z0/* q 1A cASENo.Dissatisfied with Oracle's failure and refusal to perform the work necessary to...
Transcript of z0/* q 1A cASENo.Dissatisfied with Oracle's failure and refusal to perform the work necessary to...
Filing # 68003440 E-Filed 02ll52Al8 10:58:36 AM
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF TFIE
ELEVENTH JTJDICIAL CIRCUTT IN AND
FOR MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
CIRCUIT CIVL DIVISION
cASENo. z0/* q 7// 1A Ol
A&E ADVENTURES LLC, a Florida limited
liabitity company, and M&A GROUP, LLC,aFlorida limited liability company'
Plaintiffs.
v.
ORACLE AMERICA, NC., a Delaware
corporation,
CLASS REPRESENTATION
plaintlffs, A&E ADVENTURES LLC; a Florida limited liability company ("A&E'), and
M&A GROUP, LLC, aFlorida limited liability company ('M&A") (collectively, the '?laintiffs"),
file this Class Action Complaint on behalf of themselves and a similarly situated individuals
pursuant to Rule 1.220,F1a. R. Civ. P., against Defendant, ORACLE AMERICA, INC" a Delaware
corporation ("Oracle"), and allege:
Jurisdiction. Parties. and Venue
1. This is an action for damages in excess of Fifteen Thousand Dollars ($15'000'00)'
exclusive of interest, attomeys' fees, and costs, over which ttris Court has jurisdiction pursuant to
Fla. Stat. S26.An.
2. A&E is a Florida limited liability company whose principal place of business is in
Broward CountY, Florida.
Defendant.
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 1 of 53
3. M&A is a Florida limited liability company whose principal place of business is in
Broward County, Florida.
4. Oracle is a Delaware corporation whose principal place of business is in Redwood
Shores, Califomia, and who maintains an agent or other representative in Miami-Dade County,
Florida.
5. Venue is proper in Mami-Dade County, Florida because Oracle has an agent or
other representatiYe in said county.
General Allesations
6. On or about September 8, 2014, Oracle acquired Micros Systems, Inc. ("Micro6"),
the manufacturer of the Restaurant Enterprise Solution 3700 Point-of-Sale system (the "RES
3700').
7. The RES 3700--whose uses include the processing of food and beverage orders and
payments-is among the most widely-used point-of-sale systems in the food' beverage' and
hospitality industrY worldwide
S.SinceitsacquisitionofMicros,oraclehaspurposefullyandknowinglyengagedina
deliberate and purposefur scheme to force owners of ttre REs 3700 to abandon that system and
upgrade (at a substantial cost) to oracle's subscription-based Simphony Point-of-Sale system
("SimphonY").
g. As discussed below, in furtherance of that scheme, oracle has: (1) failed and refused
to provide adequate support to operators of ttre t{ES 3700; (2) taken "Red Keyt'' - usB drives
containing license code enabling upgrades to the RES 3700's software - from users' thereby
preventing them from upgrading their RES 3700 systems; (3) failed to provide support for credit
and debit cards containing computer chips (<nown as "EMV"' which standS for Europay'
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 2 of 53
Atleeaf ons SDecific to.Ptaintiffs
Ptaintiffs, Acquisition and Deplovment of RES 37fi) SvstemsA.
Mastecard, Visa), the new global standard in payment security; (4) refused to acknowledge the
validity of licenses for RES 3700 softrrare purchased from and delivered by Micros/Oracle; and (5)
prevented operators of the RES 3700 from obtaining necessary support from third parties.
10. Oracle has deceptively held itself out as providing support for the RES 3700 when,
in fact" it was engaged in a deiiberate scheme to deprive the owners of those systerns with adequate
support in order to force tfrem to upgrade to Simphony'
11. Plaintiffs own and operate, among other businesses, a number of family
entertainment centers in Florida.
12. In early 2010, Plaintiffs acquired five (5) RES 3700 systems (the..Systems',).
13. On or about April 23, 2A!0, A&E and Micros entered into those certain sales
conffacts to deploy one (1) of the systems at A&E's Miami, Frorida center and one (1) of the
Systems at A&E',s Tampa, Florida center. A ffue and conect copy of the sales contracts are
attached as Composite Exhibit "A'"
14. The Sales Contracts provide in relevant part:
Upon payment in full of all sums due under this Sales contract' MICROS grants to
tA&E]anonexclusivenonfiansferablelicensetousethesoftwareidentifiedonthehttt pug" of ttris Sales Contract ' ' ' '
15. At the suggestion of Mictos's agents, for each of their five (5) Systems' Plaintiffs
purchased a.'Red Key''- a uSB drive containing license code enabling upgrades to the System's
software.
16. Subsequent to plaintiffs' acquisition of these "Red Keys," A&E engaged Micros to
perforrn various and regular necessary software upgrades on A&E's Miami and Tampa Systems'
which Micros performed using said "Red Keys"'
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 3 of 53
B. Oracle's Acquisition of Micros
t7. On or about September 8, 2014, Orucle acquired Micros, and thereby succeeded to
Micros's rights and obligations under the Sales Conffacts'
C. Oracle's Defrcient Deplovment of Fort Mvers Svstem
1g. On or about Octob er 9,2015, M&A engaged Oracle to deploy one of the five (5)
systems at its Fort Myers, Florida center. (See Invoice, a true and conect copy of which attached as
Exhibit "B.")
|g. The services provided by oracle were deficient, however, aS the Fort Myers
system's software has malfunctioned continuously since that time'
2A. M&A notified Oracle of these malfunctions immediately after ttre Fort Myers
System's dePloYment:
2t. on or about Decemb er g,2015,M&A engaged oracle, pursuant to the terms of that
certain Executable euote (a true and conect copy of which is attached as Exhibit "c'), to remedy
the software marfunctions affecting the now deproyed Fort Myers System.
22.SimilartotheApril23,2010SatesConfiactwithMicros,theoracleExecutable
Quote Provides in relevant Part:
UponpaymentforServices,Youhavethenon-exclusive,non-assignable'royaltyfree,perpetual,limitedrighttouseforYourinternalbusinessoperationsanythingdevetbped uv oracre and detvered to You under ttris order . . . .
23. oracle billed M&A for sixteen (16) hours of service it claimed to have performed on
the Fort Myers system's software between December 2015 and January 2016' (See Invoice' a ffue
Exhibit "D"')and conect copy of which is attached as Exhiblt "L'"')
24. Those services, however, were also deficien! as the Fort Myers system's software
subsequently contrnued malfunctioning'
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 4 of 53
E.
D. Oracle's Unsrade of Miami and Tampa SYst€m Software
25. During the summer of.20l6,A&E engaged Oracle to perfonn software upgrades on
the Miami and TamPa SYstems.
26. Oracle performed those software upgrades and billed A&E for nineteen (19) hours
of service it claimed to have perfonned on each of the Miami and Tampa Systems. (See Invoices,
t'ue and conect copies of which are attached as Composite Exhibit'E''")
27.onoraboutFebruary15,2017,M&Aengagedoracle,pursuanttothetermsofthat
certain ordering Documen (a true and conect copy of which is attached as Exhibit "F'), to repatr
and de-bug the Fort Myers System's software'
2g. Not only did Oracle's technicians fail to conect the Fort Myers System's software
malfunctions, the work oracle performed caused the System to crash, resulting in M&A's total
inabitty to complete any transactions at its Fort Myers center the weekend of March 25' 2017 '
whichinturnresultedinasubstantiallossofrevenuebyM&A.
29. Although oracle technicians were subsequently able to get the Fort Myers system
operational, they were unable to remedy the System's software malfunctions' which continue to this
day.
30, Despite demand, Oracle has failed and refused to remedy its defective work
ftware'performed on the Fort Myers System's so
f,'.
31. Dissatisfied with Oracle's failure and refusal to perform the work necessary to
[unctions' Plaintiffs have attemptedcorrect ttre Oracle-deployed Fort Myers System's software mall
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 5 of 53
to engage third-party Postec, Inc. ("Postec") to repair the Fort Myers System's software, and to
deploy Plaintiffs' remaining two (2) unused Systems at new locations.
j2. Postec has advised Plaintiffs that, in order to perfomr any work on the Systems, it
must fint receive confirmation from Oracle that Plaintiffs have valid licenses for ttre Systems'
software.
33. Oracle, however, has advised Plaintiffs ttrat-despite the express licenses granted by
ttre Micros Sales Contracts, despite Plaintiffs purchasing, at Micros' suggestion, "Red Keys"
containing software license code, and despite Micros and oracle having performed (and Plaintiffs
having paid for) upgrades and repairs of the Miami, Tampa, and Fort Myers Systems' software-it
is oracle,s position that Plaintiffs lack valid licenses for the Systems' software'
34. As a consequence of oracle failing to repair the Fort Myers System's software as
A&E had paid for, and preventing Plaintiffs from obtaining those services ftom Postec, Plaintiffs
cannot make reliable use of the Fort Myers System, resulting in ongoing losses to that business'
35.Further,bypreventingPlaintiffsfromengagrngthird-partyPostec'oraclehasalso
made it impossible for Plaintiffs to properly process EMV card payments with their Systems' and
ttrereby compry with the payment card Indusfiy Data Security standard c"cl Dss"). As a
consequence of plaintiffs, non-compliance with pcl DSS, plaintiffs now automatically lose all
credit card disputes, which has resulted in tens of thousands of dollars of lost revenuo'
36, Although A&E has deployed at its Miami center a third-party system that accepts
EMV cards, the interface between ttrat system and ttre Micros payment module consistently
malfunctions, causing credit card payments to be lost in ffansmission and never to be found, wi*r
corresponding losses to A&E for those lost payments'
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 6 of 53
37. Moreovgr, Oracle's confiscation of Plaintiffs'"Red Keys," and its refusal to
acknowledge the validity of the plaintiffs' Systems' software licenses has also prevented Plaintiffs
from deploying the two (2) unused Systems at new locations'
3g. Unable to deploy these two (2) Systems, Plaintiffs have been required to purchase
new point-of-sale systems, at significant expense, for those locations.
39. All conditions precedent, if any, to the commencement of this action have either
occwed or been performed, waived, or excused'
40. plaintiffs have retained the undersigned counsel to prosecute this action, for which
they have agreed to pay said counsel a reasonable fee for ttreir services'
41. plaintiffs state that all relevant agreements not attached hereto are in oracle's
possession and will be made part of the pleadings once obtained through discovery'
42. Plaintiffs repeat and reallege Paragraphs I through 41 as if fully set forttr herein'
43. Valid contracts - ttre Executable Quote and ordering Document - exist between
M&Aandoracle,wherebyoracleagreedtoperformcertainsoftwareservices,namelythe
deployment of the Fort Myers System and repair of its malfunctioning software'
44.TheservicesoracleprovidedtoM&Aweredeficientinsofarastheyfailedtoeither
propeily deploy that System or remedy its software malf-unctions'
45.PursuanttoexpresswarrantiescontainedintheExecutableQuoteandordering
m these deficient services'Document, Oracle is obligated to re-perfot
46.oraclehasbreachedthoseContractsbyfailingandrefusingtore.performthe
services or take other commercially reasonable steps to conect ttrese malfunctions'
direct and proximate result of that breach, M&A has sustained damages in the
formofamalfunctioningSystemcausingcontinuousbusinesslosses'
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 7 of 53
48. Because Oracle has not only failed to correct the malfunctions, but has also
prevented M&A from instead obtaining repair services from Postec, money damages from Oracle
are inadequate to remedy the foregoing breach.
49. M&A therefore respectfully requests that this Court enter either: (i) an order of
specific performance requiring Oracle to take commercially reasonable steps to repair the Fort
Myers System's software; or (ii) an order requiring Oracle to permit and pay for such repair services
to be performed by Postec or other qualified servicer'
50. Absent the requested order, M&A will sustain ineparable harm by not being able to
reliably use or obtain repairs to its Fort Myers System'
WHEREFORE, plaintiff, M&A GROUP, LLC, respecfully requests that this Court enter
judgment in its favor and against Defendant' ORACLE AMERICA' INC" for specific performance
or damages, interest, attorneys' fees, costs, and such other and furttrer relief which this Court deems
just and Proper.
plaintiffs repeat and reallege Paragraphs 1 ttfough 41 as if fully set forttr herein'
plaintiffs have attempted to engage Postec to perfo work on the systems'
oracle knows of the business relationship or expectancy between Plaintiffs and
Postec.
54. Specifically, oracle knows that Plainffi are attempting to obtain from Postec
services essential to the oPeration of the Systems'
55. oracle, however, has intentionally interfered wittr the relationship or expectancy
gtoacknowledgethevalidityoftheSystems'softwarebetween Plaintiffs and Postec by refusin;
licenses.
51.
52.
53.
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 8 of 53
56. As a proximate result of the foregoing interference by Oracle, Plaintiffs are unable to
engage Postec's services, and are thus unable to use and maintain the Systems, which has in tum
proximately caused Plainti s to sustain damages.
