Site 2 51 River RoadProperty Line


22/41

Site 2 51 River RoadBuilding Setback Line


23/41

Site 2 51 RiverRoadTree Buffer


24/41

Site 2 51 RiverRoadNoise Buffer


25/41

Site 2 51 RiverRoadImpervious Area


26/41

Site 2 51 River RoadBuildable Area


27/41

Site 2 51 River RoadProposed Layout


28/41



29/41



30/41

!"#$%#&'() +,'&-,'# .'&- B 01< 4'"-, 4(#5+,'&-,'# 678(,)9- :,#5- .9(,- +(77-)&;


31/41

Site 1 325 Commerce DriveProperty Line


32/41

Site 1 325 Commerce DriveBuilding Setback Line


33/41

Site 1 325 Commerce DriveTree Buffer


34/41

Site 1 325 Commerce DriveImpervious Area


35/41

Site 1 325 Commerce DriveBuildable Area


36/41

Site 1 325 Commerce DriveProposed Layout


37/41



38/41



39/41

!"#$%#&'() +,'&-,'# .'&- < 0 /B1 +(77-,9- C,'"-+,'&-,'# 678(,)9- :,#5- .9(,- +(77-)&;


40/41

Questions & Answers


41/41

Site Evaluation Matrix 12 02 13.xls

Silver/Petrucelli + Associates, Inc. December 30, 2013Architects / Engineers / Interior Designers

3190 Whitney Avenue Hamden, Ct 06518

(P) 203-230-9007 silverpetrucelli.com

Town of Canton - Public Garage Site Assessment Study

Site Evaluation Matrix

Evaluation CriteriaCriteria Importance Grade Score Comments1 Site Acquisition Cost / Value 1 1 1 5% of construction cost - 225,000$2 Site Development Cost 1 5 5

3 Site Size 2 10 20

4 Site Location and Accessibility 2 10 20

5 Vehicular Access & Parking 3 10 30

6 Neighborhood Impact & Aesthetics 2 10 20

7 Public Utility Availability 3 10 30 On site8 Zoning Restrictions and Variances 3 10 30

9 Open 'Green' Space 1 10 10

10 Environmental & Wetlands Impact 3 5 15

11 Building Construction Costs 2 10 20

12 Potential Site Contamination 3 10 30 undeveloped site13 Building Demolition Costs 1 10 10

14 Future Expansion Opportunities 2 5 10

TOTAL SCORE 251

Evaluation CriteriaCriteria Importance Grade Score Comments

1 Site Acquisition Cost / Value 1 10 10

2 Site Development Cost 1 10 10

3 Site Size 2 1 2




7 Public Utility Availability 3 10 30

8 Zoning Restrictions and Variances 3 1 3


10 Environmental & Wetlands Impact 3 10 30

11 Building Construction Costs 2 5 10 possible 2 story needed12 Potential Site Contamination 3 10 30

13 Building Demolition Costs 1 5 5


TOTAL SCORE 158

Evaluation CriteriaCriteria Importance Grade Score Comments

1 Site Acquisition Cost / Value 1 10 10

2 Site Development Cost 1 5 5

3 Site Size 2 10 20




7 Public Utility Availability 3 1 3

8 Zoning Restrictions and Variances 3 10 30


10 Environmental & Wetlands Impact 3 1 311 Building Construction Costs 2 10 20

12 Potential Site Contamination 3 10 30

13 Building Demolition Costs 1 10 10


TOTAL SCORE 193

Importance Grade

3 - Very Important 10 - Good

Site 1 - 325 Commerce Drive

Site 2 -51 River Road

Site 3 - 55 Lawton Road