8/2/2019 Yitzchok Ullman Intervenor Plaintiffs motion against Defense Motion to Dismiss, Redistricting Case

1/11

\MOPL@ SPEPLS @OSPVOCP CA\VPLESPLVM @OSPVOCP AG MLY _AV DrHE VD E- GEWA VS* lp ej- C-E- Ma- 55(CW(>9>/^EMMAML JA^LS @LWLVLE\R ' Y LSP JJCEppavmls gav Omplvwlma v ^jeompogg _op{cbad \jjhem25 H eom Spvllp* S|opl Y bopl jeoms* Mly _ avd 5>7>5"?50/(2?2(60>> "Pljl~baml/"?50/(2?2(60>5 "Gecsohojl/je~apbldlvN~j`y-cah

5

Cesl 5;55(cw(>0!>?!56 ^eil 5 ag 55 ^eilO@ #;073>

8/2/2019 Yitzchok Ullman Intervenor Plaintiffs motion against Defense Motion to Dismiss, Redistricting Case

2/11

O- OMPVA@\CPOAM-Omplvwlmav ^ jeompogg _op{cbad \ jjhem "&^jeompogg)/ vls~lcpg|jj s|fhops pbos hlh avem`|h

ag jey om a~~asopoam pa pbl Hapoam pa @oshoss gojl` f @lglm`emps Sblj`am Sojwlv* KabmHcLm lm* em` Vahem B l`ils "pbl &@lglm`emps&/-5

OO - SPEPLHLMP A G GECPSAm Hevcb 556* gajjayomi pbl 6>5> `lclmmoej clms|s* @lglm`emp C|aha soiml` ompa

jey pbl Esslhfj vl`ospvocpomi ~jem* Cbe~plv 57 ag pbl Jeys ag 6>56 "pbl &^jem&/- Ep oss|l ompbos hepplv os pbl vl`ospvocpomi ag pbl P aym ag Veh e~a-

Eccav`omi pa pbl 6>5> \-S- clms|s* pbl Paym ag Vehe~a bes e ~a~|jepoam ag 567*

8/2/2019 Yitzchok Ullman Intervenor Plaintiffs motion against Defense Motion to Dismiss, Redistricting Case

3/11

\m`lv pbl ^jem* Deslv em` Hamsl evl may jacepl` om `ospvocp ?2 em` Mly Su|evl os jacepl` om`ospvocp ?9-

Am Hevcb 5?* 6>56* Omplvwlmav ^jeompogg gojl` e Cah~jeomp "pbl &Cah~jeomp&/6cbejjlmiomi pbl ^jem es |mcamspop|poamej |m`lv pbl \mopl` Spepls Camspop|poam em` pbl Mly _avdSpepl Camspop|poam- Pblvlegplv* @lglm`emps hawl` pa `oshoss pbl Cah~jeomp |m`lv Gl`lvej V|jlag Cowoj ^vacl`|vl 56"f/"7/- Flce|sl ^jeompogg bes ejjlil` s|ggocolmp gecps pa veosl e ~je|sofjlcjeoh pbep @lglm`emps woajepl` pbl spepl em` gl`lvej camspop|poams yblm pbl s~jop Vehe~a ompapbvll `ospvocps em` sl~evepl` Deslv em` Mly Su|evl ompa sl~evepl `ospvocps* pbos Ca|vp sba|j` `lm@lglm`emps) hapoam-

O-PEM@EV@ A G VLWOLY-&Pa s|vwowl e hapoam pa `oshoss* e cah~jeomp h|sp campeom s|ggocolmp gecp|ej hepplv*eccl~pl` es pv|l* pa spepl e cjeoh pa vljolg pbep os ~je|sofjl am ops gecl-& @ewosam w- Iaa`yojjOm`|spvols ag Ivleplv M-_- em` Mavpblvm M-K-* Ma- 5>(652>* 6>56 \ -S- @osp- JLR OS 03623* ep +0"L-@-M-_- Hevcb 62* 6>56/ "u|apomi Esbcvagp w- Oufej* 55/"u|apomi Fljj Epj- Cav~- w- Py ahf j*

8/2/2019 Yitzchok Ullman Intervenor Plaintiffs motion against Defense Motion to Dismiss, Redistricting Case

4/11

OO- EVI\HLMP-e- Pbl ^jem woajepls Evpocjl OOO* Slcpoam < ag pbl Mly _avd Spepl

Camspop|poam flce|sl op oh~lvhossofj `owo`ls Vehe~a ompa pbvll`ospvocps-

Pbl ^jem oh~lvhossofj `owo`ls Vehe~a ompa pbvll esslhfj `ospvocps om `ovlcpcampvewlmpoam ag pbl Mly _avd Spepl Camspop|poam- @lglm`emps bewl geojl` pa slp gav ecah~ljjomi vlesam* av lwlm e vepoamej fesos gav `aomi sa-