57. Such damages include lost profits, which losses were reasonably foreseeable by
Oracle.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs, A&E ADVENTTIRES LLC and M&A GROUP, LLC,
respecfirlly request that ttris Court enter judgment in ttreir favor and against Defendant, ORACLE
AMERICA, NC., for damages, interest, attorneys' fees, costs, and such other and furttrer relief
which ttris Court deems just and proper.
5g. plaintiffs repeat and reallege Paragraphs 1 through 41 as if fully set forth herein'
59. plainffis have valid licenses to the Systems' sofhvare by virtue of the Sales
confiacts, Plaintiffs' purchase of 'Red Keys" at Micros's suggestion, and oracle's installation of
upgrades to the Systems' software.
60. oracle, however, refuses to acknowledge the validity of the Systems', software
licenses
6L. Because postec requires such ac}nowledgment in order to perform service on the
systems, software, and oracle refuses to provide such acknowledgment' Plaintiffs are unable to
obtain essential support for their Systems'
62. plaintiffs and Oracle thus have an actual, presenl adverse and antagonistic interest in
whetherPlaintiffs have valid licenses for the Systems' software.
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 9 of 53
63. Because Plaintiffs are unable to obtain services from Postec ttrat are essential to the
use and maintenance of ttre Systems, there is a bona fide, actual, present practical need for a
declaration as to the validrty of the Systems' software licenses.
64. The declaration sought deals wittr a present ascertained or ascertainable set of facts -
the tenns of the agreements and course of dealing benveen Plaintiffs and Oracle'
65. The validity of the Systems' software licenses is dependent upon ttre law applicable
to those facts.
66. The antagonistic and adverse interests are all before the cour,t by proper process, and
the relief sought is not merery the giving of regal advice by the courts or the answer to questions
propounded from curiositY.
LLC and M&A GROUP' LLC'WHEREFORE; Plaintiffs, A&E ADVEf'ITURES
that this court enter judgment in their favor and against Defendant, ORACLE
AMERICA, INC., declaring that Plaintiffs possess valid licensqs for the Systems' sofhrare' together
with attorneys, fees, costs, and such other and further relief which this court deems just and proper'
Class Representation Allegations
67 . Plaintiffs repeat and reallege Paragraphs 6 through 10 as if fully set forttr herein'
6g. plaintiffs are not unique in the aforementioned difficulties they have experienced
with oracre, which are instead common to all operators of the RES 3700'
69.RecenttestimonialsfromotherREs3?00usersregardingtheirdrfficultieswith
Oracle are replete on ttre World Wide Web' Some examples:
GrouP - "THE WORST CUSTOMERDara Maleki, CEO of RMS Franchise
sERvIcE EVER. ."'^: ilo EGnucreris--*.T*J:go^*lXH^HDEr(vruE 'EYLir\' rnB rms LARGE oF A ..MPANY'"
bornpeNv I CANT BELIEVE TryY { . r.. n^n,\
tt was good when itDominicFielden,PresidentofRoctyMountainFlatbreach_..1was Micros but since or;J; tougtrtitrem its appalling. . . . I think selling to oracleb.
10
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 10 of 53
c.
d.
has reduced the customer focus. . . . They are very slow to respond and about as far
from being customer cenfiic as possible. Pity as I I say I was quite happy with
Micros and have another lrcation coming up next year. Having spoken to other
POS companies I am now considering changing all my systems." (Id')
Frank Lyons, President of Contav, LLC - "Oracle Hospitality is an Abomination!! . .
. There-is absolutely nottring good to say about Oracle Hospitality. -I
h1e no.idea
how they are still inbusiness and why they haven't been sued out of existence! . . .
Why hain't anyone filed a class action suit against Oracle to recover our losses?"
(rd.)
Frank Staiger, President of Fraser River Lodg^e .
"\nf!-ry is Oracle-Micros still in
business? . . . Tenible customer service. Getting the runaround for 3 weeks'
Nobody'seems to be responsible for anything. Running in circles. . . . Headaches
*iftr p6.ntps the most diiorganized company ever dealt wi$ Not sure how they are
rtiff iir bus'iness. We will Ui tetting our equipment from Micros go and swirch to a
provider wittr customer service." fld.)
Rose Wong, owner of the Pearl Asian Kitchen - "No live support. . No software
,opport. lNo service. No knowledqgable people .working
for tfre iom.pany:nralmented help. . .l ' My 3700 l{[cros ii.teis than a.ye1r old' eurcnle!
maintenance conffact and was ASSURED it has hardware and software support' Not
ffiJ l\11 kinds of programming glilches that I had P lty" with for months with no
tefp from support. f'oi months-t had email communications wittr a conffact renewal
,rt", p"rron tttr" same person who sold me the first confiact) about getting
soFTwARE support help/ contact. Now there is a'fatalhard drive' efror message
;;;;;Ailj;ror.rring company ried !o install a terminal ltgt .T t4: :liqcards since Mcros still doei'not have the technology to do so.I ftied again and [sic]
again technicat support saidjhey can help but they ha. -t
t9 submit a billable ticket'
This is a software problem. nact< to same sales person for he$ with qettine sofryare
;;;ffi "il;;;i ; email from her saying my same contract that has not worked
and that has not expired was'activatid'-and'ryneyed'and it should work'
I cannot believe *traif was reading. lhis is months of communications back and
forth about NO SOF|WARE HELP. To date I paid for 2 contracts with tty same
r*U"t",it" rp.rin; thardware technical supqo-rt' tut still have a piece of
equipment ttrat cannoi accept chip card reader. *d trtU have all kinds of glitches no
on. i.t* to know why. . . - Buyer beware!" (Id')
Stephanie Koyama, the silver spul "This is a tenible company' Each time I call
.tech support' the p*pr. tt the other end literally read out,of the manual I have' I
ptace requests tor caffJiact theV qlgmlse to call and never do. .Nobody knows what
'Ui"V areioing. S**- lik u t*uU jenky call center. And each time I call they.ask
the same questions about my busineis *q 1.o*t so there afe no notes kept on their
system tohelp ttreir paying customers"' (Id')
Ed Griffith, Courtyard Maniott - "Honible service!!! ' ' ' Use another platrorm' The
service for theirpOs products is worse than honible. Support communicates poorly
f.
o
11
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 11 of 53
h.
and failed to communicate with customers. Have NEVER had a positive experience
with Oracle since they assumed Micros POS support."
Aaron Mackee, Senior Hospitality Analyst - "I curently have over 300 POS
workstations deployed across-multiple Micros plaforms includifg Simnhgny-1I *dRes 3700, as well as a number of hotels running Opera PMS. Dealing with Micros
since ttre [O]racle takeover is the most painful customer service I have.ever fad to
deal with in 20+ years in the hospitality industry. Their sales process is broken to
the point where it is almost imnosli_bf9 to_get a timetry guote, and their support
,r*ir", are beyond useless. I would liJerally :i9r"Pt:9.going with ANY other
provider beforahaving to deal with Oracle Hospitality"' (Td')
Justin McGranahan, AP/IT Manager of Boone Tavern.- "sin1e .ttre nyc{ry oj
Mi.ro, by oracle, thesupport standqds have gone so farbeyond sub par-thatJ d9n't
even receive phone calft na* about issues t caU in, the tickeB just get closed when
Oracle feels like it. ffif rtut" tttut they have left messages with the site which is
false as all technical .uil, *. routed directly to me) plus {Y,p!on? number an!
"*.if *" on every piece of documentation and yet they can't find the time to contact
me before closing the case. During the installation of a new terminal,I kepl rgcgrds
of the times that were worked, and yet the times that t!9ir slaff submitted did not
il; ,h;ffi ;;rktd ,t";, *a they refused to adjust the issue ro show the
correct times. If you are thinking of buying this product, buy a different one simply
due [sic] to the suPPort." (Id')
Iamar Mendes, Menin Hotels - "Ever since Oracle took over Micros Hospitality we
have had ausotutery trorriut. experiences supporfil.rs *:l T integral part of our
t"r1r.". 1,. add sh"ame to ttre entire experienii we have 11+ locations and pay over
$125,000 a year:"ro i" ft "" tttig top of tn" fine service' and I have never felt more
insulted by the wa)i a support deparfinent has fieated us' Excessive delays' gross
#ff#";;;;J;.t*pfut i"u'6'ity toreceive promised call backs'" (Id')
MarilynnHaylvard,boo}lceeperforDimitriou:sJazzAlley-.oWehavemademanyattempts to try to;rdtht; tystem work, including conversations with Oracle sales
team and support. They have beel.completety ineffective in solving any of ttreir
systems snort comintt, t our.opinion, out insuuation has never been completed'
We were teft with tttJayJ*"tionat equipmenl Pd inaccrlfe reports 1Sn!fr91 tle
reunabletoresolveourproblemswewillbeforcedtolookforautgtryTg' If we a ) our restrauranrs tsicj neJt.- wt will not
n"iu pos system that is able to handle our restaurail s [s1(
.*.**t"ittris POS system to anyone at tttis time"' (Id')
Em B, General Manager of TnnJapanese 9il1 11l*:H^lt - "I am the general
manager or u ,Jtuir*i who p'qrchased a $20,000 system through Micros
approximatelyzyearsago.everythingstartedoutgreaL.MicroswasFABtjLoUSuntil oracte uoogniii.i%"r ilf; dracte look
ovir'IF I had anv proplegs or just
;:ffi;ffi;iliffid Jmost.*-*"t r{ g:t.u prosrymmer or technician from
the local office on tft -ptto*
and they atways hid the answers"'but then Oracle canle
along. we immedi;"d;;; to h; ,yrt * issues that stayed unresolved because I
j.
t.
t2
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 12 of 53
was rarely ever contacted back by a service technician an{.yhen I was they made
ttre problem worse, once even knocking my ertire system off-line...it stayed t!{ way
for an entire weekend until a tech from ttre local office was sent out to fix it. He was
one of the original people who installed my system and had the issue fixed within 15
minutes tfrantfuUy. He was amazing!!! It took dozens of phone calls, massive hold
times, some profanity and a little crying on my end to aglually glt an onsite tech sent
out. My Micros salei rep provided me wittr the email address_ of the head of Oracle's
service dept...Xve neveihiard back from him. The onsite tech told me that the local
office had been downsized considerably and the employees that were left wery
torbioden by oracle to speak directly with anyone about service issues- He also told
me that the employeet u:t tttt Oraclecall center were never fiained to us-e-much less
ttrof* it*"s with the Mcros system. We have regretted the change to Micros ever
;;;;; o;r.ir took over. rnanHuuv we haven't fra{ anryecent issues 3nd
t grav tfaf
we don't because it will be nothing but a headache. Jhe owner of the lgstaurant I
manage is in the process of opening a2nd an4^3rd restauranl..we will NOT be
instatting Oracle systems in either. It's a shame after spending $20'000 on a system
atong wlth paymg yearly service confiact f99s ttral a qerlor/company should- be
neatEd this way. WL *, Uottt in the'hospitality hdLlg-.:,lwould be mortified to
noo* tttat *y of *y customers were freated this way!!" (Id')
-C - "The [sic] lady at the old corporateSteve Miller, Mem-ber of TLC Miller LI;ffi.; in fvfutyf*O ,uiO rino Oracle took over the phone tingt :.o1'j3t1y
eight
rrooi, u day with complaints. Looking for others to start class action'" (Id')
C. Landise - "Used Micros (now 3700) for 20 years { three.locations',Whi1e,ttr1
;;#;;"pn*il n"u., teen grear (or cheap) it h,as sruk to new lows since
Oracle took over. Layers of bureaucrTy io get the sqnl.est change or progr1lmlg
tweaks accomplishi. Over a week 1o gtt an ordering printer replaced Td",1contract and many to*, on the phone pfis 1plea to $9 gates rep was reguired'
The individual."pr r.Joot personat 'clieat sheets. explaining step by step how to
piu.t . support ^order ol m: incredibly confusing Tg^:u*bttsome
customer
interface website. (it tooks like it was disigned by a 1970's DOS Geek who had
English as a third language.) The.last staw ivas the industry-wide upgrade in credit
card certificate f5Sli 'security which happened on Dec 28' 20t6
Ottrer Oracle .o*priito^ told theirilients about its coming and had the fix in place'
Oracle just let ""
t"Vt* g; a;;" and let us hold on with customer support for
hours on ttre holidai]- Wr-*.r. then told that they would need two WEEKS to
.jji.rJ-^ri-u..u*. trt.y had so many c-lients. w.tro needed ttre upgrade!
neailv hard to ueriw". w":*! upgt4.d all of our hardware a couple of years ago
, so we are stuck to, nor *ifi oracie, but never again! I do not recommend any bar
I t* L urc oracle."s vstems/micro s/micro s/)
Binda - ..I've used Micros for over 20 years wit! little ol ng.nr9llems' etlat
customer support...until 20141! Not sure what has happened with this company'
ttrey closed the local offrce leavin_g us w$ no- sungo{ when you call the support
line you are put on t ora io, urry iong, when they finally do answ€r ttrey offer very
t3
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 13 of 53
little to no support. They charge very high fees for customer support that ispractically non existent. After being a loyal Micros customers for over 20 years I am
ready to look for a new system that offers support, is more advanced and easier to
program." (Id.)
p. Anne - "The Micros POS system is nearly non-functional. If we use it when our
business is busy it crashes. We paid $2,000 for 1 year's support. When we call forsupport we're put on hold, then after remarkably long waits we're cut off by the
phbne system, then when someone fltnally picks up after several more calls they
don't know enough about the system to fix it and they hang up on us. Our system is
often down for days and when we put pressure on them to get it up and running they
tell us we need to pay ttrem more money. It's extortion and they should be put our to
business for ttre fraud they're perpetrating on the small business public." (Id.)
