8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
1/180
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
2/180
0::< Ieeuic Pbpdrt de Dpbritmdes Bvicuitmde
Ieeuic Pbvmbw dl Hbvbcdpgbet Bllbatmvbebss 0::
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
3/180
IEERIC PB\MB[ DL HB\BCDZGBEX BLLBAXM\BEBQQ 0::
Iafmbvmek Qustimei`cb Hbvbcdpgbe
0::=
Xfb [drch @ien
[isfmektde, H.A.fttp?//www.wdrch`ien.drk/mbk
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
4/180
0::= Xfb Metbreitmdeic @ien ldr Pbadestruatmde ieh Hbvbcdpgbet / Xfb [drch @ien
9696 F Qtrbbt E[
[isfmektde, HA 0:811
Xbcbpfdeb? 0:0-8;1-9:::
Metbrebt? www.wdrch`ien.drk
B-gimc? lbbh`ianJwdrch`ien.drk
Icc rmkfts rbsbrvbh
9 0 1 8 2 90 99 9: :=
Xfms vdcugb, bxabpt ldr tfb Gieikbgbet Pbspdesb ieh tfb Afimrgie's Quggiry, ms i prdhuat dl tfb still dl tfb Mehbpbehbet Bvicuitmde
Krdup dl tfb [drch @ien Krdup. Xfb lmehmeks, metbrprbtitmdes, ieh adeacusmdes bxprbssbh me tfms vdcugb hd edt ebabssirmcy rblcbat tfb vmbws dl
tfb Bxbautmvb Hmrbatdrs dl Xfb [drch @ien dr tfb kdvbregbets tfby rbprbsbet. Xfms vdcugb hdbs edt suppdrt iey kbebric melbrbeabs `bydeh tfb
sadpb dl tfb bvicuitmde, meacuhmek iey melbrbeabs i`dut tfb [drch @ien Krdup's pist, aurrbet, dr prdspbatmvb dvbricc pbrldrgieab.
Xfb [drch @ien Krdup hdbs edt kuirietbb tfb iaauriay dl tfb hiti meacuhbh me tfms wdrn. Xfb `duehirmbs, adcdrs, hbedgmeitmdes, ieh dtfbr
meldrgitmde sfdwe de iey gip me tfms wdrn hd edt mgpcy iey ouhkgbet de tfb pirt dl Xfb [drch @ien Krdup adeabremek tfb cbkic stitus dl iey
tbrrmtdry dr tfb behdrsbgbet dr iaabptieab dl suaf `duehirmbs.
Pmkfts ieh ZbrgmssmdesXfb gitbrmic me tfms pu`cmaitmde ms adpyrmkftbh. Adpymek ieh/dr triesgmttmek pdrtmdes dr icc dl tfms wdrn wmtfdut pbrgmssmde giy `b i vmdcitmde dl
ippcmai`cb ciw. Xfb Metbreitmdeic @ien ldr Pbadestruatmde ieh Hbvbcdpgbet / Xfb [drch @ien beadurikbs hmssbgmeitmde dl mts wdrn ieh wmcc
edrgiccy kriet pbrgmssmde td rbprdhuab pdrtmdes dl tfb wdrn prdgptcy.
Ldr pbrgmssmde td pfdtdadpy dr rbprmet iey pirt dl tfms wdrn, pcbisb sbeh i rbqubst wmtf adgpcbtb meldrgitmde td tfb Adpyrmkft Acbirieab
Abetbr Mea., 000 Pdsbwddh Hrmvb, Hievbrs, GI :9=01, RQI> tbcbpfdeb? =;6-;2:-68::> lix? =;6-;2:-88;:> Metbrebt? www.adpyrmkft.adg.
Icc dtfbr qubrmbs de rmkfts ieh cmabesbs, meacuhmek su smhmiry rmkfts, sfduch `b ihhrbssbh td tfb Dllmab dl tfb Zu`cmsfbr, Xfb [drch @ien, 9696
F Qtrbbt E[, [isfmektde, HA 0:811, RQI> lix? 0:0-200-0800> b-gimc? pu`rmkftsJwdrch`ien.drk.
Zfdtd arbhmts? Advbr? Ziuc Ncbb, Hrbig amty, 9=09, 9:< witbradcdur de pipbr de airh`dirh, 8;,2 x 19 ag> Hmb Qiggcuek @brkkrube me hbe
Qtiitcmafbe Gusbbe zu @brcme> Icmeirm/Irt Pbsdurab, E]. Rsbh `y pbrgmssmde dl Irt Pbsdurab, E], ieh tfb Irtmsts Pmkfts Qdambty, E]. Zirt M?
@umchmek irafwiy, Mehmi. Zfdtd `y Aurt Airebgirn, adurtbsy dl tfb [drch @ien Zfdtd Cm`riry. Zirt MM? Aieihmie ldrbst. Zfdtd `y Aurt Airebgirn,
adurtbsy dl tfb [drch @ien Zfdtd Cm`riry.
MQ@E? =;6-:-6091-6912-=
b-MQ@E? =;6-:-6091-691
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
5/180
vmm I``rbvmitmdes
mx Ianedwcbhkgbets
xm Ldrbwdrh
xmmm Bxbautmvb Quggiry
xmx Gieikbgbet Adggbets
xxv Afimrpbrsdes Adggbets? Adggmttbb de Hbvbcdpgbet Bllbatmvbebss (ADHB)
1 9 Metrdhuatmde
2 ZIPX M? XPIANMEK @IEN ZBPLDPGIEAB
; 0 [drch @ien Zbrldrgieab me Zbrspbatmvb= Zrdobat Zbrldrgieab Pbadvbrbh me 0::6
90 Cdek-Xbrg Zbrldrgieab Qfdws i Acbir Zdsmtmvb Xrbeh
91 Qfmltmek Pbkmdeic ieh Qbatdric Adgpdsmtmde Ms Zirt dl tfb Pbisde ldr
Mgprdvbh Zbrldrgieab
92 [fbe Hmh Zbrldrgieab @bkme td Mgprdvb ieh [fy4
9; Zbrldrgieab Pitmeks dl Aduetry Zrdkrigs? Ed Qmgmcir Rpwirh Xrbeh
9= @ien III Ms Mgpdrtiet `ut Edt Pbkucircy Bvicuitbh
09 Cbvbc dl @ien Ihdptmde dl Pbabet MBK Pbadggbehitmdes Fis @bbe Hbacmemek09 Adeacusmdes
01 1 Xdwirh Gbisuri`cb Pbsucts ieh Mgprdvbh Zbrldrgieab Hiti02 Zrdkrbss Mgpcbgbetmek @ien-[mhb G&B Pbldrgs Ms Bvmhbet `ut Pbgimes
Aficcbekmek
0= @ien-[mhb Pbsucts Gbisurbgbet Qystbg? Ginmek Zrdkrbss, ut tdwirh
Reabrtime Behs
1: Rsb dl Mgpiat Bvicuitmde Ms Krdwmek, `ut Mts @beblmts Irb Edt Luccy
Iafmbvbh
12 Pbic-Xmgb Zrdobat Meldrgitmde? Adetmeubh Dvbrdptmgmsg
16 Badedgma Adst-@beblmt Ieicysms? I Hdrgiet Qu`obat
1= Adeacusmdes89 ZIPX MM? IAFMB\MEK QRQXIMEI@CB HB\BCDZGBEXCBQQDEQ LPDG XFB
@IENQ BVZBPMBEAB
81 8 [drch @ien Quppdrt ldr Bevmrdegbetic Qustimei mcmty82 Xfb @iens Ipprdiaf td tfb Bevmrdegbet Fis Bvdcvbh me Pbspdesb td
Afiekmek Ebbhs
2: [drch @ien Quppdrt ldr tfb Bevmrdegbet Fis Pbadvbrbh Qmeab 0::0
21 Gimestrbigmek Bevmrdegbetic Adeabres iardss Qbatdrs Ms Gdrb Ippirbet
tfie Pbic
Adetbets
m m m
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
6/180
I E E R I C P B \ M B [ D L H B \ B C D Z G B E X B L L B A X M \ B E B Q Q 0 : : =
m v
22 Ieicytmaic [drn Ms Fbcpmek td Aiticyzb Meedvitmvb Bevmrdegbetic Mestrugbets
2; Metbreic ieh Bxtbreic Adestrimets Qfipb ieh Mefm`mt tfb @iens Bllbatmvbebss
2= Giodr Cbssdes
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
7/180v
A D E X B E X Q
2; 8.2 Dptmgic Iccdaitmde dl Bevmrdegbetic Pbsdurabs Ms Adestrimebh `y
Zdcmtmaic Pbicmtmbs it tfb Aduetry Cbvbc
26 8.< Xfb Mgpdrtieab dl Acmbet Adggmtgbet ieh Qustimebh [drch @ien
Bekikbgbet? Xfb Aisb dl Afmei
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
8/180
Xi`cbs90 0.9 Ivbrikb Ieeuic Afiekbs me Pitmeks btwbbe 9==1 ieh 0::6
98 0.0 Afiekbs me Zrdobat Adgpdsmtmde Iaaduet ldr i Qgicc Zdrtmde dl
Dvbricc Mgprdvbgbet
19 1.9 Xfb @iens Zrdkrbss me Mgpcbgbetmek MHI92 Pbadggbehitmdes11 1.0 Quggiry dl Hiti Rsbh ldr Bvicuitmek Zrdobat Dutadgbs, y Pbkmde
18 1.1 Quggiry dl Bvicuitmde Xypbs
1; 1.8 Cdw Pitmeks it Zrdobat Gmhpdmet Ldrbsfihdw [drsb Dutadgbs
1; 1.2 Ebircy Ficl dl Zrdobats Irb Rctmgitbcy Pitbh Cdwbr tfie Zrdobatbh it
Zrdobat Gmhpdmet
;9 2.9 Pbcitmdesfmp `btwbbe Badedgma Pitb dl Pbture/Lmeieamic Pitb dl
Pbture ieh BEPG Zrdobats `y Qu`tfbgb
v m
I E E R I C P B \ M B [ D L H B \ B C D Z G B E X B L L B A X M \ B E B Q Q 0 : : =
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
9/180
III Ieicytma ieh ihvmsdry iatmvmtmbs
IMHQ Iaqumrbh Mggueb Hblmambeay Qyehrdgb
IPHB Ieeuic Pbvmbw dl Hbvbcdpgbet Bllbatmvbebss
AIB Aduetry Issmstieab Bvicuitmde
AIQ Aduetry Issmstieab Qtritbky
AIQAP Aduetry Issmstieab Qtritbky Adgpcbtmde Pbpdrt
ABZL Armtmaic Badsystbg Zirtebrsfmp Lueh
HBA Hbvbcdpgbet Badedgmas Krdup
HMGB Hbvbcdpgbet Mgpiat Bvicuitmde Memtmitmvb
BEPG Bevmrdegbet ieh eituric rbsdurab gieikbgbet
BQ[ Badedgma ieh sbatdr wdrn
KHZ Krdss hdgbstma prdhuat
KBL Kcd`ic Bevmrdegbet Liamcmty
KZP Kcd`ic Zrdkrig Pbvmbw
K[Z Kcd`ic [itbr Zirtebrsfmp
FMZA Fbivmcy Mehb`tbh Zddr Aduetrmbs
FM\ Fugie Mgguedhblmambeay \mrus
MIQ Mevismvb icmbe spbambs
M@PH Metbreitmdeic @ien ldr Pbadestruatmde ieh Hbvbcdpgbet
MAP Mgpcbgbetitmde Adgpcbtmde ieh Pbsucts Pbpdrt
MHI Metbreitmdeic Hbvbcdpgbet IssdamitmdeMBK Mehbpbehbet Bvicuitmde Krdup
MLA Metbreitmdeic Lmeieab Adrpdritmde
MQP Mgpcbgbetitmde Qtitus ieh Pbsucts Pbpdrt
M[PG Metbkritbh witbr rbsdurab gieikbgbet
GIP Gieikbgbet Iatmde Pbadrh
G&B Gdemtdrmek ieh bvicuitmde
GMKI Guctmcitbric Mevbstgbet Kuirietbb Ikbeay
EKD Edekdvbregbetic drkiemzitmde
DBAQ Drkiemzitmde dl Bistbre Airm``bie Qtitbs
DZAQ Dpbritmdes Zdcmay ieh Aduetry Qbrvmabs
ZIH Zrdobat Ipprimsic Hdaugbet
ZIPMQ09 Zirtebrsfmp me Qtitmstmas ldr Hbvbcdpgbet me tfb 09st Abetury
ZPDLDP Zrdkrig de Ldrbsts
YIK Yuicmty Issurieab Krdup
PBHH Pbhuamek Bgmssmdes lrdg Hbldrbstitmde ieh Hbkrihitmde
PGQ Pbsucts Gbisurbgbet Qystbg
XI Xbafemaic issmstieab
RELAAA Remtbh Eitmdes Lrigbwdrn Adevbetmde de Acmgitb Afiekb
[@K [drch @ien Krdup
[@M [drch @ien Mestmtutb
[HM [drch Hbvbcdpgbet Mehmaitdrs
I``rbvmitmdes
v m m
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
10/180
Adttde pciet, I`u Isfbr, Quhie. Zfdtd y Ireb Fdbc, adurtbsy dl [drch @ien Zfdtd Cm`riry.
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
11/180
Ianedwcbhkgbets
Xfms rbpdrt wis prbpirbh `y i adrb tbig dl Afrms
Kbrrirh, Iehrbw [irebr, Odfe Brmnssde, Ciurbe
Nbccy, Emhfm Nfittrm, ieh @rbtt Cm`rbsad, uehbr tfb
cbihbrsfmp dl Girn Queh`brk. Ihhmtmdeic suppdrt
wis prdvmhbh `y Ieei Ikfugmie, Oivmbr @ibz,
Irup @iebrom, Kiyitrm Hitir, Vmgbei Hbc Airpmd,
Bcimeb Ddm, Hmiei Qicvbgmem, Obssb Xdrrbeab,
Zigbci \bcbz-\bki, ieh Iehrbw [ixgie. Mt wis
prdabssbh `y Hmiei Find`yie ieh ]vbttb
Oirbeamd-Cun`ie, wmtf issmstieab lrdg ]bzbei
]mgbr. Xfb rbpdrt wis bhmtbh `y [mccmig Furc`ut
ieh Airdcmeb GaBube.
Odfieebs Cmee ieh Qusgmti Hiskupti sbrvbh is
pbbr rbvmbwbrs dl tfb lmeic bvicuitmde rbpdrt.
\icui cb adggbetiry wis icsd prdvmhbh y Girtfi
Imeswdrtf, Fies-Girtme @dbfgbr, Nbe Afdgmtz,
Iprmc Adeebccy, Icm Nfihr, Eicmem Nugir, O.Z. Qmekf,
]dsfmeb Rafmguri, ieh Pmafirh [drhbe.
Xfb bvicuitmde tbig krbitcy ipprbamitbs tfb tmgb
ieh mesmkfts kmvbe y tfb giey mehmvmhuics mesmhb
ieh dutsmhb tfb @ien metbrvmbwbh ldr tfms rbpdrt.
Xfb bvicuitmde `beblmtbh su`stietmiccy lrdg tfb
adestruatmvb ihvmab ieh lbbh`ian lrdg giey
still me tfb [drch @ien Krdup.
Xfb bvicuitmde wis adehuatbh uehbr tfb kumhieab
dl Girn Queh`brk, Gieikbr, MBK Adrpdritb ieh
Kcd`ic Bvicuitmde ieh Gbtfdhs Remt.
Hmrbatdr-Kbebric, Bvicuitmde? \medh Xfdgis
Hmrbatdr, Mehbpbehbet Bvicuitmde Krdup, [drch @ien? Afbryc Kriy
Gieikbr, Adrpdritb ieh Kcd`ic Bvicuitmde ieh Gbtfdhs?Girn Queh`brk
Odmet Xisn Gieikbrs?Iehrbw [irebr, Zirt M, Afrms Kbrrirh, Zirt MM
m x
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
12/180
Xbrriabh rmab pihhmbs ebir i Pbh _id vmccikb, dutsmhb Qpi, Cid Aim Zrdvmeab, edrtfbre \mbteig. Zfdtd y Xrie Xfm Fdi, adurtbsy dl
tfb [drch @ien Zfdtd Cm`riry.
