Zakiya v. U.S. SupCrt No. 06-7116

8/2/2019 Zakiya v. U.S. SupCrt No. 06-7116

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/zakiya-v-us-supcrt-no-06-7116 1/25

Lg, 65(:335

AL PBO

Y_VTOHO IG_TP GE PBO _LAPO@ YPCPOY WWWWWWWWWWWW

KCDCTA [CNAQC,

Vopapaglot

u,

_LAPO@ YPCPOY GE CHOTAIC-D_TOC_ GE VTAYGLY- op cm-

Toyvgl`olpy WWWWWWWWWWWW

Gl Vopapagl Egt Ztap Ge Iotpagtcta Pg Pbo_lapo` Ypcpoy Igtp ge Cvvocmy

Egt pbo Egtpb Iatiap WWWWWWWWWWWW

DTAOE GE VOPAPAGLOT KCDCTA [CNAQC WWWWWWWWWWWW

Kcdcta [cnaqc0166 Sctmoy YP Lo- )0Zcybaljpgl @I, 46631464(916(5912

Vtg Yo



a

S_OYPAGLY VTOYOLPO@

3! @goy pbo Dtoc ge Vtaygly bcuo pbo cpbgtapq pg ahvgyo gt orpol` c vtaygl poth

gl alhcpoy vtyclp pg 32 _YI ª 9540"o!- cy ap imcahy7

4! Ae lgp- à` pbo àyptaip igtp ott al tmalj- cl` pbo Egtpb Iatiap al ceeathalj-

pbcp pbo DGV*y cipagly zoto $tocyglcdmo$- cl` pby vtgpoipo` lòt pbo $ò icto$

vtguayagl ge pbo Eoòtcm Pgtp Imcahy Cip cjcalyp yap egt `chcjoy- egt ahvtayglalj

cl alhcpo egt guot 9 qocty vcyp bay tomocyo `cpo- cl cip zbaib zcy egl` pg do

ammojcm dq glo àyptaip igtp zbaib gtòto` pbo alhcpo*y ahhoàcpo tomocyo- cl` egt

zbaib clgpbot àyptaip igtp cmmgzo` yap cjcalyp pbo jguotlholp egt pboyo cipagly7



aa

VCTPAOY PG PBO VTGIOO@ALJ

Vopapaglot ay Kcdcta [cnaqc,

Toyvgl`olpy cto pbo _lapo` Ypcpoy ge Chotaic- Dtoc ge Vtaygly- op cm,



aaa

PCDMO GE IGLPOLPY

S_OYPAGLY VTOYOLPO@ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, a

VCTPAOY PG PBO VTGIOO@ALJ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, aa

PCDMO GE C_PBGTAPAOY ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, au

IAPCPAGLY PG GVALAGLY ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 3

K_TAY@AIPAGL ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 3

YPCPOHOLP GE PBO ICYO ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 4

Y_HHCTQ GE CTJ_HOLP ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 36

CTJ_HOLP ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 33

A, 32 _YI ª 9540"o! @GOY LGP JAUO PBO D_TOC_ GE VTAYGLYC_PBGTAPQ PG AHVGYO GT ORPOL@ C VTAYGL YOLPOLIO ,,,,,, 33

AA,TOYVGLOLP*Y @OIAYAGLY CL@ CIPAGLY PG AL@OEALAPOMQAHVTAYGL CL ALHCPO VCYP BAY YPCP_PGTAMQ HCL@CPO@TOMOCYO @CPO ZOTO $ZTGLJE_M CIPY$ CL@ PB_Y

LGP VTGPOIPO@ ETGH MACDAMAPQ DQ PBO $@_O ICTO$VTGUAYAGL GE PBO EO@OTCM PGTP IMCAHY CIP,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 3?

IGLIM_YAGL ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,3:



au

PCDMO GE C_PBGTAPAOY

Icyoy; Vcjo

Ichaloppa u, _lapo` Ypcpoy- 404 _,Y, 0:6 "313:! ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,34

Bcpcbmoq u, _lapo` Ypcpoy- 9?3 _,Y, 3:9 "31?5! ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,3?(3:

Bammhcl u, ATY- 4?6 E,9` 442 "0pb Iat, 4663! ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,34

Tgyy u, Pbghvygl- 14: E,Yvv, 1?5 "L,@,Z,Uc, 3115! ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, vcyyah

_lapo` Ypcpoy u, Kgblygl- 02 E,9` 265 "0pb Iat, 311?! ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?-1-36-30

_lapo` Ypcpoy u, Hammot- :: E,9` :3 "0pb Iat, 3115! ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,0-?-1-36-30

_lapo` Ypcpoy u, Hgtpahot- 10 E,9` 21 "4l` Iat, 3115! ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 1

_lapo` Ypcpoy u, Vtgpq- 969 E,9` 3401 "33pb Iat, 4664! ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 1

[cnaqc u, Tolg- ?4 E,Yvv,4` 541 "O,@,Uc, 3111! ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, vcyyah

Ypcpupoy;

32 _,Y,I, ª 9530 ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,33

32 _,Y,I, ª 953? ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,33

32 _,Y,I, ª 9543"c! ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,33-39

32 _,Y,I, ª 9540"c! ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 9-34-39

32 _,Y,I, ª 9540"d! ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,34

32 _,Y,I, ª 9540"o! ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, vcyyah

42 _,Y,I, ª 4526 ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,3?



u

PCDMO GE C_PBGTAPAOY(Iglpaluo`

Hayiommcloguy;

Mojcm Toygtio Jaò Pg Pbo Eoòtcm Dtoc Ge Vtaygly ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 1

Dtoc Ge Vtaygly Vtgjtch Ypcpoholp "DGV VY! ?926,6?Yolpolio Ighvpcpagl Hclcm "IIIC ge 3120! ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 4

Dtoc Ge Vtaygly Vtgjtch Ypcpoholp "DGV VY! ?226,42Yolpolio Ighvpcpagl Hclcm "IIIC ge 3120! ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,36-34-35

Alòr ge Cvvolàioy

Cvvolàr C @oiayagly ge pbo Egtpb Iatiap

Cvvolàr D @oiayagly _,Y, @ayptaip Igtp Lgtpbotl @ayptaip ge Z,Uc,

Cvvolàr I @oiayagl _,Y, @ayptaip Igtp egt @ayptaip ge Igmhdac

Cvvolàr @ [cnaqc u, Tolg- ?4 E,Yvv,4` 541 "O,@,Uc 3111!

Cvvolàr O Tgyy u, Pbghvygl- 14: E,Yvv 1?5 "L,@,Z,Uc 3115!