10. As evidenced by the foregoing testimonials, Oracle is engaged in a deliberate
scheme to deprive RES 3700 system owners of essential support, and to prevent system owners
from obtaining that support from third parties, in order to force those consumers to abandon the
RES 3700 and purchase Oracle's subscription-based Simphony system.
71. plaintiffs bring this class action on behalf of themselves and others similarly
situated, aS members of a class they propose be defined as follows: all consumers who (a) reside in
Florida, O) owned a RES 3700 prior to the date of this Complaint, and (c) who purchased the RES
3700 within ttre United States.
72. Excluded from the proposed class are Oracle; any entity in which Oracle has or had
; any of Oracle's officers, directors, legal representatives, heirs, successors, and
lunsel and anyone employed by Plaintiffs' counsel; any Judge assigned to thisassigns; Plaintiffs' ct
action and his or her immediate family; an anyone who timely requests exclusionfrom the class.
7?- This action may be maintained on behalf of the class proposed above pursuant to
Rule 1.220(b)(1) or, altematively, Rule 1.220(bX3)'
74. Upon information and belief, the number of proposed Class members exceeds one
thousand, and individual joinder of the purchasers of these systems would be impractical'
t4
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 14 of 53
75. Common questions of law and fact exist as to members of the class and predominate
over questions affecting only individual class members. These common questions include:
a. Whether Oracle has provided adequate support for the RES 3700;
b. Whettrer Oracle has purposely or knowingty failed and refused to provide adequate
support for the RES 3700;
c. The steps taken (or not taken) by Oracle to maintain an adequate number of personnel
with adequate training to support ttre RES 3700s in operation;
d. Whether Oracle made false or misleading representations or omissions to the public
regarding the availability of support for the RES 3700; and
e. whether oracle has prevented owners of the RES 3700 from obtaining support from
third-Parties.
76. plaintiffs are members of the proposed class and their claims are typical of the
claims of the other members of the class. Plaintiffs and class members all reside in Florida and
pwchased the RES 3700.
77. plaintiffs are adequate representatives of the class because their interests do not
conflict with ttre interests of the members bf the class they seek to represent. Plaintiffs have
retained counsel competent and experienced in complex class action litigation, and Plaintiffs intend
to prosecute this action vigorously. The interests of members of the Class will be fairly and
adequately protected by Plaintiffs and their counsel'
?g. The class action device is superior to other available means for the fair and efficient
claims of the Plaintiffs and other class members. The relief sought per
[vely small given the burden and expense of individua]individual member of the Class is relat
prosecution of the potentially extensive litigation necessitated by oracle's conduct' Even if the
class memben themselves could afford such individual litigation, the court system could not'
Individual litigation of the legal and factual issues raised by oracle's conduct would increase delay
and expense to all parties and to the court system. The class action device presents far fewer
15
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 15 of 53
management difficulties and provides the benefits of a single, uniform adjudication, economies of
scale and comprehensive supervision by a single court. Given the similar nature of the Class
members' claims, the Class will be easily managed by the Court and the parties.
7g. Furthermore, the prosecution of separate claims and defenses by individual members
of the Class would create a risk of either: (a) inconsistent or varying adjudications concerning
inOiviOuat members of the Class which would establish an incompatible standard of conduct for the
party opposing the Class; or (b) adjudications concerning individual members of the Class which
would, as a practical mattef, be dispositive of the interest of other members of the class who afe not
parties to the adjudications, or substantiany impair or impede the ability of ottrer members of the
class who are not parties to the adjudications to protect their interest.
plaintiffs repeat and reallege Paragraphs I through 41, and 67 through 79 as if fully
set forth herein'
gl. The Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act, Fla. Stat. $ 501'201 et seq'
(.FDUTPA") provides in relevant part that *[u]nfair mettrods of competition, unconscionable acts
or practices, and unfair or deceptive acts or practices in the conduct of any trade or cofirmerce are
hereby declared unlawful." Fla' Stat' $ 501'20'1(l)'
82. Each of the Plaintiffs is a "consumet'' as defined in Fla' stat' $ 501'203'
g3. At all times material hereto, oracle has been engaged in the business of selling
products and services nationwide'
34.oracleisengagedin..fiadeorconrmefce,,asdefinedinFla.stat.$501.203.
85. oracle,s above-described conduct - namely, holding itself out as providing support
for the RES 3700, when it is in fact intentionally depriving consumers of that essential support,
80.
t6
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 16 of 53
while also preventing censumers from obtaining ttrat support from third parties, for ttre purpose of
forcing those consumers to upgrade from those systems to Oracle's subscription-based Simphony
system - constitutes an unfair or deceptive act or practice under Fla. Stat. $ 501.204(1).
g6. Said conduct is against public policy because it needlessly subjects consumers to
purchasing newef and more expensive hardware and services in place of the REs 3700, which
consumers could continue using if oracle made adequate support available for those systems (as
Micros had done), or allowed consumers to contract with ttrird parties to obtain that support'
rds, of Florida consumers have been harmed by Oracle's
conduct discussed above.
SS.Anawardofpunitivedamagesisappropriatebecauseoracle'sconducthasbeen
oufiageous, willful and wanton, and has showed a reckless disregard for the rights to Plaintiffs and
other consumers.
WHEREFORE,Plaintiffs,A&EADVENTURESLLCandM&AGROUP,LLC,
respecfully request that ttris court enter judgment in their favor and that of the proposed class, and
rmpensatory and punitive damages inagainst Defendant, ORACLE AMERICA' NC" awarding co
amounts to be determined at trial, and reasonable attorneys' fees and costs pursuant to Fla. stat' $
501.2105(1), together with such other and furttrer relief wtrich ttris court deems just and proper'
DEMAND FOR.IURY TRIAL
Plaintiffs demand a fiial by jury of all issues so niable'
I7
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 17 of 53
Dated this 15fr day of February, 2018.
Respectfully submitted,
The Behar Law Firm, P.A.Ano rney s fo r P laintiffs17501 Biscayne Boulevard, Suite 460
Aventura, Florida 33 160
Telephone: (786) 735-3300
Facsimile: (7 86) 7 35 -3307
hrb@beharlegal"[email protected]@behariegal.com
By s/ Samuel M. Sheldan
Howard R. BeharFlorida Bar No. 5447tSamuel M. SheldonFlorida Bar No. 54088
18
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 18 of 53
COMPOSITEEXHIBIT A
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 19 of 53
$lrlE$:COtlT
)ATEr
0*€9l1qSALES ACCOUNT EXECUIIVE:
Lynn A ltdhile
)USTOf$ER A0COUNT #i $AL!.BoRoeR* iFDilF^tlFD 0JJtFFilfii rari'rE :
SV'Ieel<s
:OETSIEERSLTGi| TiAEEi
A & gA*|fr#IURFS ttf 'TQRE LOCATISS| {$116 i14.1+E}r
oAe{E}t/sRt{$\ftrlR!$S
?f i2$1e$irrn Rrl. #1g0
rtDR€sg'
't600 E €Th Ave spaoe P{-147
ii'ry $:isri: i.la
,fileston FL 33.]?6
rFof'tE.
s54-5SlaoCI$
;,:-)r: .ST,IJE ?lY
farnna FL 33$05
i3'y.:{e
TBT
tII.[. TO; IF DiFFERE}.{T THAN ASSVE:
I.Tilt$,AL$Ir$l.i(}Dillt'lFf.Nf? 1'ES .X. NC
$l.llP TO tD€LlvER'rOl, lF DIFFERENT Yb{AN ABOV€:
itefiri$g iDL:R999
:ll/ Sr'Ft:i :':tF rxcr$f; t].:v .3fAiE 3|F >tiS.lE
U.TY ! n:t tD#p tEscEr^lrDN ui+rT FSrcE T{iT*L
...............:.sEF.Al:r-AgjiFP$.q.F-EN.P,-U.U.P.S..G-.F.S"."-."".""H ardwaref$oft ura re/Su PPlies $ 725,00
MS,aJHels DesU$FL $ervices
Frobramminq and Training ,gelires
PAYMENTTERMS:
PREPAY
F/}Lt A IEA$ING'JghlFirNY 3E USED? *.VS$ *X. }EJ
I'lEl'"'3USTCi"1ER? -X-
YE$ -
IJO
TAX
TRAVEL EXPENSES
SHIPPING
TOTAL:FUS.CHASE'
'ri)ttuDil'r.i rd:{ & ShiPFB.t"t' ;r}
T9 BE INVOTOE9
TO BE INVOIOED
TO BE INVOICEO
UEPOSIT
CHECK {ITUIVIFER:
IANCE DUE
c J
IS P/O REQUIRED FOR PAYIT,IENT?
IF YES, TNSERT PUR*HASE OROER NUMBER: ......-.--icusrcruenNnrur: n.S..ES.Py.F.l1_r_lLAHg.!-1.,q..... ......
l*nrorvrr:u*L*$eRFoR.Tigl!..*,1'.*1,T.ligf:s._nf_d"_tl-"g-.."..i;;, DorNG BU$rNEssAs cAfvtEllitRns
i 8Y L-.,,: \-*. : {=.ft}:,{d'
1,,ffi''' LX,lllii;r,.{,, tt$it, t -,tl*,..* .,"}r.,ir,
IS CUSTAhIER SITE bVITHIN OTSTRICT'$SRVICING TERRITORY?
-YES -X-NO
lr'ltllicH BiS|RICT? -[11CRE$ of Oeri|fol iL| ''.r::' '1 ' tn'intif i**le
lcusrotlrsn HAg RgcEtuED AIIB AGftEEt! To rHE TERti[s Alilo
lconorroxs olt ALL pAc€$ oF yt'rts cot{TRAcr, ts}cluslt'Jclrns sranroARo TERsts ARD cot{Dffn,qs ATTAoHEo HERET0
rCR USE SY CBENiT DEPARTIIiEI'TT ONLY l€YtElriFD.BPr FCR r,tnnr)g IJSE OltL
l${.SSMAt{.:irYil l};rirf
.i:^f, rr;; ^r5rs4 *r*irwp t:aiT
\0(:6Fi€SBY: cRED{TDEPrsltl,lglrl sltl-)
)iiFDtT MAIJ66FR tl:Tf
ll
rfr?il#r{}s1$ALE$ OONTRAST
MICROS $ysterns, Inc:639S. MilitaryTrail
Deerfield Beach, FL 3344?
W8v11.fi1 fi0id0/o0 3S8.8?000.$0.120.99
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 20 of 53
mi*r$s"$htp To:'GAMEltllffiKS Bllt Tor A & E ADVENTUBES LLL
t*ardwa re/$ o fuva tg,/& wFF tles A: {de n ds *tSrlmconttacr& LL
-*'-'**'..r:*'-**"1i::ii
t.l'::'Fffi --.. j:?jry-"q$$pc;irirrssiiieiv,ii:Yli],i,{il:iti ! i TotBlHardvvq!9199,1'fg.{9/.9!|.eF.li9f:--
'lrY .,r1i.01 ,t .cB r0 .oo lo ,01.t il(.0 mI4 ,!1 5t4;t4'41
'Hdn/${rviodarar*n?? grr,$?N ffi
Srlo4 conl'3ct$:
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 21 of 53
rttnBAft a tEr\[f$ /|bo coNor'aoNr.itr 8Al&5 cqa{rMql l$NavEAR}yAr*AiftYl
i!,.i:l.trt co,.$P-cci:r9.3$n-DT Lx rBF Fc!.14!k\(l lE\rrsi!4I$t)ftgttytng:.:!d}qn,{'i4}'*5\s}NEl9.4i*o.&*h!.Mei:4:'!b?'dcir''!ut+}!to:r, 4c:q!:!). lE lx4rii..'{. s bnir*g $sffi$, itdi br Slss^u d f*t n{ ,hiJ E6g,* C^(.i!Frtt i.lfiv.#*! i:$$f ldk..@r(rirBp.:ri\: :flI aJt;$!+jrw 4 [.!r P$dut& !v^$t5i4x**ct{d,i$tr:.5s'idi.lrii$hel4:u|':$r}.'d'r,b;4.xsl9'it*'h*ic€stir+9'[,qt!b{:'l'hiv4fdftF%})(r.l:di''g'!'c*do";(*l,Ie; qdr: tr* l#Fs il iir3aF A l* F,ir+!l- .6i4 b$$tc ,*rs!ibtt+t|icitt,tb|bY.il(l,:i6*s(y!b*G:d,jCt[3!.!:i|r$55!,c$\h!r..'ra'{$<|is'$Js1'vc|s$c$d.ti*!wcnDi!e$r49p'Hf?#!d*i*$,ddatai..h.! []irrE$! ao!.r b e.bx Fl tr!.ni.$-- rtqa] t!* rrrot&,:& {6 [xrt*t *dt tilr*o pr{*6({lra? <qx{ itrzNr{ $ rqt39ts.Yc nt9.c{n (r4gr fc" nv.r sj8 n$t}Eiu ti}:ElAi .?r Rtnslc r$ !rE irsib' [Es. ndtqtrotti 31xpgr;lrpyrtrD:ihF.?tgttrirtisc|:@i't}Gic;iiS|n+'t,rlgi,iie5lw!i'b!r..t'iiiis*I!iRcab16lssAo'iE*K('re6xi**ro1hosjty.ioprriir<'tl.+hoihc|r49*'g$)i*et.w!cs'aed)t'a.{shxil,x{hEi,F4tnE{blvlitcfc9l'rFJ'FM;'\t!''cFtsx*arfnwi+ftut:!'E , i"*{irLr. Mhwr i*d6iinr; tif @.V E6Mr tif.rrom. irrirJ fAtrfatE/.'ilt M brnt prrltc ll rD{hFliid $irx $oltvd(q. z.Jtt )R. da0l*F|rrl ct tittC €t{ !.€Nril.hFr .
