7/31/2019 2008 a Year to Forget
1/12
[email protected](917) 796-2987
1 of 12
January 2, 2009
2008, A Year to Remember ForgetJonathan Golub, CFA
Chief Investment Strategist
Justin GordonResearch Associate
I think I speak for all of us when I say Goodbye and Good Riddance to 2008. While the past year
may not have been unprecedented (the 1930s come to mind), its been far worse than any currentinvestor has ever seen. Anyone predicting the events of 2008 at this time last year would have been
thought insane.
Summary of Market Activity
Stocks S&P 500 declined by 38.5% in 2008 (37.0% including dividends);Down 51.9% from peak to trough (10/09/07-11/20/08)
Volatility VIX peaked at 81 (11/20/08), 5 times the average over the prior 5 years
Oil Peaked at $147 (07/14/08) then plummeted to $35 (12/24/08)Gasoline began at $3.05, ended at $1.65, and peaked at $4.18 (07/11/08)
Rates 10-year US Treasury yields fell to 2.2% (12/31/08) from 4.0% (06/30/08)3-month T-bill yields fell into negative territory in December
Credit High yield spreads peaked at 20% over Treasuries (12/16/08) from 5.6% (12/31/07)
Source: Standard & Poors Corporation; CBOE; New York Mercantile Exchange, Reuters; US Dept of Energy; Federal Reserve; Bloomberg; Merrill Lynch
and then theres Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers, AIG, Merrill Lynch,
Washington Mutual, Iceland, the devastating Madoff scandal, a bailout of the auto industry, and more.
On the bright side, thanks to an aggressive statement by the Fed on December 16, a capital injectioninto Citigroup, a lifeline to Detroit, and welcomed cabinet appointments by Barack Obama, the market
rallied 20% from its November lows, finishing the year down only 38.5%.
2008 Market Returns
While the market has been in decline for the past twelve months, breaking the years movements into
smaller time periods is always useful. 2008s market gyrations are best explained by their flirtationwith or avoidance of apocalyptic events. As the chart below illustrates, it was the fallout from theLehman bankruptcy that did the majority of the damage to markets, driving volatility and risk premiums
through the roof.
7/31/2019 2008 a Year to Forget
2/12
[email protected](917) 796-2987
2 of 12
S&P 500
2008 12/31/07 - 03/17/08 03/17/08 - 09/15/08 09/15/08 - 11/20/08 11/20/08 - 12/31/08 10/09/07 - 11/20/08Fall of Bear Stearns Lehman Bankruptcy Peak - Trough
(38.5%) (13.1%) (6.6%) (36.9%)
20.0%
(51.9%)
Source: Standard & Poors Corporation
While we generally applaud the efforts of the Fed and Treasury, it is clear that allowing Lehman to failwas a colossal mistake. Yes, the stock market bounced back a bit from its nine-week, 37% fall, but
credit markets have only begun to thaw. So, where do we go from here?
Outlook For 2009
Were often asked whether the worst is behind us. Have we yet seen capitulation? Unfortunately, we
think the bigger question is whether or not the economy can avoid a 1930s style economic malaise. If
it can, then things are oversold. If not, were in the early innings.
Cutting to the chase, we would be underweight equities at this time for three reasons.
First, we believe that the current level of stress in credit markets is incompatible with a functioningeconomy and that future flashpoints will arise. The environment reminds us of the following anecdote.A patient walks into the emergency room with a 107o temperature. He asks the doctor how long the
fever will last. The doctor reassures him that by this time tomorrow the fever will be down. Thequestion is whether he will be cured or dead. 107o fevers are incompatible with life.
Second, we believe that the economy is more likely to recover than not (our unscientific odds are 3:1);
however, we are uncomfortable with the risk/return trade-off given the potential downside. In addition,
we think its important to look at an investment decision in context. If things head south, you mightlose your job or watch your business fail, the value of your home will fall, your annuity contract or
pension plan might not payoff as expected, and your local municipality might be insolvent. Not toover-emphasize the negative but if things turnout poorly, your stock portfolio might not be your biggest
worry.
