1
Assessment of Community-based MDR TB care in Yangon Region: An Operational Research
Saw Saw1, KhinSwe Win2, Si Thu Aung3, AungPyae Phyo1, Kyaw Thu Soe1, Zaw Lin Tun2 and MyatKyaw Thu3
Department of Medical Research Myanmar Medical Association
National Tuberculosis Programme, Department of Public Health
February 2018
2
3
List of investigators Principal investigators
1. Dr. Saw Saw
Director (Socio-Medical Research)
Department of Medical Research
2. Dr. Khin Swe Win
Programme Coordinator
MMA MDR-TB Project
Co investigators
1. Dr. Si Thu Aung
Programme Manager
National TB Programme
2. Dr. Aung Pyae Phyo
Research Officer
Health Systems Research Division
Department of Medical Research
3. Dr. Kyaw Thu Soe
Research Officer
Health Systems Research Division
Department of Medical Research (PyinOoLwin Branch)
4. Dr. Zaw Lin Tun
Senior Project Officer
MMA MDR-TB Project
5. Dr. MyatKyaw Thu
Assistant Director/Focal person for MDR- TB
National TB Programme
Collaborators
1. Dr. Myo Myat Aung
Project Officer, MMA MDR-TB Project
2. Dr. Thurain
AEI Officer
MMA MDR-TB Project
3. Dr.Khine Sabai Min
M&E Officer
MMA MDR-TB Project
4. Daw Thandar Min
Research Assistant
Health Systems Research Division
Department of Medical Research
5. Daw Hla Thida Tun
Research Assistant
Health Systems Research Division
Department of Medical Research
6. Dr. Zayar Moe
Project Assistant, MMA MDR TB Project
4
5
Acknowledgement Our sincere gratitude goes to Director Generals from Department of Medical Research and
Department of Public Health, Deputy Director General (Disease Control) and the President from
MMA for their kind approvals to conduct this study. Special thanks go to Regional Health
Director and Regional TB Officer from Yangon Region, NTP staff, TMOs, TB coordinators and
BHS from study townships (Thingankyun, HlaingTharYar, ShwePyiThar). Our heartfelt thanks
are given to volunteers, staff from MMA, MHAA, PyiGyiKhin and research assistants who
involved in data collection. We are grateful to all MDR TB patients and all participants for
sharing their views and experiences with great enthusiasm. Without them, this research would
not have been possible. The study was funded by the 3MDG.
6
7
Table of content
List of abbreviations
Executive summary ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 9
Introduction ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 11
Objectives …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 13
Methodology ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 15
Findings ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 21
1. Background characteristics of MDR TB patients ………………………………………………………. 23
2. Treatment seeking pattern of MDR TB patients ………………………………………………………. 23
3. Treatment outcomes of MDR TB patients …………………………………………………………….... 26
4. Recruitment process of community volunteers and volunteers supervisors …………… 27
5. Attrition among recruited community volunteers …………………………………………………… 29
6. Performance of community volunteers …………………………………………………………………… 30
1.1 Providing Evening DOTS to MDR-TB patients ……………………………………………………….. 30
1.2 Health Education and adherence counseling to MDR-TB patients and close contacts.31
1.3 Side effect monitoring of MDR-TB drugs ………………………………………………………………. 34
1.4 Home-based infection control ………………………………………………………………………………. 36
1.5 Household Contact tracing and referral ………………………………………………………………… 37
1.6 Assisting in monetary and nutritional support ………………………………………………………. 37
1.7 Assisting in follow up visits ……………………………………………………………………………………. 37
1.8 Recording and Reporting ………………………………………………………………………………………. 37
2. Role of volunteers in community based MDR TB care ……………………………………………… 38
3. Success of CB MDRTBC ……………………………………………………………………………………………. 40
4. Challenges of CB MDRTBC ………………………………………………………………………………………. 43
5. Patients’ preference on existing support package ………………………………………………….. 48
6. Opinions and Suggestions ………………………………………………………………………………………. 52
Discussion and conclusion ………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 57
Recommendation ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 61
References …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 62
8
Abbreviations TB = Tuberculosis
MDR-TB = Multidrug resistant tuberculosis
CB MDRTBC = Community based MDR-TB care
NTP = National Tuberculosis Programme
NGO = Non Governmental Organization
MMA = Myanmar Medical Association
PGK = PyiGyiKhin
MHAA = Myanmar Health Assistant Association
DOT = Direct Observed Treatment Short Course
BHS = Basic Health Staffs
ANC = Ante Natal Care
9
Executive summary This is a collaborative operational research among DMR, National TB Programme (NTP) and
Myanmar Medical Association (MMA). It aimed to assess the patient-centered community based
MDR-TB care (CB MDR TBC) and treatment support model implemented by local Non-
Governmental Organizations (NGOs) in Yangon (2015-2016). The study was conducted in three
townships in Yangon where three local NGOs (MMA, PyiGyiKhin and Myanmar Health
Assistant Association) implement CB MDR TBC. Record review of MDR TB patients’ registers
from 37 townships and volunteer reports from 3 study townships; 16 key informant interviews
with Basic Health Staff (BHS) and local NGO staff; six Focus group Discussions (FGDs) with
MDR TB patients; and three FGDs with community volunteers were conducted. Ranking were
conducted during FGD with MDR TB patients to prioritize their needs on care and supports.
Observation of quarterly meetings of local NGOs, volunteers and BHS at township was also
carried out. Qualitative data were analysed with the assistance of Atlas ti version 6.1 software.
Community volunteers provided evening Directly Observed Treatment (DOT) to (1654/2053,
81%) MDR TB patients in 2015-2016 in 37 townships in Yangon where 3 local NGOs
implemented comprehensive community based MDR TB (CB MDR TB) care. They provided
health education and adherence counseling to MDR TB patients and referred 578 contacts of
MDR TB patients. Among referral, 48 (8%) were diagnosed as TB and 14 (2%) were diagnosed
as Drug Resistant TB. Majority of participants accepted role of volunteers for CB MDR TB care
as they assist and reduce workload of BHS. Adherence counseling and evening DOT by
volunteers were appreciated both by patients and BHS. Attrition of volunteers was low (8%).
Main reasons for sustainability of volunteers were proper selection of them in collaboration with
BHS and supervision and monitoring. MDR TB patients preferred monetary support, evening
DOT and adherence counseling in order of ranking. The challenges identified as weak
coordination between LNGO and BHS for supervision of volunteers; refusal of patients to take
treatment, some BHS pointed out patients did not appreciate their care and more rely on LNGOs
or volunteers who provided them monetary supports. Some BHS stated that they gave priority
for selection of volunteers would usually assist them. However, few key informants concerned
volunteers would not assist them for other health activities which did not pay any incentives (eg.
Immunization, AN care). Few BHS could not provide injection at MDR TB patient’s home and
very few community volunteers were absent to provide evening DOT. The study recommended
strengthening coordination among local NGOs, volunteers and BHS; enhancing supervision and
monitoring my Township Health Department to ensure DOT; continuing monetary support for
MDR TB patients, clarifying roles and responsibilities of BHS, volunteers and volunteers’
supervisors; and expending CB MDR TBC while human resources at public health sector is
limited. Dissemination meeting to share research findings was conducted on 26th
December 2017
and recommendations were taken up by the NTP and implementing partners.
10
11
Introduction
12
Introduction
Tuberculosis, one of the diseases of national concern, is still a major public health problem in
Myanmar. Not surprisingly, the burden due to MDR-TB is also immense in Myanmar. The
country is listed as one of the 30 high TB, MDRTB and TB-HIV burden countries in the world
(1).
The management of MDR-TB patients is rather complicated, resource intensive and costly to
both patients and countries’ health systems. Current recommended MDR-TB treatment includes
highly toxic drugs with long treatment duration, which lead the patients facing many social and
psychological problems along with their disabilities due to the drugs’ side effects (4). The
treatment success rate among MDR-TB patients is significantly poor at ~50% because of high
rates of mortality and loss to follow-up among them (1).
Multi-drug resistant tuberculosis (MDR –TB) is one of the major challenges facing global TB
control today. It was estimated that there were 480,000 new MDR-TB cases worldwide, 125,000
patients enrolled for MDR-TB treatment, and 250,000 deaths due to MDR-TB in 2015.
Compared to 2014, the number of treated cases increased, but the incidence of MDR-TB and
number of deaths due to MDR-TB was higher than that of estimated 190,000 deaths in 2014 (1-
3).
The third nationwide drug resistance survey (2012-2013) in Myanmar showed that the
prevalence of MDR-TB was 5% among new TB cases and 27.1% among retreatment cases.
Compared to previous drug resistance surveys, it was significantly higher (4% in 2003, 4.2% in
2008, 5% in 2013 among new cases, 15.5% in 2003, 10.2% in 2008, 27.1% in 2013 among
retreatment cases) (5-7).
Myanmar has the treatment success rates among registered MDR-TB patients as 79% versus
50% for 2012 cohort. This is possibly due to several patient support measures implemented by
the National TB Programme (NTP) (1).
However, the big gap still exists between estimated incidence of MDR-TB, number of patients
diagnosed and numbers treated in Myanmar. World Health Organization (WHO) estimated in
2015 that 9,000 MDR-TB cases develop each year, less than half of them are diagnosed and not
all of the diagnosed patients are enrolled for treatment (1).
To fight against MDR/DR-TB, the National Tuberculosis Programme (NTP) in Myanmar, in
close collaboration with partners and generous support of the donors has been implementing the
programmatic management of drug resistant TB (PMDT) guidelines since 2009. The pilot
project in 2009 initiated in ten townships of Yangon and Mandalay Regions has now been scaled
up country-wide with decentralized availability of treatment services at every township. The
PMDT includes initial hospitalization, only for sick patients, for baseline investigations and
treatment initiation, follow by ambulatory care in the community. During the ambulatory care,
patients receive DOT by a nurse, Basic Health Staff (BHS), Non-Governmental Organization
(NGO) staff or volunteer trained in DOT and MDR-TB care (8).
Both the STOP TB strategy and The END TB strategy of WHO recommended the involvement
of community in delivering TB care (9-10). The community-based tuberculosis care has been
proved as an effective model in early TB case findings, providing DOTS for TB patients by
previous studies in Myanmar (11-13).
To reduce the morbidity and mortality of MDR-TB in Myanmar, early and increased MDR-TB
case detection, improving linkage to appropriate treatment initiation once diagnosed and
successful treatment with short, efficient and tolerable therapy are crucial. More importantly, a
13
public health effort to prevent further transmission of and progression to MDR-TB needs high
attention. By 2020, Myanmar targets to enroll all MDR-TB patients on treatment within 2 weeks
of their diagnosis and standardized patient support package to enable treatment success rates of
more than 80% (14).
Four local NGOs namely MMA MDR TB project, Myanmar Health Assistant Association
(MHAA), PyiGyiKhin and Maternal and Child Welfare Association (MCWA) implement
community based MDR TB projects since 2013 in Yangon Region (14).
This community based DOT model is scaled up by The Three Millennium Development Goals
Multi-Donor Trust Fund (3MDG Fund) coordinating and collaboration with National TB
Program.In 2015, MMA has continued implementing this model, as MMA MDR-TB Project, in
8 townships of Yangon Region.Community volunteers were recruited from the existing
community networks in the 13 focus townships. They worked alongside basic health staff to
conduct daily home visits to MDR-TB patients for evening DOT,providing psychosocial support,
conducting contact tracing, infection control and providing health education to patients and
family members. Other supports include nutritional support and financial support (30000
kyats/month).
These were the country’s first community volunteers to provide DOT for MDR-TB patients, and
the community-driven DOT model was recognized by the international sector for its potential for
scale-up.The NTP has also valued the potential of this community-based MDR TB model to
support rapid scale-up of PMDT through expansion to other project townships. With support
from the 3MDG Fund, this model has now been scaled up to 43 townships in Yangon through 3
partners MMA, MHAA, and PGK. MCWA got funding from Burnet Institute to implement CB
MDR-TB in one township in Yangon.
The net impact of these measures on treatment outcomes among MDR-TB patients have not been
systematically assessed yet. Furthermore, studies are limited to evaluate how much success has
been made so far about this patient-centered community-based MDR-TB care model, and to
address the operational challenges.
Expected benefits:-
The findings from this operational research will highlight the current situationof patient-centred
community-based MDR-TB care and treatment support model in Yangon Region. It would be
useful in scaling up of this model to other regions in Myanmar and to strengthen and sustain
partnership approach.
Objectives
General objective
To assess the patient –centered community-based MDR-TB care and treatment support model
implemented by local NGOs in Yangon (2015-2016)
Specific Objectives:-
1. To assess treatment outcomes (the cure rate, treatment success rate and mortality) of
MDR-TB patients enrolled by NTP in 2015 and supported with standardize package of
support by trained community volunteers of local NGOs
2. To determine the performance of community volunteers on MDR TB care and support
3. To explorethe success and challenges ofcommunity-based MDR TB care and treatment
support model
4. To elicit the suggestions and opinion of community volunteers, Basic Health Staff and
MDR TB patients on community-based MDR-TB careand treatment support model
14
15
Methodology
PHOTOS
16
17
Methodology:
Study design: An operational research using mixed methods design
Study Areas: Yangon, the city with the highest population density and large existing of mobile
and migrant population, enrolled the highest number MDR-TB cases (1272 out of 2793 MDR-
TB cases). Three townships (one township from each local NGO) were selected for qualitative
assessment in Yangon based on criteria of largest enrollment number of MDR-TB patients in
2015-2016.