3i$'cFc$w$.{ursi|:uAdl'ilL|tFc5lvtrFn:dffp,r!fNfc,oi|s|g<!tE*Usf,1rR'DEs[:$t(lt'3$o!Gtljq':Qi'Y9:+Ad(,k*ry0!le!,e!$ g(irof. :|:trjaitostfc:liLe.rr ltgrii6{*ry4i:Gtnfii.i'irdod:hf,<!t$k$r.i:nrlrqtlDfoDgd,Rr4iftn:itfc6crr$hutJouis4:?itdc.s'f},':DFlo':!h:t*,t*!slhcird'r;coinr.*eri+i*ui'l&rc&scdNc:it'ei€d'*tirrfttv!.|s*o9t|€|idf'b:Ai gssll$ltr rr:ctr ir4gisrshw 6)6ri4ntnt*{ 4l ilrn F :}Jte:tt. ffr: ,x(rt tx+*..si$},E. :n+ t{K{r ie:dt i\ $ris Safr! irnlt$.,iv-}do id$d Fr,4:rssr}E Fn :
:1.f.*'l."f.'...19.'r:}:orcirigRo$i9aJo<{E,.+lla:*atlar*aoi<..*595**,g'p+iiii'i,'*ii,.i'r.oi.ii-qi*invnu'*ctt:{tl:E8lifb:|*af4r']xssqrq6'6:r4a'':ixuardnp.o.s!it!9'iug9*f'.c::o8st'(<r;R0s*is,avriteorAl:|$kxc*€$i.:o*t{!c:oU6si4Di.:l!r':l.i+f€f;Htdrrlc8!iF'al'iErtbf4^xt'hi::6\db{u.tcio6jw*rp.oo,.vi:.ii",tw";G;.';;G';;,";;;;ti':t-tg ttx:! {$$adli rs ibtiii }9.ri.rut&*vF.:!i5s tirrs*.vrd de B$ fe *xt .,ro. imwt atS a*bF rig+s+f :ic *}r;tc.
3 ii?Fiu;4:s-.dinr:v,(fr*oCcw,,go"on*r,iiirq;x*rtrt:xirnt6{pcl{{$.*.x{q)r*6-dr,y.d!io.i85.etiir:K5x6(.6)is$!t8r:6ta.D.ti,\rr-Aulxfni:ntnd*r:il;,rnire*Adkcuf.r.& i.i$!q,i..*v"r),silFq5'in'.!.,'irti.$!sRc€s\dqes.c*ii6}B'$:q6i*u*''}d*6:|s*bittt*llt''|io;g:iiiigiiigi<irtg'q+o.J€lli#'lpoii!F::Rcs4tq'srtd'u'({{cir4.y.{if}ceiI:i1'iiTilj.$]Yiiind,8lh}^Y'.:-Ff,.pcli?!'o[d{'i}P!:t5*lf4r.t8t r,i$nos{4rpf,1;rctrre.dr(,!*r:b($t:d.,iDfl;trg!$riu,ji[e)t.l11cfu{F.itgltF,irrO.Aar,ttjstftr .ris ir 6.o:*t{c 1r@iTl dal6 licr $sl }uf }i?S aft rn lf .{0 Fdr:i{eyrlg boHJllgT t:o.t ry ry*.,r}k4s r*iirr*?d rd rlslrtrx'. 16r.!$rr ,x{ito) rdti:o rbrtqi{ru td6 *,*"r.
.irtRqs kd[ frslrdr cusiDrf *rh ,rfdrJe refartt .iter( oh $i] (edE ;xltr reroiiw ut-trewi*xgr$oii8!*.coi'*d6|iriE'rdfL|rat|b|d.s:lnqdt*muoatonulrll*ioriiaG;iii'i;dii,.;ii;*'il.cisd.f"iipe'!{',h}d.!:ud!|qtt9{i'qn#t'Tirjdi'T}tEqNtr!vARRtttiYksEA$fo*i8ikn''i{.ie;d':o*io1a+iiJ1I:illr.zi}|EtxARf^NIiEs,:F#eRo#-rg^$|.$Y.f.i:rit53IQ'in,'E*'i'jUl,!ltiin$glsE.,\cotne.cY'i.|{oi6E.,.aiiiai;ioreoBrcriu#ittrri^figlsgNT 9r :HE rtqRC.#qRE.ppt$_pifE Eg f.^*ys :r1e$f*o"i(sF(Q6Ds4*3Itrf€,frioi,$''e'siF:"1:]::l}l*5''y.t'*":gl+}:h*ti*l'vstf.j$Jr$Elti,|x.'.'aY4.:l&$J.d||v*|.?gMi.,|$Bxnf{'*gt$,(ifGtl.'Eu'<|'itr.8J'tl'n$!s€gw*rrtlPmi.'ksl*njrl6<rttn.iqgit;td,"..o,'ii.o;i"i"i'*"i,'.ii@N tt nre? rA il]gp$.g 6i&rb- r,Hrr:o:b ee!,sl drf,ti$J i.J !t! ( ryrc o! is wc$crA wB rl dwrJs.8.lI|Rta.[tt'TsRq!t.l'Enc6.!rss}sojl-Rj65*no.q6F:rit'?f9,'ftr#sRr}'iinsHP!''.gEsw_'.t4aLt'sR^$..EI4g€${&'LiSf esoFfA $isisFat t:tgRaV$C*. !:G o.r;*!f {e*CerrrAi i,r,_li#l€ ,:r E+O1CAg $n&cns il,{Crld#'retesiriGcl8nBlpcir:rF,iEsli.r,iEiHre,iii$rNci.lrri$ai:rrrrdlE,rdCg15g1!qftr$;lldii?-iiiill*-
E.e
H$fl$tr1Ei*1.Htr:T,;:,f"AH,'*Tif^q.Jlff--.F,,Tfi*jigtriieH{i,fjf;}.ii*"-g;Ltr,u$l#:H;lilHHAp#e}.E'*'*e' ,rcnJsr,r.,.r,rit',*cfc6't?ul.t:{63.g\.nFjtss}tfIFY'€bi":i+vit'.i'Ar-|:+ionmcg.-'cr.nois.a=3'5.'';.3111i!}iz+-iii.i{ii}*'oi"iu..itqLE?o.:ls1c$'8RFtacoHFE:,,$pi4'1.^g|}er$i$gilg...{;f.'{'cr*{aia91.cqccit'tc€'rgrc€e$iF;;si'gcii;,i;;$ji;'.;ii:;d;;ii}f;:$fctr..frrrrHi'lri Lr*ct jN i:ruriEs!i,fil.sjrv Tlie{vri!_a[rn]i$ENi. #ili-Clrg.rrr-r ri,l|riiY.'lig^FooiJg;$|iNGi.:jd.NeF^eo.^6*g:aip.scsi'loltE).+xJiriL1y.rc43e.q1[,EoF!iFI$*Toi'ARe"pv'*ototl*u
#;1}.ii,fT;i'l'T#.li*';jH.sf*I.;..5*i::"T:r#*:fl?;.j**fii'6f.Hij#;'t*"ii.ii.J,r,l,.i;"t;;;.;i;;;i;i,J,"'9vft6fiqi*j."ibi'ttia.R*tesN.t€b'op'ldiNti'kibb)'ld.Wl:}Elii${C:]hv?RiFrcvnirtrorrrraia*d}'ci6f$fi}.})Ril[t{t$1f4. itc*rtfft iFtars tebR06:iJrp'iir:Ory,qc:iyrsrlrr;riticllX irifs|dF4f'/*96s:s!x:|<w'*|t':G|dri,fk.o*viwiittctttp<:tonartgms.ttraxcciuis.]c;;"'*':id;;i.i'to4lur&'$dEltt4xtn|$Ffdfas'9q.1'!'f4d}'ntp'of?.irsF$.s|,'qtlif'c.r*nyi"*l+'.utvengpa''':*rs.*dt..:'ir;+quno:..ircr*t*cmi$cfl|ff.
