1IntroductionTheEocene-Oligocene(E-O)transitionwasanepochofgreatturnover,inbothterrestrialandmarineenvironments.MammalswerehighlyaffectedbyanextinctioneventcalledgrandecoupureofStehlin,which
hasbeenverywelldocumentedinEuropeandAsia(Hartenberger,1998).InAmericathetropicalmolluscsunderwentasignificantextinctioneventatthebeginningoftheOi-1glaciationintheOligocene(Hickman,
2003).ThisdropintemperaturewascausedbytheopeningoftheDrakeStrait,therebygivingrisetothecircumAntarcticcurrent,theformationoficecapsonthepolesandthedevelopmentofthepsychrospherein
thedeepocean(ShackletonandKennett,1975;KennettandShackleton,1976;BarkerandThomas,2004;Livermoreetal.,2005).EvidenceandcausesoftheEocene/Oligoceneevent,basedonextinctionandsurvival
patternsofforaminifera,werereviewedbyMolina(2015,seeotherreferencesherein).
Inorder toestablish theprecisechronologyof the turnoverat theE-O transition,as thePriabonianandRupelianstagestratotypesdurationwas imprecise, the InternationalCommissiononStratigraphy
organized a working group in 1980 to define the Eocene/Oligocene (E/O) boundary, which officially corresponded to the base of the Rupelian Stage. This task was undertaken by the International Geological
Plankticforaminiferalbiostratigraphy,paleoecologyandchronostratigraphyacrosstheEocene/OligoceneboundaryinnorthernTunisia
NarjessKaroui-Yaakoub a,b
ChaimaGriraa,b
MoncefSaïdMtimeta
MohamedHédiNegrab
EustoquioMolinac,∗
aDépartementdesSciencesdelaTerre,FacultédesSciencesdeBizerte,UniversitédeCarthage,Jarzouna,Bizerte,7021,Tunisia
bUnitédeRecherche:PétrologieSédimentaireetCristalline,UniversitédeTunisElManar,Tunisia
cDepartamentodeCienciasdelaTierra&IUCA,UniversidaddeZaragoza,E-50009,Zaragoza,Spain
∗Correspondingauthor.
Abstract
Thebiostratigraphicanalysis of theEocene-Oligocene transitionof theMenzelBouZelfa and Jhaff sections innortheasternTunisia (CapBonpeninsula) allowsus to identify a continuousplanktic
foraminiferalbiozonation.Thefollowingbiozoneswererecognized:GlobigerinathekasemiinvolutaZone(E14),GlobigerinathekaindexZone(E15),(HantkeninaalabamensisZone(E16)oftheupperEoceneand
Pseudohastigerina naguewichiensis Zone (O1) of the lower Oligocene. A rapidmass extinction event in planktic foraminifera occurred at the Eocene-Oligocene transition, including the extinction of the
turborotalids (Turborotalia cerroazulensis, Turborotalia cocoaensis and Turborotalia cunialensis) followed by a significant size reduction of the genus Pseudohastigerina and the extinction of the hantkeninids
(Hantkeninaalabamensis,Hantkeninabrevispina,HantkeninananggulanensisandCribrohantkeninalazzarii),whichmarktheEocene/Oligoceneboundary.Thesespeciesweretropicalandsubtropicalsurfaceand
intermediatedwellers,withdistinctivemorphologies(carinateturborotalidsandspinosehantkeninids),whichwerewelladaptedspeciesofk-strategy.Thesurvivingplankticforaminiferaspecieswerequite
similarinmorphologywithglobularchambers(globigerinids)andsmallplanispiral(pseudohastigerinids),whichwereopportunisticspeciesofr-strategy.Therecognitionofa4mthickinterval,betweenthe
extinctionofturborotalidsandhantkeninids,indicatesthatthesectioniscontinuousandoneofthemostexpandedthroughouttheEocene-Oligocenetransition.Thissectioncouldserveasanauxiliarysection
(hypostratotype)forthecompletedefinitionoftheGlobalStratotypeSectionandPointfortheEocene/Oligoceneboundary,whichmarkthebaseoftheRupelianStage.
Keywords:Plankticforaminifera;Eocene/Oligocene;Biostratigraphy;Paleoecology;Chronostratigraphy;Tunisia
CorrelationProgramme,Project174 ledbyCharlesPomeroland IsabellaPremoliSilva (PremoliSilvaand Jenkins,1993).Theworkinggroupsearchedworldwide for suitable sections,mainly inSpainand Italy.
Severalsectionswerevisited,sampledandstudiedintheBeticCordillera,southernSpainandtheproposedcandidatesweretheFuenteCalderasection(Molina,1980,1986;Comasetal.,1985),theTorreCardela
section (Martínez-Gallego andMolina, 1975) and theMolino deCobo section (Molina et al., 1988). These three sections showed an expanded stratigraphic interval based on planktic foraminifera, between the
extinctionoftheturborotalidsandthehantkeninids,spanningabout1minthickness,neverpreviouslyfoundinothersections,butalsofoundintheMassignanosectioninItaly(Molinaetal.,1986,1993;Nocchiet
al.,1988;GonzalvoandMolina,1992).IntheMassignanosectionthiscriticalstratigraphicintervalwaslessexpanded,butwhenthesectionwasmultidisciplinarystudied(PremoliSilvaetal.,1988),otherinteresting
datawere found.Consequently, theGlobalStratotypeSectionandPoint (GSSP) for thebaseof theOligocene (Rupelian)wasdefinedatmeter19of theMassignanosection,coincidingwith theextinctionof the
hantkeninids(PremoliSilvaandJenkins,1993).
SincethentheE/OboundaryhasbeenrecognizedworldwideandthebiostratigraphyoftheE-Ointervalhasbeenimproved.ArevisedgeochronologyandchronostratigraphywasproposedbyBerggrenetal.
(1995)andarevisedtropicalandsubtropicalPaleogeneplankticforaminiferalzonationwasproposedbyBerggrenandPearson(2005),Pearsonetal.Eds.(2006)andWadeetal.(2011).TheupperPaleogenedeposits
attractedtheinterestofsomeresearchersinTunisia,whowereabletofindtheEoceneandlowermostOligoceneinnortheasternandcentralTunisia(BenIsmail-Lattrache,1981,2000;Boukhalfaetal.,2009;Amami
Hamdi,2014;BenIsmail-Lattracheetal.,2014),inJordan(Farouketal.,2013,2015)andinEgypt(Orabietal.,2015).However,theywereneverabletofindthecriticalexpandedintervaloftheE/Oboundary.