3

IAPCPAGLY PG GVALAGLY

Pbo gvalagl ge pbo _lapo` Ypcpoy Igtp ge Cvvocmy egt pbo Egtpb Iatiap

ay yop egtpb al Cvvolàr C, Pbo gtòt ge pbo _lapo` Ypcpoy @ayptaip Igtp egt pbo

Lgtpbotl @ayptaip ge Zoyp Uatjalac ay yop egtpb al Cvvolàr D, Pbo gtòt ge pbo

_lapo` Ypcpoy @ayptaip Igtp egt pbo @ayptaip ge Igmhdac ay yop egtpb al Cvvolàr

I, Pbo gtòt cl` gvalagl ge pbo _lapo` Ypcpoy @ayptaip Igtp egt pbo Ocypotl

@ayptaip ge Uatjalc cy tovgtpo` al [cnaqc u, Tolg- ?4 E,Yvv,4` 541 "O,@,UC,

3111! 541 ay yop egtpb al Cvvolàr @, Pbo gtòt cl` gvalagl ge pbo _lapo` Ypcpoy

@ayptaip Igtp egt pbo Lgtpbotl @ayptaip ge Zoyp Uatjalac cy tovgtpo` al Tgyy u,

Pbghvygl- 14: E,Yvv, 1?5 "L,@,Z,UC, 3115! ay yop egtpb al Cvvolàr O,

K_TAY@AIPAGL

Pbo k`jholp ge pbo _lapo` Ypcpoy Igtp ge Cvvocmy egt pbo Egtpb Iatiap

ceeathalj pbo àyptaip igtp zcy olpoto` Hcq 32- 4665- cl` òlqalj toboctalj zcy

olpoto` gl Kmq 32- 4665, Pbay Igtp bcy ktayàipagl lòt 42 _,Y,I, ª 34?0"3!,



4

YPCPOHOLP GE PBO ICYO

Pbay icyo alugmuoy hib hgto pbcl yahvmq zbopbot Vopapaglot bcy pbo Tajbp

pg yo pbo jguotlholp egt doalj ammojcmmq ahvtayglo` egt guot 9 qocty- ygmomq gl

pbo òiayagl ge cl Oroipauo Dtclib geeaiot, Tcpbot- pbo lòtmqalj tcpaglcmo- ypamm

cyyotpo` dq pbo jguotlholp- pg ahvgyo lgl(kàiacm "alòealapo! vtaygl pothy gl

alhcpoy- zbaib ceeoipy ouotq votygl bom` al iypg`q dq pbo jguotlholp- ay pbo

ayyo zbaib jauoy tayo pg pbo icyo ge cipagl ge pbay icyo,

Pbay imcah ge cpbgtapq àtoipmq iglemaipy zapb- cl` vpy al kogvct`q- pbo

Iglypappaglcmmq uoypo` cpbgtapq ge pbo Igtpy pg do pbo ygmo dtclib ge

jguotlholp bcualj pbo vgzot pg ahvgyo vtaygl pothy gl vogvmo zbg bcuo dool

`mq ibctjo`- ptao`- cl` igluaipo`- ge itahoy, Pbay ayyo doighoy ouol hgto

ahvgtpclp lgz- cy ap mojcmmq yojoy alpg pbo cyygiacpo` ayyo ge pbo imcaho`

cpbgtapq ge pbo Oroipauo Dtclib pg òpcal cl` ahvtaygl vogvmo lòt pbo tdtai

ge pbo $zct gl pottgtayh,$

Pbo Dtoc ge Vtaygly "DGV! bcy itocpo` pbo Alhcpoy Ealcliacm

Toyvglyadamapq Vtgjtch "AETV!3, _lòt pbo AETV pbo DGV cppohvpy pg egtio

alhcpoy pg vcq igtp ahvgyo` ealoy cl` toypappagl zbamo ahvtayglo`,

Vopapaglot Kcdcta [cnaqc "c eatyp paho ”geeolòt‘! yome(yttolòto` pg pbo

halahh yoitapq vtaygl cp EIA Hgtjclpgzl- Z,Uc gl Zo`loy`cq- Kclctq 0-

3 DGV Vgmaiq Ypcpoholp VY ?926,6?



9

311? pg yotuo c 35 hglpb yolpolio toympalj etgh c igluaipagl gl pcr tomcpo`

ibctjoy, C "ypcppgtq hcrahh! 4?N ealo zcy alimò` al pbo yolpolio, Zapb

pbo cvvmaicpagl ge ypcppgtamq hcl`cpo` jgg` paho itoàp4 bay yibo`mo` tomocyo `cpo

zcy pg do Pbty`cq- Eodtctq 41- 3115,

Vtagt pg bay tomocyo- pbo DGV cppohvpo` pg jop [cnaqc pg yajl c egth papmo`

”Alypcmmholp Yibo`mo Cjtooholp egt _lvca` Ealoy,‘ Pbay $Cjtooholp$ ypcpoy;

A cjtoo pg vcq- zbamo lòt yvotuayo` tomocyo- pbo tohcalalj

dcmclio gl clq ealo tomcpauo pg pbo geeolyo lòt zbaib A chighhappo`,,, A cmyg lòtypcl` pbcp ecamto pg cjtoo pg c`botopg pbay alypcmmholp yibo`mo hcq òmcq ge vtouolp hq tomocyoetgh alictiotcpagl, "[cnaqc cp 596!

Pbo `cq doegto bay hcl`cpo` tomocyo- pbo DGV vtoyolpo` pbay egth pg [cnaqc-

cjcal- cl` ypcpo` pbcp ae bo à` lgp yajl ap bo zgm` lgp do tomocyo` cl` zgm` do

bom` alòealapomq lpam bo yajlo` ap- imcahalj 32 _YI ª 9540"o! cpbgta{o` pbay,

[cnaqc orvmcalo` pg DGV geeaiacmy pbcp 9540"o! itocpo` lg ypcppgtq tosatoholp pg

yajl pbay egth pg do tomocyo` etgh vtaygl- cl` pboat alpotvtopcpagl ge ap iglemaipo`

zapb pbo imoct hcl`cpo ge 32 _YI ª 9540"c! pg tomocyo vtaygloty zbol pboat vtaygl

pothy orvato`, Bo- pby- toeyo` pg yajl ap- zbotovgl bo zcy bclìeeo`-

ybcinmo`- cl` pbtgzl al ”pbo bgmo,‘

[cnaqc zcy bom` al ”pbo bgmo‘ zbamo DGV cl` @ovctpholp ge Kypaio "@GK!

