1
EMERGING ISSUESEMERGING ISSUES
in thein the
MUNICIPAL SECURITIES MARKETMUNICIPAL SECURITIES MARKET
Presented to International Municipal Lawyers Association
2008 Annual Conference
September 15, 2008
By Robert W. Doty
AGFSSacramento
2AGFS
OVERVIEWOVERVIEW
• Bond Insurer Downgrades & Impacts on IssuersBond Insurer Downgrades & Impacts on Issuers
• Dual vs. Single Rating ScalesDual vs. Single Rating Scales
• Collapse of ARS Bonds (Related Enforcement); Collapse of ARS Bonds (Related Enforcement); Underwriter ConflictsUnderwriter Conflicts
• Jefferson County Defaults; Pending BankruptcyJefferson County Defaults; Pending Bankruptcy
• SEC Action Against Former San Diego OfficialsSEC Action Against Former San Diego Officials
• MaterialityMateriality
• SEC Limitations on Reliance on Counsel/ProfessionalsSEC Limitations on Reliance on Counsel/Professionals
3
BOND INSURER DOWNGRADES BOND INSURER DOWNGRADES & IMPACTS ON ISSUERS& IMPACTS ON ISSUERS
AGFS
4
NUMEROUS INSURER RATING DOWNGRADESNUMEROUS INSURER RATING DOWNGRADES
•All But Two Insurers Downgraded, All But Two Insurers Downgraded, Some RepeatedlySome Repeatedly
•Negatives for Remaining TwoNegatives for Remaining Two
•Some Now Below Investment GradeSome Now Below Investment Grade
•Had Declined to Certify Completeness of InformationHad Declined to Certify Completeness of Information
AGFS
5
ISSUER BOND DOWNGRADESISSUER BOND DOWNGRADES
Affects Outstanding Bonds, Not New IssuesAffects Outstanding Bonds, Not New Issues
Requires Material Event Notice FilingsRequires Material Event Notice Filings
Sometimes RepeatedlySometimes Repeatedly
AGFS
6
DUAL vs. SINGLE RATING SCALESDUAL vs. SINGLE RATING SCALES
AGFS
7
DIFFERENTIALS IN DIFFERENTIALS IN DEFAULT RATESDEFAULT RATES
Municipal Market Advisors, Says, e.g.—Municipal Market Advisors, Says, e.g.—
AGFS
Moody’s S&P
Muni Baa/BBB
0.13% 0.32%
Corporate Baa/BBB
4.64% 10.29
Muni Aaa/AAA
0.00% 0.00%
Corporate Aaa/AAA
0.52% 0.60%
8
ISSUER CHALLENGES TO RATING SCALESISSUER CHALLENGES TO RATING SCALES
California Treasurer Bill Lockyer—California Treasurer Bill Lockyer—
““Under the current system, the agencies hold governmental issuers to a higher standard.
The result is lower bond ratings that force taxpayers to shoulder substantial,
unwarranted costs in the form of higher interest payments and insurance premiums.””
AGFS
9
PROPOSED FEDERAL ACTIONPROPOSED FEDERAL ACTION
Regulatory—Regulatory—Several New Requirements Several New Requirements for Rating Agency Disclosure & Conflicts Regulationfor Rating Agency Disclosure & Conflicts Regulation
Legislative (Rep. Frank)—Legislative (Rep. Frank)—Restrict Rating Focus to DefaultRestrict Rating Focus to Default
Litigation—Litigation—Connecticut AG Connecticut AG (Rating Agencies)(Rating Agencies); ; New Orleans, Los Angeles, Stockton New Orleans, Los Angeles, Stockton ( Bond Insurers)( Bond Insurers)
AGFS
10
STANDARD & POOR’S—STANDARD & POOR’S—
““[S&P] uses the same rating scale across the [various] sectors””
““conducting an ongoing review … with goal of further promoting the comparability of our rating opinions””
AGFS
11
MOODY’S—MOODY’S—
AGFS
““we are proposing to transition our public finance ratings to our global
scale””
12
FITCH—FITCH—
AGFS
Indications Are a Move to Single Indications Are a Move to Single “Global” Scale“Global” Scale
13
COLLAPSE OF ARS COLLAPSE OF ARS BONDS BONDS
(RELATED ENFORCEMENT);(RELATED ENFORCEMENT);UNDERWRITER CONFLICTSUNDERWRITER CONFLICTS
AGFS
14AGFS
AUCTION RATE SECURITIESAUCTION RATE SECURITIES
• Long-Term SecuritiesLong-Term Securities
• Rates Change Periodically Rates Change Periodically (e.g., 7, 28, 35 Days)(e.g., 7, 28, 35 Days)
• High Insured RatingsHigh Insured Ratings
• Periodic AuctionsPeriodic Auctions
• No Liquidity AgentNo Liquidity Agent
• Marketed as Highly Rated, Marketed as Highly Rated, Highly Liquid SecuritiesHighly Liquid Securities
15
