Writ of Mandate and Complaint for Injunctive and Declaratory Relief

7/31/2019 Writ of Mandate and Complaint for Injunctive and Declaratory Relief

1/33

YLXAIAL@ ^LPAPADE IDX WXAP DI MJE@JPL JE@

ODM^CJAEP IDX AEK\EOPAYL JE@ @LOCJXJPDXQ XLCALI

:

8

?

0

::

:8

:?

:0

:

8:

88

8?

80

8MJXA_DC DXAB\LCJ# _HE 89:?7>:7Plcl~bdel; "8:?! 177-

Ijosamacl; "8:?! 177-?117HLEKJMAE @% CAOBPMJE# _HE 80::?>97Plcl~bdel; "?:>! 8>:-8:>>Ijosamacl; "?:>! 8>:-8::>

OBJXCL_ K% DGCLPXLL"^xd bjo yaol j~~caojpade idxpbodmaeg!Bjxyjx` Cjw _obddc+:8:?2Plcl~bdel; "9:7! 01-8


2/33


ODM^CJAEP IDX AEK\EOPAYL JE@ @LOCJXJPDXQ XLCALI:

:

8

?

0

::

:8

:?

:0

:

8:

88

8?

80

8:>!% Lro|c~jpdxq lya`leol as pq~aojccq xlilxxl` pd jsHxj`q

mjplxajc# jiplx pbl \%_% _|~xlml Od|xp xlodgea{l` pbjp j ~xdslo|pdx yadcjpls @|l ^xdolss hq ~xdoll`aeg

pd pxajc wapbd|p `asocdsaeg lro|c~jpdxq lya`leol pd pbl `lile`jep% _ll Hxj`q# ?7? \%_% jp 29%

0% @ls~apl :>


3/33


ODM^CJAEP IDX AEK\EOPAYL JE@ @LOCJXJPDXQ XLCALI8

:

8

?

0

::

:8

:?

:0

:

8:

88

8?

80

8::!%~`i6 Obxas Ydglc#Mles Od|epq Kjac Yasapdx Yaoad|scq Hljple hq G|jx`s# C%J%WLLFCQ#

Mjq :1# 8>::# jyjacjhcl jpbpp~;$$www%cjwllfcq%odm$8>::->

Ojc% _l~p% 82# 8>::! "iacl` aeX|pblxidx` y% Hjoj# 70:::-@@^ "O%@% Ojc% iacl` @lo% 1# :17:8!6X|pblxidx` y% Hjoj# 70:::-@@^ "O%@% Ojc% Dop% :># 8>>2! "Ed% 882! "mdpade idx ~xdplopayl dx`lx pd lekdae xlpjcajpade#

aeoc|`aeg xlpjcajpade ae pbl idxm di ~bqsaojc jh|sl# jgjaesp ~xasdelxs!6 Odclq y% Hjoj# OY>1->2:8 WC :?0>?7? "O%@% Ojc% Mjx% 2# 8>:8!# js wlcc js je degdaeg oxamaejc aeylspagjpade hq pbl

Il`lxjc H|xlj| di Aeylspagjpade# sll Xdhlxp Ijp|xloba# IHA ^xdhaeg Xl~dxps di Hljpaegs ae C%J% Od|epq

Kjacs# C%J%PAML_# _l~p% 8::# jyjacjhcl jpbpp~;$$jxpaocls%cjpamls%odm$8>::$sl~$8


6/33


8/33



:

8

?

0

::

:8

:?

:0

:

8:

88

8?

80

8% Xls~de`lep CJ_@ as j cjw leidxolmlep jgleoq pbjp lm~cdqs ~ljol diiaolxs% JmdegCJ_@s xls~desahacapals as pbl d~lxjpade di jcc Cds Jeglcls Od|epq Kjacs% CJ_@s wdxf as àxlopl` hq

Xls~de`lep Hjoj%

K\XA_@AOPADE JE@ YLE\L

8:% Pbas Od|xp bjs k|xasàopade |e`lx Od`l di Oayac ^xdol`|xl :%

80% Pbas spjp|pdxq dhcagjpade lobdls pbl @|l ^xdolss xlz|axlmlep pbjp j oxamaejc pxajc hli|e`jmlepjccq ijax hq am~dsaeg j hxdj` `|pq de pbl ~xdslo|paeg hd`q di pbl _pjpl pd àsocdsl ijydxjhcl

lya`leol pd oxamaejc `lile`jeps% _ll_pxaofclx y% Gxllel# pbl `lilesl dx b|xps pbl ~xdslo|pade% ^ld~cl y% Mlej# "8>:8! "z|dpaeg^ld~cl y%

[jmhxjed# 0: Ojc% 0pb :>28# ::?8 "8>>7!!% Hloj|sl pbl oxlàhacapq di pbl ~xdslo|pades wapelssls as

aeyjxajhcq oxapaojc# lya`leol pbjp am~ljobls pblm hq sbdwaeg hajs# mdpayl pd cal# dx àsbdelspq m|sp hl


9/33



:

8

?