1)ThinganKyun (MMA township)
2)HlaingTharYar (MHAA township)
3)ShwePyiThar (PyiGyiKhin township)
Study Population:
NTP enrolled MDR-TB patients from January 2015to September 2016 from study
townships
Trained Community volunteerswho were providing MDR-TB treatmentfrom study
townships
Community supervisors from study townships
Township Medical Officers (TMOs), TB coordinators, and midwives from study
townships.
Data collection methods and sample size
Objectives Data collection methods Study population and Sample
size
1. To assess treatment
outcomes (the cure rate
and treatment success
rate and mortality) of
MDR-TB patients who
are enrolled by NTP in
2015 and supported with
standardize package of
support by community
volunteers
Record review of MDR TB
treatment registers from 37
townships and records of
community volunteers from 3
study townships
NTP enrolled MDR-TB patients
from January 2015 to September
2016 in Yangon Region
2. To determine the
performance of
community volunteers on
MDR TB care and
support
Record review of community
volunteers’ reports from study
townships
Supervision reports of
community supervisors
3. To explorethe success
and challenges of
community-based MDR
TB care and treatment
support model
Key informant interviews (KIIs)
by using pre-tested Guide
(Annex 1)
Focus Group Discussion (FGDs)
by using pre-tested Guide
(Annex 2)
From each township:
One TMO, one TB coordinator
and one community supervisors
One FGD with Community
volunteers
One FGD with MDR TB patients
who completed initial treatment
18
4. To elicit suggestions and
opinion of community
volunteers, Basic Health
Staff and MDR TB
patients on community-
based MDR TB care and
treatment support model
Key informant interviews (KIIs)
by using pre-tested Guide
(Annex 1)
Focus Group Discussion (FGDs)
by using pre-tested Guide
(Annex 3)
From each township:
One TMO, one TB coordinator
and one community supervisors
One FGD with Community
volunteers
One FGD with MDR TB patients
who completed initial treatment
Data Management:-
Quantitative data were obtained from the existing records ofMDR-TB projects and MDR-TB
treatment registers of NTP and descriptive analysis were done.
Qualitative data from KIIs and FGDs were transcribed and analysed according to main themes
and sub-themes with assistance of ATLAS ti version 6 software ..Data use agreement form has
been signed between PI and NTP (Annex 4)
Ethical Consideration
This research proposal was submitted to the Ethics Review Committee (ERC) of Department of
Medical Research. The potential participants were invited and explained about the study by using
participants’ information sheet. Interviews were done with those who gave informed written
consents. Names of townships, local NGOs and participants were kept anonymous and
confidentiality and privacy of respondents were ensured at each and every step of research.
Permission form local NGOs to review their records were obtained.
19
Dissemination of research findings
Dissemination meeting to present findings to key stakeholders were conducted on 26
th December
2017 at Inya Lake Hotel, Yangon. About 100 participants attended the dissemination meeting.
Participants included representatives from local and international NGOs working on TB and
MDR TB, TMOs from 43 townships. Findings were shared to participants and Flyer of summary
findings were distributed
20
21
Findings
22
23
Findings Background characteristics of MDR TB patients
Age distribution of MDR-TB patients
Age groups MHAA
townships
PGK townships MMA townships Total
<14 years 2 1 1 4
14-44 years 543 396 539 1478
45-64 years 228 226 215 669
>65 years 34 39 43 116
Total 807 662 798 2267
Gender distribution of MDR-TB patients
Age groups MHAA
townships
PGK townships MMA townships Total
Female 300 229 282 811
Male 508 433 516 1457
Total 808 662 798 2268
Treatment seeking pattern of MDR TB patients
Most of the patients sought for treatment of fever and cough at general practitioners (GPs).
After not relieving from the symptoms and chest X-ray showing tuberculosis, the GPs referred
them or they themselves went to Township Health Centre (THC) and then the patients took
treatment at THC as drug sensitive Tuberculosis. Some of the patients sought for treatment of
fever and cough at PSI DOTS clinics or Public-Private Mix DOTS clinics and took treatment at
these clinics as drug sensitive TB. Some of the patients were so ill that they were hospitalized to
General Hospitals and then referred again to THC to be treated as drug sensitive TB. A few
patients went to the specialist physicians and then they referred to THC to be treated as drug
sensitive TB.
The patients in this study who started taking treatment at 2015 and 2016 took drug sensitive
anti-TB drugs at THC or PSI DOTS clinics or Public-Private Mix DOTS clinics before the
suspect of MDR-TB. If there was no sputum conversion after 3 months among new and relapse
24
cases, they were referred to Aung San TB Center or Latha TB Center for gene expert and
diagnosed as MDR-TB.
(ေဖဆသ၄) ကျနးေတားက၁ပတးေလာကးဖာ၊ဖာေတာ ေန၊လေဆခနးမြာ သျာျပေတာေဆစပးေသာကး၊ ေဆသျာထအကေနမသကးသာတာန ဆရာ၀နးကဓါတးမြနးသျာၾကညးဆ ထကး မြာသျာရကး ဓါတးမြနးမြာပေတျလဆလြငးသာယာေဆရလႊတးတယးျပမြေဒသႏရမြာသလပးစစး၊ျပမြေအာငးဆနးကသျာ
ေမ-ေအာငးဆနးကထပးသျာခငးေဆယဥးပါဖစးတယးဆတာဘယးအခနးမြာသတာလလြငးသာယာကေပာလကး တာလာ၊ ေအာငးဆနးေရာကးမြသတာလာ။
၄-လြငးသာယာကေနေပာတယးပထမတဘေဆ၆လေသာကးျပမြမသကးသာဖဆလေအာငးဆနးက ေဆရ တကးကတယး (MDRTB patient from FGD)
“Firstly, I suffered from cough and breathlessness, though no blood-stained sputum. I couldn’t
even work. So I went to private clinic (general practitioner). But the cough was not relieved. My
mother took me to the township health centre. Sputum examination was done and then
tuberculosis was diagnosed. Therefore, I took anti – TB drugs for 6 months. But I wasn’t relieved
and I had to take injection for 2 months and oral for another 6 months”
(MDRTB patient from FGD)
“(ေဖဆသ၃)
ထျနးေဆခနးမြာပတယး။အလပးထမြာခမးလာလကး၊ပလာလကး၊အလေတျဖစးတာ၊ေခာငးလညး ဆ။ အလပးလပးရငးနဖစးတာ။အတာနထျနးေဆခနးမြာသျာျပေတာစစးၾကညးတယး။သကသလပးတေသျတ စစးေပတယး။ဓါတးမြနးကေတာ ထနးေခာကးပငးမြာသျာရကးရတယး။
ေမ- ထနးေခာကးပငးဆတာေဆရလာ။
(ေဖဆသ၃) - မဟတးဘ။ေကာငးစေအာငး၊အပငးေဆခနး၊အဒမြာရကးျပေတာထျနးကေနတဘတ၊ေရႊပညး သာေဆရသျာပတယး။တဘေဆ၂ပတးေသာကးရတယး။တဘေဆ၂ပတးေသာကးျပထျနးမြာသလပးပနးစစး တယး။သလပးပနးစစးေတာရရတဘမဟတးဘတ၊ေဆယဥးပါတဘတ” (MDRTB patient from FGD)
“Respondent 3: I went to Tun clinic. I felt hot and cold again and again and then also suffered
from cough. I suffered from these symptoms at work and then I went to Tun clinic. They did
sputum and blood investigations. For chest X-ray, I did at HtanChauk Pin.
Interviewer: Is HtanChauk Pin a hospital?
Respondent 3: No, it means the clinic named Kaung Su Aung. It is a private clinic. After chest X-
ray and investigations, I was diagnosed as tuberculosis and I went to ShwePyiThar Hospital and
anti-TB drugs for two weeks. After those two weeks, sputum examination was done again and I
was diagnosed as multidrug-resistant tuberculosis.”
(MDRTB patient from FGD)
25
“...ေဆခနး(အေထျေထျက)ထပးသျာေတာသကမသကၤာတအတျကးဓာတးမြနးရကးၾကညးလကးတယး။ဓာတးမြနးရကးၾကညးလကးေတာတဘပရြတယးေပါေနား။ရြတယးဆေတာသကေဆေပတယး။သကတခါထေဆေပတယး။အဒါနဆရာမေဒၚရတနာေကားဆေရာကးသျာတယး။သကစပေဆရမြာလညးထငးတယး။အပငးေဆခနးမြာလညးထငးတယး။ဆရာမဆေရာကးသျာေတာဆရာမကဟေပါေနားအရမးစတးထမြာမတငးမကဖစးေနတယးဆရငးေတာေဆရတကးလကးတ။အစာမဝငးဘဖစးေနေတာေလ။ဆရာမကေဆရတကးခငးလကးတယး။ေနာကးတေနမြာပခကးခငးေဆရတကးလကးရတယး။ေဆရမြာ၁၀ရကးေလာကးေတာေနလကးရတယး။ေဆရတကးေတာ ဆရာမကေဆေတျဘာေတျစစးတယးဘာညာစသညးဖငးေပါ။အခနးတနးကလညးအလေဆယဥးပါတဘပါလမေပာေသဘ။ဒေဆပဆကးေသာကးေပါဆျပေဆရကဆငးလာတယး။ဆငးျပတစးလႏြစးလေလာကးေနတအခါကေတာေသျေတျဘာေတျေဆေသာကးေနရငးနေသျေတျဘာေတျပါလာတယး။ေဆရကဆငးျပေတာ ေနာကးတေခါကးဆရာမဆပနးသျာတယး။ဆရာမကအဒေဆရကေနပရနးကနးေဆရၾကမြာေဆယဥးပါတဘ စစးလကးပါလေပာလအဒမြသျာစစးလကးေတာမြေဆယဥးပါတဘေပၚတာ။အေတာမြေအာငးဆနးကလႊတယး။ေအာငးဆနးမြာေဆစေသာကးဖစးတာ။” (MDRTB patient from FGD) “At the follow-up visit, the doctor (general practitioner) did chest X-ray to me with the suspect of
tuberculosis and I was diagnosed as tuberculosis. So I was given anti TB drugs by the
generalpractitioner and then I reached to Daw Yadanar Kyaw. She was a doctor at San Pya
Hospital who also gave service at private clinic. She told me to stay at hospital and then I was
hospitalized immediately. I stayed at hospital for 10 days and investigations were done. Till then
MDR-TB was not diagnosed. So I was told to continue same antiTB drugs as before. Within 2
months after being discharged, my sputum became blood-stained and so I went to Daw Yadanar
Kyaw again and she told me to do some investigations for multidrug resistant tuberculosis
(MDRTB) and then MDRTB was diagnosed. And then I was referred to Aung San”
(MDRTB patient from FGD)
26
Community based MDRTB care
Table Treatment outcomes of MDRTB patients under the care of volunteers from local NGOS
MHAA
n(%)
MMA
n(%)
PGK
n(%)
Cured 175(67) 185(66) 224(63)
Completed 21(8) 29(10) 36(10)
Died 41(16) 46(16) 63(18)
Failure 2(1) 4(1) 5(1)
Loss to Follow Up 13(5) 8(3) 13(4)
Not evaluated 9(3) 7(3) 17(5)
261(100) 279(100) 358(100)
27
Recruitment and Performance of volunteers
Recruitment of volunteers and volunteers’ supervisors
The majority of community volunteers were recruited by the suggestion of basic health staffs and
TMO from Township Health Departments, especially by the township TB Coordinator and
particular midwives. Most of the community volunteers stated that they were selected by the
recommendation of the midwives because they were helping them in other health related
activities, such as immunization programmes and larva control. After recruitment process, the
volunteers had to attend the advocacy meetings and the trainings organized by each organization.
Volunteer supervisor are recruited amongst the community volunteers by each organization after
observing the efficiency as a community volunteer with the recommendation of TMO, HA, TBC
and BHS from related Township Health Department. There is special training for Volunteer
supervisorusing Community Coordinator (Community Supervisor guide) after receiving the
same package of training with community volunteers. “အကနးလအတျကးက မယက ကေနေခၚတအခါၾကေတာ၊ ေခၚခငးေတာ ရပးကျကးစကေလ လနာဖစးမယး ရပးကျကးေတျအမာဆေနရာေတျက ေခၚခငးတာေပါ။ အေတာဥစာေပေခၚခငးေတာ ကျနးမကရပးကျကးထမြာ လမႈေရလပးတယး။ လကးရြမြာလလမႈေရလပးတယး။ ၾကကးေခနလညးလပးတယး ဆေတာ ေနာကးကနးမာေရနပတးသကးျပ ရပးကျကးထမြာ တာဝနးလႊေပထာတာရြေတာ ရပးကျကးက ကျနးမကလႊတးလကးတယး ေထျအပးက” (FGD with Community Volunteers) “The volunteers are collected through the head of wards especially from the areas with highest
burden of MDR TB cases. As I have been involving in the health related activities in the
communities, I was chosen by the head of ward” (FGD with Community Volunteers)
The duty assignment to provide care to MDR-TB patient was arranged by the Community
Supervisor while conducting Quarterly Meeting participated by persons from NTP, THD and
organization.
