30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 1
Parliamentary BriefingPerformance and strategy
of theMunicipal Infrastructure Investment
Unit
Alwyn Naidoo
MIIU Project Manager
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 2
Contents Performance report for the year under review
2004/05• Background
• Project performance and KPIs
• Expenditure
The exit plan
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 4
Background Cabinet Memorandum No. 14 of 1997 created
MIIU as short-term arrangement to be wound up in five years (2003)
This term was extended by Cabinet Memorandum 4A of 2002 for an additional three years, to 31 March 2006
Mandated “To encourage and optimise private sector investment in local authority services on a basis that is sustainable for both local authorities and at a national level.”
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 5
Background Non-profit private Company established in
April 1998 USAID Donor support for technical assistance
(PADCO) Project Preparation Fund Grants & TA to support local MSPs
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 7
Project performanceAuditable (PFMA) KPIs (1)Key Performance Area Target Actual
Active MSP projects 50 77
Completed projects: 7 MSPs
1 loan guarantee
2 revenue management
4 MSPs
Uthungulu Water (KZN);
CPT drop-off (solid waste) WC);
CPT SMMEs (solid waste) (WC);
Epping Fresh Produce Market (WC)
0 loan guarantee
2 revenue management
Mogale City (GA);
Albert Luthuli (MP)
Disbursement on MSP’s R12,8 m R12,77m
Efficiency ratio 25.5% 17.8%
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 8
Project performanceAuditable (PFMA) KPIs (2)Key Performance Area Target Actual
Active guarantee projects
3 3 Joburg Water (GA)
Mogale CIty (GA);
Midvaal (GA)
Active revenue enhancement projects
3 3 Ugu (KZN);
Thembisile (MP)
Dr JS Moroka (MP)
Target value of guarantees to be committed
50% of $35m (R105m)
0
Disbursement related to guarantee projects
$375 000 $257 500
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 9
Project performanceAuditable (PFMA) KPIs (3)Key Performance Area Target Actual
Monitoring of major projects
5 5 ongoing
Customer surveys
(Contract Monitoring)
5 completed projects
3 new projects
5 ongoing – Nelspruit (MP) ;Dolphin Coast (KZN)
Kelvin Power (GA); Msunduzi (KZN); Mogalakwena (LM)
0 – not yet started
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 10
Project performanceInternal KPIs (1)Key Performance Area Target Actual
Case studies written up 5 5 in progress (75% complete)
Standard terms of reference documented
3 3
Generic Terns of Reference
Generic Request for Proposals
Template financial model
Publication of MIIU history and case studies
1 1 Pending
Technical Assistance (TA) not associated with projects
4 hours per project manager per month or a total number of equivalent hours as a ceiling
Section 78 task team, dplg MSP workshops, Project Consolidate, loan guarantee marketing
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 11
Project performanceInternal KPIs (2)Key Performance Area Target Actual
TA Disbursement of USAID funds
$185 000 $43 365
Market Development Seminar with financial sector
1 Session with Standard Bank in Aug 04; with Nedbank in Mar 05
Staff development SA staff (includes the use of USAID* funds of $15 000
6 personal development plans
6 plans followed: UK Study tour, Midrand Graduate Institute, various short courses
Implement MIIU obligations to Johannesburg Housing if fund becomes operational
N/A
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 12
Completed projects (MSP) Uthungulu Water (KZN)
• an interim O & M contract with WSSA for operations of all rural schemes
CPT drop–off (solid waste) (WC)• establishment of four green waste drop-off centres
CPT SMMEs (solid waste) (WC)• CBO waste collection contracts in disadvantaged areas,e.g
Bloekombos, Kalkfontein, Khayelitsha Epping Fresh Produce Market (WC)
• sale of a non-core asset for R16m. A 20yr lease was entered into with the new owner, with repair, maintenance & expansion risk transferred to new owner. Proceeds of the sale to improve water and sanitation infrastructure. Winner of the Africa Investor Award in November 2004.
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 13
Revenue Management & Loan GuaranteeMogale City (GA)
data cleansing, debt review and audit of customers, meters, connections, tariffs, etc resulting in significant saving of lost revenues. Private partner entered a shared risk contract with municipality, earning a reward only in the event where the municipality saves revenues relative to set revenue benchmarks.
Ugu District (KZN)data cleansing, debt review and audit of meters, connections, etc to improve revenue. Private partner is recommending a replacement of the existing revenue management systems to improve coordination of all billing systems that have existed in the individual B municipalities.