geeaiacmy al pbo _,Y, Cppgtloq Jolotcmy geeaio ptao` pg eajto gp zbcp pg `g zapb

4 $Jgg` Paho$ itoàp zcy attougicdmo lòt pbo ypcppo zbol [cnaqc zcy yolpolio ,



0

bah, Pbay zcy doicyo [cnaqc zcy pbo eatyp votygl al baypgtq lgp pg do tomocyo`

dcyo` gl pbay loz imcaho` DGV cpbgtapq- cl` pboto zoto lg vtgio`toy- gt

vtoioòlp- egt `galj ap, Ealcmmq- cepot pzg zoony- [cnaqc zcy tomocyo` dcin alpg

pbo jolotcm vgvmcpagl ge EIA Hgtjclpgzl- ahvtayglo` lgz ygmomq gl pbo

òiayagl ge- vtoyhcdmq- pbo _,Y, Cppgtloq Jolotcm- Kclop Tolg,

[cnaqc pbol eamo` c bcdocy igtvy- eatyp uac bay Vgzot ge Cppgtloq- zapb bay

yolpolialj igtp- K`jo K,Etoòtain Hgp{- ge pbo _,Y, @ayptaip Igtp ge Hctqmcl`-

Dcmpahgto- H@, K`jo Hgp{ toeyo` pg ciiovp pbo bcdocy cl` ptclyeotto` ap pg pbo

Lgtpbotl @ayptaip ge Z,Uc,, Glio tomocyo` etgh ”pbo bgmo‘ [cnaqc cmyg eamo` zapb

pbo L,@,Z,Uc, Pbo icyo zcy cyyajlo` pg K`jo Zammach Na``,

Gl Hcq 3- 3115- K`jo Na``- al Tgyy u, Pbghvygl- 14: E,Yvv, 1?5

"L,@,Z,Uc 3115!- òlao` bcdocy- ypcpalj al Tgyy cp 1?2;

Iglptctq pg vopapaglot*y ctjholp- bo ay lgp doalj bom` hotomqvgl cl leglò` alpotlcm DGV vgmaiq, Pbo DGV vgmaiq cl`

vtgio`to cto yoitomq jtglò` al cl` cpbgta{o` dq pboIgljtoyyaglcm hcl`cpo ge 32 _YI ª 9540"o!, Pbo DGV ayegmmgzalj cl` icttqalj gp pbo ypcppgtq `pq cyyajlo` pg ap,

^4X Vopapaglot*y gpbot ctjholp- dcyo` vgl _,Y, u, Hammot -:: E,9` :3- ::(:2 "0pb Iat, 3115!- ay pbcp glmq pbo yolpolialjigtp bcy cpbgtapq pg yop pbo chglp cl` pahalj ge ealo

vcqholpy- lgp pbo DGV, Zbamo vopapagl*y ypcpoholp ge mcz ayigttoip- bay tomaclio pbotovgl ay hayvmcio` , "ohvbcyay!

Al tmalj yg- K`jo Na`` ecamo` pg vbgm` pbo hcl`cpoy ge _,Y, u, Hammot- :: E,9`

:3 "0pb Iat, 3115!- zbaib zcy ayyo` Hctib 5- 3115- glo zoon cepot [cnaqc*y



?

tomocyo `cpo, Egmmgzalj al pbo eggpvtalpy ge _,Y, u, Kgblygl- 02 E,9` 265 "0pb Iat,

311?!- Hammot cp ::(:2 tmo`;

Al _lapo` Ypcpoy u, Kgblygl- 02 E,9` 265- 262(61 "0pb Iat, 311?!zo bom` pbcp c àyptaip igtp mciny cpbgtapq pg òmojcpo pg pbo

vtgdcpagl geeaiot pbo ealcm cpbgtapq pg òpothalo pbo chglp ge toypappaglctq alypcmmholp vcqholpy- zapbgp topcalalj mpahcpocpbgtapq guot yib òiayagly, "::!

Mano toypappagl- pbo ypcppgtq `pq ahvgyo` vgl àyptaip igtpypg ear pbo pothy ge c ealo hyp do toc` cy orimyauo doicyo pboahvgyapagl ge c yolpolio- alimàlj pbo pothy ge vtgdcpagl gt

yvotuayo` tomocyo- ay c igto kàiacm elipagl, Ciigtàljmq- zobgm` c àyptaip igtp hcq lgp òmojcpo apy cpbgtapq pg yop pbochglp cl` pahalj ge ealo vcqholpy pg pbo Dtoc ge Vtayglygt pbo vtgdcpagl geeaiot , ":2! "ohvbcyay!

Pbo DGV*y cipagly imoctmq ytvo` pbo igto kuàiacm eulipagl ge pbo yolpolialj

igtp pg yop ealo vcqholp yibo`moy cl` ahvgyo c yolpolio, Pbo Egtpb Iatiap

ceeatho` Tgyy- cmyg ecamalj pg vbgm` apy gzl tmaljy al Hammot cl` Kgblygl,

Cepot cmhgyp pzg qocty ge doalj ahvtayglo` vcyp bay tomocyo `cpo cp EIA

Hgtjclpgzl- [cnaqc zcy ptclyeotto` al Eodtctq 3112 pg pbo hoàh yoitapq

vtaygl EIA Vopotydtj- Uc,- cepot eatyp yvolàlj pzg zoony al ptclyap cp pbo

hcrahh yoitapq vtaygl EIA Mozaydtj- Vc, Cy ap zgtno` gp- ae lgp egt pbay

ptclyeot [cnaqc hcq ypamm do ahvtayglo`,

Doegto doalj ptclyeotto`- [cnaqc bc` eamo` c bcdocy cl` iauam mczyap al pbo

_,Y, @ayptaip Igtp egt pbo @ayptaip ge Igmhdac cjcalyp pbo DGV @atoipgt cl` _,Y,

Cppgtloq Jolotcm Kclop Tolg, _vgl bay ptclyeot pg EIA Vopotydtj- pbo @I Igtp



5

ptclyeotto` pbo bcdocy pg pbo _,Y, @ayptaip Igtp egt pbo Ocypotl @ayptaip ge Uc,

Pbo icyo zcy cyyajlo` pg K`jo Moglao Dtalnohc,

K`jo Dtalnohc òlao` pbo gtajalcm ptclyeotto` vtg yo bcdocy, Minamq-

[cnaqc- zbg bc` louot dool ceegtò` iglyom cp clq paho- pbtgjb bay igyal-

ealcmmq zcy cdmo pg topcal vtg dglg iglyom- zbg tolozo` pbo bcdocy,

_vgl touaoz ge pbo hotapy ge pbo DGV'@GK*y imcaho` cpbgtapq pg ahvtaygl

[cnaqc "egt maeo! vcyp bay tomocyo `cpo- K`jo Dtalnohc- al [cnaqc u, Tolg- ?4

E,Yvv,4` 541 "O,@,Uc 3111!- ohvbcpaicmmq todno` pbo ycho imcahy K`jo Na``

iapo` zoto ”yoitomq jtglò`‘ al Igljtoyyaglcm cpbgtapq> [cnaqc cp 590(95;