0

::

:8

:?

:0

:

8:

88

8?

80

8: "Pd `ljc wapb pbl ~xdhclms# pbl àspxaop jppdxelqs diiaol

bjs lspjhcasbl` jHxj`q odm~cajeol àyasade# wbaob wacc hlgae lyjc|jpaeg lya`leol elrp mdepb# sja`

s~dflswdmje Kjel Xdhaesde%!%

82% _aeol pblHxj`qOdm~cajeol \eaps oxljpade# CJ@J bjs xl~ljpl`cq ~daepl` pd pbl \eapje` pd|pl` ap pd sbdw pbl diiaols ~|x~dxpl` odm~cajeol wapb aps dhcagjpades% Idx lrjm~cl# ae 8>>7#

CJ@J slep j clpplx pd pbl Ojcaidxeaj Odmmassade de pbl Ijax J`maeaspxjpade di K|spaol jxg|aeg pbjp pbl

Odmmassade sbd|c` edp xlodmmle` lebjeol`Hxj`q ~dcaoals hloj|sl pblHxj`q Odm~cajeol \eap

s|~~dsl`cq jcxlj`q les|xl` i|cc odm~cajeol% _ll Diiaol di pbl @aspxaop Jppdxelq# Cds Jeglcls Od|epq#

Xls~desl pd Ojcaidxeaj Odmmassade de pbl Ijax J`maeaspxjpade di K|spaol Ido|s Z|lspades idx Bljxaeg

de ^xdilssadejc Xls~desahacapq Ass|ls# K|cq ::# 8>>7# jp :?%

81% CJ@Js d~lxjpayl ~dcaoq xlgjxàeg pbl ~xdyasade di mjplxajc lro|c~jpdxq jeàm~ljobmlep lya`leol as slp idxpb ae _~loajc @axlopayl :>->9# lspjhcasbl` de _l~plmhlx 8># 8>:>%

_~loajc @axlopayl :>->9 mje`jpls pbjp pblHxj`q Odm~cajeol \eap `lplxmael wbjp aeidxmjpade ae

CJ@Js ~dsslssade jhd|p ~ljol diiaolxs je` dpblx aeàya`|jcs wbd mjq hl ~jxp di j ~xdslo|pade pljm dx

mjq hl gdylxemlep wapelssls sbd|c` hl aeoc|`l` ae pbl Hxj`qJclxp _qsplm je` odesa`lxl` idx

àsocds|xl pd pbl `lilesl ae ~xdslo|pades aeydcyaeg pbdsl aeàya`|jcs% \e`lx pbl ~dcaoq# `l~|pq àspxaop

jppdxelqs xlcq de pblHxj`q Jclxp _qsplm hq oblofaeg pbl ejmls di ~dplepajc wapelssls je` mlmhlxs di

pbl ~xdslo|pade jgjaesp ap# a%l%# pblq lyjc|jpl pblax àsocds|xl dhcagjpades |e`lxHxj`q hjsl` de j

`jpjhjsl pbjp wjs oxljpl` wapbd|p jeq fedwcl`gl di pbl s~loaiao ijops di pbl ojsl jhd|p wbaob pbl `l~|pq

àspxaop jppdxelq as aez|axaeg% PblHxj`q Odm~cajeol \eap jcsd odes|cps wapb `l~|pq àspxaop jppdxelqs

jhd|p pblax xls~desahacapals ae p|xeaeg dylx lro|c~jpdxq je` am~ljobmlep lya`leol# h|p decq pblHxj`q

Odm~cajeol \eap oje `lplxmael wblpblx lya`leol wacc hl aeoc|`l` ae pblHxj`q Jclxp _qsplm%

Mdxldylx# `l~|pq àspxaop jppdxelqs mjq edp àsocdsl jeq lya`leol pbjp pblq ae`l~le`lepcq |eodylx pd

pbl `lilesl wapbd|p iaxsp odes|cpaeg wapb pblHxj`q Odm~cajeol \eap%

?>% Jcpbd|gb pblHxj`q Odm~cajeol \eap wjs oxljpl` ae xls~desl pd slxad|sHxj`qyadcjpades# pbl ~dcaoals gdylxeaeg pbjp |eap jxl ~xlslepcq xls~desahcl idx pbl sqsplmjpao# acclgjc

s|~~xlssade diHxj`q mjplxajc% _~loaiaojccq# pbl diiaoajc ~dcaoals ~xdm|cgjpl` hq Xls~de`leps Oddclq

je` CJ@J odm~lc `l~|pq àspxaop jppdxelqs pd yadcjpl ocljx `|pals |e`lx ^lejc Od`l :>


11/33


ODM^CJAEP IDX AEK\EOPAYL JE@ @LOCJXJPDXQ XLCALI:>

:

8

?

