Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

32
CHOOSING A MODEL OF FISCAL DECENTRALISATION Jean-Marc Lepain EU PFM Reform Advisor [email protected] www.slideshare.net/JeanMarcLepain/ National Dialogue Conference Sana’a, Yemen, June 30 th 2013

description

 

Transcript of Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

Page 1: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

CHOOSING A MODEL OF FISCAL

DECENTRALISATION

Jean-Marc Lepain

EU PFM Reform Advisor

[email protected]

www.slideshare.net/JeanMarcLepain/

National Dialogue Conference

Sana’a, Yemen, June 30th 2013

Page 2: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

CONTENT

• Part 1: Introducing fiscal decentralization concepts

• Part 2: Defining fiscal decentralization models

• Part 3 The components of a decentralized PFM system

• Part 4 Advice for choosing a decentralisation model

Page 3: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

PART I

Introducing fiscal decentralization concepts

Page 4: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

WHAT IS DECENTRALISATION?

Decentralization is the devolution of powers and responsibilities from central Government to subordinate or quasi-independent government organizations at the sub-national level (provinces, districts, municipalities, etc.) for the delivery of public services.

Page 5: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

THE FOUR DIMENSIONS OF

DECENTRALIZATION

Political

Administrative

Fiscal

Economic

Page 6: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

RELATION BETWEEN THE FOUR DIMENSIONS

Political decentralisation is relatively independent from other dimensions of decentralisation;

Federalism is a model of political decentralisation but not a model of fiscal decentralisation;

Fiscal decentralisation should be aligned with administrative decentralisation but is relatively independent from political and economic decentralisation;

Page 7: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

WHAT IS FISCAL DECENTRALISATION ?

Fiscal decentralisation is a system of public finance management in which human and financial resources of administrative / budget entities matches precisely the definition of their missions and responsibilities and is aligned with administrative decentralisation.

Page 8: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

WHAT DOES FISCAL DECENTRALISATION

IMPLIES?

Each level of government is closely identified;

Each budget entity has a precise mission and responsibilities;

Each budget entity has sufficient resources to finance its mission;

Upper budget entities take responsibility for lower entities funding gaps

Page 9: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

PART II

Models of Fiscal Decentralisation

Page 10: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

THERE ARE FOUR MODELS OF FISCAL

DECENTRALISATION

The Deconcentration Model

The Delegation Model

The Devolution Model

Mixed Models

Page 11: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

THE DECONCENTRATION MODEL

The highest degree of fiscal centralization

Sub-governments, with the exception of municipalities, have little or no independent revenue

Policy making is centralized, only policy execution is decentralized.

Line-ministries allocate budgets to their regional offices

Local governments have only an advisory and coordination role

Line-ministries sub-national offices are responsible for reporting provincial expenditures

Page 12: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

THE DELEGATION MODEL

The centre provide the fiscal frameworks as well as rules and norms for allocating resources.

Sub-governments collect only local/regional taxes in a limited amount.

Sub-governments receive block-grants from the central government.

Line-ministries and sub-governments have joint authority for allocating fiscal resources to projects.

Sub-governments have a certain amount of authority for reallocating resources across different sectors.

Page 13: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

THE DEVOLUTION MODEL

Sub-governments have full authority for collecting revenues which they share with the central government.

The central government provide orientations through national policies

Sub-government have legal authority to prepare their own budget and to allocate resources across the different sectors.

The role of line-ministries is to implement local policies decided by sub-governments.

Page 14: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

WHY MIXED MODELS ARE POPULAR?

Each economic sector has its own decentralisation requirements.

Education performs very well under a deconcentration model;

Health thrives under a delegation model;

Agriculture usually requires to be highly decentralised (devolution model)

Page 15: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

Governorates

Districts

Municipalities

Sector 1 Sector 2 Sector 3

Horizontal and

Vertical Lines of

Responsibilities

Page 16: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

PART III

The Components of a Decentralized

System

Page 17: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

THE FIVE MAIN COMPONENTS OF A

DECENTRALISED PFM SYSTEM

An expenditure assignment

A revenue sharing system

A revenue assignment

A system of intergovernmental transfers

A decentralized system of human resources management (civil service)

Page 18: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

EXPENDITURE ASSIGNMENT

Who is responsible for delivering service and what is the system of delegation of authority?

Who is responsible for administering the service (resource allocation and managerial decision)?

Who is responsible for financing the services?

Who is responsible for setting standard, regulations or policies guiding the provision of service?

Page 19: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

REVENUE ASSIGNMENT

• What scope of public services regional and local governments are responsible for ?

• Are their fiscal resources commensurate with their responsibilities?

• What is the autonomy of regional and local governments in making fiscal decisions and in allocating human and financial resources to individual services?

• Can regional and local governments determine the rate of their taxes and user charges?

Page 20: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

REVENUE SHARING

Types of taxes: local, provincial, central

Taxes are shared on the basis of formulae

Taxes can be shared locally or pulled

together centrally to be redistributed.