Thembisile (MP)data cleansing, debt review and audit of meters, connections, etc to improve revenue.
Dr J S Moroka (MP)data cleansing, debt review and audit of meters, connections, etc to improve revenue.
Loan Guarantee MIIU has recently refined the implementation methodology and tender document for banks to bid on.
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 14
Distribution of Projects in SADistribution of projects throughout SA
KwaZulu-Natal22
Western Cape14
Eastern Cape14
Gauteng10
Mpumalanga8
Free State5
Limpopo3
North West1
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 15
Distribution of projects by sectorDistribution of projects by sector
Water & Sanitation34
Solid Waste26
Other5
Electricity4
Fleet Management4
Fresh Produce Market3
Airport1
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 16
ExpenditureCapital & operational expenditure
0
3,000
6,000
9,000
12,000
15,000
18,000
R (
Th
ou
san
ds)
Compliance costs 388 459 767 619 589 940 1,021 1,180
Non disbursement expenditure 347 266 386 743 993 1,179 1,340 1,441
Disbursement expenditure 1,027 833 1,230 1,670 2,040 3,166 2,725 3,671
Capital expenditure 8,331 7,022 9,286 9,860 7,401 16,619 15,341 16,289
1998/99 1999/00 2000/01 2001/02 2002/03 2003/04 2004/05 2005/06
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 17
EfficiencyTotal operating expenditure : Total expenditure
17.5%18.2%
20.4%
23.5%
32.9%
24.1%24.9%
32.1%31.0%
27.9%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
1998/99 1999/00 2000/01 2001/02 2002/03 2003/04 2004/05 2005/06
Actual Budget
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 18
Income Statement31 Mar 2005 31 Mar 2004
REVENUE (2 384) (5 045)
(Deficit) / Surplus of grants received to disbursements (2 999) (6 620)Grants received 12 342 10 000 Grants disbursed (15 341) (16 620)Sundry Income - 48 Investment income 615 1 527
OPERATING EXPENSES 5 085 5 285
Auditors' Remuneration 137 136 Board of Directors Costs 29 25 Remuneration and staff development 2 704 3 332 MIIU Business 1 265 1 481 Consulting Fees 214 35 Entertainment 10 10 Folders,Brochures and Publications 84 103 Marketing 124 746 Public Relation Activities 261 113 Subsistence and Travelling 258 474 Training 314 -
Administration Costs 950 311 Bank charges 10 7 Copiers - 1 Courier Services 16 12 Electricity 27 - Portfolio management fees 352 45 Rental 427 134 Stationery 46 55 Sundry expenses - 13 Telephone 72 44
Deficit for the year (7 469) (10 330)
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 19
Statement of Changes in Equity
R'000
Retained surplus as at 1 March 2003 21 667 Deficit for the year ( 10 330)
Retained surplus at 1 April 2004 11 337
Deficit for the year ( 7 469)
Retained surplus at 31 March 2005 3 868
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 22
Background Cabinet Memorandum No. 14 of 1997 created MIIU
as short-term arrangement to be wound up in five years (2003)
This term was extended by Cabinet Memorandum 4A of 2002 for an additional three years, to 31 March 2006
In year 2005/06 the exit plan will be implemented as follows:• Closure of projects on the pipeline • Archiving of project deliverables• Packaging of institutional memory for dplg as executive
authority
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 23
Why exit now? Discussions between management and BOD
with dplg (as executive authority) on the prospect of continuity for MIIU date as far back as June 2004
A decisive position from dplg on the continuation of MIIU has not been forthcoming
At BOD meeting of 24 June 2005, directors resolved to proceed with exit plan
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 24
The exit plan Background Project activity Management contract with DBSA USAID-funded contracts Other donor issues Risk analysis dplg National Treasury Knowledge and information management Communication strategy Financial reporting Closure housekeeping Succession arrangements Action plan
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 25
Project activity Pipeline of active MSP projects has been
audited. Projects classified into 3 classes of priority
All other activities are ongoing, but with succession arrangements per activity are being crafted for continuity (dplg as natural successor)
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 26
Management contract with DBSA
Provides MIIU with:• Treasury and accounting function
• Employment contracts & HR services
• Office rental
• Administrative and IT services
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 27
USAID-funded contracts Provisions:
• Expatriate staff contracts
• Assets
• Commitment agreement for DCA implementation
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 28
Other donor issues DFID commitment agreement Mega-Tech funding Cities Alliance (World Bank)
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 29
Risk analysis HR risk – staff retention Financial risk – incurring of liabilities Legal risk – breach of grant funding
agreements Reputational risk – resulting from exiting from
funding agreements
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 30
Department of Provincial and Local Government MIIU is a PFMA Schedule 3A public entity (of
dplg). Whilst certain responsibilities are expected of dplg, these cannot be taken for granted. MIIU needs to strategise without dependency on dplg.