0

::

:8

:?

:0

:

8:

88

8?

80

8->9 ~xdya`ls pbjp lya`leol pbjp sjpasials jcc pbl lclmleps diHxj`q je` :>


12/33


ODM^CJAEP IDX AEK\EOPAYL JE@ @LOCJXJPDXQ XLCALI::

:

8

?

0

::

:8

:?

:0

:

8:

88

8?

80

8->9 ijacs pd oapl :>>7!

"z|dpaeg\eapl` _pjpls y% Hjgclq# 07? \%_% 997# 97< ":12

_|~xlml Od|xp blc` pbjp pbl j~~xd~xajpl spje`jx` idx lyjc|jpaeg wblpblx pd dylxp|xe j odeyaopade idx

ijac|xl pd àsocdslHxj`qlya`leol as wblpblx pblxl as j xljsdejhcl ~xdhjhacapq pbjp# bj` pbl lya`leol

hlle àsocdsl` pd pbl `lilesl# pbl xls|cp di pbl ~xdollàeg wd|c` bjyl hlle àiilxlep% Ae Fqcls#


13/33


ODM^CJAEP IDX AEK\EOPAYL JE@ @LOCJXJPDXQ XLCALI:8

:

8

?

0

::

:8

:?

:0

:

8:

88

8?

80

8->9 odepjaes j slopade papcl` Wbjp as edpHxj`q Mjplxajc# wbaobspjpls# ^le`aeg oxamaejc dx j`maeaspxjpayl aeylspagjpades jxl odesa`lxl` ~xlcamaejxq ae ejp|xl je` wacc

edp hl aeoc|`l` ae pbl Hxj`q Jclxp _qsplm% Pb|s# lyle ai j ~xdslo|pade wapelss wlxl pbl s|hklop di je

degdaeg oxamaejc dx j`maeaspxjpayl aeylspagjpade# CJ@J j|pdmjpaojccq s|~~xlssls jcc aeidxmjpade

jssdoajpl` wapb pbjp aeylspagjpade |epac pbl aeylspagjpade as odm~clpl`%

?1% Pbas xlz|axlmlep ojeedp hl sz|jxl` wapb :>>1!# jyjacjhcl jp

bpp~;$$iacl%cjod|epq%gdy$ho$z8T8>>1$oms:T:??


17/33


ODM^CJAEP IDX AEK\EOPAYL JE@ @LOCJXJPDXQ XLCALI:9

:

8

?

0

::

:8

:?

:0

:

8:

88

8?

80

81! "bdc`aeg pbjp cjw leidxolmlep diiaolxs `lcahlxjpl `loasade pd wapbbdc` lro|c~jpdxq lya`leol

yadcjpls @|l ^xdolss!6Mdc`dwje y% Oapq di Wjxxle#


21/33


ODM^CJAEP IDX AEK\EOPAYL JE@ @LOCJXJPDXQ XLCALI8>

:

8

?

0

::

:8

:?

:0

:

8:

88

8?

80

8


23/33



:

8

?

0

::

:8

:?

:0

:

8:

88

8?

80

8% Pblxl jxl jcsd jp cljsp sar swdxe spjplmleps hq aemjpls dx idxmlx aemjpls `lsoxahaeg id|xàiilxlep aeoa`leps ae wbaob @l~|pq C|yajed |sl` lrolssayl je` |eelolssjxq idxol jgjaesp aemjpls ae

Mles Olepxjc Kjac% Ae j`àpade# pblxl as jp cljsp del j`àpadejc swdxe spjplmlep hq je aemjpl spjpaeg pbjp

@l~|pq C|yajed ~cjepl` odepxjhje` de bam% Elapblx CJ@J edx CJ_@ bjs ~xdya`l` pbdsl `locjxjpades

pd Mx% Pdwesle`s cjwqlx# lyle pbd|gb jcc pbl spjplmleps wlxl slxyl` de od|eslc idx _blxaii Hjoj je`

pbl Od|epq%

7:% Mx% Pdwesle`s pxajc as o|xxlepcq slp idx pbas s|mmlx%78% Mx% Gjhxalc Ojxaccd% De Ilhx|jxq 89# 8>::# Mx% Gjhxalc Ojxxaccd wjs slylxlcq hljple

hq m|cpa~cl CJ_@ `l~|pals wbacl jpplm~paeg pd yasap bas hxdpblx jp Mles Olepxjc Kjac jiplx j `l~|pq

id|e` pbjp Mx% Ojxxaccd wjs ojxxqaeg j olcc ~bdel# ae yadcjpade di pbl Kjacs yasapjpade ~dcaoq%