ffiTiil'&',f.iL:-f::Xi..HT*11f'i;tX.11$,iftff"li1.*fyf-;f:-J"1if ?i<qsp,t$rkr'(r$d,s,.)',cinur!$idsi.u3an+"iq,*riv,*"rorori6n.,ioo"t,.p:fc'9}^:uigl'lsA3'tl(RRRsTy'sx|f{a9nElHpI,es'th4r..+*mrrir*trrirrrrsT.qLiAtif4.gY',!cRQs.sAi'"|9tcRos'PRFj^9?s0*WtL'RF|,:l,{l4ftuv.F.i.8ew'al.Y.1I'ces.cieulr'gxrrecret$l.';"}E}e1.;cril.irsi.vriu;cli.rt,]ivi,.&-i.^,,rune+rr'!nttfr''''**'t!3rjr irc*?^:il:ri.o*'a€r_c&sros't##i.Nli;p;iijctr,c*usn*dcrss annrioil,:irer*i1*.ciqtuaGr''l|li.riA|.?EA3c$jrar€'Er:L\iT6*nas.*rar+l:*ari+*ireii,rr's5^9}*Aisr.;rr;*6*'''u*ic..l.^+olr*,rua*u
ili.f;$#ifiii,trSjiqqff"$illegllpli;},:**g* ffiTn1lru,*,s^ieroroiiiri:iiiriidivcrc,Fca:.?o]rsArs.r-rrrr*r1q133'I|'t<q!+.qJ5r!v3iL&ti<'*d!5H'li'eFc{:oF..fr.,,('{93l!.?,itetgEffcnr'j|JE.ovi3l?g.irb{AEni!^0'.i1t.9|ri.5l]Fr.il.t:.:ri ti:.t$$' t?'q rsb=rr.Nc_ €ir-sr:,-:di!r.r r*iui;pFiCiir:h-Cii?ii.g .*nus *orrcrtsg ess;s$i[:c{lLljfEc9qi}sT,3,.Er.ssrctrrr!son;isl,'siersvc'ri'rr+ini[.iiiiB.l*.:''rs*nB,JLr$;6xic-Jii;i-.i:s-t':kEyss.t.cl;grrvei*
^irtthil'r!fi*i:;t:zErr^ccesxic':us-,c*aepsivsils* ::rtjirii,iififfts6"i.;;ssr*';i*!'C'i;HJfi;;Elhe,r !$iro:iJANetEE,6!:clicsR*rEr.''.lli'$,ix0wrtilsn$8':e5r]'ell';^q53Bstl1$t|si:oJJ..mIt..'${1(5::l'l'i5lIlgj:itssf*+-l$l&:t.c*tyswlrgl4ll*qcsi(A{tt$E.$,$.mrdP*.*'}DMlctcb:t'Ntlliiifsr,a:o$,;ygr'6nr*o.a*+o.+rg""o?u.bnc5triar&l,txool.#11i1*."xo*11iidfi;iJ.!*9{|qsL:4tid.'|Elr@'nt{hEgdkduonttld*i*u-i*i*fIxum1i'rcny.a.c;oiruc*,oti*..diiic.,,t.ctlni'l!'ollri|d!c
ffSff;1';iffi,TH$J''#gffiHfinfi*ffih#gi$e'ffifttrd',tffitiffffi"***il'ri,*..ur.ie",ce'rFcrrs,$D'rs'rdr'r6tnr:*nsa.oeocc*rcm*aiil'.:l:'s,$y..c&nPr1.|icfqBuRfdB.i,lsf..IrBla*dtxll'\'1aJdftlt1'sni'n!.4:l1ctrq!t.}|*:rhs.uNq{It}'fJiD'5|t!oU'x,t'y;Bifin(4r,sifiitor'i*'siJc*t#'t.;f;;i*.:-t*i'**.r'".l.toioouio;l-'8rcad;iNicUgror,Ff;AdHiI^J.tfsl'f'ff,,|6R|s{t9TE,tJLY{Y'Fpl$.rTHrrsP6crreAhii'.,i:;;drIttlses",$ndNa;i;'Po".cn;i5dourar,'brnrcrii.oaltoiieiliiri..ie34FF^i.ne3RELA1t'v'rnwesug,lgcti,p.1Txnrra.aai,li{6r.;'niiiijrri*tc'd,P;.*i1Gf;E;^;;i;i.?rn.ao,vrgx,iiiiirlJi
iiiIfia.yrj:i*xsm.*u*:rn]Ici;if#:i,;;;|rs$t{*'Iul.t.}|fe'n8tn!*tllHdRE:!';n..:t.ah}aw'terlJt(trdllslcm''|fj*hq$&n'.it:l.|bsnr''.r:i'n*.J'{:l{,9rcm*fck!:bd.kmesiknaql:t6s!3i.r4't.t54fl.p:3i.j:xli!l$|kbQf$a*|pa{l'w!''t^ckJnNvjrEriF'a6,iai'*A.f$!r.}ire.'a<ilr:i'l#r*i*iL*"*Jri*.voor'"r,.otxr,.wnilntnlii.ai,rrrii*lt:e,*+lerl|lisis:{:|t*N.{.,:d'.ib8|iorqw:tc.tn+cicBjt2.f;,t*.,'i"piiliii.ri.e.".J,"#Li.xsi+Usi65sen*F.ci.5.!P4|#}"fl'0cg'$x!*)*sr*',*.?f/.93'*'".ai,r.'j.'ii.'l"]r*1i*itr*kE{:x',}:jesFp'Ef}xr.lc,^ii';,t,#,ir|ilN;fs'.Dtiq('sJn,*4t's'':EJq!cs':1,i''dtr:#Mn:rwrirrx''eunJJ't.li'ik'*.-"s**i;'d*;;;.b;;;;-firr*r;a<qo*x'll,lit"liita{*Y'+'!d:ti:okl!i"txJ:lt$ttF,tsdbrrd!hp.eilascsro".or*xu?*,iqelrirnb:'efQ6irq.(ifrEfiAhhsp\?Eirrrturl.ararn:rf{tr^r*,ndpca
s';i:serA'.9l:+ftvJ$t6r:4|:Bdi4u9'tigiiJot!.;rlx.Nl*m'o:.lrt:y*:vto:uixnxlr!'a?oso,,".'mi.r",*$.i"riiJ,'l*qtra;rrstrul*rurti'';.R+R6e'r:e!l(}r;itt9:(i6f:99:$cvl']Qt.'crs}sYti:FfM6h8s{*!''it.rctest:qiol''G'FF,s.'rsy..'A(ok4(qt s;ib.*{.:tir !r+$i:r $5&i}* {lx9*.yt*il p.+ryrkJ i$a,l h.{,rt ,aG8*d, ,ui*iivi, to ei{"q ,h ,o,r€ $ Srd r*itrrl! !r clrA4yr,|{c^os:?f€rs'.iii:6eddu6:G<f':8*,'ii'ittt,$(w|t|s!usc9|cittvjg{i{th'&dc':3},af|tn'9'^$:tA,Dsu+.d.q>|'rri'f!trca;tl.fi'qtHrr.ciaplua*1uitr+n'':"J.iii""i*ronloi,,ri+lgcrd'3rt*si+1rrraa35ai'icl,sl.a,',v..'qruwtli.iL}fq$dr+$s!f'(oi6'*6t}ioriii:*li{r$g!'l'qMoidiubg**;}.d,"ii.]iii}*os,oa*gi*+..c"r::ieliLajl,iriii,.*oQF{x$s} &d}t*x!*,ceiaurrsbo.d:'fid4r$*r.tsusr,ro*,:05o. or,.if!.i,;*i-,* r"rxii.{*;i;;;;;;ff;t.or:r$qrhirhiE*rrsaeEi+i!i$..|E'v,MFi}qtliIf9t4i'd"ufed€f''il*:l!s'i6|io|dr4i:^i:8'rxo:?rocau|W].iag4bJ9lqIff.ofbn'ldt'Ft{|su'ql,t'5tEs3ai^t''\'5Ut.c4.|t'|Ho{ri:n'.'loi'<1D':|3l|hE|Urnmu!'C*ugmrrrrs;;iii:iji';.*tt**.*.*,d'sc{an5\serf{i4ftsraljmuxm,nf.ir't*fr.,:a|;i"]'i.j-"iii.*;c"*-ot"""u,g'Lir"i.dniu,l**,^io.r.'"g,,if:fffi*il';lf*ffi[TJ.l*ffi1*lllltg;X-flffl'u#'-"i* ",oo',*a*uurtix*arr+,**uiir,riioe,r*i*riuo,,c-*;;;;.;*;;uf,q.rak\n(+qpcar^tr€q{Hqrqilft'ir'r.. sti.Ect nNvi'. fir'ri{u.wcfl r{0 r{$r,r(be h c$i!it; untp.s,:usrsiof fliios firq{k}Y$(:;i,Cc(8ft.hdmrloiqiio*l+.,:;sp{dLl$L.J.ao,Jo,.prlqJ*ia,rsc.ves.t":a.aid{i,iiiii.r.ii.i'jit-*,,o*o,*.i:rsvtt$b.q:ni$cRcs?ilsiRncr,irtaErcunct*cmryrgniocl*fi'imuic gc$oR.!r*ryi.f.rhpirr,tt+r;trr*i.cr:rouolE,nusr:Bof,treMl:irJ6ftb4{rel'*[u,:trrx.scRs *.dpj@aqr,iisi]*Ddr6Jb:rarndnt;;;,d;;i;;"tjiiii,r.*l,lr:il*u,i;;f;.ifitRbtlJ(A.fo's hf te:t br{ni&i rrh* iiraioDcidqiandrhrs5rclilimrtDs)!r*ci.sqkr"".",iCc'_iGlia,:;;;ilil:tn,_o,.
t{i} qi.t*ts i wd ..g j\x
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 22 of 53
TE:
04,€9ri0sF.i. E5 ASCCIUI'JT E,'( EC UThE:
Llnn A bvhitp
CUST0S{ER A*SOUtr't,*: S:ALfi,S ORBER #: iriQll!'r iilf; B trirFp:rtQ t \!Pr
6.\,Veehs:usr.otd€R'g LE€AL NAraF:
4 -9 F AOyFNnrRgs t I.c$ron€ L64AT|FN l$trE LrAfi €l:
94d4.&y0nKsil0Fgss
'!1'!2 W'esto$ Fd. #i9t$ptfiiit
5"70J $snset Friye; t3!g;lrY FtrItE !i;r
eVeslgl FL 33gt6
ItG!9[
,954.593.SiiS0
ifiY :g".{TF flb
Miaryii FL 3Ai43 305-667-42ts3BItL TO. IF DIFFEREI{T TI^IAN ABSVEI
s Ti ri$ A Lg.ott\9 ytr,rplN.|. ? * yES _x_ t!r)
sldtP To (FEUIIER Tg). tF DtFFEREttT THAFI ABOVE:
ii.fiR.iS,S I'i)3iF(45
)lTr lf.nTt ;tP +{fi{n $TA!E gtA 4tfiit
oTt _Pl4l'tiuersERu$? Feici lilin!
$ 725.0SServices $
trtrg ortrvt$es Drttvlo:
PREPAY
rdrll A LEASI|\IG cohdpANy BE US€F? _ ?ES _{* l{{){E}& CUSTOT{ER? *x_ ygs _ NO
TAX
TP.AVFL EXPENSES
SHIPPIMG
TOTAL PUNCHASE*'gipiwNc'i,$-4 $r{tr.rrNc19 gs p1,1sp;u"
rO BE IN\,oICEDTO BE INVCIICED
TO BE INVO|CED
725.0C
NONRETUNNABT€ UEPO-SIT
CllECKNUtslBEh;
B*LANCE OUE
$ {7?5.00'S P1O REQUIRFD FOR PAYIVi.NT?
YES, INSERT PUI{CHASF CRDEA I{UfuIBER:
I t\lfl- (:i fnTf"li,tstrt turl ler rrrrar r I rFFc r/-J!iU$TOMER T,IAME: s..q EADVENTURE$ LLC
CUST'f,MER EITE P'iTHtN DISTRI{;T $E,IVICING IERRi'CRY'
,(_ yEs ** r.lo ,l,44e.a," t, "{*..'.J * t
"ilcH dSTRtCr? ... _*sFLP.frifiTE t,{ANE
HAS RECB\IED A}i ON ATL FAGES C
"' iiii'ri"'-tl*'dr''--":'lD AGREED To TIiE ?EBI,I$ TI{DF TH'S COITTRACT, .'I{C LUD'NGOIUDI?I(}U3 dff a,.!ttch u66EY^Ff|n.llRF f,lv.1I'FFH.i ETIT|IE AHD
p{;{FF.rEg.er..
L6lxFlAr{Agi&
I
trH?r#rss-SALE$CONTRACT
M|0ROS Systerne, Ine.632 $. Mititary Trail
Deerfield Beash, FL t33442
?4?406C1O,0O.95.00
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 23 of 53
[nrsi$s'Ship To: eAfiEWORltg
ecv iFe** il;;;
9iB Tor A.t E AEVEIfiJRES LLC
l{a rd wa relS E#werel${r;oplfes A dde n d wnS,stes C*ntnrct #: .l-L
.ofl
!Tt]'r11 ;Gl.{ .0tttD,OJ JO.qt4 C.0tei,'tri. S+€Stl.{tl*'$*n l^d*e4rJqm? .{ sy!$? .!,t
ff*t;"i' l-ffipi I ro-$ |ffie,' t...fl_**J
'l$ti:.:rli: \/
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 24 of 53
EXHIBIT B
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 25 of 53
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 26 of 53
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 27 of 53
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 28 of 53
EXHIBIT C
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 29 of 53
Yost Hame
Your LscCtion
td&A S.rcup:iLC *'e Gare*iinre Fortl+[,ers10$3? Gulf Cente1 Crr
Fcri MlsrEFL 33S13
Your Contsct
Fhon* NurnberEnuilAddresr
0rseb &terica, Inc:5tl0 Grucle Fari<rr,'a11
He$rjood $nates.,g.qE4tl65
fd!ir6,Sbe*assis
clracb tJetpila8g Fptd arld Severete po:int gi $ale
j Het,Foe
31?:rlrl
A, Agreament and t$odlflcatio,ns to the Agresm€nt
{. Agre*ment
a' This sldef incorpsrates bY ruierEnce tne ieflrs $f the oflsle M38lei.fsreement usict:rA-irr561i-€g$ ind atl Bmflidmer,rs Bnd lcdersJa therato {the"Ms$le'Agf86rnet(:}.T5g4*6'gd.ism.!intkahiester,Aglee*errtr}oauh.a.reGs*'n*"me"nit?!'rtlliisEIderuftessolher9.,is€5Fqcirl*|dh|n.
B. General Ternrs
1. Surnrnary of Fees
e' Listed sbovs is a Et''fifrtary sf n*t lees due uncel lhls otrtet, Aft nees on ru6 0fdef afe in us o{r}tsf3 gr:d are e*susiue af sfiy spplicable shiFFtnscharge$ sr applicable tades.
b. Ys$ haee ortrerad Hardwaf€ arrd,tr Frogrerns iAnd s mo{th5 cifte,:hnicd ouFFcri s*G,ices,
c. Fsr Coflsutlir?l SEryiCe$, fees tQf trxed pnce ru-"rces andlor.egtinn&* for.Tnrw aflrJ Matetisls services wrJt s,$o be,tstr?d in the summ;ry Ehova.
?. Commeneament Drte
a, Fot Gomrdtilg $ervicrq. i,\e Conrmenil*nerti Fnte siisl| be,.the efedive dale of th;s syd*.
3. Priqirg lnvoiclag and payment Obligation
*.Fs!s'0'rc0tt9ufin9Sexieesrrnybeirwoicedi}inadvgnceotrervrTqt*I,nd.nc9|w|rr'$fpse'.1lice.s;uji}rnrnilr|yasgetvicflar::pefflxrdr$[nnranl[*qie|i9|sservicesrvhichiireig*rrtitioc*ircwan1petl*cur:'ln..aoaitisn.tarne.Ber*cele€sHsted;n:th;,Brdei.kgtitliItinvorc*Ygrlf'}r1f3ve|g&Jcu1jor.pa'ukerexsei;5.finy,i.l"t*at"IG;#ii;{to9"*:.anv.gmJi'[lt'.Ere e5J[Batse- 3.td'ate i4t€dded ortly la bs'Jsr'Yoqcou*$etini Furposes. .silcir e]pdne". uar iri,'nuil#;! iil;;; -'
sr6,0cri6^ t.tscssJ.sy Or4eie Aftoccn. ir,{. ,?ffl?ri
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 30 of 53
4. Fae*
Of,ce pteEsd, ygur ude{ shalt be no+csncedob afld the s'rJrtrs pritd ncnreiundairle. a}c€pt bs.pr^r}vided ht inE} }r4s5te.rA$raerreni.