Third, upside opportunities play out over time. Market trends tend to be long lived consider the run
between 1982-2000. If the economy recover there will be plenty of time to invest. Were verycomfortable missing the initial bounce should markets rebound.
7/31/2019 2008 a Year to Forget
3/12
[email protected](917) 796-2987
3 of 12
Market Barometer
In October, we established a subjective barometer to indicate the level of risk that we saw to oureconomic system. If the worst case outcome was a dramatic, self-reinforcing downward spiral, then
the scale would be a measure of its likelihood. Low might represent a 1/10,000 chance. Severe
would indicate that we were on the precipice.
We believe that we were on the edge twice in the past year first, when
Lehman was left to fail; and second, when Treasury made the decision toredirect TARP funds away from troubled assets, causing a near-failure of
Citigroup.
We put the current rating at High but believe that we will be back to
Severe sometime in 2009.
Economic Indicators All Point South
On December 1, the poobahs at NBER (National Bureau of Economic Research) responsible fordeclaring a recession finally pulled the trigger. Whats interesting is that as bad as it feels, theeconomy actually edged out a positive gain over the twelve months ending September (the most
recent data available).
GDP
50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 00 05
(4)%
(2)%
0%
2%
4%
6%
8%
10%
12%
Source:Bureau of Economic AnalysisNBER takes a variety of indicators into account when declaring a recession including growth and jobs.On the labor front, the US economy lost almost 2 million jobs in the first eleven months of 2008, and itappears that things are only beginning to get ugly. At 6.7% the unemployment rate is still rather
benign, only slightly worse than the long-run average of 5.6%. Dont be fooled, the only reason therate didnt jump more in November was because disillusioned workers dropped out of the labor pool.
GDP is -0.5% whenquoted on quarterlychange annualized
0.7%YoY
GUARDED
ELEVATED
SEVERE
LOW
HIGH
GUARDED
ELEVATED
SEVERE
LOW
HIGH
7/31/2019 2008 a Year to Forget
4/12
[email protected](917) 796-2987
4 of 12
Non-Farm Payrolls Monthly
90 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06 08
(400)
(200)
0
200
400
600
Source:US Department of LaborWhile the first official reading of fourth quarter GDP arrives in late January, monthly data fromindustrial activity to retail sales clearly indicates a precipitous drop in economic vigor.
ISM (Manufacturing)
90 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06 0830
35
40
45
50
55
60
Source: Institute for Supply Management (ISM)
ISMS most recent reading of 32.4 (01/02/09) indicates a rather severe fall in manufacturing. (Scoresbelow 50 indicate a contraction.) While we live in a service-based economy, the ISM Manufacturing
Index provides a excellent read on turning points in the economy. The rapid deterioration in ISM isconsistent with anecdotal evidence that everything froze up in October and November.
In addition, the great American consumer appears to have been humbled recently. The bottom-line isthis when you lose your job (or are in danger of losing it), watch your home value decline by 20%
and your 401(k) by 40%, your inclination to go to the mall as a leisure activity is likely to shrink. Asexpected, this has been the weakest Christmas season in years. Retailers have been discounting
heavily to lure customers. Can you say deflation?
Expansionary (>50)
Contractionary (
7/31/2019 2008 a Year to Forget
5/12
[email protected](917) 796-2987
5 of 12
Retail Sales ex-Autos
94 96 98 00 02 04 06 08
(2)%
0%
2%
4%
6%
8%
10%
Source: US Census Bureau
Its Not The Indicators That Scare Us
Given all of this weakness, it might surprise you that the economic data is not what keeps us up at
night. We expect economic releases and profit announcements to continue to be weak for quite sometime. This negative news flow only tells what we already know that things are pretty lousy. For thisreason we have identified those indicators that should lead us out of (or deeper into) this mess arenormalization of credit, fall in volatility, and stability in real estate values.
Indicators
Interest Rates Employment
Treasuries Corporate Profits
Credit Spreads Economic Activity
Inter-bank Lending GDP
Volatility Manufacturing
Real Estate Values Retail Sales
Leading Indicators Coincident Indicators
When we came up with this list in October, it was our belief that credit would slowly thaw allowingeconomic activity to gradually improve. On a positive note, the inter-bank market has become more
fluid and stock market volatility has fallen meaningfully from peak levels. However, credit availability isstill quite strained.