TheaimofthisstudywastosearchforanexpandedcontinuousmarinesectioncrossingtheE/OboundaryinnorthernTunisia.AcompositesectionhasbeenfoundintheCapBonpeninsula:MenzelBouZelfa
andJhaffsections.Theplankticforaminiferalbiostratigraphyindicatesthatthiscompositesectionincludesaveryexpandedcriticalintervalbetweentheextinctionoftheturborotalidsandhantkeninids.Consequently,
thissectionissuitableandcouldbeapotentialauxiliarysection(hypostratotype)tocomplementthedefinitionoftheE/OboundarythatwasdefinedintheMassignanosection,Italy.
2Materialandmethods2.1Geologicalandgeographicallocation
TheMenzelBouZelfasectionislocatedintheCapBonpeninsula,north-easternTunisia,36°43'30.22″Nand10°42'15.57″E.ThesectionwassampledintheNEflankoftheJebelAbderrahmananticlinethatrisesto602min
height.Thestratigraphicseriesisessentiallycomposedofmarls,limestonesandsandsranginginagefromthemiddleEocenetoQuaternary(Fig.1).TheE/Oboundaryinthissectionwascoveredbyvegetationandsoil,preventinga
detailedsampling.However,thisintervalappearsverywellexposedattheJhaffsectioninthesameareaabout1kmsouthward,whichislocatedbetweenthecoordinatepoints36°42'16.44″Nand10°41'42.58″E.Atthiscriticalinterval
thesamples,whicharenamedJ6toJ13,arelocatedbycorrelationbetweensamplesMBZ26andMBZ25.
2.2MethodsInthefield,afirstloosesamplingwascarriedouttoidentifythelocationoftheboundaries.LateraregularsamplingatmeterintervalintheMenzelBouZelfasectionwascarriedout,andamoredetailedsamplingwastaken
acrossthecriticalintervaloftheE/OboundaryoftheJhaffsection.Inthelaboratory,samplesweresoakedintapwaterfortwodaysandH2O2wasaddedtosomeverycompactedsamples.Allsampleswerethenwashedthrougha
columnofsieves:250μm,100μmand63μm.ThewashedresidueswerecollectedintoPetridishesandstovedriedjustbelow50°C.Toperformthestatisticalanalysis,theresidueobtainedwassubdividedusingastandardmicro-
splitterOttotypetoobtainarandomnon-selectiverepresentativesample.Theselectedfractioncontainedatleast300individualsofplankticforaminifera,whichcanbeconsideredrepresentativeofthewholesample(Table1).The
dataobtainedweresubsequentlytreatedtodeterminethefrequencies(relativeabundance)ofrecognizedspeciesandtotracktheverticaldistributionofthesefrequenciesthroughoutthestudiedsection.Theresiduesweresorted
underabinocularmicroscopetoidentifytheplankticforaminiferaspeciesandtherestofthesamplewasscannedtolookforrarespecies.
Table1Tableofthequantitativeanalysisofplankticforaminiferaspecies.
alt-text:Table1
Samples Species
Catapsydraxdissimilis
Catapsydraxglobiformis
Catapsydraxhowei
Catapsydraxafricanus
Catapsydraxunicavus
Cribrohantkeninalazzari
Cribrohantkeninainflata
Dentoglobigerinatripartita
Dentoglobigerinagalavisi
D.pseudo-venezuelana
Globigerinathekasemiinvoluta
Globigerinathekaindex
MBZ1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Fig.1GeographicalandgeologicallocationoftheMenzelBoyZelfaandJhaffsections.
alt-text:Fig.1
MBZ6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ7 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ8 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ10 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ11 X 0 0 0 0,19 0 0 0,38 2,2 1,7 0 0
MBZ12 X 0 0 0 0,2 0 0 0,4 0 3,5 0 0
MBZ13 0 0 0 0 X 0 0 0,3 0 2,6 0 0
MBZ14 X 0 0 0 0,3 0 0 0 5,5 7,9 0 0
MBZ15 X 0 0 0 X 0 0 0,6 0 1,5 0 0
MBZ16 0 0 0 0 X 0 0 7,2 2,4 1,9 0 0
MBZ17 X 0 0 0 X 0 0 0 1,1 2,5 0 0
MBZ18 X 0 0 0 0 0 0 1,3 0 7,4 0 0
MBZ19 X 0 0 0 0 0 0 0,7 0,5 1,1 0 0
MBZ21 X 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ22 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0,3 0 0 0
MBZ23 0.31 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ24 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ25 X 0 0 0 0 0 0 0,3 0 0 0 0
Jhaff13 0 0 0 0 0,1 0 0 0,18 0,5 0 0 0
Jhaff12 0.19 0 0 0 0,06 0 0 0,19 1,2 0,6 0 0
Jhaff10 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0,5 0 0 0
Jhaff9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0,6 0 0 0
Jhaff8 0 0 0,05 0 0,05 0,05 0 0,21 0,5 0 0 0
Jhaff7 0 0 0,1 0 0 0,05 0 0,26 1,4 0,9 0 0
Jhaff6 0 0 0 0 0,36 X 0 0 0,5 0,3 0 0
MBZ26 0 0 0 0 X 0 0,27 0,27 0 2,6 0 0
MBZ27 0 0 0,8 0 0 X X 0 0 2,5 0 0
MBZ28 0 0 0,3 0 X 0 0 0 0 0 0 0,8
MBZ29 0 0.15 0,3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0,9 0 0,1
MBZ30 0 0.32 0,32 0,3 0 0 X 2,9 4,5 5,8 1,6 1,9
Chilguembe-linaototara
Pseudohasti-gerinamicra
Ps.nague-wichiensis
Subbotinaeocaena
Subbotinacorpulenta
Subbotinajacksonensis
Subbotinaangiporoides
Subbotinalinaperta
Subbotinagortanii
Streptochilusmartini
Tenuitellainsolita
Tenuitellapraegemma
Turborotaliaincrebescens
Turborotaliaampliapertura
Turborotaliacocoaensis
MBZ1
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ2
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ3
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ4
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ5
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ6
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ7