5- Order of Prgcpdance
in lhe euent af anqonsisiercies hphryeen the tefrns atntaift€.J ii this Crdcr ard f,re t!r6sle'Atredment. thi5 trder ehaE tAi(a Frecedgnce, This Order r*ilfco*trol oisr lhe te'rrrs Esntained in any ptrn:irase urder.
6, OfferVf,lidity
Thtr qrdsr is virlid ihrcvgh l+FHSr3ls. and shslt Qsr:*rne tiB.JmS r$tn F.xecuiioa 9, *u uid acceFtance bt' Crletv.
7. C ustorrier RBferBBcg
orade may tete( It you as gi? irecfB G$$ltlner sf ihe fidsred Pr'oducts snd 6errrtce Dfi?ringg i$ setes Fieseri:;3$of$.a:'k*ling ,lehide.r..snd aff,{ilies.
{" RightF Gmrrted I Rsstriq,tion+
a' UFw paymen{ fgt Sorvices. fau-hav.e inorl'Dxclu&\'e,1an-asg!Sq1-ot. {}alf,tre . perFefial, li,.niieC right tu use frr yoir ir.rr.ernut L\ieinecaoperetions aP,ylhins develcpad lr9 oragle snd d€li.uEred ls You undei ttlg rd.{iifde{iw;u6;i;'*h"evJr. i6rta,n ueri*[uruo-,#il*-*i*Lo mf,dditionf,l lkers€ lerms pwided in thie ordef.b You may afiorv v' out us""t-1*.:.9?hactors iincJyciog, lfttayl.li;nrtajbn. ouf;otucersi t0 iJs* deffr€rcbFs lbr yo.Jr iai*rnal busine$ oper.*tions andYau are resFlnsible for their compliance wittr the Agreerienf aa* tfrs otde" in iuch r.is".
' -
c' $ervices ploeid9C T6f \ lSfec.la,.Your lisefrie tc uee.Products rv,,ned or disiributerJ by ora,:le ,,rhichiy$, ecnure undiar I separate crder. TneaBree{}€nt f€teaenc€d irt lhal e'de-t.*$ell:Sorretn yotlr usg of. s\rc}t, pr,lductg. t1' $ st !uF' t vel"t drv : Bruei:
,2. Sen ica Deccriptions
!e1xt$r'ra$o,etYouha15.or!eledUnderlhisfrdEfat'ede9crtF*dnar,icEot.e$redF}?'ho'ccnsuRin8$eMr;+3..serr.ie9de,fJis|icrCaesiJttiBg Ser.vices sedion A{ wrv\li.ttrac}s.corr r*cent, aets.
3. Tlne rnd lGetetiah {.T&it-} $enricec
a' consuRrng |e1+ices rdenlified above.Ss -Pgr Hc8/' atE provided sn a tirrra snd maieriets frSMt basis: lnot is. you ehali pav oracie st fc.r ail rf thrlirnesF€ntFer{orgrr'nsl$chrgruii'tga!th*1a|E'p6tifetJai,.+l,v,r.t*.*eqri,;ri.ix#-],.q1i*ra*,,A|1fed
b. For coasilning Services tserltirred abw6 Rs, -p€!.Hsi,r". the ft€e rpe*iea in *iL-*e abc,re are esiimaree ,;, ,ail; ;; ;;;ftil#il;io l" torYaur btdEetrrg and or+gt€'* reaourea *6hedu{in8i$wp$se$r thesa:estirsaf's oo "*il*iJ$ i*i.#-iiiiir"-n;itin""ive yfi, for autu,irl time s*entp€tfof'mi'Et$e'scM0es,l)|t.,$mfie{!ala,tgx€*p''dih:'iiises's'J..*iin,$gir:e:*y*ii.iarn*romr*5t,#atedar$!ft$d$
lheles{',}l,*eo$ €arhthe asiixste, oficlawill rooperiti'rrrur'yiiriir*led;,;#;il;r"rv*ce$ an a r&i't,baels.
4, Asrumptloor snd Obligrtinns
f.Y6$|yi|'ideFt,'fa'J€s;g,}at9d,cq'}tactlog{dc|e.rvith'h*3.pp'o.P'i+'teve|.qta$|hprity.tosetpfior'ife.$.sqt}ToioRte8ctMte9irndreta!'r
l"]yl.ej.Tg-"j.PSrns to euFpt\rl lhe Fefo{rnflsce otrhe t?onsulring ServtCes.
B;13"il"{'!3f,|l6sunable tsguest. You Bgt*e !o previde dch acces$ to r*lewnt resaiJrc.{rs vr..iih trncwiedge io surrpori the performance ri th*
1voywiriuoui'l€f6.aitcn1f::11':r*:'r,fontjrlo11yti.o,su*99,.:j^\.:-.j:j::,]l1i|s"{*andlrea|lh|Ulrqfrkspeceie.:'r,,a\,,k9F8€ih3t|gfreefrgrtifefog'ii:redhB2aI.tJstftatprecausing.or|ilqeiytogruse.',Jea|hc'senoUs9f'u.sicaikrntr'awofsga*evrainasPraFer'Ea|ilstioacsepr€bk ior resourcs petforr-rinB sennuzsin the ;orksl;.sce,
""ulis"no*on, ioi'r* *** ,i;;;;,';i;- " -' 'd.Arryrequeatfwchenges'nc$f'siJfingseri{'e*m$5lue,inr+tjiing:iiin;nc*dess,,q-u':-,lr':Jectp|-a'fssEop€.'9pfcifiations'schedule.dir$iiis'r${|0fe4t.en'0..sErv;e9$s'fye'ab{es,sofwareenyE,$qe|tl.htr9.''9e$Gnd;L.-iiy.ou,u'Bspeutbrv-c,ure'i'ii'orcru$uunal
:l{H-;s$Xf:1*f";.:***u hr iirne, scope. *osr.,oicqnr'a'tuar wriiaiiono*tii'f*i'iiiiLlir! rg;H'rfsrir-,1ts ihe pr$pos*d *ranse rn ii,i;*,j,Txl3iiJ,?;?**iJl&1$J*tr"iffi*:!ions i2{ tFR i$5.?31i. You u?in a$vo., (rra,*e ro Fr.{ a roric.G res*rdhrs ordcrr H-18 ftnproye*{'i ar
$, Warrantlae; Dltchlmers gnd E*clusivp Flornedies
s' orscle $,ana$ls that su*'T*:Inprcvided in f ?rlle.1lona-r afHlef cons:sten! \.5tth indu$i:r) s'trrrds. you nr.rst naii[,*ra-{e of any wananlyf"lsj"$.sT1't6.dagsfrcmpedcnnince*ii,eue.'n,;i*ntsefyice-<. "D(ilsuod]'rHr)cD'cv' le$j7r'lstxf'c.fy'i.Jrab{eof8tlyv/ar
b' FoE AHv BREACH ol ^H1J-vl!t{ryw. YouR exil-usrve REmEov Aip. rqRAcLE s EirrrRE LrAEn rry sFTALL EE rH€R€-pEJ?FontnAFqE oF rH€ ocFtcr€xr sERvicis, b& ir oiAcii-d*niijti'fiiasr*xnarlx eoinFCf rile osrtcreilcy tN,a
9?e4BB5 ' t ,Esued by gracle A.iyrencr: tnc.. cB.{:it] "2E : s
pBQe,Z sr..s
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 31 of 53
COMI'ERCIAILY REAS€I'IABL€ IIAHHEN, YSU III'AY EFIU TfIE O€F{CIEIIT $SRVI$ES:ARD RECOVEF T}IE FEES YOTJ PAIN TO ORACTEFOR TTIf OEFIGIE}IT $ENNGE&g:.T9 THe exTEt{T lror P.Ro.filgtT€o.!y LA}!r, ?ttrs wARRAirTy ts ExcLUstvE ARo rHERE ,sRF N(' OTHER eXFRESS gR $rrFLlEDwARRAiln€s oR coNDfrlot{s. INGLUDING $ARRAilnEs on coolomoxs oi r,rrncxnnrAgrLrry rlro riiriibi?oRffFiliiiAitlTfiPURPOS*
ll$,{. Group LLe cro Gatrtatirne Fort ltlyetr*
Authorlred $lgnature
Name
Title
Slgnafure DatrcF€L-._Serg. eOfS*--:--
lssue<i by lrrsdj6.An'6nrjr. Inc Ct-,5€C_u01jpagi S:.f :l
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 32 of 53
EXHIBIT T)
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 33 of 53
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 34 of 53
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 35 of 53
COMPOSITEEXHIBIT E
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 36 of 53
{}I?ACL€-Page I of2
INVOICEFederal Ta:r ID: 94-2805249
BILL TO:A& E Advenhrresl-l,Cc/o GametimeMr. Mike Abecassis1600 E 8TH AVESPACE 4-147TAMPA. FL 33605United States
SHIPTO:A&EAdventuresLLCc/o GametimeMr. Mike Abecassis1600 E 8TH AVESPACE A-147TAMPA, FL 33605United States
FOR BILLING QUESTIONS, CALL: (8S8) 303-7414 OREMAIL: [email protected]
(: 65t4284m$9n. $!F$i S::i 29-Aug-2016t .fuO-;.. POEF 340529496
ip,fr.ItNsn$.T:t NET 30 DAYSDES'n-St$.,r,: 28-Sep-2016
PAYMENT INSTRUCTIONS:REFERENCE 6514284 ONYoURREMITTAI\CE
NLAIL CHECKS To: Oracle America" Inc.P.O. Box 203448Dallas TX 75320-3448
wrRErRANsFERsro: Hlttrllfff*?*ACCT 4522420841
,1';ffiU*+;ffi*pffi.i.iii:::::::::::::::ioIi*e[DORDDR:,:,:,:,::,,t,:,:,:,i,1,,i:::::,,::ii:::,:,,';e+i,,ui!ti;+i;i:i$+i
ii::i..:ril..iiiiiii:,iiiiiil;i:ilir:.i:l:;:i;i:,:.iii:.t.ffiDiluffiili.l.l,i:.liili.i:,,'i.i:...:.:...i,...i,..',i.i,l ::::i::ii::l::::::i::::rlf *;UUf$en :,:,.':i:,i,.,i.,: j.:,:ts.$*I;SI j'.Ii+.,,Il--,,Yii
Moreno, Ana Corina(Corina)
300529496 Mike Abecassis A & E Adventures LLC c/o Gametime
tr;FS.{j,:il::::Ir[el;:t::::i:l ..+ru..:ti.ii.,:ii'i.ff ffi ffi+ii..ii.li
I BMs{IF&BTOS Services per Hr) - 18 hn billed at 99.47USDlhr I N 1,790.46
2 @ piHr) - I hrs billed at 114.1 IUSD/hr N 1 14.1
J 881074(3.HW InsAll Componeds) - 361.8 USD t N 361.80
4 8810S3(4.HW Install Servers) - 80.4 USD 1 N 80.40
SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS: |rtT
,;734.90 | o.oo 2;t34.90
Less Payments 0.00
CreditVAdiustments 0.00
Outstandins Balance as of 17-Sen-2016 2,134.90
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 37 of 53
f}r+ACL€-Page 2 ofZ
INVOICEFederal Tax ID: 94-29A5249
6514284
NET 30 DAYS
5 US:PARKING I N 5.80
6 US:DINNER N 6.17
7 US:Mileage/I(m I N 2',16.48
8 US:HOTEL I N 99.68
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 38 of 53
ffi€ .Lffi'', Oracle ServicesInvoice Expenditure Details
Report Date:8/29/2016Page 1 of2
JUUCZ9zt96
HGBU 9002271 GametimePOEF 3005294966514284
18 hrs billed at 99.47USD/hr
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 39 of 53
ffifffeffiLffi'' Oracle ServicesI nvoice Expenditure Details
Report Date:8/29/2016Page 2 of 2
Labor Automatic 26-Aug-2O16 4.nvv tnstarlServers
881083 0 o.oo o.oo 80.40 881083(4.HW Install servers) - Eo.4USD
Labor Automatic 26-Aug-2016 2.F&B ProjectMgmt p/Hr
880285 0 0.o0 0.00 1 '14.1 880285(2.F&B Project Mgmt p/Hr) - 1
hrs billed at 114.11USD/hr
Labor Automatic 26-Aug-20'16 3.HW lnstallComDonents
881074 0 0.00 0.00 361 .60 881074(3.HW Install Components) -361 .8 USD
Labor
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 40 of 53
C}rQACL€"Page 1 of2
INVOICEFederal Tax ID: 94-2805249
BILL TO :
A&EAdventuresLLCc/o GametimeMr. Michael Abecassis57OI SUNSET DR STE 330
SOUTTI MIAMI, FL 33143United States
SHIPTO:A&EAdventuresLLCc/o GametimeMr. Michael Abecassis5701 SUNSETDR STE 330
SOUTI{MIAMI,FL 33143
United States
6s r7301
PAYMENT INSTRUCTIONS:REFERENcE 6517301 oNYoURREIvtrTTAI\cE
MAIL CHDCKS TO: Oracle America- Inc.P.O. Box 203448Dallas TX 75320-3M8
lilIRE TRANSFERS TO: WELLS FARGO BANKABA 121000248ACCT 4s2242084r
FOR BILLING QUESTIONS, CALL: (8SS) 803-7414 OR EMAIL: [email protected]
riiiil nr.n lIS l;::lu$ffi x+*qlliiilli.A & E Adventures LLC c/o Gametime
Moreno, Ana Corina(Corina)
30052949',7 Michael Abecassrs
irlilis$.r.1:::i.:tstiil:::::::::*' iiliii::..it'Hfttiiffi i:ii:ii:ii
I ffiices perHr) - 16 hrs billed at 99.4ruSD/hr N 1,59r.s2
2 @1tp/H0 - 3 hnbilledat 114.11usD/hr N 342.33
J @-361.EUsD I N 361.80
4 TEms llEW-InstattTewers) - 80.4 U SD I N 80.40
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 41 of 53
(}I?ACL€-Page 2 ofZ
INVOICEFederal Tan ID: 94-2805249
$Ri:i:i:.i:r:r: 6517301
,SIV;rCI.fS$:D'ASIli 30-Sep-2016
rV rP;S..:I$:{J:ilF.ER:rr
.r*,Vffin. nns,ii'rli
NANET 30 DAYS30-Oct-2016
) US:PARKING I N 9.56
6 US:Mileage/Km N 130.68
I$ xn s#j'rsP srRUcrIoNS, xirii$tb+-ffffiirr
2,51529 0.00 2,516.29
f xs Pcvments 0.00
CreditVAdjustments0.00
ffi03-Nov-2016 2,516.29
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 42 of 53
ffi*"4$uffLW Oracle ServicesInvoice ExPenditure Details
Report Date_: 1 0/3/201 6Page 1 of2
300529497HGBU 9002284 GametimeNA6517301
l\D - ualllEulllc lvrrqrrrr. rr,ers
RES on server Provided bY Customer
ll9 - 9-rrrsrrrrrv
RES on server Provided bY CuSomer
o 0.00
6T6
0.00 361 .EO 881 074(3. HW lnstall comPonents)361.8 USDLabor Automatic 30-Sep-2016 3.HW Install
Components881074
0.00 80.40 EEi663(4XW Install Servers) - 80.4
USDLabor Automatic 3GSep-2016 4.HW lnstallServers
861063 0
't,591 .52 B,W282(1,F&B Pos Servbes Per Hr)
16 hrs billed at 99.47USD/ht
-
Labor Automatic 3SSep-2016 1.F&B POSServices per Hr
B,80282 0
d
0.00
0.00 0.00 342.33 e86285(2Fae Proiect Mgmt P/Hr) - 3
hrs bifled aI114.11 USD/hrLabor Automatic 30-Sep-201 6 2.F&B ProlectMgmt p/Hr
BE0265
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 43 of 53
Oracle ServicesInvoice ExPenditure Details
Report Date:101312016Page 2 of 2
ffir;iiffiiT.[3d@7-ilgltiiglilllliilll NA
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 44 of 53
EXHIBIT F
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 45 of 53
{:}l"dJ}f,L*'
iltme
Address
tul&A Gr$uP LLc
ft,1037 *ulf $enter trr
Fort Myer$ FL
33S13
Coritact
Fhone N*tnber
S.mail Addresa
Gracie Ar-:!erits. l{:e5011 0racle Parhr'vay
Fle<tc,r$rJ $holrllr OA
t.i0$-q
Miks, Ab6cessi9
$5.1-69367?B
nre$as.br
lgsu*o,try Crscle Anerice' in8' tE-FgE-?.0r?