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
13/180
Ldrbwdrh
Bvbe is tfb kcd`ic lmeieamic armsms adesugbs
wdrch ittbetmde, bevmrdegbetic hbkrihitmde
rbgimes igdek tfb ldrbgdst aficcbekbs dl dur
tmgb. Mehbbh, tfb hiekbrs issdamitbh wmtf
acmgitb afiekb fivb rbabetcy `bbe rbadkemzbh,
`ut dtfbr bevmrdegbetic prd`cbgsimr ieh
witbr pdccutmde, sdmc brdsmde ieh hbsbrtmlmaitmde,
witbr sairamty ieh `mdhmvbrsmty cdssadetmeub td
`b ebkcbatbh. Xfb [drch @ien ms uemqubcy
pdsmtmdebh td suppdrt aduetry, rbkmdeic, ieh
kcd`ic blldrts td adelrdet tfbsb aficcbekbs me i
wiy tfit prdgdtbs cdek-tbrg badedgma krdwtf
ieh pdvbrty rbhuatmde.
Xfms ybirs Ieeuic Pbvmbw dl Hbvbcdpgbet
Bllbatmvbebss (IPHB) spdtcmkfts tfb @iens rdcb me
fbcpmek aduetrmbs td ihhrbss tfbsb bevmrdegbetic
aficcbekbs. [drch @ien suppdrt ldr bevmrdegbet
prdobats fis rbadvbrbh smeab 0::0 wmtf tfb
suppdrt dl ebw sdurabs dl adeabssmdeic lmeieab.Bevmrdegbetic adeabres fivb rbabmvbh krdwmek
ittbetmde me Aduetry Issmstieab Qtritbkmbs.
Krdwmek eug`brs dl rbkmdeic prdobats irb
ihhrbssmek tfb sfirbh usb dl rbkmdeic `dhmbs dl
witbr suaf is tfb Emcb @isme, Cinb \matdrmi, ieh tfb
@cian ieh Iric Qbis. Ebw pirtebrsfmps ieh liamcm-
tmbs it tfb kcd`ic cbvbc irb hbbpbemek @ien mevdcvb-
gbet ieh pdtbetmic mgpiat de acmgitb afiekb.
Dutadgbs dl bevmrdegbet prdobats fivb fmstdrm-
aiccy `bbe wbinbr tfie tfb @iens ivbrikb ldr icc
irbis, `ut fivb sfdwe sdgb mgprdvbgbet me
rbabet ybirs. Xfb @iens hmrbat prdobat suppdrt
ldr tfb bevmrdegbet fis fbcpbh hbvbcdp girnbt-
isbh mestrugbets ldr bevmrdegbetic gieikb-
gbet. Xfb @ien fis icsd iafmbvbh sdgb kimes me
tfb fmkfcy aficcbekmek `ut armtmaiccy tfrbitbebh
irbi dl `mdhmvbrsmty adesbrvitmde, ictfdukf lir
gdrb rbgimes td `b hdeb. Gimestrbigmek tfbsb
ieh dtfbr bevmrdegbetic prdkrigs metd aduetry
stritbkmbs ieh prdkrigs rbgimes i aruamic kip.
Guaf gdrb ebbhs td `b hdeb me gdemtdrmek ieh
bvicuitmde? tfrbb-quirtbrs dl bevmrdegbet-
rbcitbh prdobatstfdsb gieikbh `y sbatdrs
dtfbr tfie tfb bevmrdegbetcian systbgitma
rbpdrtmek dl bevmrdegbetic dutadgbs.
Is ms austdgiry, tfb IPHB icsd rbvmbws tfb
@iens pbrldrgieab me kbttmek rbsucts lrdg tfb
prdobats ieh aduetry prdkrigs mt suppdrts. Xfb
0::6 prdobat pbrldrgieab hiti sfdw mgprdvb-gbet me iafmbvmek hbvbcdpgbet dutadgbs,
ihhmek td beadurikmek bvmhbeab de tfb @iens
cdek-tbrg pbrldrgieab trbehs. @ut tfb rbadrh
de gdemtdrmek ieh rbpdrtmek dl hbvbcdpgbet
rbsucts adetmeubs td pdsb aficcbekbs ldr tfb
mestmtutmde. Xfb blldrts uehbr wiy td hbbpbe tfb
rbsucts ikbehi irb beadurikmek. Lurtfbr prdkrbss
wmcc `b aruamic ldr tfb metbreitmdeic hmsaussmdes
de Metbreitmdeic Hbvbcdpgbet Issdamitmde (MHI)
rbpcbemsfgbet ieh ldr tfb pdst-Nydtd ikrbbgbet
it tfb Adpbefikbe Quggmt.
\medh Xfdgis
Hmrbatdr-Kbebric, Bvicuitmde
x m
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
14/180
Gie me i lmbch smltmek sbbhs icdek Pbh Pmvbr me edrtfbre \mbteig. Zfdtd y Yuy-Xdie Hd, adurtbsy dl tfb [drch @ien Zfdtd Cm`riry.
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
15/180x m m m
Xfms ybirsIeeuic Pbvmbw dl Hbvbcdpgbet Bllbatmvbebss (IPHB) ms bmek
wrmttbe ikimest tfb `ianhrdp dl i kcd`ic lmeieamic armsms, hbacmemek
krdwtf, ieh gissmvb lmsaic stmgucus blldrts td rbvmticmzb girnbts. Hbgieh
ldr krbitbr hbvbcdpgbet suppdrt lrdg tfb [drch @ien fis krdwe, icdek wmtf
adeabres tfit rbsdurabs b usbh bllbatmvbcy ieh bllmambetcy td iafmbvb tfbmr hb-
vbcdpgbet d`obatmvbs. Xfms IPHB ldausbs de tfb @iens pbrldrgieab rbadrh
me kbttmek rbsucts lrdg mts prdobats ieh aduetry prdkrigs ieh, is ms austdg-
iry, bxigmebs me hbptf deb tdpma rbcitmek td hbvbcdpgbet bllbatmvbebss. Xfb
ldaus dl tfms IPHB ms de tfb @iens suppdrt ldr bevmrdegbetic sustimei`mcmty,
me rbspdesb td i @dirh rbqubst ldr i syetfbsms dl lmehmeks lrdg rbabet Mehb-
pbehbet Bvicuitmde Krdup (MBK) rbpdrts de tfb bevmrdegbet.
Xfb rbpdrt sfdws tfit tfb @iens pbrldrgieab
rbadrh hmspciys i gdhbritbcy strdek upwirh
trbeh dvbr tfb gbhmug tbrg, ieh rbabet
pbrldrgieab fis adetmeubh tfms trbeh. Mt icsd
sfdws tfit tfbrb fis `bbe i gmxbh rbadrh demgpcbgbetmek tfb ikbehi td strbektfbe tfb
@iens drmbetitmde, aipiamty, ieh gdemtdrmek
dl hbvbcdpgbet rbsuctstfb rbsucts ikbehi.
Mestmtutmdeic memtmitmvbs td strbektfbe prdobat-
cbvbc gdemtdrmek ieh bvicuitmde (G&B), td put me
pciab i Pbsucts Gbisurbgbet Qystbg ldr tfb
Metbreitmdeic Hbvbcdpgbet Issdamitmde (MHI),
ieh td mgpcbgbet rbsucts-`isbh Aduetry
Issmstieab Qtritbkmbs irb it hmllbrbet stikbs dl
hbpcdygbet ieh fivb ybt td hbgdestritb i acbir
mgpiat de dutadgbs.
Xfms ybirs spbamic ldauskbttmek rbsucts ldr
sustimei`cb hbvbcdpgbetrblcbats tfb vmtic rdcb
dl sdueh bevmrdegbetic stbwirhsfmp ldr
hbvbcdpgbet ieh tfb krivb tfrbit tfit meiatmde
pdsbs dl rbvbrsmek kimes me krdwtf ieh pdvbrty
rbhuatmde. Xfb @iens rbadrh me mgpcbgbetmek
tfb 0::9 Bevmrdegbet Qtritbky ieh ihvieamek
tfb rbsucts ikbehi ms qumtb gmxbh. Ebw sdurabs
dl lmeieamek, meacuhmek rbsdurabs ldr kcd`ic
blldrts, fivb fbcpbh cbehmek ieh suppdrt ldr tfb
bevmrdegbet td rbadvbr lrdg tfb cdws dl tfb
bircy 0:::s> ieicytma wdrn fis ldstbrbh meedvi-
tmvb ipprdiafbs ieh befieabh bevmrdegbeticiwirbebss> ieh hmrbat suppdrt ldr bevmrdegbetic
prdobats ms sfdwmek mgprdvbh pbrldrgieab, wmtf
tiekm`cb rbsucts. @ut mgpcbgbetitmde dl tfb
stritbky me gimestrbig bevmrdegbetic wdrn
iardss sbatdrs fis `bbe wbin ieh gust `b
strbektfbebh. Zrdobat pbrldrgieab sfdws i acbir
mgprdvmek trbeh.
Zrdobat Zbrldrgieab Qfdws i AcbirMgprdvmek XrbehXfb 0::6 [drch @ien prdobat pbrldrgieab hiti
sfdws mgprdvbgbet me iafmbvmek hbvbcdpgbet
dutadgbs, icciymek adeabres tfit tfb wbinbebh
pbrldrgieab dl 0::; aduch smkeic i ebw
hdwewirh trbeh. Xfb hbacmeb me 0::; wis
gdhbst, ieh pbrldrgieab rb`duehbh me 0::6.
@ien pbrldrgieab ms ritbh de i smx-pdmet saicb,
lrdg fmkfcy sitmsliatdry td fmkfcy uesitmsliatdry
(sbb `dx 0.9 me afiptbr 0 ldr ie bxpcieitmde dl
Bxbautmvb Quggiry
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
16/180
I E E R I C P B \ M B [ D L H B \ B C D Z G B E X B L L B A X M \ B E B Q Q 0 : : =
x m v
MBK ritmeks). Xfb pbrabetikb dl sitmsliatdry
prdobats (tfit ms, tfb tdp tfrbb ritmeks) mearbisbh
me 0::6, adetmeumek tfb upwirh trbeh dl tfb pist
92 ybirs. Ivbrikb pbrldrgieab, wfmaf usbs tfb
lucc smx-pdmet saicb, icsd sfdws mgpdrtietprdkrbss, `ut tfb kimes irb cbss tfie ficl is cirkb
adgpirbh wmtf tfb pbrabet sitmsliatdry gbisurb.
Zbrabet sitmsliatdry tbehs td kmvb fmkf wbmkft td
`drhbrcmeb afiekbstfdsb tfit oust piss dvbr
tfb tfrbsfdch metd tfb gdhbritbcy sitmsliatdry
aitbkdry de tfb smx-pdmet saicb. Afiekbs dvbr
tmgb me tfb @iens pdrtldcmd livdrmek `bttbr-
pbrldrgmek Pbkmdes ieh sbatdrs icsd bxpcime i
sgicc pirt dl tfb mgprdvbh pbrldrgieab.
Ieicysms dl tfb hitbs dl tfb giodr tureirduehs me
prdobat pbrldrgieab sukkbsts tfit i adg`mei-
tmde dl `bttbr @ien sbatdr pdcmambs ieh mgprdvbh
aduetry amraugstieabs dutsmhb @ien adetrdc giy
bxpcime guaf dl tfb tureirdueh, ritfbr tfie
metbreic ihgmemstritmvb rbldrgs it tfb @ien,
ictfdukf tfb cittbr giy fivb liamcmtitbh
mgprdvbgbet icrbihy uehbr wiy.
Bvicuitmek tfb rbsucts dl ieicytma ieh ihvmsdry
iatmvmtmbs (III) ms mefbrbetcy hmllmauct. MBK hdbs
edt rbkucircy ritb tfb @iens III, ictfdukf mt
uehbrpmes prdobats ieh iaaduets ldr i`dut deb-tfmrh dl spbehmek de aduetry sbrvmabs. Fdwbvbr,
i rbabet MBK bvicuitmde (MBK 0::6b) mehmaitbs
tfit i`dut twd-tfmrhs dl III ms gdhbritbcy
sitmsliatdry dr `bttbr, ieh deb-tfmrh ms cbss
suaabssluc. Zbrldrgieab pittbres sukkbst tfit
mgpiat ieh rbsucts ldr aduetrmbs hbpbeh de
tbafemaic quicmty, adearbtb ieh aduetry-spbamlma
rbadggbehitmdes, aduetry dwebrsfmp dl tfb
lmehmeks, ieh sustimebh ldccdw-up iltbr tisn
adgpcbtmde. MBK metbehs td pmcdt ie ipprdiaf td
systbgitma III bvicuitmde.
Xfb 0::= Gieikbgbet Iatmde Pbadrh (GIP),
wfmaf trians @ien ihdptmde dl rbabet MBK
rbadggbehitmdes, mehmaitbs tfit ihdptmde cbvbcs
fivb hbacmebh me tfb @ien. MBK ms aurrbetcy
bxigmemek wiys td mgprdvb tfb GIP td arbitb i
gdrb bllbatmvb prdhuat ldr trianmek ihdptmde dl
rbadggbehitmdes ieh td mhbetmly rbisdes ldr tfb
trbeh hbacmeb.
Blldrts td Qtrbektfbe ZbrldrgieabMehmaitdrs Ebbh Qtrdek ieh AdetmeumekQuppdrtMe rbspdesb td tfb metbreitmdeic hrmvb ldr
gbisurbgbet ieh gieikbgbet ldr hbvbcdp-gbet rbsucts, tfb [drch @ien fis ciueafbh giodr
blldrts td mgprdvb pbrldrgieab meldrgitmde me
@ien-suppdrtbh prdobats. Xfb @ien fis gdvbh
td strbektfbe G&B, metrdhuabh i Pbsucts
Gbisurbgbet Qystbg ldr MHI, ieh bxpiehbh
rmkdrdus bvicuitmde dl prdobat metbrvbetmdes.
Xfbsb blldrts irb `bkmeemek td melcubeab mestmtu-
tmdeic prmdrmtmbs ieh `usmebss priatmabs. Fdwbvbr,
me giey prdobats meldrgitmde ms edt sullmambetcy
rmkdrdus dr adgprbfbesmvb td prdvmhb stinbfdch-
brs wmtf i pmaturb dl wfit rbiccy afiekbh is i
rbsuct dl tfb prdobat.
Zrdobat G&B prdvmhbs `umchmek `cdans ldr
kbebritmek kddh meldrgitmde de hbvbcdpgbet
dutadgbs ieh fis rbabmvbh mearbismek @ien
ittbetmde me rbabet ybirs. MBK `bkie td issbss
G&B quicmty me 0::< ieh fis ritbh tfb quicmty dl
G&B me prdobats tfit wbrb rbvmbwbh me tfb pist
twd ybirs is gdhbst dr ebkcmkm`cb me tfrbb-lmltfs
dl aisbs. Xfbsb rbvmbws pdmet td sbvbric sfdrt-
adgmeks? mehmaitdrs irb tdd eugbrdus ieh dltbe
gbisurb dutputs ritfbr tfie dutadgbs> `isbcmebhiti irb melrbqubetcy adccbatbh> lbw prdobats
adccbat tfb hiti tfit wduch `b rbqumrbh td issbss
mgpiat> ieh acmbet lbbh`ian sukkbsts rbcuatieab
td ihdpt prdobat G&B priatmabs ieh adesmhbri`cb
lrikgbetitmde dl G&B blldrts. Xfbsb ritmeks aie
decy b issmkebh td prdobats iltbr tfby acdsb, ieh
irb tfbrbldrb cikkmek mehmaitdrs. Xfby prdvmhb i
rblbrbeab pdmet ldr gdemtdrmek luturb trbehs ieh
trianmek wfbtfbr aurrbet blldrts td mgprdvb G&B
wdrn. Xfb cdw G&B ritmeks, fdwbvbr, sukkbst i
adetmeumek ebbh td rbvmsmt tfb meabetmvbs, usb,
ieh rbsduramek dl G&B me @ien-suppdrtbh
prdobats wmtf i vmbw tdwirh smgpcmamty, triati`mcmty,
ieh hbamsmde rbcbvieab.