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ8
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ9
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ10
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
MBZ11
2,4 9,5 2,4 4,94 6,65 X 0,76 0 0 4,94 0 0,57 0,95 X 0
MBZ12
6,9 14,6 8,003 4,60 3,47 X 1,77 0 0 8,4 0 5,09 0,24 0,4 0
MBZ13
14,5 10,7 2,6 5,37 3,22 X 0 0 X 11,11 0 0,89 0,17 0,71 0
MBZ14
3,9 0,7 1,5 3,9 5,53 X 0,39 0 0 2,76 0 0 0 1,58 0
MBZ15
10,8 10,4 12,6 5,68 3,18 X 4,2 0 0 9,32 0 0,79 0,45 X 0
MBZ16
2,4 6,3 7,7 5,82 15,53 X X 0 X 1,94 0 1,94 4,36 4,36 0
MBZ17
3,3 5,3 8,3 8,65 7,26 X X X 0 2,51 0 3,91 1,95 1,11 0
MBZ18
10,2 6,4 7,8 1,36 3,4 X 0 X X 3,74 0 1,02 2,38 1,7 0
MBZ19
11,9 9,04 7,5 2,95 8,11 X X 0 0 9,04 0 0 1,6 3,5 0
19
MBZ21
18,4 9,7 7,1 5,88 5,62 0 0 X X 8,95 0 0 1,27 X 0
MBZ22
5,1 10,2 10,6 3,85 5,78 0 0 0 0 9,64 0 0 1,92 0 0
MBZ23
10,1 10,1 12,6 1,89 2,84 X X 0 0 6,01 0 1,58 0,94 0,63 0
MBZ24
21,7 8,1 15,9 1,55 1,94 X X X X 12,06 0 0 0 X 0
MBZ25
26,4 4 12 1,84 4,3 X X 0 0,61 15,08 0 0 1,23 X 0
Jhaff13
5,4 12,1 12,1 2 2,5 0 11,29 0 0,25 4,13 0 0 0,12 0,5 0
Jhaff12
5,3 9,08 9,6 4,54 4,28 0 7,39 0 0,38 4,41 0 0 0 1,94 0
Jhaff10
1,5 10,3 9,8 1,55 2,78 0 5,79 0 0,33 1,33 0 0 0,1 0,5 0
Jhaff9
5,1 9,6 12,5 3,59 4,35 0 5,38 0 0,26 2,55 0 0 0,2 0,53 0
Jhaff8
7,4 15,1 10,9 4,11 4,16 0 0,16 0 0,1 1,44 0 2,51 0,1 0,32 0
Jhaff7
4,4 7,07 7,02 4,2 6,92 0,62 0,57 0,2 0,15 1,35 0 0,52 0,5 0,57 0
Jhaff6
9,6 20,3 13,89 3,52 2,43 0,57 0 0,15 0,05 5,02 0 0 0,05 0 0,15
MBZ26
7,8 15,2 12,47 9,86 11,51 X 0 0,13 X 3,97 0 0 0 X 2,6
MBZ27
8,5 12,1 21,49 7,44 7,021 0 0 0 X 6,38 0 0 0,63 0 1,9
MBZ28
6,9 14,8 15,25 2,48 5,67 X X 0 0,35 17,38 1,41 0 0,17 0,17 0,35
MBZ29
7,8 13,8 13,66 5,31 5,46 X X 0 0,45 22,76 1,6 0 0,3 0,6 1,51
MBZ30
0 0,6 0 14,84 13,55 X 2,58 6,45 0,96 0 0 0 1,9 0 3,2
3Results3.1Lithostratigraphy
WesubdividedtheMBZsectionintothreelithostratigraphicunitsbasedonthefacieslithologicalvariations(Fig.2).UnitU1(MBZ30-Jhaff10)extendsover26mandcomprisedfriablemarls,lightgreyincolour,occasionally
interspersedwithcentimetricargillaceousreddishlimestonebedsandoxidesrichiniron.Themicropaleontologicalanalysisdeliveredawell-developedforaminiferalassociation,diversifiedandwellpreserved.Plankticforaminiferain
thisunitare representedbyspeciesbelonging to thegeneraSubbotina,Globigerinatheka,Globigerina,Turborotalia,Dentoglobigerina,Hantkenina,Cribrohantkenina,Catapsydrax, Pseudohastigerina, Tenuitella, Chiloguembelina,
Streptochilus, andGloborotaloides. In this unit, the Priabonian,which is largely developed in the Souar Formationwas identified. Ben Ismail-Lattrache (2000) recognized theGlobigerinatheka semiinvoluta and the Turborotalia
cerroazulensisBiozonesandconsideredthemasbelongingtothePriabonianstage .(seeFig.3)
Fig.2Compositestratigraphicaldistributionofplankticforaminiferalspecies.
alt-text:Fig.2
Fig.3Compositequantivativedistributionofplankticforaminiferalspecies.
UnitU2(MBZ25–Jhaff11)is20mthickandconsistsofmarlsdarkgreyincolourwithagreenishshade,interspersedatthetopbyacentimetriclevelofinduratedmarlwithferruginousconcretions.SampleJ11iscomposedof
asandylimestonebedrichinironoxides.Thissamplemarksatransitiontogreysandymarls.TheKorbousunit,whichreferstotheOligocene,overliesthelatePriabonianclays.ThiswasalsoreportedbyBenIsmail-Lattrache(2000),
whorecognized theCassigerinellachipolensis-Pseudohastigerinamicra,“Globigerina”ampliapertura,“Globorotalia”opima andGlobigerina ciperoensis biozones. This unit is poor in planktic foraminifera and shows a remarkable
reduction in the size of the taxabelonging to thePseudohastigerinagenus. The species foundbelong to thegeneraChiloguembelina, Pseudohastigerina, Streptochilus, Subbotina Turborotalia,Dentoglobigerina,Globorotaloides,
Tenuitella,Globoturborotalita,Catapsydrax,andGlobigerina.Furthermore,itischaracterizedbythepresenceofshark'steeth.Farouketal.(2015)recordedshark'steethandphosphateparticlesinJordansuggestingsomereworking.
UnitU3(MBZ10-MBZ1) is10mthickandbeginswithasandstonebedofabout2mthick,ochre inpatinaandyellow-to-beige inbreakageandrich inbioturbationtraces.Abovethisunit, lightgreymarlpredominates,
sometimesintercalatedwithsmallyellowish-to-brownishrustsmalllevelsrichinironoxides.Plankticandbenthicforaminiferaareveryrare,poorlypreservedanditwasextremelydifficulttoidentifythespecies,havingprobablybeen
reworked.Boukhalfaetal.(2009)foundasimilarunitonseveralsectionsinNorthernTunisia,composedofclayeysandstone,veryrichinPectenarcuatus, fossilplants, indicatingaveryshallowshelfenvironmentwithterrestrial
influence.Consequently,itsageisveryuncertainandislikelytobeupperRupelianorChattian.
3.2BiostratigraphyDuetotheirmarineenvironmentandtheirabundanceorfrequencyinplankticforaminifera,thestudiedmaterialhasallowedustorecognizethreebiozonescharacterizingtheupperEoceneandthelowermostzoneofthe
lowerOligocene(Fig.2).