“Q: ဆရာရပးကျကးမြာလနာအသစးေရာကးလာျပဆပါစအဆအဒသာဖျာဆရာမကအက (volunteer) ကေပာတာလာ? A: မဟတးဘ၊ Supervisor ကေနတဆငးေပါေနား၊အခနးမြာကျနးေတားတ၃လ၁ႀကမး Meetingမြာတစးခါတညးေဆျေႏျ ၾကတာေပါေနား။အဒမြာေပာတယးေပါေနားအဒမြာဒရပးကျကးမြာေတာအသစးေရာကးလာေပါေနားအေတာ Supervisor ကေနျပေတာအစးကရပးကျကးမြာမလအစးကတာ၀နးယလကးပါ (FGD with Community Volunteers)” “Q: If the new MDR TB patient was found in your area, the midwife informed you
(volunteer)? A: No. Indeed, it was told by the community supervisor at the quarterly meeting.
(FGD with Community Volunteers)”
28
Table 1) Background characteristics of recruited and trained volunteers
Characteristics of volunteers Number Percentage
Organization
LNGO-1 269 31.1
LNGO-2 300 34.7
LNGO-3 295 34.1
Gender
Female 661 76.5
Male 203 23.5
Age (years)
17-24 166 19.2
25-35 224 25.9
36-45 228 26.4
46-66 246 28.5
Education
Graduated 103 11.9
Undergraduate 59 6.8
High School 617 71.4
Middle School 68 7.9
Primary School 17 2.0
Other Jobs 199 23.0
AMW/CHW 146 16.9
Members of orgs 192 22.2
Regular income 306 35.4
No job 21 2.4
Retired health staffs 199 23.0
Marital Status
Missing 300 34.7
Single 301 34.8
Married 260 30.1
Other 3 .3
Table 1.1 showed the background characteristics of recruited volunteers to provide community
based MDRTB care. There were 864 recruited volunteers by three LNGOs. The mean (SD) of age
was 37(12) years ranging from 17 to 66 years. Two thirds of them were female (76.5%)(Figure
1).The highest education status was high school (71.4%). One third of them had regular incomes
(35.4%) and 23% were retired health staff.
29
Attrition of volunteers
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
LNGO 1
LNGO2
LNGO3
Active
Inactive
Figure 1) Active volunteers among trained volunteers for community based MDRTB care by local
non-governmental organizations in 37 Townships in Yangon (n=849)
Figure 1 revealed the low gap between the numbers of trained volunteers and active volunteers.
Reasons for attrition
Among 864 recruited volunteers,849 were undergone training and 68 (8%) of them were
inactive. The main reasons for attrition of volunteers included getting paid jobs, moving to another places,
and their health related issues.
”အခေပာငးသျာတထမြာ မလပးခငးပနမပါဘဂရတစကးန လပးေပၾကတယး။ တခကေတာလညး အလေပါေနား အေၾကာငးေၾကာငးန လဝပနးမေရာကးႏငးဘဆမြ ဖနးခတးလပးလကးေတာမြ အလမေတျ ေပါ ေဝေဝသျာတာ။ သတလပးခငးခတယး။ ဒါေပမယး မသာစရအပါအမးပါ ေပာငးသျာတအခါ ကေတာ….”(KII with volunteers’ monitor from Township 1) Among the volunteers who couldn’t do the activities anymore, actually, they had worked this job
very well. Because of many personal reasons, they were unable to work this job again although
they are knee on this job. But because their families move to other places….” (KII with
volunteers’ monitor from Township 1)
30
Box 1 Functions of community volunteers in community based MDRTB care and treatment
support 1. Providing Evening DOTS to MDR-TB patients
2. Health Education and adherence counseling to MDR-TB patients and close contacts
3. Side effect monitoring of MDR-TB drugs
4. Home-based infection control
5. Household Contact tracing and referral
6. Assisting in monetary and nutritional support
7. Assisting in follow up visits
8. Recording and Reporting
Box 2 Functions of volunteers’ supervisors
1. Monitor and supervise the activities of volunteers randomly for the evening DOTS (right
dose, right time, right drug, right recording), and counseling, health education
2. Coordinating between health staffs from township health departments, MDRTB patients,
and LNGOs
3. Organizing monthly meetings with volunteers
4. Sharing of information to MDRTB patients and volunteers on monthly nutritional and
transportation allowance support
5. Sharing the tasks of volunteers for evening DOTS when volunteers are on leaves
6. Attending monthly coordinating meeting with LNGO
7. Attending quarterly coordinating meeting with THD, BHS, NTP and LNGO.
8. Collecting, validating and verifying the reporting forms from community volunteers and
submit to the LNGOs
Performance of volunteers
1. Providing evening DOT to MDR-TB Patients
There were total (2053) MDRTB patients registered at townships health departments where
CBMDRTB care projects implemented in 2015-2016. Of them, 1654(80%) were provided
evening DOT by community volunteers. Basic health staffs (BHS) including lady health visitors,
midwives, and public health supervisors were responsible for injection of drugs and provision of
DOT to MDRTB patients in the morning. Most of the patients received the injection of drugs at
their homes. There were exceptional cases which needed to give injection at the urban health
center, for example, MDRTB patients who stayed at hostel, and resisted receiving injection at
their places. Morning pills were taken at the health center after receiving injection. MDRTB
patients enrolled in 2017 didn’t have volunteers for evening DOTS. BHS gave the drugs for the
evening since in the morning. In the next morning when BHS reached the patients home, BHS
asked and checked whether the MDRTB patients took the pills or not. There was few MDRTB
patients who travelled outside their township during their treatment. They requested the BHS to
31
give the pills for their travelling days. BHS gave pills for maximum three days. Sometimes, BHS
left the pills in the hand of patients’ families to provide them to the patients.
“၂ေခါကး၃ေခါကးေလာကးရြမယး၊ ကျနးေတားကမဘနေနေတာ အဒဆရာမကအေမကမြာျပ အေမကပ တကးခငးလကးတယး” (MDRTB patient from FGD) “It was two or three times when the BHS gave the pills to my mom to provide DOT to me”
(MDRTB patient from FGD)
Provision of evening DOTS to MDRTB patientsis the major function of volunteers. MDRTB
drugs were collected from BHS by volunteers for a week. Volunteers provided Evening DOTS to
MDRTB patients every day. Every evening around 6 pm, volunteers went to patients’ home to
provide evening DOTS. Almost all patients were aware of the time volunteers came to their
home.There were some male patients who went outside in the evening. There were also patients
who got back late from their jobs. In this case, volunteers contacted the patients by phone to fix
the time for taking drugs. Sometimes, it was difficult to adjust the best time for evening DOTS
between volunteers and patients.
“လနာအမးကသျာလရြရငးဟဘယးလေခၚမလဆေတာ၅နာရေလာကးသျာလရြရငးအစာစာျပရေလေဆတကးဖကမလျယးဘအဒါန၆နာရတစးေခါကးပနးလာအလ၆နာရ၆နာရချအေလာကးမြတကးရတယးဘာလလဆေတာသတကအမသမကအ၀တးေလြားျပမြပနးလာတယးပနးလာျပမြ၁၂နာရ၁ခကးေလာကးမြထမငးအတညးတအခါမၾကေတာ၂နာရ၂နာရချေလာကးမြထမငးစာတယးညေနကျနးေတားတက၅နာရသျာတအခါၾကေတာအစာနနညးနညးကပးေနတယးတစးခါတေလၾကရငးဟဟာစာခငးတယးဒဟာစာခငးတယးဆရငး၀ယးသျာရေသတယး”(
Volunteer from FGD)
“When I reached at the patient’s home around 5 pm, sometimes the patient just finished meal.
So, I need to come back to the patient’s home gain around 6 30 pm. Because of their daily
routine, they arrived late home, and prepared lunch very late. (Volunteer from FGD) There were patients who refused volunteers to provide them evening DOTS because of they
didn’t want people come to their places. They even didn’t like BHS coming to their working
places as they were afraid of people knew they had infectious disease.
“သတကနညးနညးေတာၾကကယးတယး။ဆရာမ၀ငးတာေတာငးမၾကကးခငးတာ။ဆရာမေတာငးမြသတဟဟာဖစးလလကးခရတာေပါေနား။တခာသစမးအပငးလမ၀ငးေစခငးတာ” (KII with BHS)
“Sometimes, patients didn’t like BHS to come to their home”. (KII with BHS)
2. Health Education and adherence counseling to MDR-TB patients and close
contacts
Before volunteers were assigned to each MDRTB patient, the health education and post-
diagnosis counseling was done to MDRTB patients by BHS. The counseling was taken place at
the patients’ home. The post-diagnosis counseling included explaining that the patients had
32
MDRTB, the importance of taking treatment, the duration and side effect of treatment. When the
patients were confirmed that they would be provided treatment, the pre-treatment counseling was
also done at the patients’ home. It included the importance of infection control to prevent
transmission to other people, details about the MDRTB treatment course i.e. 20 months duration
of treatment, injections period, oral period, daily needs of taking drugs, the procedures for giving
consent to receive treatment i.e. consent by patients, BHS, and TMO. The family members of the
patients were also explained about them. When the patients gave consent to receive treatment,
the consent forms was filled and signed in front of TMO.
Daily, BHS conducted counseling to the patients regarding the side effects of the drugs. Patients
used to complain about their symptoms such as heart burn, bad smell of drugs, joint pain,
swollen of joint, loss of appetite etc. BHS encouraged them to be patient, and to eat nutritious
food. Most of the community volunteers stated that they gave health education to both MDR-TB
patients and family members while they are providing evening DOTS. The message included the
mode of transmission of disease i.e. transmitted through air, TB/MDRTB was treatable if the
treatment was received regularly, the possibility of infected to other people if it was not treated
properly, the importance of investigations for TB/MDRTB among the family members of the
patients, infection control measures such as how to dispose their sputum, the importance of
wearing mask while communicating with other people, and side effects of the drugs.
The community volunteers performed counseling to MDR-TB patients and family at every stage
of treatment.Counseling was done to all patients especially when patients complained about the
side effects of drugs and they wanted to stop taking drugs. Volunteers gave counseling to those
patients, as well as informed to respective BHS, TMO, and PO about patients’ condition.
Sometimes, peer to peer counseling was also done.
“Counseling ကေတာလနာတငးကလပးရတယးေဘထျကးဆကမာေတာ တခကေတာ ေဆေသာကးတအခနးမြာကေဆဒဏးကမခႏငးတာရြတယး မခႏငးေတာဒဟာကဆခနးတငးေအာငး
counselingလပးရတယးေနာကးဆမႏငးလရြရငးမႏငးဖဆတာသတလကးခတာကၾကညးျပေတာေပာကးသျာတလေတျကေခၚျပသဘာေတျေဘထျကးဆကခစာရလအလခစာရတၾကာထကသဒဟာေတျေသာကးလကးတအတျကးေပာကးသျာတယးေဆေတျေပၚယၾကညးေအာငးသတတနးကလတေနတစးမမရေအာငးေဘထျကးဆကေတျခစာရတယးအေတာအဒါေတျကသညးချပေတာေပာကးမြဖစးမြာအေရၾကတာကအသကးေနာကးသတေမြားလငးခကးေပါေနားတခမသာစရြတလဆပဆတာေပါ၊အကေလေတျအတျကးရြတယး၊သတအတျကးရြတယးအအတျကးကသတအာတငးျပေသာကးလာတယးေပါ၊သတကရြငးပျပေပာေတာကယး၁၀ခါေပာတာ
ထကးသတ၁ခါေပာတာကပထေရာကးတယးအလမနတလေတျက volunteer ေခၚျပေတာအလမလပးေပတယး” (KII with community supervisor) “Counseling was given to every MDRTB patient as the MDRTB drug has numerous side effects, and patients couldn’t bear it. Sometimes, we have to arrange to meet the MDRTB patients who successfully finished treatment despite the side effects with the patients who were reluctant to
33
continue treatment to share the experiences how they overcome the side effects.” (KII with community supervisor) “အစပငးေၾကာကးတအခါကေတာဒေဆေတျကမေသာကးခငးဘ၊ ဒဟာလညးခစာေနရတယး၊ဒေဆေတျလညးမေသာကးခငးေတာဘ၊ေသတာပေကာငးတယးဆျပေတျ တာေပါ” (MDRTB patient from FGD)
“At first, I am much worried to suffer the side effects of the drugs. I even thought that it would be better to die.” (MDRTB patient from FGD)
However, despite the counseling, there were patients who were lost to follow and stopped
treatment because they didn’t tolerate the side effects of the drugs. Q- အခနအစးမေပာသျာတာcounselingလပးတယးတခ defaulter ဖစးသျာတယးေပါေနားအလလမေတျကဘယးလအပးစေတျအဖစးမာလ။
A-ဆရာ၀နးသတေတျကေတာcounselingလလပးလမရသတကဒအေၾကာငးက HE ေပေတာလ ပသတယးcounselingလပးေတာသတကအာေပတာေတာလကးခတယးသတကယးတငးကဆရာ၀နးဖစးေပမအတျယးတာမေနတာသတရ ေဘထျကးဆကကမခစာႏငးဖ၊ေဆရေဘထျကးဆကကမခစာႏငးဖ၊ဆကးျပေတာမကခငးေတာဖ၊ေဒါကးတာတစးေယာကးဆေနာကးဆကတာလကးလႊတးလကးရတာေပါေနားေနာကး
ဆရာၾက TMO ကယးတငးသျာတယးအစးမ HA တနသျာတယးေနာကးဆဘယးလမြမရဖ၊လကးလႊတးလကးရတယး(KII with community supervisor)
Q: As you said, although the counseling was done, there were people who were lost to follow or
refused to continue treatment. What kind of MDR TB patients are they?