(2.9%)Most recent
3 mo avg
7/31/2019 2008 a Year to Forget
6/12
[email protected](917) 796-2987
6 of 12
Dislocation in Credit Markets Continues
There are two huge problems in the credit markets first, investors are so uncomfortable with thecurrent environment that they are willing to accept a near-zero yield from the US government for the
promise of a return of capital; and second, credit spreads for anyone other than the US government
are outrageously high.
T-Bill Yields
90 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06 080%
2%
4%
6%
8%
Source:ReutersJust as consumers have flocked to Wal-Mart to purchase safes for their homes, the security of US 3-
month T-bills has driven yields to near-zero. At the same time, credit has been harder to come by for
even the most credit-worthy borrowers. In many cases, the availability of credit has been non-existent.For example, on December 3, the Wall Street Journal reported that the Port Authority of New
York/New Jersey auctioned off $300 million in bonds without a single bid.
Corporate Spreads (Baa)
90 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06 08
1.0%
2.0%
3.0%
4.0%
5.0%
6.0%
Source: Moodys; Reuters; Federal Reserve
5.8%
8 bps
7/31/2019 2008 a Year to Forget
7/12
[email protected](917) 796-2987
7 of 12
More risky segments of the credit market have virtually seized. To put this into perspective, high yield
bonds traded at a yield of 275 basis points over Treasuries in June 2006. The spread now stands at17.3% over Treasuries, down from a peak of 20.1% on December 16.
High Yield Spreads
96 98 00 02 04 06 080%
5%
10%
15%
20%
Source:Merrill Lynch; ReutersInter-bank lending is an essential part of the global banking system. Over the past twenty years, theTed Spread (3-month USD Libor minus 3-month T-bills) has averaged 55 bps. This rate jumped to
464 bps on October 10. A coordinated global effort has pushed this back to 135 bps, a substantialdecline but still meaningfully above long-term levels.
TED Spread
90 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06 08
0.0%
1.0%
2.0%
3.0%
4.0%
Source:ReutersVolatility High But Declining
It would be logical to think that the best days in the stock market would occur in the best years. Oddly,they occur in the worst because these periods are punctuated by wild swings, the definition of high
volatility.
(ML HY Index Yield 10 Year Treasury Yield)
17%
Ted Spread measures thewillingness of banks to
lend to each other.
1.3%
7/31/2019 2008 a Year to Forget
8/12
[email protected](917) 796-2987
8 of 12
Worst/Best Days Since 1929
Year Period Return Year Period Return
6 Worst Days 6 Best Days
10/19/87 1987 Crash (20.4) 10/30/29 Great Depression 12.510/29/29 Great Depression (16.1) 09/21/32 Great Depression 11.8
05/14/40 World War II (10.3) 10/13/08 Current Crisis 11.6
10/15/08 Current Crisis (9.0) 10/28/08 Current Crisis 10.8
07/20/33 Great Depression (8.9) 04/20/33 Great Depression 9.5
09/29/08 Current Crisis (8.8) 10/21/87 1987 Crash 9.1
Source: Standard & Poors Corporation
2008s market gyrations have been accompanied by a spike in volatility. The VIX rose to 35 following
the fall of Bear Stearns and a staggering 81 following the collapse of Lehman. As time passes aftereach market incident volatility subsides. That has been the case over the past several weeks with the
VIX retreating to only 40.
VIX
99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 080
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Source: Standard & Poors Corporation; CBOE
Many of the markets day-to-day movements can best be explained by swings in volatility. Throughout
2008, the VIX and the S&P 500 have moved as almost perfect opposites the market falling asvolatility rises. Throughout 2008 a four percent change in the VIX has generally been accompanied bya one percent change in stock prices. This simple math helps explains the markets run since
November 20.