TheGlobigerinathekasemiinvolutaBiozone,E14(Highestoccurrencezone)correspondstotheintervalbetweenthelastoccurrenceofMorozovelloidescrassatusandthelastoccurrenceoftheindextaxonGlobigerinatheka
semiinvoluta.ItcorrespondstothetopofthePorticulasphaerasemiinvolutaBiozone,P15ofBerggrenetal.(1995).ItisequivalenttotheGlobigerinathekasemiinvolutaBiozoneofBerggrenandPearson(2005)andWadeetal.(2011).
TheGlobigerinathekaindexBiozone,E15(Highestoccurrencezone)istheintervalbetweenthelastoccurrenceofGl.semiinvolutaandthelastoccurrenceofGlobigerinathekaindex,accordingtoBerggrenandPearson(2005)
andWadeetal.(2011),althoughthereisnointervalcorrespondingtoZoneP17.ItisalsoequivalenttotheupperpartoftheGl.semiinvolutaBiozoneandtothelowerpartofTurborotaliacunialensisandCribrohantkenina inflata
Biozone,P16ofBerggrenetal.(1995).
TheHantkeninaalabamensisBiozone,E16(Highestoccurrencezone)correspondstotheintervalrangebetweenthelastoccurrenceofGl.indexandthelastoccurrenceofH.alabamensis,accordingtoBerggrenandPearson
(2005)andWadeetal.(2011).AccordingtoBerggrenetal.(1995)itcoincideswiththeupperpartofTurborotaliacunialensisandCribrohantkeninainflataBiozone,P16andtotheT.cerroazulensisBiozone,P17.
ThePseudohastigerinanaguewichiensisBiozone,O1(Highestoccurrencezone)correspondstotheintervalrangezonebetweenthelastoccurrenceofH.alabamensisandthelastoccurrenceofPs.naguewichiensis,according
toBerggrenandPearson(2005)andWadeetal.(2011).ItcorrelatestotheTurborotaliacerroazulensis/Pseudohastigerinaspp.Biozone,P18,accordingtoBerggrenetal.(1995).
4Discussion4.1Biostratigraphy
Thebiostratigraphicalanalyseswerecarriedout inordertobetterknowarelevantplankticforaminiferaltimeintervalacrosstheEocene/Oligoceneboundary.Thestratigraphicdistributionsofthemostsignificantspecies
showninFig.2leadtotherecognitionoffourbiozonesandtheircorrelationtosimilarzonespreviouslyestablishedbyotherauthors.
Inthestudiedsectionwedidnotfindtherelevantextinctioneventofthelargemuricateplankticforaminifera,suchasAcarininaandMorozovelloides(Wade,2004),whichiswellrepresentedintheTorreCardelasection,Spain
(GonzalvoandMolina,1996),theAlanosection,Italy(Agninietal.,2011)andcharacterizestheBartonian-Priaboniantransition(Wadeetal.,2012a).ThelowermostpartoftheMenzelBouZelfasectioncorrespondstotheuppermost
partoftheE14biozone(middlePriabonian).
Thebasalpartofthesection,upto18m,canbeassignedtotheupperpartofthebiozoneE14definedbythelastoccurrenceofM.crassatusatthebaseandthelastappearanceofG.semiinvolutaatthetop(Berggrenand
Pearson(2005);Pearsonetal.,2006).ThisbiozoneisoverlainbythebiozoneE15,thetopofwhichismarkedbytheextinctionofG.indexBerggrenandPearson(2005);Molinaetal.,2006;WadeandPearson,2008;Wadeetal.,2011).
ThesetwobiozoneswerealsofoundinseveralsectionsinSpain(Martínez-GallegoandMolina,1975;Molina,1986;Molinaetal.,1986,1988,1993,2006),inItaly(Nocchietal.,1988;PremoliSilvaetal.,1988;GonzalvoandMolina,
1992)andinTanzania(WadeandPearson,2008;Pearsonetal.,2008).
alt-text:Fig.3
AmajorextinctioneventofplankticforaminiferaoccurredacrosstheE/Oboundary.Indeed,justbelowtheboundary,intheupperpartoftheBiozoneE16(sampleJ6)thereisasuddenextinctionofthreespeciesbelongingto
theTurborotaliagenus:T.cerroazulensis,T.cocoaensisandT.cunialensis.Theydisappear4mbelowtheEocene/Oligoceneboundary,whichismarkedbytheextinctionofhantkeninids,theeventusedtoofficiallydefinethisboundary
byPremoliSilvaandJenkins(1993).TheintervalbetweentheextinctionoftheturborotalidsandhantkeninidswasalsorecordedintheboundarystratotypesectioninMassignano,Italy(Nocchietal.,1988;PremoliSilvaetal.,1988;
GonzalvoandMolina,1992)spanningonly0.4m.TheextinctionpatternacrosstheE/Oboundarycanbeconsideredarapidmassextinctionevent(Molina,2015).
At the topof theE16 zone,we found theextinctionof the last speciesbelonging to theFamilyHantkeninidae:HantkeninaprimitivaandH.alabamensis (very rare in the uppermost part); the other species:Hantkenina
compressa,HantkeninananggulanensisandCribrohantkeninalazzariibecameextinctjustbelow.However,thehighestoccurrenceofCribrohantkeninainflata,characterizedbyveryinflatedglobularchambers,isquestionable,inour
sectionitbecameextinctjustabovetheextinctionofGlobigerinathekaindex,inthelowerpartofthezoneE16anddidnotreachtheE/Oboundary.Ontheotherhand,WadeandPearson(2008)andBerggrenandPearson(2005),did
notrecognizeC.lazzarii,withtherugosesquarechambers;theyconsidereditajuniorsynonymofC.inflataandindicatedasimultaneousextinctionofHantkeninaandCribrohantkeninainflata.
Furthermore,wenotethatotherspeciesbelongingtothePseudohastigerinagenusunderwentamajorturnover,thelargeronesbecomingextinctattheE/OboundaryandthesmalleronessurvivingintotheOligocene.Itis
remarkable that thegenusPseudohastigerinaapparentlyshowsdwarfingsynchronouswith theHantkeninidaeextinction (Milleretal.,2008;WadeandPearson,2008).P.naguewichiensis survived through the boundary and rare
specimensofP.micraarepresent intheOligocene,buttheyaresmallerthan150μmandareconsideredPseudohastigerinacf.micra.ThosebiostratigraphicdataareconsistentwiththeFuenteCalderasection insouthernSpain
(Molinaetal.,2006),theTanzaniasection(WadeandPearson,2008;PearsonandWade,2015)andtheNoroñasectioninCuba(Molinaetal.,2016).