A: Medical Doctors (MDR TB patients)! They know about the disease much more than us. So, it
was difficult to make counseling to them. They are afraid of the side effects of the drugs. There
was one medical doctor who failed to continue taking treatment although the proper counseling
by TMO. (KII with community supervisor)
“ေနာကးတစးေယာကးကေတာသကေကာငးသာကရြငးလသငးတယးသကပစရမးတယးသကစာသငးတာဆ
ေတာေလကေလေတျအတျကးဒါေပမသကကယးထကးပဒဟာေတျကသတယးသကလငးေပၚမြာဒ page ကရကးျပေတာအကနးဖတးထာတာ Facebook ေပၚမြာဒေဆကေသာကးျပေပာကးသျာတလရြသလမေပာကးေသတလလရြမယးဒေဆေတျကေဘထျကးဆကမာေတာတခဗမာေဆတငးရငးေဆနကလရတယးေပါ၊တခဓါတးစာနကတယးအလမသကအမာၾကေတျထာတယးေလအထကမြသၾကကးတဟာကသေရျ ခယးတာေလအလနေဆဆကးမေသာကးေတာတလနာေတျလရြတယးတခကေတာလမသာစအေခအေနေၾကာငးေဆကဆကးမေသာကးေတာဘနပကးသျာတလန
34
ာေတျရြတယး”(KII with community supervisor) “The next one was a teacher. He knows very well about the disease. He explored the information
on MDR TB through internet. He believes that MDRTB can be cured with traditional medicines,
and he chose not to treat with MDRTB drugs.” (KII with community supervisor)
Side effect monitoring of MDR-TB drugs
Some community volunteers stated that there are several side-effects during the treatment, so
they were always monitoring the side effects what the patients suffered using checklist forms.
Generally, side effects were recorded and reported using checklists by volunteers every week.
Almost every day, they asked the patients whether they suffered any side effect, or improvement
of symptoms. If the patient suffered from mind side effect, the community volunteers counseled,
explained, reassured and gave health education to patient and family. In case of suffering severe
side effect, the community volunteers informed step by step to the Midwife, TBC, TMO and also
to respective organization and then if needed, they have to refer the patients to the Aung San TB
hospital.
Side effects reported by MDRTB patients to community volunteers* (n=449)
Reported Side Effects Number Percentage
Hearing Defect 12 2.7
Tinnitus and Vertigo 12 2.7
Neuropathy 74 16.5
Hypokalaemia 0 0.0
Depression 9 2.0
Hallucination 4 0.9
Hypersensitivity 0 0.0
Hepatitis 5 1.1
Nausea 42 9.4
Vomiting 23 5.1
Joint Pain 189 42.1
Goiter 0 0.0
Gastritis 17 3.8
Anxiety 13 2.9
Diarrhea 2 0.4
Feeling worse than before 8 1.8
TB symptoms 6 1.3
Dyspnoea 2 0.4
*as of March, 2017, Reported by INGO 3
35
Average number of side effect monitoring in a month for MDRTB patients by volunteers*
Average number
1 time 12 2.7
2 time 15 3.3
3 time 8 1.8
4 time 388 86.4
Not recorded 26 5.8
Total 449 100.0
*as of March, 2017, Reported by INGO 3
Joint pain is the most common symptoms MDRTB patients suffered during the treatment. Other
common symptoms they reported during interviews were tinnitus, diarrhea.
“ေဆေတျေသာကးျပကယးေတျလကးေတျကကးတာေပါ။၆လ၇လအထကယးေတျလကးေတျကကးတာ၊အဆစးေတျပတးကမတတးပ။ေသေတာငးေသခငးတယး။ေတားေတားခစာရတယး၊” (MDRTB patient from FGD) “After taking drugs, I suffered from the severe joint pain for six to seven months. It was dying.” (MDRTB patient from FGD) “အဒေဆေသာကးျပတာန ေခဆစးလကးဆစး ကကးလာတယး၊ ေတားရတနးရအမငးေတာငးတကးလမရဘ။ ေလြခါထစးကေလဘကးသျာရတယး” (MDRTB patient from FGD) “Because of the joint pain due to the MDR TB drugs, I could not even make a step to the stairs. I have to keen down.” (MDRTB patient from FGD) “ေခေထာကးေတျေရာငးလာတယး။ ဆရာမကလမးမာမာေလြ ာကးတ၊ ေရတစးေန၆ပလငး ေသာကးတ။ ေရာငးတာကသျာမယးတ” (MDRTB patient from FGD) “My leg becomes swollen as the side effect of MDRTB drugs”. (MDRTB patient from FGD) “ဖနးလြမးဆကးျပေတာသမဆရာမကေပာပတာေပါ။သမအနးတအခါကရငးေဆေသာကးေသာကးျပခငးအနးတာတ၊အစာစာျပအနးတာ၊ဆရာမသမအလဖစးတာဆသမအတာဆဘယးလမစာန၊ေဆနအစာနနညးနညးေလချစာ၊ေရမာမာေသာကးအလမဆရာမကပနးပနးျပေပာပတယး” (MDRTB patient from FGD) “I phoned to the Sayama (BHS) telling her about the side effects of the drugs. I vomit frequently after taking the drugs. Syama (BHS) instructs me what to do.” (MDRTB patient from FGD) “Refer ကကျနးမတလပးတာ။ volunteer ကကျနးမတကပလပးတာ။ကျနးမမြာ volunteer
36
တစေယာကရတယဆရငဆရာမေရသကေတာဘယလျဖစေနတယဘာညာဆရငကၽြနမလမးလပတာေပါေနာ။သညေနပငးသြားတAခနကရငျဖစတာဆရငေပါသတ႔(volunteers)ကေတာဒါရကမလပပါဘး။ကၽြနမတ႔ကလပပါတယ။” (KII with BHS) “Refer of MDRTB patient for the side effect was done by BHS. Volunteers just informed us
about the patient.” (KII with BHS)
3. Home based Infection Control
Infection control was done every 3 months at LNGO 1 and LNGO 3, and monthly at LNGO 2, and
the checklists have to be reported to the organizations. Through infection control checklist,
number of family members, including under five children, pregnant mothers and over 60 years
people, were recorded. Moreover HIV testing done or not, diabetes status of the patients and
contact TB examination done or not were also recorded.
BHS and patients stated that infection control activities were mutually done by BHS and
volunteers. Most of patients stated that volunteers asked them to wear masks, to stay
separately with other family members, to dispose their sputum properly using the provided
sputum cups to prevent the spread of disease to other people in every day basic.
Table 6.4.1 Numbers of reported infection control checklists throughout the treatment course
of MDR TB patients by LNGOs (reported by LNGO1 and LNGO3)
Reported infection control
checklists
LNGO 1
(N=558)
LNGO 3
(N=693)
Not reported yet/ Never reported 76 187
1 time 23 123
2 times 22 82
3 times 31 80
4 times 78 73
5 times 83 67
6 times 87 51
7 times 109 25
8 times 49 5
Total 558 693
“စစျဖစတနးကသလပခြကကေရေႏြးေလာငးထညလကတယ၊Aမသာမာသြနတယ၊AတာဆလတငးလတငးစစလကရငAေျဖကAေကာငးခညးပထြကတယ၊ဆရာမဆသေဘာကတယ၊ က ြနမ (MDRTB patient)Aရမးေတာတယ၊စာAပေတြဘာေတြမာေသခာမတထားတယ။ဘယAခနဘယAခနေဆး ေသာကတယဆတာ။ျပးရငတစလတစခါစမးတယ။” (MDRTB patient from FGD)
“ I pour hot water into my sputum cup, and throw into the toilets. Sayama (BHS) always praise me that I
follow their advices.” (MDRTB patient from FGD)
37
4. Household Contact tracing and referral
They referred 578 close contacts of MDRTB patients after proper health education for further
diagnosis of TB or DRTB. Out of the referred patients 48 (8%) were diagnosed as TB and 14
(2%) were diagnosed as DRTB .Most of the patients stated that volunteers as well as BHS asked
their family members for sputum examination. BHS stated that they performed contact tracing
and referral among contacts of MDRTB patients using referral forms. During active mobile team
visits to the communities, contacts of MDRTB patients were asked to check for TB symptoms,
and further diagnosis. Among contacts, children who were under five years of age and over sixty
years of age were considered as prioritized group. There were contacts who failed to do sputum
examination because of they were unable to produce enough sputum.
5. Assisting in monetary and nutritional support
Patients stated that the BHS phoned them to collect nutritional support at township health
department every month. Volunteers collected the lists of MDRTB patients who received the
monetary and nutritional support, and informed to the organization to record in the registers.
6. Assisting for follow up visits
At 6th
, 10th
month of treatment, MDRTB patients had to undergo follow up investigations
including chest X ray, sputum examination, and blood tests. Patients and TBC stated that
volunteers reminded patients for follow up visits. In some cases, they prepared referred notes for
investigations.
7. Recording and Reporting
Community Volunteers carried out recording and reporting such as daily DOT record, Side
Effect Checklist, Infection Control Checklist.
38
Roles of volunteers Some key informants stated that health education activity of volunteers was crucial for treatment
adherence and completion. They explained that health education to MDR TB patients was
essential because of long duration of MDR TB treatment, possibility of suffering side effects and
risk of transmission to others. Moreover, few key informants highlighted health education
provided through volunteers was more effective because he/she stays in that community and gets
more opportunity to deliver health messages not only to MDR TB patients but also to the general
community.
”အဓကေတာ HE (health education)ပေပါေနား။ Side effect ကေပာရငးလညး HE ေပာရတာပ၊စကာတချနးမြ မေပာပန ေရာအငး ေသာကးဆလေတာ မဖစးဘေလ။ အဒါဆလရြရငး အလနာကလညး ေရာေသာကး အငးဆလရြရငး ကယးဘာသာေသာကးလညး ရတာၾကက၊ အဒါဆ သလညး ေသာကးခငးေသာကးမယး မေသာကးခငးမေသာကးဘေပါ။ ကမတရ HE ကအဓကပ။”(KII
with volunteers’ monitor from Township 1)
“The main thing is HE (health education). When we talk about the side effects of the drugs,
we also give HE. It does not make sense to give anti TB drugs to patients without talking a
word. They can take drugs by themselves. But they might be taking drugs or not. The most
important one is HE by volunteers to the patients”(KII with volunteers’ monitor from
Township 1)
“HE ေပမယးဆလညး ဒပညးသလထထက လကပ ပညးသလထထက ပနးစမးဝငးျပေပတာ ထေရာကးတယးဆရာ။ ဥပမာ သတက ေဆတကးခနးမြ မဟတးဘ။ ေစသျာသျာ၊ ရပးကျကး ဓမၼာရမြာ ကစၥရြလ ဥပသးပသျာေစာငးေစာငး လစမလရြရငး HE ေပတာမ၊ ဒ MDRTB ဆတာ ဘာလ။ ဘာက ေခၚတာလ။ ဘာလပးရတာလ အကေန အစချပ ေပာတာ အလေပာတာေလေတျရြတယး။ ဒါ HE ေပတာလညး ပညးသထကပေပါ။ ဒရပးကျကးထက လေတျနပ ရပးကျကးထမြာ HE ပနးေပတ သေဘာပဆေတာ ထေရာကးတယး ဆရာ။”(KII with volunteers’ monitor from Township 1)
“The health education is effective when it is given to the communities by someone who is
from the same communities. Community volunteers talk about MDRTB not only to the
patients and families at the time of providing DOTS, but also at the time when people gather
eg. in markets, in religious activities etc. So, I must say that, the HE by community
volunteers is effective.” (KII with volunteers’ monitor from Township 1)
Some volunteer’s supervisors highlighted evening DOT by volunteers was necessary and
supportive to assist BHS who were overburden with several tasks. They also mentioned BHS
appreciated roles of volunteers for CB MDR TB. However a few mentioned about challenges
of volunteers in initial phase especially for coordination with BHS.