PaAe 1 of $
Froperty Name Bantelir.Ie Fott lvtyers
fb.g{sftu foo.lerrd Be.+erage Point of $ele irlpE $effBJi{tl $ert4ces '
. r fso tbsctidfot! il€t F*{
Oiher Feet51*1.S{ii
totel Fpel 5
cPG.X8o?d{.. I
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 46 of 53
A" Agreement and Blsdificatians ts th€ Agreement
1, Agrssment
Thisorder'ulcerF.rrare*b'refererctrilet*r'IHoflnecnilneTrgilsaD!ibna!ctBc'ei{i]s.+e'A,}rseme'.lIsn(Sii1edu:ieAcr6empn(1whi,*rmsv't}e,rielaledathitp:/i}v$t}vofscln*o"rr*ipo*!e,4ontr€cts,tt.$5u|iir'g+ervicesiir,dex'httftl.Thoc€dinedtefrnsin'th}I$|er'*fiteerw*lt sirsti hew tfre sgrr]e nreaFir]g k] {hi$ stiJer uniegg triherviigg ii}eei$ed herelti.
B. GaneralTems
tr. $urot$rry:of F€GE
ugt€d ahAva is s sirnffFsr,./ of net ftee due uilr,ef lhis ordel All tees oR this orrler are :n us collars aM ale eKciu*i're uf a'r.v s.cpiicabie shippint cirsrges
oo ippric+ue rares. : :, ri^^ ^.;_-a-,. rh.aFot$.:nsultirrg'$e|Vices,be$'Brfx€t1prise5e'vices'i.dlor8sti$ate$k,{rIf}1'ar:!6|sattx-iajsser'i.*$.vJilia'5ohE
t. Comrilebcofte$t ns$
F$f C0rE$ttiilS Servfces..tire CoctnrerrerY.rstr, Dale'shNll b,e'Dre €ldgctive Date:of tfiis Brrler'
3. Pricing Invoiting and Payment Obligation
Feesfi;ons{.lltla4s*rv1,:esi'ayhef1vli9f,j1.1'^.y1no"*''sel.JicepBrfe'Ta6Pr'fR{e.d|.QqF€rc'D'$i.{'Iii}m'rfTJi'}sand[|aleria|s]'s€n/j.,caswt1td3a8'iderr'ifiedeDoue*;"JH;i;/.iiiaaq'tonroiriiiil'i.F.*v{in:meow lDu b travel snd bi.rt's.r-pccket Bxlans€G ft ttw.ieiateJll lhy Fut{oPTss{males and are lnleiroeap,]['to f-i6'id;b"dgetilq p'Jrpgses' $udr bxpenses vciii !]e inioksei e$ inculrsti'
Nstwis'$tandhQarr"vrhingiothe$cntfsry.ifsddttiGBtothese{Vice|eestistedia.|ftscrder.Qrackw|ll|fivI.!ic{'yoi|}I|f'gerYices'.u$Jer|iiiBorder'RsvelTif{o3isdelineds*t.*r,iiX*+-*i;r;;..*li1'n'u*#:ici,a*lil*rr|ii!irherp|aFtJbisctrlh8'srar}e.Tfr4xP.'l|Dy'Yot'wtl|.'9Ini*F',3i*a]}g"El:Ttr*era*sinyoti'iJei,it'ttui'*roercoesn#'inct*Tlgggorder R{tt,bs *11,e$dad lia Gi-C['ang*c"1troi Frac6$R 18 hctude such Tta{nil Tifre taies'
4, Fe€ls
,cnce piacad, ysur order eial! be norl4arlcelsbie and the,surn€ psrd.nor:reiur'dabie, exce-pt i}$ pr8?idBd ifi'lhe laBsler '&'g{esftr8nt'
Fl0t'ilhstBrEl3fqsny$t-gvi9.1of.:,!o*re6sstr6{yifrllleMa9te|Agrtirfent.allh€spafalletgsradeuadprtnl5of,Jeifre ittwitx,
5^ Order ol Frecedencs .cer wili* ,* *n*n, ot iFcsnsiot$ruE$ tlet$/eeri tna tsrryig $)ntairied irl trrie flde{ arB the I'.lasler Agreerireht. lhis nrdei shaii lake FiEcedefce' lhis ct
lll^i;""G.t'i"liiri* iifititoeu in artv purctusa orq*i'
6. €ffective Deto
The efhc$ve datE ot ihis rrrder io Yotr sgnan'rre date'
?- QfferValldttyThis ofderris eatid ibl,otagh ?&FEE-201i, and shalf beAltrie btndi&f,,119gql.g}gciItign by
"'$$ And scsgple$t8''A'Y 6tacl6
t, Cugtqmer Relersnce
CrudemayreprtuYoua"s.anct'g9gacustgmero|ths$det9dPTFd\xd9'gf}dsgrvigs.o'f€'i',islinsaletrpreserl1
Gr Terms $pectfic to Gontqltlng Sswices
1. Rights Grantedl RrctricUonc
8:Upo|lF6ytief.hf$et.vicar.YoUnaUa]|henon^eXeIusiyeincn.a6siQrrsble.roy*|f*ea.:perp?jtttli'iilli'P,,sperariors anythir€ dev64sped by Q*ch a'd c"n*'*i-ii'vou'iinJui trir'org6r-t'*.ri*riu"J'l: hu*ever' niltain deiiwratiiPE rncy be sitbiect ta
iiiffiiini*;ls. rirrnt prc'ilced ih lh3 order
o.$ournayeltotYoutag:nisandc0nt.?$y-?{i1$udns,,*itlloUtiirrtilntiofi,og'5s''.ta.$J!:^..rsed*|ir.iraRss.ygu aie respor6infe nt fnfir *rpi;uira'-iii rit.i t lattetlqtu*"eel and this order in str'dl use'
c.scrie€spfs!.lt'€d$uyt}6r6|a|edls!1ou'|iceP!9etc,us*er9o.ucts.6i,fNdordistributedbyofBote,'iIc}|Y,]3fire;G;;Bt;E;&.d in'that order *hatt E{r'ern Yot'r tisv ti suctt Frtd\icts'
2. Servlce DescriPtiorir
66ngtrltinE Seryrceg rfov harre otde:ed undet thi$ ordes ira desuribGd jn and gsvesneu
congulffi Serviies gectiiin at$,xatoract'?'cofii"tcntr3cl5
CPG'zSlt44' 1
bt,lhe C$heuttit:p F,elu.*:es sPrisc de$ctiptloris loutld in t'he-
tssue'$ by 6qede Am*ci':r. lirs' 15-FEB":0'17
Pa{s ? o! 3
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 47 of 53
3, As$$mpuons and 0bllgations
a, ycu wll irienGry a degignaied contact ts Ofacl6, wth tha a,i$fgFristo le\r€l qf suhority. t0 $€t frriaii'Jeg. +ootciriale acliuiiies and rssoiue 90n-fiici!
bet*eer' t'cw teams ls:su.pstlrt tna $re#crnarrcp o{ the Uo'l$ullisg Strvices.
b.UBori0rach9ie8$oir+biei]eq@$t.1tuagieetp.Ffo!i'Je'0r*s}ealtess.1ot"kvanlreS<lurcr:sr,viin*rclrv|edgeCo0Sutttq $gruitrrs
c'u}tJ.l,'itiproirdefsra||f.ca$ere$ourc6epgr|orntrrg.i}onefi1iirg.se'u'eesRl'Yourtg(jaiti}n€sirtef|t}88{1ffro$fecofniied'hciards$.,"r]atecaUsifd.ctlit(ehitc'catjSe'teaforser;cuspnysicalhaf|n'alnli]ri(5ca'e|nathasp.:op.eruent:tei:on.5U3d|ewl$accefiabd br resources per{crrlrt$S gervices rr tire lvoricspsge, and erRono$ics:ly coftectr$rk slaticsr'. etc i.