On the other hand, we noticed that some species are found to survive above the E/O boundary, such as Subbotina gortanii, Subbotina angioporoides, Subbotina eocaena, Subbotina corpulenta, Catapsydrax unicavus,
Globoturborotalitaouachitaensis.Atthebaseof theOligocene, fiveotherspeciesrecordedarelativeabundance innumberof individuals.ThesespeciesareDentoglobigerinatripartita,Dentoglobigerinagalavisi,Dentoglobigerina
pseudovenezuelana,TurborotaliaampliaperturaandTurborotaliaincrebescens(Table1).
SubbotinajacksonensisandCatapsydraxhoweiareidentifiedconsistentlyduringthemiddletolateEocene.TheydisappearattheE/Oboundary,unliketosomeotherGlobigerinidae.AccordingtoBerggrenandPearson(2005),
CatapsydraxhoweiandSubbotinajacksonensisbecameextinctatthesametime,inthetopoftheE16biozone.However,inourstudywenoticedthatCatapsydraxhoweidisappearsjustbeforeSubbotinajacksonensis,whichcontinue
totheuppermostEoceneandbecameextinctatthesametimeastheHantkeninidae.
Furthermore,Molina(1980,1986,2015)notedthatintheBeticCordillerathespeciesCatapsydraxdissimiliswasneverfoundintheupperEoceneandappearsinthebaseoftheRupelianstage.However,thisspecieswas
foundbyBerggrenandPearson(2005)fromthelateEocene,continuedintheOligocene,andwasconsideredasurvivorspecies.InMBZandJhaffsections,weidentifiedthelowestoccurrenceofthisspeciesinthefirstbiozoneofthe
Oligocene,similartowhathappenedintheBeticCordillera,Spain.
4.2PaleoecologyInadditiontotheirutilityinbiostratigraphy,thesequenceofassemblagesoftheplankticforaminiferaprovidespaleoecologicaldataaboutthewatercolumnstructure(CoxallandPearson,2007;Pearsonetal.,2008;Alegretet
al.,2008).ThequantitativeanalysisoftheplankticforaminiferaintheMenzelBouZelfaandJhaffsections(Table1)showsthatthesepelagicformsarepresentandconstantlyabundantthroughoutthesectionexceptinafewturbiditic
levels( )(Fig.3). Indeed, just below theEocene/Oligoceneboundary, theplanktic foraminifera are representedmainlyby typical species of the intermediate surfacedwelling, suchas Turborotalia pomeroli, T. cocoaensis, T.
cunialensis,T.cerroazulensis,T.ampliapertura,Globigerinathekatropicalis,H.compressa,H.primitiva,H.alabamensis,Cr. inflata,Cr. lazzarii,Ps.naguewichiensis,Ps.micra,D.galavisi,S.eocaena,S.corpulenta,S. linaperta,S.
jacksonensis.Thisassemblageoftropicalspecies(suchasT.cocoaensisandT.cunialensis)andsubtropicalspecies(Ps.naguewichiensis)infactreflectsafavorableenvironmentforthedevelopmentofthesespecies,amongwhichthe
mostabundantareS.corpulenta,S.eocaena,Ps.micra(about10–15%),whichrequireintermediatedwelling(seePlate1).
Fig.4
Fig.4BiostratigraphiccorrelationacrosstheEocene/Oligoceneboundary.
alt-text:Fig.4
Plate1PhotographsA–C:GlobigerinathekasemiinvolutaKEIJZER.SampleMBZ30.ZoneE14.Scalebar=100μm.D–F:GlobigerinathekaindexFINLAY.SampleMBZ29.ZoneE15.Scalebar=100μm.G–I:Turborotaliacocoaensis(CUSHMAN).SampleMBZ27.
ZoneE16.Scalebar=50μm.J–L:Turborotaliacunialensis(TOUMARKINEETBOLLI).SampleMBZ26.ZoneE16.Scalebar=100μm.M,N:Cribrohantkeninainflata(HOWE).SampleMBZ27.ZoneE16.Scalebar=100μm.O–Q:Cribrohantkeninalazzarii
(PERICOLI).SampleJhaff8.ZoneE16.Scalebar=100μm.R–T:HantkeninaalabamensisCUSHMAN.SampleMBZ27.ZoneE16.Scalebar=100μm.U:StreptochilusmartiniPIJPERS.SampleMBZ27.ZoneE16.Scalebar=50μm.V:Pseudohastigerinamicra
(COLE).SampleMBZ12.ZoneO1.Scalebar=50μm.W:PseudohastigerinanaguewichiensisMYATLIUK.SampleMBZ12.ZoneO1.Scalebar=50μm.
ApproachingtheboundaryE/O,thepercentagesoftypicalsurfacedwellersdeclineandthischangewascharacterizedbytheextinctionofamajornumberofforaminiferaspecieswhichcharacterizesthetropicalclimate,such
asthespeciesofthegenusTurborotalia(T.cerroazulensis,T.cocoaensis)andtheHantkeninidaefamilyandthespeciesS.linaperta.ThesechangeswerealsoaccompaniedbyarelativedecreaseinthenumberofPs.naguewichiensisof
sizegreater than150μm, reflectinga significant change in theecologyof theenvironment inaccordancewith thecoolingof the sea surface (Wadeetal.,2012b). Furthermore, at theEocene/Oligoceneboundary, the curves of
frequencyshowaslightdecreaseinthefrequencyofmostformsexceptsomespeciessuchasCh.ototaraandSt.martini,whichareconsideredindicatorsofstress(Gebhardtetal.,2013).
Otherspecieswerefoundconsistentlythroughthesectionandsurviveddespitetheseclimatechanges,suchasT.ampliapertura,D.pseudovenezuelana,D.galavisi,D.tripartita,T. increbescens,C.unicavus,Ps.micra,Ps.
naguewichiensis,S.eocaena,S.corpulenta,withincreasingabundanceinallOligocenesamplesandareconsideredopportunisticspecies.Ontheotherhand,thebaseoftheOligoceneisasuitableenvironmentfortheseopportunistic
speciesthatshowedaslightdecreaseinpercentagejustbelowtheE/Oboundary.Theconsiderableincreaseintheirfrequencyreflectsadropinthetemperatureofthesurfacewaterandthereforeanexpansionoftheglobalvolumeof
iceculminatingintheOi-1glaciation.TheglobalclimatedecreaseintemperatureduringtheupperEocenewastriggeredbytheopeningoftheDrakeStrait,theisolationofAntarctica,thealbedoeffect,theformationofthecircum
Antarcticcurrentandthepsychrosphere(ShackletonandKennett,1975;KennettandShackleton,1976;Kennett,1977;BarkerandThomas,2004;Livermoreetal.,2005).