Evpocjl OOO* Slcpoam < ag pbl Mly _avd Spepl Camspop|poam spepls om* om vljlwemp ~evp* pbep;Ma paym* lrcl~p e paym bewomi havl pbem e vepoam ag e~~avpoamhlmp em` aml(bejgawlv* em` ma fjacd om e cop omcjasl` f spvllps av ~|fjoc yes sbejj fl `owo`l` ompbl gavhepoam ag esslh fj `ospvocps -

Pbos Mly _avd Spepl camspop|poamej `ovlcpowl vlcaimo{ls pbl awlvejj cahhamejop ag omplvlsps agejj vlso`lmps jowomi yopbom e paym yopb vliev` pa spepl jliosjepowl oss|ls* em` pbl ~|fjoc ~ajoc agdll~omi lecb paymsbo~ es e yba jl yblm `vegpomi Esslhf j `ospvocps-

@ls~opl pbl e`hoppl` ~vl(lhomlmcl om pbl vl`ospvocpomi ~vaclss ag pbl gl`lvej lu|ej(~a~|jepoam hem`epl* pbl Mly _avd Ca|vp ag E~~lejs bes jami eggovhl` pbl campom|l` wopejop agpbl spepl camspop|poamej `ovlcpowls lmsbvoml` om Evpocjl OOO* Slcpoam M-_-6` 9>* 92 "5??6/- Omsbavp* ybojl pbl Jliosjep|vl he `lwoepl gvah spepl camspop|poamej `ovlcpowls pa seposg gl`lvejhem` epl* op os map gvll pa pvlep spepl camspop|poamej vlu|ovlhlmps es h lvlj ~vlcepav-

0

Cesl 5;55(cw(>0!>?!56 ^eil 0 ag 55 ^eilO@ #;0733

8/2/2019 Yitzchok Ullman Intervenor Plaintiffs motion against Defense Motion to Dismiss, Redistricting Case

5/11

Blvl* pbl sl~evepoam ag Vehe~a ompa pbvll sl~evepl esslhfj `ospvocps os map vlu|ovl` pacah~avp yopb lopblv pbl gl`lvej lu|ej(~a~|jepoam `ovlcpowl av pbl spepl `ovlcpowls ag Evpocjl OOO*Slcpoam 5> \-S- clms|s* pbl Paym ag Vehe~a bes e ~a~|jepoam ag

567*

8/2/2019 Yitzchok Ullman Intervenor Plaintiffs motion against Defense Motion to Dismiss, Redistricting Case

6/11

Mlwlvpbljlss* @lglm`emps* vljomi am Scbmlo`lv* camplm` pbep yblm pbl Jliosjep|vl`owo`l` Vehe~a* op hlvlj lrlvcosl` ops `oscvlpoam om fejemcomi pbl &camwlmolmcl& gecpav agEvpocjl OOO* Slcpoam 5> ljlcpoams* pblm(esslhfj `ospvocp ?< omc|hflmp Esslhfjyahem Keggllcevvol` Mly Su|evl om e jem`sjo`l "5*205(2>/* f|p ca|j` map cevv Deslv< - Gajjayomi pbl 6>5>clms|s* iowlm pbl mly ~a~|jepoam m|hflvs om Vehe~a* pblvl lrospl` pbl ~aplmpoej pbep Vehe~aya|j` fl ` veym es e somijl `ospvocp* pblvlf `oj|pomi Esslhfjy ahem Keggll)s so{efjl e`wempeilom Mly Su|evl- Pa c|vl Keggll)s ~vafjlh* @lglm`emps amcl eieom `owo`l` Vehe~a ompa pbvll`ospvocps f|p pbos pohl ~|v~aslg|jj hemo~|jepl` pbl esslhfj `ospvocp fa|m`ev jomls sa es pasl~evepl Deslv a|p ag Esslh fjyah em Keggll)s esslhfj `ospvocp "may `ospvocp ?9/ ybojl dll~omiMly Su|evl om op- Om `aomi sa* @lglm`emps omlr~jocefj sl~evepl` pya cahh|mopols yopb `ll~jomplvpyoml` cahh am omplvlsps |m`lv pbl i |osl ag e cjeohl` vls~lcp gav &befop|ej essacoepoam* ~voavpve`opoams em ` ~ voav jomls-&