AUCTION RATE SECURITIESAUCTION RATE SECURITIES
AGFS
Actually, Auction Agents Actually, Auction Agents (Underwriters) Supported Market(Underwriters) Supported Market
Support Levels Not DisclosedSupport Levels Not Disclosed
As Bond Insurers Downgraded, ARS As Bond Insurers Downgraded, ARS Became IlliquidBecame Illiquid
Underwriters Built Enormous Underwriters Built Enormous InventoriesInventories
Damning EmailsDamning Emails
16
AUCTION RATE SECURITIESAUCTION RATE SECURITIES
AGFS
Alleged That Certain Firms—Alleged That Certain Firms—
Discussions of Withdrawing Support Discussions of Withdrawing Support for Marketfor Market
Simultaneous Inventory Sales to Simultaneous Inventory Sales to Investor ClientsInvestor Clients
(Including Local Governments)(Including Local Governments)
Investors Found Illiquidity When Investors Found Illiquidity When Support WithdrawnSupport Withdrawn
17
AUCTION RATE SECURITIESAUCTION RATE SECURITIES
AGFS
Alleged That Certain Firms—Alleged That Certain Firms—
Issuers Experienced Issuers Experienced High Interest High Interest RatesRates under Interest Formulae under Interest Formulae
MotivatedMotivated to Reduce Interest Costs to Reduce Interest Costs
Underwriters “Assisted Issuers” in Underwriters “Assisted Issuers” in Refinancings Refinancings to Other Structuresto Other Structures
““Dream” World for FeesDream” World for Fees
Underwriters Were Large Investors Underwriters Were Large Investors Through InventoriesThrough Inventories
18AGFS
AUCTION RATE SECURITIESAUCTION RATE SECURITIESState Legal ActionsState Legal Actions
• New YorkNew York
• MassachusettsMassachusetts
• TexasTexas
• New Hampshire (for Student Loan New Hampshire (for Student Loan Issuer)Issuer)
• New Orleans (VRDOs)New Orleans (VRDOs)
• Missouri (Reported Pending)Missouri (Reported Pending)
• More Reported PendingMore Reported Pending
19AGFS
AUCTION RATE SECURITIESAUCTION RATE SECURITIESState Legal ActionsState Legal Actions
• Several SettlementsSeveral Settlements
• Buyouts of Retail Customers ($20B)Buyouts of Retail Customers ($20B)
• Refunds of Restructuring Refunds of Restructuring Underwriting Fees to Underwriting Fees to
Some IssuersSome Issuers
• Significant FinesSignificant Fines
20
JEFFERSON COUNTY (AL) JEFFERSON COUNTY (AL) ARS & VRDO DEFAULTS; ARS & VRDO DEFAULTS; PENDING BANKRUPTCYPENDING BANKRUPTCY
AGFS
21
JEFFERSON COUNTYJEFFERSON COUNTY
AGFS
Looming Enormous Municipal Looming Enormous Municipal DefaultDefault
Potential Investor LossesPotential Investor Losses
22
JEFFERSON COUNTYJEFFERSON COUNTY
AGFS
Approximately $3B in Bond Issues in Approximately $3B in Bond Issues in 2003/20042003/2004
Also Substantial Interest Rate SwapsAlso Substantial Interest Rate Swaps
Bond Insurer Downgrades Led to Bond Insurer Downgrades Led to Auction FailuresAuction Failures
Interest Rate IncreasesInterest Rate Increases
Swap TerminationsSwap Terminations
23
JEFFERSON COUNTYJEFFERSON COUNTY
AGFS
Interest Rates BurdensomeInterest Rates Burdensome
Swap Termination Fees HighSwap Termination Fees High
County Forbearance AgreementsCounty Forbearance Agreements
Various Restructuring ProposalsVarious Restructuring Proposals
““End Game” ApproachingEnd Game” Approaching
24
SEC ACTION SEC ACTION AGAINST FORMER SAN DIEGO OFFICIALS AGAINST FORMER SAN DIEGO OFFICIALS
AGFS
25AGFS
SAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSSAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS
OPEB DISCLOSURE ISSUESOPEB DISCLOSURE ISSUES
• CityCity
• City Auditor & Individual PrincipalCity Auditor & Individual Principal
• Former City OfficialsFormer City Officials
26AGFS
SAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSSAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS
OPEB DISCLOSURE ISSUESOPEB DISCLOSURE ISSUES
• OS Disclosure—OS Disclosure—Both Text & Both Text & Financial Statement NotesFinancial Statement Notes