4.3ChronostratigraphyTheE/OboundarywasformallydefinedbytheRupelianGSSPatmeter19oftheMassignanosectioninItaly,coincidingpreciselywiththehantkeninidsextinction(PremoliSilvaandJenkins,1993).TheE/Oboundarywasdated
as33.9Ma(Vandenbergheetal.,2012).Thesedimentsof theMassignanosectionarepelagicmarinewithnoevidenceofanyhiatus,but theuppermostEocene ischaracterizedbya0.4m thick condensed interval between the
extinciónof the turborotalidsand thehantkeninids.Anothersection in Italy, theMonteCagnerosection,wasproposedasapotentialparastratotype for theMassignanoglobal stratotypesectionandpoint (GSSP)due to itsgood
integratedstratigraphicandastrochronologicalcalibrationoftheEocene-Oligocenetransition(Hylandetal.,2009),althoughtheintervalissimilarlycondensed.
TherecognitionofthisintervalintheTunisiansectionisaveryrelevantfindingbecauseitis4mthickandisoneofthemostexpandedknowntodate(Fig.4).OnlyinTanzaniaisthisintervalmoreexpanded,sinceitis5.2m
thickanditsdurationwasestimatedat65ky(Pearsonetal.,2008).IntheFuenteCaldera,TorreCardelaandMolinodeCobosectionsintheBeticCordillera,southernSpain,thisinterval is1.2mthickanditsdurationhasbeen
estimatedat40ky(Molina,2015).Nevertheless,inJordanFarouketal.(2013,2015)foundahiatusmissingthisinterval.
AuxiliarysectionsshouldbeproposedinordertoimprovethedefinitionoftheE/Oboundary.Theseauxiliarysections,alsoknownashypostratotypes,mustbeplacedindifferentregionstobettercorrelatetheE/Oboundary
worldwide.ThemostexpandedandcontinuoussectionsknownsofararelocatedinTanzania(drillingsite12),Spain(FuenteCalderasection)andTunisia(Jhaffsection),whichareverysuitableandshouldbeproposedasauxiliary
hypostratotypes.
5ConclusionsTheplankticforaminiferadetailedstudyoftheMBZandJhaffcompositesectionallowedustoestablishadetailedbiozonation.InthisTunisiansectionwewereabletorecognizethefollowingbiozones:the
upperpartoftheGlobigerinathekasemiinvolutaZone(E14),theGlobigerinathekaindexZone(E15),theHantkeninaalabamensisZone(E16)oftheupperEoceneandthePseudohastigerinanaguewichiensisZone(O1)ofthe
lowerOligocene.
WenoticedamajorturnovereventacrosstheEocene/Oligoceneboundary,thatwasmarkedbyanintervalbetweentheextinctionofturborotalidsandhantkeninids.Theextinctionpatterncanbeconsidereda
rapidmassextinctioneventsinceitlastedabout40–65ky.Therecognitionofthisintervalindicatesthatthesectionisverycontinuousandexpanded.AtthetopofthisintervalthereisdwarfingofthePseudohastigerina
genus,withonlythespecimensnolargerthan150μmsurvivingintotheOligocene.
Thespecies thatbecameextinctacross theE/Oboundaryweretropicalandsubtropicalsurfaceand intermediatedwellers,withdistinctivemorphologies (carinate turborotalidsandspinosehantkeninids),
whichwerewelladaptedspeciesofk-strategy.Thisextinctioneventwastriggeredbythecoolingthatculminated intheOi-1glaciation inthe lowermostOligocene.Thesurvivingplanktic foraminiferaOligocene
specieswerequitesimilarinmorphologywithglobularchambers(globigerinids)andsmallplanispiralpseudohastigerinids,whichweremainlyopportunisticspeciesofr-strategy.
TheTunisiansectionallowsustorecognizea4mthickintervalbetweenextinctionoftheturborotalidsandhantkenids,whichisoneofthemostexpandedknowntodate.OnlyinTanzaniaisthisintervalmore
expanded,sinceitis5.2m.InSpainthisintervalis1.2m.IntheE/OboundarystratotypedefinedinItalyitis0.4mthick.Asaresult,theTunisiansectioncouldbeaverysuitableauxiliaryhypostratotypetocorrelate
theE/Oboundaryworldwide.
alt-text:Plate1
AcknowledgementsWewouldliketothanktheresearchunitteam“Pétrologiesédimentaireetcrystalline”oftheFacultyofSciencesofTunis.ThisstudyreceivedfinancialsupportandassistancethroughProjectCGL2014-58794P
fromtheSpanishMinistryofScienceandTechnology(FEDERfunds)andtheConsolidatedGroupE05fromtheGovernmentofAragón.
ReferencesAgniniC.,FornaciariE.,GiusbertiL.,GrandessoP.,LanciL.,LucianiV.,MuttoniG.,PälikeH.,RioD.,SpofforthD.J.A.andStefaniC.,IntegratedbiomagnetostratigraphyoftheAlanosection(NEItaly):aproposalfor
definingthemiddlelateEoceneboundary,GSABull.123(5/6),2011,841–872.
AlegretL.,CruzL.E.,FeneroR.,MolinaE.,OrtizS.andThomasE.,EffectsoftheOligoceneclimaticeventsontheforaminiferalrecordfromFuenteCalderasection(Spain,westernTethys),Palaeogeogr.Palaeoclimatol.
Palaeoecol.269,2008,94–102.
Amami-HamdiA.,Etudemicropaléontologique,biostratigraphique,paléoécologiqueetpaléobiogéographiquedessériesdel’EocènemoyenàsupérieurenTunisiecentrale,Thèsededoctorat,2014,UniversitéTunisElManar,230.
BarkerP.F.andThomasE.,Origin,signatureandpaleoclimaticinfluenceoftheAntarcticcircumpolarcurrent,Earth-ScienceRev.66,2004,143–162.
BenIsmail-LattracheK.,Etudemicropaléontologiqueetbiostratigraphiquedessériespaléogènesdel’anticlinalduJebelAbderrahmane(Cap-Bon,TunisieNord-oriental),Thèsede3émecycle,1981,FacultédessciencesdeTunis.
BenIsmail-LattracheK.,PrécisionsurlepassageLutétien/BarthoniendanslesdépôtséocènesmoyensenTunisieCentraleetNord-orientale,Rev.Micropaléontologie43,2000,3–16.