< Sll* Lrbofops* F* C* em` @* eppecbl`- Lrbofops F em` C sbay s pbl 6>5> ljlcpoam vls|jps gvahVeh e~a Ljlcpoam @ospvocps 0!>?!56 ^eil 7 ag 55 ^eilO@ #;073

8/2/2019 Yitzchok Ullman Intervenor Plaintiffs motion against Defense Motion to Dismiss, Redistricting Case

7/11

Gav awlv 6> levs* Mly Su|evl em` Deslv bewl vlheoml` om pbl sehl `ospvocp em` gaviaa` vlesam- Deslv omcj|`omi s|vva|m`omi cahh|mopols s|cb es Hamsl em` Mly Su|evl evljay(omcahl* hekavop Cbesso`oc cahh|mopols jacepl` e`keclmp pa lecb apblv om Vehe~a- PblCbesso`oc cahh|mopols ag Mly Su|evl em` Deslv evl oms|jev cahh|mopols pbep* |mjodl hemapblv Ehlvocem Klyosb cahh|mopols* bewl map essohojepl` ompa pbl heomspvleh c|jp|vl- Pblhlhflvs ag pblsl cahh|mopols evl omspempj vlcaimo{efjl gvah pblov hemmlv ag `vlss em` agplms~led ~vohevoj _ o``osb- Om sbavp* pblsl cahh |mopols sbevl soimogocemp cahhamejopols ag omplvlspem` pbl bewl jami fllm campeoml` yopbom pbl sehl esslhfj `ospvocp-

Es om`ocepl`* @lglm` emps may slld pa s~jop pblsl cahh |mopols flpyllm esslhfj `ospvocpsom pbl mehl ag &befop|ej essacoepoams* ~voav pve`opoams* em` ~voav jomls& em` asplmsofj gav pbl~|v~asl ag seposgomi pbl &camwlmolmcl gecpav& campeoml` f Evpocjl OOO* Slcpoam levs em` slwlvomi op gvah ops mloibfavomi cahh|mop yopb yb ah op sbevlsspvami cahhamejopols ag omplvlsp os bev`j lwo`lmcl ag e vls~lcp gav &befop|ej essacoepoams* ~voavpve`opoams* em` ~voav jomls-& Es s|cb* pbl ^jem)s `owosoam ag Vehe~a os map ca|mplmemcl` f pblScbmlo`lv `lcosoam;7

Ybojl op os pv|l pbep pbl Scbmlo`lv `lcosoam |~blj` e vl`ospvocpomi ~jem pbep s~jop Vehe~a* pbl`lcosoam cemmap fl vle` es e campom|omi lm`avslhlmp ag pbep ~vecpocl- Om pbl 0> levs pbep bewl~essl` somcl Scbmlo`lv* Vehe~a bes cbemil` camso`lvefj- Op bes ivaym soimogocempj om~a~|jepoam em` ops c|jp|vl* jodl pbep ag hem apblv payms* bes ejsa ivaym em` cbemil`- Pblslcbemils* ehami apblvs* k|spog e vlmlyl` lrehomepoam ag pbl @lglm`emps) cjeohl` vlesamomi gav`l~evpomi gvah pbl spepl camspop|poamej `ovlcpowl pbep Vehe~a sba|j` map fl s~jop ehami h |jpo~jl`ospvocps- Ybojl pbl ~vomco~jls ls~a|sl` om Scbmlo`lv ejjay `lwoepoam gvah pbl spepl `ovlcpowls omjohopl` covc|hspemcls gav ia a` vlesams om joibp ag pbl gl`lvej lu|ej(~a~|jepoam hem`epl* may blvlom pbep `lcosoam `als pbl Ca|vp ivemp e fjemdlp e|pbavo{epoam gav pbl campom|l` woajepoam agVeh e~a)s camspop|poamejj ~vaplcpl` fav` lvs om pbl vl`ospvocpomi ~ vaclss-

9

Cesl 5;55(cw(>0!>?!56 ^eil 9 ag 55 ^eilO@ #;0737

8/2/2019 Yitzchok Ullman Intervenor Plaintiffs motion against Defense Motion to Dismiss, Redistricting Case

8/11

TPbl empo(ilvvhem`lvomiX ~vawosoams ylvl e`a~pl` gav pbl sej|pev ~|v~asl agewlvpomi pbl ~ajopocej ilvvhem`lv em` ep ~vlslmp evl pbl amj hlems eweojefjl papbl ca|vps gav campeomomi pbep ~lvmocoa|s ~vecpocl- Og pbl Jliosjep|vl ~jes gesp em`jaasl yopb pblsl camspop|poamej vlu|ovlhlmps* op vosds bewomi e `ospvocpomi ~jem slpeso`l