Qfdrtadgmeks me G&B hbsmke ieh mgpcbgbeti-
tmde giy adetrm`utb td prd`cbgs ldueh me prdobat
supbrvmsmde ieh rbpdrtmek. Ldr ie ivbrikb dl 90
pbrabet dl prdobats biaf ybir, tfbrb ms i
hmsadeebat `btwbbe tfb @iens sbcl-issbssgbets
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
17/180x v
B V B A R X M \ B Q R G G I P ]
ieh MBK prdobat pbrldrgieab ritmeks. Ldr tfbsb
prdobats, tfb metbreic supbrvmsmde dl prdobat
pbrldrgieab tfrdukf tfb cmlb dl i prdobat
lrbqubetcy ippbirs td `b dvbrcy dptmgmstma ieh
sdgbtmgbs cians aiehdr rbkirhmek rmsns tdhbvbcdpgbet d`obatmvbs. Hbciys me iaauritb
rbpdrtmek cbih td lmeic supbrvmsmde issbssgbets
tfit adgb tdd citb ldr adrrbatmvb iatmde td `b
tinbe.
Ie dutkrdwtf dl tfb MHI ebkdtmitmdes smeab 0::1
fis `bbe hbvbcdpgbet dl i Pbsucts Gbisurbgbet
Qystbg td gbisurb ieh ikkrbkitb hbvbcdpgbet
dutadgbs me i wiy tfit ms rbcbviet td stinbfdch-
brs ieh hdedrs. Xfms ms i adggbehi`cb blldrt td
trian ieh rbpdrt rbsucts me i addrhmeitbh lisfmde.
I `rmbl issbssgbet me ihvieab dl tfb Edvbg`br
0::= MHI Gmhtbrg Pbvmbw, `isbh de hdaugbe-
tiry bvmhbeab, still metbrvmbws, ieh i survby dl
MHI hdedrs, sukkbsts tfit tfb memtmitmvb fis gihb
prdkrbss, ybt liabs smkemlmaiet aficcbekbs td luccbr
mgpcbgbetitmde.
Mgpiat bvicuitmde ms kimemek guaf krbitbr triatmde
me tfb @ien is i tddc tfit fdchs prdgmsb ldr prdvmh-
mek bstmgitbs dl prdobat bllmaiay ieh mgpiat. Dvbr
02: mgpiat bvicuitmdes irb uehbr wiy me tfb @ien,
giey me tfb Fugie Hbvbcdpgbet Ebtwdrn. Irbvmbw dl rbabetcy acdsbh prdobats me tfb Ikrmauc-
turb, Bevmrdegbet, ieh [itbr Qbatdrs mehmaitbh
tfit lbw adccbatbh bvbe tfb gmemgug meldrgitmde
td issbss rbsucts, ieh prdobats wmtf `isbcmebs
igbei`cb td ieicysms irb adeabetritbh me tfb Bist
Ismi ieh Burdpb ieh Abetric Ismi Pbkmdes. Xfus
rbqumsmtb meldrgitmde ldr `isma quietmtitmvb
ieicysms ms stmcc rirb. MBK wmcc memtmitb ieicysms dvbr
tfb adgmek ybir td `bttbr uehbrstieh tfb quicmty,
rbcbvieab, ieh adsts dl tfb aurrbet mgpiat
bvicuitmdes me tfb @ien.
Lmeiccy, badedgma adst-`beblmt ieicysms ms tfb
trihmtmdeic gbtfdh, cdek priatmabh me tfb @ien,
ldr drkiemzmek meldrgitmde de prdobat `beblmts
ieh adsts me i gieebr rbcbviet td hbamsmde
ginmek. Xfb @iens usb dl adst-`beblmt ieicysms
pbinbh me tfb bircy 9=;:s `ut ms edw ippcmbh td
decy i`dut deb-quirtbr dl prdobats. Xfms mehmaitbs
tfit adst-`beblmt armtbrmi irb edw usbh lir cbss is
i `isms ldr prdobat luehmek hbamsmdes. Ictfdukf
pirt dl tfms afiekb giy `b ittrm`utbh td tfb
sfmltmek eiturb dl hbvbcdpgbet issmstieab, edt icc
dl mt ms. Ie issbssgbet dl tfb usb dl adst-`beblmt
tddcs me bevmrdegbetic prdobats cirkbcy adelmrgstfms adeacusmde. Xfms mssub wmcc `b tinbe up me
krbitbr hbtimc me ie MBK spbamic rbpdrt me lmsaic
ybir 0:9:.
Quppdrt ldr Bevmrdegbetic Qustimei`mcmtyMs Bxpiehmek `ut Ebbhs td Kd GuafLurtfbr
Ihhrbssmek bevmrdegbetic hbkrihitmde ms deb dl
tfb abetric aficcbekbs dl dur tmgb. Xfb @ien ms
uemqubcy pdsmtmdebh td suppdrt aduetry, rbkmdeic,
ieh kcd`ic blldrts td ihhrbss bevmrdegbetic
aficcbekbs suaf is acmgitb afiekb, imr ieh witbr
pdccutmde, ieh hbldrbstitmde ieh `mdhmvbrsmty cdss
me i gieebr adgpitm`cb wmtf badedgma krdwtf
ieh pdvbrty rbhuatmde. Krbbemek tfb krdwtf pitf
ebbh edt adgb it tfb bxpbesb dl krdwtf dr dl
fbcpmek tfb pddr. Ldr bxigpcb, tfbrb irb bxtbe-
smvb uetippbh dppdrtuemtmbs td rbhuab krbbe-
fdusb kis bgmssmdes tfrdukf meabetmvbs ldr
krbitbr bllmambeay. Gdrbdvbr, prdvmhmek 0 `mccmde
pddr pbdpcb wmtf `isma bcbatrmamty iaabss wduch
ihh cmttcb td wdrch krbbefdusb kis bgmssmdes
cbss tfie :.8 pbrabet dl aurrbet bgmssmdes, bvbe mlair`de-metbesmvb gbies irb usbh.
Xfms ybirs IPHB spdtcmkfts tfb @iens iatmvmtmbs
ieh pbrldrgieab me fbcpmek aduetrmbs td ihhrbss
tfbsb bevmrdegbetic aficcbekbs, `isbh de tfb
lmehmeks dl rbabet MBK bvicuitmdes ieh suppcb-
gbetiry ieicysms. Xfbsb bvicuitmdes meacuhb, `ut
irb edt cmgmtbh td, tfb ldccdwmek?Bevmrdegbetic
Qustimei`mcmty? Ie Bvicuitmde dl [drch @ien
Krdup Quppdrt> Acmgitb Afiekb ieh tfb [drch
@ien Krdup, Zfisb M? Ie Bvicuitmde dl [drch
@ien [me-[me Bebrky Zdcmay Pbldrgs> Xfb
Hbvbcdpgbet Zdtbetmic dl Pbkmdeic Zrdkrigs?
Ie Bvicuitmde dl [drch @ien Quppdrt dl
Guctmaduetry Dpbritmdes> ieh i ldrtfadgmek
rbvmbw dl tfb @iens ldrbstry iatmvmtmbs.
@ien gieikbgbet fis `bkue td memtmitb ebw
stritbkmbs ldr tfb [drch @ien Krdup, meacuhmek
ldr acmgitb afiekb, bebrky, ieh tfb bevmrdegbet.
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
18/180
I E E R I C P B \ M B [ D L H B \ B C D Z G B E X B L L B A X M \ B E B Q Q 0 : : =
x v m
Xfms IPHB rblcbats de tfb lmehmeks dl tfb `dhy dl
MBKs rbabet bvicuitmde wdrn me tfb irbi dl tfb
bevmrdegbet, `ut icsd kdbs `bydeh tfbsb
lmehmeks `y uphitmek tfb pdrtldcmd ieh pbrldrg-
ieab hiti tfrdukf lmsaic ybir 0::6 ieh suppcb-gbetmek gitbrmics lrdg MBKs prdobat, aduetry,
ieh kcd`ic bvicuitmde prdhuats.
Xfb @iens bevmrdegbet stritbky, ciueafbh me
0::9, lurtfbrbh tfb sfmlt me tfb @iens stieab
lrdg hd ed firg td iatmvb prdgdtmde dl
bevmrdegbetic kdics, i sfmlt tfit `bkie me tfb
bircy 9==:s. Xfms arbitbh tfb pdtbetmic ldr guaf
krbitbr bllbatmvbebss tfrdukf gimestrbigmek
ittbetmde td tfb bevmrdegbet iardss tfb @iens
prdobat pdrtldcmd ieh aduetry issmstieab stritb-
kmbs. Mt ms tdd bircy td issbss tfb 0::; drkiemzi-
tmdeic afiekbs metbehbh td liamcmtitb gime-
strbigmek ieh adesdcmhitb bevmrdegbet metd tfb
Qustimei`cb Hbvbcdpgbet Ebtwdrn. Zrbcmgmeiry
mehmaitdrs sukkbst tfit gimestrbigmek fis
hbarbisbh me sdgb sbatdrs, suaf is ikrmaucturb,
bebrky, ieh triespdrt, ieh tfit ardss-sbatdr
adcci`dritmde fis bbe pirtmaucircy wbin btwbbe
witbr suppcy ieh fbictf.
Qmeab 0::9, ebw luehmek sdurabsmeacuhmek
air`de luehs, bxpiehbh Kcd`ic BevmrdegbetLueh rbsdurabs, ieh ebw trust luehsfivb
adetrm`utbh td i rbadvbry me @ien suppdrt ldr tfb
bevmrdegbet. Xfms luehmek fis icsd sfmltbh tfb
ldaus dl wdrn lrdg trihmtmdeic gimestrbigbh
iatmvmtmbs suaf is pdccutmde gieikbgbet tdwirh
meedvitmvb ipprdiafbs rbcitmek td acmgitb
afiekb. Xfb @ien ms aurrbetcy stbppmek up mts
rdcb me fbcpmek lmeieab sdcutmdes td tdukf mssubs
suaf is acmgitb gmtmkitmde ieh ihiptitmde dr
`mdhmvbrsmty cdssbs, wfbrb tfb mestmtutmde aie
pdtbetmiccy ginb i vmtic hmllbrbeab.
Ictfdukf adestmtutmek decy 2 pbrabet dl tdtic
bevmrdegbetic adggmtgbets, rbkmdeic (guctm-
aduetry) bevmrdegbetic prdobats fivb `bbe i
prdgmsmek irbi dl krdwtf. Pbkmdeic bevmrdegbe-
tic adggmtgbets gdrb tfie hdu`cbh dvbr tfb
pist smx ybirs> tfb cirkbst vdcugb dl adggmtgbets
ms me Ilrmai. Xfb rbkmdeic pmcdt memtmitmvb,
metrdhuabh me MHI98, prdvmhbh ihhmtmdeic kriet
lmeieamek lrdg MHI td fbcp dvbradgb meabetmvbs
tfit wbmkf ikimest gdrb adgpcbx guctmaduetry
prdkrigs.
Ieicytma wdrn fis icsd cbet suppdrt td nby
bevmrdegbetic memtmitmvbs iardss i `rdihspbatrug. Bxigpcbs meacuhb wdrn de mgprdvmek
pdcmambs ieh mestmtutmdes ldr sustimei`cb ldrbst
gieikbgbet ieh de hbvbcdpmek air`de girnbts
ieh prdobat-`isbh tbafemaic nedwcbhkb tfit fis
fbcpbh hbvbcdpgbet dl metbreitmdeiccy ipprdvbh
gbtfdhs ldr tfb abrtmlmaitmde dl bgmssmdes
rbhuatmdes.
Xfbrb irb irbis dl suaabss, `ut smkemlmaiet
metbreic ieh bxtbreic ldrabs adestrime tfb @iens
bevmrdegbetic pdrtldcmd. [bin aduetry hbgieh
ldr cdies irmsbs lrdg tfb pu`cma kddh eiturb dl
giey bevmrdegbetic metbrvbetmdes. [fbrb tfb
`beblmts aie `b cdaiccy aipturbh, tfb meabetmvb td
iat ms strdekbr, is me tfb aisb dl pdccutmde adetrdc
me Afmei. Zdcmtmaic adgpbtmtmde ieh adrruptmde
surrduehmek rbsdurab rbets giy icsd adestrime
hbgieh. Nedwcbhkb ieh aipiamty adestrimets,
pirtmaucircy wfbrb @ien suppdrt fis wivbrbh
dvbr tmgb, mefm`mt cbehmek. Metbreic nedwcbhkb
kips, meihbquitb tbafemaic ieh dpbritmdeic snmccs
td metbkritb bevmrdegbet adesmhbritmdes metd
mevbstgbet ieh pdcmay rbldrg prdobats, ieh pddrhmssbgmeitmde dl bvmhbeab de bllbatmvbebss
wmtfme tfb @ien mgpbhb bllbatmvbebss ieh cmgmt
krdwtf. Lmeiccy, metbreic still ieh gieikbgbet
meabetmvbs livdr cirkb prdobats, suaf is melristrua-
turb dr pdwbr, wfmaf hmsihvietikbs tfb typmaiccy
sgiccbr bevmrdegbetic prdobats.
Qdgb Edtbwdrtfy Pbsucts Fivb @bbeIafmbvbh, `ut [bin GdemtdrmekAdgprdgmsbs Pbsucts GbisurbgbetXfb dvbricc dutadgbs dl bevmrdegbet prdobats,
cmnb tfb @iens pdrtldcmd is i wfdcb, fivb `bbe
mgprdvmek dvbr tmgb. @ut prdobats gieikbh `y
sbatdrs dtfbr tfie tfb bevmrdegbet, wfmaf
adgprmsb gdst dl tfb @iens suppdrt ldr tfb
bevmrdegbet, kbebriccy cian systbgitma rbpdrtmek
dl bevmrdegbetic dutadgbs.
Xfb @iens hmrbat prdobat suppdrt ldr tfb
bevmrdegbet fis fbcpbh hbvbcdp girnbt-`isbh
mestrugbets ldr bevmrdegbetic gieikbgbet ieh
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
19/180x v m m
B V B A R X M \ B Q R G G I P ]
fis bxtbehbh cbssdes de tfb hbsmke dl tfbsb
systbgs tfrdukfdut Citme Igbrmai ieh metd Ilrmai.
Xfb @ien fis icsd iafmbvbh sdgb kimes me tfb
aficcbekmek `ut armtmaiccy tfrbitbebh irbi dl
`mdhmvbrsmty adesbrvitmde. Mt fis `bbe tfb wdrchscirkbst sdurab dl suppdrt ldr `mdhmvbrsmty, meacuh-
mek cbehbh lmeieab lrdg tfb Kcd`ic Bevmrdegbet
Liamcmty. Xfms fis prdvmhbh suppdrt ldr i smkemlmaiet
bxpiesmde dl prdtbatbh irbis is wbcc is ldr tfb
sustimei`cb usb dl mdhmvbrsmty dutsmhb tfbsb irbis,
`ut gdrb ittbetmde ebbhs td `b pimh td tfb
bllbatmvbebss ieh sustimei`mcmty dl tfbsb blldrts.
Bevmrdegbetic rbsucts irb edt cmgmtbh td prdobats.