Ae zo ciiovp pbo DGV*y tocàlj ge pbo ypcpo ^yaiX- zooeeoipauomq hyp eal` pbcp Igljtoyy òmojcpo` pg pbo DGV-cl oroipauo dtclib cjoliq- pbo cpbgtapq pg orpol` còeol`clp*y yolpolio doqgl` pbcp gtòto` dq cl Ctpaimo AAAigtp, Yib c vtgvgyapagl zgm` iglptcuolo dcyai polopy ge yovctcpagl ge vgzoty cl` toymp al cl liglypappaglcmòmojcpagl ge kàiacm vgzot pg pbo oroipauo dtclib, "590(?!

^9-0X Ciiovpalj pbo toyvglòlp*y tocàlj ge ª 9540"o!zgm` pby tosato y pg yptano pbo ypcppo cy clliglypappaglcm òmojcpagl ge kàiacm vgzot pg pbooroipauo dtclib, "595!

K`jo Dtalnohc ayyo` pbo tmalj gl Hcq 0- 3111- gtòtalj [cnaqc*y ahhoàcpo

tomocyo, Pbo DGV'@GK tomocyo` [cnaqc pbo lorp `cq- Hcq ?- 3111- ibggyalj lgp

pg cyn egt c ypcq pg cvvocm pg pbo Egtpb Iatiap- zbaib bc` vtouagymq ceeatho`

K`jo Na``*y tmalj al Tgyy gl pbo orcip ycho ayyoy, [cnaqc zcy pby tomocyo`-

cepot bcualj yvolp guot 9 qocty cl` 4 hglpby "3354 `cqy! ammojcmmq ahvtayglo` vcyp



:

bay tomocyo `cpo egt bay gtajalcm 35 hglpby yolpolio,

_vgl bay tomocyo- [cnaqc topcalo` iglyom- cl` al Cvtam 4663 dojcl pbo

c`halayptcpauo vtgioyy pg yoon tomaoe egt `chcjoy egt bay ammojcm ahvtayglholp, Al

Hctib 4664- [cnaqc eamo` yap al pbo _,Y,@,I egt @I- cl` pbo icyo zcy cyyajlo` pg

K`jo Tojjao Zcmpgl, K`jo Zcmpgl òlao` Toyvglòlpy* Hgpagl pg @ayhayy-

toigjla{alj hmpavmo cmmgzcdmo imcahy cjcalyp pboh- ypcpalj al bay gvalagl pbcp pbo

”alpotoypy ge kypaio tosatoy‘ pbcp [cnaqc ybgm` vtyo bay imcahy, Bgzouot- al

Hcq 4660- K`jo Zcmpgl ptclyeotto` pbo icyo dcin pg pbo L,@,Z,Uc cp pbo tosoyp

ge Toyvglòlpy,

K`jo Atolo Noomoq zcy cyyajlo` pbo icyo, Alypoc` ge lgz jgalj pg ptacm gt

yoonalj c yoppmoholp- Toyvglòlpy eamo` clgpbot Hgpagl pg @ayhayy9, Bcualj pbo

ycho icyo baypgtq K`jo Zcmpgl bc`- vmy bay òiayagl- K`jo Noomoq guotptlo`

K`jo Zcmpgl*y òiayagl- cl` jtclpo` Toyvglòlpy* Hgpagl pg @ayhayy pboq bc`

mgyp al @I- pby yscybalj [cnaqc*y Tajbp pg jg pg ptacm zgl etgh pbo @I Igtp,

Pbo dcyay egt K`jo Noomoq*y tmalj zcy pbcp Toyvglòlpy zoto jtclpo`

vtgpoipagl lòt pbo ”ò icto‘ vtguayagl ge pbo Eoòtcm Pgtp Imcahy Cip "EPIC!

doicyo pbo ammojcmmq gtòto` alòealapo ahvtayglholp ge [cnaqc zcy ”tocyglcdmo‘

ygmomq doicyo bot Igtp al Tgyy bc` vtouagymq tmo` ap pg do yg,

9 Pbay Hgpagl zcy alc`hayyadmo lòt pbo Eoòtcm Tmoy ge Iauam Vtgio`toy- doicyo ap tcayo` lg loz ayyoy- cl`Toyvglòlpy zoto tosato` pg cvvocm pbo olacm ge pboat àyhayycm hgpagl pg pbo @I Igtp ge Cvvocmy, Dq lgpcvvocmalj apy òlacm dq K`jo Zcmpgl- Toyvglòlpy bc` ciiovpo` pbo uotàip ge pbo Igtp- cl` egteoapo` pbo Tajbp pgiglpoyp pbcp tmalj al pbo cvvtgvtacpo Cvvocmy Igtp ktayàipagl- gt tcayo ap al clq gpbot Igtp, Pbo Hgpagl uagmcpo`K`jo Zcmpgl*y tmalj pbcp [cnaqc zgm` do cmmgzo` pg vtyo pbo cmmgzo` imcahy al Zoyp Uatjalac,



2

Al pbo alypclp icyo- pbo Dtoc ge Vtaygl*y cipagly zotocvvtguo` dq pbay Igtp cl` pbo Egtpb Iatiap Igtp ge Cvvocmy "iapoy ghappo`!, Iglyosolpmq- ap ay tocyglcdmo

pg iglimò pbcp pbo DGV pama{o` ò icto al orotiayaljapy `paoy, "Noomoq Cvv, D- v1!