Average = 21.412/31/07 = 22.511/20/08 = 80.912/31/08 = 40.0
Lehman CollapseCitigroup Capital Injection
Bear Stearns Collapse
7/31/2019 2008 a Year to Forget
9/12
[email protected](917) 796-2987
9 of 12
Changes In The VIX And S&P 500
(15.0%)
(10.0%)
(5.0%)
0.0%
5.0%
10.0%
15.0%
(20.0%)(10.0%)0.0%10.0%20.0%30.0%
Source: Standard & Poors Corporation; CBOE; Bureau of Economic Analysis
Real Estate Holds The Key
Real estate played a huge role in getting us into the current crisis and will surely play a pivotal role in
leading us out. Residential and commercial property remain the predominant collateral backing ourbanking system. As such, the financial system will remain vulnerable until home values stabilize.
Concerned about additional declines, it is not surprising that banks have chosen to hoard governmentcapital infusions rather than lend.
Real Estate Values
90 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06 08
$100
$125
$150
$175
$200
$225
Source: National Association of Realtors
To date, real estate values have declined by 21% nationwide with greater losses in hot markets likeCalifornia, Florida, and other sunshine states. At current levels, it will take nearly a year to workthrough the inventory of unsold new and existing homes. A combination of more readily available
credit and further price declines is necessary before inventories can be worked off, providing a floor tovalues.
Daily Pct Changein S&P 500
Daily Pct Changein VIX
($000)
$181
7/31/2019 2008 a Year to Forget
10/12
7/31/2019 2008 a Year to Forget
11/12
[email protected](917) 796-2987
11 of 12
We think the more compelling argument is that the flood of fiscal and monetary stimulus will eventually
have its desired effect. 2009 will surely start with a large gift from Congress and the Obamaadministration. Chairman Bernankes Open Market Committee recently promised near-zero interestrates for an extended period and a willingness to buy virtually any asset onto its balance sheet. We
believe that the ECB and other central banks will follow suit. Their arguments for not lowering rates, to
leave powder dry for the future, is like the argument for saving life jackets on the Titanic for the nexticeberg.
Fed Funds Target and Effective Rates
Jan-08 Apr-08 Jul-08 Oct-08
0.5%
1.0%
1.5%
2.0%
2.5%
3.0%
3.5%
4.0%
4.5%
Source: Federal Reserve; Bloomberg
What the Fed failed to highlight in the official statement was that it has already been implementing a
near-zero rate policy, and buying up assets.
Hoping To Be Wrong
So is now the time to jump in the deep end in pursuit of undervalued assets? As tempting as it seems,were reluctant to say Yes. Do assets look cheap? Sure. Is the level of stimulus compelling? Youbetcha. However, with credit markets holding the jugular vein of the economy in its hand, we believethe next move on our risk barometer will be to Severe rather than simply Elevated.
We still believe that renormalization is the more likely outcome and that well avoid a 1930s stylefinancial meltdown, but the odds of an adverse outcome are too high and its implications are toopainful for comfort.
Weve never hoped to be wrong more than now.
Good luck to all of us in 2009.
Effective Rate
Target Rate
7/31/2019 2008 a Year to Forget
12/12
[email protected](917) 796-2987
12 of 12
DISCLAIMERThe views expressed are those of Jonathan Golub d/b/a Golub Market Insights. Opinions and estimates offeredconstitute our judgment. They are subject to change at any time without notice, as are statements of financial
market trends, which are based on current market conditions. We believe the information provided here isreliable, but do not warrant its accuracy or completeness. This material is not intended as an offer or solicitationfor the purchase or sale of any financial instrument. The views and strategies described may not be suitable forall investors. Each investor must make his own determination of the appropriateness of any investment. Thismaterial has been prepared for informational purposes only and on the condition that it will not form the solebasis for any investment decision. Any forecasts contained herein are for illustrative purposes only and are notto be relied upon as advice or interpreted as a recommendation.
CIR 230 DisclaimerJonathan Golub does not provide tax, legal or accounting advice. You should consult your own tax, legal andaccounting advisors before engaging in any transaction.
Jonathan Golub d/b/a Golub Market Insights, January 2009.
Top Related