XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan...

32
XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies vy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from Extragalactic Sources above The Ankle

Transcript of XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan...

Page 1: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.

XXIst European Cosmic Ray Symposium

Kosice 2008

^

Tadeusz Wibig

University of Łódź

A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies

Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from Extragalactic Sources above The Ankle

Page 2: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.
Page 3: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.

R.U. Abbasi et al.., e-Print: arXiv:0804.0382 [astro-ph], Apr. 2008

Page 4: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.

R.U. Abbasi et al.., e-Print: arXiv:0804.0382 [astro-ph], Apr. 2008

Page 5: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.
Page 6: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.

source (l, b) objects (sources) distance observed angular size

A (310º,20º) CEN-A 4.9 Mpc 10º

B (190º, -60º) FORNAX

NGC 1052

NGC 1407

18 Mpc

22 Mpc

C ( 60º, -45º) 33 Mpc 10º

Page 7: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.
Page 8: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.
Page 9: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.

Source A

Page 10: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.

Source B

Page 11: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.

Source C

Page 12: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.

Source A

Source B

Source C

Page 13: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.
Page 14: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.

source (l, b) objects (sources) distance observed angular size

IGM deflection

A (310º,20º) CEN-A 4.9 Mpc 10º 1.1º

B (190º, -60º) FORNAX

NGC 1052

NGC 1407

18 Mpc

22 Mpc

6º 2.2º

C ( 60º, -45º) 33 Mpc 10º 2.8º

Page 15: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.
Page 16: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.
Page 17: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.

source (l, b) distance observed angular size

IGM deflection

Galactic deflection

deflection

A (310º,20º) 4.9 Mpc 10º 1.1º 0.7º 1.3º

B (190º, -60º) 20 Mpc 6º 2.2º 0.5º 2.2º

C ( 60º, -45º) 33 Mpc 10º 2.8º 0.5º 2.8º

Page 18: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.

source (l, b) distance observed angular size

Deflection for Z=1

Z

A (310º,20º) 4.9 Mpc 10º 1.3º 7.7

B (190º, -60º) 20 Mpc

6º 2.2º 2.7

C ( 60º, -45º) 33 Mpc 10º 2.8º 3.6

Page 19: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.
Page 20: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.
Page 21: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.

J.R.Hoerandel, 36th COSPAR, Beijin 2006 ; astro-ph/0702370

■●

Page 22: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.

Conclusions:

The extragalactic CR with E > 5.6 1019 eV from the close AGN do not have to be protons

there is not necessary to change of the ‘conventional’ model of nuclear interactions above 60 EeV

Page 23: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.

T. Wibig & A.W. Wolfendale, J.Phys. G34, 1891 (2007)

G- and power law EG- the fit

A.A. Watson, Proc. 30th ICRC (Merida) (2007)

Page 24: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.

V.S. Berezinsky & S.I. Grigorieva, Astron. Astrophys. 199, 1 (1998)

EG protons only

A.A. Watson, Proc. 30th ICRC (Merida) (2007)

Page 25: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.

T. Wibig & A.W. Wolfendale, J.Phys. G34, 1891 (2007)

the quasar source model for protons

A.A. Watson, Proc. 30th ICRC (Merida) (2007)

Page 26: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.
Page 27: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.
Page 28: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.
Page 29: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.
Page 30: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.
Page 31: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.
Page 32: XXI st European Cosmic Ray Symposium Kosice 2008 ^ Tadeusz Wibig University of Łódź A. Sołtan Institute for Nuclear Studies Heavy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from.