Al yg tmalj- K`jo Noomoq hayypcpoy pbo tmalj ge pbo Egtpb Iatiap al Tgyy-

zbaib zcy cl lvdmaybo` vot itach òiayagl zbaib hotomq ceeatho` pbo òlacm

ge [cnaqc*y bcdocy cl` à` lgp c``toyy pbo DGV*y imcaho` cpbgtapq vot 9540"o!,

K`jo Noomoq cmyg ecamo` pg cvvmq pbo $ò icto$ vtguayagl igttoipmq- cy ap glmq

cvvmaoy pg $mczem olegtioholp$ cipagly, Dp K`jo Dtalnohc cl` K`jo Zcmpgl

bc` dgpb tmo` pbo jguotlholp*y cipagly zoto ammojcm "cl` pby lgp vtgpoipo`!-

ealàljy zbaib K`jo Noomoq à` lgp c``toyy- iglpoyp- gt toigliamo al bot tmalj,

[cnaqc zcy- pby- lgz egtio` pg cvvocm- cjcal- pg pbo Egtpb Iatiap- zbaib

bo zcy egtio` pg `g- cjcal- vtg yo cepot bay iglyom moep bay icyo glio gl cvvocm, C

pzg k`jo vclom0 ceeatho` pbo ayptaip igtp òiayagl gl Hcq 32- 4665, C Vopapagl

egt Toboctalj zcy òlao` gl Kmq 32- 4665,

Pbo tchaeaicpagly ge pbay icyo ect orioo` pbo àtoip iglyosolioy pg [cnaqc,

Pbo DGV bcy c lcpaglcm Vtgjtch- zapb Vgmaiaoy ap emclpy- imcahalj cpbgtapq pg

ahvtaygl vogvmo vcyp pboat tomocyo `cpoy lmoyy pboq ighvmq zapb vcqholp

0 Gtajalcm vclom hohdot K`jo K, Haibocm Mppaj lorvoipo`mq toyajlo` etgh pbo Egtpb Iatiap gl Hcq 36- 4665-2 `cqy doegto pbay òiayagl zcy ayyo`- cl` à` lgp mol` bay lcho pg ap, K`jo Mppaj vtoyaò` guot Vcàmmc u, Bclep-cl` al @oiohdot 466? vdmaimq itapaia{o` pbo jguotlholp- zbol 4 `cqy doegto apy Yvtoho Igtp eamalj òc`malo-ealcmmq ibctjo` Vcàmmc lòt itahalcm ibctjoy àeeotolp etgh pbgyo cmmojo` pg kypaeq bay alòealapo hamapctqòpolpagl, Al cljot guot pboyo àyitovcliaoy- bo cppohvpo` pg àycmmgz hgualj Vcàmmc etgh hamapctq pg iauamacliypg`q, Cvvctolpmq- bay àyhcq zapb pbo vclom al pbay icyo- òcmalj cjcal zapb pbo alòealapo ahvtayglholp ge clChotaicl iapa{ol dq pbo Oroipauo Dtclib- iglptadpo` pg bay òiayagl pg sap pbo Igtp- cepot 3? qocty gl ap,



1

yibo`moy ap itocpoy egt vogvmo zbamo al vtaygl- cl`'gt cy c iglàpagl egt tomocyo,

Pbo DGV iapoy al apy Vgmaiq Ypcpoholpy? cl` Jaòy5 pbcp Tgyy jauoy pboh pbay

cpbgtapq- yomoipauomq ajlgtalj [cnaqc*y todno ge pbay ycho cmmojo` cpbgtapq,

Yahamctmq- pbo Egtpb Iatiap bcy ecamo` pg cvvmq cl` olegtio pbo ypcppoy- pbo

_,Y, Iglypappagl- cl` ouol apy gzl icyo vtoioòlp- al c mgjaicm- mojcm- iglyaypolp-

cl` Iglypappaglcmmq tosato`- hcllot,

Pby- pboto orayp imoct iglemaipy- al àchoptaicmmq gvvgyalj ztappol gvalagly-

zapbal pbo àyptaip igtpy zapbal pbo Egtpb Iatiap gl pbo ayyoy pbay icyo tcayoy,

Pboto oraypy c imoct iglemaip dopzool pbo @I Igtp cl` pbo L,@,Z,Uc, cl` Egtpb

Iatiap, Gpbot àyptaip cl` iatiap igtpy igho `gzl ysctomq gl pbo yaò ge pbo

tmaljy alugno` al Kgblygl cl` Hammot,:

Ae [cnaqc ay lgp cmmgzo` pg yo Toyvglòlpy egt bay kàiacmmq bom` ammojcm

ahvtayglholp- pbol pbo DGV'@GK zamm bcuo ictpo dmclibo pg iglpalo pg cvvmq apy

ammojcm AETV vgmaiaoy- zapbgp eoct ge vlaybholp gt ciiglpcdamapq- cl` yo pbay

tmalj- cy ap*y `galj zapb Tgyy- pg kypaeq uagmcpalj pbo Tajbpy ge clq votygl bom` al

apy iypg`q,

Ighdalalj pbo vtoioòlp pbay icyo zgm` itocpo- zapb pbo Oroipauo

Dtclib*y imcah ge lamcpotcm cpbgtapq pg alòealapomq òpcal cl` ahvtaygl clqglo

mcdomo` c $pottgtayp$- zgm` itocpo cl cmhgyp ahvoloptcdmo ybaom` cjcalyp macdamapq

? DGV Vgmaiq Ypcpoholp VY ?226,425 Mojcm Toygtio Jaò Pg Pbo Eoòtcm Dtoc Ge Vtaygly "4660!> zzz,dgv,jgu'lozy'V@Ey'mojcmWjaò,vè : Yoo _,Y, u, Hgtpahot- 10 E,9` 21 "4l` Iat, 3115!- _,Y, u, Vtgpq- 969 E,9` 3401 "33pbo Iat, 4664!- op cm



36

etgh cipy vogvmo icl vtguo pg do ammojcm cl`'gt liglypappaglcm- pby oeeoipauomq

tolòtalj vogvmo*y Tajbp pg yo pbo jguotlholp lmm(cl`(uga` egt yib cipy, Zapb

pbo alitocyalj lhdot ge egtoajl alàua`cmy cl` iapa{oly egl` pg do ammojcmmq gt

lkypaeacdmq òpcalo` gt ahvtayglo` dq pbo jguotlholp- pbay doighoy cl tjolp

ayyo pbo Igtp ybgm` c``toyy- pg vtgpoip vogvmo*y Tajbpy pg bcuo pboat jtaouclioy

cl` yapy egt `chcjoy- cjcalyp ammojcm jguotlholp cipagly- boct` doegto c ktq,

Y_HHCTQ GE CTJ_HOLP

Pbo Lgtpbotl @ayptaip ge Zoyp Uatjalac igtp òiayagly tmalj pbo DGV bcy

ypcppgtq cpbgtapq pg ahvtaygl vogvmo vcyp pbo ol` ge pboat kàiacmmq ahvgyo`

vtaygl pothy- cl` cto ybaomò` etgh macdamapq egt `galj yg- cto al ottgt- cl` pbo

Egtpb Iatiap*y ceeathalj ge pboyo tmaljy cto cmyg al ottgt, Pboyo òiayagly cto al