”ကမတအမငးေပာမယးဆရငးေတာ ဒညေနပငးေဆတကးတအလပးက လကလအပးတယး၊ ဘာဖစးလလဆေတာ အပငးဆရာမေတျကလညး အလပးအရမးမာတယး။ ဆရာမေတျမြာ တာဝနးေတျ တအာပတယး။ ပတအခါကေတာ ဆရာမေတျအေနနလညး မနကးပငးေပါ သတရ တခာ ကာကျယး ေဆထေတျ ဘာေတျနသတရ အလပးေတျ အရမးမာတအခါ ကမတ အဖျ စညးေတျ ခလ ..ကမတအေနနလညး သတမေရာကးႏငးတ လနာအမးေတျကဆ ကမတ ကလညး သတငးအခကးလကးပေပေနတအတျကး သတ (ဆရာမေတျ) အရမးဝမးသာတယး။ ဘာဖစးလလညးဆေတာ သတ မအာတၾကာထကေန ကမတက အလ ပမြနးလ
39
လပးေပေနတအခါကေတာ သတက တဖကးတလမးကကေပေနတအတျကး သတကလညး ကမတက ၾကကးတယး။ ကမတကလညး အခလညေနပငး ေဆတကးေပတအတျကး လနာေတျကလညး ေရာဂါသကးသာေပာကးကငးလာတယး။(KII with volunteers’ monitor from Township 1)
“We believe that the evening DOTS is necessary. Sayama (midwives) are very busy, and they
have several tasks. eg.in the morning, they are engaged with immunization activities, while
they are busy as we inform her about the MDRTB patients, they are happy. They accept that
we are supporting them. Because of the provision of DOTS by us, MDRTB patients become
healthy” (KII with volunteers’ monitor from Township 1)
“သတကလစတးပါလကးပါနကလပးရတယးတစးခvolunteerေတျဆသတရတ၃၀၀၀၀သတမသ ရဖေပါေနားလမးစရတးလတယးဆလတစးလတစးခါေဆေသာကးခငးေအာငးၾကကးဥတ၊အာေဆတ၊ပနးသတ၊ငြကးေပာသတ၀ယးေပတယး၊ေနာကးသတကယးတငးစတးပါ၀ငးစာလလာေတာမသအဒမသာစေတျကလနာမသာစကသတမသာစေတျလဘသတကကေတာအကနးေပာတယးသတရ အခကးခကကေနားတကသတဆကမြတဆငးဒလနာေတျဟာကပနးၾကာရတာေလ” (KII with volunteers’ monitor from Township 1) “Some volunteers could not even use the incentives 30000MMK they received. Sometimes, because of their patients’ needs, they used it to compensate the travel charges. Also they bought some foods such as eggs, apple and banana for patients. Because of their good will and interest, patient’s family became like their family and patient tells every problem to them. We know about these through volunteers. (KII with volunteers’ monitor from Township 1)
Challenges
Previously, there was a weak coordination between volunteers and Basic Health Staff which
made their activities difficult. Main challenge was building trust and BHS did not want to
hand over MDR TB patients to volunteers for evening DOT. However, after sometimes, BHS
realized that volunteers are assisting their workload by visiting MDR- TB patients’ homes
and monitoring side effects of drugs.
”အခေနာကးပငး ေတားေတားေတာ အဆငးးေပလာတယး အခကးခမရြဖ၊ စလပးလပးခငးကေတာ ခာလပတးက ရမးေနတာဘ ကယးကတငးေတာငးမလပးခငးဘ ထျကးေပခငးတအဆငးထဖစးတယး။ ကနးမာေရဌာနက ဆရာမ ေတျကလ ကေနားတေပၚ အယအၾကညးမရြဖ၊ သတက အရငးဒလနာကကငး ရေတာ ကေနားတ ညေန volunteer ကေပလကးရငးဘ သတအတျကး ပသာနာဖစးလာ မလာေပါ၊ အေတာ သတက volunteer က လနာမေပဖ၊ ေနာကးဆ သတကမႏငးမနငးေတျဖစးလာေတာမြ ေနာကးဆ volunteer ကေပတယး။ ကေနားတအေပၚ အယအၾကညးမရြဖ၊ အဓက သတန ပသာနာဖစးမြာစလေပါေနား၊ သတဌာနက volunteer ကညေနပငးၾကညးခငးမြ သတရ ေဘထျကးဆကကသႏငးမယး။ လနာအေၾကာငးလသရမယး၊ တစးေယာကးထ လပးတာထကး ၂ေယာကးေပါငးလပးေတာ သကးလသကးသာမယး ထေရာကးမယးေပါေနား အလမေပာလာ ေတာ အခကေတာမြ လကးတျလပးလာရင:းနမြ သတလအရမးအကညရမြနးသေတာ အဆငးေပသျာတယး အစက သတအတျကးပသာနာဖစးမြာစလ သတဖာသာ cover လပးျပေတာ လနာလမေပဖ။”(KII with
40
volunteers’ monitor from Township 2)
“Now, we (volunteers) are convenient working for CB MDRT care. When we start working,
there are many challenges as things are complicated. Sayama (BHS) from health centers
didn’t believe in us. If we provided evening DOTs to the MDRTB patients under their care,
they were afraid that there would be problems and troubles, and they didn’t want us to work
with them. Now, they have noticed that we can support to them, and share the burdens of
their tasks. So, now it is more comfortable than before” (KII with volunteers’ monitor from
Township 2)
Success of CBMDR TB care
Most key informants expressed the success of CB MDR TB care as follows:
• ReduceworkloadofBHS
• Ensure evening DOT for MDR TB patients
• Health education and Adherence counseling MDR TB patients
• Psycho social support MDR TB patients
Reduce workload of BHS
Most key informants from public sector and local NGOs convinced that
activities of community volunteers can reduce the workload of BHS.
အာသာခကးကေတာကမတ Midwife ေတျကအမြနးအတးငးေပာရငး ၁ရကး၂ေခါကးဆတာေတာ မလပးေပႏငးဘေပါ။သတကကယးကယးစာဝငးထမးေပတယးဆေတာလနာအတျကးေတာအကရြတာေပါေနား။တကယးတမးသျာမယးဆလနာအတျကး Dose လညးမြနးမယး။ အခနးမြနးမြနးလညး ရမယး။ျပေတာသျာၾကညးရငးန ဆရာမကမေပာရလကးတစကာေတျကအ Volunteer ကေပာပ လ ရတယးေပါ။ဥပမာဆရာမေဆထျပတအခနးမြာသတကမတာရြမယး။အစာမဝငးတာဖစးရငးဖစးမယး။ေပာခငးမြေပာပမယးေပါဆရာ။အဒါမေလေတျကေပာပလးကးတအခါမြာအVolunteerကေနျပေတာဒကလာတယးဆရာ။၁ပတး၁ခါသတလာတအခးနးမြာကမတကေပာလရတယး။(KII
with BHS-Township 1) “The strengths of using community volunteers in CB MDRTBC were BHS can reduce the workload. To be honest, we (BHS) couldn’t provide DOT to MDRTB patients several times. As the volunteers assist us, the patients have many benefits. The right dose of drugs can be given to the patients. Besides, patients can talk to volunteers especially the issues they are reluctant to talk to us. (KII with BHS- Township 1)
41
Ensure evening DOT for MDR TB patients
Community volunteers provided evening DOT to (1656, 81%) MDR TB patients in 2015-2016in 37 townships of Yangon Region. Majority of respondents (both BHS and MDRTB patients) convinced evening DOT by volunteers was necessary. Some BHS stated that volunteerssometimeshelpedtoprovidemorningDOTifBHSwereengagedwithothertasks.
ကာကျယးေဆထရကးက၁ရကးကေန၇ရကးရြတယးဆရာ။ကမတကအဒေနေတျမကေတာကမတနနအခနးေႏြာငးသျာမယးေလဆရာ။ထေဆရကးသာပမြနးရေအာငးေပထတာ။ေသာကးေဆအခနးကေတာကေလေတျ(volunteers) ကမနကးပငးလညးကမကကေပတာရြတယး။
(KII with BHS Township 1) “The immunization was given in the communities in the first days of every month. On that day, we are late to provide morning DOT to the patients, where some volunteers help us providing morning DOT. (KII with BHS Township 1)
42
သတလာေတာပအဆငးးေပတာေပါ၊သတလာေတာသတကယးတငးတကးသျာေတာကယးအတျကးစတးခရတယးကယးဖာသာေသာကးရငးေမရငးေမသျာမယးသတကတခအာရေရာကးသျာရငးေဆေသာကးတအခနးလႊရငးလႊသျာမယးသလာေတာ၅နာရဆ၅နာရပမြနးေသာကးဖစးတာေပါ၊ (FGD with MDR TB patients Township 3) It was very good that volunteers come and provide DOT at our home. By ourselves, we can forget to take drugs. Now, because of the volunteers, we can regularly take the drugs at the exact time every day. (FGD with MDRTB patients- Township 3)
ကမတ အမငးေပာမယးဆရငးေတာဒညေနပငးေဆတကးတအလပးကလကလအပးတယး၊ဘာဖစးလ လဆေတာအပငးဆရာမေတျကလညး အလပးအရမးမာတယး။ ဆရာမေတျမြာ တာဝနးေတျ တအာပတယး။ ပတအခါကေတာ ဆရာမေတျအေနနလညး မနကးပငးေပါ သတရ တခာ ကာကျယးေဆ ထေတျဘာေတျန သတရအလပးေတျ အရမးမာတအခါ ကမတ အဖျ စညးေတျခလ..ကမတအေနန လညးသတ မေရာကးႏငးတလနာအမးေတျကဆ ကမတက လညး သတငးအခကးလကးပေပေနတအတျကးသတ (ဆရာမေတျ) အရမးဝမးသာတယး။ ဘာဖစးလလညး ဆေတာ သတမအာတ ၾကာထကေန ကမတ ကအလပမြနးလ လပးေပေနတ အခါကေတာ သတကတဖကးတလမးကကေပေနတအတျကး သတကလညး ကမတ က ကးတယး။ကမတ ကလညးအခလညေနပငးေဆတကးေပတအတျကးလနာေတျကလညးေရာဂါသကးသာေပာကးကငးလာတယး။
(KII with volunteers’ supervisor from Township 1)
“From our opinion, the evening DOT is essential. Because the BHS were too busy with several tasks eg. Immunization to children in the communities in the morning. As we help them (BHS) reaching to the MDRTB patients where BHS are hardly reach, BHS are happy. Because of evening DOT by volunteers, MDRTB patients improve. (KII with volunteers’ supervisor from Township 1)
Health education and Adherence counseling MDR TB patients
Community volunteers provided health education and adherence counseling to MDR TB patients and referred 578 contacts of MDR TB patients. Among referral, 48 (8%) were diagnosed as Tb and 14 (2%) were diagnosed as Drug resistant TB. Both BHS and volunteers stated that health education activity of volunteers was crucial for treatment adherence and completion. Key informants explained that health education to MDR TB patients was essential because of long duration of MDR TB treatment, possibility of suffering side effects and risk of transmission to others.
Moreover, few key informants highlighted health education provided through
43
volunteers was more effective because he/she stays in that community and gets more
opportunity to deliver health messages not only to MDR TB patients but also to the general
community.
HEေပမယးဆလညးဒပညးသလထထကလကပပညးသလထထကပနးစမးဝငးျပေပတာထေရာကးတယးဆရာ။ဥပမာသတကေဆတကးခနးမြမဟတးဘ။ေစသျာသျာ၊ရပးကျကးဓမၼာရမြာကစၥရြလဥပသးပသျာေစာငးေစာငးလစမလရြရငး HE ေပတာမ၊ဒ MDRTB ဆတာဘာလ။ ဘာက ေခၚတာ လ။ ဘာလပးရတာလအကေနအစချပေပာတာအလေပာတာေလေတျရြတယး။ဒါ HE ေပတာ လညးပညးသထကပေပါ။ဒရပးကျကးထကလေတျနပရပးကျကးထမြာ HE ပနးေပတ သေဘာပ ဆေတာထေရာကးတယးဆရာ။”
(KII with volunteers’ monitor from Township 1)
“Health education is more effective through community volunteers. They can often meet with people at market, social affairs, and religious affairs. They can share about MDR TB, what is this disease, how it is transmitted etc. It is effective that if health education was given by volunteers to the communities where they live. (KII with volunteers’ monitor from Township 1)
Psycho social support MDR TB patients
Most MDR TB patients appreciated psychological supports from volunteers especially while
they are suffering from side effects of drugs and social stigma.