BenIsmail-LattracheK.,ÖzcanE.,BoukhalfaK.,SaraswatiP.K.,SoussiM.andJovaneL.,EarlyBartonianorthophragminids(Foraminiferida)fromReinecheLimestone,northAfricanplatform,Tunisia:taxonomyand
paleobiogeographicimplications,Geodin.Acta2014,http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/09853111.2013.858950.
BerggrenW.A.,KentD.V.,SwisherC.C.,IIIandAubryM.P.,ArevisedCenozoicgeochronologyandchronostratigraphy,In:BerggrenW.A.,KentD.V.,AubryM.P.andHardenbolJ.,(Eds.),Geochronology,TimeScalesand
GlobalStratigraphicCorrelation,vol.54,1995,SocietyofEconomicPaleontologistsandMineralogists(SEPM)(SocietyforSedimentaryGeology)SEPM,129–212,SpecialPublication.
BerggrenW.A.andPearsonP.N.,ArevisedtropicalandsubtropicalPaleogeneplanktonicforaminiferalzonation,J.Foraminifer.Res.35,2005,279–298.
BoukhalfaK.,BenIsmail-LattracheK.,RiahiS.,SoussiM.andKhomsiS.,Analysebiostratigraphiqueetsédimentologiquedesserieséo-oligocènesetmiocènesdelaTunisieseptentrionale:implicationsstratigraphiques
etgéodynamiques,ComptesRedusGeosci.341,2009,49–62.
ComasM.C.,Martínez-GallegoJ.andMolinaE.,LitofaciesysucesiónestratigráficadelEocenoyOligocenoalNortedelCerroMencal(Zonasubbética,ProvinciadeGranada),Cuad.Geol.12,1985,145–155.
CoxallH.K.andPearsonP.N.,Theeocene–oligocenetransition,TheMicropalaeontologicalSociety,SpecialPublicationsIn:WilliamsM.,HaywoodA.M.,GregoryF.J.andSchmidtD.N.,(Eds.),Deep-timePerspectiveson
ClimateChange:MarryingtheSignalfromComputerModelsandBiologicalProxies,2007,TheGeologicalSociety;London,351–387.
FaroukS.,AhmadF.andSmadiA.A.,Stratigraphyofthemiddleeocene-lowerOligocenesuccessionsinnorthwesternandeasternJordan,J.AsianEarthSci.73,2013,396–408.
FaroukS.,FarisM.,AhmadF.andPowellJ.H.,NewmicroplalnktonicbiostratigraphyanddepositionalsequencesacrosstheMiddle-LateEoceneandOligoceneboundariesineasternJordan,GeoArabia20(3),2015,
145–172.
GebhardtH.,ĆorićS.,DargaR.,BriguglioA.,SchenkB.,WernerW.,AndersenN.andSamesB.,MiddletoLateEocenepaleoenvironmentalchangesinamarinetransgressivesequencefromthenorthernTethyan
margin(Adelholzen,Germany),AustrianJ.EarthSci.106(2),2013,45–72.
GonzalvoC.andMolinaE.,BioestratigrafíaycronoestratigrafíadeltránsitoEoceno-OligocenoenTorreCardelayMassignano(Italia),Rev.EspañolaPaleontol.7,1992,109–126.
GonzalvoC.andMolinaE.,BioestratigrafíayCronoestratigrafíadeltránsitoEocenoMedio-EocenoSuperiorenlaCordilleraBética,Rev.EspañolaMicropaleontol.28(2),1996,25–44.
HartenbergerJ.L.,AnAsiangrandecoupure,Nature394,1998,321.
HickmanC.S.,EvidenceforabruptEocene-OligocenemolluscanfaunalchangeinthePacificNorthwest,In:ProtheroD.,etal.,(Eds.),FromGreenhousetoIcehouse,2003,ColumbiaUniversityPress;NewYork,71–87.
HylandE.,MurphyB.,VarelaP.,MarksK.,ColvellL.,ToriF.,MonechiS.,CleavelandL.,BrinkhuisH.,vanMourikC.A.,CoccioniR.,BiceD.andMontanaryA.,Integratedstratigraphicandastrochronologiccalibration
oftheEocene-OligocenetransitionintheMonteCagnerosection(northeasternApennines,Italy):apotentialparastratotypefortheMassignanoglobalstratotypesectionandpoint(GSSP),SpecialPaperGeol.Soc.Am.452,2009,303–322.
KennettJ.P.,CenozoicevolutionofAntarcticglaciations,thecircum-Antarcticoceanandtheirimpactonglobalpaleoceanography,J.Geophys.Res.82,1977,3843–3860.
KennettJ.P.andSchackletonN.J.,Oxygenisotopicevidenceforthedevelopmentofthepsychrosphere38Myrago,Nature260,1976,513–515.
LivermoreR.,NankivellA.,EaglesG.andMorrisP.,PaleogeneopeningofDrakepassage,EarthPlanet.Sci.Lett.236,2005,459–470.
Martínez-GallegoJ.andMolinaE.,EstudiodeltránsitoEoceno-OligocenoconforaminíferosplanctónicosalSurdeTorreCardela(ProvinciadeGranada,ZonaSubbética),Cuad.Geol.6,1975,177–195.
MillerK.G.,BrowningJ.V.,AubryM.-P.,WadeB.S.,KatzM.E.,KulpeczA.A.andWrightJ.D.,Eocene–Oligoceneglobalclimateandsea-levelchanges:St.StephensQuarry,Alabama,Geol.Soc.Am.Bull.120(1),2008,
34–53.
MolinaE.,Oligoceno-MiocenoinferiorpormediodeforaminíferosplanctónicosenelsectorcentraldelasCordillerasBéticas(España),Tesisdoctoral1980,PublicaciónUniversidadesdeGranadayZaragoza,342.
MolinaE.,DescriptionandbiostratigraphyofthemainreferencesectionoftheEocene/OligoceneboundaryinSpain:FuenteCalderasection,Dev.PaleontologyStratigr.9,1986,53–63.
MolinaE.,EvidenceandcausesofthemainextinctioneventsinthePaleogenebasedonextinctionandsurvivalpatternsofforaminifera,Earth-ScienceRev.140,2015,166–181.
MolinaE.,MonacoP.,NocchiM.andParisiG.,BiostratigraphiccorrelationbetweenthecentralSubbetic(Spain)andUmbro-Marchean(Italy)pelagicsequencesattheeocene/oligoceneboundaryusingforaminifera,
Dev.PaleontologyStratigr.9,1986,75–85.