àchoptai iglemaip zapb K`jo Dtalnohc*y al [cnaqc u, Tolg- zbg al gtòtalj

[cnaqc*y ahhoàcpo tomocyo egt doalj ammojcmmq ahvtayglo` egt guot 9 qocty vcyp bay

tomocyo `cpo- tmo` pbo DGV bcy lg cpbgtapq pg ahvgyo c yolpolio- lgt pg orpol`

glo ahvgyo` dq cl Ctpaimo AAA Igtp- cl` pbcp Igljtoyy à` lgp òmojcpo pbay

cpbgtapq al 32 _YI ª 9540"o! pg pbo Oroipauo Dtclib, Cmyg- pbo Egtpb Iatiap*y

gzl icyo vtoioòlp al _,Y u, Kgblygl cl` _,Y, u, Hammot todp pboyo iglpolpagly,

Pboyo òiayagly cmyg iglemaip zapb pbo ealàljy ge K`jo Zcmpgl ge pbo @,I, Igtp-

zbg toigjla{o` igjla{cdmo imcahy ge macdamapq cjcalyp pbo jguotlholp, Pby- pbo

àyhayycm ge [cnaqc*y mczyap ybgm` do guotptlo`- cl` cmmgzo` pg jg egtzct`,



33

CTJ_HOLP

A, 32 _YI ª 9540"o! @GOY LGP JAUO PBO D_TOC_ GE VTAYGLY

C_PBGTAPQ PG AHVGYO GT ORPOL@ C VTAYGL YOLPOLIO

32 _YI ª 9543- papmo` $Ahvtayglholp ge c igluaipo` votygl$- al yoipagl "c!

vtguaòy pbo ypcppgtq dcyay egt pbo ighhapholp ge vogvmo pg pbo DGV,

"c! Ighhapholp pg Iypg`q ge Dtoc ge Vtaygly- (( C votyglzbg bcy dool yolpolio` pg c poth ge ahvtayglholp vtyclp pgpbo vtguayagly ge ydibcvpot @ ge ibcvpot 44: ybcmm do ighhappo`pg pbo iypg`q ge pbo Dtoc ge Vtaygly lpam pbo orvatcpagl ge pbo

poth ahvgyo`- gt octmaot tomocyo` egt ycpayecipgtq dobcuagt vtyclp pg pbo vtguayagly ge yoipagl 9540, "ohvbcyay!

32 _YI ª 9540- papmo` $Tomocyo ge c vtayglot$- vtguaòy al yoipagl "c!;

"c! @cpo ge Tomocyo,(( C vtayglot ybcmm do tomocyo` dq pboDtoc ge Vtaygly gl pbo `cpo ge pbo orvatcpagl ge pbo

vtayglot*y poth ge ahvtayglholp- moyy clq itoàpo` pgzct` pboyotuaio ge pbo vtayglot*y yolpolio cy vtguaò` al ydyoipagl "d!,

Pbo DGV cvvmao` $jgg` paho$ itoàp pg [cnaqc*y 35 hglpb yolpolio- zbaib dojcl

Kclctq 0- 311?- cl` icmimcpo` bay tomocyo `cpo cy Eodtctq 41- 3115,

Pbo DGV- bgzouot- toeyo` pg tomocyo [cnaqc- imcahalj pbo mcyp yolpolio ge

9540"o! cpbgta{o` ap pg alòealapomq ahvtaygl bah vcyp bay tomocyo `cpo lpam bo

yajlo` pbo $Cjtooholp$- itocpo` vtyclp pg apy Alhcpoy Ealcliacm Toyvglyadamapq

Vtgjtchy "AETV!- pg c`boto pg c vcqholp yibo`mo egt c ealo pbcp zgm` do itocpo`

dq c vtgdcpagl geeaiot cepot bo zcy tomocyo` etgh vtaygl pg $yvotuayo` tomocyo,$

Bgzouot- ahvtayglholp ge vogvmo egt lglvcqholp ge ealoy ay cmyg c kàiacm vgzot

igàeao` al 32 _,Y,I, ªª 9530 cl` 953?- cinlgzmo`jo` al DGV VY ?226,42,



34

32 _YI ª 9540"o! ay papmo` $Yvotuayagl cepot Tomocyo$- hoclalj tomocyo

etgh ahvtayglholp dq pbo DGV- cl` $yvotuayagl$ dq c vtgdcpagl geeaiot- dojaly;

C vtayglot zbgyo yolpolio alimòy c poth ge yvotuayo`tomocyo cepot ahvtayglholp ybcmm do tomocyo` dq pbo Dtocge Vtaygly pg pbo yvotuayagl ge c vtgdcpagl geeaiot,,,

Pbo mcyp yolpolio ge 9540"o! ypcpoy;

Lg vtayglot ybcmm do tomocyo` gl yvotuayagl lmoyy yib vtayglot cjtooy pg c`boto pg cl alypcmmholp yibo`mo- lgp pgorioo` pzg qocty oriovp al yvoiacm iatihypclioy- pg vcq egt

clq ealo ahvgyo` egt pbo geeolyo ighhappo` dq yib vtayglot,

[cnaqc bc` c 9 qoct poth ge yvotuayo` tomocyo pg yotuo cepot bay vtaygl poth,

Pbo DGV toeyo` pg ighvmq zapb pbo imoct $vmcal mcljcjo$ hcl`cpo ge pbo eatyp

yolpolio ge 9540"o! cl` tomocyo [cnaqc pg c vtgdcpagl geeaiot pg dojal bay poth ge

yvotuayo` tomocyo, Pbo mcyp yolpolio ge 9540"o! ay lgp cl alyptipagl pg pbo DGV

gl tomocyalj vogvmo etgh vtaygl- dp cl alyptipagl pg vtgdcpagl geeaioty gl pbo

tomocyo ge vogvmo gl $yvotuayagl$- a,o, yvotuayo` tomocyo,

Dq vmcal mcljcjo ypcppgtq clcmqyay2- c bcthglagy tocàlj ge cmm pbo

tomouclp ypcppoy votpcalalj pg ighhapholp ge vtaygloty pg pbo DGV- cl` pboat

tomocyo- hcl`cpo pbo DGV icl glmq "hyp! toìo vtaygl pothy vot 9540"d! cl`

pbol hyp tomocyo vogvmo zbol pboat pothy bcuo orvato` vtyclp pg 9540"c!, 1

[cnaqc ay pbo eatyp votygl al _,Y, baypgtq pboyo ypcppoy à` lgp cvvmq pg,

2 $Pbo jolotcm tmo ay pbcp lmoyy pboto ay ygho chdajapq al pbo mcljcjo ge c ypcppo- c igtp*y clcmqyay hyp ol`zapb pbo ypcppo*y vmcal mcljcjo,$ Ichaloppa u, _lapo` Ypcpoy- 404 _,Y, 0:6- 02? "313:! cy iapo` al Bamhcl u, ATY-4?6 E,9` 442 "0pb Iat, 4663!- 494(499,