တစးပတးမြာ၄ရကးေလာကးကကယးကယးကစတးဓါတးကတယး၊ေဆစေသာကးရငး၊ကယးကတနးတဆကးဆတလရြမြႏြစးးသမးအာေပတလရြမြဒေဆကဆကးေသာကးခငးတယး၊ေရာဂါေပာကးခငးစတးကဖစးတယး။”
(FGDwithMDRTBpatientsTownship2)
“At least 4 days a week, I am depressed. I feel better if there are people who are not discriminating us, and encouraging us. (FGDwithMDRTBpatientsTownship2)
Challenges
Although there are many successes, some challenges were also identified:
Weak coordination between LNGO and BHS for supervision of volunteers
Refusal of patients to take treatment Some BHS pointed out patients did not appreciate their care and more rely on LNGOs or volunteers
who provided them monetary supports Some BHS stated that they gave priority for selection of volunteers would usually assist them However, few key informants concerned volunteers would not assist them for other health activities
which did not pay any incentives (eg. Immunization, AN care) Few BHS could not provide injection at MDR TB patient’s home and very few community
volunteers were absent to provide evening DOT
44
ကမတကေဆထ၊ေဆတကး၊HE အာေပါကးေအာငးေပာရ၊ဒါေပမသတ (လနာ) က ကယးကမကးစထ မမငးဘ၊ပကးဆေပတသဘေကဇတငးတာ။တခVolunteers ေတျကလ ကယးေတျေပာတာဂရမစကးဘေလ။ကမတကသတကsupervision မြ မလပးရတာ။ သတမြာကသတ supervisor သပးသပးရြတယး။
(KII with BHS)
“Although we (BHS) made big effort to take care for the MDRTB patients, they did not
appreciate us. They only thanks to people who pay money support for them (INGO).
Sometimes, volunteers did not care about us as we cannot supervise them. They have their
own supervisors.” (KII with BHS)
Refusal of treatment
Some volunteers and key informants mentioned that few MDR TB patients refused to take
treatment even after repeated counseling.
ကျနးမလနာတစးေယာကးရြတယးေဆကျပခါနေနျပ follow up သျာဆတာ မသျာေတာ ေဆလမေသာကးေတာဖတ ဆရာမေတျေရာ၊ မနယးအပငးဆရာေတျေရ ာ လာဆငးေပာ သကမေသာကးေတာဖတ သအေဖကလ အေရာဂါနဘဆသျာ သတရျာမြာဘသကလ ဒေရာဂါနဘအေသခမယးတသမသာစကလမေပာေတာဘ။ (FGD with volunteers)
“I have one MDRTB patient who is almost complete the treatment. He refused even for the follow up visits. The team from township health department makes counseling to him to finish the treatment. However, he resists to continue treatment, and his family also fails to make it. “ (FGD with volunteers)
Few key informants also pointed out some inappropriate behavior of patients made volunteers
embarrassed.
A: တခ လနာက ဆတယး volunteer အေပၚမြာ... Q :ဆတယးဆတာက ဘယးလမလ A: ဆတယးဆတာက ဟဟာေပါ character ေပာရမြာေပါ။character ေလေတျပါတယးေပါေနား Q : character ဆတာ ဘယးလမက ေပာတာလ၊ ကေနာက ရြငးပပါဥ A :အတညးပ ေပာလကးရမလာ (ရလကး)၊ တခလနာေတျက အလ ေဆတကးတဆရာမေလေတျက ရညးစာစကာေပာတာ။ အလမေလေတျဆရငး ဒဆရာမေလေတျန ဆ အဝငးအထျကးသပးမေကာငးဘ။ ထနးေပရတာ ရြတယး။တေယာကးဆ တစးအမးထမြာ သတစးေယာကးထပ။ အမးၾကကလညး ကယးတယး။ ခၾကကလညး အရြညးၾကဝငးရမယးဆရငး သနေနတငးပမြနးေတာ မဖစးဘေလ။ မသာစဝငးေတျက အပငးအလပး သျာေနတာဆေတာ….
45
A: Some patients are bad on volunteers Q: How? A: Their character Q: Character? How? A: (Laughing) Some male patients make a propose to young female BHS. It was not good for the BHS. You know, there is a male patient who lives alone in a big house. For him, it is not good for BHS to take care of him at his home every day. Other family members are going out for work
Incentives or identified volunteers…
About one third of BHS concerned incentives for volunteers may have negative impacts.
They expressed that few volunteers were not willing to help their activities other than MDR
TB after getting incentive from CB MDR TB projects. Such issues are especially related to
volunteers who were AMW or CHWs previously.
However, some BHS revealed that incentives from CB MDRTB project helped their existing
volunteers to assist their activities.
A: အခ Larva Control ေတျလပးေနျပ။ DHF အတျကးေနား။ Abate ခတးတေနရာမြာ လညးသတပါရမယးေလ။အကနးသငးထာျပျပဆရာ။ လဥေရသနးေခါငးစာရငး ေကာကးပါရမယး။ အခကမတဟဟာေပါ JE စာရငးအတျကး လညး ကမတ ကေလစာရငးေတျလညးေကာကးေနျပ။ဆရာမကကညေပဖေလဆရာ။အဒါေတျမြာလညးအကနးလပါရမယးေလဆရာ။မပါႏငးဘဖစးေနတယး။သတကညေန၅နာရထမြတကးရတဥစၥာကမနကးဖကးမြာလာမကေပႏငးဘ။
Q: ၁၀ေယာကးမြာဘယးႏြေယာကးကလာမကေပႏငးဘလ။
A:ဆရာအဒါေတာ။၁၀ေယာကးမြာ၅ေယာကးေပါဆရာ။ ဒမြာကမတမျမးမေခၚလကးျပဆရငးေတာအကနးေပၚခလာတာဘဆရာ။
A: Now we start Larva Control activities for DHF prevention. Volunteers are expected to
involve in those kinds of activities (eg. Abate). They all are well trained. Eg.in Census data
collection, JE campaign, etc. We need the help of volunteers. But they could not. They have
to provide evening DOT only in the evening. But they fail to help us in the morning.
Q: Out of 10 volunteers, how many fails to help you?
A: Half. 5 out of 10. But when we invite them for refresher trainings, they all attended.
BHSအလပးမာေတာ volunteer ကMDR TB အတျကးကေပႏငးတယးေပါ။ဒါေပမ ….BHS
ခငးတာကတခကေတာသတမလပးခငးၾကဘ။ဥပမာ BHS က ဒမြာတဘလနာေပာကးေနတယး သျာရြာေပပါအဆ အနညးအကငးေပါ၊ တေယာကးႏြစးေယာကးေလာကး ေတာ ရြာေပတယး၊ လတငး ကေတာမလပးေပဘ။ (KII)
“As BHS were busy, volunteers can help for MDRTB care. But sometimes, volunteers refuse to do what BHS have requested. For eg. BHS requested volunteers to trace lost to follow up TB patients, not every volunteer willingly help BHS. (KII)
46
Providing Injection
Another challenge is providing injection for MDR TB patients. There are few cases that
injective were not given at patients’ homes.
(၅)- ေဆရရကးခနးတကးတအခါတခါတေလကရငးထေပလကးတယး။ေဒသႏရမြာပ။
(၇)- ရကးခနးတကးတေနကေတာ အေစာၾကသျာရတ ေန ကရငး ေဒသႏရမြာပ ထေပလကးတယး။
(၁၂)- ေဆရရကးခနးေဒသႏရက သျာရမယးဆရငး ဆရာမက ေဒသႏရထ လကးထေပတယး။ ေဆအခနးေစာငးသျာမြာစလ၊ လကးခတယး၊ ဆကးကာနဘာန သခမာလာတယး။လာျပေဒသႏရမြာပထတယး။ဘယးေနရာထထမကးရညးကေအားငရတာပ။ဘယးလမြဟနးမေဆာငးႏငးဘ။
(FGD with MDR TB patients)
(5): Especially on the day of follow up visits at urban health center, injection was given at
the urban health center.
(7): Injection was given at the urban health center on the day of follow up visit to urban
health center.
(12): Sayama (BHS) gave injection at the urban health center when we have to go follow
up visit at the urban health center not to delay the time of injection in the morning. As
injection was painful, it always tears. (FGD with MDR TB patients)
လကးရြကေတာတစးေယာကးပရြတယး။ကနးတသေတျကအးမးမြာပထၾကတာ။အခတစးေယာကးဒကေခၚထတာကသကကေတာအမးပငးမရြဘ။အပေလပဆေတာ အမးက အခနးငြာ ေနတာ တစးရကးကႏြစးေထာငးေပရတယး။အေဆာငးပစမေလပ။အမးခနးကဥးေလပ။ေပာငးဖတငဥပတးတေရာငးတာေပါ။အဒါလပးစာတာေပါ။အမးပငးမရြေတာ အခကးအခ ရြတယးေပါ။ သကယးတငးကဒမြာလာထလရလာလေတာငးဆတာနဒမြာပထေပလကးတယး။ (KII with
BHS)
Now I have only one MDRTB patient in injection phase to which injection was given at health center due to her request. She stayed at a hostel, and it was not convenient for her to receive injection at this place. The rest of patients were given at their homes. (KII with BHS)
Few BHS highlighted that giving injection at health center has some advantage for patients to
meet other patients and get social support.
ေဆကေတာကျနးမတကသျာဖလတလကသျာေပလကးတယး။တခ ကေတာအမးအ၀ငးအထျကးခကးတလေတျကေတာေဆခနးမြာပစရပးလပးျပေဆခနးေဆာကးလကးတယး။ကျ နးမတဆရာမေတျကယးဟာကယးစျပေဆခနးေဆာကးလကးတယး။
47
မနကးဆလနာေတျလာထတယး။မနကး၆နာရဆသတထျကးလာတယး။၆နာရန၇နာရချၾကာမြာအကနးျပသျာျပ။ဆရာမေတျလညးအဒမြာပအကနးစျပလာႏငးတလ၊လာခငးတလကပဒကေခၚတယး။မလာခငးတလကအမးလကးတယး။ကျ နးမဆရငးေတာအကနးလလလလာတယး။အကနးလာတယး၊သတကဒကပလာခငးတယး။ထျပလdose ပညးတာေတာငး ဘာဖစးလလဆေတာ သတက ဒမြာကေတာဆရာမေတျကလညးအာေပတစကာေတျနတ၊ေနာကးတစးေယာကးကတစးေယာကးေဆျ ေႏျတစကာေတျနကေတာအခငးခငးကတစးေယာကးနတစးေယာကးအာေပၾကတာေပါ။အေရြကလနာကသဘယးလခစာခရတယး။ေရမာမာေသာကး၊အစာမာမာစာ၊အာမငယးနကျနးေတားတလညးဒလကေနတကးလာတာဆေတာတစးေယာကးနတစးေယာကးသတရ ခစာတေ၀ဒနာေလေတျကဖလြယးရငးဖလြယးရငးနရငးႏြမြလညးရတယး။ဘာပေပာေပာအာလညးရြၾကတာေပါ။တစးေယာကးနတစးေယာကးအာေပၾကတာေပါ။မနကးမနကးဆသတလာထတယး။ကျ နးမတ၆နာရစထရငး၇နာရေလာကးဆအကနးလျပျပ၊ (KII with BHS)
Injection was given at MDR TB patients who are in needs. For some patients who are
difficult to receive injection at their residence, MDRTB patients are gathered at one area at
health centers. In the morning MDRTB patients come and receive injections. Around 6 am,
patients come, and between 6 and 7 am, everything was finished. BHS are gathered at this
place. MDRTB patients who are difficult to come to this place, we (BHS) go to their homes.
All of my MDRTB patients come as they prefer this place even after they finished injection
phase. Because, here in this place, patients can discuss among themselves about their
diseases. Moreover, BHS can encourage them. (KII with BHS)
Evening DOT
Very few patients revealed that volunteers did not provide evening DOT for every day. There
were few days in a week that they had to take their drugs by themselves.
၇။တစးခါတစးေလကေတာေလသတေလေတျအကနးမလာတာကေတားေတားဆတယး။
၅။ေနာကးဆသတမလာႏငးရငးဖန းဆကးျပေတာေပာတယး။
၇။ေဆေသာကးရမယးအခနးေရာကးရငးသတလာမလာေစာငးတယးမလာရငးလညးကယးဟာကေသာကးလကးတယး။လာေတာလညးလာေပါေနားစကာေလေတျဘာေလေတျေပာေပာျပေတာပနးေပါ။
၉။ကယးေတျကေတာမေပာပါဘညေနပငးလညးကလညးကယးဟာကယးလညးေသာကးတာလညးရြတယး။
၇။ေဆပတးရငးေတာေဆပတးေနျပငါကလပးေပဥဘာညာဆေတာသတကလပးေပတယး။ေဆပတးေနျပကမဘယးမြာသျာထတးရမြာလညးကမကနညးနညးပါပါဆကးသျယးေပပါဥေပာရတယး။အခေနာကးပငးဆရငးေတာေဆေပတဆရာနရငးႏြေတာလညးကယးဟာကသျာျပေတာထတးလကးတယး။
(FGD with MDR TB patients)
7: Sometimes, volunteers don’t come to our homes.