35 M-_-6` ep 03>4 sll ejsa Vlmaj`s w- Sohs* 399 \-S- ?!56 ^eil 2 ag 55 ^eilO@ #;0739

8/2/2019 Yitzchok Ullman Intervenor Plaintiffs motion against Defense Motion to Dismiss, Redistricting Case

9/11

Jliosjep|vl pa heompeom pbl omplivop ag paym jomls om ops vle~~avpoamhlmp- Ybojl pbl Jliosjep|vlhe `l~evp gvah pbos `ovlcpowl om johopl` covc|hspemcls gav iaa` ce|sl* op he map `a sa hlvljep ops ~evposem yboh- Blvl* ^jeompogg bes ejjlil` pbep pbl Jliosjep|vl bes `owo`l` Vehe~a ompapbvll sl~evepl `ospvocps om woajepoam ag pbep camspop|poamej `ovlcpowl 9 - Havlawlv* ^jeompogg besejjlil` pbep s|cb `owosoam os oh~lvhossofjl flce|sl op yes favml mlopblv a|p ag em lggavp pacah~j y opb pbl gl`lvej vlu|ovlhlmp ag ~va~avpoamej vl~vlslmpepoam mav a |p ag em lggavp pa fejemclpbl spepl camspop|poamej `ovlcpowls yopb pbep vlu|ovlhlmp* f|p vepblv yes pbl vls|jp ag ojjliej~evposem ilvvhem` lvomi- Eccav`omij* ^jeompogg bes ejjlil` gecps pbep veosl e ~je|sofjl cjeoh pbeppbl ^jem woajepls Evpocjl OOO* Slcpoam < ag pbl Mly _avd Spepl Camspop|poam- Em`* ybojl@lglm`emps `os~|pl ^jeompogg)s camplmpoams vliev`omi pblov hapowls gav pbl `owosoam ag Vehe~a*pbep `os~|pl os cjlevj ivosp gav pbl `oscawlv!gecp(gom`omi hojj- Gav* og pbl ~vomco~jls ls~a|sl` omScbmlo`lv em` ops ~vailm hlem empbomi ep ejj* pbl hlem pbep pbl Jliosjep|vl cemmap k|spog`lwoepoams gvah pbl spepl camspop|poam soh~j pbva|ib e pejoshemoc omwacepoam ag ops &jliosjepowl`oscvlpoam& pa e~~j pbl vlu|ovlhlmps ag Evpocjl OOO* Slcpoam < om em hemmlv op slls gop-Eccav`omij* `oshossej |m`lv V |jl 56"f/"7/ os ome~~va~voepl-

f- Pbl ^jem woajepls pbl Lu|ej ^vaplcpoam Cje|sl ag pbl \mopl` SpeplsCamspop|poam flce|sl om lmecpomi op pbl @lglm`emps ~|v~aslg|jjsl~evepl` pbl cahh |mopols ag Deslv em` M ly Su |evl om em lggavp pa`oj|pl pbl wapomi ~aylv ag pbasl cah h|m opols em` ~ajopocejjilvvhem`lv pbl esslhfj `ospvocps om Vacdjem` Ca|mp em` Veh e~a-

Pbl Lu|ej ^vaplcpoam Cje|sl ag pbl Ga|vpllmpb Ehlm`hlmp ~vawo`ls pbep ma spepl sbejj&`lm pa em ~lvsam yopbom ops k|vos`ocpoam pbl lu|ej ~vaplcpoam ag pbl jeys-& \-S- Camsp-*Ehlm`- 50* 5- Pbl \mopl` Spepls S|~vlhl Ca|vp bes blj` pbep pbl cjeohs ag e ~lvsam yba

9 @lglm`emps Esslhfj H omavop Jle`lv Fvoem H - Dajf em` JE PGAV hlhflv Vaflvp Aeds om5< ag pblov vls~lcpowl Em sylvs pa pbl Ehlm `l` Ca h~jeomp* lecb e`hop pbep pbl ^jemoh~lvhossofj `owo`ls pbl Pay m ag Veh e~a ompa pbvll esslhfj `ospvocps-?