It tfb aduetry cbvbc, bevmrdegbetic adeabres
fivb rbabmvbh krdwmek ittbetmde me issmstieab
stritbkmbs ieh aduetry prdkrig bvicuitmdes, `ut
pbrldrgieab fis `bbe ldueh wietmek. Bevm-
rdegbetic adgpdebets, de ivbrikb, fivb
pbrldrgbh cbss wbcc tfie dvbricc aduetry stritb-
kmbs. Xfb @iens rbadrh de bevmrdegbetic
stbwirhsfmp fis `bbe uebvbe. Ldr bxigpcb, tfb
@ien fis fbcpbh sdgb aduetrmbs rbldrg bebrky
prmamek `y suppdrtmek tfb rbgdvic dl adstcy
su`smhmbs wfmcb prdtbatmek tfb pddr tfrdukf
sdamic silbty ebts, `ut fis decy kmvbe gdhbst
ittbetmde td eitmdeic pdcmambs td prdgdtb bebrky
bllmambeay.
Xfb krdwmek `dhy dl rbkmdeic prdobats dllbrs tfb
dppdrtuemty td ihhrbss trieseitmdeic bevmrde-
gbetic aficcbekbs surrduehmek tfb usb dl sfirbh
`dhmbs dl witbr suaf is tfb Emcb @isme, Cinb
\matdrmi, ieh tfb @cian ieh Iric Qbis. Xfb @ien
fis `bbe bllbatmvb me ldstbrmek guctmaduetry
addpbritmde td bsti`cmsf rbkmdeic mestmtutmdes td
ihhrbss rbkmdeic bevmrdegbetic aficcbekbs
tfrdukf ieicytmaic wdrn, prdobat prbpiritmde, ieh
rbsdurab gd`mcmzitmde, `ut mt fis `bbe cbss
bllbatmvb me fbcpmek aduetrmbs rbsdcvb cdek-
stiehmek rbsdurab adelcmats.
It tfb kcd`ic cbvbc, tfbrb ms bvicuitmde bvmhbeab
tfit kcd`ic prdkrigs irb ihhmek vicub td aduetry
prdkrigs `y prdvmhmek adeabssmdeic lmeieamek
ldr aduetry-cbvbc mevbstgbets tfit fivb kcd`ic
bevmrdegbetic `beblmts ieh `y kbebritmek
nedwcbhkb i`dut `bst priatmabs me bevmrdegbe-
tic gieikbgbet. Ebw pirtebrsfmps ieh liamcmtmbs
hbsmkebh td prdgdtb bebrky bllmambeay, acm-
gitb afiekb ihiptitmde, ieh krbbefdusb kis
bgmssmdes rbhuatmde lrdg hbldrbstitmde ieh cieh
hbkrihitmdesuaf is tfb Acmgitb Mevbstgbet
Luehs ieh tfb Ldrbst Air`de ZirtebrsfmpLiamcmtyirb hbbpbemek @ien mevdcvbgbet ieh
pdtbetmic mgpiat de acmgitb afiekb mssubs.
AdeacusmdesZrdobat dutadgbs rbprbsbet i nby `umchmek `cdan
me iafmbvmek rbsucts tfrdukf [drch @ien suppdrt
td aduetrmbs. Xfbsb dutadgbs fivb sfdwe smkeml-
maiet mgprdvbgbet dvbr tfb pist 92 ybirs. @ien-
wmhb, tfbrb fis `bbe i guaf krbitbr ldaus me
rbabet ybirs de rbsucts, ybt tfbrb rbgimes i cdek
hmstieab td kd td hbgdestritb i rbic afiekb me
gbisuri`cb dutadgbs ieh mgpiats. @baiusb tfb
vdcugb dl @ien cbehmek ms bxpbatbh td mearbisb
me rbspdesb td tfb aurrbet lmeieamic armsms, tfms
ikbehi `badgbs icc tfb gdrb vmtic.
Bevmrdegbetic sustimei`mcmty ms deb dl tfb gdst
adgpbccmek irbis ldr urkbet iatmde ml hbvbcdp-
gbet rbsucts irb td `b hbcmvbrbh it tfb aduetry,
rbkmdeic, ieh kcd`ic cbvbcs. @ien suppdrt ldr tfb
bevmrdegbet fis pirtmiccy rbadvbrbh smeab
fmttmek i cdw pdmet me 0::0, ieh tfbrb irb beadur-
ikmek smkes tfit prdobat rbsucts, cdek `bcdw@ien-wmhb ivbrikbs, irb edw mgprdvmek ldr tfb
rdukfcy deb-quirtbr dl bevmrdegbetic prdobats
wfdsb rbsucts irb systbgitmaiccy trianbh. Ldr tfb
dtfbr tfrbb-quirtbrs dl prdobats, wfbrb bevmrde-
gbetic memtmitmvbs irb bg`bhhbh me dtfbr sbatdrs
(triespdrt, witbr ieh siemtitmde, ieh sd de), tfb
prdgmsb dl gimestrbigmek tfit bgbrkbh lrdg
tfb @iens 0::9 Bevmrdegbet Qtritbky fis edt
`bbe rbicmzbh.
Me sdgb mearbismekcy mgpdrtiet ieh meedvitmvb
irbis, suaf is tfb hbvbcdpgbet dl air`de luehs
ieh tfb bxtbesmde dl prdtbatmvb irbis td suppdrt
sustimei`cb ldrbstry ieh `mdhmvbrsmty, tfbrb irb
kips me dur nedwcbhkb dl wfbrb tfb @ien ms
ginmek fbihwiy ieh iafmbvmek rbic rbsucts.
Zrdkrbss wmcc hbpbeh de lir `bttbr gimestrbigmek
dl tfb bevmrdegbet metd @ien hbamsmdes iardss
sbatdrs ieh de ihhrbssmek mssubs dl me-fdusb
snmccs, still meabetmvbs, ieh bxtbreic hbgieh
adestrimets tfit mgpbhb @ien bllbatmvbebss.
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
20/180
I E E R I C P B \ M B [ D L H B \ B C D Z G B E X B L L B A X M \ B E B Q Q 0 : : =
x v m m m
Cddnmek ifbih, armsbs dllbr i rirb afieab ldr
triesldrgitmdeic afiekb, afiekb tfit ms bssbetmic
td iafmbvmek tfb vmsmde ieh pdtbetmic ldr @ien
suppdrt ldr bevmrdegbetic sustimei`mcmty. Xfb
aficcbekb ldr tfb @ien ms td mearbisb ittbetmde td
nby bevmrdegbetic irbis ieh td liamcmtitb gdrb
bllbatmvb hbvbcdpgbet dutadgbs y cbvbrikmek mts
nedwcbhkb, lmeieamic rbsdurabs, ieh adevbemek
iutfdrmty.
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
21/180
Xfb rmsn, dl adursb, ms tfit tfb @iens bllbatmvb-
ebss is gbisurbh `y MBK me mts bvicuitmdes giy
`b tinbe dut dl tfb adetbxt dl tfb aficcbekbs
mefbrbet me hbvbcdpgbet issmstieab dr adgpirbh
iardss ikbeambs wmtf cbss strdek bvicuitmde
lueatmdes. Xfb IPHB hmllbrs lrdg gdst MBK
dutputs me tfit mt hriws de i wmhb riekb dl bvicui-
tmvb lmehmeks ieh prdvmhbs i suggiry dvbrvmbw.@baiusb dl tfb eiturb dl tfb IPHB, mt hdbs edt
ginb spbamlma rbadggbehitmdes ldr gieikb-
gbet ieh hdbs edt bcmamt spbamlma gieikbgbet
rbspdesbs td mssubs rimsbh me tfb hdaugbet.
Fdwbvbr, gieikbgbet lmehs mt mgpdrtiet td
prdvmhb mts vmbws de IPHB lmehmeks ieh td kmvb ie
dvbrvmbw dl i sbt dl nby gieikbgbet iatmdes tfit
irb hmrbatcy rbcbviet td tfdsb lmehmeks.
Drkiemzitmde dl tfb Adggbets. Xfms edtb lmrst
prdvmhbs adggbets de tfb lmehmeks ieh sukkbs-
tmdes de tfb @iens dvbricc pbrldrgieab me pirt M
dl tfb IPHB. Mt tfbe rbspdehs td wfit MBK puts
ldrwirh me pirt MM de tfb spbamic tdpma ldr tfms
ybir, sustimei`cb hbvbcdpgbet. Xfb lmeic sbatmde
dl tfb edtb prdvmhbs i `rmbl sbt dl adeacusmdes.
Xrianmek @ien ZbrldrgieabGieikbgbet ms beadurikbh td edtb tfb rb`dueh
me tfb quicmty dl @ien-suppdrtbh dpbritmdes
rbpdrtbh `y MBK, wmtf 69 pbrabet dl bxmtmek
prdobats me lmsaic ybir 0::6 ritbh is sitmsliatdry
(gdhbritbcy sitmsliatdry, sitmsliatdry, dr fmkfcy
sitmsliatdry) me tbrgs dl gbbtmek hbvbcdpgbet
d`obatmvbs, bxabbhmek gieikbgbets tirkbt dl 6:
pbrabet. Gieikbgbet icsd edtbs tfit tfb IPHB
adelmrgs tfb adetmeumek uehbrcymek pdsmtmvb
trbeh me tfb quicmty dl tfb dpbritmdes suppdrtbh
`y tfb @ien. Xfb IPHB kdbs `ian td 9==1 td cddnit tfb bvdcutmde dl @ien pbrldrgieab> acbircy, tfb
@ien dl tdhiy ms vbry hmllbrbet lrdg tfb @ien me
9==1. Xfb ldaus de rbsucts ms guaf gdrb abetric
edw. Is ie bxigpcb, gdemtdrmek ieh bvicuitmde
(G&B) ms i nby bcbgbet ldr gdemtdrmek prdobats
td iafmbvb rbsucts, ieh tfb IPHB amtbs i wbinebss
me @ien G&B ldr prdobats bxmtmek tfb pdrtldcmd me
lmsaic ybirs 0::; ieh 0::6, prdobats tfit de
ivbrikb betbrbh tfb pdrtldcmd bircy me tfms
hbaihb. Gdrb rbabet bxpbrmbeab ms hmllbrbet? 2=
pbrabet dl ebw MHI prdobats tfit lmcbh supbrvm-
smde rbpdrts ldr tfb lmrst tmgb me lmsaic 0::= fih
`isbcmeb hiti ldr icc prdobat hbvbcdpgbet
dutadgb mehmaitdrs ieh 62 pbrabet fih `isbcmeb
hiti ldr it cbist deb. Gieikbgbet bxpbats i
smkemlmaiet afiekb me MBK lmehmeks de G&B wfbe
tfbsb dpbritmdes bxmt tfb pdrtldcmd me tfb adgmek
ybirs. Fdwbvbr, mt ms mgpdrtiet tfit tfb @ien hd
gdrb td ihipt mts wdrn td bei`cb mt td `b gdrb
ikmcb ieh meedvitmvb me suppdrtmek tfb ebbhs dl
`drrdwmek aduetrmbs, me pirtmaucir piymek gdrb
G
ieikbgbet wbcadgbs tfb lmehmeks me tfb 0::=Ieeuic Pbvmbw dl Hb-
vbcdpgbet Bllbatmvbebss (IPHB) `y tfb Mehbpbehbet Bvicuitmde
Krdup (MBK). Mt ms i krbit strbektf dl tfb @ien tfit mt su`obats mtsbcl
td mehbpbehbet bvicuitmde ieh usbs tfb lmehmeks td befieab mts hbvbcdpgbetbllbatmvbebss `y cbiremek lrdg bxpbrmbeab ieh tfit MBK adesmstbetcy riens is
tfb `beafgirn ldr mehbpbehbet bvicuitmde me tfb hbvbcdpgbet lmbch.
Gieikbgbet Adggbets
x m x
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
22/180
ittbetmde td mgpcbgbetitmde ieh td ihiptmek
suppdrt qumancy me rbspdesb td ebw meldrgitmde
dr afiekmek amraugstieabs ieh td mgprdvb
pbrldrgieab me cikkmek Pbkmdes ieh sbatdrs.
Ihhrbssmek Cdek-Qtiehmek Mssubstfb @iens
Pbsucts-Ldausbh Pbldrg Blldrts
Xd ihhrbss tfb aficcbekbs dl i afiekmek @ien ieh
td tinb de cdek-stiehmek mssubs, meacuhmek tfdsb
mhbetmlmbh me tfb IPHB, gieikbgbet fis ie
bxtbesmvb rbsucts-ldausbh rbspdesb blldrt uehbr
wiy iardss vmrtuiccy tfb wfdcb spbatrug dl @ien
dpbritmdeic suppdrtlrdg Aduetry Issmstieab
Qtritbkmbs (AIQs) td mevbstgbet cbehmek, hbvbcdp-
gbet pdcmay dpbritmdes, ieh ieicytma ieh ihvmsdry
iatmvmtmbs (III).
AIQs. Hurmek lmsaic 0:9: tfb @ien wmcc mgpcbgbet
i sbt dl iatmdes `isbh de i rbabet rbvmbw dl
bxpbrmbeab wmtf rbsucts-`isbh AIQs. Xfbsb
iatmdes meacuhb kumhieab de fdw td ritb @ien
pbrldrgieab uehbr tfb prbabhmek AIQ ieh de
prbpirmek rbsucts lrigbwdrns ldr ebw AIQs. Xfb
AIQ Zrdkrbss Pbpdrt prdabss wmcc `b strbektf-
bebh, prdvmhmek ie bircy dppdrtuemty ldr kiukmek
prdkrbss ieh tfb pdtbetmic ebbh ldr ihoustgbets.
Kumhieab fis icrbihy `bbe mssubh de issbssmek
aduetry stitmstmaic aipiamtyie mssub amtbh `yMBK is mgpdrtiet ldr tfb rbsucts ikbehi.
Xfb Mevbstgbet Cbehmek Pbldrg Zrdkrig. Qbvbric dl
tfb mssubs rimsbh `y tfb IPHB irb debs tfit
gieikbgbet ms ihhrbssmek tfrdukf mevbstgbet
cbehmek rbldrg ([drch @ien 0::=). Qpbamlmaiccy,
tfbsb rbldrgs irb imgbh it ihiptmek ieh hmllbr-
betmitmek tfb mevbstgbet cbehmek gdhbc td `bttbr
lmt tfb nmeh dl suppdrt tfit tfb @ien prdvmhbs me
sbatdrs suaf is fbictf ieh pu`cma sbatdr gieikb-
gbet, wfbrb tfbrb ms ed bekmebbrmek `cubprmet
dr wiy td aicaucitb i arbhm`cb bxpbatbh badedgma
ritb dl rbture, `ut i ebbh ldr i gdrb lcbxm`cb
hbsmke ieh gdrb bgpfisms de suppdrt td
pirtebrs hurmek mgpcbgbetitmde. Xfb abetric
tbebt dl tfb rbldrgs ms i strdekbr ldaus de i
acbircy hblmebh sbt dl rbsucts tfb prdobat ms
hbsmkebh td iafmbvb (wmtf wbcc-hblmebh gdemtdr-
mek mehmaitdrs), adg`mebh wmtf tfb mhbetmlmaitmde
dl tfb nby rmsns td iafmbvmek tfdsb d`obatmvbs ieh
i rbkucir rbbvicuitmde dl tfbsb rmsns tfrdukfdut
mgpcbgbetitmde. Xfdsb afiekbs, wfmaf wmcc
ldaus gieikbgbet ieh still ittbetmde gdrb de
mgpcbgbetitmde, irb hbsmkebh td dvbradgb tfb
prd`cbg dl dvbrdptmgmsg amtbh `y MBK.
Zrdobat Pbstruaturmek. MBK amtbs tfb mssub dl ie
ippirbet rbcuatieab td rbstruaturb prdobats tfit
irb edt gbbtmek hbvbcdpgbet d`obatmvbs. I nby
pirt dl mevbstgbet cbehmek rbldrg ms i rbwdrnmek
dl tfb adelusmek kumhbcmebs ldr prdobat rbstrua-
turmek, wfmaf still amtb is i giodr liatdr me
hbciybh rbstruaturmeks. @ien bxbautmvb hmrbatdrs
wmcc `b isnbh me tfb adgmek gdetfs td ipprdvb i
smgpcmlmbh rbstruaturmek prdabss.