_~loaiaojccq# @l~|pals _|ssal Jqjcj# ^jepjmapx [|eggllmdgl# Ilxeje`d C|yajed# je` Edlc Wdmjof jcc

pddf ~jxp ae pbl hljpaeg di Mx% Ojxxaccd% Jp ed paml `|xaeg pbas aeoa`lep à` Mx% Ojxxaccd jppjof pbl

`l~|pals# xlsasp pbl `l~|pals# dx lyle ijac pd idccdw pbl `l~|pals aespx|opades%

7?% Elylxpblclss# pbl `l~|pals aeydcyl` ae Mx% Ojxxaccds hljpaeg ijhxaojpl` ijcsl xl~dxps pbjpobjxjoplxa{l` Mx% Ojxxaccd js pbl jggxlssdx% Hjsl` de pblsl xl~dxps# CJ@J objxgl` Mx% Ojxxaccd wapb

yadcjpaeg ^lejc Od`l 91 "Xlsaspaeg je Lrlo|payl Diiaolx!6 ^lejc Od`l 80?"o!"8! "Hjpplxq wapb Aek|xq

de j ^ljol Diiaolx!6 je` ^lejc Od`l 80?%1"j! "Hjpplxq hq Gjssaeg!%

70% Mx% Ojxxaccds od|eslc elylx xlolayl` jeq lro|c~jpdxq lya`leol ixdm pbl @aspxaopJppdxelqs diiaol |e`lx ^lejc Od`l :>


24/33


ODM^CJAEP IDX AEK\EOPAYL JE@ @LOCJXJPDXQ XLCALI8?

:

8

?

0

::

:8

:?

:0

:

8:

88

8?

80

8::# CJ@J

`asmassl` pbl objxgls%

+ + +

79% Pbl ^apoblss X|cl# :>


28/33



:

8

?

0

::

:8

:?

:0

:

8:

88

8?

80

8?% Ae yadcjpade di pblax `|pals pd les|xl pbjp oxamaejc pxajcs jxl i|e`jmlepjccq ijax# js xlz|axl`hq pbl @|l ^xdolss ocj|sl# Xls~de`leps Oddclq je` CJ@Js ~dcaoq s|~~xlssls ijydxjhcl lya`leol ai

pbl `l~|pq s~lo|cjpls pbjp ap wacc edp jiilop pbl ylxàop%

EAEPB OJ\_L DI JOPADE

"Yadcjpade di ^lejc Od`l :>0% ^lpapadelx xljcclgls je` aeodx~dxjpls hq xlilxleol ljob je` lylxq jcclgjpade di ~jxjgxj~bs:-:>?%

:>9% Ae yadcjpade di pblax `|pals pd odm~cq wapb ^lejc Od`l :>7% ^lpapadelx xljcclgls je` aeodx~dxjpls hq xlilxleol ljob je` lylxq jcclgjpade di ~jxjgxj~bs:-:>9%

:>2% Xls~de`leps Oddclq je` CJ@J bjyl j maeasplxajc `|pq |e`lx pbl @|l ^xdolss ocj|sl dipbl \eapl` _pjpls Odespap|pade pd àsocdsl pd pbl `lilesl ae j oxamaejc ~xdslo|pade mjplxajc lro|c~jpdxq

je` am~ljobmlep lya`leol%

:>1% Ae yadcjpade di pblax `|pals pd les|xl pbjp oxamaejc pxajcs jxl i|e`jmlepjccq ijax# js xlz|axl`hq pbl @|l ^xdolss ocj|sl# pbl js~lops di Xls~de`leps Oddclq je` CJ@Js ~dcaoq objcclegl` blxlae#

pjfle pdglpblx# s|~~xlss ijydxjhcl lya`leol%

LCLYLEPB OJ\_L DI JOPADE

"Yadcjpade di @|l ^xdolss "Ojcaidxeaj Odespap|pade! jgjaesp Xls~de`leps Oddclq je` CJ@J!

::>% ^lpapadelx xljcclgls je` aeodx~dxjpls hq xlilxleol ljob je` lylxq jcclgjpade di ~jxjgxj~bs:-:>1%

:::% Xls~de`leps Oddclq je` CJ@J bjyl j maeasplxajc `|pq |e`lx pbl @|l ^xdolss ocj|sl dipbl Ojcaidxeaj Odespap|pade pd àsocdsl pd pbl `lilesl ae j oxamaejc ~xdslo|pade mjplxajc lro|c~jpdxq je`


29/33



:

8

?

0

::

:8

:?

:0

:

8:

88

8?

80

8

:

8

?

0

::

:8

:?

:0

:

8:

88

8?

80

8


32/33


33/33

Writ of Mandate and Complaint for Injunctive and Declaratory Relief

Documents

Transcript of Writ of Mandate and Complaint for Injunctive and Declaratory Relief