1 Cy K`jo Dtalnohc egl`; *Ydyoipagl "c! `goy lgp ypcpo $oriovp cy vtguaò` al ydyoipagl "o!,$* [cnaqc cp 59:,



39

K`jo Dtalnohc- al [cnaqc u, Tolg- ?4 E,Yvv,4` 541 "O,@,Uc,3111!

votegtho` c ydypclpacm ypcppgtq- Iglypappaglcm- cl` icyo vtoioòlp clcmqyay ge

pbo jguotlholp*y imcah ge cpbgtapq lòt 9590"o!, Ybo ohvbcpaicmmq todno`

pbgyo imcahy- tmalj pboq iglemaipo` zapb pbo hcl`cpo ge 9540"c!- pbcp pbo vgzot pg

ahvgyo c yolpolio ay c $ygmo kàiacm elipagl$ vtyclp pg Ctpaimo AAA ge pbo

Iglypappagl- pby pbo DGV bc` lg cpbgtapq pg ahvgyo gt orpol` c yolpolio- cl`

pbcp Igljtoyy à` lgp "cl` igm lgp! òmojcpo pbcp cpbgtapq pg pbo DGV, Ap ybgm`

cmyg do lgpo`- pbo DGV ibgyo lgp pg cvvocm K`jo Dtalnohc*y tmalj pg pbo Egtpb

Iatiap- qop ypamm imcahy pbay cpbgtapq vot apy Vgmaiq Ypcpoholpy lòt pbo AETV,

Igluotyomq- K`jo Na`` cl` K`jo Noomoq vtoyolpo` lg ztappol ypcppgtq

cl` Iglypappaglcm clcmqyay ge pbo DGV*y imcaho` ypcppgtq cpbgtapq, K`jo Na``

hcò lg holpagl al Tgyy ge pbo ypcppgtq hcl`cpoy ge 9543"c! gt 9540"c!-"o!-

zbaib hcl`cpo tomocyo ge vtaygloty- lgt ptao` pg toigliamo pboyo zapb pbo DGV*y

ypcppgtq imcahy, Yahamctmq- K`jo Noomoq cmyg vtoyolpo` lg ypcppgtq clcmqyay ge

pboyo imcahy al bot tmaljy pg oypcdmayb pbo jguotlholp*y cipagly zoto mczem,

Pby- pboto oraypy c imoct iglemaip dopzool àyptaip igtpy zapbal pbo Egtpb

Iatiap gl pbo DGV*y cmmojo` ypcppgtq cpbgtapq lòt 9540"o! pg iglpalo pg

ahvtaygl vogvmo vcyp pbo ol` ge pboat Igtp ahvgyo` vtaygl pothy, Pbay- pby-

itocpoy cl loscm ktayàipaglcm ptocpholp ge vogvmo lòt pbo mcz al pbo iatiap-

zbaib pbo Egtpb Iatiap bcy lgp imoctmq cl` àtoipmq toygmuo`,



30

Al c`àpagl- pbo Egtpb Iatiap*y gzl icyo vtoioòlp imoctmq yvvgtpy pbo

ypcppgtq clcmqyay, K`jo Dtalnohc tomao` bocuamq gl _,Y, u, Kgblygl- 02 E,9` 265

"0pb Iat, 311?! pg oypcdmayb ap ay pbo ygmo kàiacm cpbgtapq ge Igtpy pg ahvgyo c

vtaygl yolpolio, Cmyg- pbo 0pb Iatiap al _,Y, u, Hammot- :: E,9` :3 "0pb Iat, 3115!

tmo`- $zo bgm` c àyptaip igtp hcq lgp òmojcpo apy cpbgtapq pg yop pbo chglp cl`

pahalj ge ealo vcqholpy pg pbo Dtoc ge Vtaygly gt pbo vtgdcpagl geeaiot,$ Hammot 36

eathmq oypcdmayboy ap zcy ammojcm egt pbo DGV pg lgp tomocyo [cnaqc egt lgp yajlalj

pbo $Cjtooholp$ cy pbo DGV cl` vtgdcpagl geeaioty icllgp yop vcqholp yibo`moy,

Vopapaglot iglpol`y K`jo Na`` cl` K`jo Noomoq imoctmq hayypcpo pbo

cpbgtapq ge pbo DGV pg ahvtaygl vogvmo vcyp pboat tomocyo `cpoy vot 9540"o!- cl`

pbo vmcal mcljcjo ge cmm pbo tomouclp ypcppoy cyyoyyo` cl` cvvmao` al iglporptcm

bcthglq- cl` [cnaqc- todno pbcp yca` cpbgtapq- cl` pbo Egtpb Iatiap otto` dq

alàtoipmq ciiovpalj pbay imcaho` ypcppgtq cpbgtapq dq ceeathalj pboyo òiayagly-

zbamo ajlgtalj apy gzl icyo vtoioòlp- zbaib pbay Igtp ybgm` pcno cvvtgvtacpo

hocytoy pg igttoip,

36 Pbo pzg k`jo vclom zbaib ceeatho` K`jo Noomoq*y tmalj iglyaypo` ge K`jo Imqò Bchampgl cl` K`jo NctolZammachy, Ap ay atglai pbcp K`jo Bchampgl ztgpo pbo Gvalagl al Hammot dp à` lgp cvvmq apy hcl`cpoy al pbay icyo,



3?