• Continuing (Annual) Disclosure—Continuing (Annual) Disclosure—Financial Statement Notes AgainFinancial Statement Notes Again
• Rating Agency Presentations—Rating Agency Presentations—Indirect Disclosure to Investors & Indirect Disclosure to Investors & MarketMarket
27AGFS
SAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSSAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS
CITY SETTLEDCITY SETTLED
• Cease & Desist OrderCease & Desist Order
• Agreed to Employ Independent Agreed to Employ Independent Consultant to Review & Recommend Consultant to Review & Recommend Improvements in PracticesImprovements in Practices
• Extremely Expensive Internal ReviewExtremely Expensive Internal Review
• Many Years Later, Maybe Ready to Many Years Later, Maybe Ready to Re-Enter MarketRe-Enter Market
28AGFS
SAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSSAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS
AUDITOR SETTLEDAUDITOR SETTLED
• Permanent InjunctionsPermanent Injunctions
• Individual Paid $15,000 Civil PenaltyIndividual Paid $15,000 Civil Penalty
• SEC Challenged Auditor’s SEC Challenged Auditor’s Qualifications, Investigation & Qualifications, Investigation & Knowledge of CityKnowledge of City
DON’T EMPLOY AUDITORS ON FEES ALONE!DON’T EMPLOY AUDITORS ON FEES ALONE!
29AGFS
SAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSSAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS
FORMERFORMER CITY OFFICIALS CITY OFFICIALS(Pending)(Pending)
• City ManagerCity Manager
• City Auditor-ComptrollerCity Auditor-Comptroller
• Deputy City Manager for FinanceDeputy City Manager for Finance
• Assistant City Auditor-ComptrollerAssistant City Auditor-Comptroller
• City TreasurerCity Treasurer
30AGFS
SAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSSAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSFORMERFORMER CITY OFFICIALS CITY OFFICIALS
Penalties Sought Against IndividualsPenalties Sought Against Individuals
• Declaratory ReliefDeclaratory Relief
• Permanent InjunctionsPermanent Injunctions
• Monetary Civil PenaltiesMonetary Civil Penalties
City Recently Denied Legal FeesCity Recently Denied Legal Fees
31
SAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSSAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSFORMERFORMER CITY OFFICIALS CITY OFFICIALS
Changing & Stale InformationChanging & Stale Information
2002 Financial Statements Reported2002 Financial Statements Reported$39.2 MM$39.2 MM NPO NPO
But City Knew 2003 But City Knew 2003 Would Be $51.9 MMWould Be $51.9 MM
AGFS
32
SAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSSAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSFORMERFORMER CITY OFFICIALS CITY OFFICIALS
Undisclosed EstimateUndisclosed Estimate
Estimated PV of Retiree Health Care LiabilityEstimated PV of Retiree Health Care Liability$1.1 Billion$1.1 Billion
AGFS
33
SAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSSAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSFORMERFORMER CITY OFFICIALS CITY OFFICIALS
Predictive or Probability InformationPredictive or Probability Information
““City was aware that the CERS funded ratio would likely fall below [82.3% funded ratio] trigger level””
[Trigger in Manager’s Proposal 1 [Trigger in Manager’s Proposal 1 Required Additional City Contributions]Required Additional City Contributions]
AGFS
34
SAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSSAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSFORMERFORMER CITY OFFICIALS CITY OFFICIALS
Expectation for Future EventExpectation for Future Event
Retiree Health Care Paid in Past from “Surplus Earnings” Retiree Health Care Paid in Past from “Surplus Earnings” in Pension Fund in Pension Fund
Would Have To Be Paid Would Have To Be Paid in Future in Future from from Direct City PaymentsDirect City Payments
AGFS
35
SAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSSAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSFORMERFORMER CITY OFFICIALS CITY OFFICIALS