48
5: At last, they made a call to us that they could not come to us. 7: We waited for volunteers, but when they failed, we took by ourselves. When they come, we can talk each other. 9: Sometimes, if they don’t come to us, we take the drugs by ourselves. 7: We can ask volunteers where to take drugs when the medications become out, these days, as we know how to do it, and we do it by ourselves. (FGD with MDR TB patients)
Opinion and suggestion
All patients viewed positive towards CB MDR TB Care in general. They appreciated
activities of volunteers and support package.
Majority of key informants stated that CB MDRTB Care was supportive for patients and
BHS. Most effective activity of CB MDR TB care is evening DOT. Majority highlighted
health education and counseling by volunteers was important. All convinced that
monetary support for patients is necessary. Few pointed out that incentive was provided
only for MWs and not for TB focal persons at township health department although
he/she was also taking care of MDR TB cases.
Patients’ preference on existing support package
Rank Type of supports Reasons for preference by patients
1 Monetary support -Supportive not only for the patient but also for
the family
-Reduce burden of family
2 Evening DOT -Not missing the pills
-Volunteers remind to take the pills at the exact
time
3 Adherence counseling -Becoming strong enough to bear the
sufferings from the disease or side effects
4 Side effect monitoring -Know what to do if patient suffers from some
side effects
5 Infection control -Know how to prevent family by getting
TB/MDR TB
6 Nutrition -Quality of rice and Nutrition support was poor
and cannot eat
49
Monetary support
Almost all patients gave priority for monetary support during ranking exercise. The most
common reason was this monetary support helped while they loose or reduced earning
due to their illness.
(၁၂)- ေငျေၾကကေတာ အေထာကးအကဖစးတာပ။ အလပးမြမလပးႏငးတာ၊ အေထာကးအကဖစးတာေပါ။
(၅)- ကယးစာခငးတာစာလရတာေပါ။
(၄)- အရငးတနးကဆရငး လစာ၂သနးနပါေလာကး ရတယးေလ။ အခညမေလက အလပးမလပးတာ၁၀လပညးေတာမယး။
(၅)- ေဆစာေတာအလပးမလပးႏငးေတာေငျေၾကကအဓကအေထာကးအပဖစးသျာတယး။
12: Money is supportive as we cannot work. 5: Money is helpful as we can buy what we want to eat. 4: In the past, we earn almost 2 lacks a month. Now, I cannot work for 10 months. 5: Because of the disease, I cannot work, so monetary support was the main supportive.
ကေနားဆအခဘယးလလပးလကးလဆေတာသမေလက (၂)တနးကရႈငး တကးေနတယးေလ။ အေတာATMကဒးကအမသမလကးထပထညးထာလကးတယး။သမေလကဒလစဥးကရြငးလခေ
ပါ၊ကရြငးလခကကေနားေခါငးထကထတးထာလရတယး။ေခါငးထမြာအပတစးခေပါသျာတယး။ဒ
ဖယးရခကသာကေနားလစဥး၁၅၀၀၀....၁၅၀၀၀ကဒရြာတထကဖေပတာေပါ။
Now, what I have done was, my daughter was in third grade. The supported ATM was given to my wife to support the tuition fees for my daughter. I don’t need to worry about her tuition fees. Only for my transportation charges 15000, I have to find it.
Evening DOT
ကယးဟာကေဆေသာကးရငးေတာနာရဝကးၾကာရငးလညးၾကာမယးတစးနာရၾကာရငးလညးၾကာမ
ယး။ပမြနးေတာမဖစးဘေပါ။ဟ.. အမးကစၥရြလသျာလကးရငးလညး အဒမြာ အခနးကနး သျာရငး လညးကနးသျာတယး။တကယးလသ ငါနာရကျကးတလာေတာမယး ဆရငး ေအားသလာေတာမယး ကယးကေပတယး။ေလစာမႈရြတာေပါေနားကယးက။အေမေရ..ေဆတကးတဆရာမကေရာကးေန
တယးအမးမြာဆရငးဖတးဖတးဖတးနကယးကေရာကးလာတယး။
50
As we took the drugs by ourselves, it cannot be regular as we go to and from in the communities. As volunteers come to our home at exact time very evening, we are aware the exact time to take the drugs every evening. When one of the family members remind that the volunteers are here for you, I go back home immediately from where I am.
Health education and adherence counseling
ေဖဆသ (၅)ကနးမာေရပညာေပတာကကယးနာမလညးတာကေပာပေတာေကာငးတာေပါ။
ေဖဆသ(၄)- သတေပာပေတာနာလညးသျာတာေပါ။
ေဖဆသ(၃)- ဘယးလေနရမယးဆတာသသျာတာေပါ။
ေဖဆသ(၆)- ေနထငးေရ၊အစာအေသာကးေတျကအစသသျာတယး။ 5: Health education is good as they explain to us that we don’t understand before. 4: Yes. We are clear when they give health education. 3: We know how we have to behave. 6: We know very well what to eat, how to behave.
Monitoring side effects
ကယးမသတာေတျရြရငးလညးသတကေမရငးေပာပတယး။သမသရငးလညးသအထကးကသေတျ
ကပနးေမေပျပေတာတစးခအေၾကာငးအရာေတျကေပာပတယး။ကယးကမခစာဖေတာဒလဒ
လဖစးတယးေဟဘယးလဘယးလဖစးတာလဆလရြရငးသသရငးလညးသေပာပတယး။သမသရငး
လညးအမရယးကမေမေပဥမယးဘာေလေတျလပးရငးဘာညာသေမေပတယး။အလေလေတျ
သလပးေပပါတယး။
(FGD with MDR TB patients)
“They explain to us when we asked what we are not sure about. If they (volunteers) don’t
know about we asked, they asked to their superior persons. We share that what we are
suffering and they explained to us why it happens. (FGD with MDR TB patients)
Home based infection control
ႏြာေခါငးစညးကလညးအခာလေတျကမကစကးရေအာငးလဒါကတပးေပါေနား။ကာကျယးဖ၊ကးယး
ရ ညအစးကေမာငးႏြမေတျ၊ေဘပတး၀နးကငးေတျကလဒေရာဂါမကစကးႏငးေအာငးလ
…..ဒါကလညးဆရာမေတျကေပာပေပေတာေကာငးပါတယး။
(FGD with MDR TB patients)
51
It is good that volunteers ask us to wear the facial masks to prevent transmission to other
people especially to our family members and the neighboring. (FGD with MDR TB patients)
Nutritional support
Almost all patients did not like the quality of nutritional support they received. Most
complained about rice and they said that they sold it out and bought better rice. About
half of patients did not eat cereal powder.
“ဒအတငးေတာငး ေဆကရတာအစာအေသာကး အရမးပကးတယး၊ အာေခါငးေတျနာ၊
အစာေတျ မေၾက၊ အလခနးမြာဒါနပပျပအဆငးေပေအာငး စာရတာေလ၊
ဆရာမကေပာပါတယး၊ ဒဆနးကဒလ ေ၀ဒနာရြငးေတျ အတျကး
ထတးထာတာစာသငးတယးေပါ၊ အာဟာရရခါစကေတာ စာမယးေပါ၊ တစးရကး ကေန ႏြစး
ရကး သရကးေပါ၊ တကယးတမးေတာ လပးရတာအဆငးမေပေတာတာန မစာဖစးေတာတာ” (FGD with MDRTB patient)
“Because of the disease, I have always loss of appetite, sore mouth, inability to digest. I
have to eat this provided rice no matter what has happened to me. Sayama (volunteers)
told me that this nutritional support (rice and other) are particularly made for MDR TB
patients, and we should eat it. I tried at first, but after few days, because of difficult in
preparation, I failed to continue eating it. (FGD with MDR TB patient)
52
Suggestions
Most common suggestions from participants on CB MDR TB care were as
follows:
• Capacity building for volunteers
• Continue providing Incentives (for volunteers and patients)
• Selection criteria for volunteers
• Comprehensive approach
• Strengthening Coordination among LNGOs, BHS and volunteers
Capacity building ေတျကပလပးေပသငးတယး။အခကေတာ refresher training
တႏြစးတခါလပးတယး။၃လတခါေလာကးquarterly meeting လပးရငး refresher
လပးရငးပေကာငးမယး။တႏြစးတခါမြေပေတာတခကေမတယး။ (KII)
“Capacity building for volunteers are needed more. Now, refresher trainings are done once a year. It will be better if the refresher training is done every quarterly meeting. As it was given once a year, some people forget. (KII)
(၇) ကျနးမတ Volunteer ေတျအတျကးကေတာ Training မာမာေပဖ
Q: Training ပလတယးဘယးလမ Training ေတျအဓကလခငးလ?
(၂) အဓကကေတာ Counseling Training သတကႏြစးသမးေဆျေႏျ ဖ (၂) ဟတးႏြစးသမးေဆျ ေႏျဖအမာစကဒေဆဒဏးကေၾကာငးစတးကတာေပါစတးကတ Side Effect
ရြေတာအဒအတျကးေၾကာငးလတယး။
(၄) Refresher training လမာမာလပးေပါ။ (FGD with volunteers)
7: We, volunteers, want trainings. Q: What kind of trainings do you want? 2: Especially counseling training to make counseling for MDRTB patients who are depressed due to side effects 4: More refresher trainings are needed (FGD with volunteers)
ေနာကးတခကေတာ incentive၊အဒါမပါဘနေတာ ကယးအပးထက စကးျပဒအလပးက ေရရြညး လပးႏငးမြာမဟတးဘေလ။ခဏတဖတး၁ရကး၂ရကးလပးရတကာကျယးေဆထလမကincentive
53
မေပလရခငးရတယး။ဒါေပမေနစဥးၾကေဆသျာတကးေပဖကေတာincentive မေပဘ မလပးႏငးဘ။ (KII with BHS from Township 2)
The incentive. Without incentive, volunteers cannot stand long term. For activity which last one or two days, incentive is not needed. For eg.Immunization. But to provide DOT every
day, incentive is essential. (KII with BHS from Township 2)
MDR TB လနာက supports ေတာလတယး။ monetary incentive
ေပတာလသတအတျကးေတားေတားအေထာကးအကဖစးပါတယး။ေရာဂါေၾကာငးအလပးမလပးႏငးဘ
၀ငးေငျမရြတအခါ၊ဒါေလကလအာထာစရာေပါ။ (FGD with volunteers from Township 3)
MDR TB patients need supports. Monetary incentives are supportive for them. As they cannot work because of disease, they rely on monetary support. (FGD with volunteers from Township 3)
Selection process ကလအေရၾကတယး။ေရျကတညးကေသခာေရျထာရငးsustain
ဖစးပါတယး။၁၅ေယာကးလရငးပေခၚရတယး။တကယးစတး၀ငးစာတသ၊လပးႏငးမသကေရျ ရတာ။
လပးရမလပးငနးေတျေသခာရြငးပျပရငးတ၀ကးေလာကးေလာသျာတာမလရြတယး။ (KII with
Local NGO 1)
The selection process for volunteers was very much important. If they are chosen very carefully at the start, volunteers can sustain. If we need 15 people, we need to recruit more than that. We have to choose those who actually interested in. When we explain about the nature of MDRTB care activities, half of the recruited volunteers become lost. (KII with local NGO 1)
တကယးတမးကေတာ BHS ေတျကအလကာကညေနတ Volunteer ေတျလရြတယး၊ ကမတေပာတာ BHS ေတျနအဆငးေပတယးဆတာ အဒလလမကေပာတာေလ။ ကမတEpiသျာရငးသတကကေလေခၚေပတယး၊ဒါမြမဟတးရငးကမတတဘလနာရြာေပပါဆရငး
သတကရြာေပတယး၊လဥေရစာရငးလရငးလညးသဘ၊ဒါေပမကမတကအခေၾကေငျမေပႏငးဘ
။သကအျမတမးကညေနတသဆေတာအေထာကးအပရမဟာမဆရငးသတကဥစာေပေစခငး
တယး၊အဒလမဆပပအဆငးေပတယး၊ဘယးျမ နယးဘဖစးဖစးေပါ၊ျမ နယးတငးမြာေတာဒလမ
လေတျရြတယး။ (KII)
Actually there are volunteers who help BHS without any incentive. They gather children for immunization activity, tracing lost to follow up TB patients, census data collection. We cannot give any incentive for them. As they always assist us, we would like to make priority for them for the activity which they can get incentives. It will be much better. (KII)
54
ဒCBMDR TB ကခသငးတယး။ခရငးလ sporadic ဆမထေရာကးဘ။ Comprehensive approach
ဘသျာသငးတယး။ဆလတာက TA ၃၀၀၀၀support ေပရနမရဘ၊ကနးတ activities ေတျevening
DOT, health education, adherence counseling, side effect monitoring, volunteer supervision
အဒါေတျအာလပါမြေအာငးမငးမယး။ (KII with Local NGO 1)
This CBMDRTB can be extended to other townships. But it will not be effective if sporadic. It should be in the comprehensive approach. What I mean is supporting Travel allowance 30 USD is not enough. Other activities such as evening DOT, health education, adherence counseling, side effect monitoring, volunteer supervision should be included. (KII with local NGO 1)
Strengthen coordination with focal person, BHS and volunteers
and Clarify roles and responsibilities
volunteerေတျဆကဆရာမေတျကreport လပးတာမရြဘဆရာ၊
monthlyလမရြဘ၊လနာေတျနပတးသကးတာဘာမြ reporting လပးတာမရြဘ။လနာမြာ side
effect ေတျရြရငးေတာေပာပါတယး၊အဒကတဘဆရာ၀နးကေပာတယး၊ဆရာမတDOT provider
ကေတာမေပာဘ၊Volunteer နကဒမြာေတာ ေဆလာယတအခနးတငး ေတျရတယး။ ေဆကအပတးတငးေသာၾကာေနတငးေဆလာယရတယး။အဒအခနးမြာေတျဖစးတယး။ပနးျပ
report လပးတာမေတာမရြဘ။ (KII with BHS from Township 1)
There is no direct report from volunteers to us (BHS), not even monthly. They don’t inform MDRTB patient data, but when MDRTB patient suffered side effect, they informed us. We again inform to medical doctors. We (BHS) meet with volunteers every Friday when we collect drugs for MDRTB. But there is no report from volunteers. (KII with BHS from Township 1)
ကမတကSupervision, monitoring လပးရတာမရြဘ။သတစာအပးမြာေဆထတးတအခါ Sign
ထေပရတာေတာရြတယး။ (KII with BHS from Township 1)
We (BHS) don’t do any supervision or monitoring to volunteers. When they collect MDRTB drugs, we have to sign at their book. (KII with BHS from Township 1)
55
ပညာေပလပးငနးေတျအမာၾကလပးသငးတယး TV တလမဒယာကေန TB
အေၾကာငးကအခလရကးေပမယးအျမမလႊငးႏငးေတာမထေရာကးဖ၊ HE ေတျကမာမာ campaign
သေဘာမေကာငးေတျကေဟာေပာပျေတျလပးတာမအလမလပးသငးတယးေပါေနား။ကေနားတ
ကေကာငးေတျကလပးေပေတာကေလေတျရ behavior change ေပါေနား၊ မမေခာငးဆ၊ ႏြာေခတငး လကးကငးပ၀ါအပးရမယး၊အဒါကကယးတငးတာ၀နးယရမယး။အလပညာေပလကးတအ
ခါကေတာေတားေတားေတာေအာငးမငးတယးေပာတယး။သျာရငးဘာမြမပါရငးေတာငးမြအလမေလ
(ပါစပး၊ႏြာေခါငးလကးကအပးျပ) အဒါက TV တလမဒယာတ၊ channel တကေန လႊငးေပရငးေတာ ေတားေတားမာမာကာစရငးဒါမေတျသလာရငးသတကယးတငးလမလပးရငးရြကးတတးလာမြာေပါ
ေနား။ ဒတငးကေတာဖစးလာမြ လနာေတျကလပးေပတာေပါေနား ကာကျယးဖအတျကးလပးရငး ပျပေတာထေရာကးမယးလထငးတယး။ (KII with volunteer supervisor from Township 1)
We need more health education sessions. Through TV channels, it was not effective because
it cannot be released always. Health education campaign, health talks at school needs to be
done for the behavior change of school children for eg. to cover their mouth with towel etc.