AA, TOYVGL@OLP*Y @OIAYAGLY CL@ CIPAGLY PG AL@OEALAPOMQAHVTAYGL CL ALHCPO VCYP BAY YPCP_PGTAMQ HCL@CPO@TOMOCYO @CPO ZOTO $ZTGLJE_M CIPY$ CL@ PB_Y LGP

VTGPOIPO@ ETGH MACDAMAPQ DQ PBO $@_O ICTO$VTGUAYAGL GE PBO EO@OTCM PGTP IMCAH CIP,

K`jo Noomoq iapo` pbcp 42 _,Y,I, ª 4526"c! vtgpoipy pbo Jguotlholp etgh

macdamapq egt ”orotiayalj ò icto‘ al pbo oroipagl ge c ypcppo gt tojmcpagl- dp-

iapalj Bcpcbmoq u _lapo` Ypcpoy- 9?3 _,Y, 3:9 "31?5!- ”*@o icto* ahvmaoy ygho

halahcm igliotl egt tajbpy ge gpboty,‘ Dp Bcpcbmoq cmyg bom` pbcp ”ztgljem cipy‘

cto lgp vtgpoipo` cl` jauo tayo pg ighvolycdmo imcahy lòt ª 4526"c!- ypcpalj;

42 _,Y,I ª 4526"c! icllgp cvvmq- lgt dct macdamapq cjcalyp cjolpy zbgzoto lgp orotiayalj ò icto al pboat olegtioholp ge eoòtcm mcz, $Boto-pbo cjolpy vtgiooò` zapb ighvmopo àytojct` egt pbo vtgvotpq tajbpy ge pbo vopapaglot,,,Pboyo cipy zoto ztgljeum ,,alugmualj àyitopagl gl pbo

vctpy ge pbo cjolpy- cl` pboq `g jauo tayo pg c imcah ighvolycdmo lòt pbo Eoòtcm Pgtp Imcahy Cip,‘ "ohvbcyay!Bcpcbmoq u _lapo` Ypcpoy- 9?3 _,Y, 3:9- 323 "31?5!

Ap ay imoct etgh [cnaqc pbcp Toyvglòlpy zoto lgp olegtialj eoòtcm mcz dq

ahvtayglalj [cnaqc vcyp bay tomocyo `cpo- dp zoto al imoct uagmcpagl ge ap, Al ecip-

pboat uagmcpagl ge eoòtcm mcz zcy yg orptoho- pbcp cy K`jo Dtalnohc lgpo` al

[cnaqc cp 595- $Ciiovpalj pbo toyvglòlpy* tocàlj ge ª9540"o! zgm` pby tosato

y pg yptano pbo ypcppo cy cl liglypappaglcm òmojcpagl ge kàiacm vgzot pg pbo

oroipauo dtclib,$ Doicyo Toyvglòlpy zoto lgp olegtialj eoòtcm mcz pboq

icllgp do vtguaò` vtgpoipagl lòt pbo $ò icto$ vtguayagl ge pbo EPIC- cl`

K`jo Noomoq*y ealàlj $ap ay tocyglcdmo pg iglimò pbcp pbo DGV pama{o` ò icto



35

al orotiayalj apy `paoy$ ay imoct ottgt,

Bcpcbmoq cmyg tosatoy pbcp jguotlholp cjolpy hyp ybgz $c halahcm

igliotl$ egt pbo tajbpy ge gpboty al pbo orotiayo ge pboat mczem cpbgtapq al gtòt pg

do ceegtò` $ò icto$ vtgpoipagl, Pbo jguotlholp orbadapo` uatpcmmq lg igliotl

egt [cnaqc*y Tajbpy zbamo ammojcmmq ahvtayglalj bah, [cnaqc zcy louot ibctjo`

zapb c itaho- louot pcnol al etglp ge c k`jo pg cyyoyy bay ahvtayglholp- louot

jauol cl alpotlcm DGV boctalj- cl` louot ceegt o` cl cppgtloq, Ouol pbgjb

[cnaqc zcy c $halahh yoitapq$ vtayglot- bo zcy ydyosolpmq ptclyeotto` pg c

hoàh yoitapq vtaygl- cepot eatyp yvolàlj 4 zoony cp c hcrahh yoitapq vtaygl

zbamo al ptclyap- dgpb uagmcpagly ge DGV vgmaiq egt bay gtajalcm yoitapq mouom,

Pbo DGV cmyg uagmcpo` c hqtac` ge vgmaiaoy al ammojcmmq ahvtayglalj [cnaqc,

VY ?226,42 tosatoy $Zbolouot cl alhcpo ay lgp tomocyo` gl pbo yibo`mo `cpo ge

tomocyo cy pbo toymp ge c ealo vtgdmoh,, Ouotq oeegtp vgyyadmo ybgm` do lòtpcnol

pg cyyto pbcp pbo alhcpo ay lgp iglealo` vcyp pbo tomocyo `cpo clq mgljot pbcl

loioyyctq,$ Dp- pbo DGV louot ptao` pg vtoyolp c vcqholp yibo`mo pg [cnaqc pg

dojal lojgpacpagly gl- gt gdpcal glo etgh pbo yolpolialj Igtp pg `g yg- gt pg ouol

cyyoyy [cnaqc*y cdamapq pg vcq gl yib c yibo`mo, Pbo glmq cmpotlcpauo pbo DGV

jcuo [cnaqc pg eciamapcpo bay tomocyo zcy pg votagàicmmq cyn bah ae bo zcy toc`q pg

yajl pbo $Cjtooholp$ egth, Pby- pbo DGV ecamo` pg hcno $ouotq oeegtp vgyyadmo$

pg lgp iglealo [cnaqc vcyp bay tomocyo `cpo clq mgljot pbcl loioyyctq,



3:

Pby- pbo ecipy oypcdmayb pbo DGV*y cipagly bcuo dool kàiacmmq egl` pg do

lmczem- uagmcpo` c vmopbgtc ge [cnaqc*y Tajbpy- uagmcpo` uctagy DGV vgmaiaoy

cl` vtgio`toy- cl` zoto pbotoegto $ztgljem cipy$ cl` vtyclp pg pbo hcl`cpoy

ge Bcpcbmoq pboyo $ztgljem cipy$ cto lgp $tocyglcdmo$ cl` pby lgp vtgpoipo` dq

pbo $ò icto$ vtguayagl ge pbo EPIC, Pby- cy K`jo Zcmpgl egl - $Pbotoegto-

pbo Igtp iglimòy pbcp ap ay cvvtgvtacpo pg ptclyeot pbo pbay cipagl pg pbo vtgvot

egth zboto vmcalpaee hcq cyyotp bay imcahy cjcalyp òeol`clpy zbg tohcal al pbay

icyo cy vctpaoy,$ "TZ Cvv I- v44! "ohvbcyay!

IGLIM_YAGL

Egt pbo tocygly ypcpo` botoal- pbo òiayagl ge pbo Cvvocmy Igtp ybgm` do

touotyo` cl` Vopapaglot*y mczyap cmmgzo` pg jg egtzct`- cy alapacmmq gtòto` dq pbo

@I @ayptaip Igtp,

Zakiya v. U.S. SupCrt No. 06-7116

Documents

Transcript of Zakiya v. U.S. SupCrt No. 06-7116