Page 21: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

INTERGOVERNMENTAL TRANSFERS

The objective of the system of intergovernmental transfers is to ensure that each level of government receives funding in proportion with its responsibilities.

Intergovernmental transfers should correct disparities in the revenue base of each sub-national government.

Intergovernmental transfers systems should be formula-based to ensure predictability of resources and to equalize resources across directorate.

Conditional grants can be used for special projects.

Page 22: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

Health Agriculture Public

Works

Gen.

Adm.

Provincial

Administration

Provincial Fiscal Envelope

Intergovernmental Transfer System

Expenditure Assignment based on Budget Norms

Revenue Assignment

Local

Rev.

Shared

Revenue Equalization Transfer

Ad hoc

Grants

Education

Unconditional Grants Conditional Grants

Page 23: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

PART IV

How to Choose a Model of Fiscal

Decentralisation

Page 24: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

REQUIREMENTS

Implementing a system of fiscal decentralisation requires several pre-conditions which are not met yet in Yemen:

Macroeconomic stability

Fiscal sustainability

Budget credibility

A well performing PFM system

Clarity in revenue and expenditure assignment

A well designed system of inter-governmental transfers

Political consensus

Page 25: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

(1) UNDERSTAND THE CONSTRAINS

The political constraints (see cultural and social

differences between north and south Yemen)

The macroeconomic constraints

The fiscal constraints and weaknesses in the PFM system

The human cost constraints

Page 26: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

THE MACROECONOMIC CONSTRAINS

Population grows at a rate close to 3% per year, implying a doubling every 23 years.

Weakness of the education system create a mismatch on the job market between demand and supply.

Oil resources will reach complete depletion by 2012 with no direct substitute.

Commercial balance is structurally in deficit due to the weakness of agriculture.

Water resources are dangerously depleted due to uncontrolled used for qat production.

Page 27: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

THE FISCAL CONSTRAINTS

Oil produces 70% of the current budget revenue

Oil subsidies absorb one third of the state budget

The state collect 21% of GDP in revenue but the budget remain in deficit; Civil Service remains highly inefficient and the number of state employees will be unsustainable in the future.

The fiscal base is unequally shared between governorates;

Horizontal imbalance in sector revenue allocation needs to be corrected at a certain cost;

Current level of investment is insufficient to ensure development of infrastructure and sustainable economic development.

Budget deficit is structural and will require long term donor assistance.

Page 28: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

WEAKNESSES IN THE PFM SYSTEM

MOF does not have a fiscal policy department

There is a misalignment between national priority, economic planning and budget formulation;

Budgeting is not done on the basis of programmes;

MOF does not have a treasury resulting in confusion in budget execution;

Due to shortage of resources and cash rationing budget execution has become unpredictable;

Traceability of funds is not ensured;

Etc., etc., etc.,

Page 29: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

(2) CONCIDER A LONG TERM PERSPECTIVE

The choice of a system of fiscal decentralisation should be based on the state of the country now but also in 20 or 30 years.

The oil revenue sharing is a minor problem if we consider that there will no significant oil revenue in 8 years.

Population growth, population migration and urban development should be taken into consideration;

Decentralisation should be based on a viable economic development strategy that implies sharing revenues and infrastructures such as roads, ports, Internet and telecommunication network, payments systems, etc.

Page 30: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

(3) CHOOSE A MODEL THAT CAN BE RUN

EFFICIENTLY AND EASILY

The efficiency of a fiscal decentralisation system depends on several factors:

Integration with other PFM systems (budget execution, payments transfers, etc.);

Simplicity of design, absence of redundancy and clarity of role of the different levels of Governments,

Economical use of human resources.

Page 31: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

(4) CHOOSE A MODEL THAT IS AFFORDABLE

Each model comes with a price tag. Not all models are affordable, considering scarcity of human and financial resources;

The choice of model should be based on fiscal and budgetary priority, knowing that improvement in public service delivery can only be gradual.

Cost of operation is direct and indirect. Direct cost is mainly salaries.

Indirect costs include inefficiency cost, leakages, burden on the private sector;

Page 32: Yemen:Choosing a model of fiscal decentralisation

THE KEY MESSAGES

1. Yemen is running out of time because of economic and fiscal constraints and developing the PFM system should proceed as fast as possible to re-established fiscal sustainability.

2. Fiscal Decentralisation is relatively independent from political decentralisation. Implementing fiscal decentralisation can starts before constitutional decisions are made.

3. Each model of decentralisation has a cost that limits the range of choices that Yemen can make. Yemen must choose a system that is financially sustainable in the long run.

4. A well performing system of fiscal decentralisation requires a well performing PFM system;

5. Building a decentralised system can only be made over several years and will need to be done in several phases;

6. Fiscal decentralisation requires a stable macro-economic environment, fiscal sustainability and budget credibility.