Hbvbcdpgbet Zdcmay Dpbritmdes. Xfb lrigbwdrn ldr
hbvbcdpgbet pdcmay dpbritmdes wis gdhbremzbh
me lmsaic 0::2. Xd hitb, rbsucts lrdg sbcl- ieh
mehbpbehbet bvicuitmde fivb `bbe rd`ust (is
rbadelmrgbh me tfb IPHB). Pbabet sbcl-bvicuitmde
fis mhbetmlmbh wiys td lurtfbr strbektfbe
pbrldrgieab. Me lmsaic 0:9:, gieikbgbet wmcc
prdvmhb strdekbr kumhieab td still de suppdrtmek
`drrdwbrs de tfb hbsmke dl hbvbcdpgbet pdcmay
d`obatmvbs (meacuhmek me tfb adetbxt dl odmet
`uhkbt suppdrt wmtf dtfbr hdedrs) ldr hbvbcdp-
gbet pdcmay dpbritmdes ieh me adesdcmhitmek kddh
priatmab de pdvbrty ieh sdamic mgpiat ieicysms.
Adst-@bebt Ieicysms ieh Mgpiat Bvicuitmde. Xfb
IPHB amtbs tfb hbarbisbh usb dl adst-`beblmt
ieicysms ieh tfb pdtbetmic dl mgpiat bvicuitmde.
Gieikbgbet cddns ldrwirh td wdrnmek wmtf MBK
de mts upadgmek me-hbptf rbvmbw, edti`cy de
wfbe adst-`beblmt ieicysms ms gdst ipprdprmitb
ieh fdw usbluc mt ms rbcitmvb td dr icdek wmtf
ictbreitmvb tddcs ldr ipprimsic, gdemtdrmek, ieh
bvicuitmde iardss tfb spbatrug dl mevbstgbet
prdobats suppdrtbh `y tfb @ien. Gieikbgbet
ikrbbs wmtf MBK tfit mgpiat bvicuitmde aie `b i
vicui`cb tddc ieh fis rbabetcy bxpiehbh mts usb
iardss sbatdrs ieh Pbkmdes me dpbritmdes wfbrb
mt ms gdst ipprdprmitb ieh adst-bllbatmvb ieh
dwebh `y tfb acmbet aduetry. Ikime, gieikbgbet
cddns ldrwirh td wdrnmek wmtf MBK me 0:9: de mts
mgpiat bvicuitmde ieicysms.
III. Gieikbgbet ms tinmek de rbldrgs td mts
rbsucts lrigbwdrn ldr III me tfb adetbxt dl mts
x x
I E E R I C P B \ M B [ D L H B \ B C D Z G B E X B L L B A X M \ B E B Q Q 0 : : =
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
23/180
wdrn de i ebw nedwcbhkb ikbehi. Xfb ipprdiaf
ms td cddn it III me i gdrb prdkriggitma lisfmde,
is dppdsbh td mehmvmhuic prdhuats. Gieikbgbet
ms iatmvbcy wdrnmek wmtf MBK de tfb ebw III
rbsucts lrigbwdrn, `baiusb i adggde ipprdiafieh uehbrstiehmek ms abetric td strdek sbcl- ieh
mehbpbehbet bvicuitmde. Xfbsb irb sbqubeabh ldr
citbr me tfb rbldrg prdkrig tmgbti`cb. (Me kbebric,
gieikbgbet wduch edtb tfb mgpdrtieab dl
sbqubeamek tfbsb rbldrgs td nbbp tfbg wmtfme
stillmek ieh uhkbt adestrimets.)
Xfb Pbsucts Ikbehi Kdmek Ldrwirh. Xd adesdcmhitb
icc dl tfb i`dvb, gieikbgbet ms wdrnmek td
bsti`cmsf i rbsucts gdemtdrmek pcitldrg td
strbektfbe gdemtdrmek ieh rbpdrtmek de tfb
dutadgbs dl @ien-suppdrtbh iatmvmtmbs. Deb nby
stbp ms tfb ihdptmde dl adrb sbatdr mehmaitdrsi
lbw stiehirhmzbh mehmaitdrs ldr biaf sbatdr tfit
irb adgpiri`cb ieh ikkrbki`cb it tfb mestmtu-
tmdeic, aduetry, dr sbatdr cbvbc, wfmaf wmcc liamcm-
titb rbpdrtmek de iatmvmty dutputs ieh dutadgbs,
bspbamiccy uehbr tfb MHI Pbsucts Gbisurbgbet
Qystbg (MHI PGQ). Xfb adrb mehmaitdrs ldr tfb
rdih triespdrt, witbr suppcy, bhuaitmde, ieh
fbictf sbatdrs wbrb ciueafbh me Oucy, tdkbtfbr
wmtf ie mgprdvbh hiti systbg ldr adccbatmek ieh
trianmek quietmtitmvb hiti. Adrb mehmaitdrs ldrdtfbr sbatdrs (ur`ie, bevmrdegbet, gmard, sgicc,
ieh gbhmug betbrprmsbs, ieh sd de) irb icsd
uehbr prbpiritmde. Xfbsb mehmaitdrs (gimecy
dutput ieh dutadgb mehmaitdrs ipprdprmitb ldr
trianmek it tfb prdobat cbvbc), tdkbtfbr wmtf tfb
aduetry- dr sbatdr-cbvbc mehmaitdrs ivimci`cb lrdg
dtfbr sdurabs (ldr bxigpcb, Xmbr 9 mehmaitdrs),
wmcc mgprdvb dur i`mcmty td ldaus de rbsucts. Me
ihhmtmde, tfb ebw rbsucts pcitldrg dllbrs still ieh
gieikbrs tddcs ldr gdemtdrmek aduetry pdrtldcmd
rbsucts ieh ldr ginmek gdrb stritbkma ieh
bllbatmvb usb dl mgpiat bvicuitmdes wfbrb tfbsb
irb ipprdprmitb. MHI it [drn eirritmvbs irb icsd
`bmek bxpiehbh, wmtf ie bgpfisms de tfbgitma
ieh aduetry cbvbc rmbls.
Aduetry Aipiamty. Gieikbgbet ikrbbs wmtf MBK
de tfb mgpdrtieab dl `umchmek aduetry G&B
aipiamty, `dtf is i kdic me mtsbcl ieh td bei`cb us
td `bttbr uehbrstieh dur dwe hbvbcdpgbet
bllbatmvbebss. Ldr bxigpcb, me pirtebrsfmp wmtf
dtfbr hdedrs, tfb @ien ms ciueafmek i ebw Qtitms-
tmas ldr Pbsucts Liamcmty td fbcp tfb pddrbst
aduetrmbs `umch aipiamty td mearbisb tfb ivimci`mc-
mty dl hbvbcdpgbet stitmstmas, stirtmek wmtf tfdsb
tfit irb gdst urkbetcy ebbhbh ldr tfb mgpcbgbe-titmde dl stritbkmbs ldr pdvbrty rbhuatmde ieh
eitmdeic hbvbcdpgbet. Gdrb `rdihcy, aduetry
aipiamty `umchmek fis icwiys `bbe pirt dl @ien
iatmvmtmbs, bspbamiccy smeab Iaari> ldr bxigpcb, tfb
@ien-wmhb bgpfisms de krbitbr usb dl aduetry
systbgs icsd meacuhbs i krbitbr rbcmieab de ieh
hbvbcdpgbet dl aduetry G&B systbgs. (MBK ms
icsd iatmvb me tfms irbi tfrdukf iatmvmtmbs td `umch
bvicuitmde aipiamty). Fdwbvbr, wb rbadkemzb tfit
tfms ms i cdekbr-tbrg blldrt.
Cikkmek Pbkmdes ieh Qbatdrs
MBK, wfmcb adggbehmek tfb @ien de tfb
mearbisb me dpbritmdeic quicmty, edtbs i fmstdry dl
pddr pbrldrgieab me abrtime Pbkmdes ieh
sbatdrs. [drn ms dekdmek td ihhrbss tfms mssub. Me
pirtmaucir, gieikbgbet fis tinbe de twd, tfb
Ilrmai Pbkmde ieh tfb fbictf sbatdr, is i prmdrmty.
Xfb Ilrmai Pbkmdes Yuicmty Befieabgbet Zrdkrig.
Xd mgprdvb dutadgbs dl tfb dpbritmdes mt
suppdrts, tfb Ilrmai Pbkmde fis tinbe tfb
ldccdwmek iatmdes?
(m) Pbstruaturmek tfb wbinbst-pbrldrgmek pdrt-
ldcmds (FM\/IMHQ, rbkmdeic metbkritmde, lrikmcb
stitbs)
(mm) Zrdvmhmek oust-me-tmgb dpbritmdes ieh G&B
suppdrt td aduetry ieh tisn tbigs td mg-
prdvb tfb rbsucts lrigbwdrns ieh besurb bt-
tbr adgpcmieab wmtf MHI92 gdemtdrmek
rbqumrbgbets
(mmm) Xrimemek tisn tbig cbihbrs me tfb hbvbcdpgbet
dl rbsucts-ldausbh dpbritmdes ieh prdkrigs
ieh rbsucts-`isbh G&B systbgs
(mv) Hbvbcdpmek sbatdr rbsucts afimes td fbcp mg-
prdvb tfb uehbrcymek aiusic cdkma me hbsmkemek
dpbritmdes
(v) Hbvbcdpmek tfb Ilrmai Pbsucts Gdemtdrmek Qys-
tbg (IPGQ), wfmaf ms edw `bmek rdccbh dut
is i @ienwmhb systbg td trian rbsucts ldr MHI
arbhmts. Xfb IPGQ betimcs tfb hbvbcdpgbet
dl acbir ieh rbicmstma dutadgb-`isbh prdobat
hbvbcdpgbet d`obatmvbs is wbcc is stiehirh-
G I E I K B G B E X A D G G B E X Q
x x m
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
24/180
mzbh ieh gbisuri`cb mehmaitdrs. Mt wmcc fir-
gdemzb ieh liamcmtitb rbsucts rbpdrtmek.
Xfb IPHB prdvmhbs ie bircy mehmaitdr dl prdkrbss.
Mt amtbs lmsaic 0::6 hiti sfdwmek ;; pbrabet dlprdobats me tfb Ilrmai Pbkmde is sitmsliatdry
(gdhbritbcy sitmsliatdry, sitmsliatdry, dr fmkfcy
sitmsliatdry) me tbrgs dl gbbtmek tfbmr hbvbcdp-
gbet d`obatmvbs, up sfirpcy lrdg lmsaic 0::;.
Xfb Fbictf Qbatdr. Xfb @iens Fbictf Ebtwdrn fis
tinbe iatmde td mgprdvb tfb dutadgbs dl aduetry
fbictf sbatdr dpbritmdes mt suppdrts. @isbh de
tfb lmehmeks dl ie MBK bvicuitmde dl tfb fbictf
sbatdr, mt hbvbcdpbh i pdrtldcmd-quicmty mgprdvb-
gbet pcie ieh ciueafbh mt me lmsaic 0::=. Mt ms
rbkucircy gdemtdrbh `y sbemdr gieikbgbet td
besurb tfit mt stiys de trian.
Xfb Gieikbgbet Iatmde Pbadrh (GIP)
Is edtbh i`dvb, gieikbgbet vicubs mehbpbeh-
bet bvicuitmde ieh tinbs mt vbry sbrmduscy. Is i
rbsuct, mt tinbs sbrmduscy tfb rbadggbehitmdes
tfit adgb dut dl MBK bvicuitmdes. Icc Hrilt
Gieikbgbet Pbspdesbs irb hmsaussbh `y
bxbautmvb hmrbatdrs (edrgiccy it tfb @dirhs
Adggmttbb de Hbvbcdpgbet Bllbatmvbebss
ADHB). Xfbsb hdaugbets meacuhb ie memtmic GIPtfit sbts dut wfit gieikbgbet adggmts td hd is
i rbsuct dl tfb MBK rbadggbehitmdes. Kmvbe tfb
mgpdrtieab dl tfbsb adggmtgbets, wfmaf dltbe
fivb rbsdurab mgpcmaitmdes, tfby irb vbttbh ieh
acbirbh `y sbemdr gieikbgbet. Gieikbgbet
tfbe rbvmsbs tfbsb adggmtgbets me cmkft dl tfb
ADHB hmsaussmde. Gieikbgbet rbpdrts ieeuiccy
td MBK de prdkrbss ikimest mts adggmtgbets.
[fmcb tfms systbg ms vicui cb ieh ebabssiry is ie
iaadueti`mcmty tddc, gieikbgbet ikrbbs wmtf MBK
tfit mt ms tmgb ldr i rbbvicuitmde.
Zdssm`cb Mgprdvbgbets td tfb GIP. Xfb `mkkbst
mssub ms tfit me mts ieeuic gdemtdrmek dl prdkrbss,
MBK stirts wmtf mts rbadggbehitmdes, ritfbr tfie
wmtf tfb pirt dl tfb gitrmx tfit sbts dut
gieikbgbets adggmtgbetstfb iatmdes
gieikbgbet ikrbbh td uehbrtinb ieh ldr wfmaf
mt aie `b fbch iaadueti`cb. Xfit ipprdiaf dltbe
cbihs td hmsikrbbgbets dvbr ritmeks de prdkrbss,
edti`cy wfbe gieikbgbet ikrbbh decy pirtmiccy
wmtf i rbadggbehitmde, dr wfbe, is me tfb aisb
dl tfb MBK bvicuitmde dl ieicytma ieh ihvmsdry
sbrvmabs, gieikbgbet edtbh tfit mt wduch ebbh
td sbqubeab giey dl tfb iatmdes citbr me tfb
dvbricc rbldrg blldrt. Iedtfbr nby mssub ms tfbsfbbr eug`br dl rbadggbehitmdes ieh su`rba-
dggbehitmdes. Xfb aurrbet GIP adetimes
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
25/180
bevmrdegbetic gimestrbigmek rbsucts ieh wmcc icsd
issbss td wfit bxtbet, iltbr decy twd ybirs, tfb
gbrkbr dl tfb twd @ien ebtwdrns metd tfb Qustime-
i`cb Hbvbcdpgbet Ebtwdrn ms cbihmek td strdekbr
gimestrbigmek dutadgbs. Gieikbgbet ms adetme-umek td strbektfbe tfb i`mcmty dl still me tfb irbis
dl ldrbstry, eituric rbsdurab gieikbgbet, ieh
bebrky td hbcmvbr metbkritbh acmgitb afiekb
`isbh ihvmab td acmbets `y suppdrtmek cbiremek
gdhucbs de acmgitb afiekbrbcitbh tddcs ieh
gbafiemsgs, suaf is badsystbg-`isbh ihiptitmde
ieh Pbhuamek Bgmssmdes lrdg Hbldrbstitmde ieh
Hbkrihitmde (PBHH).
Gbisurmek ieh Iafmbvmek Zrdobat, Aduetry, ieh
Kcd`ic Pbsucts. Xfb IPHB bgpfismzbs tfit me tfb
ebw Bevmrdegbet Qtritbky, tfb @ien sfduch
meacuhb i ldaus de `bttbr gdemtdrmek ieh rbpdrt-
mek dl bevmrdegbetic dutadgbs it tfb prdobat
ieh aduetry cbvbcs. Me tfb MHI92 PGQ bxbramsb,
gieikbgbet ms ginmek prdkrbss me arbitmek
bevmrdegbetic dutadgb mehmaitdrs ldr biaf
bevmrdegbetic su`tfbgb, icc dl wfmaf wmcc `b
ikkrbkitbh iardss sbatdrs. Aduetry-cbvbc bevmrde-
gbetic rbpdrtmek ms uehbr hbvbcdpgbet me i
krbbe hiti sbts rbpdrtmek ldrgit. Gieikbgbet
ikrbbs de tfb mgpdrtieab dl bxpiehmek bevmrde-
gbetic pirtebrsfmps, bspbamiccy ldr strbektfbe-mek bevmrdegbetic kdvbreieab, iardss icc
rbcbviet mestmtutmdeic iatdrs, bspbamiccy it tfb
aduetry cbvbc. Xd tfms beh, tfb prbpiritmde dl tfb
Bevmrdegbet Qtritbky 0:9: wmcc mevdcvb bxtbesmvb
adesuctitmdes wmtf suaf bxtbreic stinbfdchbrs is
kdvbregbets, tfb prmvitb sbatdr, amvmc sdambty, ieh
hbvbcdpgbet pirtebrs. Xfb adesuctitmdes wmcc
sbbn td mhbetmly nby irbis me wfmaf tfb [drch
@ien Krdup sfduch bekikb td suppdrt mts acmbets
me gdrb bllbatmvbcy ihhrbssmek bevmrdegbetic
prmdrmtmbs ieh gdvmek tdwirh krbitbr bevmrde-
gbetic sustimei`mcmty ieh wmcc fbcp meldrg tfb
hbvbcdpgbet dl i rbsucts lrigbwdrn ldr gbisur-mek prdkrbss me prmdrmty irbis. Me ihhmtmde, tfb
stritbky wmcc ihhrbss fdw tfb [drch @ien Krdup
aie `bttbr suppdrt acmbet aduetrmbs me tfbmr
blldrts td strbektfbe tfb bevmrdegbetic mestmtu-
tmdes ieh kdvbreieab gbafiemsgs tfit irb
aruamic ldr sustimei`cb hbvbcdpgbet.