So that, school children can understand its their responsibilities. It can be said that this
approach is effective. People can be aware of the importance of covering mouth while
coughing through the health education from TV channels. (KII with volunteer supervisor
from Township 1)
56
57
Discussion
58
Discussion and Conclusion
Brief summary of findings
This is the operational research done in Myanmar to assess the community based MDR-TB
care package. Providing Evening DOT by community volunteers assisting to basic health
staffs result in the high and successful treatment outcomes of MDR-TB patients. Very low
rate of attrition among recruited volunteers across different organization was found. Out of
different health care activities provided by community volunteers to the MDR-TB patients, it
was reported that health education to MDR-TB patients and their contacts as well as in their
communities was the most effective one. The significant role of volunteers in community
based MDR-TB care was they were supportive to reduce the tasks and workloads of basic
health staffs. Monetary support was reported by most of the patients as the most essential and
supportive one by CB MDRTB care program. However, this study revealed some challenges
in implementing community based MDR-TB care. They included 1) weak coordination
between LNGO and BHS for supervision of volunteers, 2) refusal of patients to take proper
treatment which may indicate more counseling was needed, 3) low incentive provided for
community volunteers, 4) few BHS could not provide injection at MDR-TB patient’s home
and very few community volunteers were absent to provide evening DOT, 5) conflicting role
between BHS and volunteer supervisors.
Strength and limitation of study
Strengths of this study are it includes two years program’s data of three LNGOs providing
CB MDR TB care in Yangon Region, and it truly represents the perspectives of MDR-TB
patients who received the care, as well as the perspectives of community volunteers,
community supervisors, and public health staffs (TMO, TBC, BHS) that provided the care.
However, the comparison between the program’s outcomes of townships with CB MDR TB
care and that without CB MDR TB care was unfeasible to conduct.
59
Possible reasons for findings
Globally, the treatment success rates among MDR/RR-TB patients are poor at ~50%, largely
due to high rates of mortality and loss to follow-up. Myanmar has the high treatment success
among MDR TB patients which was obviously much higher than the global rate. This study
also found the treatment outcomes of MDR-TB patients under community based MDR TB
care was high (>80%). Supportive measures by NTP and partners organization through
international donors might be the reasons for having high treatment success rate.
In Myanmar’s health care sector, community participations are encouraged to deliver the
comprehensive health care to the communities. Provision of community based health care
deliveries through community volunteers have been practicing for communicable disease
control (TB/HIV/Malaria), and maternal and child health. Because of the nature of
volunteering, the sustainability of them is a big concern in that kind of delivering care
including community-based TB care (11,12).
However, in this study, very low rate of attrition among recruited volunteers was found. The
findings for the possible reasons of low rate of attrition are also revealed and reported that it
was related to the selection process. Majority of community volunteers recruited for CB
MDR TB care in Yangon region were previously retired health staffs, community health
workers, auxiliary midwives, and members of organizations (MRCS, MMCWA, MWAF).
They had been actively involved in health related activities in the communities as well as
social activities at their townships before by assisting the basic health staffs. Therefore,
recruiting this kind of people as community volunteers has lesser chance of drop-outs.
Another reason might be because of their existing jobs. The main reason for attrition is
reported as getting paid jobs. In this study, there was very low percentage of volunteers with
no paid jobs, and the drop outs among them make the overall attrition very low.
Few participants responded that a low incentive for community volunteers was reported as it
can be one of the barriers for their sustainability. However, several considerations has to be
made to increase incentives because of limited funding support.
This study found that community volunteers are supportive to basic health staffs not only in
providing MDR-TB care, but also at other health related activities such as provision of
60
immunization in the communities, disease control activities etc. This might also be due to
most of the recruited people were already working closely with basic health staffs before.
Health Education to the MDR-TB patients as well to their close contacts was reported as the
most effective services by community volunteers. Myanmar people in nature are reluctant to
communicate with basic health staffs to discuss on their health. With community volunteers,
patients can have more frankly, transparent and effective communication to ask about their
diseases. One of the activities of community volunteers is referring close contacts of MDR
TB patients for screening of TB. In this study, it was found that considerable numbers of
close contacts were referred for further investigations for diagnosis of TB and MDR-TB. Out
of the referred cases, 8% and 2% detected as TB and DR-TB respectively. It reflects the
important role of community volunteers referring the risk contacts of MDR-TB.A global
qualitative study reported that community-based and patient-centered MDR-TB care are
preferable among health care providers and patients themselves because it is safe, conducive
to recovery, facilitating psychosocial support and allowing more free time and earning
potential for patients and caretakers (15).
Among the supportive measures through community based MDR TB care, monetary support
was reported by most of the patients as the most essential support for them. Because of
inability to work during long term MDR TB treatment, the families of MDR TB patients face
financial hardship, and the minimal monetary support help them most of the MDR TB
patients in poverty solving their social problem.
There are 20% of MDRTB patients who refused to receive care from volunteers. It is because
of; 1) occupation of some patient (eg. Doctor) want to take self-medication and,
Company/office staff prefer BHS wearing uniform. 2) other cause is that there was no trained
volunteers closed to MDR-TB patient's residence. 3) some patients totally refuse to take
MDRTB treatment. According to a study done in China, the possible reasons to refuse MDR-
TB treatment included out-migration for work, concerns about work and studies and belief
they were cured after undergoing drug-sensitive TB treatment (16).
61
Conclusion and Recommendations
To conclude, the assessment from this operational research found high treatment success rate
among MDR TB patients who received the community based MDR TB care through local
NGOs. For the challenges, we would like to make several recommendations. First, we would
like to recommend strengthening coordination among local NGOs, volunteers and basic
health staffs especially for close supervision and monitoring of community volunteers by
routine reporting of volunteers’ activities to township health department. Second, we strongly
recommend continuing monetary support for MDR TB patients. Third, we would like to
recommend to clarify role and responsibilities of BHS, volunteers and volunteer’s supervisor
by conducting proper meetings among them. Last, we would like to recommend to expand
CB MDR TB care in comprehensive manner while human resources at public health sector is
still limited.
62
References
1. World Health Organization. Global Tuberculosis Report 2015, 20th Edition. Geneva,
Switzerland. WHO/HTM/TB/2015.22; 2015.
2. WHO. WHO | Drug-resistant TB: global situation [Internet]. WHO. [cited 2016 Dec 5].
Available from: http://www.who.int/tb/areas-of-work/drug-resistant-tb/global-
situation/en/
3. Ahuja SD, Ashkin D, Avendano M, Banerjee R, Bauer M, Bayona JN, et al. Multidrug
resistant pulmonary tuberculosis treatment regimens and patient outcomes: an individual
patient data meta-analysis of 9,153 patients. PLoS Med [Internet]. 2012 [cited 2016 Aug
26];9(8):e1001300. Available from: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22952439
4. WHO | Companion handbook to the WHO guidelines for the programmatic management
of drug-resistant tuberculosis [Internet]. [cited 2016 Dec 5]. Available from:
http://www.who.int/tb/publications/pmdt_companionhandbook/en/
5. World Health Organization (WHO). Third Nationwide TB Drug Resistance Survey in
Myanmar. 2013.
6. World Health Organization (WHO). Second Nationwide TB Drug Resistance Survey in
Myanmar. 2008.
7. World Health Organization (WHO). First Nationwide TB Drug Resistant Survey in
Myanmar. 2003.
8. National Tuberculosis Programme (NTP). Tuberculosis in Myanmar Progress , Plans and
Challenges. 2012;(September 2012):6. Available from:
http://www.searo.who.int/myanmar/areas/TBinMyanmar.pdf
9. World Health Organization (WHO). The Stop TB strategy. Available online at:
http://www.who.int/tb/strategy/stop_tb_strategy/en/
10. World Health Organization (WHO). The End TB strategy. Available online at:
http://www.who.int/tb/post2015_strategy/en/
11. Le Le Win, Saw Saw, Yin Thet Nu Oo, ThandarLwin and Tin MiMiKhaing (2014),
Community empowerment in TB control activities in Myanmar: National TB
programme and INGOs. 45th
World Conference on Lung Health of the International
Union Against Tuberculosis and Lung Disease (The Union); 28 October-1 November
2014; Barcelona, Spain; 2014.
12. Saw Saw, WaiWai Han, San LattPhyu, ThetAung, HtetMyet Win Maung. Factors for
sustainability of community health volunteers for TB control in Thanintharyi Region,
Myanmar. September 2016 (unpublished report).
13. Kyaw Thu Soe, Saw Saw, Johan van Griensven, Shuisen Zhou, Le Win, Palanivel
Chinnakali, Safieh Shah, Myo Myo Mon, Si Thu Aung. International non-governmental
organizations’ provision of community-based tuberculosis care for hard-to-reach
populations in Myanmar, 2013-2014. Infectious Disease of Poverty (2017) 6:69.
14. National Tuberculosis Programme (NTP). Myanmar:National Strategic Plan for
Tuberculosis (2016-2020). 2016;126. Available from:
https://www.google.com/search?q=National+Strategic+Plan+on+HIV,++STIs+and+TB+
2012+–+2016”,+SANAC,+2011+www.gov.za/documents/national-strategic-plan-hiv-
stis-and-tb-2012_2016&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8
15. Horter S, Stringer B, Reynolds L, Shoaib M, Kasozi S, Casas EC, et al. "Home is
where the patient is": a qualitative analysis of a patient-centred model of care for
multi-drug resistant tuberculosis. BMC Health Serv Res. 2014 Feb 21;14(1):81.
16. Xu Z, Xiao T, Li Y, Yang K, Tang Y, Bai L. Reasons for Non-Enrollment in Treatment
among Multi-Drug Resistant Tuberculosis Patients in Hunan Province, China. Gao L,
editor. PLoS One. 2017 Jan 23;12(1):e0170718.
Top Related