,J. ArV ieqHest kr chaflles io fonsrilislg Servicss rnusi De is writi{g: *.his inclurJes changq? ifi f}l$}ecj p:n-ls.s€u?l ifl:T:f::,:f::'11,:::'Snl'req4ri#ilts, selice diliveraUur, *oriuru *nrrlrornent,
:hardvrere-emircnfient $r Br{y.othst aiFe(r of 'vbtit. erder' Crede srraii ntt he obligaled tn
9eifo'8}t?i$iqiiEr.tedlof;naEgesin.tinre;gc'Fe.casl.sfte8lra{tu'|0b1i$alinnsirr.rti|i*cuai1t1Qra6lBag*eirr$.'itiJtgt{,sntsr)drnant tc Y$ur erdef.
b.Agfeguir*db}.iU.$.Pep?'!$entoi'L3hpt.refuialir:19i}3Clt|1655'?}4.t:Yitwi||ei!(}.{srob:|[lyJ$|qlhB {ncrl( 5iits priG ic t"ta employaet anival cn slte
4. Tlms and Matariala {'Tfllr"} $ervicss
a,c$$5u|tingse.n.cosidC:nEified*b'^*eas*Feri.lorifqfe'F.{wNedonQii|",}41'f.j"J."Ti'oki'T$Mr}ua5iii:lfatis,{*u{itii]llpfvctracieBltiqr99'pqnrparhrming3uchse;;i9g;at,ti*tgtegp'bg,.feds6gvu,F|tiq'E6ieria!s'i.otesarrdsrper'teB./\if'es.6t8,JexFgxr*es.'lf
u.ForsDfisultinss€rvi6e:$U6n|ifedaboVe.99(?el|.lnL+r,;tF.€ise.*spec.1fte6irl!ner8bIeaboveBreestid:a!es|8,:labcrsnBiEiiiefd*YotrrhJdgetisB.,rrrdotacte.fressi,rsessJerJritrqE-.rposesltF.ane-Estfnaies.uonntliiuJde!sxes*(tgswil|*r"t,liixuilll.'gduaif*rrming11,1gsefvicBF.ptt5matBriats.'ex€seno.anpensieii.u*';;u,oct*u'ig^tBedtr,atg!aiestit'tatedirY,i'8|ttE..dr]cu{'l'r!jii** srri.* raecn.ttie cstin!;tr. 6iiir*nti"ioi.*ite'*.,r:$'/oti ro:rnovl.te ciir{i$'.,irq $Erv:ces 6n a T'it"l basis'
:5. Warrsotles. Eieclakners and Excluslve filernedieg
a.Gtarl*wirr3ntqt}iatSe{viceswil|beFfov!dectin'$ohssto8#rIi.rnRefqar'$isteJ]i,.!ithindus1r',i$tsRda|ds'YcUnrusti\stit.omg|eofanynertanletciendqs wrttfin g(! dny$ tram performf,nce vf th€ den$iellt setiiices.
b. FOR AllY BREACH OF THF !\IABRII]X^I9UR EXCLUSfvE-.tEJtJfl.;l'illD oFAgLtF- Et{rtRE-LlABlLlrY sHAtL AE THE RE-
pEFFURtT^llcE oF *tE. O€F.C.EXT $F*lffi5"'ir'{l |ft1aqS-.-*$fu Suesnoxrnlw coRRseY rH€ 'EFIGTEH'Y
lil A
comreftctntly FEAs$NABLE mnnxrR, you tytAy Ei;rie oeliurtr sin'rlce$ Axo nEGovER TBE FEE$ You PAID rCI 0RASLE FoR
TTIE DEFICIENT SERI/ICE$
;. Ail;;,**; *oi "*oouqqs,$.Hryr3ts
wARRAxry ls Excl.r|$t\iE. Asrfi rrrEns ^RE
lto otHcR ExPEEss oR l[tPLlEo
waef,A[TJ€s oR cor.rn;11or*si p{cLuDtH6 wARnAilTtE* oR cot{bf-Ttof.ls 6r *e*cxEwaBll-lrY'*l'lo FlfREss FsF A FARrtc{]LAB
FURPOSf"
M&A Grotrp Ll-G
$ignature
Narne
**#t-+s+-Mike Akr*cassis
BILL TO I.Sfi IP Tc. IIIFSTTNfiATIO'H
:I,5'FEF 2017
Fqge 3 Bl a
Addwes
Nrme
Gonirct FhonP
Eruail
,'l.,.,,,,,;:,.,.;,,,1', :',
,. '',",; " "" " '",',, ' ,..,.1' ." ."
M&A BrDrip LLC ab G$rfl€time FcrtMyera
14137 Guff Center Sr
Fort h{y*rs FL
33913
Miks $.becassis
s54-E93SrlE
:;$hip:tTcil' .,.,,r
:. ::,,:,
r,, ,i
Eusioher Heme
c$$tgmer Addt€$a
gsnt€at Hantg
'Contbct Phone
Coatac!'Email
'''''.M&A. Gr.rrip LLC clo Ssrnetirne Fprl
Myers
" 80^' nutf Celtter Fr
Fort:Myern FL
33A1t
MiK€ Ar,erjas*,$
95*t.$gB8t?.$
rne(riau.bz
CP62E13d4 ' 1lssrisd [t 0raclc Arner.ic€, klc-
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 48 of 53
Filing # 68003440 E-Filed02l15120l8 l0:58:36 AM
FORM ,I.997. CIVIL COVER SHEET
The civil cover sheet and the information oontained in it neither replace nor supplement the filing and service of pleadings
or other documentrs as required by law. This form must be filed by the plaintiff or petitioner for the use of the Clerk ofCourt for the purpose of reparting judicial workload data pursuant ta section 25.075, Florida Staiutes. (See instrudions forcompletion.)
CASE STYLEIN THE CIRCUIT CCIURT OF THE ELEVENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT,
IN AND FOR MIAMI.DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA
Case No.:Judge:
A&E ADVENTURES LLC et al-A&E ADVENTURES LLC" et alPlaintiff
v5.p.Ra-p.
"!E AMER.LSA. n{C.Defendant
TYPE OF CASE
il Condominium
I Contracts and indebtedness
I Eminent domain[ ,At$o negligence
n Negligence - othertl Business govemancen Business tortsil Environmentalffoxictortil Third party indemnification
tr Construction defecttl Mass tortil Negligent security
n Nursing home nqligenceil Premises liabitity - commercialil Premises liability - residential
I Products liabili$I Real Property/Mortgage foreclosure
f Comrnercialforeclosure $0 - $50,000
U Commercialforeclosure $50,001 - $249,999n Commereial foreclosure $250,000 or rroreil Homestead residentialforeclosure $0 - 50,0S0
il Homestead residential foreclosure $50,001 -$249.999
il Homestead residential foreclosure $250,000 ormor€
tr Non-homestead residentialforeclosure $0 -$50,000
n Non-homesteadresidentialforeclosure$50,001 - $249,999
tr
trEiltr
n
Non-homestead residential foreelosure$250,00 or rnoreOther real property astions $0 - $50,000Other real property actions $50,m1 - $249,999Other real propefy actions $250,000 or more
Professional rnalpractioen Malpractice - businessn Malpractice - nedicaln Malpractice - other professicnal
Othern AntitrusUTradeRegulationil Business Transaction
n Circuit Civil- Not Applicable
tr Constititionalchallenge-statuteorordinance
n Constib.rtionalchallenge-proposedamendment
n Corporate Trusts
tr Discrimination-employmentorothern Insurance claims
e Intellectualproperty
H Libel/Slander
tr Shareholder derivative action
n Securities litigation
n Tradesecretsn Trust litigation
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 49 of 53
COMPLEX BUSINESS COURT
This aciion is appropriate for assignment to Complex Business Court as delineated and mandated by thaAdministrative Order. Yes f No X
lll. REMEDIES SOUGHT (check ail that appty):X Monetary;I Non-rnonetary declaratory or injunctivs relief:I Punitilre
lV, NUMBER OF CAUSES OF ACTTON: { }(specify)
1
V. |s fi|s CASE A CLASS ACTTON I.AWSUIT?E YesfNo
VI. HA$ NONCE OFANY KNOVIIN RET.ATED CASE BEEN FILED?X. No
I Yes - lf .yes" list all related ces€s by nsme, csse numbar and court:
VII. IS JURY TRIAL DEMANDED IN COMPLANT?tr Yes
il t,tO
I CERTIFY that the information I have provided in this cover sheet is accurate to the best of my knowledge and belief, andthal I have read and will comply with the requirements of Florida Rule of JudicialAdministration 2.425.
Signalure sl Howard R, Behar FL Bar No.: 544?IAttomey or party (Bar number, if attomey)
Ho,ward & Fehar _ofiU{?gr$(Type or print narne) Date
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 50 of 53
Filing # 68217016 E-FiIed AA}UZAIS 04:24:40 PM
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THEELEVENI}I JUDICIAL CIRCUIT IN ANDFOR MIAMI-DADA COUNTY" FLORIDA
CIRCUIT CIVIL DMISION
cAsE N0. 2018-004766_CA-0 I
A&E ADVENTURES LLC. a Ftorida limitedliabilitycompany! and M&A GROUP, LLC, aFlorida limited liabil ity company,
ptaintift,s.
CLASS REPRESHNTATIONv,
ORACLE AMERICA,INC., a Delawarecorporation,
Defendant.
THE STATE OF FLORIDA:
To Each Sheriff of the State:
YoU ARg HEREBY CCIMMANDED to serve this $ufilmon$ and a copy of the Complainr,Plaintiff,s in this action on Defendanf oRAcLE AMERICA' NC., a Delaware corporationn
Bv serv'ing its Regisrered Agenr: coRpoRATE SERVICE coMpANy1201 HAYS STREETTALLAHAS$EE, rL 32301
Each defendant is required to serve written defenses to tlre complaint or petition onPlaintiffs attoney, to wit:
HOWARD R BEHAR and/oTSAMUELM, [email protected]; sms @beharregal.cam; np @behartegal.crm
THE BEHAR LAW FIRM, P.A.I?5OI BISCAYNE BOULEVARD, SINTE 460
AVENTURA, FL 33160786-?35-3300
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 51 of 53
wittrin 20 days after sen'ice of this $ummontl on that defendant, exslusive of the day of service, &nd
to file the original of *re defenses with the Clerk of this Court whether before service on Plaindffs
attorney or immediately thereafter. If a defendant fails to do so, a default will be entered against
that defendarrt for the relie.f demanded in the complaint or petition.
Dated On: ,2018 Howard C. Forman, Clerk of Court
By
As Deputy Clerk
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 52 of 53
$AF.QRPAI'{T
A lawsuit has trcen filed against you. You have 20 calendar days after this sumtnons is served on you tofile a written resfxrnse to the attached conrplaint with the clerk of thi* court. A plrone call will *ot protect
ygu. Your wriden respclnse, including thc ca"se number given above and tlre name$ of the parties, ulust be
filed if y'ou want the coufi to hear your side of the case. If you do not file your response ol tims, you may
lose the case, and your wages, nmney. and prtrperty may {hereatter be taken withouf further warning {tom
the cow"t. 'Ihere are other legal require*rents. You may want to call an attorney right away. If yctu do not
know an auorney, you ilray call an attorney referral service or t legal aid oflice (listed in tlre phone book).
If you choose to file a written re,$ponse yourself. ai the same time you file your written resf$nse to the
co$rt you must alscl mail or take a copy of your written respon$e to the "PlaintiffifPlaintiffs AttornBy"
nanred below.IMPORTANTE.
I,tstecl ha sido demandado legalmente. Tiene 20 dias, contados a partir del recibo de esta notificacion, para
c$nte$tar la demanda adjunta, por escrito, y presentarla ante este lribunal. Una llameda telef6nica no Io
proteger{. Si usted deser que el lribunal considere su defensa, deb* presentlr su respuesta por escrito'
incluyencl6 el nrimero tlel caso y los nombres de las parte$ interesadas. Si usted no contesta la tlemanda a
tiempo, pu<liese lxrder el caso y podria ser elespojado de sus ingresos y propiedades, o privada dt: sus
Aerectros, sin previo aviso del tdbun t. Fxi*ten onos requisitas legales. Si lo desea. puede usted consultar
a un atrogarlo inmecliatamente. Si no conoce a un abogado, puede llamar a una de las oficinas de
asistencia legal que aptrecen en la gufa telef6nica.Si desea .r*ltnnil*. a la demantla por $u cuente" al misma tiemEr en que preselta su respuesta ante el
trihunal, rtetrera usted enviar p<,r Correo o entregar una copia de su respussta a la persona denominalla
atrajo conrc '?laintiff/Plaintiff s Attrrney" (Demandante o Abogado del Demandante).
IMPORTANT
lles poursuites jurliciares ofi ets enueprises contre vous. Vous avez ?0 jeiurs conseeutifs a partir de la
datc dc I'assignation de ccfic citation pour deposcr unc reponsc ecrite a la plainte ci'jointe aupres clc ce
tribunal. Un simple coup de telephone est insuflisant pour vflxr proteger. VoEs etes obliges de deposer
votre repon$e ecrite, avec mention du numero de dossier cidessus e.t du nom des parties nommees ici' si
oous *oul aitez que le tribunal entende votre cause. Si vous ne depasez pas votre reponse ecrite dans le
relai requis. r'oui risquez de perdre la canse ainsi que votre salaire, votre argent" et vos biens peuvent etre
saisis par Ia suire, san$ aucun preavis ulrerieur du uibund. Il y a d'rulres obligations juridigues et vous
yru"ei requerir Ies services iurnrediats d'un avocaL Si vous ne connaissez pa$ d'avtxal, vous ptruniez
ielephuner a un service de reference tl'avocat$ ou a un bureau d'assistancejuridique (figurant a I'annuaire
de telephones).Si voui choisissez de deExer vous-meme une reponse ecrite, il vous faudra egalement, sn meme temp$
que gette formalite, faire par.renir ou expedier une copie de vore reponse ecrite au "Plaintif'f/Plaintill"s
A$orney" (Plaignant ou a son avocat) norrune ci-dessous.HOWARD R BAHAR, RSQ.
TIM T'EI{ARLAW FTRM, P.A.17501 BISCAYNE BOT'LE,VARD. SIIITI] 460
AVENTURA, FL 33HO786-?35-3300
sabiliries Acr of 190 {ADA), rlisabled persons who, trecause
ir 4isabilities, need sgrecial accommodation to participrue in this proceeding shoulti contact the ADA
luxdinatcrr no later dran SEVHN (?) husiness
Case 1:18-cv-21082-KMW Document 1-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/21/2018 Page 53 of 53