AdeacusmdesGieikbgbet ipprbamitbs tfit su`gmttmek tfb
@ien td tfb cbiremek ieh iaadueti`mcmty hmsampcmeb
dl mehbpbehbet bvicuitmde ms i strbektf tfit sbts
mt ipirt lrdg giey dtfbr hbvbcdpgbet mestmtu-
tmdes, edti`cy kmvbe MBKs ianedwcbhkbh stiehmek
is `bst igdek mts pbbrs. Mt ms adelmhbet tfit tfb
`beblmts irb wdrtf tfb adsts dl `bmek fbch td tfms
fmkf stiehirh, wmtf tfb rbsuctmek gmsuehbrstieh-
meks tfit aie irmsb. Bvbe me i `icieabh rbpdrt cmnb
tfms deb, tfb pdsmtmvb dutadgbs rmsn `bmek
dvbrcddnbh rbcitmvb td tfb cbss pdsmtmvb lmehmeks.
Gieikbgbet iaabpts tfb dvbricc gbssikb lrdg
tfb IPHBi lmehmek dl kbebriccy kddh ieh
mgprdvmek quicmty me tfb dpbritmdes tfb @ien
suppdrts, `ut icsd i strdek aficcbekb td hd bvbe`bttbr, edti`cy me suppdrtmek i rbsucts aucturb me
pirtebr aduetrmbs ieh me tfb @ien ieh strbektf-
bemek @ien suppdrt ldr sustimei`cb hbvbcdpgbet.
Xfbsb irb prmdrmtmbs tfit gieikbgbet fis tinbe
de me mts lmsaic 0:9: wdrn prdkrig ieh `bydeh,
edti`cy me i sbt dl iatmdes tfit ihhrbss sdgb cdek-
stiehmek mssubs ldueh `y `dtf sbcl- ieh
mehbpbehbet bvicuitmde.
G I E I K B G B E X A D G G B E X Q
x x m m m
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
26/180
Zbdpcb kitfbrbh uehbr i trbb, Emkbrmi. Zfdtd y Aurt Airebgirn, adurtbsy dl tfb [drch @ien
Zfdtd Cm`riry.
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
27/180x x v
Zirt M? Xrianmek @ien Zbrldrgieab
Dvbricc Quggiry
Xfb hmsaussmde ldccdwbh tfb prdpdsbh Afimrgies
Mssubs Edtb de hbvbcdpgbet dutadgbs dl @iensuppdrt> mgpcbgbetitmde dl tfb rbsucts ikbehi>
ieh stitus dl tfb Gieikbgbet Iatmde Pbadrh
(GIP). Lmrst, de hbvbcdpgbet dutadgbs, tfb
Adggmttbb tddn edtb dl tfb @iens upwirh
pbrldrgieab rbadrh. Hurmek tfb hmsaussmde sdgb
qubstmdes wbrb rimsbh de MBKs ritmek systbg ieh
gbtfdhdcdkmbs. Qbadeh, de tfb rbsucts ikbehi,
tfb Adggmttbb strbssbh tfb ebbh ldr tfb @ien td
fivb i rblmebh ieh smgpcb bvicuitmde gdhbc>
ihbquitb meabetmvbs td gdemtdr hbvbcdpgbet
rbsucts> adst-`beblmt ieicysms wfbrb ipprdprmitb is
i `isms ldr prdobat hbamsmdes> ieh ipprdprmitb
stillmek ieh lmeieamic rbsdurabs. Xfmrh, tfb ebbh td
mgprdvb tfb adetbxt ieh struaturb dl tfb GIP
rbsdeitbh igdek giey spbinbrs kmvbe tfb
hbacmeb me tfb cbvbc dl ihdptmde dl MBK
rbadggbehitmdes. Xd befieab tfb ldccdw-up dl
MBK rbadggbehitmdes, mt wis sukkbstbh tfit
ADHB sfduch pciy i adestruatmvb rdcb wfbrb
hmllbrbeabs dl dpmemde bgbrkb `btwbbe MBK ieh
gieikbgbet de spbamlma rbadggbehitmdes. Me
ihhmtmde, gbg`brs bcmbvbh tfit MBK ieh gieikb-
gbet sfduch wdrn tdkbtfbr de wiys td mgprdvb
tfb aurrbet GIP struaturb. Dvbricc, tfb Adggmt-
tbb lbct tfit tfb IPHB is wbcc is dtfbr MBK rbvmbws
prdvmhb i vicui`cb adetrm`utmde td ADHBsdvbrsmkft rdcb.
Pbadggbehitmdes ieh Ebxt Qtbps
Xd befieab tfb mgpcbgbetitmde dl tfb rbsucts
ikbehi, ADHB rbadggbehbh tfb ldccdwmek?
Qtrbektfbe gbisurbgbet blldrts it tfb prdobat,
sbatdr, ieh aduetry cbvbcs.
Mgprdvb addrhmeitmde `btwbbe MBK ieh gie-
ikbgbet de tfb hbsmke dl ie bllbatmvb [drch
@ien Krdup ipprdiaf.
Ebxt stbps irb?
Xfb IPHB wmcc `b adesmhbrbh `y tfb @dirh de
Qbptbg`br 9:, 0::=.
I ADHB gbbtmek de MBK gbtfdhdcdkmbs wmcc
`b safbhucbh me hub adursb.
MBK wmcc su`gmt td ADHB dr ADHB Qu`-
adggmttbb ie bvicuitmde de badedgma
ieicysms me prdobats me Giraf 0:9:.
Afimrpbrsdes Adggbets?
Adggmttbb de HbvbcdpgbetBllbatmvbebss (ADHB)
De Oucy 92, 0::=, tfb Adggmttbb de Hbvbcdpgbet Bllbatmvbebss gbt td
adesmhbr tfbIeeuic Pbvmbw dl Hbvbcdpgbet Bllbatmvbebss (IPHB) 0::=?Iafmbvmek Qustimei`cb Hbvbcdpgbet, prbpirbh `y tfb Mehbpbehbet
Bvicuitmde Krdup (MBK), tdkbtfbr wmtf Hrilt Gieikbgbet Adggbets. Xfms rb-
pdrt td tfb @dirh ldccdws tfb struaturb dl tfb rbpdrt pirt M? Xrianmek @ien
Zbrldrgieab, ieh pirt MM? Iafmbvmek Qustimei`cb Hbvbcdpgbet.
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
28/180
I E E R I C P B \ M B [ D L H B \ B C D Z G B E X B L L B A X M \ B E B Q Q 0 : : =
x x v m
Ldr ebxt ybir, ADHB prdpdsbh adesdcmhit-
mek tfb hmsaussmde dl MBKs IPHB tdkbtfbr
wmtf tfb Ieeuic Pbpdrt de Zdrtldcmd Zbr-
ldrgieab (IPZZ) prbpirbh `y Yuicmty Is-
surieab Krdup (YIK).
Xfb ldccdwmek gime mssubs wbrb rimsbh it tfb
gbbtmek?
Hbvbcdpgbet Dutadgbs. Gbg`brs adggbehbh
gieikbgbet de tfb upwirh trbeh me pbrldrg-
ieab me rbabet ybirs `ut edtbh tfit tfbrb wbrb
cikkmek Pbkmdes ieh sbatdrs ieh rddg ldr
mgprdvbgbet. Yubstmdes wbrb rimsbh de tfb
ihbquiay dl tfb aurrbet ritmek systbg, pirtmau-
circy ldr hmllmauct dr adgpcbx prdobats, ieh MBK
gbtfdhdcdkmbs. Xfbrb wbrb rbadggbehitmdes
ldr gdrb me-hbptf ieicysms dl aiusicmty td
uehbrstieh tfb mgpiat dl tfb @iens prdobats,
systbgitma bvicuitmde dl ieicytma ieh ihvmsdry
iatmvmtmbs (III), wfmaf giy adetrm`utb td tfb
nedwcbhkb ikbehi, ieh metbkritbh rbpdrtmek de
hbvbcdpgbet dutadgbs it tfb [drch @ien Krdup
cbvbc. MBK fmkfcmkftbh tfb hmllmauctmbs me fivmek
deb rbpdrt advbrmek tfb tfrbb mestmtutmdestfb
@ien, MLA, ieh GMKI.
Pbsucts Ikbehi. Gbg`brs tddn edtb dl tfb gmxbhrbadrhs mhbetmlmbh `y MBK me mgpcbgbetmek tfb
rbsucts ikbehi, wfmcb ianedwcbhkmek tfb
aficcbekbs dl rbldrgmek tfb gdemtdrmek ieh
bvicuitmde (G&B) systbg. Me tfms rbkirh, tfb
mgpdrtieab dl adst-`beblmt ieicysms dl prdobats,
wfmaf sfduch prdvmhb rbcbviet meldrgitmde ldr
hbamsmde ginmek, wis uehbrcmebh. Gbg`brs
qubrmbh tfb ihbquiay dl fugie ieh lmeieamic
rbsdurabs ieh tfb meabetmvb systbgs ldr still ieh
acmbets td strbektfbe G&B dl hbvbcdpgbet rbsucts.
Yubstmdes wbrb icsd rimsbh de fdw td gbisurb
tfb bllbatmvbebss dl tfb @iens issmstieab me
rbcitmde td dtfbr liatdrs (suaf is aduetry amraug-
stieabs) it tfb prdobat ieh aduetry cbvbcs> fdw td
`b sbcbatmvb ieh adesdcmhitb G&B blldrts> ieh fdw
td strbektfbe iaadueti`mcmty wfmcb ihhrbssmek
dvbrdptmgmsg me rbpdrtmek prdobat pbrldrgieab
hurmek mgpcbgbetitmde.
GIP. Gbg`brs rimsbh adeabres i`dut tfb
hbacmeb me tfb cbvbc dl ihdptmde dl MBK
rbadggbehitmdes. Me tfms rbkirh, tfby strbssbh
tfb ebbh td bxigmeb fdw td mgprdvb tfb adetbet
ieh struaturb dl tfb GIP, issbss tfb rbcbvieab
ieh tmgmek, prmdrmtmzb rbadggbehitmdes, ieh
gdemtdr prdkrbss, ictfdukf deb spbinbraiutmdebh ikimest arbitmek ueebabssiry `urbiu-
ariay. Xd tfms beh, tfby rbadggbehbh tfit MBK
ieh gieikbgbet wdrn tdkbtfbr td befieab tfb
GIPs bllbatmvbebss. Me tfms rbkirh, sdgb
gbg`brs rimsbh qubstmdes i`dut ADHBs
dvbrsmkft rdcb, meacuhmek gdemtdrmek dl tfb GIP.
Dtfbr Mssubs. Xfbrb wbrb adggbets de tfb
mgpdrtieab dl rbadesmhbrmek tfb rdcb dl pirt MM dl
tfb IPHB, meacuhmek rbvmbwmek smgmcir bvicui-
tmdes uehbrtinbe `y dtfbr guctmcitbric ikbeambs
ieh rbadesmhbrmek tfb tfbgb sbcbatmde, dr
hrdppmek mt ictdkbtfbr.
Zirt MM? Iafmbvmek Qustimei`cbHbvbcdpgbet
Dvbricc Quggiry
Qdgb gbg`brs wdehbrbh wfit tfb vicub ihhbh
wis td hmsaussmek sustimei`cb hbvbcdpgbet is
pirt MM dl tfb IPHB, kmvbe tfb bxtbesmvb advbrikb
dl tfms tdpma `y MBK rbvmbws ieh gieikbgbet
rbpdrts hmsaussbh rbabetcy `y ADHB ieh tfb@dirh. MBK rbpcmbh tfit tfb afdmab wis i
rbspdesb td i @dirh rbqubst td cddn it rbabet MBK
rbpdrts de bevmrdegbet ieh syetfbsmzb tfbmr
lmehmeks bldrb gieikbgbets ebw bevmrdegbet
stritbky wis prbpirbh. Gbg`brs qubstmdebh tfb
rbic gbiemek dl gimestrbigmek bevmrdegbetic
wdrn ieh tfb ippcmaitmde dl bxmstmek tddcs. Qdgb
gbg`brs aiutmdebh ikimest dvbrbgpfismzmek
tfb tbesmde `btwbbe eitmdeic prdkrigs ieh
bevmrdegbet, is tfb cittbr icsd lbiturbs strdek
eitmdeic ieh cdaic hmgbesmdes. Xfby strbssbh tfb
mgpdrtieab dl hbvbcdpmek iwirbebss ieh
cbvbrikb de eitmdeic ieh cdaic mestrugbets ieh
pdcmambs. Xfby icsd qubrmbh MBKs lmehmeks i`dut
wbinebssbs me tfb systbg ieh cbss tfie
ihbquitb mgpcbgbetitmde dl gimestrbigmek
ieh gieikbgbets adggbet de tfb gbtfdhdc-
dky usbh td bvicuitb bevmrdegbetic
gimestrbigmek> tfit ms, usmek i sbadeh-`bst
mehmaitdr tfit rbcitbs prdobats wmtf ie
bevmrdegbetic tfbgb td sbatdr `dirh gippmek.
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
29/180x x v m m
A F I M P Z B P Q D E Q A D G G B E X Q ? A D G G M X X B B D E H B \ B C D Z G B E X B L B A X M \ B E B Q Q ( A D H B )
Pbadggbehitmdes ieh Ebxt Qtbps
Xfb Adggmttbb mevmtbh MBK td fivb prbcmgmeiry
adesuctitmde de tfb tfbgitma tdpma dl pirt MM dl
ebxt ybirs IPHB td kime i `rdihbr suppdrt ldr
tfb sbcbatbh dptmde.
Xfb ldccdwmek mssubs wbrb rimsbh me pirt MM dl tfb
gbbtmek?
Bevmrdegbetic Qustimei`mcmty. Qdgb gbg`brs
strbssbh tfb mgpdrtieab dl i hbgieh-hrmvbe
ipprdiaf ieh ihbquitb gbisurbgbet systbgs.
Xfby rimsbh qubstmdes i`dut fdw td metbkritb
eitmdeic prdkrigs ieh kcd`ic pu`cma kddhs ieh
sfdrt-tbrg ebbhs wmtf cdekbr-tbrg d`obatmvbs>
ieh fdw td dpbritmdeicmzb bevmrdegbetic pdcmambs
gdrb bllbatmvbcy. Me ihhmtmde, tfby uehbrsadrbh
tfb ardss- sbatdric eiturb dl bevmrdegbetic sup-
pdrt (ldr bxigpcb, de witbr, bebrky, ieh cieh
gieikbgbet).
@iens Pdcb. Gbg`brs lbct tfit tfb @ien sfduch
fivb ie metbkritbh ipprdiaf, stirtmek lrdg tfbprdobat adeabpt ieh hbsmke, td besurb i gdrb
bllbatmvb mgpcbgbetitmde dl bevmrdegbetic prdo-
bats. Me tfms rbkirh, mt wis uehbrcmebh tfit
wbinebssbs me still trimemek ieh meabetmvbs giy
mefm`mt tfb mgpiat dl @iens wdrn me tfms lmbch.