Cesl 5;55(cw(>0!>?!56 ^eil ? ag 55 ^eilO@ #;0732

8/2/2019 Yitzchok Ullman Intervenor Plaintiffs motion against Defense Motion to Dismiss, Redistricting Case

10/11

s|gglvs omwo`oa|s `oscvohomepoam es e vls|jp ag ~ajopocej ilvvhem`lvomi evl k|spocoefjl |m`lv pblLu|ej ^vaplcpoam Cje|sl- @ewos w- Fem`lhlv* 092 \-S- 5>?* 563 "5?27/4 sll ejsa Wolpb w-K|fljovlv* 0(3>< "6> >0/-

Es `lpeojl` efawl* @lglm`emps ~|v~aslg|jj somijl` a|p pbl cahh|mopols ag Deslv em`Mly Su|evl em` `oj|pl` pbl wapls ag pbl jay(omcahl* hekavop Cbesso`oc hlhflvs ag pbaslcahh|mopols* ag ybocb ^jeompogg os e hlhflv* f s~joppomi pbl pya wojjeils ompa sl~evepl ljlcpoam`ospvocps- Iowlm pbl soimogocemp cahhamejop ag omplvlsps sbevl` flpyllm pblsl cahh|mopols* pblsl~evepoam ag pblsl pya cahh|mopols ompa `ogglvlmp esslhfj `ospvocps slwlvlj bevhs pbl wapomi~aylv pbep pbl lmkal` yblm cahfoml` es e iva|~- Eccav`omij* pbl gecps ejjlil` f ^jeompoggslp gavpb e ~je|sofjl cjeoh pbep @lglm`em ps bewl woajepl` pbl lu|ej ~vaplcpoam voibps ag ^jeompogg-

Cjlwlvj* @lglm`emps epplh~p pa ewao` ^jeompogg)s spveoibpgavyev`* caimo{efjl cjeoh agomwo`oa|s `oscvohomepoam f evi|omi eieomsp e cjeoh map h e`l f ^jeompogg pbl evi|l pbep |m`lvcampvajjomi ~vlcl`lmp ^jeompogg em` pbl Cbesso`oc cahh|mop os map lmpopjl` pa &~vaplcpl` spep|s&|m`lv pbl Lu|ej ^vaplcpoam Cje|sl- Baylwlv* es mapl`* ^jeompogg hedls ma s|cb cjeoh- ^jeompogg

`als map cjeoh pbep bl av bos cahh|mop os lmpopjl` pa empbomi havl pbem em apblv waplvs4 blhlvlj cjeohs pbep bl os lmpopjl` pa map fl pvlepl` `ogglvlmpj- Em` * ybojl op os pv|l pbep pbl mlopblvpbl spepl mav pbl gl`lvej camspop|poam ess|vls ^jeompogg pbep bos ~evpoc|jev cahh|mop av ~avpoam age cahh |mop yojj map fl &sl~evepl` gvah pbl vlsp ag bos cahh|mop em` kaoml` y opb mloibfavomievles om pbl gavhepoam ag em ljlcpoam `ospvocp*& Hovvoaml w- Em`lvsam* 959 G-6` 903* 900 "6` Cov-5?23/* op os lu|ejj pv|l pbep ^jeompogg)s voibp pa fl gvll gvah omwo`oa|s `oscvohomepoam pbva|ibilvvhem`lvomi* fl op vljoioa|sj* vecoejj* av lwlm ~ajopocejj hapowepl`* os ~vaplcpl` em`k|spocoefjl |m`lv pbl Lu|ej ^vaplcpoam Cje|sl- @ewos* 092 \-S- ep 56< "&TPXbep pbl cjeoh oss|fhoppl` f e ~ajopocej iva|~ vepblv pbem e vecoej iva|~* `als map `ospomi|osb op om plvhs* ag

5>

Cesl 5;55(cw(>0!>?!56 ^eil 5> ag 55 ^eilO@ #;073?

8/2/2019 Yitzchok Ullman Intervenor Plaintiffs motion against Defense Motion to Dismiss, Redistricting Case

11/11

k|spocoefojop- Pbep pbl cbevecplvospocs ag pbl cah~jeomomi iva|~ evl map ohh|pefjl av pbep pbliva|~ bes map fllm s|fklcp pa pbl sehl bospavocej spoihe h e fl vljlwemp pa pbl hemmlv om y bocbpbl cesl os e`k|`ocepl`* f|p pblsl `ogglvlmcls `a map k|spog e vlg|sej pa lmplvpeom s|cb e cesl-&/-

Om pbos ye @lglm`emps) copl` cesl ag \KA w- Yojsam* G-6` 9>/^EMMAML JA^LS @LWLVLE\R ' YLSP JJCEppavmls gav Omplvwlmav ^ jeompogg _op{cbad \jjhem25 H eom Spvllp* S|opl Y bopl jeoms* Mly _ avd 5>7>5"?50/(2?2(60>> "Pljl~baml/"?50/(2?2(60>5 "Gecsohojl/je~apbldlvN~j`y-cah

5 5

Cesl 5;55(cw(>0!>?!56 ^eil 55 ag 55 ^eilO@ #;070>