MolinaE.,KellerG.andMadileM.,LateEocenetoOligoceneevents:MolinodeCobo,BeticCordillera,Spain,Rev.EspañolaMicropaleontol.20,1988,491–514.
MolinaE.,GonzalvoC.andKellerG.,TheEocene-Oligoceneplankticforaminiferaltransition:extinctions,impactsandhiatuses,Geol.Mag.130(4),1993,483–499.
MolinaE.,GonzalvoC.,OrtizS.andCruzL.E.,ForaminiferalturnoveracrosstheEocene–OligocenetransitionatFuenteCaldera,southernSpain:Nocause–effectrelationshipbetweenmeteoriteimpactsand
extinctions,Mar.Micropaleontol.58,2006,270–286.
MolinaE.,Torres-SilvaA.,ĆorićS.andBriguglioA.,IntegratedbiostratigraphyacrosstheEocene/OligoceneboundaryatNoroña,Cuba,andthequestionoftheextinctionoforthophragminids,Newsletters
Stratigr.49(1),2016,27–40.
NocchiM.,MonechiS.,CoccioniR.,MadileM.,MonacoP.,OrlandoM.,ParisiG.andPremoliSilvaI.,TheextinctionofHantkeninidaeasamarkerfordefiningtheEocene–Oligoceneboundary:aproposal,SpecialPublicationIn:PremoliSilvaI.,CoccionR.andMontanariA.,(Eds.),TheEocene–oligoceneBoundaryintheMarche-UmbriaBasin(Italy),vol.1,1988,InternationalSubcommissiononPaleogeneStratigraphy;
Ancona,249–252.
OrabiH.,ElBeshtawyM.,OsmanR.andGadallahM.,Largerbenthicforaminiferalturnoveracrosstheeocene-oligocenetransitionatSiwaoasis,westerndesert,Egypt,J.Afr.EarthSci.105,2015,85–92.
PearsonP.N.andWadeB.S.,Systematictaxonomyofexceptionallywell-preservedplanktonicforaminiferafromtheEocene/OligoceneboundaryofTanzania,CushmanFound.Spec.Publ.45,2015,1–85.
PearsonP.N.,OlssonR.K.,HuberB.T.,HemlebenC.andBerggrenW.A.,(Eds.),AtlasofEocenePlanktonicForaminifera,41,2006,CushmanFoundationSpecialPublication,514.
PearsonP.N.,McMillanI.K.,WadeB.S.,JonesT.D.,CoxallH.K.,BownP.R.andLearC.H.,ExtinctionandenvironmentalchangeacrosstheEocene-OligoceneboundaryinTanzania,Geology36(2),2008,179–182.
PremoliSilvaI.andJenkinsG.,DecisionontheEoceneOligoceneboundarystratotype,Episodes16(3),1993,379–382.
SpecialPublicationPremoliSilvaI.,CoccioniR.andMontanariA.,(Eds.),TheEocene–oligoceneBoundaryintheMarche-UmbriaBasin(Italy),1988,InternationalUnionofGeologicalSciences,Commissionon
QueriesandAnswersQuery:Thecitations“AmamiHamdi,2014;BenIsmail-Lattrache(1981);Wadeetal.,2004;Berggrenetal.,2005;AmamiHamdi,2014”havebeenchangedtomatchtheauthorname/dateinthereferencelist.Pleasecheck.Answer:Ok
Query:PleasenotethatFig.3andPlate1wasnotcitedinthetext.Pleasecheckthatthecitationssuggestedbythecopyeditorareintheappropriateplace,andcorrectifnecessary.Answer:IchangedtheplaceofFig.3andFig.4
Query:Pleaseprovidethegrantnumberfor‘GovernmentofAragón’ifany.Answer:ThenumberisE05
Query:Pleaseconfirmthatgivennamesandsurnameshavebeenidentifiedcorrectly.Answer:Yes
Stratigraphy;Ancona,268.
ShackletonN.J.andKennettJ.P.,PaleotemperaturehistoryoftheCenozoicandtheinitiationofAntarcticglaciation:oxygenandcarbonisotopeanalysesinDSDPSites277,279and281,InitialRep.DSDP29,1975,
743–755.
VandenbergheN.,HilgenF.J.andSpeijerR.P.,ThePaleogeneperiod,In:GradsteinF.M.,etal.,(Eds.),TheGeologicTimeScale2012,2012,Elsevier,855–921.
WadeB.S.,PlanktonicforaminiferalbiostratigraphyandmechanismsintheextinctionofMorozovellainthelatemiddleEocene,Mar.Micropaleontol.51,2004,23–38.
WadeB.S.andPearsonP.N.,Planktonicforaminiferalturnover,diversityfluctuationsandgeochemicalsignalsacrosstheEocene/OligoceneboundaryinTanzania,Mar.Micropaleontol.68,2008,244–255.
WadeB.S.,PearsonP.N.,BerggrenW.A.andPälikeH.,ReviewandrevisionofCenozoictropicalplanktonicforaminiferalbiostratigraphyandcalibrationtothegeomagneticpolarityandastronomicaltimescale,Earth-
ScienceRev.104,2011,111–142.
WadeB.S.,FucekV.P.,KamikuriS.,BartolM.,LucianiV.andPearsonP.N.,Successiveextintionsofmuricateplanktonicforaminifera(MorozovelloidesandAcarinina)asacandidateformarkingthebasePriabonian,
NewslettersStratigr.45(3),2012a,245–262.
WadeB.S.,HoubenA.J.P.,QuaijtaalW.,ChoutenS.,RosenthalY.,MillerK.G.,KatzM.E.,WrightJ.D.andBrinkhuisH.,Multiproxyrecordofabruptsea-surfacecoolingacrosstheEocene-OligocenetransitionintheGulf
ofMexico,Geology40(2),2012b,159–162.
Highlights
• PlankticforaminiferaE14,E15,E16,O1ZonesareidentifiedacrosstheE/Oboundary.
• ThesectioniscorrelatedwithothersinTanzania,SpainandtheE/OGSSPinItaly.
• TurborotalidsandhantkeninidsunderwentarapidmassextinctionacrosstheE/O.
• TheextinctioneventattheE-Otransitionisrecordedinaveryexpandedinterval.
• TheTunisiansectionisaverysuitableauxiliarysectionfortheE/Oboundary.
Query:Yourarticleisregisteredasaregularitemandisbeingprocessedforinclusioninaregularissueofthejournal.IfthisisNOTcorrectandyourarticlebelongstoaSpecialIssue/Collectionpleasecontacts.murray@elsevier.comimmediatelypriortoreturningyourcorrections.Answer:Yes
Top Related