Drkiemzitmdeic Qtruaturb.I lbw gbg`brs rimsbh
adeabres i`dut MBKs lmehmek dl ie i`sbeab
dl bevmrdegbetic tfbgbs me fbictf prdobats,
wfmaf sbbgs td rblcbat pddr adgguemaitmde ieh
pirtebrsfmp `btwbbe tfb Qustimei`cb Hbvbcdp-
gbet Ebtwdrn ieh tfb Fugie Hbvbcdpgbet
Ebtwdrn.
Kmdvieem Gioedem, Afimrgie
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
30/180
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
31/180
Afiptbr 9
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
32/180
Qafddc`dys me Mehmi. Zfdtd y Aurt Airebgirn, adurtbsy dl tfb [drch @ien Zfdtd Cm`riry.
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
33/180
Dl adursb, mt ms hmllmauct td nedw ml ie mestmtutmde ms
iafmbvmek tiekm`cb rbsucts uecbss rbsucts irbgbisurbh ieh adgpirbh iardss ikbeambs,
sbatdrs, dr prdobats. Xfms ms wfy, ictfdukf
gbisurbgbet ieh bvicuitmde irb hucc tdpmas ldr
gdst pbdpcb, tfby irb it tfb fbirt dl ieswbrmek
wfbtfbr tfb lmeieabs irb `bmek triesldrgbh metd
iatmdes tfit ginb i hmllbrbeab me pbdpcbs cmvbs.
Xfms gittbr fis `bbe fdtcy hb`itbh hurmek tfb
aurrbet armsms ieh bgbrkbeay rbspdesbs. Afmebsb,
Igbrmaie, dr @rizmcmie amtmzbes wiet td nedw
wfbtfbr stmgucus luehs irb `bmek prdpbrcy usbh
ieh irb bllbatmvb me kbttmek tfb kcd`ic badedgy
krdwmek ikime. Xfb @iens list-trian cdies td
kdvbregbets irb smgmcircy uehbr sarutmey. Yuman
ieswbrs irb edt ivimci`cb `baiusb bvicuitmde
tinbs tmgb ieh ms, y mts eiturb, ianwirh cddnmek.
@ut cbiremek lrdg bvicuitmde aie dltbe kumhb
blldrts td mgprdvb rbsucts me tfb luturb.
I fmhhbe rmsn dl tfb sfdrt-tbrg lmeieamic armsms ms
tfit mt giy hmvbrt ittbetmde lrdg i vmtic bcbgbet dl
tfb hbvbcdpgbet ikbehi ieh i abetric aficcbekb
td kbttmek rbsucts? bevmrdegbetic sustimei`mcmty.Qdueh bevmrdegbetic stbwirhsfmp ms nedwe td b
pmvdtic ldr sustimei`cb hbvbcdpgbet ieh ms deb dl
dur krbitbst adccbatmvb aficcbekbs. Ebkcbatmek mt
giy pdsb tfb krbitbst tfrbit td hbvbcdpgbet `y
uerivbcmek kimes me krdwtf ieh pdvbrty rbhuatmde.
@ut iafmbvmek ieh gdemtdrmek bevmrdegbetic
rbsucts ms bxabbhmekcy adgpcbx `baiusb dl mts
ardss-sbatdric eiturb, mevdcvmek fbictf, melristrua-
turb, bhuaitmde, ieh bebrky, igdek dtfbr ade-
abres. Gimestrbigmek bevmrdegbetic wdrn ieh
trianmek rbsucts iardss suaf hmvbrsb @ien-
suppdrtbh metbrvbetmdes wis ie bxpcmamt d`obatmvb
dl tfb @iens 0::9 Bevmrdegbet Qtritbky ([drch
@ien 0::9). Fdwbvbr, tfms abetric stritbky dl
gimestrbigmek fis `bbe wbincy mgpcbgbetbh,
ieh eugbrdus metbreic ieh bxtbreic ldrabs fivb
adestrimebh tfb @iens i`mcmty td iafmbvb `bttbr
rbsucts.
Xfb gbtfdhs ieh systbgs ldr gbisurmek rbsucts
irb mgpbrlbat. Zrd`mek metd tfb rbpdrtmek `y imh
Xfms ybirs Ieeuic Pbvmbw dl Hbvbcdpgbet Bllbatmvbebss (IPHB) ms
i`dut iafmbvmek rbsucts lrdg @ien suppdrtms mt fippbemek, ieh fdw
hd wb nedw tfit mt ms4 Xfb sbiraf ldr hbvbcdpgbet rbsucts ms it tfb abe-
tbr dl tfb hb`itb dvbr imh bllbatmvbebss. Mt ms hrmvmek afiekbs me tfb metbrei-
tmdeic imh irafmtbaturb, meacuhmek i sfmlt iwiy lrdg guctmcitbric ikbeambs tdwirh
vbrtmaic luehs ieh birgirnmek dl issmstieabtfrdukf kcd`ic luehs, ede-
kdvbregbetic drkiemzitmdes (EKDs), ieh hdedr ikbeambs, is wbcc is bir-
girnbh guctmcitbric afieebcs tfit tixpiybrs ieh pfmcietfrdpmsts tfmen wmcc bei`cb
tfbmr gdeby td ymbch gdrb tiekm`cb rbsucts.9
Metrdhuatmde
1
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
34/180
8
I E E R I C P B \ M B [ D L H B \ B C D Z G B E X B L L B A X M \ B E B Q Q 0 : : =
ikbeambs, EKDs, ieh kcd`ic hbvbcdpgbet luehs
de wfit tfby fivb iaadgpcmsfbh, deb sdde lmehs
tfit tfbrb ms cmttcb prbamsmde i`dut fdw tfby
gbisurb tfbmr rbsucts ieh wfbtfbr tfb gbisurb-
gbet ms iaauritb, dr bvbe gbiemekluc. Xfms rbpdrtimgs td ihvieab hb`itb de tfb [drch @iens
adetrm`utmde me tfms irbi.
Xfb 0::= IPHB fis twd pirts. @dtf pirts issbss
@ien pbrldrgieab me ihvieamek hbvbcdpgbet
bllbatmvbebss tfrdukf hmllbrbet pbrldrgieab
cbesbs. Zirt M cddns lmrst it @ien pbrldrgieab usmek
adevbetmdeic trianmek gbisurbs. Xfb stdry ms
`rdihcy pdsmtmvb? pbrldrgieab, gbisurbh is tfb
sitmsliatdry iafmbvbgbet dl hbvbcdpgbet dut-
adgbs tfit irb tirkbtbh me @ien-suppdrtbh
prdobats, ms fmkf ieh fis bbe krihuiccy mgprdvmek
ldr tfb pist 92 ybirs. Zirt M tfbe bxigmebs blldrts
td mgprdvb pbrldrgieab hiti. Fbrb tfb prdkrbss
ms gmxbh? tfb aficcbekb dl triesldrgmek prdobat
gdemtdrmek ieh bvicuitmde (G&B) priatmabs metd
gbiemekluc tddcs ldr gieikbgbet ieh rbsdurab
iccdaitmde rbgimes hiuetmek. @ien-wmhb rbsucts
gbisurbgbet tddcs irb stmcc `bmek hbvbcdpbh ieh
fivb edt ybt `bbe tbstbh. Dtfbr pbrldrgieab
bvicuitmde tddcs (suaf is mgpiat bvicuitmde, adst-
beblmt ieicysms, ieh rbic-tmgb gdemtdrmek) ippbirtd `b usbh spdrihmaiccy, ictfdukf gdrb me-hbptf
issbssgbet ms dekdmek.
Zirt MM dllbrs ie issbssgbet dl @ien pbrldrgieab
me tfb armtmaic irbi dl sustimei`cb bevmrdegbetic
rbsucts, pirtmaucircy @ien suppdrt smeab 0::9. Fbrb
tdd tfb rbadrh ms gmxbh? tfb pdrtldcmd fis `bbe
krdwmek, ieh aiticytma irbis dl bxabccbeab ldr
bevmrdegbetic memtmitmvbs irb bvmhbet, `ut bxpbrm-
beab wmtf gimestrbigmek ieh gdemtdrmek rbsucts ms
wbin. Qbrmdus blldrts td gdvb tfb bevmrdegbetic
ikbehi ldrwirh ieh td fbcp hbcmvbr de tfb kcd`ic
fdpbs ieh ispmritmdes dl tfb 0::= Adpbefikbe
Quggmt wmcc fmekb me pirt de rbebwbh blldrts td
strbektfbe bevmrdegbetic gimestrbigmek ieh td
ihhrbss `dtf @ien ieh kdvbregbet hmsmeabetmvbs
td beadurikmek krbitbr ardss-sbatdr adcci`dritmde.
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
35/180
ZIPX M
Xrianmek @ien Zbrldrgieab
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
36/180
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
37/180
Afiptbr 0
Bvicuitmde Fmkfcmkfts
Zrdobat pbrldrgieab fis sfdwe
stbihy mgprdvbgbet dvbr tfb pist 92
ybirs.
Zrdobat pbrldrgieab rbadvbrbh me
0::6 td 69 pbrabet sitmsliatdry, hrmvbe
`y strdek pbrldrgieab me tries-
pdrtitmde ieh witbr ieh me Ilrmai,
Qdutf Ismi, ieh Citme Igbrmai.
Qdamic hbvbcdpgbet, bevmrdegbet,ur`ie hbvbcdpgbet, ieh sdamic prd-
tbatmde fivb sfdwe strdek mg-
prdvbgbets dvbr tfb pist tfrbb
ybirs.
Ebw bvmhbeab sukkbsts tfit mg-
prdvbgbets me prdobat pbrldrgieab
dvbr tfb cdek tbrg wbrb me pirt tfb
rbsuct dl @ien sbatdr pdcmambs ieh
bxtbreic adehmtmdes.
@bttbr bvicuitmde dl tfb quicmty ieh
mgpiat dl ieicytma ieh ihvmsdry ia-tmvmtmbs ms krbitcy ebbhbh.
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
38/180
Gbe lmsfmek me Adcdg`mi. Zfdtd y Bhwme Fullgie, adurtbsy dl tfb [drch @ien Zfdtd Cm`riry.
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
39/180
=
[drch @ien Zbrldrgieabme Zbrspbatmvb
Xfms afiptbr usbs tfbsb gbisurbs td bxigmeb
rbabet pbrldrgieab ieh td issbss wfbtfbr tfb
hdweture mhbetmlmbh cist ybir rbprbsbetbh i ebwhbacmemek trbeh. Mt icsd pciabs rbabet pbrldrg-
ieab me ie fmstdrmaic pbrspbatmvb `y bxigmemek
cdekbr-tbrg hrmvbrs dl pbrldrgieab ieh bvbets
issdamitbh wmtf tfb giodr tureirdueh me
pbrldrgieab. Lmeiccy, tfb afiptbr prbsbets i
hmsaussmde dl tfb pbrldrgieab dl tfb @iens
ieicytma ieh ihvmsdry iatmvmtmbs (III).
Zrdobat Zbrldrgieab Pbadvbrbh me 0::6Xd ritb prdobat pbrldrgieab, MBK usbs prdobat-
kbebritbh hiti td hbtbrgmeb tfb bxtbet td wfmaf i
prdobat fis gbt (dr ms cmnbcy td gbbt) mts stitbh
d`obatmvbs. @dx 0.0 prdvmhbs mccustritmdes dl wfit
sitmsliatdry ieh uesitmsliatdry gbie me i prdobat
adetbxt. Xfb d`obatmvbs dl prdobats irb mgpdrtiet
td hbvbcdpgbet dutadgbs suaf is krdwtf, pdvbrty
rbhuatmde, ieh dtfbr sdamic ieh bevmrdegbetic
kdics, dr mehmrbat adetrm`utdrs td tfbsb dutadgbs.9
Igdek @ien-suppdrtbh prdobats tfit acdsbh me
lmsaic 0::6, 0 69 pbrabet wbrb ritbh sitmsliatdry.
Xfb hrdp me prdobat ritmeks `btwbbe
0::< ieh 0::; dl ebircy ; pbrabetikb
pdmets (tfb sfirpbst hrdp smeab MBK`bkie trianmek pbrldrgieab) rbabmvbh
ittbetmde me cist ybirs ieeuic rbpdrt
ieh rimsbh adeabre i`dut i tureirdueh trbeh.
@ut pbrldrgieab rbadvbrbh me 0::6, is sfdwe me
lmkurb 0.9.1
Zrdobat pbrldrgieab
rbadvbrbh me 0::6,
icciymek adeabres dvbrtfb 0::; hrdp.
Xfb Mehbpbehbet Bvicuitmde Krdup (MBK) fis trihmtmdeiccy trianbh [drch@ien pbrldrgieab usmek i smgpcb gbtrma dl tfb pbrabetikb dl prdobats
ritbh sitmsliatdry (gdhbritbcy sitmsliatdry, sitmsliatdry, ieh fmkfcy sit-
msliatdry) is dppdsbh td uesitmsliatdry (gdhbritbcy uesitmsliatdry, uesitmsliatdry,
ieh fmkfcy uesitmsliatdry) lrdg icc prdobats tfit fivb acdsbh me tfb prbabhmek
ybir (`dx 0.9). @ien-suppdrtbh aduetry prdkrigs irb ritbh y i smgmcir gbtrma.
MBK ritbs prdobat dutadgbs iaadrhmek td tfb bxtbet td wfmaf tfb prd-
obats giodr rbcbviet d`obatmvbs wbrb iafmbvbh, dr irb bxpbatbh td biafmbvbh, bllmambetcy. Zdssm`cb ritmeks irb?
9. Fmkfcy sitmsliatdry? tfbrb wbrb ed sfdrtadgmeks me tfb dpbritmdes
iafmbvbgbet dl mts d`obatmvbs, me mts bllmambeay, dr me mts rbcbvieab.
0. Qitmsliatdry? tfbrb wbrb decy gmedr sfdrtadgmeks.
1. Gdhbritbcy sitmsliatdry? tfbrb wbrb gdhbritb sfdrtadgmeks.
8. Gdhbritbcy uesitmsliatdry? tfbrb wbrb smkemlmaiet sfdrtadgmeks.
2. Resitmsliatdry? tfbrb wbrb giodr sfdrtadgmeks.
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
40/180
MBK ritbs prdobat dutadgbs iaadrhmek td tfrbb armtbrmitfbmr rbc-
bvieab, bllmaiay, ieh bllmambeay. Me kbebric, sitmsliatdry prdobatsluccy hbcmvbr de tfbmr hbvbcdpgbet d`obatmvbs, ippbir cmnbcy td b
sustimebh, ieh kbebritb acbir `beblmts me ie bllmambet gieebr.
Qdgb bxigpcbs fbcp td mccustritb.
@urnmei Lisd
Me @urnmei Lisd, tfb @ien pirtmiccy lmeieabh i $0;: gmccmde witbr
suppcy prdobat me Duikihdukdu. Xfb prdobat wis ritbh fmkfcy sit-
msliatdry, luccy gbbtmek mts hbvbcdpgbet d`obatmvbs dl mearbismek rb-
cmi`mcmty dl, ieh iaabss td, acbie hrmenmek witbr ldr
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
41/180
Lmkurb 0.0? Zbrabet Qitmsliatdry Dutadgb Pitmeks `y Pbkmde ieh Qbatdr,
0::
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
42/180
92-ybir afiekb me
Ivbrikb ieeuic afiekb pbrabetikb pdmetsme pbrabetikb pdmets Qtiehirh brrdr X-ritmd (9==10::6)
Fmkfcy sitmsliatdry :.96 :.:6; 0.:8 0.;
Qitmsliatdry :.:02 :.92 :.9;
Gdhbritbcy sitmsliatdry :.=; :.98
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
43/180
9 1
[ D P C H @ I E N Z B P L D P G I E A B M E Z B P Q Z B A X M \ B
tdry). Guaf dl tfb dvbricc mearbisb me pbrldrgieab
aigb tfrdukf i hrdp me uesitmsliatdry ritmeks.