Expectation for Future EventExpectation for Future Event
City’s City’s ““LoomingLooming Financial Crisis” Financial Crisis”
Unfunded Liability Unfunded Liability ExpectedExpected To Increase To Increase DramaticallyDramaticallyfrom from $720 MM $720 MM in 2003 to in 2003 to $2B $2B in 2009in 2009
EstimatedEstimated Annual Pension Contribution Annual Pension Contribution Would GrowWould Grow from from $51 MM $51 MM in 2002 in 2002
to to $248 MM $248 MM in 2009in 2009
AGFS
36
SAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSSAN DIEGO ENFORCEMENT ACTIONSFORMERFORMER CITY OFFICIALS CITY OFFICIALS
NOTE—NOTE—
In Each Case, SEC Asks for In Each Case, SEC Asks for Disclosure of Disclosure of Present State of KnowledgePresent State of Knowledge
Estimates, Expectations, ProbabilitiesEstimates, Expectations, Probabilities
Uncertainties Also Should Be DisclosedUncertainties Also Should Be Disclosed
Requires Care to Frame InformationRequires Care to Frame Information
AGFS
37
MATERIALITYMATERIALITY
AGFS
38AGFS
MATERIALITYMATERIALITY
DC COURT OF APPEALSDC COURT OF APPEALS
•EachEach “reasonable” investor “reasonable” investor
•Many types of “reasonable” investorsMany types of “reasonable” investors
• Singular, idiosyncratic preference Singular, idiosyncratic preference for for balancing risk & return in unique portfoliobalancing risk & return in unique portfolio
•Different investors Different investors make very make very different different decisionsdecisions
39
SEC LIMITATIONS ON SEC LIMITATIONS ON RELIANCE ON COUNSEL/PROFESSIONALSRELIANCE ON COUNSEL/PROFESSIONALS
AGFS
THE NAKED ISSUERTHE NAKED ISSUER
40AGFS
RELIANCE ON PROFESSIONALSRELIANCE ON PROFESSIONALS
SEC’S FORMULASEC’S FORMULA
• Complete Disclosure to ProfessionalComplete Disclosure to Professional
• Seek Advice as to Appropriateness of Seek Advice as to Appropriateness of Challenged ActionChallenged Action
• Receive Advice Conduct Is AppropriateReceive Advice Conduct Is Appropriate
• Rely on Advice in Good FaithRely on Advice in Good Faith
41
Neshannock Township School District—Neshannock Township School District—
Actually Asked & Received Informal LetterActually Asked & Received Informal Letter
Did Not Read OS or Understand Tax CertificateDid Not Read OS or Understand Tax Certificate
Dolphin & Bradbury—Dolphin & Bradbury—
Bond Counsel Fairness OpinionBond Counsel Fairness Opinion
Underwriter Counsel OpinionUnderwriter Counsel Opinion
““Must Have Known”Must Have Known” AGFS
RELIANCE ON PROFESSIONALSRELIANCE ON PROFESSIONALS(Good Faith)(Good Faith)
42AGFS
RELIANCE ON PROFESSIONALSRELIANCE ON PROFESSIONALS
• Formal Written OpinionFormal Written Opinion((Not Mere Participation Not Mere Participation in Transaction)in Transaction)
• Qualified ProfessionalQualified Professional((Not Least ExpensiveNot Least Expensive))
• Make Complete DisclosureMake Complete Disclosure
• Review CarefullyReview Carefully
• Certifications of ExpertsCertifications of Experts
• Good Faith RelianceGood Faith Reliance
43AGFS
RELIANCE ON RELIANCE ON PROFESSIONALSPROFESSIONALS
• Use Your OwnUse Your Own Counsel/Professional Counsel/Professional
• Not Underwriter CounselNot Underwriter Counsel(Contrast Disclosure Counsel)(Contrast Disclosure Counsel)
• NotNot Underwriter (Adverse) Underwriter (Adverse) • NotNot Developer’s Appraiser/Feasibility Developer’s Appraiser/Feasibility
ConsultantConsultant
44AGFS
RELIANCE ON RELIANCE ON PROFESSIONALSPROFESSIONALS
• Bond Counsel—Bond Counsel—Limited EngagementLimited Engagement
• Fairness Opinion—Fairness Opinion—Limited in ScopeLimited in Scope
• Disclosure Counsel—Disclosure Counsel—Exceptions; Exceptions; Limited ReviewLimited Review
45AGFS
GUESS WHO IS LEFTGUESS WHO IS LEFT
46
IMLA’SIMLA’SFINANCING PROCEDURES CHECKLISTSFINANCING PROCEDURES CHECKLISTS
AGFS
47
THE ENDTHE END
AGFS
Top Related