Expected responsibilities of dplg in winding up MIIU:• provide funding for the final year
• de-list MIIU as a public entity
• disengage the Board of directors
• disengage company members
• provide a custodian by September 2005
• take cession of assets, liabilities and institutional memory
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 31
National Treasury A business case for delisting of a public entity
should include• financial statements of the final year prepared on
liquidation basis
• transfer (cession) of the entity’s function to a successor
• transfer of surpluses, assets and liabilities
• risk analysis of de-listing
• closure of budget line, bank accounts, etc
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 32
Knowledge and information management
MIIU to package the following for handover purposes to a suitable repository:• Projects on the pipeline
• Archived project deliverables
• Institutional memory
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 33
Communication strategy Pronouncement by dplg as executive
authority Communication from MIIU (in collaboration
with government) to:• municipalities
• engaged consultants
• PADCO, USAID, DFID
Press release Website updates
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 34
Financial reporting Functional closure to be 31 March 2006, but
financial closure to be 31 August 2006 Caretaker arrangement necessary for the
March – August period Audit and Annual Report to be prepared
(liquidation basis) Cash flow management to be done monthly to
aim for zero balance at 31 March 2006.
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 35
Closure and succession arrangements
To be managed in collaboration with dplg• Archiving
• Handling of new requests from municipalities
• Transition out of ongoing project activity from January 2006
• Identification of areas where specialist successor to MIIU is required to support dplg
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 36
Budget 2005/06: Monthly cashflowApr - Jul Aug 05 Sep 05 Oct 05 Nov 05 Dec 05 Jan 06 Feb 06 Mar 06 2005/06
Actual Est. Est. Est. Est. Est. Est. Est. Est. Fore.Sources of funds
Budget allocation (MTEF process) 0 2,809 0 2,809 0 2,809 2,809 0 0 11,236 Anticipated donor funding - Cities Alliance 0 0 1,200 0 0 0 0 0 0 1,200 Anticipated interest on investments 85 8 12 9 13 4 7 12 0 150 Recoverable expenses 0 30 0 0 30 0 0 0 30 90 Total inflow of funds 85 2,847 1,212 2,818 43 2,813 2,816 12 30 12,676
Application of fundsoperational expenditure
Board of directors 0 0 15 0 0 15 0 0 16 46 DBSA 894 229 229 229 229 230 230 740 230 3,240 *salaries seconded staff & support services 690 154 154 154 154 154 154 664 154 2,432 *overheads 204 75 75 75 75 76 76 76 76 808 Costs related to general admin actvities 230 165 165 165 165 165 165 166 270 1,659 Marketing and communication strategy 54 250 30 60 60 346 0 0 0 800 Trainee programme 35 0 100 45 50 100 0 0 0 330
Total operational expenditure 1,213 644 539 499 504 856 395 906 516 6,075 Capital expenditure 1,104 1,399 1,399 1,399 1,399 1,400 1,400 1,400 1,400 12,300 Total outflow of funds 2,317 2,043 1,938 1,898 1,903 2,256 1,795 2,306 1,916 18,375
Change in equityOpening balance 3,868 1,636 2,440 1,713 2,633 772 1,329 2,349 55 3,868 Total inflow of funds 85 2,847 1,212 2,818 43 2,813 2,816 12 30 12,676 Total outflow of funds (2,317) (2,043) (1,938) (1,898) (1,903) (2,256) (1,795) (2,306) (1,916) (18,375) Closing balance 1,636 2,440 1,713 2,633 772 1,329 2,349 55 (1,831) (1,831)
30 August 2005
NCOP Briefing 37
Action plan: Key milestones Recommend adoption of plan by BOD on 4
August 2005 Submit budget to dplg reflective of exit plan Set up custodian arrangement Communication strategy Handover to dplg by 30 January 2006 Caretaker arrangement required March –
August 2006
Top Related