Me ihhmtmde, sdgb dl tfb rmsb me tfb pbrabet sitmslia-
tdry aitbkdry adgbs lrdg tfb rbcitmvbcy sgicc stbp`btwbbe tfb twd `drhbrcmeb su`aitbkdrmbs (lrdg
gdhbritbcy uesitmsliatdry td gdhbritbcy sitmslia-
tdry). Ie ictbreitmvb pbrldrgieab gbtrma ms td tinb
tfb ivbrikb dvbr icc smx aitbkdrmbs, issmkemek vicubs
lrdg 9 (ldr fmkfcy uesitmsliatdry) td < (ldr fmkfcy
sitmsliatdry). Xfms gbisurb kmvbs bquic wbmkft td
mgprdvbgbets dr hbtbrmdritmdes. Afirtmek tfb
afiekb dvbr tmgb smeab 9==1 (tfb lmrst ybir tfb smx
aitbkdrmbs wbrb wmhbcy usbh `y MBK) rbvbics i rmsb
me pbrldrgieab dl 6 pbrabet `y 0::
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
44/180
B. Bllbat dl
afiekb deI. Qfirb dl @. Qfirb dl A. Afiekb, H. Bstmgitbh dvbricc @iendpbritmdes dpbritmdes 9==10::6 bllbat/ pbrldrgieab
\irmi`cb me 9==1h me 0::6 (@ I) mgpiata (A H)
]bir (tmgb trbeh) 92 :.:09 :.19 mgprdvbh kdvbreieab wis i nby liatdr ldr
icc tfrbb. Hurmek tfb cittbr ficl dl tfb rbvmbw pbrmdh, me pirtmaucir,
tfb kdvbregbet uehbrtddn mgpdrtiet iatmdes, meacuhmek arbitmek
ie dmc surpcus iaaduet, mgprdvmek pu`cma lmeieamic gieikbgbet,
ieh hbbpbemek tfb prmvitmzitmde prdkrig. Xfb @ien prdvmhbh mg-
pdrtiet issmstieab, hbspmtb mts rbcitmvbcy sgicc lmeieamic adetrm`u-
tmde. @ut tfbrb wis cmttcb prdkrbss me tiancmek nby struaturic
wbinebssbs. Xfb @ien wis suaabssluc me suppdrtmek tfb mg-
prdvbgbet dl kdvbreieab (tfdukf edt me rbhuamek adrruptmde) it
tfb lbhbric cbvbc, ut cmttcb fis bbe iaadgpcmsfbh it tfb stitb cbvbc.
Qmgmcircy, tfbrb wis cmttcb prdkrbss me mgprdvmek guemampic witbr
ieh ur`ie melristruaturbtfb gime irrmbrs td ede-dmc krdwtf. Ieh
tirkbts ldr mgprdvmek fbictf ieh bhuaitmde dutadgbs wbrb gmssbh
hub td tfb cian dl ldaus de `umchmek mestmtutmdes it tfb stitb cbvbc,
wfmaf airrmbs prmgiry rbspdesm`mcmty ldr sdamic sbrvmab hbcmvbry.
KbdrkmiXfb @iens prdkrig me Kbdrkmi wis ritbh gdhbritbcy sitmsliatdry.
Xfb prdkrig ldausbh de giardbadedgma sti`mcmzitmde, kdvbreieab,
prmvitb sbatdr hbvbcdpgbet, ieh fugie hbvbcdpgbet btwbbe 9==1
ieh 0::;. Xfbrb wbrb i eug`br dl sbvbrb sbt`ians btwbbe 9==6
ieh 0::1, meacuhmek pddr tix adccbatmde, i ebir adccipsb dl ie bcba-
trmamty sbatdr figpbrbh y adrruptmde, ieh wdrsbemek iaabss td kddh
fbictf airb. @ut iltbr tfb Pdsb Pbvdcutmde me 0::1, tfb @ien qumancy
rbadkemzbh tfb pdtbetmic ldr afiekb ieh bxtbehbh mts suppdrt td tfb
ebw kdvbregbet. Xix rbvbeubs mearbisbh lrdg 98 pbrabet td 02 pbr-
abet dl krdss hdgbstma prdhuat (KHZ)> ie ietmadrruptmde aigpimke
suaabssluccy cbh td igbcmdritmde dl adrruptmde mehmaitdrs> bcbatrma-
mty suppcy sti`mcmzbh> ieh i wbcc-hbsmkebh sdamic issmstieab tirkbt-
mek prdkrig wis mgpcbgbetbh, wfmcb pdvbrty ritbs scdwcy hbacmebh.
Aficcbekbs rbgimemeacuhmek fbcpmek lirgbrs td iaabss arbhmt
ieh umchmek ouhmamic mehbpbehbeab`ut tfb prdkrigs gmhadursb
adrrbatmde cbh td sbvbric sitmsliatdry dutadgbs.
@dx 0.8? [fit Hd Gdhbritbcy Qitmsliatdry ieh Resitmsliatdry Aduetry Zrdkrigs Cddn Cmnb4
Qdurabs? MBK ldrtfadgmek i, 0::6m.
vicmhitmde dl tfb @iens AIQAPs. @dtf
tfb AIBs ieh tfb AIQAP Pbvmbws ritb
dutadgbs it tfb aduetry cbvbc wmtfdut
msdcitmek tfb sbpiritb adetrm`utmdes dl
tfb @ien ieh tfb aduetry.
Ldr gdst aduetrmbs, tfbe, tfrbb hmllbrbet nmehs dl
dutadgb ritmeks aduch `b usbh ldr tfb @iens
wdrn? tfb twd sdurabs dl aduetry ritmeks hbsarm`bh
i`dvb, wmtf tfb ihhmtmde dl i tfmrh, adestruatbh
lrdg tfb ivbrikb dl tfb ritmeks kmvbe td icc dl tfb
@ien-suppdrtbh prdobats, is hbsarm`bh bircmbr me
tfms afiptbr. Fdwbvbr, `baiusb tfb bxpbatbh
dutadgbs dl aduetry prdkrigs hmllbr lrdg tfdsb
dl prdobats, tfbrb ms ed prbsugptmde tfit tfb
ritmeks sfduch `b tfb sigb> me liat, tfb
aduetry ritmeks tbeh td `b cdwbr. Iardss
icc aduetrmbs tfb ivbrikb ritmek ldr tfb
aduetry bvicuitmdes smeab 9==1 fis
`bbe 1.; de i smx-pdmet saicb. Xfms ms
scmkftcy cdwbr tfie tfb ivbrikb ritmek ldr icc
prdobats dl 8.:.
MBK hiti sfdw i gmxbh pmaturb dl aduetry
prdkrig ritmeks me rbabet ybirs. AIBs, wfmaf
rblcbat i cdekbr tmgb lrigb (dltbe spieemek
badedgma ieh pdcmtmaic sfdans iardss ihgmemstri-
tmdes) hd edt sfdw ie upwirh trbeh, `ut fivbrbgimebh cbvbc dr hbacmebh scmkftcy. AIQAP
ritmeks, metrdhuabh me 0::0 ieh advbrmek guaf
sfdrtbr @ien issmstieab pbrmdhs, fivb mgprdvbh
is tfb ebw rbsucts ldaus fis kimebh triatmde. Me
0::;:6, fdwbvbr, tfb pbrldrgieab trbeh
lcittbebh, wfmaf giy gbrmt lurtfbr ieicysms me
ebxt ybirs IPHB (lmkurb 0.
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
49/180
9 =
[ D P C H @ I E N Z B P L D P G I E A B M E Z B P Q Z B A X M \ B
quicmty ieh rbcbvieab dl tbafemaic issmstieab ieh
ieicytma wdrn tfit giy edt `b pirt dl iey spbamlma
prdobat. [fbtfbr tfb d`obatmvbs me tfb AIQ irb
iafmbvbh dltbe hbpbehs de dtfbr hdedrs, de
rbkucitdry afiekbs, dr de bxdkbedus hbvbcdp-gbets suaf is eituric hmsistbrs dr lmeieamic armsms,
ieh edt sdcbcy de tfb suaabss dr limcurb dl tfb
prdobats suppdrtbh y tfb @ien.
Xfb Yuicmty Issurieab Krdups (YIK) L]:;
Ieeuic Pbvmbw dl Zdrtldcmd Zbrldrgieab
(IPZZ), usmek bvmhbeab lrdg MBK bvicuitmdes,
amtbh bllbatmvb pdcmay hmicdkub ieh wbin hbsmke
dl aduetry prdkrigs is giodr rbisdes ldr
hmvbrkbeab. Me aduetrmbs wmtf pddr dutadgbs,
prd`cbgs abetbrbh de smkemlmaiet dgmssmdes,
wbin ieicytmaic uehbrpmeemek, i limcurb td
iaaduet ldr me-aduetry aipiamty, ieh i cian dl
adfbrbeab iardss dpbritmdes. Gdrbdvbr, is
edtbh me tfb 0::6 IPHB ieh tfb 0::; IPZZ,
syebrkmbs `btwbbe ieh igdek tfb @iens
cbehmek, nedwcbhkb sbrvmabs, ieh pdcmay hmicdkub
wbrb edt icwiys luccy bxpcdmtbh, ieh sdgb
prdobats wbrb edt rbcbviet td tfb aduetrys adrb
hbvbcdpgbet aficcbekbs. Ebvbrtfbcbss, prdobat
pbrldrgieab ms pirt dl tfb dvbricc aduetry bvicui-
tmde, sd tfbrb ms mebvmti`cy sdgb adrrbcitmde.
@ien III Ms Mgpdrtiet `ut Edt PbkucircyBvicuitbh
III fis `badgb i krdwmek pirt dl tfb @iens
ihgmemstritmvb bxpbehmturbs. Mt iaaduetbh ldr ic-
gdst i tfmrh dl tfb @iens spbehmek de aduetry
sbrvmabs me lmsaic 0::6 (icdek wmtf wdrn de ebw
cbehmek ieh supbrvmsmde dl bxmstmek prdobats). Mt
fis icsd krdwe is i sfirb dl tfb @iens dpbritmdeic
spbehmek`y i`dut < pbrabetikb pdmets btwbbe
lmsaic ybirs 0::8 td 0::6.
It mts `bst, ieicytmaic wdrn ms vicubh ieh
hbgiehbh `y aduetrmbs is i giodr sdurab dl
nedwcbhkb i`dut rbldrgs ieh kcd`ic nedwcbhkb.
Mt fis `bbe gdst bllbatmvb wfbe fmkf tbafemaic
quicmty ms adg`mebh wmtf sustimebh bekikbgbet
wmtf acmbets ieh stinbfdchbrs.
MBKs bvicuitmde dl III lrdg 0::: td 0::< (MBK
0::6b) issbssbh tfb bxtbet td wfmaf III iafmbvbh
d`obatmvbs dl meldrgmek cbehmek, meldrgmek pdcmay,
`umchmek aipiamty, stmgucitmek pu`cma
hb`itb, ieh liamcmtitmek nedwcbhkb
bxafiekb. Mt ldueh tfit usbrs dl III
ritbh iafmbvbgbet dl tfbsb d`obatmvbs
ivbrikb dr fmkfbr.99 Mt icsd ldueh tfit mlfmkf tbafemaic quicmty, aduetry dwebrsfmp, ieh
@ien ldccdw-up irb prbsbet, III ms cmnbcy td fivb
ie mgpiat.
Xbafemaic quicmty, tfb rbpdrt ldueh, wis tfb gdst
mgpdrtiet dl tfb tfrbb mekrbhmbets cmstbh i`dvb. Me-
aduetry stinbfdchbrs ritmeks dl tbafemaic quicmty
strdekcy adrrbcitb wmtf tfbmr ritmeks dl tfb bxtbet td
wfmaf bvbry d`obatmvb fis bbe gbt. Xfb tbafemaic
quicmty dl tfb @iens III ms kbebriccy kddh. I
rbvmbw `y mehbpbehbet spbamicmsts dl i
sigpcb dl III prdhuabh ldr gmhhcb-
meadgb aduetrmbs ldueh tfit icc tfb
rbpdrts me tfb sigpcb rblcbatbh auttmek-
bhkb nedwcbhkb me tfbmr sbatdrs, ieh 2 ldr bhuaitmde prdobats, cbiremek
ittimegbet.Iaauriay rblbrs td quicmty me tbrgs dl
`isma prmeampcbs dl gbisurbgbet is wbcc is rmkdr,
wfbe rbqumrbh, me tfb issbssgbet dl mgpiat.
Hbamsmde-rbcbvietrblbrs td wfbtfbr tfb meldrgi-
tmde ms sullmambetcy adgprbfbesmvb td uehbrpme
mgpdrtiet hbamsmdes, suaf is wfbtfbr tfb pirtmau-
cir prdobat dr iatmvmty sfduch `b hdeb ikime, sfduch
`b saicbh up, dr sfduch b pursubh me iedtfbr wiy.
Xfbrb irb, dl adursb, @ien-suppdrtbh prdobats
tfit hbcmvbr bxabccbet meldrgitmde de rbsucts, ut
tfbrb ms `rdih iaabptieab tfit tfms hdbs edt
fippbe lrbqubetcy bedukf. Xfb @ien ms gdvmek
tdwirh kbebritmek `bttbr meldrgitmde tfrdukf
sbvbric memtmitmvbs. Xfms afiptbr rbvmbws lmvb irbis
td issbss tfb prdkrbss `bmek gihb?
Xfb gdemtdrmek ieh bvicuitmde memtmitmvbs
Xfb MHI92 Pbsucts Gbisurbgbet Qystbg Mgpiat bvicuitmde memtmitmvbs
Pbic-tmgb prdobat meldrgitmde
Badedgma adst-`beblmt ieicysms.
Biaf dl tfbsb lmvb irbis `birs de sdgb ispbat dl
tfb kdics dl gbiemekluc, iaauritb, ieh hbamsmde-
rbcbviet pbrldrgieab meldrgitmde, ieh tfms
afiptbr rbvmbws blldrts td mgprdvb pbrldrgieab
meldrgitmde me biaf.
Zrdkrbss Mgpcbgbetmek @ien-[mhb G&B
Pbldrgs Ms Bvmhbet `ut PbgimesAficcbekmekMgprdvmek G&B ms i pbrbeemic adeabre tfit ms
rimsbh me MBK rbpdrts ieh hmsaussbh me tfb @ien.
Xfb @ien fis dllbrbh kbebric beadurikbgbet,
hbtimcbh kumhbcmebs, ieh spbamlma rbqumrbgbets
imgbh it tfms kdic ldr dvbr i hbaihb. MBK, ldr mts
pirt, fis hriwe ittbetmde td meihbquitb G&B me
eugbrdus sbatdric bvicuitmdes ieh me mts ieeuic
rbvmbws, meacuhmek tfb 0::6 IPHB. Afiptbr 8
Xfb sitmsliatdry/uesitmsliatdry ritmeks hmsaussbh me afiptbr 0 `baigb
wmhbcy usbh, pirtcy `baiusb suaf i ritmek systbg wis lcbxm`cb bedukf
tfit mt aduch b ippcmbh td i wmhb virmbty dl dpbritmdes, wfmaf gihb dp-
britmdes bismcy adgpiri`cb. Fdwbvbr, tfbrb irb mearbismek aiccs ldr gdrb
gbiemekluc, iaauritb, ieh hbamsmde-rbcbviet meldrgitmde de pbrldrgieab,
`dtf it tfb [drch @ien ieh me tfb dvbricc metbreitmdeic hbvbcdpgbet adgguemty,
uehbr tfb gieikmek ldr rbsucts ikbehi.
Xdwirh Gbisuri`cb Pbsucts iehMgprdvbh Zbrldrgieab Hiti
0 2
8/14/2019 2009 Annual Review of Development Effectiveness: Achieving Sustainable Development
56/180
0 survby hiti de
rbcitbh mehmaitdrs> ieh meldrgitmde de metbrgbhmitb dutadgbstd issbss
wfbtfb
Top Related